Great review! As a Japanese who reads both the originalJapanese version and English-translated version, I noticed a slight mistranslations in Hild’s commentary. She actually said in the original Japanese version that “You worked hard to release ME from the curse of my revenge” whereas in the English version “You worked hard to be released from the curse of my revenge.” Well they both got released from it, but I definitely think the original language reflects Hild’s true feelings.
Indeed, the community is small, but I've been seeing many good channel pop up over the last 6 months. Its exciting! Thanks for the videos you make, I can't make a video at this level every month (hence my inconsistent uploads) so I'm glad you and a few others are there to keep the content game going even when I'm slacking. :)
Oh my god I didn't even consider the observation of Hild's and Thorfinn's hair looking like Prologue Thorfinn's and Askeladd's. Intentional or not that is an incredible detail. Overall excelent video, the editing and your script are all on point.
Really? I thought you and LadyvGrey were talking about it in the Discord... I remember feeling "nooooooo, I was going to make that point T^T" but maybe my mind is playing tricks on me haha. Thank you for the compliment! I'll be sure to sit down and listen to your video once I get the time! I purposely hadn't watched because I didn't want your thoughts to influence mine.
@@JarkeyBacon I think I did discuss a similar idea about the hair, but I mostly focused on Hild! I liked the idea that, by covering her face, she is able to stand in for all the people Thorfinn has hurt. Thorfinn being forgiven is both personal for her, but also much much larger than her. In that moment I see her as an amabassador for the souls of his victims.
Yeah, I absolutely believe that this is the completion of the house of cards Thorfinn has built and starting soon, they'll be falling, one-by-one or maybe all at once. Too many forces are gathering to ruin what they've built, and it won't be long before Thorfinn might have to start fighting uphill again.
Another amazing video!! Chapter 191 really was something else. Highest of praises towards Yukimura. As you pointed out, the way the chapter was constructed couldn’t have been more perfect. I’ve still hardly recovered from the emotional whiplash and now it’s almost time for a new chapter to be released! Looking forward to the next video!
0:22 I can’t believe I’m in a JarkeyBacon video aha, I want to congratulate you for making such a masterpiece video, I know this took more than a week to do! From the perfect thumbnail with the coloring, the phenomenal 3D movement editing, the amazing references (my fav one was the comparison with Thorfinn and Askeladd hair) This is the kind of video that when you rewatch it 10 years later, you’re gonna say “damn I can’t believe it I made something like this. ”Quality>Quantity! Thank you for making content like this!
Congrats, you are now part of an elite circle of people cameo-ing in my videos! Its nice to see other editors watch and complement your work because they often notice the smaller things that others don't. I really appreciate the long comment! My goal with all these videos are to make ones that I can watch in a year's time and still be proud of them (which for as someone as s̶e̶l̶f̶-̶o̶b̶s̶e̶s̶s̶e̶d̶ ̶ self confident as I am, it not too hard haha). Jokes aside, I would like to maybe have a big enough audience one day where I could got through and review my own videos giving my tips and tricks along the way. But I don't think I have the following to do that. Thanks for stopping by! Looking forward to more edits from you! Ik I haven't been commenting as much but I love them all the same
Video comment: Worth the wait! This is really beautifully edited. Really clean (both the edits and the music), but also very engaging. Eyes (gaze*) glued to the screen \(*-*)/ I was taken aback by your statement about Pulmuk for a second, until I realized you were referring to Vinland as a location, not the series! In that case, I agree he's probably one of the best potential fighters in Vinland at the moment (I like the addition of his handshake with Thorfinn, it's not a panel I had paid much attention to when I first read that chapter!). Really loved your summary of Hild's mindset, her journey, and the parallels between her declaration of war and ultimately, her forgiveness. It's a good time to be a Hild fan. Now here's to swatting away her death flags now that her big "arc" has reached its end! I often jokingly say "thanks for the food" when I enjoy a piece of fan content, but in this case, thanks for the sandwiches? xD ----- Chapter comment: It truly is a great chapter. I think it's been clear for a really long time that Hild would eventually declare Thorfinn had atoned and let him go on with his life, but the main reason I found the chapter so beautiful is that she *forgave* him. Thorfinn's been plagued by guilt for so long, and being forgiven and accepted by one of the only people hurt by him who's seen both who he was in his violent youth and who he is now must mean the world. It's on a whole different plane than being accepted by people like Einar and Gudrid, who have only known him after that period of his life. Ahh, and Hild -- having that moment in such a calm, mundane setting and looking so free and unburdened at last... it's been a long time coming, and I couldn't have imagined a better execution.
Thank you for the multiple comments! The response to this video have been much more happy then I anticipated. It turned out much more polished then I envisioned haha. (Very funny gaze* comment. Very astute.) I'm glad you enjoyed the sandwiches! The Pulmuk hand thing was why I made that tweet all the way back. Yukimura and his hands xd. When / if Pulmuk throws hands, I'll be waiting! A Hild death would hurt, but also be kinda amazing. Einar is the main target people are looking at, but if Yukimura wants to hurts is readers more (which I'm all for) Hild is the way to go atm. Your chapter comment sums up really well what makes this execution of Hild's arc so perfect. Really well put! Very important distinction between Thorfinn's atonement, and Hild's forgiveness.
randomly came across this video and all i have to say is keep 👏 making 👏 more 👏 videos. The way you narrate viewers through this is beyond beautiful (had to subscribe). The editing is top tier nothing too crazy nothing too lazy either. It's just perfect. Loved this so much. Ready to watch more from you ill be sharing this video with the ppl who read this chapter. Thank you. Thank you again.
Ahh thanks! Well, as far and my videos are concerned, 2k views is really good! So, I'm pretty happy with where it is at. Though, I appreciate the sentiment.
Aww, thanks a ton! I'm glad you liked this video haha. A little secret is that I was aiming for this video to be quick and messy... but I guess I couldn't help myself XD.
3 minutes into the video, I must say, hats off for the effort! Knowing how painful and time consuming to do all this in After Effects (which I presume is what u used haha). keep it up! Great video :)
Woow this is some quality content that surely took a lot of time to make, it was very well constructed and edited. A fantastic review to one of vinland's best chapters. I'm looking forward to see more of these reviews in the future, i hope you'll do more at least for the bigger and more important chapters. Thanks for your great work.
Thank you for the lovely comment! I can't guarantee these reviews to be common, I need both the time and the will (to put in that time) into making these videos. Furthermore, I can't make a video if I have nothing interesting to say. This chapter had enough little things I think it warranted a video but that is not always the case. Despite this, its perfectly possible I make a video on another chapter in the future. Either way, there are more Vinland Saga videos on the way!
I love how both Hild’s and Thorfinn’s fathers’ wishes came true this chapter
Great review! As a Japanese who reads both the originalJapanese version and English-translated version, I noticed a slight mistranslations in Hild’s commentary. She actually said in the original Japanese version that “You worked hard to release ME from the curse of my revenge” whereas in the English version “You worked hard to be released from the curse of my revenge.” Well they both got released from it, but I definitely think the original language reflects Hild’s true feelings.
Fascinating! Thank you for commenting. It brings an interesting subtext that wasn't there before :D
The English translation I read said “u fought hard and long to release me from the curse of vengeance. You Thorfinn, are a TRUE warrior”
FANTASTIC video! Will be sharing 👍 We need more Vinland content on youtube!
Indeed, the community is small, but I've been seeing many good channel pop up over the last 6 months. Its exciting!
Thanks for the videos you make, I can't make a video at this level every month (hence my inconsistent uploads) so I'm glad you and a few others are there to keep the content game going even when I'm slacking. :)
Oh my god I didn't even consider the observation of Hild's and Thorfinn's hair looking like Prologue Thorfinn's and Askeladd's. Intentional or not that is an incredible detail.
Overall excelent video, the editing and your script are all on point.
Really? I thought you and LadyvGrey were talking about it in the Discord... I remember feeling "nooooooo, I was going to make that point T^T" but maybe my mind is playing tricks on me haha.
Thank you for the compliment! I'll be sure to sit down and listen to your video once I get the time! I purposely hadn't watched because I didn't want your thoughts to influence mine.
@@JarkeyBacon I think I did discuss a similar idea about the hair, but I mostly focused on Hild! I liked the idea that, by covering her face, she is able to stand in for all the people Thorfinn has hurt. Thorfinn being forgiven is both personal for her, but also much much larger than her. In that moment I see her as an amabassador for the souls of his victims.
Ohh yeah that was me and OxSystem/OddHesitation! The mod colours all blend together ;)
@@ladyvgrey Ahhh, I see. Probably Artorios/Mayonnaise too now I think about it!
Yeah, I absolutely believe that this is the completion of the house of cards Thorfinn has built and starting soon, they'll be falling, one-by-one or maybe all at once. Too many forces are gathering to ruin what they've built, and it won't be long before Thorfinn might have to start fighting uphill again.
Another amazing video!! Chapter 191 really was something else. Highest of praises towards Yukimura. As you pointed out, the way the chapter was constructed couldn’t have been more perfect. I’ve still hardly recovered from the emotional whiplash and now it’s almost time for a new chapter to be released!
Looking forward to the next video!
It wouldn't be a good video without an Emma comment! Really glad you liked this chapter and video. I hope to produce more good videos on the future!
Still not over the chapter. Can’t wait to see the rest of this arc play out.
0:22 I can’t believe I’m in a JarkeyBacon video aha, I want to congratulate you for making such a masterpiece video, I know this took more than a week to do! From the perfect thumbnail with the coloring, the phenomenal 3D movement editing, the amazing references (my fav one was the comparison with Thorfinn and Askeladd hair) This is the kind of video that when you rewatch it 10 years later, you’re gonna say “damn I can’t believe it I made something like this. ”Quality>Quantity!
Thank you for making content like this!
Congrats, you are now part of an elite circle of people cameo-ing in my videos! Its nice to see other editors watch and complement your work because they often notice the smaller things that others don't. I really appreciate the long comment!
My goal with all these videos are to make ones that I can watch in a year's time and still be proud of them (which for as someone as s̶e̶l̶f̶-̶o̶b̶s̶e̶s̶s̶e̶d̶ ̶ self confident as I am, it not too hard haha). Jokes aside, I would like to maybe have a big enough audience one day where I could got through and review my own videos giving my tips and tricks along the way. But I don't think I have the following to do that.
Thanks for stopping by! Looking forward to more edits from you! Ik I haven't been commenting as much but I love them all the same
I just want them all to be happy 😭 they've been though so much
Video comment:
Worth the wait! This is really beautifully edited. Really clean (both the edits and the music), but also very engaging. Eyes (gaze*) glued to the screen \(*-*)/
I was taken aback by your statement about Pulmuk for a second, until I realized you were referring to Vinland as a location, not the series! In that case, I agree he's probably one of the best potential fighters in Vinland at the moment (I like the addition of his handshake with Thorfinn, it's not a panel I had paid much attention to when I first read that chapter!).
Really loved your summary of Hild's mindset, her journey, and the parallels between her declaration of war and ultimately, her forgiveness. It's a good time to be a Hild fan. Now here's to swatting away her death flags now that her big "arc" has reached its end!
I often jokingly say "thanks for the food" when I enjoy a piece of fan content, but in this case, thanks for the sandwiches? xD
-----
Chapter comment:
It truly is a great chapter. I think it's been clear for a really long time that Hild would eventually declare Thorfinn had atoned and let him go on with his life, but the main reason I found the chapter so beautiful is that she *forgave* him. Thorfinn's been plagued by guilt for so long, and being forgiven and accepted by one of the only people hurt by him who's seen both who he was in his violent youth and who he is now must mean the world. It's on a whole different plane than being accepted by people like Einar and Gudrid, who have only known him after that period of his life.
Ahh, and Hild -- having that moment in such a calm, mundane setting and looking so free and unburdened at last... it's been a long time coming, and I couldn't have imagined a better execution.
Thank you for the multiple comments! The response to this video have been much more happy then I anticipated. It turned out much more polished then I envisioned haha. (Very funny gaze* comment. Very astute.) I'm glad you enjoyed the sandwiches!
The Pulmuk hand thing was why I made that tweet all the way back. Yukimura and his hands xd. When / if Pulmuk throws hands, I'll be waiting!
A Hild death would hurt, but also be kinda amazing. Einar is the main target people are looking at, but if Yukimura wants to hurts is readers more (which I'm all for) Hild is the way to go atm.
Your chapter comment sums up really well what makes this execution of Hild's arc so perfect. Really well put! Very important distinction between Thorfinn's atonement, and Hild's forgiveness.
Really appreciate the back round music choices.
Thank you! I spend quite a bit of time deliberating on them - trying to get the right 'feel'.
randomly came across this video and all i have to say is keep 👏 making 👏 more 👏 videos. The way you narrate viewers through this is beyond beautiful (had to subscribe). The editing is top tier nothing too crazy nothing too lazy either. It's just perfect. Loved this so much. Ready to watch more from you ill be sharing this video with the ppl who read this chapter. Thank you. Thank you again.
Thank you! I don't upload the most frequently but I've got more video like this planned.
Forgot to comment here!
I hope you keep doing this type of content for long, it's very well done and concisely written.
I don't plan on stopping any time soon :)
Amazing chapter! Good video bro 👍🏽
Thanks mate! Keep doing what you're doing to!
Crazy good editing and very nice analysis, I hope this video blows up for you sometime because it deserves it
Ahh thanks! Well, as far and my videos are concerned, 2k views is really good! So, I'm pretty happy with where it is at. Though, I appreciate the sentiment.
Man, I love your channel so much. Every video is so well made. You deserve way more subs, I hope good things come your way :)
Aww, thanks a ton! I'm glad you liked this video haha. A little secret is that I was aiming for this video to be quick and messy... but I guess I couldn't help myself XD.
3 minutes into the video, I must say, hats off for the effort! Knowing how painful and time consuming to do all this in After Effects (which I presume is what u used haha). keep it up! Great video :)
Thanks for the kind comment! I use Hitfilm Express (because its free haha) but one day I hope to grade once I get enough space to ran the programs XD
These videos are so good god damm
Thank you!!
One of the best chapters in the whole series legitimately
Woow this is some quality content that surely took a lot of time to make, it was very well constructed and edited. A fantastic review to one of vinland's best chapters. I'm looking forward to see more of these reviews in the future, i hope you'll do more at least for the bigger and more important chapters. Thanks for your great work.
Thank you for the lovely comment! I can't guarantee these reviews to be common, I need both the time and the will (to put in that time) into making these videos. Furthermore, I can't make a video if I have nothing interesting to say. This chapter had enough little things I think it warranted a video but that is not always the case.
Despite this, its perfectly possible I make a video on another chapter in the future. Either way, there are more Vinland Saga videos on the way!
Man i hope your prediction is wrong, but honestly I've been feeling the same way for the past three chapters
I can't say I'm the same, haha. I'm here for the pain!
Gudrid announcing that she's pregnant was extremely cute 😍
bruh this editing.... for only 600 views... god DAMN