Knit & Chat: Don’t make these yarn substitution mistakes!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 77

  • @kirsten07734
    @kirsten07734 Рік тому +21

    Spinner here.
    We use cards for woolen prep or combs for worsted prep. We can’t comb wool using cards. Combing produces prep with all the short fibers removed and all the remaining fibers aligned. Cards distribute different length fibers without alignment.
    We can mix and match fiber preparation with spinning technique to produce semi woolen or semi worsted yarns. To get true woolen you would use a carded prep and a long draw. To get a true worsted you would use a combed top and a short draft.
    Yards per pound is called grist. You can use it for comparing two yarns of the same fiber or fiber family, but not two yarns of different fibers. So you wouldn’t compare cotton and wool yarn using grist but you could compare merino and corriedale yarn that way.

    • @dhurd4099
      @dhurd4099 Рік тому +1

      Well explained. You beat me to it. Also, in spinning woolen fibers are not pulled out then spun.

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  Рік тому +2

      Thank you for sharing this! I knew I got that bit confused (I keep mixing up the combing amd carding).

    • @bagladysendtheferalspinner3761
      @bagladysendtheferalspinner3761 Рік тому +1

      Yes, part of the Master Spinners' program. Woolen prep is carded where the fibers crisscross to trap air(like a brush). Worsted prep is combing the fibers parallel and compressed together(actual combs). If all the neps/noils and short bits will be removed leaving you will a spinning fiber called top which usually the 'top' 3% of the fiber(result of multiple passes through the wool combs). There is a lot of wastage fiber with combing. This is why good worsted yarn is much more expensive. The finished worsted garment will have minimal or no pilling because there are little to no small bits to work their way to the surface of the yarn. Woolen preparation traps all the short and broken bits of fiber into the batt that will be spun. It is light, airy, and relatively cheap because of little fiber wastage. In addition to fiber preparation, there are both woolen and worsted methods of draft out the fiber and spinning the fiber that will enhance the characteristics of either woolen or worsted yarn. A garment that is made with purely worsted yarn that requires many steps will last 200 years with use and proper care. A woolen garment with good woolen yarn will last with careful use and proper care for 25+ years.

  • @trudiroach
    @trudiroach 11 місяців тому +10

    PLEASE make a video like this about substituting “2 different yarns held Together” to a single yarn! AND how to accurately estimate yardage 🙏🏽 I’m so tired of all the current patterns that require me to purchase 2 sweater quantities of yarn for every project🤔 thank you

    • @maryfrank2175
      @maryfrank2175 6 місяців тому

      Me, too! It's so annoying...this trend. I often skip patterns for this reason alone. It simply adds to cost, production, time, etc. Sometimes, it is worth it, but not often - for me.

    • @wendyamsterdam8482
      @wendyamsterdam8482 Місяць тому

      YES. As a new knitter I do a lot of weird things, stitches are dropped by accident and new stitches appear unintended as well. I don't think I can knit with two strands😂

  • @cassmacdonald-perfectlyimp2486
    @cassmacdonald-perfectlyimp2486 Рік тому +21

    I LOVE the yarnsub website - not least because it goes through all the best subs based on multiple criteria. I told my sister - newish knitter - about it and she RAVES about it. The website ensures that I can find options for discontinued or unavailable yarns for projects, or at least know what to look for. I often find that if I go with a similar type of yarn from the same brand for a project then there’s a good chance it will work - that’s what my mom told me 😂

  • @mimihealy5046
    @mimihealy5046 Місяць тому

    Incredibly helpful and timely for my sock project. Husband wants me to knit him lots of pair of socks. I found a great sock that meets his desired features. So, I grabbed three colors of my highly twisted sock yarn and prepared to knit. Then I met you! Based upon the info in this vid, I realized that this pattern appeared to be using a sport weight yarn based upon the “yarn out-up”. I’d never thought about it before. In addition, the pattern suggested a six 3 needle. I prefer knitting socks with a US 0 or 1. A tighter knit gives my socks a much longer life. Thank you!

  • @vnatik
    @vnatik 2 місяці тому

    OMG! This is the most useful video on knitting yarn I've seen by now

  • @dawert2667
    @dawert2667 Рік тому +36

    Currently frogging a 99% complete sweater because of a poor yarn sub choice (and a bad pattern choice). This sh** is serious people

  • @karenalbery2773
    @karenalbery2773 Рік тому +9

    Yep i have a whole sweater i never touch. I choose a budget acrylic for a crochet sweater designed for top quality woolen spun wool. The designers sweater is cozy light and trendy. Mine is heavy and looks like a 70s afghan with sleeves despite many years of crocheting and garment making. Oops. I might put it on a scarecrow and plant it in the garden

  • @ChynnaBlue1
    @ChynnaBlue1 8 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for mentioning the smoke detector alarm. I hear that in TV shows sometimes and, since they're such a long pause between beeps, I always end up rewinding and playing it again a few times to make sure it was the TV and not my OWN alarm crying for a new battery.

  • @joanp105
    @joanp105 Рік тому +3

    As a new knitter I found this information so important. The yarn shop I went to had no desire to give me any of this type of information about the yarns, nor how to use each. ( This was a large shop that does mainly mail order all over the world) Learning about how Mulberry silk is created was most important to me. I WILL NEVER USE IT BECAUSE OF HOW IT IS MADE.

    • @stregalilith
      @stregalilith 7 місяців тому +1

      Totally agree!!! Lifelong devotee of silk here but now that I know I will only use plant based and vegan silk that allows the little creatures we owe so much to to complete their life cycle and leave their cocoons before they’re unwound and processed for manufacturing ❤❤❤

  • @noelleparris9451
    @noelleparris9451 Рік тому +7

    This was a great topic to cover, thank you for doing it.
    I usually check Ravelry projects before I start a project. I like to see what yarns people chose (if not the recommended yarn used in the pattern/sample) and get an idea from them what works. It has helped enormously: no misses in my yarn sub choices since I've been doing this!

  • @stregalilith
    @stregalilith 7 місяців тому +1

    I really appreciate how detailed this information is. As a beginner I find there is so much to learn before investing time and money into a project I will enjoy knitting and wearing. I love just visiting this channel and learning so much from someone so knowledgeable and comfortable to listen to ❤❤❤

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  7 місяців тому

      You're very welcome! I'm glad you find it helpful!

  • @peggytraeg
    @peggytraeg Рік тому +5

    Such great information. Knitting is a science plus art.

  • @EgObArNeT
    @EgObArNeT Рік тому +4

    This was very informative and helpful! I like your way of presenting information. I crochet any moment I can and I love the whole proces of picking a pattern and searching for the right yarn. I can't wait to apply this new knowledge :)

  • @SoupCanGirl
    @SoupCanGirl Рік тому +4

    Yarn Canada shut down 😢 (they’re becoming an Ashford weaving dealer), which makes finding yarns here so much harder and/or so much more expensive (that US to Canada shipping is so expensive sometimes)! I found out when I went to find yarn for my current project. And with Michael’s moving towards only carrying Loops & Threads, I turned to my LYS, which didn’t have the same kind of variety of selection as Yarn Canada did (it is an impressive collection, but obviously geared more towards what is popularly used in my city, rather than a super diverse selection).
    I made a substitution for my current yarn based on what my LYS had in the same weight, similar enough fibre content to the two recommended yarns (one is no longer available, the other has been reworked and re-released since the pattern was released, and both are surprisingly difficult to find information on) and what I wanted out of the garment, so my choices were pretty limited. Thankfully, it seems to be a good enough match to work!

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  Рік тому +3

      I had no idea about Yarn Canada shutting down! That's sad news for us. 😢

  • @samkaterji1348
    @samkaterji1348 9 місяців тому +1

    I haven't knit a cable hat yet but it's in the list. On my needles right now are socks with some cable knitting. First time trying cables.

  • @latitude1904
    @latitude1904 10 днів тому

    Egads! I purchased 10 balls of Malabrigo Rios for a cabled sweater for my son. Havent started yet. Looks like I'll destash them and get a non-superwash instead.

  • @stregalilith
    @stregalilith 7 місяців тому

    The yards per gram computation is very helpful! Thank you ❤

  • @stephaniewilliams8687
    @stephaniewilliams8687 Рік тому +1

    This is so helpful. I am sure I am going to watch this more than once. Thank you!

  • @SM-wr8ld
    @SM-wr8ld Рік тому +2

    This video was super helpful! Ty so much! You really explain things in a way that's easy to understand.

  • @10amTracy
    @10amTracy Рік тому +2

    You’re so cute with your chocolate game idea! ❤

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  Рік тому +1

      Haha - thank you! I was so embarrassed when I was editing but didn't have time to re-record the whole thing. Hopefully, the fire alarm beeps weren't too distracting! 😁

  • @valeriehowden471
    @valeriehowden471 Рік тому +3

    Very useful info. I lucked out on my first knit sweater - subbed cotton for wool. Luckily for me, it was seamed. It was simple stockinette so my gauge swatched matched.
    FYI Yarn Canada is switching to a spinning and weaving supply company. 😔

  • @aggierowe9574
    @aggierowe9574 Рік тому +1

    Excellent topic. Thank u for covering a very basic but super important topic

  • @elisebachert6654
    @elisebachert6654 Рік тому +4

    Also have to consider if the yarn construction and fiber is masking a lighter weight yarn.
    The shawl in a ball is a good example it’s so thick n thin that it’s really a 3 weight when working up with spots that are almost lace weight and spots that are almost bulky. Yarns like that tend to only be for certain types of projects like shawls and accessories because the yarn style doesn’t lend well to garments.

  • @iris_nazarena_4882
    @iris_nazarena_4882 5 місяців тому

    Negatives aside, baby alpaca is supposedly a good alternative to mohair. (Fyberspates Cumulus is heavenly.) But like the Texan person, I also live in a warm climate, so the fuzzy halo trend is a no- go, which breaks my heart. It is so pretty!

  • @sassysuzy4u
    @sassysuzy4u Рік тому +1

    Thank you so much for the link to the Craft Yarn Council chart! I have been going crazy looking through old books trying to figure out what different yarns are talking about.

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  Рік тому

      You are so welcome! I use it all the time too.

  • @GymGirl88
    @GymGirl88 Рік тому +1

    Working on my second sweater, made and washed three swatches to get gauge and I'm so excited to block the final garmet. Working with a worsted spun single (lambs pride worsted) and its so fun to work with. Very strong with a bit of mohair

  • @yarnmotivated
    @yarnmotivated Рік тому +2

    Excellent information presented clearly. Thank you.

  • @kathyffarney-keck8593
    @kathyffarney-keck8593 Рік тому +1

    Great info. At some point during your episode planning, could you go I to how to clean and care for our knitting needles. Mine tend to become sticky

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  Рік тому +3

      I'm not sure there would be enough to say to fill an episode! I just usually wipe them down with a damp cloth when I feel like they need it.

  • @laurahorgan7657
    @laurahorgan7657 Рік тому +1

    Thanks for sharing this great information!

  • @angelahunter5256
    @angelahunter5256 2 місяці тому

    I love this video! Thank you so much! Also, did you make the sweater you’re wearing in this video? If so, I’d love to know the pattern name and where to purchase it. Thank you! ❤

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  2 місяці тому

      I'm wearing the Westbound by Elizabeth Doherty (www.ravelry.com/patterns/library/westbound) using Knit Picks CotLin [color: Indigo Bunting].

  • @adeleb7753
    @adeleb7753 9 місяців тому

    thank you :))

  • @karenbochinski
    @karenbochinski 5 місяців тому

    Great show. Except I am a spinner. To make worsted wool you use a comb not a carder to align the fibers perfectly straight. You also spin it worsted way. Carded wool use a carder and you pull from the batt.

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  5 місяців тому

      You can tell I'm not a spinner - I always get carding and combing confused!

  • @danielepoirier7237
    @danielepoirier7237 Рік тому

    Merci

  • @heartstoe1
    @heartstoe1 Рік тому +2

    Why would you not want to use cotton for a cabled sweater?

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  Рік тому +1

      In general, cotton is a fairly heavy yarn so the sweater is going to way more (and a cabled sweater already uses a lot of extra yarn for the cables). It's also not very elastic and can have a tendency to keep growing instead of holding its shape. Not a good combination for a cabled sweater!

    • @heartstoe1
      @heartstoe1 Рік тому +1

      Thank you

  • @savannahd1457
    @savannahd1457 Рік тому +1

    I'm allergic to wool. Do you know of a UA-cam who does not knit with wool?

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  Рік тому +1

      Sorry, I don't!

    • @savannahd1457
      @savannahd1457 Рік тому +1

      @@NerdyKnitting Thank you for your time😊

    • @stregalilith
      @stregalilith 7 місяців тому +1

      I find that cashmere doesn’t cause any reaction and a blend of cashmere and other fibers that don’t include wool also works well. Even a small percentage of a synthetic helps but if you don’t want anything plastic the bio synthetics such as rayon mixed in with the cashmere or cotton is good.

    • @EntangledFields
      @EntangledFields 3 місяці тому

      Not a UA-camr, but I am similarly allergic. I have found that if I regularly go to the same LYS and mention my allergy, over the years they get more yarn varieties that work for me 😅🎉.
      I have trouble with all animal fiber aside from silk. Sometimes I can knit or crochet with an animal fiber as long as I wash my hands before touching my face, but often just touching the skein is enough to make my hand tingle.

  • @DGaryMoore
    @DGaryMoore Рік тому +1

    Is there something wrong with the sound. Your voice is very high.

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  Рік тому +4

      I had trouble with my usual microphone so had to use the built-in one on the camera - maybe that's it?

  • @lizh2752
    @lizh2752 11 місяців тому +1

    Oh my goodness, you have so much information but, you talk so fast that my brain cannot comprehend all that you are saying. Do you only have a certain amount of time that your video can last? If so, I can understand. If not I need to slow you down a little bit😂😂😂

    • @NerdyKnitting
      @NerdyKnitting  11 місяців тому +2

      Sorry!🤣 I know I talk fast - I try to fit everything within an hour or less and sometimes there's just so much information to share! Thankfully, UA-cam has a setting for playback speed so you can slow me down.

    • @maryfrank2175
      @maryfrank2175 6 місяців тому

      @@NerdyKnitting I don't think this is an issue for the majority. And I'm from the state of the long southern drawwwwl....Texas.

    • @mimihealy5046
      @mimihealy5046 Місяць тому

      Hi Liz. Try slowing the video for a slower presentation. On the video, select the Settings icon (looks like a cog wheel). In the drop down select Playback Speed. Experiment with the speed that works best for you, maybe 0.5 or 0.75 speed. I listen to videos sped up, usually 1.5 or 2. Enjoy your day.