A lot of people seem to dislike Melissa in this which is a total surprise to me. This is one of the most memorable performances from Season 4 for me (that's not saying much). But even from the whole series, this is one of my faves. I think they both sound great. It was very similar to the 'Maybe This Time' duet between Lea and K Chen
The SECOND I saw her on that show i was like OMG WHO IS THAT?! I instantly fell in love with her....and then i heard her sing this and i became forever hopelessly devoted to Melissa Benoist as a fan. The fact that she made a poor comic book nerd like me happier by being one of my all time favorite super heroines in Kara Zor El/Supergirl was just icing on the cake. Now ive had 3 of my favorite actresses transition to comic book roles. Her, Elizabeth Olsen as Scarlet Witch, and my celeb crush "wife" Karen Gillan as Nebula.
I can't be the only one who is so shocked that in ALL those moments in which Rachel was back at McKinley, her and Marley did not once cross paths or have a conversation, or scene together. For somebody who was meant to be the New Rachel, I would have liked that scene and it forever baffles me why they never interacted.
I absolutely love this scene. It was the perfect way of introducing the new star of the new directions. Also, it shows Rachel with a new maturity level with her singing. Such great singing in one scene!
Melissa is an incredible talent. She originally was studying Musical Theatre and aims for Broadway landing her the role of Marley on Glee. Now Melissa is finally coming to Broadway this summer. She is going to be making her Broadway Debut for a limited run starting June 7th as Carole King in the show BEAUTIFUL.
+SIARANKA_CZ I did too! I hate how they screwed her over simply because the original cast's fan club didn't take to her instantly. I'm like, "Her voice is _GOLDEN_, and the original cast had _three years_ to build a fan base! Quit writing crap for her and give her some dang time!" But alas, they did not listen. Oh well. She now has her own show and it's successful, so I couldn't be happier for her. ^_^
I think that Rachel has more vocal technique than Marley. She has a higher register and more vocal agility. However, Marley has a warmer, softer and sweeter voice than Rachel. Listening her is much more "comfortable" than listening Rachel, who always sounds the same.
happikachu there's no new Rachel. Yeah. But there's someone better than Rachel. :3 Even then back in the days of the show I loved Santana's voice even more.
Seeing Melissa Benoist as Marley just makes me soo happy ♥️ What a talented human. A great actress, a great singer and a beautiful person inside and out
I catch myself coming back to listen to this song way too often. I've heard both of the solo versions and I love how this works so well as a duet, with the contrast between their voices. I wasn't watching glee anymore when this happened, but it's in my Top 5 glee songs for sure.
Lyrics: Some folks like to get away, Take a holiday from the neighborhood Hop a flight to Miami Beach or to Hollywood But I'm takin' a Greyhound on the Hudson River line I'm in a New York state of mind It was so easy livin' day by day Out of touch with the rhythym and blues But now I need a little give and take The New York Times, the Daily News It comes down to reality, and it's fine with me cause I've let it slide I don't care if it's Chinatown or on Riverside I don't have any reasons I left them all behind I'm in a New York state of mind Oh yeah Who, oh, oh whoa who It comes down to reality, and it's fine with me cause I've let it slide I don't care if it's Chinatown or on Riverside I don't have any reasons I left them all behind I'm in a New York state of mind I'm just taking a Greyhound on the Hudson River line Cause I'm in a, I'm in a New York state of mind
Absolutely incredible!! I fell in love with Melissa and marley!! I can't believe they didn't play her more! And she sang this way better then Lea! She gave soul! Favorite song from glee! ❤️
+Μαρια Ιωαννιδου He sang "Music of the Night" with John Barrowman at a convention not long ago. The guy's got some pipes on him. Most of the Berlanti-DC actors have musical theater chops, so some singing gags wouldn't be out of the norm.
+Μαρια Ιωαννιδου I'm not sure about Stephen Amell but Emily Bett Rickards can, John Barrowman can, Jesse L Martin can, Carlos Valdes can, Danielle Panabaker can, Tom Cavanagh can, Jeremy Jordan can, Chyler Leigh can and so can Colton Hayes!
I was never a massive fan of Marley as a character xxx But I LOVE LOVe LOVE Melissa and as much as I love Leas voice on this song I much prefer the Melissa version xxx
I thought Marley did the song better then Rachel because she sounded more into the song, put more emotion behind it, dont get me wrong, Rachel has textbook perfected vocals, but sometimes thats not whats important.
I don't know, maybe it's just that Marley showed her emotion better. Which is probably because being in two widely diverse scenarios, immense character differences difference, and dream contrast, their out word appearance and behavior should differ.
+Autumn Danielle you are right about that, sometimes is more important the emotion you can put into a song more than the techniques you can use for the song, vocals skills are awesome but when you put feelings when you are singing makes the whole scenario more credible and perfect
+Yo YO (Awesome) I didn't say that they didn't matter I was clearly stating that even though someone may be a great singer, the song is always better if there is emotion behind it. I also wasn't saying that Marley doesn't have un perfected vocals, Rachel AKA, Lea has been trained on Broadway since a child and basically has textbook perfected vocals (in a broad way type). They are two completely different singers, both excellent.
This music makes me want to go to NYC and have many imaginations and feelings about USA. Maybe I won't forget this song until i die. It got me so much inspirations.
I love Marley as much as I love glee. Such a shame she didn't come back for the final season 😭 her voice.. Her personality her relationship with Ryder was left unfinished. She was one of my fav in season 4 & 5 ☺️ Ugh glee makes me mad... They lead me on with disappointment. 😖😠😭
Totalmente de acuerdo contigo... Marley debió de estar aunque no fuera papel principal... ella debió estar ahí! Ni en el final de temporada estuvo :'( I love Marley
Alien Ind But on the other side (probably the better side) she didn't come back because she was busy filming Supergirl,and not because she wasn't invited :)
I was actually glad they got rid of marley, jake, ryder, and unique for the sixth season. They were boring and lackluster to me. Kitty was the only one that had something special about her and she deserved to come back. The others were carbon copies
Indika Dreamer me too. I jist hated them for that and actually didn't want to watch supergirl cause my hate extended that far. then I watched supergirl and now I love melissa. she's a great actress
I love this! I wish that Marley was in season 6!! I watch it on netflix and in demand tv. I also prefer not watching in order. After watching season 6 episode 10. I was so confused. I only knew kitty. MARLEY WE NEEDED YOU.
I knew I'd love Marley from the very first I saw her on Glee. Or maybe it's because I love Melissa Benoist. Either ways, o would've still loved Marley. She's adorable. Watching season4 just for her ♥️
Can't wait for the musical episode crossover of The Flash and Supergirl! They finished filming not that long ago. ❤❤❤❤ I just heard this on Apple Music and I had to watch it.
I know Rachel is the "star" of Glee but personally, I've always loved Quinn's voice. It's obviously not like Rachel's but it has a softness and a classiness to it that I'm in LOVE with.
A lot of people seem to dislike Melissa in this which is a total surprise to me. This is one of the most memorable performances from Season 4 for me (that's not saying much). But even from the whole series, this is one of my faves. I think they both sound great. It was very similar to the 'Maybe This Time' duet between Lea and K Chen
That duet was 100 times better than this.
誤りです。レイチェル役をした方が出演者から嫌われていました。何故ならばこのドラマの出演者に対して人種差別的な事をしていました。なので…嫌われているのは、レイチェル役の方ですよ。
I just love how both of their voices blend at 2:36
The moment I fell in love with Melissa Benoist
Exactly how i felt lol , she really is beautiful (:
She's my supergirl
me too bruh
yepppp
The SECOND I saw her on that show i was like OMG WHO IS THAT?! I instantly fell in love with her....and then i heard her sing this and i became forever hopelessly devoted to Melissa Benoist as a fan. The fact that she made a poor comic book nerd like me happier by being one of my all time favorite super heroines in Kara Zor El/Supergirl was just icing on the cake. Now ive had 3 of my favorite actresses transition to comic book roles. Her, Elizabeth Olsen as Scarlet Witch, and my celeb crush "wife" Karen Gillan as Nebula.
I can't be the only one who is so shocked that in ALL those moments in which Rachel was back at McKinley, her and Marley did not once cross paths or have a conversation, or scene together. For somebody who was meant to be the New Rachel, I would have liked that scene and it forever baffles me why they never interacted.
Connor Hamilton bad writitng
She was a new student in this season
Connor Hamilton ikr I wish they were friends
What about the final song they played on the series finale where almost everyone was back?
@@lindsayv1239 ikr..
I absolutely love this scene. It was the perfect way of introducing the new star of the new directions. Also, it shows Rachel with a new maturity level with her singing. Such great singing in one scene!
I just love their faces. They're all like she's the new Rachel, we're screwed.
Who ever though that Melissa Benoist and Grant Gustin 2 actors from Glee would be superheroes today AKA Supergirl & The Flash
there has to be something going on behind the cameras now Blake daflake plays at supergirl too
Yea they were both on glee
+By Ron yeah and their married. They are so cute together
no they are not married
Katie White i thought that too but not anymore shes married to ryder from glee search it
Flash can Sing , Supergirl Can Sing WTF every heroes actors can sing these days lmfao
+Epiphany So can the guy who played Felicity's ex from college!!!
+pmparda I was just going to say that
Your love
Ya, don't forget freaking Jeremy Jordan
+Epiphany OMG, the flash was on glee!!!
I think Marley's blues sound is better for this song than Rachel's Broadway. I'm sad that Marley isn't a regular on the show this season.
It’s because Marley sang it “Billie Joel” style, and Rachel “Barbra Streisand” style. :D
Marley is in more episodes in season 4 than Rachel
Molly will
Molly
Molly will
I LOVE this version! Melissa and Lea smash it out!. My girls!
Melissa is an incredible talent. She originally was studying Musical Theatre and aims for Broadway landing her the role of Marley on Glee. Now Melissa is finally coming to Broadway this summer. She is going to be making her Broadway Debut for a limited run starting June 7th as Carole King in the show BEAUTIFUL.
oh god i love melissa's voice. i loved marley 💞
+SIARANKA_CZ I did too! I hate how they screwed her over simply because the original cast's fan club didn't take to her instantly. I'm like, "Her voice is _GOLDEN_, and the original cast had _three years_ to build a fan base! Quit writing crap for her and give her some dang time!"
But alas, they did not listen. Oh well. She now has her own show and it's successful, so I couldn't be happier for her. ^_^
Stephen Amell can sing, he just hasn't done it professionally as far as I know. He sang at a convention and at a Nerd HQ Q&A session
KarxDanvers yasssss
KarxDanvers 👑
KarxDanvers same but I feel bad for her mom
I think that Rachel has more vocal technique than Marley. She has a higher register and more vocal agility. However, Marley has a warmer, softer and sweeter voice than Rachel. Listening her is much more "comfortable" than listening Rachel, who always sounds the same.
I agree
Ana P , I hate Rachel
i do think rachel has softer and sweeter voice... maybe not in this song...
Annie Xoxo Santana was better than Rachel I don't care what people say
And Mercedes and Santana were the true queens of glee
jose lopez hell to the yes
This performance always makes me cry
There will never be a "new Rachel"...
There can only be one Rachel
They tried, but if Supergirl can't make it who can?
Rachel will never be Supergirl XD
happikachu there's no new Rachel. Yeah. But there's someone better than Rachel. :3 Even then back in the days of the show I loved Santana's voice even more.
Magical Eevee101 | {(
Nameless Pierrot In your opinion
Marleys little waving at the end of her performance is soo adorable. My heart can't ♥️
Seeing Melissa Benoist as Marley just makes me soo happy ♥️ What a talented human. A great actress, a great singer and a beautiful person inside and out
I catch myself coming back to listen to this song way too often. I've heard both of the solo versions and I love how this works so well as a duet, with the contrast between their voices.
I wasn't watching glee anymore when this happened, but it's in my Top 5 glee songs for sure.
Lyrics:
Some folks like to get away,
Take a holiday from the neighborhood
Hop a flight to Miami Beach or to Hollywood
But I'm takin' a Greyhound on the Hudson River line
I'm in a New York state of mind
It was so easy livin' day by day
Out of touch with the rhythym and blues
But now I need a little give and take
The New York Times, the Daily News
It comes down to reality, and it's fine with me cause I've let it slide
I don't care if it's Chinatown or on Riverside
I don't have any reasons
I left them all behind
I'm in a New York state of mind
Oh yeah
Who, oh, oh whoa who
It comes down to reality, and it's fine with me cause I've let it slide
I don't care if it's Chinatown or on Riverside
I don't have any reasons
I left them all behind
I'm in a New York state of mind
I'm just taking a Greyhound on the Hudson River line
Cause I'm in a, I'm in a New York state of mind
Actually guys, I believe Marleys voice suits this song better, marly has more of a pop/jazz voice, of course lea sounds amazing as always lol
That is my take too. It doesn't diminish Lea's talent in any way.
Rachel and Marley both sound amazing beautiful
they NEED to bring these characters back for the final season! I was so annoyed and sad when they got rid of the mckinley students! loved them!
True.
And ami I would like you cut the internet for you to stop commenting shit, stupid and return to the past so that your mother had not given birth
Pablo Monteith chill, bro... What is the matter with you? It's just a show.
***** Cuz she got injured and couldn't get back to the final group number
My Best Favorite Song in Glee
Preach 💁🏾🙌🏾
Molly will
I still think this is Melissa Benoist''s best performance....
Melissa Benoist Forever Love💘💓💞💕💖❤️💗💜💙
Melissa Benoist being perfect as usual ♥️
Their voices sound so good together
Is so magic ✨
That was absolutely awe inspiring! That is what billy joel was originally trying to say when he recorded this song.....WOW!!!!!!!
the best glee performance !!! without a doubt !!!
Amazing voices and feeling from the girls. Wow, so deep.
Hands down the best performance of season 4
Virtual standing ovation
Honestly, this is one my favorite duets
Looking back Melissa was under apriciated on Glee, she definetely can act, she continues to impress on Supergirl
Absolutely incredible!! I fell in love with Melissa and marley!! I can't believe they didn't play her more! And she sang this way better then Lea! She gave soul! Favorite song from glee! ❤️
2024 and this never gets old✨
I miss this show so much how many years later.
supergirl and flash should do a two hour special musical episode.. just for us the gleeks.😆
hey does anyone know if Stephen smell can sing??
+Μαρια Ιωαννιδου He sang "Music of the Night" with John Barrowman at a convention not long ago. The guy's got some pipes on him.
Most of the Berlanti-DC actors have musical theater chops, so some singing gags wouldn't be out of the norm.
Awesome
+Μαρια Ιωαννιδου if it was like OMWF that could be awesome
+Μαρια Ιωαννιδου I'm not sure about Stephen Amell but Emily Bett Rickards can, John Barrowman can, Jesse L Martin can, Carlos Valdes can, Danielle Panabaker can, Tom Cavanagh can, Jeremy Jordan can, Chyler Leigh can and so can Colton Hayes!
Pretty much the whole cast from both shows can sing!
Both are great singers but I really love Melissa's version. I wish there is a version where it's just Melissa.
there is a version of just Melissa singing
JUST SEARCH UP MARLEY new yourk state of mind solo
UberWarriorGirl I hate Rachel and I love Marley but Rachel was better even tho I utterly hate her I hate the fact that I perder Rachel's
UberWarriorGirl Lea Mitchel started making music again and playing shows
I was never a massive fan of Marley as a character xxx But I LOVE LOVe LOVE Melissa and as much as I love Leas voice on this song I much prefer the Melissa version xxx
This scene is just perfect and beautiful.
I so love how you sing together, beautiful voices!
I thought Marley did the song better then Rachel because she sounded more into the song, put more emotion behind it, dont get me wrong, Rachel has textbook perfected vocals, but sometimes thats not whats important.
+Autumn Danielle perfected vocals don't matter? what...Lol?
I don't know, maybe it's just that Marley showed her emotion better. Which is probably because being in two widely diverse scenarios, immense character differences difference, and dream contrast, their out word appearance and behavior should differ.
+Autumn Danielle you are right about that, sometimes is more important the emotion you can put into a song more than the techniques you can use for the song, vocals skills are awesome but when you put feelings when you are singing makes the whole scenario more credible and perfect
+Yo YO (Awesome) I didn't say that they didn't matter I was clearly stating that even though someone may be a great singer, the song is always better if there is emotion behind it. I also wasn't saying that Marley doesn't have un perfected vocals, Rachel AKA, Lea has been trained on Broadway since a child and basically has textbook perfected vocals (in a broad way type). They are two completely different singers, both excellent.
Autumn Danielle lol got it
love them BOTH
Amazing! ❤
Barry fucked up the timeline so hard that supergirl join the glee club😁😁😁
I love this audition.
Chanel #6 ft Supergirl xD
She will always be Rachel Berry❤️
+Ivana Carrion yasss ❤
Ivana Carrion she was not Rachel berry that is Lea Michele. Supergirl was Marley
omg
Absolutely perfectly
Wow!!!!!!!
This music makes me want to go to NYC and have many imaginations and feelings about USA. Maybe I won't forget this song until i die. It got me so much inspirations.
i love this song
That's perhaps the most beautiful moment on all Glee!
Esta canción es la que escucharé cuando visite new york😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️❤️
Go Melissa!!!
Melissa benoist is the best!!!!!!!😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀💞💞💞💞💞
they both have the most beautiful voices in the wholl intire people in this whol show they both do
Wow! Glee was te soundtrack of my life! Miss it so much!
Wooooooooh!!!!!! Ang galing! 😍 🐼
@beingapartofsomethingspecial..
I just wanted to say thanks so much for uploading the playlist it makes it easier to find a lot of their songs😊
i love this song . someday I'll be in the park of newyork with this song.
Marley voice made me cry I love her :'(
I love Marley as much as I love glee. Such a shame she didn't come back for the final season 😭 her voice.. Her personality her relationship with Ryder was left unfinished. She was one of my fav in season 4 & 5 ☺️ Ugh glee makes me mad... They lead me on with disappointment. 😖😠😭
Totalmente de acuerdo contigo... Marley debió de estar aunque no fuera papel principal... ella debió estar ahí! Ni en el final de temporada estuvo :'( I love Marley
Alien Ind But on the other side (probably the better side) she didn't come back because she was busy filming Supergirl,and not because she wasn't invited :)
I was actually glad they got rid of marley, jake, ryder, and unique for the sixth season. They were boring and lackluster to me. Kitty was the only one that had something special about her and she deserved to come back. The others were carbon copies
Ryley for life
Indika Dreamer me too. I jist hated them for that and actually didn't want to watch supergirl cause my hate extended that far. then I watched supergirl and now I love melissa. she's a great actress
On a Glee marathon and couldn't be happier
What talented ladies.
Wow she sings good amazing wow 😀
I love this song!
Ahaha brody at the end and Ms. Tibedeaux is like "Brody what are you doing" XD
Love this love Marley live Rachel there both the best singers on glee
I love this! I wish that Marley was in season 6!! I watch it on netflix and in demand tv. I also prefer not watching in order. After watching season 6 episode 10. I was so confused. I only knew kitty. MARLEY WE NEEDED YOU.
you can sing so good i almost cried
j adore pas d autre mot a ajouter glee c est juste genial😃
Daaaaaaaamn! Supergirl got some pipes!
I remember this soong at the beginning of the season. I was omggg that duet
I love this music 😍
This song is life and also glee
I always thought there was two parts to the Glee series. This performance really captivates that transition.
Omg Kara and berry are in glee aaaaaaa I love them 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😁😁😁😁😁😘😘😘😘😘🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤
I knew I'd love Marley from the very first I saw her on Glee. Or maybe it's because I love Melissa Benoist. Either ways, o would've still loved Marley. She's adorable. Watching season4 just for her ♥️
this is still one of my glee favourites of all seasons
I love the juxtaposition of Marley being Rachel in this scene
And that's how you give a glee audition ♥️
the chills!
Sing, Supergirl. Sing!
Yeah...Love Melissa. She can really sing! Go Supergirl!
Wow beautiful
Their voices compliment each other so well
Can't wait for the musical episode crossover of The Flash and Supergirl! They finished filming not that long ago. ❤❤❤❤ I just heard this on Apple Music and I had to watch it.
Because New York state of mind..
easily my favorite song on glee
Don't dare call Marley the new Rachel. She's nothing like Rachel. She's likeable and easily won my heart in seconds.
Melhor dueto da temporada inteira ❤
melissa benois love forever
Amo questa canzoneeee
I love ❤️ glee
この曲大好き
I love there music
When their voices blend...
wow perfect voices :)
I know Rachel is the "star" of Glee but personally, I've always loved Quinn's voice. It's obviously not like Rachel's but it has a softness and a classiness to it that I'm in LOVE with.