Thank you. Since I love both Mr. Domingo and Mr. Lanza, I shall not attempt to decide who does what best. I shall continue to listen and watch and love both for being the magnificent artists they are and will always be.
Que torrente de hermosos recuerdos abarrotan mi mente ! esta hermosa melodía la cantaba mi padre RIP, Que maravilla !! se me hizo un. nudo en la garganta y se me puso la piel de gallina...bravisimo maestro Plácido Domingo !!!
Maestro Domingo is a spinto/lyric,a great tenor,not to forget,Danny Rodriguez.A great tenor,just like the great late Mario Lanza,no longer with us.God bless them all.
to say that Domingo--let alone every major tenor since the 50's--are nuts--maybe even obsessed by Lanza is an understatement (D. said Lanza was his idol) Lanza casts a giant shadow, influence over them all---
Lanza had an operetta voice. Tenors like Domingo are the real deal: musicians, language experts, and stage performers with huge voices that carry and - most importantly - are able to sustain their power throughout an entire opera (and not merely one recorded hit).
@@sebastianmelmoth685 You say that among other things that Tenors like Senor Domingo are stage performers and able to sustain their power throughout an entire opera (and not merely one recorded hit) ? I must have seen a different video of Domingo attempting to sing "Be My Love". It appears that he has to look down periodically to see the lyrics. I keep waiting for him to hit the high notes that Mario could hit but apparently he wasn't capable of doing so. Apparently, Domingo is not able to "sustain his power through one recorded hit". If you noticed, Mario held back and let Katherine Grayson hit her high note when they sang their duet of "Be My Love" in the "Toast of New Orleans". Mario's range included singing Baritone. I know because I sing Baritone. He was also a wonderful actor and a "heartthrob".
@@sebastianmelmoth685 - If you don’t now, just shut up. Fact, the great Domingo, isn’t able to sing that correctly. Not a single high C, not even a very small C 😛 , the great Lanza has been dead for over 60 years and none of the great Tenors could sing the song properly, not even Domingo, Tucker, Pavarotti, Wunderlich, Del Monaco, the only one hwo did well was the great Antlantov.
It doesn't hurt to know: the author of this great song is the world-famous hungarian Miklós Brodszky, who wrote it for Mario Lanza! No está de más saberlo: ¡el autor de esta gran canción es el mundialmente famoso húngaro Miklós Brodszky, que la escribió para Mario Lanza!
J'ai découvert Placido en 1971, sur le coffret d'anniversaire de la mort d'Enrico Caruso, il utilisait ses enregistrements pour parfaire sa voix de ténor (il est naturellement baryton et l'ai aujourd'hui redevenu) c'est pour moi le meilleur et la référence! PfM
Lanza is a champion of this song, he only could make you goosebumps with such expressive phrasing and style. anyway, This is a good version, but the ultimate rendition of the song will still remain as a Lanza's signature. I'm still waiting to see Lanza on bluray ... when ???
+Julio Alexander Aguilar Angulo I agree--love Domingo in many things--but the intimacy is just not there--its too opera house--Lanza sounded like he was singing this to his lover....
Se tiene que admirar en Placido D es que en casi todas sus grabaciones se hizo acompañar de excelentes orquetas pero de ahí que tenga más bella VOZ que Lanza NUNCA, Lanza nació cantante, Placido se hizo cantante.
Beautiful! Thanks! Be my love for no one else can end this yearning this need that you and you alone create just fill my arms the way you've filled my dreams the dreams that you inspire with every sweet desire Be my love and with your kisses set me burnin gone kiss is all i need to seal my fate and hand in hand we'll find love's promised land there'll be no one but you for me eternally if you will be my love
Max Mustermann , ein lyrischer Tenor kann der Beste lyrische Tenor sein, aber nicht der Beste von Allen. Wann hat Wunderlich zum Beispiel Otello gesungen?
Cuantas veces debemos decirlo , Domingo es un tenor inmenso , pero una de sus grandes cualidades es la humildad, cada vez que se a referido a Lanza , lo ha hecho con respeto y mucha admiración, lo que Domingo logro con muchísimos anos de sacrificio con su voz, Lanza solo tuvo que abrir su inigualable garganta y cantar, esta como muchas otras piezas pertenecen a el gran Mario Lanza y Placido lo sabe.
Nadie debe quitarle el poderio a Mario Lanza, pero como Domingo van a tardar años y años, en salir una voz con el poderio de la suya, es únicol, y una persona tan abierta y dispuesta a compartir cancion con cualquier artista solo hace falta ver si historial, en fin un ser excepcional.
I know Domingo is very popular. I find his enunciation blurry and timber uneven. He may be technically sound, but for pure listening enjoyment, Mario Lanza remains the greatest.
I love and admire Placido Domingo. He has given me much joy. Domingo loves and admires Lanza. But, this performance certainly makes a point. Domingo does not even attempt to better or even equal his childhood idol. There is no comparison at all. None.
If you sing this tune from the bottom of your heart, you don’t need to look at the sheet music, especially as a professional vocalist. I am sure he does not care about this at his age as of 2022.
Mario Lanza was greater than any of these tenors in my opinion and I am not an expert in opera. However, Mario had a sound that was ethereal and his high notes were hit much more effortlessly than even the great Pavarotti! I haven't heard anyone try the high note at the end as Mario did on some of the recordings of this song!
Some people like this singer and some like another. But there are objective standards that can be used in comparisons. Domingo ends the song on a G. Lanza sings a High C.
@@ursmue1937 ja pavarotti fand ich auch besser als Domingo also mein Lieblings Sänger war mario lanza weil er vielseitig war er konnte sogar normale Lieder singen wie come prima aber auch echte Klassiker und sein Gefühl und seine Power von einer anderen Welt aber das Alter mit rein zunehmen ist lächerlich genau wie Interpretation von Domingo finde kein Gefühl keine Kraft da war Luciano schon ne andere Klasse obwohl ich Domingo eig gerne höre
mis respetos por Domingo pero por favor porque nunca , nunca , nunca la nota final la trata , aunque sea trata de cantarla medianamente como Lanza....!No puede!
Placido is a pale imitation of Mario. And what is this apparent having to read the lyrics while singing? Mario hits high notes that Placido is apparently not capable of reaching. And Mario could also sing as well as any baritone. His range was unbelievable and he was an excellent actor too. God Bless Mario. This would have been the year of his 100th birthday.
i DON'T BELIEVE any tenor but Mario Lanza sang this song extremely well. The accent and strangulated squeezing sound here does not do it for me. I'm not crazy about the song in the first place, but Lanza truly stands alone in this song.
Though I very much enjoy the singing of Mr. Domingo, I feel it is unwise to sing a song which has high notes which not are hit as originally written. Especially if you are performing a classic of Mr. Lanza. It is quite the let-down. I have sung this gem on occasion(as written) and will never perform it live unless I am in good voice to hit those passionate notes in a fat sound.
+Arythmnmaker1 thanks for sharing--do you mean Mr D. is not hitting the high notes? He is a spinto not a lyric like Lanza---transposed them?? come to santa fe and sing for us!!
+windstorm1000 Yes, I mean to say, that though he was capable, he chose to transpose ---- on a ' CLASSIC ' of Mr. LANZA. My Feeling is, that there are those pieces not to take artist ic liberty I believe others here have made comments which concur with my perspective. I am not sure I understand your point regarding lyric and spinto. Many years ago I had the great fortune to meet Maestro Marcopoulus; spinto operatic tenor, when he was 65, who still performed this masterpiece as originally composed. Amazingly he could create a ringing high ' C ' at will and without to much fuss warming-up. He always praised his Italian teacher.
Not even close. Not an altogether bad performance. However, key things missing. One, the passion. Two, failure to hit the high notes at the climactic moment of the piece. The man is skilled, of that there is not doubt. However, if you want to hear this piece sung as it should be, listen to Mario Lanza sing it.
He is not standing in Lanza's shadow. He is in a league of his own. He is real opera singer and not a little operetta tenor - a huge spinto voice able to sustain his abilities throughout an entire opera. He TOWERS over Lanza. Hyperion to a satyr. Of course this little ditty does not suit his voice. He is not a ditty-singer.
Sebastian Melmoth , Ja ja, blos der riesige Operntenor hat es nicht gekonnt, wie Jeder Andere zuvor auch nicht. Wo sind denn die ganzen hohen C ? Vom Winde verweht. Sehen Sie Pappano on Lanza, oder P.Domingo Tribut für Lanza, usw. Lustig kleines Stimmchen, schlägt riesige Opernstimme. Nebenbei, ich mag Domingo.
lo digo en español que casi ya domIno, ¿Que Lanza esta nervioso, fumando del otro lado?, es sin lugar a dudas el mas estúpido e insulso comentario que un ser vivo haya pronunciado.
Thank you for keeping Mario Lanza's memory alive with this beautiful and moving redention ❤
solo una maldita vez queria escuchar de DOMINGO la c 5. pero no, nunca pudo ser, que inmenso es MARIO LANZA.!
Thank you. Since I love both Mr. Domingo and Mr. Lanza, I shall not attempt to decide who does what best. I shall continue to listen and watch and love both for being the magnificent artists they are and will always be.
That is my attitude, too!
It doesn't matter who sang it better first, but if that love was convinced!
Que torrente de hermosos recuerdos abarrotan mi mente ! esta hermosa melodía la cantaba mi padre RIP,
Que maravilla !! se me hizo un. nudo en la garganta y se me puso la piel de gallina...bravisimo maestro Plácido Domingo !!!
Thanks Placido. Wonderful performance.. This orchestration is also excellent.
Bravissimo PLACIDO DOMINGO ❤
Gracias infinitas por todo querido Placido....!! Su arte su generosidad su voz su presencia.....!!!
Maestro Domingo is a spinto/lyric,a great tenor,not to forget,Danny Rodriguez.A great tenor,just like the great late Mario Lanza,no longer with us.God bless them all.
Oh, how I love this song!!! Nobody sings it with so much emotion like him! Many thanks Pilar!
You have a right to your opinion, but I much prefer the Mario Lanza rendition.
za
Mais uma prova da inigualável e belíssima voz do maior tenor de todos os tempos: MARIO LANZA. Somente Mario cantava Be My Love com emoção,
Domingo, il più grande e applaudito ❤
to say that Domingo--let alone every major tenor since the 50's--are nuts--maybe even obsessed by Lanza is an understatement (D. said Lanza was his idol) Lanza casts a giant shadow, influence over them all---
Lanza had an operetta voice. Tenors like Domingo are the real deal: musicians, language experts, and stage performers with huge voices that carry and - most importantly - are able to sustain their power throughout an entire opera (and not merely one recorded hit).
@@sebastianmelmoth685 - If stupidity hurt 😢 you world cry day und night.
@@sebastianmelmoth685 You say that among other things that Tenors like Senor Domingo are stage performers and able to sustain their power throughout an entire opera (and not merely one recorded hit) ? I must have seen a different video of Domingo attempting to sing "Be My Love". It appears that he has to look down periodically to see the lyrics. I keep waiting for him to hit the high notes that Mario could hit but apparently he wasn't capable of doing so. Apparently, Domingo is not able to "sustain his power through one recorded hit".
If you noticed, Mario held back and let Katherine Grayson hit her high note when they sang their duet of "Be My Love" in the "Toast of New Orleans". Mario's range included singing Baritone. I know because I sing Baritone. He was also a wonderful actor and a "heartthrob".
@@joanschilleci7564 If you are basing a man's career on one song... then, sure. You're right. ;)
@@sebastianmelmoth685 - If you don’t now, just shut up. Fact, the great Domingo, isn’t able to sing that correctly. Not a single high C, not even a very small C 😛 , the great Lanza has been dead for over 60 years and none of the great Tenors could sing the song properly, not even Domingo, Tucker, Pavarotti, Wunderlich, Del Monaco, the only one hwo did well was the great Antlantov.
It doesn't hurt to know: the author of this great song is the world-famous hungarian Miklós Brodszky, who wrote it for Mario Lanza!
No está de más saberlo: ¡el autor de esta gran canción es el mundialmente famoso húngaro Miklós Brodszky, que la escribió para Mario Lanza!
One of the best versions sung! Great job!
Belissima ! Belissima ! Belissima !
J'ai découvert Placido en 1971, sur le coffret d'anniversaire de la mort d'Enrico Caruso, il utilisait ses enregistrements pour parfaire sa voix de ténor (il est naturellement baryton et l'ai aujourd'hui redevenu) c'est pour moi le meilleur et la référence! PfM
Bravo
Meraviglioso
Rita jacono da
Ischia
😂 The master of Be my Love 😍 MARIO LANZA !
Placido
Domingo pats nuostabiausias dainininkas, menininkas,žmogus,kuris nenustoja stebinęs savo įvairiapusiškumu!
Love how Domingo has another gear and shine in his voice when he hits his high's. He has great round fullness all the way to a high b flat.
Yes, yes, Placido !
Placido, recalco !nunca! se ha atrevido a realizar la ultima nota como Lanza , simplemente !No puede!
Pues escucha a Bocelli y verás como no tiene ningún problema para llegar a ese C 5.
Eso lo convierte en mejor tenor que Domingo? Por supuesto que no.
Quelle merveilleuse interprétation. Merci Placido you are the best for me .
what a glorious sound!
???
Sin palabras Me fascina esa canción !! Se la dedico al gran amor de mi vida
gracias por compartir . . .
Belíssima música.
Lanza is a champion of this song, he only could make you goosebumps with such expressive phrasing and style. anyway, This is a good version, but the ultimate rendition of the song will still remain as a Lanza's signature. I'm still waiting to see Lanza on bluray ... when ???
+Julio Alexander Aguilar Angulo I agree--love Domingo in many things--but the intimacy is just not there--its too opera house--Lanza sounded like he was singing this to his lover....
@@windstorm1000 Amen, Amen, Amen!
I would only say that Mr. Domingo deserves a "A" for having the "cojones" to attempt to sing the "Maestro" Mario's signature song.
Adorable always~! 🙂
Maravillosa y conmovedora interpretación de esta bellísima canción, para escucharla una y mil veces ! Gracias por este video !
Placido, you make life worth living
DOMINGO IS THE GREATEST TENOR OF ALL TIMES, I AM TENOR FOR MY SELF, BUT DOMINGO, THE SUN OF ALL TENORS. FOR EVER GRANDE PLACIDO DOMINGO.
You are an idiot, Del Monaco, Lauri Volpi, Fritz Wunderlich...just to mention a few, are by far better than Domingo.
Se tiene que admirar en Placido D es que en casi todas sus grabaciones se hizo acompañar de excelentes orquetas pero de ahí que tenga más bella VOZ que Lanza NUNCA, Lanza nació cantante, Placido se hizo cantante.
Placido, a la ópera. Cada maestrito con su librito.
Mario Lanzas Lied für immer...was für ein Herzschmerz er auslöst..bei anderen Interpreten kann man Zeitung lesen
Beautiful! Thanks!
Be my love for no one else can end this yearning
this need that you and you alone create
just fill my arms the way you've filled my dreams
the dreams that you inspire with every sweet desire
Be my love and with your kisses set me burnin
gone kiss is all i need to seal my fate
and hand in hand we'll find love's promised
land there'll be no one but you for me eternally
if you will be my love
como siempre magnífico
Distinguido colega muy pocos pueden cantar como Domingo eso es verdad pero Domingo siempre a querido cantar como Lanza, otra verdad. ! Saludos!
The great Lanza has a lot to laugh about in the grave 😂
Trio bandits
Wow is he still alive? We need more opera singers like him .
Fortunately, he is still living today!
Placido Domingo is the greates all the times...
@george george the best was Fritz Wunderlich
Says Pavarotti in a Interview 1990
Max Mustermann , ein lyrischer Tenor kann der Beste lyrische Tenor sein, aber nicht der Beste von Allen. Wann hat Wunderlich zum Beispiel Otello gesungen?
Max Mustermann , Pavarotti says 1984 in Frankreichs TV, the best tenor voice of all time, Gigli, Lanza, Caruso.
Belíssima música na voz de Plácido Domingo..
Cuantas veces debemos decirlo , Domingo es un tenor inmenso , pero una de sus grandes cualidades es la humildad, cada vez que se a referido a Lanza , lo ha hecho con respeto y mucha admiración, lo que Domingo logro con muchísimos anos de sacrificio con su voz, Lanza solo tuvo que abrir su inigualable garganta y cantar, esta como muchas otras piezas pertenecen a el gran Mario Lanza y Placido lo sabe.
Oh yes....I'll be your love Mr. Domingo. 😍
❤❤❤
quien diga que placido lo hace mejor pregúntenle al mismo Placido y Villazon y carreras a quien admiran , por supuesto a Lanza.
Dolce voce❤
placido domingos maravilhosooooooo
placido je. t'aime depuis toujours,ta voix est un enchantement pour mes oreilles .pour moi tu es la VOIX.
Placido Domningo cnante très bien
Nadie debe quitarle el poderio a Mario Lanza, pero como Domingo van a tardar años y años, en salir una voz con el poderio de la suya, es únicol, y una persona tan abierta y dispuesta a compartir cancion con cualquier artista solo hace falta ver si historial, en fin un ser excepcional.
Lamentablemente colega no entiendo vuestro comentario ;Lanza o Domingo?
mariol la fin il monte plus haut ...la bombe de tout les temps
Amazing orchestra behind him
Eternally 🌹.
The great Lanza, hat im Grab eine Menge zu lachen 😂
I know Domingo is very popular. I find his enunciation blurry and timber uneven. He may be technically sound, but for pure listening enjoyment, Mario Lanza remains the greatest.
Исполнение понравилось, но МАРИО ЛАНЦА лучший исполнитель этой песни.
Великий Марио вне конкуренции. Еще прекрасно пел Карел Готт, мне очень нравится его запись 1974 года.
que madrugadora Yvonne, lo has visto incluso antes que yo. Que tengas un feliz día
Placido, la canta bene, ma Lanza, e migliore, voce più squillante, più chiara. 2 grandi.
Domingo at his best...beautiful
mozart200657 , ???????????????
ESPLENDIDO
Domingo a great tenor but Lanza owns this song, he touches my heart, Domingo doesn't.
Веома лепа песма, а Плесидо Доминго од страних оперских певача, мој је омиљени.
Cómo Mario Lanza no hay otro
bravo!!!
I love and admire Placido Domingo. He has given me much joy. Domingo loves and admires Lanza. But, this performance certainly makes a point. Domingo does not even attempt to better or even equal his childhood idol. There is no comparison at all. None.
No comparison! Lanza sings, mingo barking and stealing money, making a freak popularity.
Grande Placido ❤
If you sing this tune from the bottom of your heart, you don’t need to look at the sheet music, especially as a professional vocalist. I am sure he does not care about this at his age as of 2022.
Būtinai!
Lovely voice but this is Lanza's song
As my Italian grandmother would say "You said a mouthful". There is and will never will be another singer with Mario's talent.
OH placido SI ALGUNA VEZ PUDISTE HACER LA ULTIMA NOTA EN SOBREAGUDO, PERO YA NO NOCON 80 ANOS NO ERES loforese.
@TheIRememberYou
Me alegra que te guste, gracias
Ő A LEGNAGYOBB......MINDENBEN,,,
Super Superissime
Mario Lanza was greater than any of these tenors in my opinion and I am not an expert in opera. However, Mario had a sound that was ethereal and his high notes were hit much more effortlessly than even the great Pavarotti! I haven't heard anyone try the high note at the end as Mario did on some of the recordings of this song!
@@sebastianmelmoth685 - But the great Lanza, can sing „ Be my Love „ Domingo cannot 😫
Be my love..
Super regalito Pilar! Absolutamente precioso!
Cecilia Opitz , yes negative preciouso.
I love this performance. In which auditorium or venue was was he performing it, please.
Some people like this singer and some like another. But there are objective standards that can be used in comparisons.
Domingo ends the song on a G. Lanza sings a High C.
Mr. Lanza was half his age.
@@ursmue1937 ja pavarotti fand ich auch besser als Domingo also mein Lieblings Sänger war mario lanza weil er vielseitig war er konnte sogar normale Lieder singen wie come prima aber auch echte Klassiker und sein Gefühl und seine Power von einer anderen Welt aber das Alter mit rein zunehmen ist lächerlich genau wie Interpretation von Domingo finde kein Gefühl keine Kraft da war Luciano schon ne andere Klasse obwohl ich Domingo eig gerne höre
You know very well Domingo struggle with high notes but who cares , he is still the best when it comes to technique
@@Sacha_Kudli - The greatest technique, does not make a beautiful voice 😛.
@@sebastianmelmoth685 - You were born stupid, and haven’t learned anything. See Pappano on Lanza and keep your wicked mouth shut 🤐.
mis respetos por Domingo pero por favor porque nunca , nunca , nunca la nota final la trata , aunque sea trata de cantarla medianamente como Lanza....!No puede!
Koks balso skambesys ir nuosirdumas!
eccellente!!!
@mozart200657
Realmente es hermosa la canción y más aún la voz de Placido
Placido Domingo insuperabile
ESCUCHAR MARIO LANZA...
@gudinomarina
Sí, realmente Placido está esplendido y la canción es preciosa, muchas gracias
Placido is a pale imitation of Mario. And what is this apparent having to read the lyrics while singing? Mario hits high notes that Placido is apparently not capable of reaching. And Mario could also sing as well as any baritone. His range was unbelievable and he was an excellent actor too. God Bless Mario. This would have been the year of his 100th birthday.
i DON'T BELIEVE any tenor but Mario Lanza sang this song extremely well. The accent and strangulated squeezing sound here does not do it for me. I'm not crazy about the song in the first place, but Lanza truly stands alone in this song.
Lanza was half his age.
Sebastian Melmoth aber Du bist doppelt so blöde.
Superb voice but sadly put no emotion in it
Vastly inferior to Mario Lanza
@mtmorrispk
Muchas gracias
thrilling!
Though I very much enjoy the singing of Mr. Domingo, I feel it is unwise to sing a song which has high notes which not are hit as originally written. Especially if you are performing a classic of Mr. Lanza. It is quite the let-down. I have sung this gem on occasion(as written) and will never perform it live unless I am in good voice to hit those passionate notes in a fat sound.
+Arythmnmaker1 thanks for sharing--do you mean Mr D. is not hitting the high notes? He is a spinto not a lyric like Lanza---transposed them?? come to santa fe and sing for us!!
+windstorm1000
Yes, I mean to say, that though he was capable, he chose to transpose ---- on a ' CLASSIC ' of Mr. LANZA. My Feeling is, that there are those pieces not to take artist
ic liberty I believe others here have made comments which concur with my perspective. I am not sure I understand your point regarding lyric and spinto. Many years ago I had the great fortune to meet Maestro Marcopoulus; spinto operatic tenor, when he was 65, who still performed this masterpiece as originally composed. Amazingly he could create a ringing high ' C ' at will and without to much fuss warming-up. He always praised his Italian teacher.
Some artists are human cash registers.
Not even close. Not an altogether bad performance. However, key things missing. One, the passion. Two, failure to hit the high notes at the climactic moment of the piece. The man is skilled, of that there is not doubt. However, if you want to hear this piece sung as it should be, listen to Mario Lanza sing it.
@ArredondoMD
Gracias a ti
no high C?
He can not step out of Mario Lanza's shadow.
He is not standing in Lanza's shadow. He is in a league of his own. He is real opera singer and not a little operetta tenor - a huge spinto voice able to sustain his abilities throughout an entire opera. He TOWERS over Lanza. Hyperion to a satyr. Of course this little ditty does not suit his voice. He is not a ditty-singer.
Sebastian Melmoth , Ja ja, blos der riesige Operntenor hat es nicht gekonnt, wie Jeder Andere zuvor auch nicht. Wo sind denn die ganzen hohen C ? Vom Winde verweht. Sehen Sie Pappano on Lanza, oder P.Domingo Tribut für Lanza, usw. Lustig kleines Stimmchen, schlägt riesige Opernstimme. Nebenbei, ich mag Domingo.
Nadie canta esta canción como Lanza, ni Bjorling ni Caruso.
He can not step out of Mario Lanza's shadow.
Escuchate esta version en la que el cantante no grita
lo digo en español que casi ya domIno, ¿Que Lanza esta nervioso, fumando del otro lado?, es sin lugar a dudas el mas estúpido e insulso comentario que un ser vivo haya pronunciado.
Solamente mis felicitaciones al gran tenor de todos los tiempos Plácido domingo
Placido kicks some Pavoratti ass
А Паваротти лучше. Простите,простите меня поклонники Доминго