i don't understand why people are sleeping on this. i'm glad that many reveluvs appreciate this bop, but people who don't are really missing such a masterpiece.
To tell you frankly, This song made me love Red Velvet (not a fan, but I appreciate Red Velvet's discography and overall) because the beat is so sultry and I love it. I wish Red Velvet make an another song that kinda similar to this.
The most underrated yet the most aesthetically pleasing. I actually feel bad to those who didn't get to hear Automatic. Dudee, u're missing a masterpiece 👏
as a musician myself, this is why I love Red Velvet, not just simply because of the visuals, but most importantly also the diverse, unique, experimental music artistry. they're just different from all other groups. I particularly really admire their 'velvet' side (usually much more experimental & artistic, than just simply following the 'mainstream' trends/hype like all other groups), which in today's music world, it's only Red Velvet that I know that performs music genre/style like this. I hope people could appreciate this more.
Not to put other group intended but I think CLC also have this kind of music that have a slower type of songs, sadly they are not successful as RV who also have two sides of music. Hopefully people would enjoy this kind of genre!
How bout those key changes in One of these nights eh? I like where youre coming from. Red velvet has some really interesting music. Bad Boy single handedly got me into Kpop and now I'm here to stay.
This song was way ahead of its time, kpop wasn't just ready for rnb and soul music as title tracks. If it was released today it'd have been hit on charts.
I want them to recycle this song so badly. This was released too early in their careers. It came at a perfect time to establish them as THE Red Velvet but the downside was that it wouldn't be fully appreciated
i think if iced coffee got promoted, it would be the new "one of these nights" and would fs establish their dominance in the rnb genre as a kpop group in their respective fields (basically showing they're one of, if not, the best kpop group to do krnb)
This is the type of song you listen when you're just chillin' alone, gazing up in the sky and watching the moon and stars while drinking a can of beer. Or the the type of song cafes usually plays.
i still can't believe that red velvet did *THIS* 7 months into their debut. they're something else indeed.. and to think that this is yeri's debut too 😳
they really debuted with LALALALALALALALALALA HAPPINESS and shifted into "it just comes so naturallll, it just comes automatic" less than a year into their career, they ARE the definition of something else
joy's gwanshim yeah and i think the fact that they have several concepts is so underrated, like they have red (happiness, dumb dumb, zimzalabim, etc.) and velvet (automatic, one of these nights) AND a combination of both (psycho, russian roulette...) they are really versatile and talented
Daniela psycho is definitely full on velvet and russian roulette is as red as u can get!! the mixture of both is more like peekaboo, and really bad boy
@@ladievengeance1577 for me Psycho and Pee-ka-boo are combination of red and velvet, while Psycho is more on velvet side and Peekaboo leans toward red side.
Ok let’s say they’re “barely” then 🤣 and also I think Power Up is kinda similar to Red Flavor (bc of the summer fruits) but I don’t see any similar of RF and PU with Umpah Umpah 😅?
honestly THIS is still one of their best, if not the BEST song of Red Velvet! it is so classy and timeless and it will never get boring. Kingdom Come to me has similar vibes, but will never give me the same satisfaction Automatic gives. It's absolutely a great song not only because of it's simple yet powerful r&b sound, but the wonderful harmonization, vocals and visuals of our girls make it complete.
@@nydrayahhadayah the song itself is a mix but the mv is purely a red concept for the day 1. plus the ReVe Festival trilogy is about Festival so in other word, it is a happy or a red (or a mix) concept. but i or you may be wrong when the Day 3 is out lol let's just support them
Automatic, Be Natural and Look are Red Velvet's best songs imo. That smooth, groovy and jazzy feel is what they fit the best. I'll stan if SM produces more songs like them.
You should check out their b-sides then. I'm sure you'll like Kingdom come, perfect 10, little little and a bunch of other rnb/chill retro tracks by them.
I mean... What’s new with Red Velvet? Many of their songs are ahead of their time. RBB is also one that aged well. Even Psycho was a few days ahead of its time. “Hey now it’ll be okay” after Wendy fell. They know how to call them, What else is there to say?
If this was released today it will be underappreciated again, doesn't take away the fact this song is a gem. Most kpop fans don't popularize anything besides girl crush/cute concepts.
So this randomly plays while I'm doing chores...WOW...beautiful song. I've heard their music and I must say, I have come across some gems but this takes the cake.
The fact that people are forgetting is that when this originally came out in 2015, girl groups in Korea weren’t doing this type of concept AT ALL. The fact that Red Velvet was bold enough to showcase this type of versatility while they were still considered “rookies”? Let alone even a year old? The K-Pop world was probably shook by this group.
i kinda forgot that dark concept started around 2018 and back in 2015 were brighter. they pulled this off very well and i will never forget how brave they are for agreeing to do this while being a rookie
@@rafaelcamacho3015 I wouldn’t say everything is given to them on a silver spoon. They did train with SM entertainment for years before the company formed them together and there is no way that everything was handed to them knowing how the “trainee” system works.
@@rafaelcamacho3015 Oh yeah definitely I agree with that. It wasn’t until like late 2017 that they were able to give opinions on what concepts they wanted to try out and choose the songs they wanted on their albums I think.
@@mayadeltoro3090 What was your original username? And, did you ever actually expect Wendy to get a solo? I sure didn’t, no matter how many times people said she deserved one (she does), but I’m ecstatic it’s here
this song is literally legendary, a style that girl groups of those years could not try. and definitely one of Red Velvet's best songs.If only people knew their worth…
I'm gonna be honest, the way Red Velvet makes songs is amazing. They have both catchy pop jams and slow 20th century jazz, but they can immediately hook you with either one. They're like a drug; once you start, you can never stop.
unfortunately reveluv halfway houses and rehab centers don't exist, so we're just continually destroyed every time they release anything or do a comeback stage
So you're telling me that Yeri was *15* Joy was *18* Wendy was *20* Seulgi was *20* Irene was *24* WHEN THIS SONG CAME OUT? THEY HAVE GROWN UP TO BE BEAUTIFUL KIND HEARTED INDEPENDENT WOMAN 🥺❤️
I keep on seeing comments saying how this song and is boring, and how SM needs to focus on making catchy songs, and I really disagree. These catchy songs you're talking about I'd assume are like Fantastic Baby, Gee and so on, and I really don't think it would be a good idea to stick with that concept for every song. It's generic, and I prefer versatility in music by far. I see many boy groups pull off the calm/creepy concept, and I was really happy to see that Red Velvet did something in that direction. I'm starting to get tired of girl groups doing the exact same concept (sexy, but cute), I'm craving something new. And don't call this song cheap for being a calm R&B type of song.
Seriously Red Velvet pull off mature R&B songs and concepts so impeccably, they were like born for this type of style! I could imagine this song would do so well on the current western charts if it was really promoted, this whole song and Mv is grammy worthy.
This is why they called Red Velvet or SM in general is too ahead of their time. All that people complaining about this concept earlier their career be begging for this image back
i love that it's filmed in 4:3 aspect ratio (square) because thats how it was in the 90s and this song's definitely got that 90s feel, and then at 2:50 when it stretches to widescreen during Wendy's "just hold onn"..so beautiful
someone told me once that Red Velvet was debuting as a dual concept artist. "Red" was going to be their bubbly poppy side a la Happiness or Dumb Dumb, while "Velvet" was going to be the more mature side like this, Be Natural or even Bad Boy. But as I look at their more recent songs, I think they blended the two concepts into one and while I appreciate the smooth transition and growth, I personally LOVED the "Velvet" concepts and hope they get to come back with this look/sound as an A-side in the future.
They used to divide the two pretty heavily into different albums but now they always have 'velvet' and 'red' songs on their albums. There are still 'velvet' songs on each album though - celebrate, hello sunset, milky way, and eyes locked hands locked are some key recent songs I think of. The Queendom album was super r&b-influenced but most songs were still quite upbeat and poppy too.
and i want to say, mix of it - is bad, sm just wrote that fmr is both red and velvet, and this song is.. not really cool? lets say its better not to mix i didnt think of RV duality before, and in general about them, i just like their psycho, bad boy, this now - automatic and just camp under peek a boo m/v recently can i say that these are poppy or mature, idk, i cant say something concrete rn, i have to think longer bout it
@daewangnim the title track is still a mix between red and velvet but they did offer us some velvet songs in their 3rd studio album (underwater, iced coffee, wiesya, wings and scenery)
Red Velvet produces the best slow jams ever, I think it is because of their flawless harmony and dynamics amongs the member that can make even the simples track sounds perfect.
when you got a team where all 5 vocalists add and compliment the vocal colour of the track all while adding to the background instrumentation, the name of said phenomenon can only be described as the perfect red velvet
When it comes to rnb, red velvet understood the assignments 100%. Like ngl there are great rnb kpop groups but red velvet they are untouchable when it comes to rnb. Their vocals and instruments just blends so well together like broooooooooooo. And especially wendy’s voice is more built for western/rnb style, just makes all their songs 100x better. Like the queen of RnB goes to RED VELVET.
Bro... .None of KPOP grp that into RnB except Red Velvet.., u can here RnB songs in some grps esp in SM like NCT but in whole kpop nope.. The only KPOP who APPLIED and print RnB in their named after is RV. most kpop todays are into EDM, Pop, HipHop so called girl crush. RV is a RnB kpop group inspired that's why them are more of RnB and pOp than Girlcrush EDM noise music.
@@Lunafreya_Nox Because you're talking about today's Kpop but this song is from 7 years ago and back then and even before, RnB wasn't a rare concept in Kpop.
@@Lyf4rMusic true!... another reason probably is because Red Velvet are always busy thus plenty of new videos of them show up in recommendations so this MV gets lesser attention.
The thing is, the public refuses to give attention to this kind of music because they find it 'boring'. That's why automatic, be natural and ootn have the least views. Very few girl groups have the versatility that Red Velvet has.
I know most people hate the fact that they're all blonde in this era but, honestly each and every one of them looks FREAKING GORGEOUS in this hair color, why are they so beautiful?!
This by far is my favorite Red Velvet song. Yet, it's the most underrated. I don't understand why! SM needs to keep doing a concept like this with RV and see how far it gets them. THIS SONG IS MESMERIZING.
ingrid coffee yes it is it was a double title track but we saw the directions it went into so they stopped preforming it because y’all slept on it for all you new ReVeluvs
the person that’s great hunny we’re talking about slept on sister and superior Automatic you guys won’t understand the hard ship of Automatic cause B.B. is trend music abs easy to listen to that’s why it did so well now y’all dick ride off the song
+Queen J I'm a teen and once I heard this side of them I immediately declared myself a cupcake 🙌 wasn't all thatttttt crazy about ice cream cake and dumb dumb but once I heard this... 😍😍😍
If this song was released in today's time, it would have more appreciated than it was .. so advanced, all looked angelic with blonde, the choreo, vocal, so elegant, Timeless... SM creates lot of music that are Timeless and fresh.
This song shouldn't be this underrated...its their best song..probably in all k-pop. SM,you should let Red Velvet do this type...this is real MUSIC...😊👌
who would dare to produce a song like this during their debut era when back then r&b, sultry and slow songs like this are not the trend. Red Velvet only
안무빼고 그냥 보컬로만 들어도 정말 훌륭한 R&B, 소울이 풍부한 곡. 전 이곡 때문에 레벨에 입덕했습니다. 웬디의 보컬은 설명이 필요없고, 슬기의 보컬에 솔직히 놀라웠던 곡. "이미 깊게 빠진 꿈처럼 내게 올순 없어" 부분에서 차창밖에서 보는 슬기의 모습과 보컬이 너무 찰떡 궁합이라 너무 인상적인...벨벳도 잘하니까 좋아하지 않을수가 없어요...ㅜㅜ
Red Velvet's rookie days was Wendy's era, so sad that people don't give much attention to her now but I'm glad she gained a lot of fans during Psycho era :((
@rosie Nope. I spoke to a Reveluv regarding the incident. She never said black men are gangsters. She only did an impression of her friends. The impressions were that of a stereotypical sassy black girl and a stereotypical valley white girl. However, races weren't mentioned in the program. Regarding the apology, she apologized privately at a fanmeeting. She wanted to speak up about the issue but SM didn't allow her to do so.
Can't believe there are people sleeping on this when THIS IS SUPERIOR If Red Velvet released this in 2018 people would be crazy over this facts and facts only
Is weird on how many reveluvs dont know this masterpiece, but actually is a internal joke Automatic is so underrated that even reveluvs dont know it exits hahahahhahaha
omg and this back when they didn't have as much of a budget (tbh the music video is the weakest part of this song, and I wish their frilly suits had more variation to them), so they could do it so much better now.
i don't understand why people are sleeping on this. i'm glad that many reveluvs appreciate this bop, but people who don't are really missing such a masterpiece.
it's because we treasure this gem and we all have taste uwu
YOU AGAIN!
To tell you frankly, This song made me love Red Velvet (not a fan, but I appreciate Red Velvet's discography and overall) because the beat is so sultry and I love it. I wish Red Velvet make an another song that kinda similar to this.
Aaaayyy clc STAN !?! ;)
This would've been a #1 hit on R&B radio in the '90s.
This concept is severely underrated and was way ahead of it's time
I really wish they would give it a shot again , it fits them so well
SM is always ahead of time haha
I guess on kpop but not on western music.
@@NoOne-bp4oe in western music this concept had and always will have it's place and fans.
@@annamarimkrtchyan Yeah, just some. Not for many people.
Please don’t ignore this underrated bop. Automatic is still the superior top
I'm not.. 😭😭
- i n R e v e r i e - IT'S MY FAV SONG OF THEM WITH 'BAD BOY' .
i am the 666th liker of your comment. skl.
I prefer Be Natural that's underrated too
- i n R e v e r i e - ❗️
Why is no-one talking about the MV? It is gorgeously shot, the styling is amazing. It's underappreciated
its so weird
It is honestly so unique, the choice of sets and styling is so incredible, I've never seen anything quite like it.
It gives 90s vibes I love it
i been talking about this music video for YEARS
it is very aesthetically pleasing 🥰
This song aged like fine wine
Yeah!
True
too bad its to underrated 😞
hyxnjinnie true 😞
Agreed.
The most underrated yet the most aesthetically pleasing. I actually feel bad to those who didn't get to hear Automatic. Dudee, u're missing a masterpiece 👏
Kristina Jhona Quimuel i agreee
This whole album is asthetic af
the world is missing out
YES SAY IT LOUDER SIS! 😭
@@treaf7453 ًsassy me is a bop
@@treaf7453 sassy me s l a p s
as a musician myself, this is why I love Red Velvet, not just simply because of the visuals, but most importantly also the diverse, unique, experimental music artistry. they're just different from all other groups. I particularly really admire their 'velvet' side (usually much more experimental & artistic, than just simply following the 'mainstream' trends/hype like all other groups), which in today's music world, it's only Red Velvet that I know that performs music genre/style like this. I hope people could appreciate this more.
Not to put other group intended but I think CLC also have this kind of music that have a slower type of songs, sadly they are not successful as RV who also have two sides of music. Hopefully people would enjoy this kind of genre!
btw in Japan, Kalafina is strongly interesting.
How bout those key changes in One of these nights eh? I like where youre coming from. Red velvet has some really interesting music. Bad Boy single handedly got me into Kpop and now I'm here to stay.
Listen to Mamamoo too
oh please, truly, f(x) and Shinee are the first experimental artists of Kpop industry.
you all underrate them and their discography.
This song was way ahead of its time, kpop wasn't just ready for rnb and soul music as title tracks. If it was released today it'd have been hit on charts.
true, sm should let them release a title track like this again
This is not a title track. Stop being foolish
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeanspuff, what a shame, ripoff af
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeansactually it was promoted as a double title track with ice cream cake
Edit: typo
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeans both ice cream cake and automatic are title tracks
This is back in the olden days when the girls were still r&b divas, before they matured into fruits
HAHAHHAHAHAA OMG the fruit saga xD
Lmao😂😂but they still have rnb on their side tracks tho..
*"fruits"* 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
the fruit arc
the fruits thing im screaming
this is Red Velvet's most underrated song, it's deserve more attention.
Duc Anh Nguyen Thai so true
Duc Anh Nguyen Thai TRUE REVELUVS should go support all theirs title tracks (at least go check all theirs songs)
Red Velvet themselves are underrated. SM needs to work harder on promoting their work. It's great. 👍👍👍
TRUUUUU FAM
mu herrrm yeah but they are much less successful than twice and blackpink
This is so expensive.I understand why some can't afford to appreciate this.
Smooth little gay
true
@@Emiliopucci1 well then
Palavras bem ditas
I want them to recycle this song so badly. This was released too early in their careers. It came at a perfect time to establish them as THE Red Velvet but the downside was that it wouldn't be fully appreciated
I agree, they should do a special stage or something
yes. I feel like with their mature concept, this will FIT SO PERFECTLY. I just can imagine it!
i think if iced coffee got promoted, it would be the new "one of these nights" and would fs establish their dominance in the rnb genre as a kpop group in their respective fields (basically showing they're one of, if not, the best kpop group to do krnb)
I still can't believe people had the audacity to call this song "boring"
Kano Hoseok I like the song but I wouldn’t call it exciting
@@bocksbocks Totally valid, I don't think the idea of this song is to be exciting anyway, more like chill instead, but I understand your point
F that. Forever one of my fav eras from them.
This is the type of song you listen when you're just chillin' alone, gazing up in the sky and watching the moon and stars while drinking a can of beer. Or the the type of song cafes usually plays.
@@neogotmybackculturethings I'll definitely try to do that one day, sounds so relaxing
this side of red velvet is SO GOOD and deserves way more recognition
赤いベルベットのこの面はとても良いですし、認識を得るに値する
mustafa mustafa そのとおり！
Velvet side is the best for me too
@Bee Tae Ass RV has two sides: Red side is colorful, summer song, beat, ... Velvet kind of dark, girlcrush, ..
Yeah I love Red side but I love Velvet so much more!
tbh rv's dining table scenes are ICONIC
osaka honestly speaking
and 'lalala' line too
and 'lalala' line too
레드벨벳 뮤비 중 제일 좋다고 생각함.. 영상미, 스타일링, 노래 하나 빠지는게 없는데
i still can't believe that red velvet did *THIS* 7 months into their debut. they're something else indeed.. and to think that this is yeri's debut too 😳
they really debuted with LALALALALALALALALALA HAPPINESS and shifted into "it just comes so naturallll, it just comes automatic" less than a year into their career, they ARE the definition of something else
joy's gwanshim yeah and i think the fact that they have several concepts is so underrated, like they have red (happiness, dumb dumb, zimzalabim, etc.) and velvet (automatic, one of these nights) AND a combination of both (psycho, russian roulette...) they are really versatile and talented
Daniela psycho is definitely full on velvet and russian roulette is as red as u can get!! the mixture of both is more like peekaboo, and really bad boy
@@ladievengeance1577 for me Psycho and Pee-ka-boo are combination of red and velvet, while Psycho is more on velvet side and Peekaboo leans toward red side.
@@revengeofachild Psycho has nothing of red side, but well it's your opinion.
One of their best.
True!
True!! This song slaps so hard.
Yess
Fact!!!!
Yess
Automatic walked so Bad Boy could run so Psycho could fly
Yessss
no. be natural walked so automatic can run and bad boy could fly and psycho can just become an indestructible being!
@@ladievengeance1577 lmao
(Be natural is a cover of one of S.E.S's songs, so it crawled?)
moonbyun문변 truue i guess u can say crawled bc it's not their song haha
Facts
Omg red velvet really should bring back this kind of concept
same but u know that RV never repeat their concepts 😭
Yesssss
@@cheslavo never repeat? Red Flavor, Power Up and Umpah Umpah are the same
@@leoynadamas7227 never heard of Summer Concept? 3 songs u just named are just in their Red side and RV has the best discography 🤌
Ok let’s say they’re “barely” then 🤣 and also I think Power Up is kinda similar to Red Flavor (bc of the summer fruits) but I don’t see any similar of RF and PU with Umpah Umpah 😅?
honestly THIS is still one of their best, if not the BEST song of Red Velvet! it is so classy and timeless and it will never get boring. Kingdom Come to me has similar vibes, but will never give me the same satisfaction Automatic gives. It's absolutely a great song not only because of it's simple yet powerful r&b sound, but the wonderful harmonization, vocals and visuals of our girls make it complete.
Automatic is so iconic, I don’t think any other rv song will beat it
automatic & be natural
i agree but kingdom come is incomparable
I agree! I love Automatic and Kingdom Come, and Look comes close. All very timeless bops~
@@gabby-tg9iu same preference! 🙂 ❤️
I don’t trust any red Velvet fans who don’t know this masterpiece
Me too...
💙🎒💙
Me too
Reveluvs must know or even familiar to this song tho 😌
You trust me
this song was robbed of everything she deserved
Joy's voice is heaven for me, Red Velvet vocals are one of the best in the entire industry. Beautiful song.
SM please make this concept again.. I don't care if this flop in korea..
But SM cares, my girl! :) and they can't under perform now that they're soo big in Korea :/
@@Lyf4rMusic lol😂.. You're back.. I miss you..
@@seulgivssheep8416 ohh my gahdd.!
you are here too? dayum gurl...
@@ingridcoffee4062 everyone comes here to appreciate them😛
@@shaminashaikh6061 true! 👋
MORE "VELVET" CONCEPTS ARE NEEDED SM CMONNN
i hope their next cb is a velvet concept
The ReVe Festival Finale is definitely going to be a Velvet concept album.
@@cosmicdream17 not really. the lead is going to be red concept but there will be a side b song(s) that will be a velvet concept.
『thiss_Jeyms』 They don’t normally do two red concepts in a row...not to mention reve day 1 was red and velvet.
@@nydrayahhadayah the song itself is a mix but the mv is purely a red concept for the day 1.
plus the ReVe Festival trilogy is about Festival so in other word, it is a happy or a red (or a mix) concept.
but i or you may be wrong when the Day 3 is out lol
let's just support them
Automatic, Be Natural and Look are Red Velvet's best songs imo. That smooth, groovy and jazzy feel is what they fit the best. I'll stan if SM produces more songs like them.
I need more songs like these 😭😍 "One Of These Nights" is also is also very good😍
Be Natural is a cover original by the group S.E.S.
Kingdome come >
You should check out their b-sides then. I'm sure you'll like Kingdom come, perfect 10, little little and a bunch of other rnb/chill retro tracks by them.
OMG someone who likes Look!!!! Yes!!!!!!
칠감, 오토매틱, 4walls, 럽라.. 이 뮤비들은 몽환적이라 아직도 찾아보게 되는 듯
개인적으로 뉴진스보면 민희진님 스엠퇴사하신게 너무아쉬워요 😭 😢 😥
민희진이 대표님 스엠 있을때 슴돌 감성 좋았어요 이제는 하이브로 이적하셔서 못보는게 아쉽워요
Automatic is proof Red Velvet were always wayyyy ahead of their time. This song is a classic.
this song was way ahead of its time
Yes 💯
I mean... What’s new with Red Velvet? Many of their songs are ahead of their time.
RBB is also one that aged well.
Even Psycho was a few days ahead of its time. “Hey now it’ll be okay” after Wendy fell.
They know how to call them, What else is there to say?
If this was released today it will be underappreciated again, doesn't take away the fact this song is a gem. Most kpop fans don't popularize anything besides girl crush/cute concepts.
I don't know if I should be happy or sad with the fact that only us Reveluvs and kids who lived in 90s will be able to enjoy this actual masterpiece
jisoo's lost rice cooker im born 2000 and can see this. I dont see why we wouldnt be able to see it?
jisoo's lost rice cooker i think we should've happy with an amazing song..red velvet so unique..their music in another level😢
ya boi is gayyy it's just a lame joke by how long it has been since the song is released lol
sᎬuᏞᎶᎥ Ꮙs shᎬᎬᏢ truly. we're so blessed with their discography! it's flawless and one of a kind in the entire kpop industry 😭
i don't know ,why people doesn't give more attention to this song , i think they're not have a good taste at music
So this randomly plays while I'm doing chores...WOW...beautiful song. I've heard their music and I must say, I have come across some gems but this takes the cake.
Have you heard Perfect 10?
@@michi-bi nope, but I'll look it up
@@michi-bi Not my cup of tea. Sounds like generic R&B. Automatic seems much more daring and out of the box.
yes it’s such a gorgeous piece!
what about kingdom come? ever listened to that song?
The fact that people are forgetting is that when this originally came out in 2015, girl groups in Korea weren’t doing this type of concept AT ALL. The fact that Red Velvet was bold enough to showcase this type of versatility while they were still considered “rookies”? Let alone even a year old? The K-Pop world was probably shook by this group.
i kinda forgot that dark concept started around 2018 and back in 2015 were brighter. they pulled this off very well and i will never forget how brave they are for agreeing to do this while being a rookie
"bold enough" you do know it's all given to them by SM on a silver spoon, basically? they didn't do anything lol
@@rafaelcamacho3015 I wouldn’t say everything is given to them on a silver spoon. They did train with SM entertainment for years before the company formed them together and there is no way that everything was handed to them knowing how the “trainee” system works.
@@JohnMrJohnnyx8Johnson i'm talking about their discography. skill-wise they did have to work hard but their music and image is all handled by SM
@@rafaelcamacho3015 Oh yeah definitely I agree with that. It wasn’t until like late 2017 that they were able to give opinions on what concepts they wanted to try out and choose the songs they wanted on their albums I think.
This song is so underrated. Timeless production, amazing vocals, beautiful choreo. Ahead of its time, we weren't ready to appreciate Automatic.
totally agree
Ahead of its time? They're paying homage to earlier R&B and it's music videos.
unpopular opinion : automatic and be natural are red velvet's best songs
No. Automatic is great but not their best. Be natural is a cover.
Their best songs are from the perfect album
Jesus no their best songs r from the rbb album
van i like that album as well but i prefer the perfect :p
I for one find that my favorite songs come from the ReVe Festival albums.
That was an automatic downvote
gosh, this r&b masterpiece was so painfully underrated.
okay but Wendy is out of this world beautiful at 2:52
RED ROOM omgg yeah I was like .. *ShOOk*
She kinda looked like trysha
She reminds me of CL there
I think she's wonderful in general in many MVs and predebut but for me she's so unnatural at 2:52
Ikr. She looks so elegant. She can pull of a heavy makeup.
This red velvet track is their best velvet sound. They need another track like this
CallMeWoodstock try to listen be natural
kingdom come also slaps
They do but korea doesn't really bop to songs like this sadly
listen to cool hot sweet love
Listen to "Light Me Up", "Kingdom Come", "Perfect 10", "Look" - they are all smooth, melodic Velvet songs of RV.
Can we just talk about the looks Wendy is serving in this era? A 60’s goddess
Ikr
YESS
YES 😭❤️
oh this part 1:53 i died
Automatic and Kingdom Come are the reason why Red Velvet is that irreplaceable kpop gg.
Wendy was simply serving visuals and vocals in this song
Period
She is always is
@@mayadeltoro3090 now you should change your username
@@Gigizzz_ oh yeah I will
@@mayadeltoro3090 What was your original username? And, did you ever actually expect Wendy to get a solo? I sure didn’t, no matter how many times people said she deserved one (she does), but I’m ecstatic it’s here
OMFG THIS SLAYED!
go RED VELVET
YAAAAAAAAAASSSSS
AMAZING!!!!
i loved this RV are amazing
I didn't like it. ..
OMG This song is so underrated. This concept need a comeback.
Yess this song is so catchy and they look gorgeous
it's so sad that koreans are only into the cutesy crap
Ann Wei Im a Korean, I dont know about cutesy but they like exciting songs not the quiet ones. Well then bp shouldnt be popular
BP is a lot more popular internationally than in Korea alone, from what I know
A Y Correct me if I'm wrong but aren't ballads popular in Korea too?
this song is literally legendary, a style that girl groups of those years could not try. and definitely one of Red Velvet's best songs.If only people knew their worth…
Even if they tried could never top this im sorry
When I fell in love with Red Velvet.
thank you💕
Hey queen :)
me too. this song makes me a total lovestruck over Red Velvet
I'm gonna be honest, the way Red Velvet makes songs is amazing. They have both catchy pop jams and slow 20th century jazz, but they can immediately hook you with either one. They're like a drug; once you start, you can never stop.
KateTheTrash true
KateTheTrash accurate
unfortunately reveluv halfway houses and rehab centers don't exist, so we're just continually destroyed every time they release anything or do a comeback stage
mira true 😂
FACTS 👏👏👏
이거랑 be natural ㄹㅇ숨은 명곡임
Automatic 좋은데 많이 알려지지 않은게 아쉽네요 ..
뮤비도 너무 좋음
Tru I just saw this mv after 7 years
@@I_like_K-POP 당신이 옳다
分かりみが深い👍
My gurl Wendy looks so gorgeous im crying. especially at 2:53. And this song is an absolute bop probably of most elegant tracks out there
So you're telling me that
Yeri was *15*
Joy was *18*
Wendy was *20*
Seulgi was *20*
Irene was *24*
WHEN THIS SONG CAME OUT?
THEY HAVE GROWN UP TO BE BEAUTIFUL KIND HEARTED INDEPENDENT WOMAN 🥺❤️
damn, i cant get over the fact that there's an 8 year difference among the youngest and oldest member, lol
The mv was released on march 14, Irene's birthday is on march 29 so Irene was 23 when this came out.
Does RV have an underrated title track? Yes, it's called Automatic.
This is actualy B-side track.. Their title track was ice cream cake
lisa lalisa no this is a double title track
spiffy. And be natural
😭😭😭
S a e and one of these nights,rebirth,would u (singles) and i just (even though it's mv gift for us Reveluvs but it's still underrated tho)
Is it me or SM artists can pull off any concept without looking cringy.
They have a good team that can make pretty much anything look aesthetically pleasing and modern 👏🏽
The only Cringey Red Velvet MV is Happiness, like the song is a bop but that MV is a mess
Rookie says hello.
why would they look cringy here
@@newbiechu7024 Zimzalabim too
This is one of the most original stylistic concepts for a kpop video EVER and it still looks so fresh
*Unpopular opinion:* this is the best song from red velvet
And "I Just"
please check out Kingdom Come, the entire RBB mini album, In & Out, Sunny Side Up, Perfect 10, Attaboy, Time Slip, La Rouge, and Psycho
@@skc0408 LMAO HAHAHHAHAHA BUT FOR REAL THOUGH IT'S HARD TO HAVE A FAVE FROM THEIR SONGS
It is (:
Even with all their new songs, I think THIS is the best song. Nothing has beaten Automatic yet and I've been here since Happiness
I keep on seeing comments saying how this song and is boring, and how SM needs to focus on making catchy songs, and I really disagree. These catchy songs you're talking about I'd assume are like Fantastic Baby, Gee and so on, and I really don't think it would be a good idea to stick with that concept for every song. It's generic, and I prefer versatility in music by far. I see many boy groups pull off the calm/creepy concept, and I was really happy to see that Red Velvet did something in that direction. I'm starting to get tired of girl groups doing the exact same concept (sexy, but cute), I'm craving something new. And don't call this song cheap for being a calm R&B type of song.
AMEN.
Tienes tanta razon te apoyo
Thank u
first Crazy, then Growing Pains, and now this, SM is releasing really good this year
Aiden Brooks what group sang the song growing pains?
WHY THE HELL THEIR VELVET SIDE IS SO UNDERRATE? I EVEN PREFER THEIR VELVET SIDE THAN RED SIDE.
me too, velvet side is so refreshing, and suit to international taste.
Rizki Pawitra SAME THIS WAS AND IS ICONC JUST LOOK AT WENDY IM DEAD
koreans doesn't love the velvet side, i think
koreans love the red side even more, no doubt. :( but we international fans love the velvet side more ♡
Yuki Fabrian because they prefer grown women to act like little girls :/
Seriously Red Velvet pull off mature R&B songs and concepts so impeccably, they were like born for this type of style! I could imagine this song would do so well on the current western charts if it was really promoted, this whole song and Mv is grammy worthy.
I feel like this song and be natural are sisters
Yes! More like twins? Both are bops
@@Marinaleffy2129 Be natural dance syncs with automatic
Priyansha Sharma that’s what i also think lol
They are seriously like the same lol
It's the sequel of Be Natural though.
This is why they called Red Velvet or SM in general is too ahead of their time. All that people complaining about this concept earlier their career be begging for this image back
thanks for reminding lmao fans really need to stop taking every concept they do for granted.
PREACHHHHH!
true. Some of them just not ready for something new, fresh, and unique
i love that it's filmed in 4:3 aspect ratio (square) because thats how it was in the 90s and this song's definitely got that 90s feel, and then at 2:50 when it stretches to widescreen during Wendy's "just hold onn"..so beautiful
someone told me once that Red Velvet was debuting as a dual concept artist. "Red" was going to be their bubbly poppy side a la Happiness or Dumb Dumb, while "Velvet" was going to be the more mature side like this, Be Natural or even Bad Boy. But as I look at their more recent songs, I think they blended the two concepts into one and while I appreciate the smooth transition and growth, I personally LOVED the "Velvet" concepts and hope they get to come back with this look/sound as an A-side in the future.
They used to divide the two pretty heavily into different albums but now they always have 'velvet' and 'red' songs on their albums. There are still 'velvet' songs on each album though - celebrate, hello sunset, milky way, and eyes locked hands locked are some key recent songs I think of. The Queendom album was super r&b-influenced but most songs were still quite upbeat and poppy too.
Feel My Rhythm is both Red and Velvet ig
and i want to say, mix of it - is bad, sm just wrote that fmr is both red and velvet, and this song is.. not really cool? lets say
its better not to mix
i didnt think of RV duality before, and in general about them, i just like their psycho, bad boy, this now - automatic and just camp under peek a boo m/v recently
can i say that these are poppy or mature, idk, i cant say something concrete rn, i have to think longer bout it
@daewangnim the title track is still a mix between red and velvet but they did offer us some velvet songs in their 3rd studio album (underwater, iced coffee, wiesya, wings and scenery)
but damn I really want them to do a straight velvet album next year ILL WAIT AS MUCH AS THEY WANT!!!
Wow, I love this sound. Listen it while you are driving at night in the city.. and that night its raining lightly .. Wow Love it
THATS A GREAT IDEA OMFG
Omo! I'm imagining that. And my heart tho
Meowing Rabbit yep
thats exactly what i was thinking, the song is so relaxing and soothing, jazzy vibes
Cash Shew same!!! 😍
literally crying at how good this is
Barbara Catherina Broadley same
Y'all really be acting like this song doesn't exist huh
this my favorite RV's song and dance of all time.
Kibou Wanderer me too
Me too x2
Most deff
Bad boyyyyyy
Kibou Wanderer MEE TOO
Red Velvet produces the best slow jams ever, I think it is because of their flawless harmony and dynamics amongs the member that can make even the simples track sounds perfect.
when you got a team where all 5 vocalists add and compliment the vocal colour of the track all while adding to the background instrumentation, the name of said phenomenon can only be described as the perfect red velvet
When it comes to rnb, red velvet understood the assignments 100%. Like ngl there are great rnb kpop groups but red velvet they are untouchable when it comes to rnb. Their vocals and instruments just blends so well together like broooooooooooo. And especially wendy’s voice is more built for western/rnb style, just makes all their songs 100x better. Like the queen of RnB goes to RED VELVET.
Thank you, this really warms my heart ❤️
Bro... .None of KPOP grp that into RnB except Red Velvet.., u can here RnB songs in some grps esp in SM like NCT but in whole kpop nope.. The only KPOP who APPLIED and print RnB in their named after is RV. most kpop todays are into EDM, Pop, HipHop so called girl crush. RV is a RnB kpop group inspired that's why them are more of RnB and pOp than Girlcrush EDM noise music.
Early Hwayobi and this are the type of korean R&B I stan. Shinee's Noona Replay has obvs R&B dna too and that's also a classic bop to me.
So true
@@Lunafreya_Nox
Because you're talking about today's Kpop but this song is from 7 years ago and back then and even before, RnB wasn't a rare concept in Kpop.
2024년 계시는 사람?
저요❤
Me❤
Aku udah beberapa kali lihat, tapi untuk tahun ini baru kali ini mungkin kalau dulu HP yang lama sekarang Akun baru dan juga HP baru! Makasih📺
방금 이 노래를 들었습니다. 지옥처럼 매우 시원하고 고급스럽습니다. 레드벨벳 발라드를 검색한 이유는 AESPA의 새로운 발라드 멜로디를 들었기 때문이다
레드벨벳 'Cosmic', 6월 24일 발매 예정
Umm excuse me, why aren't more people talking about this incredible song?
Nana Asmah The same question is running in my mind since 3 years...
tbh, They talk! A Loooot about this song.... but that's it! They don't wanna stream it on any music platform :|
@@Lyf4rMusic true!... another reason probably is because Red Velvet are always busy thus plenty of new videos of them show up in recommendations so this MV gets lesser attention.
because very few people have decent music taste 🍵
Because not everyone has a good taste in music, what to do
all hail to red velvet's superior title track 💆
YES
Haera umm one of these nights,Russian roulette and peekaboo says hi
@@vb8988 automatic's superior
@@vb8988 Russian Roulette and PAB are Red+Velvet.
Shamina Shaikh I know but still if you wanna compare velvet songs kingdom come is 10 times better than automatic
I'm slowly becoming a fan, their musicality is just splendid.
Thank you and welcome.. Please listen to their side track.. It is so versatile and maybe better than the title tracks..😂
Yes please listen to their side tracks. They are so talented and their discography is one of the best in kpop
WELCOME TO FAMILY 'REVELUV'
the way this is on a higher level than kpop releases these days
People: *saying that Bad Boy is the best title track*
Automatic: I exist
FYI Automatic is actually their coupling(Bsides) song for Ice cream cake as the title track!
Joy loving ReVeluv automatic actually isnt a title track but a bside :)
true, red velvet is not only bad boy. :(
*_The best title track is Psycho_*
*be natural has entered the chat*
The atmosphere of this song is so ethereal, without a doubt one of the best performances of Red Velvet.
best b-side of red velvet
No way that's amazing
It's not a b-side
@Travis Coronel this is SSS+-side tbh
Automatic is a dual title track with Ice Cream Cake
Kingdom Come says hi
Red velvet has the best songs in kpop no one can change my opinion they are the best in every concept
Facts
It's not a opinion. It's a fact
They're the ones that got me hooked on K-pop.
No one cares
Я согласна, сколько слушаю уже и не знаю даже, кто может конкурировать с их концептом, ред вельвет слишком уникальны
i demand they promote with a concept similar to this
Kasha Lackey kingdom come
I WAS JUST THINKING THAT!
The thing is, the public refuses to give attention to this kind of music because they find it 'boring'. That's why automatic, be natural and ootn have the least views. Very few girl groups have the versatility that Red Velvet has.
Bad boy has come
It’s more upbeat but it’s RnB
your wish came true with bad boy
I know most people hate the fact that they're all blonde in this era but, honestly each and every one of them looks FREAKING GORGEOUS in this hair color, why are they so beautiful?!
chuckylajee they look so so beautiful yes
They do look beautiful, I prersonally prefer joy with black hair though, I feel like she really shines when her hair is black :)
This by far is my favorite Red Velvet song. Yet, it's the most underrated. I don't understand why! SM needs to keep doing a concept like this with RV and see how far it gets them. THIS SONG IS MESMERIZING.
Emily Rios ~2 years later~
Bad Boy is one of the most succesful Red _Velvet_ songs,and on *30th of November* will *realase* a *Real Bad Boy* 😍
Is this a title track?
@@bananamilk6022 if you are asking if Automatic was the title track the answer is no. Automatic is in the album Ice Cream Cake.
ingrid coffee yes it is it was a double title track but we saw the directions it went into so they stopped preforming it because y’all slept on it for all you new ReVeluvs
the person that’s great hunny we’re talking about slept on sister and superior Automatic you guys won’t understand the hard ship of Automatic cause B.B. is trend music abs easy to listen to that’s why it did so well now y’all dick ride off the song
오토매틱이 진짜 벨벳 노래에서 짱이지.. 전부 블론드헤어하고 레트로 스타일로 꾸민것도 잘어울리고
오토매틱 & 봐 & 인앤아웃 3대장
Honestly still my favorite song from them
Same TBH.
Same here.
People who like this vibe will adore this song, too bad it doesn't seem to be many of us.
same. surprised it didn't get as popular as the rest.
same
i feel like this is the song RV will be most remembered for in the future
why ??
cause its so beautiful...duh Sameera atiq
+Macie Catherine yeah :). bthh why its so underated
+Queen J I'm a teen and once I heard this side of them I immediately declared myself a cupcake 🙌 wasn't all thatttttt crazy about ice cream cake and dumb dumb but once I heard this... 😍😍😍
+Queen J yesss omg its so sad 😰 but I guess this will definitely appeal to those who are looking for more unique music to listen to ☺
You'll definitely stan Red Velvet once you hear their songs. why?
because it just comes Automatic ^^
It just comes automatic
Whoaaa, this can be tagline for my twt bio 😄
It just come so natural, it just comes automatic
its true that happened to me
one of their best songs. EVER. still a classic
Petition to bring back r&b red velvet
edit: guys i saw psycho I just prefer this style over psychos more trap/electronic sound
They did that with reve festival day 2: the album y'all love to sleep on. eyes locked, hands locked is a perfect example
@@bamboleo6348yup
psycho was their last comeback?
PLSSS
@@amare1367 Yes
I felt bad for everyone who didn't Stan Red Velvet
ikr they do be missing out doe
btw i see u everywhere
@@linassoul2654 don't mind me Fam 😁 you will see me everywhere and everyday
marina leffy ikr
SERIOUSLY RV IS SO VERSATILE.THEY CAN PULL OFF ANY CONCEPTS.THEIR DISCOGRAPHY IS BEYOND AMAZING
If this song was released in today's time, it would have more appreciated than it was .. so advanced, all looked angelic with blonde, the choreo, vocal, so elegant, Timeless... SM creates lot of music that are Timeless and fresh.
This song shouldn't be this underrated...its their best song..probably in all k-pop. SM,you should let Red Velvet do this type...this is real MUSIC...😊👌
i feel like if this came out recently this would have done so much better....queens were ahead of the times 😩😩
who would dare to produce a song like this during their debut era when back then r&b, sultry and slow songs like this are not the trend. Red Velvet only
Yes, RV is the trend, they make trends
안무빼고 그냥 보컬로만 들어도 정말 훌륭한 R&B, 소울이 풍부한 곡. 전 이곡 때문에 레벨에 입덕했습니다. 웬디의 보컬은 설명이 필요없고, 슬기의 보컬에 솔직히 놀라웠던 곡. "이미 깊게 빠진 꿈처럼 내게 올순 없어" 부분에서 차창밖에서 보는 슬기의 모습과 보컬이 너무 찰떡 궁합이라 너무 인상적인...벨벳도 잘하니까 좋아하지 않을수가 없어요...ㅜㅜ
Somewhere in SM's dungeon there's the full choreo video of Automatic that we'll never get to see
*It's out now!!!*
Rizky Ayu Ryani Putri true..although only fancam but we reveluv satisfied....
Now you can watch its choreo on fancam in RV's first concert. And I should tell you it's too amazing
Nadyatul Khair agree..they so classy..
There's a possibility that SM will release a DVD of Red Room concert because they're doing a concert tour in Japan
Red Velvet's rookie days was Wendy's era, so sad that people don't give much attention to her now but I'm glad she gained a lot of fans during Psycho era :((
It's just said people are cancelling ger for an issue that happend 4 years ago
@@loveirene7566 sorry, I'm new but what issue?
you’re probably not black so you can’t decide what we should get offended by. i’m really disappointed with wendy :/
@@mookchie at that time even the hosts of that show were really digging it and even the viewers
@rosie Nope. I spoke to a Reveluv regarding the incident. She never said black men are gangsters. She only did an impression of her friends. The impressions were that of a stereotypical sassy black girl and a stereotypical valley white girl. However, races weren't mentioned in the program.
Regarding the apology, she apologized privately at a fanmeeting. She wanted to speak up about the issue but SM didn't allow her to do so.
Can't believe there are people sleeping on this when THIS IS SUPERIOR
If Red Velvet released this in 2018 people would be crazy over this facts and facts only
WOW BISH Red Velvet is always ahead of their time 😪💞
as a reveluv i'm so sad that i'm only NOW just finding this song, it's so underrated and it's easily one of their best songs from what i've heard.
Is weird on how many reveluvs dont know this masterpiece, but actually is a internal joke
Automatic is so underrated that even reveluvs dont know it exits hahahahhahaha
The sad thing is everyone talks about how rv should do a simple sexy concept and no one knows about this
the biggest mystery in kpop is Automatic having little views. even my dad loves this song
*_Imagine if they have this concept again_*
dO yoU kNoW AnNyEonGhaSeyO I would be dead 💀
I think I'll die of nosebleed
omg and this back when they didn't have as much of a budget (tbh the music video is the weakest part of this song, and I wish their frilly suits had more variation to them), so they could do it so much better now.
you can find this kind of concept on their b-side
Seulgi and Irene's comeback would like a world with u
진짜 이런 컨셉이랑 완성도를 가진 걸그룹이 어딨냐고.... 너무 좋다 레드벨벳
it's good to see that people still check this underrated velvet bop