Synthetic Motor Oil Comparison | Which Engine Oil is Best?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 чер 2024
  • In this video we'll compare 6 motor oils to find out which one is the best for it's price and value, according to API standards. Royal Purple, Mobil 1, Castrol Edge, Valvoline, Pennzoil, and Supertech are reviewed to see which is the best synthetic oil based on API standards.
    Buy Midwest Garage Merch: teespring.com/stores/midwest-...
    Disclaimer:
    Due to factors beyond the control of Midwest Garage, I cannot guarantee against improper use or unauthorized modifications of this information. Midwest Garage assumes no liability for property damage or injury incurred as a result of any of the information contained in this video. Use this information at your own risk. Midwest Garage recommends safe practices when working on vehicles and or with tools seen or implied in this video. Due to factors beyond the control of Midwest Garage, no information contained in this video shall create any expressed or implied warranty or guarantee of any particular result. Any injury, damage, or loss that may result from improper use of these tools, equipment, or from the information contained in this video is the sole responsibility of the user and not Midwest Garage.
    FTC Disclaimer:
    I am an Amazon associate. As such, I earn a percentage of sales made through Amazon associate links found in the description of my videos and on my website and other places.
  • Авто та транспорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,8 тис.

  • @johnnychun09
    @johnnychun09 4 роки тому +426

    I'd want to drink beers with this guy and listen to him talk about car oils

    • @Synthwave89
      @Synthwave89 4 роки тому +4

      @paquiao manuel that escalated quickly

    • @wickway
      @wickway 3 роки тому +12

      I'd like to drop acid and listen to him talk about oil.

    • @illuminatikid4767
      @illuminatikid4767 3 роки тому +4

      😂😂😂😂😂

    • @im_caiman4479
      @im_caiman4479 3 роки тому +13

      I'd wake up hungover with a fresh change of Pennzoil in my pickup.

    • @javierflores940
      @javierflores940 3 роки тому +1

      Beers and oils don’t mix my good ol pal. Haha

  • @michigan_supercars6569
    @michigan_supercars6569 9 місяців тому +30

    I've been using Castrol Edge High Mileage 5W-30 Full Synthetic for two or three years now. My 2.5L T5 engine was burning about .5qt to 1 qt every 2,500 miles. Since switching to Castrol Edge, I've noticed that the engine oil burning has slowed down quite a bit. The additives in Castrol Edge High Mileage really do seem to work in engines with over 100,000. I've been pretty impressed with it and will keep purchasing it for my car for now on.

    • @jamesstobaugh
      @jamesstobaugh 4 місяці тому +3

      I’m also beginning to use castrol edge high mileage in my 2.5L (VW). That’s good to know. Thanks for your comment

    • @charlesokwuanga2423
      @charlesokwuanga2423 4 місяці тому +1

      Best for Volvo Engines

    • @darrylsjodin7184
      @darrylsjodin7184 2 місяці тому +3

      My Buick Enclave with 50,000 miles was using a qt every 3000. I switched to Amsoil high mileage and now it’s a qt every 7,500, on the way to a 12,000 mile interval. 😊

    • @cashwilson2571
      @cashwilson2571 Місяць тому

      How about doing g 1 quart of Castrol 1 quart of pennzoil platnum 1 quart of Royal purple 1quart of amsoil and then half quart of supertech in my engine? That would be the best oil in my opinion. Would that be a smart thing to do orrr?

    • @darrylsjodin7184
      @darrylsjodin7184 Місяць тому

      @@cashwilson2571 No, not a good idea😬 Amsoil has the best formulation

  • @NickBeechKingair
    @NickBeechKingair Рік тому +20

    Great video, factual and honest! Yes, any oils that meet a high standard will work, I feel the same way about gasoline. I have always been a Castrol guy myself but I would not have a problem using any others in your list in a pinch. I have a Honda EU1000 generator with 1300 hours on it and still running strong!

  • @graba.wrench8885
    @graba.wrench8885 3 роки тому +22

    Great review! Im a loyalist to Supertech, although i agree with your video. I have ran Super in a 07 focus for 300k and it still isnt burning any oil, no knocks, no pings. But Great Vid

  • @djlowtek
    @djlowtek 3 роки тому +103

    Oh boy, after watching project farm videos.... coming to some guy reading the packaging giving his opinion is painful.

    • @pitholer
      @pitholer 3 роки тому +3

      you beat me to this comment by 4 months

    • @shinymud7
      @shinymud7 3 роки тому +1

      Project farm reads the label because most people do not! They’re boneheads and would rather find out on their own merit.

    • @lonniebeal6032
      @lonniebeal6032 3 роки тому +5

      @@shinymud7 projectfarms sent oil in for an analysis in one video.

    • @Kiddomike
      @Kiddomike 3 роки тому +4

      I like Project Farm’s videos.
      However, he failed to mention that the top 4 oils in his competition videos does not have the API donut seal. Why? Because those oils have exceeded the amount of additives, specifically, ZDDP additive, which API thinks prematurely destroys catalytic converters and puts out more harmful fumes out the exhaust.
      Without the API restriction (and the donut seal), obviously, those oils came out on top because they have more anti-wear and detergent additives.

    • @swn69
      @swn69 3 роки тому +7

      Project farm does a bunch of different tests on the oils. This dude just told you what the package says and told you his favorite brand. 100% useless.

  • @idksk8464
    @idksk8464 3 роки тому +13

    I have been using Mobil 1 for about 2 years on my 13 boosted tc and it does great.

  • @pesto88
    @pesto88 4 роки тому +5

    Love the science and testing behind this video. 😳

  • @farquadshmoogle9120
    @farquadshmoogle9120 4 роки тому +13

    I was 100% Pennzoil. used it for my 2006 kia rio. but now, i switched over the past few years to SuperTech. Yes, its cheaper, but like you said, it passes all the tests like the others, so no need to pay more if you same quality as the others. I do replace oil and filter every 6,000 miles in my cars now.

  • @wolvesfan1973
    @wolvesfan1973 4 роки тому +16

    Good video!! As you said ALL the oils are good so it just depends on what your partial too. Me I prefer Valvoline Max Life as Ive never had any issues whatsoever with it. My 2nd choice would be Pennzoil. Ive never used RP, Mobil 1 or Castrol so dont have an opinion on those brands but Im sure they work just fine.

    • @stevenjack23331
      @stevenjack23331 9 місяців тому

      Stay away from Castrol oils. I've used it and it runs hot and kinda rough. Mobil1 is great and what I usually use. This oil change I used Pennzoil Platinum. Seems like a good oil but have noticed the engine temp runs a couple degrees warmer. RP is an ok oil but in my experience it lasts about 2k miles and starts to break down. More of a racing oil that's changed often.

  • @fitodaking16
    @fitodaking16 3 роки тому +4

    Very good video. I love the way you explained things. Very easy to understand. I'm currently using mobil1 full synthetic oil. I pay $11.49 for 1qt, and $38.99 for a 5qt.

    • @JDMTough
      @JDMTough 2 роки тому +5

      Buy it at walmart. Its cheaper

  • @marcoantoniocontreras6591
    @marcoantoniocontreras6591 4 роки тому

    Thanx for explaining in the beginning on the diff stamps that are on oil cans, and then just jumping into testing.

  • @Tubeytime
    @Tubeytime 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the lucid breakdown!

  • @gaguil13
    @gaguil13 4 роки тому +56

    I’ve tried mobil1, pennzoil, and Castrol edge. And Castrol Edge has been my #1. Super smooth!

    • @TomTom-gn9mp
      @TomTom-gn9mp 2 роки тому +6

      @Certified Big Dog Mobil is good but for the money Castrol is just as good.

    • @AR-uj3js
      @AR-uj3js 2 роки тому +5

      I tried the 3 mention above and castrotwas the smooth n quiet

    • @WestCoastDP
      @WestCoastDP Рік тому +3

      Put Castrol Edge in my 2001 Jag S-type 2 years ago and is was a lot quieter.

    • @charliedaniel718
      @charliedaniel718 11 місяців тому +4

      I’ve used Castrol for 3 years now and I won’t use anything else $40 for a oil change for a high quality oil is not bad

    • @bluesky-ud9wg
      @bluesky-ud9wg 10 місяців тому +2

      What do you mean Super Smooth????

  • @jimmystate
    @jimmystate 4 роки тому +6

    Real helpful video man with those two labels help me decide really quickly

  • @robertdouglas3456
    @robertdouglas3456 4 роки тому +3

    I have used all of them for myself except Royal Purple. It is very expensive!. The Super Tech is a great value of course. Nice video!..

  • @devengudinas1649
    @devengudinas1649 4 роки тому +8

    Just put castrol edge in my turbo Subaru xt for the first oil change since I got it 3 months ago it’s great to here that it stands up to high temperatures because I’m in az

  • @randybeard6040
    @randybeard6040 4 роки тому +238

    The Key to Engine Life is Changing Oil as Recommended....

    • @KevAlberta
      @KevAlberta 4 роки тому +8

      I end up changing mine every 8-10k kilometers or so
      Edit: manual asks to change every 16k

    • @overhead440
      @overhead440 4 роки тому +1

      randy beard When it starts changing color because it is getting polluted with color change or burnt...

    • @craig_sez8534
      @craig_sez8534 4 роки тому +16

      @@overhead440 So you have never seen oil go black in under 500 mi?? Color doesnt define quality at all..Only way to know condition of oil is through analizeing it..polaris or blackstone can do a full break down and tell you whats happening and life long before color change or smell or texture will show issues..

    • @craig_sez8534
      @craig_sez8534 4 роки тому +12

      @@overhead440 color is just a sign of the oil doin its job..

    • @verovoy1
      @verovoy1 4 роки тому +7

      Craig_sez Well, cheap oil from ACE store becomes dark faster, than Mobil 1. So, ACE brand is doing better job than Mobil? Absurd. Oxidation is what , mostly, make them darker. Mobil takes longer to oxides

  • @venividivici4253
    @venividivici4253 4 роки тому +27

    I swear by Castrol for my car. Runs great in my engine.

  • @candelariosanchez273
    @candelariosanchez273 4 роки тому +2

    Great information thanks a lot I really saved money on my purchase and got me full synthetic oil as well new subscriber!

    • @MidwestGarage
      @MidwestGarage  4 роки тому

      Awesome thank you, I appreciate it greatly!

  • @rafaelvmaldonadorv7959
    @rafaelvmaldonadorv7959 3 роки тому

    Midwest I highly appreciate that and fuss away my doubt for my oil selections THANK YOU

  • @myya8370
    @myya8370 3 роки тому +3

    Great video on the Pennzoil Platinum High Mileage oil 😊

  • @lawrencegatt4515
    @lawrencegatt4515 4 роки тому +6

    Well done mate from Australia 🇦🇺 great job 🏁💓.

  • @nattyp7801
    @nattyp7801 Рік тому

    Very good video,I personally was using Mobil1..now trying supertech so far so good 👍🏾

  • @1j007zm
    @1j007zm 3 роки тому +1

    I watched a video with a person putting different brands of oil through a series of hard tests, and in the end it came down to Royal purple vs Pennzoil 1, and the Pennzoil won. This guy knows what he's talking about

  • @revnto7k
    @revnto7k 4 роки тому +31

    I have used all but RP... My engines all still run fine... I like Pennz plat. as well. Also Valvoline are some of the more common ones that I use.

  • @reginaldfreeman4201
    @reginaldfreeman4201 2 роки тому +11

    Very informative and well taken... I also am a Pennzoil man but just recently went to Valvoline, due to location of oil change shop. But, I agree with you you really can't go wrong with any of them...Also Amazon has thrown its hat into the oil fight and their oil is really good also.

    • @grahamhaftka5288
      @grahamhaftka5288 Рік тому

      I use fully synthetic sheer free with esters penrite brand.

  • @toddradfordjr.3669
    @toddradfordjr.3669 2 місяці тому +2

    Excellent video Sir👍🏻!
    working out of our 2022 F-350 XL reg cab long bed 2wd with the 6.2 Gas, regularly using since new, the Pennzoil Synthetic Blend 5w30 or the Valvoline Daily Driver 5w30 Synthetic Blend, both performing extremely well after always changing oil & filter right at 5,000 mile intervals! Thanks again for your videos!

  • @lovethehuntOutdoors
    @lovethehuntOutdoors 10 місяців тому

    Great information and thank you for giving your puck in oils as well. Ive used the super tech in our camry and it had 350,000 when we sold it.

  • @HMuny55
    @HMuny55 Рік тому +23

    Pennzoil dramatically got better because they were purchased by Shell, which now provides them with some of the best base oils in the world considering they are completely vertically integrated and produce and refine their own supply on a global scale.

    • @rickss69
      @rickss69 22 дні тому

      Lol...they downgraded their top tier oils right after purchasing Quaker State and Pennzoil to line their pockets.

    • @HMuny55
      @HMuny55 22 дні тому

      ​@@rickss69 Pennz platinum is the best big box oil on the market. Pennzoil was a totally trash brand before shell bought them

  • @rskrilly
    @rskrilly 4 роки тому +25

    Been using Pennzoil Platinum since they came out with it. Great stuff. Never had an issue that was directly related to the oil

    • @karkule5919
      @karkule5919 4 роки тому +7

      I heard that the only true synthetic oil is Pennzoil Platinum because it's the only one made from natural gas, while the other brands are treated with chemicals, etc.

  • @Yotu161
    @Yotu161 4 роки тому +2

    Midwest I highly appreciate that

  • @nuancolar7304
    @nuancolar7304 Рік тому +7

    I bought a brand new 2014 Toyota Tacoma and started out using Mobil 1 (5000 mile changes) and have consistently used that oil since then. I'm not a heavy duty driver, but it does have well over 100k miles and still running like new (and no oil loss between changes).

    • @bottitabaki3073
      @bottitabaki3073 11 місяців тому +1

      Hi. What oil filter you using with Mobil oil for your Tacoma

  • @machinis
    @machinis 2 роки тому +6

    Thank you for binging the old news about Pennzoil's bad reputation in the past.

  • @assassin1055
    @assassin1055 3 роки тому +5

    Kirkland’s full synthetic is nice too! But right now I use Castro edge for my 2015 Range Rover evoque!

  • @martymar6712
    @martymar6712 3 роки тому

    Thanks to you I don’t have to do hours of research I just had to watch your video and boom 👌

  • @davidthecardcollector
    @davidthecardcollector 3 роки тому +4

    I have been using Super Tech last few years but before that I used nothing but Penzoil and changed my oil every 3-3.5K miles and I always had a clean engine when I would drop a oil pan or valve cover. Penzoil works but I saw videos on Super Tech and it lab tested good and I could save a few dollars. I also did a lab test on the High mileage Conventional Super Tech with close to 4k miles and it came back good as well.

  • @TheRichardF10
    @TheRichardF10 5 років тому +16

    I have used all of those oil with no issues at all. I have always been inclined with Valvoline full synthetic because they were the first brand I used when I started to drive plus its an American owned and operated company. At the same time, ExxonMobil is also American as well as Royal Purple but to me RP is not worth it for me. Motul has been the absolute best oil I have used and I've used pretty much every oil that's on the market. Great video.

    • @MidwestGarage
      @MidwestGarage  5 років тому +5

      Thanks for the comment bud! I agree, they're all good oils...just not quite worth it to penny up for RP.

    • @retro8696
      @retro8696 3 роки тому +4

      I'm odd I use Valvoline because there one of the few that still have simple easy to open bottles that don't have a foil seal and still use the small cap that don't get stuck when you try to open it.

    • @romankim3198
      @romankim3198 3 роки тому

      Hi Richard! Is Motul 8100 eco light 0w20 good oil?

  • @neutrodyne
    @neutrodyne 5 років тому +59

    I use whatever brand I get the best price on as long as it has the SN rating and the correct viscosity rating. I have never had an oil related issue.

    • @paulanderson79
      @paulanderson79 4 роки тому +4

      Not quite as easy with Euro and Japanese diesel engines.

    • @popeye7815
      @popeye7815 2 роки тому

      Exactly

    • @franchisefred4066
      @franchisefred4066 2 роки тому +3

      Yes. Just change it at the manufacturer change intervals

    • @ShadowxxPanda
      @ShadowxxPanda 2 роки тому +1

      Might just wanna get anything that says SP rating since it covers SN and all of the previous ratings before it.

    • @neutrodyne
      @neutrodyne 2 роки тому

      @@ShadowxxPanda I agree when I posted the SN they had not come out with the SP rating yet. The SN was the llatest version at that time.

  • @johnreynolds6291
    @johnreynolds6291 2 роки тому

    That was an Excellent Video on Different Brand's of Oil

  • @carlosl.garcia2745
    @carlosl.garcia2745 3 роки тому

    great information, thank you broski!💪🚘

  • @crazydudetz
    @crazydudetz 2 роки тому +3

    Don't remember what brands I started buying when I first started doing oil changes, but eventually I settled on whatever was cheapest on Amazon when it came to buy oil, so long as I got the right weight. Usually Castrol GTX or Edge was the cheapest and it just so happens that Mazda (car I own) recommends Castrol for its engines. But now I'm seeing Castrol's oil is expensive on Amazon. So for my last oil change, I got Valvoline.
    I recently found out Havoline sells 6 quarts for $20 which is a steal. Getting that for next time.

  • @Sproutt
    @Sproutt 4 роки тому +9

    Valvoline is used at my local Toyota Dealership. Has their little logo for next oil change. Don’t own a Toyota but I saw it actually in a new 2019.

  • @Grendelbc
    @Grendelbc 9 місяців тому +2

    I looked around to find the best oil for a long time. The top of the line oils all seem great. You really can't go wrong with any of them. I use Valvoline full synthetic high mileage in my high mileage vehicle and Castrol Edge in my other one.

  • @Rafael-si9jr
    @Rafael-si9jr 3 роки тому

    Thank you for the great info. -subscribed

  • @max-mv3yp
    @max-mv3yp 4 роки тому +4

    Awsome video man.
    Great advice and very well spoken.
    If only every review on UA-cam weren't only focused on marketing one brand, making a decision on parts/products would be a lot easier, as this video has done for me.
    Cheers man 🤙

    • @MidwestGarage
      @MidwestGarage  4 роки тому

      Thanks for the kind words man, I appreciate it! Thanks for the comment!

  • @akaitsmedre
    @akaitsmedre 4 роки тому +20

    Castrol for me in our boat, motorcycle, lawn equipment, truck and car. I am also a believer in changing my oil frequently.

    • @JA-rn5qv
      @JA-rn5qv 4 роки тому +3

      Castrol has a decent amount of Titanium.

  • @timyurkovich2412
    @timyurkovich2412 3 роки тому

    Kept it simple and informative. 👍👍👍...
    Job well done.

  • @cazzt-el7741
    @cazzt-el7741 3 роки тому +2

    Personally I use pennzoil with a mopar filter in my dodge and Mobil 1 oil and acdelco filter for my newer Chevy and they run really well.

  • @mattdrives4757
    @mattdrives4757 3 роки тому +4

    3 questions to ask when buying oil.
    Is it the right weight?
    Does the manual call for synthetic or conventional?
    How much do I need?
    And that’s it!

  • @TheCheapBiker
    @TheCheapBiker 4 роки тому +15

    I use/used SuperTech in my lease, I have to say, 6k mile intervals and the oil is still dark honey color on the rag, meaning it hasn't fully broken down, quite impressed, especially for the price for a 6qt oil change, pennzoil/ supertech are my go too's

    • @user-tb7rn1il3q
      @user-tb7rn1il3q 4 роки тому

      Rob Cottino TGMO 0W16 is the best out there. It still looks like new after 10-15k miles.

  • @stevev707
    @stevev707 3 роки тому +1

    I have been using Supertech oil for over 15 years. I have used this oil in 6 vehicles; Nissan, Toyota, Dodge, and Subaru brand vehicles. Never had a problem.

  • @jamesrobinson9176
    @jamesrobinson9176 Рік тому +1

    Good content. Dexos 1 g 2 is really important in the di v6 too.

  • @bradleypetersen5412
    @bradleypetersen5412 4 роки тому +41

    Been using super tech in my car for few years no oil leaks or burning and runs great at 170k miles.

    • @tiffanyhwang1738
      @tiffanyhwang1738 4 роки тому +6

      Same, 190k miles and used nothing but supertech

    • @joseherrera4845
      @joseherrera4845 3 роки тому +6

      Same here supertech, high mileage full synthetic oil for 13.97 and super tech filter for 2.97 a total of 18 dollars can't beat the price, for a quality oil change, I go 4,000 miles on my Honda Accord without a problem.

    • @robertolago61
      @robertolago61 3 роки тому

      Too bad you cant get no Super Tech synthethic oil in México...

  • @jamesbrown4401
    @jamesbrown4401 3 роки тому +11

    I use Pennzoil 5W30 Full Synthetic myself. It goes into a BMW V8. X5 to be precise. At one point BMW was recommending Castrol Full Synthetic. But now it seems that Pennzoil is the prefered brand. I remember the yellow M3 Pennzoil used as an advertising catch. In tests Pennzoil has done better than Castrol at heat dissipation and thermal expansion as well as breakdown. It is also created using 100% clear synthetic base oils derived from natural gas. It is the Best... What do you think. ???

    • @user-ze6qx1py2l
      @user-ze6qx1py2l Рік тому

      I use synthetic Pennzoil oil for my sedan and suv. Changing engine oil once a year (12k~15k ) They run as smooth as like new engine.

  • @benredmond8271
    @benredmond8271 3 роки тому +1

    Good video! So true I’m a mobile 1 guy always will always have.

  • @2steaksandwiches665
    @2steaksandwiches665 2 роки тому +27

    Valvoline has been doing a great job on my Saab Turbo. It’s a high compression four-cylinder turbo with 260 hp.I have the Valvoline place down the street do it. They are always busy and do a good job. I drive it less than 5000 miles a year but change the oil every year.

    • @albertopalma1663
      @albertopalma1663 Рік тому +1

      If I were you I would change the oil twice a year. 5,000 mls a year is not much but you are probably putting those miles in town, so there are a lot of stops and goes, unless those 5,000 are run driving a few long distance trips. Just a recommendation.

    • @2steaksandwiches665
      @2steaksandwiches665 Рік тому

      @@albertopalma1663 Next oil change I’m going to do an oil analysis and ship it in for the results. If it suggest I need to change the interval I will otherwise I’m going to keep it what it is. I have a feeling that it will be fine Because I’m using their full synthetic

    • @MegaOzzy28
      @MegaOzzy28 11 місяців тому

      Get out of Comiefornia!!!!!

  • @bryantturner4125
    @bryantturner4125 4 роки тому +90

    I’m currently using Castrol Edge, I’m really pleased with it so far!

    • @kenmullinax7759
      @kenmullinax7759 4 роки тому +5

      Bryant Turner me too !!!!

    • @paulanderson79
      @paulanderson79 4 роки тому +2

      Not just brand and product name.

    • @bigbog442
      @bigbog442 4 роки тому +2

      I've been using it in all my cars and I'm very happy with it.

    • @jamesvwalker268
      @jamesvwalker268 4 роки тому +4

      My 2015 Nissan Versa Note likes Castrol Edge. I switched from Mobil 1. I got an increase of 2mpg after 600 miles of driving.

    • @jomelnamoro2754
      @jomelnamoro2754 4 роки тому +4

      Can i use castrol edge on my scooter.

  • @83alpinab9
    @83alpinab9 4 роки тому +5

    I've worked in the auto industry for 30yrs and diagnosed many oil pressure and/failed engines traced back to Pennzoil (sort of). Let me explain. People do not change their oil on a regular basis and deposits and sludge build up in the engine. This is bad but not engine failure bad. The examples I've run into were all engines that were not maintained properly and had significant deposits/sludge build up and all had recently been to Jiffy Lube and had fresh Pennzoil in them. Pennzoil is very high detergent and washed out the engine and caused the oil pump pick-up screen to clog and starved the oil pump causing the loss of oil pressure and in some cases where the owner did not stop driving when the oil pressure warning system told them there was a problem it caused complete engine failure. I believe these customers were probably not using full synthetic and most likely the base Pennzoil (I had heard it was paraffin based). Had they used a less detergent oil all of the deposits would have stayed where they were and not washed into the pick-up screen. Not really a Pennzoil problem, but more of an observation.

  • @dlpannebakker
    @dlpannebakker 3 роки тому +2

    I’ve been using Royal Purple since 1993. What it did for my Audi 5 cylinder with a thrust bearing knock. I’ve been called a lier, but that knock vanished within a month of using at that time called 41 a 10/40 racing oil.
    With using Royal Purple lubricants. The first thing you want is to look to see if the Royal Purple you want to purchase, should have the following preparatory addicted called Synerlec. HPS, for high performance engines with additional additives for bearings, XPR is racing oils & they are outstanding. MaxCycle is RP’s motorcycle oils which have high zinc content.
    Put the oils on Lubricity tester. The HPS & especially the XPR & MaxCycle are just fantastic. Test all top rated oils on the machine. Have oil analysts done on oils that are in your vehicle to see how well the additive packages are holding up or failing by absorbing by products of a operating engine.

  • @DanielAbreu1984
    @DanielAbreu1984 2 роки тому +2

    I thank you for your recommendation of Castrol Edge, that's my brand. 🙂

  • @gmsagolil3496
    @gmsagolil3496 4 роки тому +3

    Castrol Edge Here!! My Toyota Camry has over 300,000 miles and it's still running strong. My local mechanic are impressed how well and strong the car is still running like new

    • @j2thec472
      @j2thec472 2 місяці тому

      Well is a Toyota obviously…🙄

  • @l.cfootman3259
    @l.cfootman3259 3 роки тому +5

    I'm a huge Pennzoil Platinum fan myself! I use to Castrol Synthetic for many years without issues! But, in the past year and a half I switched to Pennzoil Platinum. I've been and Enthusiast for ever, and have worked in the car business. But;, I have Travel across country many times buy car, and have tried different Oils, and additives. So, I've come to believe Pennzoil Platinum offers the best bang and protection, at a good price!

    • @jimsix9929
      @jimsix9929 24 дні тому +1

      yes the best base oil makes the best oil, all the others have to have more additives to keep up but just like drugs in people those additives have side effects

  • @ricos4700
    @ricos4700 2 роки тому +1

    I'm glad you brought up the sludge issue with penzoil . I'm glad the fixed it though. Have you tested the Costco/ Kirkland brand? Thanks for the great video.

  • @brianhartman3186
    @brianhartman3186 2 роки тому

    Great review, thanks for the info!

  • @007connecticut
    @007connecticut 4 роки тому +18

    I use Royal Purple in my lawn mowers. RP 30W is the only synthetic oil I can find. Makes me feel special pouring it in. It's great oil too

    • @MeanOldBastardBikerBob
      @MeanOldBastardBikerBob Рік тому +1

      worest over priced oil iv ever used !

    • @rockie307
      @rockie307 9 місяців тому

      I quit changing oil in my mowers years ago. Never had a engine fail the whole mower falls a part before engine trouble. My current mower is falling apart 7 years old never changed the oil only added when it's low. Engine runs perfect but everything else is almost done.

  • @timothybryant2898
    @timothybryant2898 3 роки тому +13

    Supertech Full Synthetic 5w30 is available in 5 quart jugs for 13.97 at my local Walmart. I love the stuff. They even have the high mileage variety for the same price.

  • @carolynsimmons3087
    @carolynsimmons3087 3 роки тому +1

    We have always used pennzoil, reg.10w30 in a 98 ford expedition, now has over 3 hundred thousand miles on it. high milage reg 5w20 in a 2011 ford f150 with 1 hundred 70 thousand miles, and 5w20 full synthetic in my 2019 kia forte with less than 5 thousand miles, never had a problem with any of them. The old ones still run great.

  • @xtrickster6556
    @xtrickster6556 Рік тому +2

    I've used mobile 1 synthetic for decades and so has my father. Yes it's more expensive unfortunately but have never had any issues.

  • @MrMikey1273
    @MrMikey1273 4 роки тому +3

    I was a long time Castroil fan. Even the mechanic I used to go to swore it was one of the best brands. But I would have to say that with the newer standards all of them are going to be close. I noticed you only focused on oil for gasoline engines. I had to switch brands when I made the change to diesel engine ten years ago. Shell rotella t6 has been working well for me as a full synthetic diesel engine oil.
    My next vehicle might be gasoline again so I will probably choose a brand that meets the vehicle specs and is priced fairly and reasonable available.

  • @MrJerry8159
    @MrJerry8159 3 роки тому +3

    Since I only change my oil once a year, even though SuperTech may be fine, Mobile 1 is only around 10.00 more. So to know for sure (yeah I'm biased) that I have a very good oil for the next year, that 10.00 more is well worth it to me.

  • @javierflores940
    @javierflores940 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the great oil comparison review! Keep up the great reviews 👍🏼

  • @zerep11
    @zerep11 4 роки тому +2

    FYI - SuperTech Engine Oil Filters are also good, which are comparable to Fram's Tough Guard. Been using them with Valvoline MaxLife 5w30 Synthetic Blend (Red Bottle) for years with zero issues. The key to long engine life is to use great products and follow the owner's manual guidance in regards to Engine Oil/Filter Change Intervals in accordance with respective operation environments (at the most), such as regular and severe conditions. Personally, I change both between 2,750 to 3,000 miles max without fail.

    • @Lemonhead8890
      @Lemonhead8890 Рік тому

      I won't touch anything fram unless its not my own vehicle, and only under another persons request. I wouldn't recommend using them either if you are, especially oil filters.

  • @mk4geo822
    @mk4geo822 4 роки тому +7

    I always knew Castrol was meant for high performance engines... +1 to nascar for correct information

  • @Judson1392
    @Judson1392 2 роки тому +6

    I use Pennzoil platinum and sometimes Rotella gas truck in my Ram 1500, Pennzoil Ultra Platinum in my mustang and Castrol Edge in my VW jetta. I think you really can’t go wrong with any of these new synthetics.

    • @gemeinschaftsgeful
      @gemeinschaftsgeful Рік тому +1

      You can only go wrong thinking that you don't have to change the oil often even though it's synthetic.

    • @Judson1392
      @Judson1392 Рік тому +1

      @@gemeinschaftsgeful im very strict on my oil changes. 5k is the absolute max I will go on changes.

  • @stevestarr6395
    @stevestarr6395 2 роки тому +11

    Been using Mobil 1 for years and recently switched to Pennsoil Platinum with great results with compression and performance. What really interests me now is the new Rotella 5-30 that's outperformed Mobil 1 in many tests which I'm trying next!

    • @blaiseingram7214
      @blaiseingram7214 Рік тому

      Pennsoil has a lot of graphite in it

    • @Dan_Hazard
      @Dan_Hazard Рік тому +2

      ​@@blaiseingram7214 is that good or bad, which would you recommend

  • @nydrell1969
    @nydrell1969 2 роки тому +2

    I've been using mobil1 since in the 90's and it never failed me. I won't use anything else period. Plus walmart sells the 5 qt.10w-30 full synthetic for $22.99 cant beat that for sure

  • @vladimpaler9274
    @vladimpaler9274 Рік тому +4

    I love Valvoline and Pennzoil 👍🏻 been using Pennzoil platinum full synthetic high mileage in my 2010 dodge avenger with 142,000+ miles on it and it runs great!!

    • @LeoGxyz
      @LeoGxyz Рік тому +1

      Yes this seems to be the winner but is it worth buying it for my 2017 Corrolla ?

    • @carlovanrijk4039
      @carlovanrijk4039 Рік тому

      @@LeoGxyzsure, as long as the viscosity and the API certification meet Toyota specifications.

  • @martinradtke5181
    @martinradtke5181 3 роки тому +15

    I've been changing oil for 45 years.... Valvoline back in the 1970s was my brand. Then I switched to Mobil 1. Back 40 yrs ago Synthetic was $1 qt vs Dino at 25¢ qt. Today the difference is less than $10 per 5 at jug. IMHO as Old Man I prefer true synthetic base oils (Mobil 1, Amsoil, Royal Purple, Redline) vs Hydro Cracking oils (Castrol). However one aspect of oil nobody can tell is the strength / quality of additives. So in conclusion, change oil with synthetic oil filter regularly. Less than 10k. 🇺🇸

    • @TomTom-gn9mp
      @TomTom-gn9mp 2 роки тому +1

      I think Castrol is just as good as Mobil1 and it's cheaper. It also is ranked very high from other sources.

  • @christianjensen3355
    @christianjensen3355 3 роки тому +2

    Great video, thank you! But the background music is a bit loud

  • @Walrus50
    @Walrus50 3 роки тому +2

    I have a lifter tap and I used super tech 10w-40 and it didn’t go away and I used mobil 1 10w-40 and it went away for a while and Royal purple is so far my favorite proven results it cleans the inside of your engine

  • @jimpie231
    @jimpie231 3 роки тому +23

    I’ve been changing my own oil since 1965. I have been very cognizant of what ratings are on oils. I follow all ratings and purchase oil based on those ratings. My oil changes originally (1965) started at around $3 (including filter). Today I’m doing between $15-$18 (including Supertech $3 oil filter or Toyota $5 OEM filter). I purchase oil that’s on sale only, brand doesn’t matter, ratings do matter. In the 60’s and 70’s any engine that went over 100,000 miles was a rarity, we just didn’t keep cars that long. Even in the 80’s, cars didn’t go that high of mileage. My first car that went over this was a 1990 Lincoln Town car, bought used from a lease at 33,000 miles, and sold at 157,000 miles, because the wheel wells were starting to develop rust (Chicago area salt). After I switched to Honda’s, every one lasted at least 150,000 miles average. In 2006 I changed to synthetic oils, and that 2006 Accord 4 cyl. lasted over 200,000 miles before a black ice accident totaled it. I changed oil every 6,000 mile intervals on that Honda. I now change at 5,000 mile intervals & use Supertech oil filters. I use car mfg. oil viscosity recommendations and buy oil on sale, any brand that meets API, etc. ratings. Thanks....Jim.

    • @NismoDJ20
      @NismoDJ20 2 роки тому +4

      And this is how it should be. It isn't too tough to be cognizant of oil maintenance.

    • @aidenarkham
      @aidenarkham 2 роки тому +2

      All my ford's have 300k miles and still have original engines and transmissions.

    • @Lemonhead8890
      @Lemonhead8890 Рік тому +3

      I mean just changing the oil regularly with ANYTHING is hard for people apparently. So I think if you change the oil with some brand at 3-7k miles you are probably doing alright.

  • @h-waytwan1257
    @h-waytwan1257 4 роки тому +6

    Well I appreciate your opinion. I'm going to switch from Valvoline to Mobil 1 full synthetic 5W-20 so I can get the best performance out of my 4.6 liter 2v

    • @jimsix9929
      @jimsix9929 24 дні тому

      Pennzoil Platinum is way better than Mobile 1, it was not shown here but it is better than Mobile 1 and about the same price, a better base oil makes a better oil and no oil it the world has a better base oil than Pennzoil platinum, the base oil is made from natural gas, not crude oil, Mobile 1 can not compete

  • @emmjee70mg49
    @emmjee70mg49 2 роки тому +1

    When I went to automotive school in the 90s the oldest instructor drove a 67 Ford ¾ton with very high miles. He said he would only use Pennzoil and it's been my brand ever since.

  • @John115Yonkers
    @John115Yonkers 2 роки тому +2

    2018 Impala V-6, I use MOBIL1. I get it on sale at Costco for $30 and buy 2! I did use Royal Purple onetime, but I stick with Mobil 1 since. Make sure you use a quality filter with any good oil.

  • @jeffreyprotzman2146
    @jeffreyprotzman2146 4 роки тому +6

    I've used valvoline high milage for a long time.. Had a 93 suburban I bought with 193,000 miles on it . Used valvoline in it since I bought it.. I sold it with 325,000 on it and still running pretty good.. Never needed to do any major work to engine.. Thanks for the videos Buddy!

    • @MidwestGarage
      @MidwestGarage  4 роки тому +1

      Thanks bud! That's a lot of miles, that's awesome!

  • @rodneyjhackenflash4865
    @rodneyjhackenflash4865 3 роки тому +56

    Well, after using Mobil 1 for years and years I recently purchased the 12 quart bulk pack of Super Tech Full Synthetic 5W-30 for $2.48/quart. Been using it for 2 years. I change the oil in my vehicles and I see Super Tech does a great job of getting dirt out of the crankcase.

    • @robertt9342
      @robertt9342 2 роки тому

      I need to review the specs, but I thought that it had something to do their base oil.

    • @btx5740
      @btx5740 Рік тому +3

      Super tech in every vehicle I own

    • @tbrwn2548
      @tbrwn2548 Рік тому +1

      I like super tech too. 2016 sonata

    • @bluesky-ud9wg
      @bluesky-ud9wg Рік тому +3

      Dirt out of the crankcase, interesting. The oil filter traps dirt, etc, the oil has 3 functions; Clean, Lubricate & Cool. That's what I care about in my oil and I use Purolator One oil filters, change every 5k

    • @nimrodpaul6875
      @nimrodpaul6875 Рік тому +1

      That's a fantastic price

  • @ebox008
    @ebox008 4 роки тому

    I used super tech on my ladies 2005 honda pilot it has now over 215,000 miles. Never had a problem. Had to do time belt change and transmission service, change air conditions conpresor. But car is Extremely good. Thank you.

  • @d.vaughn8990
    @d.vaughn8990 3 роки тому +2

    I worked as a BMW technician - 1999 to 2003. BMW’s used Mobil 1 synthetic oil, for their “extended” life oil change interval. At 15,000 miles, the oil looked like runny tar. It was absolutely awful! The oil filter element rarely came out in one piece. The filter resembled brittle plastic at 15K miles! Regardless, it wasn’t filtering anything for many thousands of miles! I told customers to change their oil every half-interval, as displayed by the oil indicator lights (or mileage counter) located in the instrument cluster.
    And damn right!! It is a free Country!!🇺🇸

  • @robertmeyer4744
    @robertmeyer4744 5 років тому +24

    I have 2010 ford fusion 2.5L 4 cy. have used most of oil's in your video and can tell you not much difference in performance and mpg. They all good! go to walmart and save some $$ most of the oil's listed are sold there !! it is a personal preference thing !!

    • @MidwestGarage
      @MidwestGarage  5 років тому +3

      Thanks for the comment! I definitely agree. Sad thing is, those are Walmart prices that I used in the video haha.

  • @pirateron9080
    @pirateron9080 4 роки тому +3

    Nice video. 30 years - Mobil1

  • @ronl8495
    @ronl8495 4 роки тому +2

    Thanks for your input and I’m going to begin using Castrol Edge in my 2018 Challenger 392 Scatpack!

  • @spadestrump1112
    @spadestrump1112 3 роки тому +1

    I just switched from Castrol Edge, Synthetic Blend with K & N Filter to Mobil 1 Full Synthetic 5w 30 and Mobil 1 Filter for my Tuned Honda Accord. I've read that going full synthetic is GREAT but Synthetic Blend also still has that natural lubricant in it.
    Wish me luck!

    • @yourelectricman
      @yourelectricman Рік тому

      My new Nissan NV v8 van takes 0w-50. Really tight tolerances I guess. Synthetic is only option. Older cars not so tight would just burn up the synthetic. The 2016 dirt bike don't like synthetic. Especially the clutch. Good luck.

  • @greyridge8279
    @greyridge8279 3 роки тому +7

    I’ve tried em all and Ive put some Engines through heck for testing.. I will forever stick with Amsoil... expensive but you get what you pay for

    • @greyridge8279
      @greyridge8279 3 роки тому +1

      Another Oil I’m also trying out is Redline 0w40 . (Have a feeling it’s gonna be neck and neck between the two) I’m running it in my Son’s 2020 CanAm 570 Factory Oil was drained at 500KM We ride hard with our Quads in the Winter here in Canada so I’m excited to have a sample tested in the summer from my buddy at the University. I will report back with results

  • @MrJerry8159
    @MrJerry8159 3 роки тому +3

    I buy Mobile 1 high mileage synthetic and pay between 23-26 dollars for 5 quarts at Walmart! Same stuff at Orelly's and AutoZone was middle to high 30's. Walmart is the winner price wise and a great oil, a win win!

  • @jameswagner5098
    @jameswagner5098 Рік тому +1

    I switched to Pennzoil Platinum recently and I may be crazy, but my car loves it. It seems to idle smoother, and is definitely quieter than before. That said, nothing wrong with my engine, just noticed the subtle difference and I’m sold on the Pennzoil Platinum. It’s a Ford and I was using Motorcraft Synthetic Blend which is good oil, but nowhere as good as the Pennzoil Platinum. In years past I ran Mobil 1 synthetic or Valvoline synthetic. I bought the Pennzoil because it was on a great sale, and have already bought more to do my next oil change.

    • @nimrodpaul6875
      @nimrodpaul6875 Рік тому

      Your not crazy, many will say you can't feel or really hear a difference but I beg to differ, I've had so many rides from 4x4 s to 4 banger high rev drifts to the most admired muscle cars with v8's and even now am enjoying an 06 mustang with the v6 and mild bolt on mods and most cars if you love your ride like I do let's ya know which oil it likes, but then again I'm crazy to :)

  • @gabevillarreal96
    @gabevillarreal96 4 роки тому +10

    Excellent video! Well done! I have a 2016 Honda Accord EXL V6 and I'm pretty darn loyal to Pennzoil Platinum 0w-20. And I use a purilator pure 1 oil filter and change it every 6-7k miles. Excellent oil quality and cleanliness as well as fuel economy and flow/ pumpability! Great engine wear protection!

    • @carlovanrijk4039
      @carlovanrijk4039 2 роки тому +1

      gabe villarreal, I run that same combo on my ‘17 Civic EX. Engine runs smoothly, and after 7K miles, the oil comes out darker (obviously) but still has a great deal of translucence to it. Can’t beat it!

  • @soko1450
    @soko1450 3 роки тому +15

    I've gone to NAPA full syn and their filters. Their oil is Valvoline and their filters are Wix. Until I watched a lot of break down videos, I didn't realize what a huge difference there really is between filters. Oil change and tire rotation every 5k.

    • @wasatchm
      @wasatchm 2 роки тому +2

      I am considering napa oil. you can right now buy napa 5w-30 fully synthetic for $18.99 (5 quart). but how long can u drive between oil changes? I typically like to go 15K miles. it doesn't say on the packaging. lots of synthetic oils will tell you right on the packing how many miles you can drive between oil changes.

    • @megaman4201
      @megaman4201 2 роки тому +2

      @@wasatchm that's too long, oil is cheap enough that you should never go over 10,000, just inviting trouble. Claiming such long change intervals is simply a marketing strategy, while your engine may not blow up it's definitely not good for it. Engine oil is continually being contaminated through intake air, combustion, condensation. Some engines can tolerate that type of abuse better than others.

    • @wasatchm
      @wasatchm 2 роки тому +1

      thanks. I've just talked to 2 mechanics and both said the oil will never go bad just sitting their in your vehicle. I use amsoil fully synthetic which is suppose to go up to 25K miles. it is very expensive that is why I ask. if I had cheaper synthetic oil, I would probably just change it out.
      my truck I never drive (maybe 500 miles/year). so I will not waste money changing the oil in that unless it looks dirty. my car (which also uses amsoil) will get an oil change at the 24 month mark (I am currently putting about 5K miles on it per year) unless it looks dirty. I understand your point about how cheap oil is. but personally, I just think it is a sales tactic used by the oil manufacturers to sell more oil. but, I don't drive anything expensive. if I had a more expensive vehicle, I may agree with you. my vehicles are usually only worth 2K or 3K.

    • @wasatchm
      @wasatchm 2 роки тому

      by the way, I think high end synthetic oil (such as amsoil) can make your engine last a long, long time without frequent oil changes. I bought a 2001 nissan frontier with 59K miles. immediately started doing 25K oil/oil filter changes using amsoil products. had no engine problems whatsoever until I hit the 327K mile mark when I blew a head gasket.

    • @Pentax645
      @Pentax645 2 роки тому +1

      I use Amsoil which claims to be good for 25,000 miles. A few years ago I kept it in my 100,000 mile, 2006 Toyota Highlander 18,200 miles. In draining it, I sent a sample to Blackstone Labs for analysis. The report came back that the oil had remarkably little metal in it, indicating very little engine wear. The report also said that the oil was good for more miles. Personally, I don't recommend going 25,000 miles unless you have a late model car and your driving is mostly highway.

  • @carljr.99
    @carljr.99 3 роки тому +10

    I was using Pennzoil Synthetic until my truck started burning it (it does have 199,000 miles though). I ended up changing over to Mobile 1 and noticed it didn't burn it as quickly.

    • @dylanholey6314
      @dylanholey6314 2 роки тому +3

      Try replacing a quart of oil with a quart of Lucas Oil Stabilizer, as someone who has used it for years and knows plenty of people that do as well it’ll help that burning of oil and prolong the life of the engine

  • @michaelhalaby53
    @michaelhalaby53 4 роки тому +2

    Is shell helix ultra 5w30 a good engine oil? Is it a top brand?