I suggest having a discussion on the weapons used in our epics: were they beyond bows and arrows, and if so how was that technology developed, and why were bows and arrows still required to deliver them?
Vanaras and Sri Hanuman belonged to a species that is a mix homo erectus and something else. These did not exist 11,000 years ago rather much older (could be more than 1.5 million years ago).
Ramayan happened at the end of Tretayug. Dvapara is around 900k years big. So it makes sense we should look to human species around 1 million to 2 million years ago
Sir i have a question ram ji was 81st king of ikshvaku dynasty, there were 64 more kings after him, the last king sumitra was killed by mahapadma nanda in 1634 bce, if each king ruled for like 50ish years(over estimation imo) it would mean the dynasty lasted for 3200 years after ram ji, that would mean it ended around 11 thousand years ago, these dates don't line up there is a 6-7 thousand year gap, please address this inconsistency
previous kings ruled more than just only 50 years, like ram ji ruled about 11 thousand years, for Kaliyuga you can assume that kings ruled only like 50ish years
This is the answer I'm pasting from chat gpt. Yes, star alignments can repeat due to the cyclic nature of celestial movements. Over long periods, stars return to similar positions in the sky, creating patterns that recur over thousands or even millions of years.
If you'll watch other videos of Nilesh Oak, be it his channel and sangam talks. He has explained all the related astronomical data. Yes some star alignment can repeat after some time some after tens of thousands of years and some are highly unlikely to recurr. He has explained in detail the dating of the nakshatra combinations mentioned in ramayan and Mahabharat and the mention of southern pole star. He has also correl8the astronomical with modern hydrogeological data of river beds and sea levels comparing it to the ramayan and mahabharat texts to come at it's date of 12000BC for Ramayan and 5000BC for Mahabharat.
@@ashwinchauhan8435 you seriously believe in those fairy tales ? Man is this what 21st century super power india is going to be? Beleiving in unscientific nonsense and stuff
It's all about metaphors. All the characters either have never existed or are just normal human being who were glorified with supernatural powers and unscientific nonsense
gompothere is a fam...ily of both ...4tuske..d and 2tusk..ed elephants...only 2tu...sked elephants have b..een found 11000 years ago..NOT 4tusked elephants...be..ware of oak...DISI..NFO
Do u even read research papers or not....4 tusked elephant fossil had already been found.....go to geology museum in bandung, west java....you'll find the fossilized skull of 4 tusk elephant
😂😂very nice. Ranveer has gone to new level of stupidity after getting that award.. Imagine Greeks trying to prove all their mythology and start claiming that Chimera and Medusa existed.. complete bullshit these guys are.
Thinking is the hardest job in this world. That’s why most remain mediocre. Just because yr small mind unable to perceive it that’s does not mean it never happened or existed.
@@stallionspirit1576 that's not the case. One of them had 2 longer and 2 shorter tusks, such that the tusks were inside the mouth and a very little portion of it was visible. But the fact they were present in South America is what baffles me. Maybe Ravan, who was from the Rakshasa kul went to Paatal Loka to get them. High probability.
@@dragonboyraunak7031 there were 3 types of gompotheres...4tusked...2tusk + 2vestigial ///...and 2 tusked....itz only the 2tusked gompothere..that existed 12000 years ago..
@@raviperav8858 gompothere is a family of both 4tusked and 2 tusked elephants...only fossils of 2tusked elephants..are found 11000 years ago..case closed..
@@raviperav8858 gompo....there is a fam..ily of both 4tu..sked and 2 tusk..ed elephants...only fossils of 2tu..sked elepha..nts..are found 11000 years ago..case closed..
It can't be... We weren't civilized that long ago. If it doesn't take place in the 7000-12000 years ago window, it's all fiction then. Nothing can be a million years ago except for hunter gatherers.
@@ARTHAPRODUCTIONS very simple...4tusked elephants becoming extinct million years ago is a fact...and 4tusked elephants mentioned in ramayan is a fact...and ramayan happened in treta yuga...case closed.
@@stallionspirit9317 not yet closed....see that Google search segment....it is clearly written that they were present on earth from some million years to 11,000 years....Case open...now try to close the case with logical explanation
Man was asked about the ramayana evidence he started proving about the special tusked elephant 😂😂😂 If All animals would be there in ramayana bro, dosnt mean it existed... Man tell me how was pushpak viman flyin at that time with what fuel? Which other technology was there to support it? If you want to give evidence of ramayan, give us the evidence of inscriptions, manuscripts, archeological findings!!
Why don't you become an archaeologist yourself?? East to talk. INDUS VALLEY CIV. was discovered by accident, when British were laying RAILWAY lines. So many things are waiting to be discovered. So as per your logic, since no discovery, these do not exist, is it??
@@infobyfaizan6338we can show but then we're tired to you people then twist the words and be like "oh oh but how does a carpet look by your perspective" and similar gibberish so it's no use, even if i present the exact words I'm pretty convinced you won't accept but rather twist it
I suggest having a discussion on the weapons used in our epics: were they beyond bows and arrows, and if so how was that technology developed, and why were bows and arrows still required to deliver them?
I learn so many things from your podcasts thankyou for giving so many things.
Salute you Nilesh oak sire
I think dhruv rathe should watch this 😂😂
True 💯😂😂
This doesn't really prove that the Ramayana happened tho.
@@vaibhavsharma4741 🤡
Exactly 🙌
Hindutva, if allowed to flourish, will certainly bring shame and destruction to India.
Thank you so much. I was losing my cool over the recent comments on our history being mythology by many 'intellectuals'.
History and mythology is different my guy.
@@SafavidAfsharid3197 Of course
Salute to both of you sir.
Vanaras and Sri Hanuman belonged to a species that is a mix homo erectus and something else. These did not exist 11,000 years ago rather much older (could be more than 1.5 million years ago).
Ramayan happened at the end of Tretayug. Dvapara is around 900k years big. So it makes sense we should look to human species around 1 million to 2 million years ago
Invite Devdatta Patnayak too for holistic view on history
I believe ramayan n mahabharat was real ..but it's more glorified about magic ,God, such things...
Definitely romila thapar or irfan habib or ramchand guha are not warriors ...they may be warriors of Macaulay
Hindutva, if allowed to flourish, will certainly bring shame and destruction to India.
First decide the time period of ramayan with all evidence . If all evidence is there the world will definitely be recognised it
Please bring one CMA (Cost and management accountant) in the show for recognise cma is global. And it is wealthy in the future..
Sir i have a question ram ji was 81st king of ikshvaku dynasty, there were 64 more kings after him, the last king sumitra was killed by mahapadma nanda in 1634 bce, if each king ruled for like 50ish years(over estimation imo) it would mean the dynasty lasted for 3200 years after ram ji, that would mean it ended around 11 thousand years ago, these dates don't line up there is a 6-7 thousand year gap, please address this inconsistency
previous kings ruled more than just only 50 years, like ram ji ruled about 11 thousand years, for Kaliyuga you can assume that kings ruled only like 50ish years
I want to know one thing.. Is it possible stars alignment during Shree Ram's birth can be repeated again in future?
This is the answer I'm pasting from chat gpt.
Yes, star alignments can repeat due to the cyclic nature of celestial movements. Over long periods, stars return to similar positions in the sky, creating patterns that recur over thousands or even millions of years.
If you'll watch other videos of Nilesh Oak, be it his channel and sangam talks. He has explained all the related astronomical data. Yes some star alignment can repeat after some time some after tens of thousands of years and some are highly unlikely to recurr. He has explained in detail the dating of the nakshatra combinations mentioned in ramayan and Mahabharat and the mention of southern pole star. He has also correl8the astronomical with modern hydrogeological data of river beds and sea levels comparing it to the ramayan and mahabharat texts to come at it's date of 12000BC for Ramayan and 5000BC for Mahabharat.
Wonderful!
Ramayan Happened 18 million years ago 👍🏻
Humans are just 300000 years old .
He is telling 18000 years ago
@@vaibhavsharma4741 Bhai different Yuga
Bruh basic maths
@@ashwinchauhan8435 you seriously believe in those fairy tales ? Man is this what 21st century super power india is going to be? Beleiving in unscientific nonsense and stuff
@@ashwinchauhan8435cut a few zeroes in that you are good
My biggest doubt ----
How come there are no proofs of ramayan / mahabharata in the indus valley civilization??????
we don't know yet there langauge that is why
Today, l post a comment.
May, 5 2024 __08.14 p.m._
Java island
मतलब हिंदी भाषियों को ज्ञान नहीं देना है क्या 😂
Indian mythology books & puranas is full of metaphor which need deep analysis, folks don't take everything literally
When I was reading them I thought they were literal and only when I started to understand what it actually means I found out it was metaphor
If their is metaphor their is explanation about it like ratha kalpana ( chariot metaphor) in Vedas
It's all about metaphors. All the characters either have never existed or are just normal human being who were glorified with supernatural powers and unscientific nonsense
@dhruverathee this is real expert your facts are nonsense
You're going against science nuff said
Aap log hindi bat nahi kar pate kya khudki basha bolte hoi saram aati hai aap logoko
gompothere is a fam...ily of both ...4tuske..d and 2tusk..ed elephants...only 2tu...sked elephants have b..een found 11000 years ago..NOT 4tusked elephants...be..ware of oak...DISI..NFO
Do u even read research papers or not....4 tusked elephant fossil had already been found.....go to geology museum in bandung, west java....you'll find the fossilized skull of 4 tusk elephant
Oak Speak ing facts
😂😂very nice. Ranveer has gone to new level of stupidity after getting that award.. Imagine Greeks trying to prove all their mythology and start claiming that Chimera and Medusa existed.. complete bullshit these guys are.
Itne evidence ke baad bhi aise comments karoge to new level of stupidity pe wo nhi aap hai. Jeeyo, apni man me bani banyai duniya me jeeyo.
They have the Proof to what they say.....What the F u have to say they are stupid?
Thinking is the hardest job in this world. That’s why most remain mediocre. Just because yr small mind unable to perceive it that’s does not mean it never happened or existed.
oak lie on 4tusked elephant...has completely blown apart...DISINFO of ramayan only 14000years old
Nonsense
@@raviperav8858 research...gompotheres are a family of both, 4tusked and 2tusked...only 2tusked gompothere existed 11.000years ago...
@@stallionspirit1576 that's not the case. One of them had 2 longer and 2 shorter tusks, such that the tusks were inside the mouth and a very little portion of it was visible. But the fact they were present in South America is what baffles me.
Maybe Ravan, who was from the Rakshasa kul went to Paatal Loka to get them. High probability.
@@dragonboyraunak7031 there were 3 types of gompotheres...4tusked...2tusk + 2vestigial ///...and 2 tusked....itz only the 2tusked gompothere..that existed 12000 years ago..
@@dragonboyraunak7031 there were 3 types of gomp-there....am specifically talikg about 2tusked ones..
I used to like ranveer a lot especially how he cares for his mom but now I seriously dislike him because he is bias towards Muslims in a negative way.
Both you folks believe in unscientific nonsense so both you guys are in the wrong here
Very scientific of you ranveer you're getting worse with each videos
Beware of Nilesh...DISINFO on ramayan age...
Nonsense
@@raviperav8858 research..dont be like a blind peacefool of arabia..lol
envy.
@@suchithraraghavan5335 disnformation needs awareness...not envy
this guy is talking complete crap on 4tusk elephants existing 11,000years ago...
? Your source? - besides ‘trust me bro’?
@@raviperav8858 simple...4tusked elephant mentioned in ramayan... became extinct 1-1.6million years ago......case closed...
@@raviperav8858 gompothere is a family of both 4tusked and 2 tusked elephants...only fossils of 2tusked elephants..are found 11000 years ago..case closed..
@@raviperav8858 gompo....there is a fam..ily of both 4tu..sked and 2 tusk..ed elephants...only fossils of 2tu..sked elepha..nts..are found 11000 years ago..case closed..
The evidence in Cambodia temple. They carved on the temple…
bew..are of ..niles,,h oak... spreading disinfo of ramayan being only 14000years old..ramayan is million+years old...
It can't be... We weren't civilized that long ago. If it doesn't take place in the 7000-12000 years ago window, it's all fiction then. Nothing can be a million years ago except for hunter gatherers.
Proof?
@@ARTHAPRODUCTIONS very simple...4tusked elephants becoming extinct million years ago is a fact...and 4tusked elephants mentioned in ramayan is a fact...and ramayan happened in treta yuga...case closed.
@@stallionspirit9317 not yet closed....see that Google search segment....it is clearly written that they were present on earth from some million years to 11,000 years....Case open...now try to close the case with logical explanation
@@ARTHAPRODUCTIONS hope you got the proof you wanted...
Man was asked about the ramayana evidence he started proving about the special tusked elephant 😂😂😂
If All animals would be there in ramayana bro, dosnt mean it existed...
Man tell me how was pushpak viman flyin at that time with what fuel?
Which other technology was there to support it?
If you want to give evidence of ramayan, give us the evidence of inscriptions, manuscripts, archeological findings!!
Why don't you become an archaeologist yourself??
East to talk.
INDUS VALLEY CIV. was discovered by accident, when British were laying RAILWAY lines.
So many things are waiting to be discovered.
So as per your logic, since no discovery, these do not exist, is it??
@lyrical9582 so you want us to believe something which is not yet discovered? As per your logic 😂
The only book which is most proven by science is QURAN
Nonsense bro. All religion is man made.
science like...earth is flat...lol
@@stallionspirit1576 where Quran says earth is flat.. Show me one ayat... Just one..
@@infobyfaizan6338we can show but then we're tired to you people then twist the words and be like "oh oh but how does a carpet look by your perspective" and similar gibberish so it's no use, even if i present the exact words I'm pretty convinced you won't accept but rather twist it
@@dolundtramp . No no u can show. I'm here. Where Allah clearly says that He made earth flat...
I'm waiting,