Flutist Reacts: Marshall Tucker Band - Heard It In A Love Song

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 208

  • @janjic
    @janjic 4 роки тому +31

    Since I subscribed to your channel, the very first thing I look for in a music video is whether the flutist is using his pinkie :-)

  • @MarkZawadzki
    @MarkZawadzki 4 роки тому +13

    One thing to also consider is that a certain "roughness" is expected in this style of music coming from the blues tradition.

    • @richardpowellTV
      @richardpowellTV 4 роки тому +3

      More like country than blues. This is nothing like blues.

    • @theohioshirey
      @theohioshirey 4 роки тому

      @MarkZawadzki Southern-flavored rock, like Outlaws, Lynyrd Skynyrd; ALLMAN BROS. & JOHNNY WINTER WERE DEFINITELY BLUES (my fave)

  • @jeremykornegay3163
    @jeremykornegay3163 3 роки тому +1

    i grew up in north carolina,i love that song,it reminds me of a wind through the pines,pine trees,thank you

  • @michaelbochnia5686
    @michaelbochnia5686 4 роки тому +5

    1979, The very first concert I was allowed to attend as a 16 year old. Marshall Tucker started first and The Charlie Daniels Band were the headliner. Looooong time ago but it was a ton of fun.

  • @geraldharris8420
    @geraldharris8420 3 роки тому

    As a Big and Long Time American Southern Rock Fan of the Marshall Tucker Band, I Enjoyed Watching your Classical Flutist Teacher Reactions of Flute Playing during the Hit Song, Heard It In A Love Song.

  • @bobmessier5215
    @bobmessier5215 4 роки тому +2

    One doesn't usually hear the flute in country/southern rock music. I love it when flute music can cross different music genres.

  • @burtw1356
    @burtw1356 4 роки тому +3

    Hello Heline! My favorite beautiful flutest. The Marshall Tucker Band is such a fun band to see in concert. I've seen them about a dozen times over the years.

  • @george5120
    @george5120 Рік тому +2

    Does she ever demonstrate her version of the flute solo? If not, then what is the point?

  • @dbcanada
    @dbcanada 4 роки тому +3

    The flute internal pickup (mic) looks like a Barcus-Berry 6100M. The "Tomasi MicroCork" pickup head is another brand.

  • @davidcomer8295
    @davidcomer8295 4 роки тому +2

    Thanks for featuring the Marshall Tucker Band. It was the first time I remember hearing the flute showcased as a lead instrument. Jethro Tull was the second. I agree with the other commenters in that a live recording doesn’t do Marshall Tucker’s music justice.
    I have also enjoyed your observations of Jethro Tull’s music and it has helped me to better appreciate Ian’s expertise as a flutist.

  • @randalmoore4704
    @randalmoore4704 4 роки тому +28

    Well, My Mom texted "He can play better but He's too stoned in this video. And THAT HELINE, she's one smart Woman, and you should work as hard as SHE does!" You can imagine hiding the smell of weed on my clothes and hair was impossible in my house growing up. And NOW I have to live up to HELINE musician standards. Gee, thanks, Heline. HHuummpphh

    • @CalJennings
      @CalJennings 4 роки тому +1

      Haha!

    • @mikearcher9390
      @mikearcher9390 4 роки тому

      DID HELINE HEART THIS? DUMB B.... THINK SHE'S BEING COMPLIMENTED BY THAT? DO THEY NOT DO SARCASM IN HER LITTLE WORLD?

    • @ruthd7274
      @ruthd7274 3 роки тому

      @@mikearcher9390 no need for that, Mr. Archer.

  • @5HlNOBI
    @5HlNOBI 4 роки тому +3

    I didn't realize this song had flute in it until now (nor this band). Though the flute parts (live) have one or two rough spots, it sounds really good as a complimentary instrument in the song.

    • @aaronmccutcheon
      @aaronmccutcheon 4 роки тому

      Hard to miss the flute... what did you think it was?

  • @bjdog42
    @bjdog42 4 роки тому +3

    Also, "Fire on the Mountain" by Marshall Tucker. Awesome song!

  • @baytownbert2
    @baytownbert2 4 роки тому

    I enjoyed your candid and honest response to this.

  • @apistosig4173
    @apistosig4173 4 роки тому +1

    Dear Heline - I've had every Marshall Tucker Band album for years and am very familiar with them all. Your summary is 'right on the money'. Another terrific presentation - thanks.

  • @joeholland9593
    @joeholland9593 4 роки тому

    The F# fingering comes from the saxophone, he probably doubles. As I use the flute 1-1 B-flat fingering on the sax all the time, works really well when jamming in the key of F on sax.
    The mic is a condenser pickup that fits above the head joint cork

  • @lorijohnson3567
    @lorijohnson3567 4 роки тому +3

    I can't believe you haven't listened to any Chicago.
    Colour My World has the most memorable and beautiful flute solo.

  • @dalelemke5786
    @dalelemke5786 4 роки тому +1

    It's on my Spotify playlist for my long nights of driving.

  • @gwhiteoh53
    @gwhiteoh53 4 роки тому +15

    Good to see the Marshall Tucker Band. I do hope you listen to “Can’t you see” by them. I think it is a much better song.

    • @HelineFay
      @HelineFay  4 роки тому +4

      I wrote that to my list of songs to check out! Thanks for the suggestion :)

    • @dwahnaslowdown8887
      @dwahnaslowdown8887 4 роки тому +1

      I saw MTB play at an outdoor festival about a year after this was filmed. They were outstaged that day by Willie Nelson and Leon Russell but overall it was a good show. I don't really care for the embellishments in their live performances. This is one band where the studio albums sound best (to me). Good road-trip music.

    • @cw6304
      @cw6304 4 роки тому +1

      @@HelineFay It is so much better! I do like Marshall Tucker and LOVE Can't You See but this song is not a fav at all :) Thanks for doing what you do Heline!

    • @theohioshirey
      @theohioshirey 4 роки тому +1

      Saw in '75 at the 1st (& only) Ohio River Festival, 18k+ fans OUTSIDE the stadium, too (Cinci) enjoying the tunes & all that comes with open-air rock music festivals. Law was unprepared, unhappy & unwilling for UC to sponsor another music event like that. It was FUN while it lasted 💖🙏

  • @spikechampkart55
    @spikechampkart55 3 роки тому

    I suggested this band in your Jethro Tull one. I used to be a guitar tech for the Marshall Tucker Band, not only is he a great player, he is a great person!! He rips a sax too!! Thanks, for the interest. Only three left from original band now!
    Jerry Eubanks is a great person too!!

  • @jamesoconnor2226
    @jamesoconnor2226 4 роки тому +1

    Heline how did you like his accent? I listen to everything and this band i always loved.

  • @OldSchoolhouseProd
    @OldSchoolhouseProd 4 роки тому

    Although I've been known to play lead guitar with the Marshall Tucker Band occasionally myself, I've never played the flute with them -- even though I could, since I learned the flute parts to so many of their songs over the years when I was working on how to use a flute and other woodwinds in a band like this one. I'd guess that the flute player, Jerry Eubanks, uses his middle finger for the F# because he was primarily a sax player, and that's how it's done. As far as electrifying his flute, Eubanks was most likely using a Barcus-Berry 6100 Flute pickup; it was an industry standard for a long time in there. Keep 'em coming!

  • @thomasdavidson8692
    @thomasdavidson8692 4 роки тому +14

    This is probably the most subdued version of this song that I have heard.

    • @elvistellen
      @elvistellen 4 роки тому

      Have to admit that that was one of the reasons why I started to follow, but mainly I just like to watch her reactions and ofcourse becouse I am musucian, playing guitar, but knoweledge is knowledge!

    • @theccpisaparasite8813
      @theccpisaparasite8813 4 роки тому

      Me too. Flute is like viola, violin, and other fretless instruments, the sound can "slide around" a bit from pure tone. That can be good or bad depending on what the player is trying for. Most performances are imperfect, it's live ... and rockish

  • @stevekomorsky4001
    @stevekomorsky4001 4 роки тому +1

    The Blues Project - A Flute Thing - 06-18-1967 - Monterey Pop Festival - Monterey, Ca

  • @bdedwards9371
    @bdedwards9371 4 роки тому +4

    Heline: Watch the pinkie, watch the pinkie. 😄

  • @markr6754
    @markr6754 4 роки тому

    I always gravitate to any band that features rich flute playing. Just something about the sweet pitch of a silver flute. Thanks for bringing back some of my favorites. Tried to switch from clarinet to flute, but failed. Just can’t get my left arm up high enough to hold proper position. So I “play” the flute vicariously through awesome flautists.

  • @wjmckay
    @wjmckay 4 роки тому

    So fun to watch you experiencing the great American genre of Southern Rock!

  • @bespoke6719
    @bespoke6719 3 роки тому +6

    The problem with classically trained musicians is you dont realize the in different styles of music its meant to be played differently and maybe even sloppy to the trained ear. I'm a trained musician so I know....

  • @TexDennis
    @TexDennis 4 роки тому +1

    I love your review of MTB. Thank you.

  • @paulstewart6203
    @paulstewart6203 4 роки тому

    Very interesting take on the flute. how Eubanks joined the band is, he received the call from one of the members asking if he played the flute, he didn't, but he said he did because he wanted to play in the band, so Eubanks said " i practiced the flute for the next week" until he auditioned for them, and luckily got the job. he played saxophone to begin with.

  • @kylesmith9291
    @kylesmith9291 4 роки тому +1

    Go to this original CD listened of the piano the guitar and the flute close your eyes and listen to the music

  • @arturocarrasco633
    @arturocarrasco633 4 роки тому +1

    Your facial expresion is really great, i love

  • @JustyHakubi
    @JustyHakubi 4 роки тому

    Great video, glad you enjoyed the Marshall Tucker Band! I was wondering do you see non-traditional flautists using a different set of styles as opposed to orchestral or traditional flautists? For example a violinist playing a violin vs. playing a fiddle? Are these short cuts that they are employing actually more efficient for more upbeat rock or pop music?

  • @michaellacy143
    @michaellacy143 4 роки тому

    Heline, if you have not already listened to this, you might be interested in reviewing this performance: Blackberry Smoke - Take The Highway ( Live from Capricorn Sound Studios) This was an historical event reopening the Capricorn Recording Studios in Macon, Georgia after being dormant for over 40 years. This is a unique example of a mainstream southern rock/rhythm & blues band incorporating the flute into their song. The song features a 1 minute plus flute solo along with flute accompaniment throughout the song.

  • @friendtazo
    @friendtazo 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks Heline!

  • @jamieburnette2438
    @jamieburnette2438 4 роки тому

    Waggaki Band - Senbonzakura. Japanese metal band who incorporates traditional Japanese instruments and vocal style. Including a bamboo flute.

  • @JWCinPDX
    @JWCinPDX 4 роки тому

    Could you explain why there are alternate fingerings? I played clarinet, bass clarinet, Tenor saxophone, and bari. I don't know of any instances on those instruments where there were alternate fingerings that might have been a little flat or sharp.

  • @jorgeolafsen4659
    @jorgeolafsen4659 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks Heline. Wonderful...

  • @alegspar
    @alegspar 4 роки тому

    I loved Marshall Tucker Band

  • @steelers6titles
    @steelers6titles 3 роки тому

    Flute was an integral part of that band's sound.

  • @brunoRLharris
    @brunoRLharris 4 роки тому

    Heline, my name is Bruno i am brazilian! and one of the reasons for falling in love with MTB was the sound of Jerry Eubanks' flute! Listen to the song Singing Rhymes, the flute solo of this song is beautiful!

  • @garygoodson2300
    @garygoodson2300 4 роки тому +6

    It definitely had a few blemishes as a live recording. The studio version is well worth a visit with a much cleaner mix, more polished flute and tighter vocals not peppered by so much distracting ad libbing.

  • @thomderd4238
    @thomderd4238 4 роки тому

    Hi. Blues Influence but also Jazz as well. A lot of jazz is free-form. Have you ever listened to Herbie Mann ?

  • @musician4life451
    @musician4life451 4 роки тому +8

    A good 70's southern rock band. His flute playing wasn't front and center in the song as it was for Ian Anderson, but was a nice accompaniment.

    • @johnbroadwell2603
      @johnbroadwell2603 4 роки тому +1

      My thoughts exactly, and Ian is one of the best, if not the best. It would be great to see Heline and Ian in a duet.

  • @paulstewart6203
    @paulstewart6203 3 роки тому +2

    When they called Jerry Eubanks and asked him if he knew how to play the flute, he lied, and said yes. They knew he played the sax, so Jerry said he practiced three days straight on the flute because he wanted to be in the band.

  • @russellcraft7269
    @russellcraft7269 3 роки тому

    Playing F# with the middle finger rather than the ring finger and pinky is how it is done on saxophone and the upper register of the clarinet. Most rock woodwind players start out on sax and migrate to the others, so will play using fingeringgs that they are familiar with.

  • @dennishinkle5010
    @dennishinkle5010 4 роки тому

    I saw your video playing Muddy Shoes and fell in love with it. Please do more original songs. You are extremely good. 😘

  • @4everblue72
    @4everblue72 3 роки тому

    This band is new to me, I love Heline's knowledge some people said that this isn't a good example of the flooter in the band ... I don't know why he wouldn't of taken learning yhe flute further to at least get the correct fingerings to get the best possible sound not just so it sounds good to an untrained ear. Always learning from Heline.

  • @davidharrison4881
    @davidharrison4881 4 роки тому

    Love this song.

  • @michaelmulrine5740
    @michaelmulrine5740 4 роки тому

    Hi Heline.
    Have you listened to a band called Wucan? Vocalist plays flute a lot.
    Well worth a listen

  • @UncleSasquatchOutdoors
    @UncleSasquatchOutdoors 3 роки тому +1

    I think he did very well considering that Jerry is a sax player.

  • @JackTheRabbitMusic
    @JackTheRabbitMusic 4 роки тому +23

    who else thinks Heline is the cutest youtuber?! 🐰❤️💐🎸🎶🤝✌️

    • @CalJennings
      @CalJennings 4 роки тому +1

      I do!

    • @mikearcher9390
      @mikearcher9390 4 роки тому

      I'LL GUESS BLIND PEOPLE?

    • @raysiekierski7656
      @raysiekierski7656 3 роки тому +1

      she hasn't returned my marriage request..no news is good news

    • @bgoneification
      @bgoneification 3 роки тому

      She's kind of snooty

    • @larryspiller6633
      @larryspiller6633 3 роки тому

      @@bgoneification No, just a school trained musician. They have a different take on things. It can come across as snooty. Everything has to be perfect in form to them.

  • @earlking1006
    @earlking1006 4 роки тому

    Jerry was a sax player who taught himself to play flute. It is what it is.

  • @benntura
    @benntura 4 роки тому

    Alright! It's nice see you watch The Marshall Tucker Band.

  • @sly2392
    @sly2392 4 роки тому +1

    i will say it for you heline. hes so so.

  • @robertprendiville1349
    @robertprendiville1349 3 роки тому

    You haven’t reacted yet to Chris Wood with Traffic- he had many great concert performances Try the John Barleycorn tune, for one

  • @rh8611
    @rh8611 4 роки тому

    Seemed like you were enjoying the music, I never really listened to them much, kind of 1980s country rock music I think. I have heard this song a lot at festivals and summer events, seems like a favorite of cover bands

  • @sbotsford1
    @sbotsford1 4 роки тому +11

    I am enjoying the commentary but would love to see you play some of the flute solos you react to!

    • @thomasdavidson8692
      @thomasdavidson8692 4 роки тому +9

      Me too. I'd love to hear Heline play some Ian Anderson...snorting and all.

    • @theohioshirey
      @theohioshirey 4 роки тому +1

      @@thomasdavidson8692 Heline would probably be very graceful, even doing that! 💖🙏

    • @mikearcher9390
      @mikearcher9390 4 роки тому

      she can't that's why...

  • @michaelloveland1330
    @michaelloveland1330 4 роки тому

    Thanks, Heline! Love your take. Love MTB too, and hope you react to two of the best 3 "flute tunes" - "Take the Highway" and "Can't You See?" ("Can't You See?" is one of my favorite all-time tears-in-my-beer songs, and I seem to be collecting reactions!) No, flutist was not singing, that's Doug Gray on lead mouth on this one. (Toy Caldwell was the other, on CYS.) Take those two tunes from the Tanglewood shows, this was not one of their best performances (and I saw them a whole bunch).

  • @alanshapiro5669
    @alanshapiro5669 4 роки тому +1

    would love you to react to "Flute Thing" by either The Blues Project or Seatrain. Andy Kulberg is the flute player

  • @499PUCK
    @499PUCK Рік тому

    Hi, I think if you listen to the studio version it’s cleaner.

  • @billdyke9745
    @billdyke9745 4 роки тому

    I think Heline should be made President of the World. When things get fractious she could do a little flute tootling and tell us what we should do with our pinkies. All those in favour press 👍.

  • @FunkyMarcel
    @FunkyMarcel 4 роки тому

    ....................................Jerry Eubanks played sax , that may explain his flute style,,,check out some Herbie Mann---- 'Memphis Underground'

  • @elvistellen
    @elvistellen 4 роки тому

    What do you think about our national fluteman mr. Loiri? I red Tervo's biograpfy that he learned ansatsi in ratikka on his way to studio to record his playing;DDD

  • @kerrymartin707
    @kerrymartin707 4 роки тому +1

    This is one of my favorite songs. You review of the flute playing is fantastic. So is your smile!

  • @ianwilkinson4602
    @ianwilkinson4602 4 роки тому

    Hello Heline, I bought one of Ian Anderson's solo albums called "Rupi's Dance" recently, Lots of flute and some nice Tullish mellow songs. you may like it.

  • @compnnburns8831
    @compnnburns8831 4 роки тому

    Heline check out Vikram Shankar he has done 3 piano interpretations of a prog group close to my heart, not to mention Royal Phil in London which covered a whole album of their work and I see some tuboists (correct pronoun?) have also covered them. They do a lot of instrumentals as a group, their name: Rush. They toured with an 8 piece string section in 2013, amazing musicians in their own right. I would love it if you covered 1 of their songs and would give you a big tip (coffee for a month).

  • @wjhandy
    @wjhandy 4 роки тому +9

    You do have to realize he most likely high, so there is that

  • @robertbutler4672
    @robertbutler4672 4 роки тому +1

    Ok, I have to admit I'm not the biggest fan of this song (it's way over played here in the American south) but the flute part makes it distinctive from other southern rock classics...well alright I've grooved to this track a few times. Nice reaction Heline, best wishes!

  • @marcelnz
    @marcelnz 4 роки тому

    Have you checked out Genesis' Peter Gabriel?

  • @doughboybellmore2347
    @doughboybellmore2347 3 роки тому

    Doug Grey is the lead singer an the rest of the band always throwing their voice in there also

  • @fiefenduddch
    @fiefenduddch 4 роки тому

    Nice to see another reaction Video from you, as "Bridge" in Case of your move 😏
    Fine done... as always

  • @thorshammer5776
    @thorshammer5776 4 роки тому

    Please listen to Spill The Wine by Eric Burden and the Animals. Very interesting flutework in this great song

  • @edwardmichalski4558
    @edwardmichalski4558 4 роки тому

    I wish you could play the same piece that you are reviewing as you review.

  • @thomasd9237
    @thomasd9237 5 місяців тому +1

    You should listen to the recorded version not the live version

  • @Fretless99
    @Fretless99 4 роки тому

    I like your videos...I will miss you when I'm gone

  • @kirbygulbrandsen4507
    @kirbygulbrandsen4507 3 роки тому

    Maybe you should listen to it from a recording studio when they play live there could be many abnormalities. I purposely listened to it on a recorded song and it was much better.

  • @vapormissile
    @vapormissile 4 роки тому

    Long ago I thought reaction videos were pointless, because I could just watch the song ... but you kids give me a fresh set of eyes as well as like jamal or whomever, keep the art alive. Thanks for a different point of view. Parallax.
    (par·al·lax - noun. the effect whereby the position or direction of an object appears to differ when viewed from different positions, e.g. through the viewfinder and the lens of a camera)

  • @jamesjenkins7944
    @jamesjenkins7944 4 роки тому +8

    MTV It's not dead, it just smells putrid.

  • @DIY-valvular
    @DIY-valvular 4 роки тому

    That's not wrong fingering, no. That's the hillbilly's way at the County of Hazzard! :-)))))

  • @JimDorman
    @JimDorman 4 роки тому

    Thanks for checking out Marshall Tucker! This isn't the best version of the band, but for checking out the flute, it will do.

  • @gmh101358
    @gmh101358 4 роки тому

    They were popular when i was in high school.....that was 72-76 ......If i remember I went to one of their concerts around 74?......close to 50 years ago you cant remember much....the flute was not the center piece for the band it was Toy Caldwell's guitar playing and his brother on bass. Them southern boys could tear it up back in their day.....sadly their all dead now. The early seventies had such great music coming out.....never to be repeated.....As I called them Jethro Dull was the one that used a flute as center piece....I only liked their first record Aqualung...TAAB was way to long.....and thats was it. I get asked who thought put on the best live shows? Led Zeppelin hands down.... Deep Purple, but expect hearing loss.....Yes ....Pink Floyd....The Who.....the golden years of rock......but nobody used a flute.

  • @waldoparsnip1025
    @waldoparsnip1025 4 роки тому

    To me , this is The Marshal Tucker Bands' best song , at least , it's my favorite !l

  • @mikeclark3013
    @mikeclark3013 4 роки тому

    Good old Southern Rock!

  • @markcastrovinci6074
    @markcastrovinci6074 4 роки тому

    I can’t tell who is singing and who is playing the flute. I believe in the seventies Doug Gray did both. Maybe you can do a reaction video to the original lineup including the Caldwell brothers on guitar and bass.

    • @MisterBeauJanGels
      @MisterBeauJanGels 3 роки тому

      In the original band, Jerry Eubanks played flute and saxophone.

  • @MikeK2100
    @MikeK2100 4 роки тому

    I am thinking they are using a vocal microphone and not one designed for instruments. There is a big difference in the sound spectrum that they pick up.

  • @patrickv391
    @patrickv391 4 роки тому +10

    MTV----Reality show killed the video star

  • @j.l.wickham2531
    @j.l.wickham2531 3 роки тому

    Southern Rock the flute was close enough!

  • @tedkay_music
    @tedkay_music 4 роки тому

    cool!

  • @EliasEliadis
    @EliasEliadis 4 роки тому

    Could you see the Temple of the King by Focus?

  • @carlosedcnatal1367
    @carlosedcnatal1367 4 роки тому +2

    Thank you, Heline! Like 👍 from Juiz de Fora, Brasil! 🤘😁✌

  • @spikechampkart55
    @spikechampkart55 3 роки тому

    Yes, his mic is in the flute, he has played for millions of hippies, they didn't mind. He has better stuff! Yes, I was guitar tech for them, he was the least trouble of all. He took care of everything, once I gave him a cord. I remember adding on his wireless, new technology then!

  • @RookBytes
    @RookBytes 4 роки тому

    'Sup Heline! Good to see you as always. I never expected you to cover TMTB but there is a flute in there. Ha! I'm glad you like them. They're an awesome old-school band. Keep up the good work Heline! TTFN! =D
    P.S. I don't support the use of the "Rebel Flag" by anyone today. It's a symbol of racial hatred against all dark-skinned human beings.

  • @MrSweelinck
    @MrSweelinck 4 роки тому

    Barcus-Berry 6100 flue transducer.

  • @heathen2487
    @heathen2487 3 роки тому

    I wish you would rate the studio version. It's much more sharper.

  • @londohondo
    @londohondo 3 роки тому

    I think you're missing the whole picture, how he did it is how it was supposed to be done he's not doing it to meet classical flutist criteria he's a southern rock stage performer and the sound he admitted is the sound he was after nothing clean sharp or on time what you hear is what you get and that's what he wanted

  • @robertportersc
    @robertportersc 4 роки тому

    Please listen to the studio version at least once. He was so stoned in that video...

  • @jtgrham
    @jtgrham 4 роки тому

    I grew up listening to them and many other Southern Rock bands. Jeez they were ripped 😂. But cool nonetheless. Good choice 🙂

  • @adriancrowfly
    @adriancrowfly 4 роки тому

    My best friend in college played flute and keyboards with a local band in the 80's. He used a screw in flute mic so as to be able to move about the stage, similar to this one. I'm not sure from when this Marshall Tucker video was made, but it looks to be from some time ago. I don't think there are any artists left who would allow confederate flags to be waved around with such wild abandon. Well, not any that play publicly.

  • @HughCorbyCruick
    @HughCorbyCruick 3 роки тому

    You might be running out of Pop and Rock N’ Rollers soon, so check out Herbie Mann.