I know this pack is supposed to be about helping the environment and whatnot, but a part of me wishes they threw in a trait like "Loves Smog" or "Hates Hippies" or something equally as ridiculous for all those players who want to be evil anti-environmentalists.
Yeah as it is it seems like it blames people in "Industrial" areas for causing their own pollution, when those communities are usually PoC whose neighborhoods are polluted bc of being underrepresented for so many years. The idea that the environment is neighborhood centric and BECAUSE of the people in those neighborhoods is so messed up
Definitely agree on the windmills point. They should cost more like $5,000. Or maybe even make them really espensive and then you pay them off in your bills.
Does it come with real windmills? Google translate (a building with sails or vanes that turn in the wind and generate power to grind grain into flour.) Or is that the white wind-things that produces green electricity? I really wanted that one that can produce flour. But I guess it goes better with farming.
I wish they would add a casino and a compulsive gambler trait so we can have somewhere to waste our money and for sims to have a reason to argue with their family member for losing the family fortune! I also wish the whole house would burn to the ground and you take the insurance money to build new.
Totally agree about the cost of windmills and solar panels. It’s like they want people to be able to create a new Sim and instantly explore the new eco gameplay (of which there is basically none - don’t get me started on how much this pack angers me). I understand why they want to do that but IRL people don’t generally live 100% ‘eco’ lifestyles unless they either have a lot of money to throw at expensive things like solar panels or are willing to sacrifice worldly possessions to live completely off the grid. So it’s unrealistic.
Besides building which is essentially the core feature it seems, the only eco gameplay your sims have is convincing people and voting so the lot changes. It’s definitely a pack geared towards UA-camrs imo. One thing I found really, really weird about the free updates is the inventory system. I remember that about a year after the game came out people were complaining and asking for a fix ‘cause it really was a pain when you had a sim with lots of items... and it took them this long to implement it :/ sometimes I think the sims team is either real tiny or EA be really pulling the strings.
I don't like how seemingly easy it is to change the environment. I saw part 1 of a Let's Play and a few days of dumpster diving and a community vote turned the neighborhood from industrial to neutral. Available votes are generated by saying "Hi" to a lot of people... No relationships required. The vote wasn't even concerning the free lot! 😅
Meaningful interactions between sims is what I miss in TS4. Sure there are many "dicussion topics", but what's the real difference between "talk about interests" and "complain about weather", for example? It's basically just a different text label for the same talking animation with maybe slightly different relationship boosts, but it doesn't FEEL different. In TS2, talking about interests actually increased a sim's interest and they would start talking about that interest independently (with different animations for different interests). And don't get me started on interactions like games and dancing! Slow-dancing, dancing together face-to-face, games like "red hands" and "mary mack", playing cops and robbers... holding hands across the table, cuddling in bed... you know, actual interactions between sims! In TS4 every sim feels isolated from the others, no matter how much they interact, because their interactions are so independent. It's good for multitasking, but it makes them feel so separate, like they're not really interacting at all, just every sim playing its own little animation, trapped in their own little bubble. What I want is holding hands while walking, slow dancing, adults helping toddlers learning to walk, children playing active games outside! What we get is... dumpster woohoo.
I'm still perplexed as to why my sims can't kiss the person they're dating goodbye when they could in previous games. You just ask them to leave as if they mean nothing to you. Even the animation is like gtfo.
Shinojeru shi0nch what the heck is this guy going to do if you keep telling this idea of yours to be added to the game, just go to the sims offical page in twitter or one of the gurus profile and start complaining and whining there and maybe they will add this like you said because here no one will listen to you.
@@ThatDawg21 I hate the only option is "ask to leave"- that was only the unfriendly way to say goodbye before. It was great in the other games seeing the gradual difference between goodbye between acquaintances, between friends where they'd hug and between romantic interests where they'd kiss.
You're absolutely right Carl, there's not a lot of stuff we can do with huge sums of money (well except paying child support). Kinda makes it boring that we'd earn so much money just to pay $850 for a solar panel. Even if we get cars later, I bet they'd make it like max a $1000. But I'm counting on bills to go over the roof though.
@@ourevilone I was just thinking of how this pack will combine with tiny living to make some of the easiest rags to riches gameplay ever, which is super disappointing to me. We definitely don't need this game to be any easier.
I like this pack better than I did, but it's missing the negative aspects. This would have been a perfect pack for the Burglar to come back. Or some kind of sinister side story.
I know the gameplay is right up my alley! If only it wasn't so one-sided. 😕 Also after the way EA has neglected the sims community Im not giving them any (more) if my money either.
@@RosheenQuynh It's sup[posed to be a deprived post-industrial neighbourhood. At least before the crunchies & hipsters move in and price everyone out their homes. It would have an increased crime rate.
@@peppermintbutler8205 I knew something was missing! I remember looking at my tasks for an occupation I hadn't used in awhile and wondered what mood I needed to be in again. I thought I had imagined it. They really don't need to make this game any easier. 😅
Man I feel like this is the next big thing they need to fix! It would def be a lot of work on their end but would change the game so much for the better!
Yeah, this has been a common complaint since the beginning of Sims 4's launch; that it was way too easy to amass huge sums of money way too quickly. They really need to make it more challenging to obtain a large home with high-end items, at the moment it doesn't feel very rewarding compared to previous titles.
Thank you so much for making this video because I personally didn't want to watch the entire stream and just wanted a simplified version of it only covering what's important.
This is still on a gameplay pack level, not expansion pack level. Theory: they made the trailers shallow on purpose so they could show more things on livestream so people think they actually get something that‘s worth 40 $. Thank you for the overview and your honesty, Carl, it‘s much appreciated!
It's not tho we have never gotten a game pack with this much depth and options. I feel like they tried with this pack and I'm actually very excited to buy it cuz I literally only play off the grid
Honestly tho, the best part about your channel is that you don't do what other annoying youtubers do and say "don't forget to like and subscribe" before you even say anything of substance in the video. As long as you stay humble, honest and unfiltered like this, I'll keep coming back to your videos for a long time
I enjoy your summaries so much. They are funny, to the point and relateable. Thank you for having kind of more "analytical" view. It is very refreshing and enjoyable. I don't need another "ooohh I really love that hair"-simmer.
why did I read that last part in a certain person’s voice? ya we all know. But in general I think there’s space for all and I enjoy Carl’s approach a lot.
@@melz6625 I totally agree. I like to watch those simmers too. But they are sometimes just too similar to one another so it can get boring. That's why I'am actually happy to have found this channel. The videos are so good in a different way and so well thought through. Who else can't understand why he hasn't Millions of subs yet :)
@@ElenMira While Carl's website, carls-sims-4-guide.com, has been a great resource since Sims 3, Carl's YT channel is only a year old. Give it time. Many people who consult his site frequently for game info, aren't aware yet that he has a channel here. :)
Carl: "I won't linger here because I wear T-shirts and polos, and nothing else..." Um, you said nothing about pants! 😂 On another note, THANK YOU for mentioning that there is a person that wants to make the neighborhood more industrial. This is absolutely my first time hearing of it (since I didn't watch the livestream) even though I have watched other Game Changers' videos.
This expack would just make me want to do it out of spite for the hipster bullcrap overload in this and past expansions, and how...stereotypically and one-sided...all this is presented. Some of the features look really nice, but I just don't want a smug mechanic in my Sims game.
It kind of sucks the expansion packs are almost always limited to one particular world. In The Sims 3, most big changes like ocean swimming, supernatural creatures or house boats weren't limited to one world. You could use them / add them to any world. It makes expansions feel very stand alone and not as if you were added more and more layers to the game.
jfb 7920 but not the community upgrades. Besides once you do something once in the sims 4 , like the upgrades or makers career, players would never revisit it since its the same thing every time. In the other games it was fun to add in other features into a previous world or pack because it was new and exciting. The only sims 4 pack that has this effect is seasons.
The purple penguin I wish the smog was thicker and had a stronger effect. I would love it to have a proper haze effect that makes the sims sick and actually makes it worth it to want to live in an eco-friendly town. Regarding the idea of trash and not being everywhere, there is a landfill lot trait that can be placed on various lots to get a trashy neigbourhood in other towns
@@aturchomicz821 definitely not for me. From what I understand there won't be trash in the streets, there won't be crappy versions of non-playable buildings in the set dressing, it sounds like it's literally just smog and coughing sims. I was actually considering spending $40 on this if they had implemented the trash and different buildings in the rest of the main worlds, but I'm definitely not spending $40 just for the smog and hacking sims. The gameplay in the new world doesn't interest me. I'm only interested in the CAS, build items, and what I thought was going to be a small reworking of the other worlds to give them a totally run down and trash filled look. So, I'm back to waiting for a sale.
I think the 'fizzy juice' is kombucha :D. I make kombucha with fruit I grow in my garden in real life and it's actually very tasty! Now, that being said... Even though I am the person this expansion portrays (I take stuff from the dumpster to restore and repurpose it, I grow food, craft, make kombucha, am an activist, live an eco lifestyle in general) I don't really see the appeal in this one BECAUSE I do that in real life. I want TS4 to give me experiences I cannot have in real life. Doing the same stuff I do IRL seems boring to me. I guess that's why I love all the fantasy stuff.
I might be in the minority here but I wasn’t too thrilled about the overhaul of gardening with seasons. I liked the grind of gardening. I feel like they made it too easy and now it looks like they did it again with this pack. I have a garden and because it’s so easy to maintain, I actually forget I have it there.
I also dislike the overhaul of the gardening skill with Seasons. I loved the gardening skill until that happened. Every Sim I played had a garden, now I just don't bother and buy what I need form the CL vendors or PC seed packets.
Playalot that’s exactly how I was. They took the joy out of finally getting that spliced plant. Now you can just get the actual seed from a festival, through the phone or rare seed packets. They also don’t produce 10 per harvest any more. I believe it’s down to 5 now. What I did like was the new evolve aspect but that’s about it.
@@LeticiaSPandaMcfly6 Some plants only give one (rare) and others 4 etc so yes, I dislike the lower rate of harvestables on each plant too. Disabling Seasons helps a little but it really was the pre-patch update that killed it for me. tbh I don't think I've spliced a plant since the update either. So it's a definite 'no' from me! :) It some ways I like that you can evolve a plant from a distance but that also feels a bit too easy as well.
Playalot I’m with you 100% on everything you mentioned! It was a bit overkill. Hopefully they make stuff more challenging in the game for however long they decide to keep going with this iteration.
My biggest issue with gardening is before it was based on actual time passing on the lot you were at. Now it’s 5 AM always, so if you play a lot but leave it to play another at 4, you never get the harvestables from all of that gameplay. Visiting a community lot at 5 AM? Nothing to harvest until the next day. I hate that. Never ever getting 10 also is dumb. I wish the gardening hadn’t been messed with in a patch. The meat wall cracks me though. And I might be as excited as Carl for the inventory sort.
I really love what they are doing with this pack/patch, but theres some things that i feel need to be said As much as this free patch and pack is definitely better than we initially believed, it still does not address core issues in the game. Like deep personalites of sims and day to day activities that bolster who are sims are and how they interact with their household. The patch is a good addition, and the pack adds a lot to the communities but revamps to the sims personalities, hobbies, love loves is very much needed. A generations pack is desperately needed as well. Good on Maxis, but we have some ways to go.
@@namaste_charlei weve already known that. The studio was shut down after they finished most of the sims 3 and the creator left. Ea reinstated the studio to make the rest of the sims 3 dlc and work on the sims 4 Its not the same people
@@christopherdelacruz9728 I iterate this because there are a lot of people that still think Maxis exists. Many will deny that Maxis is gone. The spirit of it definitely is no longer there.
Does it make me a bad person if I don’t want to care about the environment in a game? *conflicted face*. Ps! I think that juice is supposed to be kombucha 🤮
I don't think so. I already try to care about the environment and all in real life; I really don't want to play it in a game, too. It's too overwhelming when I have to deal with it in a game I'm playing to escape that whole thing for a while.
BooDotBoo you can turn it off, or not buy the pack.... I look forward to playing passively as well as actively. Like I wanna just play my sims like normal and see how it affects the world. I appreciate that gameplay affects the world around you
Thank you for that summary! I have to say the live stream made me understand why it’s an expansion and not a game pack. This whole idea is not my cup of tea (which is totally fine) but I am happy that this can be integrated in day to day gameplay - if you like playing environmentally conscious. It still feels like this pack “fixes” things that are already in game, but I guess it’s better to have off-the-Grid being fixed in a pack than not at all?! I might pick this up when it’s on sale for the new world and the new hobbies.
16:01 poor Thomas J indeed. Thanks for that My Girl reference, i appreciate it as much as I do your sims content. Great and wonderfully witty breakdown of the livestream, Carl. Thank you
I think the updates are great and it looks like this expansion pack has more to offer than what we could see in the trailer. But...6 years until we got some of these updates?
Exactly my gripe about it. These changes coming in the patch should have been included in base game from day 1! And here we all are, losing our minds with excitement that EA has granted us these great boons. It's like we all have Stockholm Syndrome and we're fawning over EA tossing us tiny scraps. It makes me feel so conflicted. I'm like Grrrrrrr... OH THANK YOU MASTER... but grrrrrrr.
😭😭😭😭😭 I want garbage to appear in the old basegame desert world. And I want candle making to be a separate skill. I want us to be able to combine different ingredients in the fizzy maker. I want to create my own NAP. I want to swim in that marble space water. I want a compost bin. I want to be able to get real parts from recycled stuff, like wood or metal or fabric, together with the bits and pieces, and that they are needed as ingredients to the stuff we can fabricate. I want to be able to fabricate stuff with bits and pieces (and mentioned ingredients) on the children creativity table, like smaller things kids can create. I want the new freelancer career to also include flower arrangements, knitting. I want a food freelancer career too, like the same but with different meals. 😁 I want it to cost money to travel to other cities/worlds.
Yes. This is the sort of gameplay I'd pay $40 for. This would make it an expansion pack in my eyes. I started to forget why I was so disappointed in this pack after watching so many other UA-camrs talk about how much they love the new hairs, or the build items. And yeah, that's fine, I think they look great, too! But they either get the packs for free, or it's a business expense for them. I have my own business expenses that don't involve buying sims games. I have my own family to take care of, and spending $40 for this pack as is just seems out of the question for me. You totally put this into perspective! There's so much missed potential here!! I'm sorry, I'll stop ranting now! 😬 I just miss the love I used to have for this game 😔
Give the modders time after the expansion comes out. I'm sure some of these things will exist. How sad is it that the modding community is so necessary to make an expensive game like this play the way it should? Also I've had candle making in my game for years. Thanks icemunmun. :)
@@HughLlewellyn I always play modded game so I know the possibilities, I have even created some small mods myself, but I think it's sad that it's not there in the game from the beginning.
You are a legend in the sims community along side a few others you are the person I normally get all my sims info from so yeah you deserve everything good that has/will happen.
From what I've seen in the livestream and other Game Changer videos, this pack just looks like a building pack to me... :/ Like it feels like this pack is aimed more towards the builders in this community tbh.. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing.. There's a lot of cool Build&Buy items in this pack. I'm sure lot of people can use to these items to build all types of lots. However, for someone like me who isn't a builder, I'm personally having a hard time finding the value in this pack.. I don't see a lot of gameplay and stuff to do in live mode, you know? And the items that do offer some gameplay, I just see myself using them once and then never touching them again. It would've been great if they added more skills and traits (especially negative ones) in this pack or something idk.. I want to love this pack, I really do, but the more things I see from this pack the more I don't want it. Like I'm more excited for the patch update than I am for this pack.. :( Anyways, thank you for the video! I like how you made even a summary video entertaining to watch!
SOOOOOO... Is there anything to do in this pack? It seems most of the features are just aesthetic and like adding a different coat of paint to the same ol' game...
The first pack I know for sure I'm not gonna buy. Environmentalism is a good thing - irl. In a game? No thanks, I play for the things I can't do irl, like having alien babies or whatever. We coulda worked as the Grim Reaper, and this is what we got? Insane.
Yeah totaly. If they want to do more realistic things, then this is also not the way to do it. I feel like they don't know what environmentalism entails at all.
This pack still feels like they’re wanting people to pay for a PSA on saving the environment. Like I don’t want to buy a pack where the main concept is Sims asking if I want to hear about the environment.
Yeah, I'm generally environmentally friendly in real life and I'm turned off by the fact they're only letting you play as a hippie. They could have at least done a "polluter" trait that hated eco friendly stuff instead of the samey Recyler and Eco Friendly traits (I heard 4 traits in another summary)
I'm definitely gonna wait for a sale on this one. There's certainly some gameplay stuff that interests me, but there's also a lot of stuff I don't really care about. And I'm also someone who spends a lot of time and effort in both cas and build/buy, and most of the items coming with this pack aren't things I see myself using. Much as I'd love those piercings right away... I'll restrain myself until it's at least 50% off
I know right! My family is paying $7000 for a 2 bedroom house. It's not all bad because the mother is an author and makes great money. But the bill system as it is doesn't make any sense (to me)
Lady Yana Number 1 For now it goes by how espensive items you have in the house. I got tired of living in my own sim house and lived in the city where rent stay the same and does not go up
Not having trashy neighborhoods other than the expansion neighborhood is a really big letdown. I got super excited thinking that there were going to be noticeable visual changes in the other neighborhoods. Especially because the expansions that I tend to buy are expansions that have gameplay changes that affect the game as a whole rather than something more specific. Now, I'm not really sure if I want to pick this up right away or just wait. Thanks for this video though, Carl. Very informative!
Well I am a console player I am NOT a fan of that new feature. I've learned my controls, they are not that hard. I don't need them poping up the control reminders like I'm some noob. It's insulting really. If you need the controls you pressed down on the left joy stick the controls are there. This really upsets me. I don't need more crap popping up on my screen. Who asked for this?!
My complaint is unwarranted. You can turn that crap off in the game menu options. HUZZAH for the patch! Also if you're on console look for a few BIG sales, I got Get Together for 50%!
I'm a console player as well! Tomorrow is actually my birthday, and I'm quite disappointed that THIS is the pack that comes out on my birthday lol but I'll definitely check out the sales and maybe just get a different one(or two, depending on the sale lol) as my bday present to myself lol
Combining SimCity with The Sims is what it sounds like to me. I love this idea. I look forward to you playing one of your vampires a week after release
Thanks Carl! I love your videos , tutorials, ect.! I had to Edit when you started talking about the meat! I am literally crying because I'm laughing so hard! ✌❤🙏
I never know when the live stream is and probably watch the VOD later. I look forward to the videos like this (that you make) that cut down the fluff and give the info we (or I) want
The Hydroponic rack reminds me of the Sims 2's Slacker Career reward. It was weird back then, because even if it was a reward for the SLACKER career, the plants in it would still die of neglect.
I love your videos. You say what I think but no one else says. And you make me laugh. I'm not interested in the gameplay aspect of this pack. I find it boring. But I thought I might buy it for the CAS and Build items. Nope. All the furniture and clothes are from the "rags" part of rags to riches. They could have thrown in a few nice items for those who aren't into the rags lifestyle. Not enough difference between the new traits and aspirations either. This expansion will be the first one I've passed on since I started playing Sims.
I’m really glad they didn’t add nectar making in this pack like I heard some people say they were doing. I’m not sure if we’ll even get nectar making back since we got this fizzy drink stuff, but I’d really like to see it return in a pack that makes sense for it to be in. Hopefully we can get another world like champs les sims in a game pack or something with nectar making.
Tbh as someone who doesn't care about the environment all that much, I am looking forward to pretending I do in a game lol. This pack is definitely a hit or miss but for those that are into it this pack will be a lot of fun.
Could not agree more. It’s so shallow, yet after the livestream so many commenters were like, ‘Wow! The trailers didn’t do this justice! There’s so much here!’ I was like, ‘What were you watching?!’ Half of the two hour stream was spent in CAS or Build/Buy and then they managed to show literally EVERYTHING else that the pack includes in the other hour! One hour’s worth of new gameplay does not an expansion make!
@@HerHollyness they always do that in their livestreams though, apparently alot of people out there care about either build/buy or CAS. I disagree with both of you actually, so far from what ive seen from the base game updates to all the new crafting stuff it seems like a rags to riches player's dream.
@@HerHollyness I'm kinda used to Sims 4 fans getting hyped and trying to hype others up and then feeling disappointed when there's nothing to do after 2-3 hours of playing. Sims 4 packs are *EXTREMELY* shallow. They're mostly rehashed animations, recycled mechanics, poorly implemented mechanics, non-existent difficulty/challenge, shallow traits, etc. It's always the same, year after year after year. It's been almost *SIX* years since The Sims 4 was released and people are celebrating because they're finally adding fire fighters (a base game feature in Sims 1, 2 and 3). I'm just so over The Sims 4 at this point. Hopefully, Paralives and the game Rod Humble is working on for Paradox (we don't know if it's a life sim yet) will bring some needed fresh air to this dying genre.
@@shadybrain3424 I play rags to riches nearly every time these days. But it's mostly because I feel the game is far too easy otherwise. The features of this pack certainly fit the theme of rags to riches, but I'm not sure it will increase the difficulty of that style of play. In fact, it looks like it will be even easier to start with no money and make a fortune. And that's already very simple to do, so I was hoping any new developments on that front would make it a bit harder to acquire easy wealth.
if fizzy lifting drinks isn't an easter egg i'll be surprised. hopefully the power and water bills will be much higher than we expect, after all if we do gardening, washing and science stuff in our houses for example thats alot of power and water! throw in pet baths, hot day sprinklers, saunas and winterfest (christmas) light decorations those bills will hopefully shoot up... hopefully. though the materials thing does sound pretty interesting, i wonder if they will have an impact on energy usage along side seasons? i mean they'v hinted at alot of cross pack interactions what with degrees influencing stuff, power, skill objects like the rocket and such all doing environmental stuff so defo willing to dip toes into this one and see how deep it goes
Thank you for making this video. It really helped to put what they are offering into perspective. I'm kind of glad the other neighborhoods won't be trashy! And I love the "meat" wall.
After the trailer got slaughtered the gurus did a good job in trying to show that the pack isn't literal garbage. And they also get a polite golf clap for having a ladder that will be added to the base game for those who'll skip the pack but still have a ladder to use.
@@CarlsSimGuides Besides the ladder the bill and utilities features are supposed to be coming with the patch but if SimGuruGeorge or Jill tweeted anything about the fireman coming to I haven't seen it.
rewatching this for a little challenge i'm doing & i do love your little jabs. "which i am calling a nap...which is what i wanted to take when he went into CAS" LOL
Come to think of it werewolves would fit just right with hippies. Material hunting, living off the land, dressing like you live in the woods. It would just be a vampire with body hair and better animations, why didnt EA think of that
The absolute best thing about the first time I watched this video was right in the middle of your delighted announcement of the inventory changes, you said "I am genuinely excited about this..." and it cut to a bra ad with a closeup shot of a woman's chest. 🤣
I think it’s fair that you can’t just fully trash other worlds. That would probably involve A LOT of work and basically rebuilding every other world.... I do like this pack. It still feels like a true expansion and I like the extra challenge to take care of the environment on top of regular gameplay...
I think he is? He thanked EA Game Changers for early access to the upcoming patch in the beginning of his last video. Does that include the pack? Maybe.
Carl is a Game Changer and has been for a very long time due to his Guides on both TS3 and TS4. He gets early access to all packs to give him a day or two to write the guides so they are up before the packs go live.
i wonder who voted for this pack luckily its an option to buy =) thought tho why is there baths and not showers and dumpster diving sounds really disgusting and dangerous
How are you NOT a Game Changer with your Origin ID bouncing around an early-access copy of Eco Lifestyle?!! You ARE the PRIME SOURCE of all Sims information. I've been consulting Carl's Guides since Sims 3! When you google "sims 4 'fill in the blank' ", your guides are often the 1st result. You ARE a game changer in every sense of the word. My game wouldn't be what it is without your guidance. Seriously EA, wtf? Thank you Carl, for all you do. About the pack... I'm VERY excited about the patch. The expansion... I'm still meh. Part of me thinks I need meat wall jerky in my life. Maybe I'll get it eventually. Or not. :D
Fregans are a different thing- they are real people that like to dumpster dive and will reuse things they find there including eating food that appears to still be good. They're not as big as they used to be- they were a phenomenon maybe 10 years ago
I know this pack is supposed to be about helping the environment and whatnot, but a part of me wishes they threw in a trait like "Loves Smog" or "Hates Hippies" or something equally as ridiculous for all those players who want to be evil anti-environmentalists.
It'd be cool if Evil Sims got a buff. If nothing else, they might react positively to other Sims coughing.
I'm here for punching hippies.
@Onion Face /s ?
Yeah it's definitely very one-sided in terms of what kind of sim they clearly want you to play...
Yeah as it is it seems like it blames people in "Industrial" areas for causing their own pollution, when those communities are usually PoC whose neighborhoods are polluted bc of being underrepresented for so many years. The idea that the environment is neighborhood centric and BECAUSE of the people in those neighborhoods is so messed up
Definitely agree on the windmills point. They should cost more like $5,000. Or maybe even make them really espensive and then you pay them off in your bills.
your profile icon 😍
Does it come with real windmills?
Google translate (a building with sails or vanes that turn in the wind and generate power to grind grain into flour.)
Or is that the white wind-things that produces green electricity?
I really wanted that one that can produce flour. But I guess it goes better with farming.
@@linneahulten405 They're for producing energy. I think they're actually called wind turbines (in real life they are)
I wish they would add a casino and a compulsive gambler trait so we can have somewhere to waste our money and for sims to have a reason to argue with their family member for losing the family fortune! I also wish the whole house would burn to the ground and you take the insurance money to build new.
Sorry but thats Pegi 16 Babey! 😎
@@aturchomicz821 Guess you didn't see the Casino stuff in The Sims 3? Fire has been in the game since The Sims 1.
That is such a good idea!
And insurance should be an added expense, which you can take or ignore.
EA is too busy putting real gambling into their games to worry about casinos in the Sims.
Totally agree about the cost of windmills and solar panels. It’s like they want people to be able to create a new Sim and instantly explore the new eco gameplay (of which there is basically none - don’t get me started on how much this pack angers me). I understand why they want to do that but IRL people don’t generally live 100% ‘eco’ lifestyles unless they either have a lot of money to throw at expensive things like solar panels or are willing to sacrifice worldly possessions to live completely off the grid. So it’s unrealistic.
I’d actually love to hear what angers you about the pack (no sarcasm), so please share!
'So it's unrealistic'. Yes, it's a game....
Besides building which is essentially the core feature it seems, the only eco gameplay your sims have is convincing people and voting so the lot changes. It’s definitely a pack geared towards UA-camrs imo.
One thing I found really, really weird about the free updates is the inventory system. I remember that about a year after the game came out people were complaining and asking for a fix ‘cause it really was a pain when you had a sim with lots of items... and it took them this long to implement it :/ sometimes I think the sims team is either real tiny or EA be really pulling the strings.
@@gaytheil it is a game that is a LIFE simulator though..
I don't like how seemingly easy it is to change the environment. I saw part 1 of a Let's Play and a few days of dumpster diving and a community vote turned the neighborhood from industrial to neutral. Available votes are generated by saying "Hi" to a lot of people... No relationships required. The vote wasn't even concerning the free lot! 😅
Meaningful interactions between sims is what I miss in TS4. Sure there are many "dicussion topics", but what's the real difference between "talk about interests" and "complain about weather", for example? It's basically just a different text label for the same talking animation with maybe slightly different relationship boosts, but it doesn't FEEL different. In TS2, talking about interests actually increased a sim's interest and they would start talking about that interest independently (with different animations for different interests). And don't get me started on interactions like games and dancing! Slow-dancing, dancing together face-to-face, games like "red hands" and "mary mack", playing cops and robbers... holding hands across the table, cuddling in bed... you know, actual interactions between sims! In TS4 every sim feels isolated from the others, no matter how much they interact, because their interactions are so independent. It's good for multitasking, but it makes them feel so separate, like they're not really interacting at all, just every sim playing its own little animation, trapped in their own little bubble.
What I want is holding hands while walking, slow dancing, adults helping toddlers learning to walk, children playing active games outside!
What we get is... dumpster woohoo.
I'm still perplexed as to why my sims can't kiss the person they're dating goodbye when they could in previous games. You just ask them to leave as if they mean nothing to you. Even the animation is like gtfo.
Shinojeru shi0nch what the heck is this guy going to do if you keep telling this idea of yours to be added to the game, just go to the sims offical page in twitter or one of the gurus profile and start complaining and whining there and maybe they will add this like you said because here no one will listen to you.
@@ThatDawg21 I hate the only option is "ask to leave"- that was only the unfriendly way to say goodbye before. It was great in the other games seeing the gradual difference between goodbye between acquaintances, between friends where they'd hug and between romantic interests where they'd kiss.
@@moudahaddad1484 how about shut up.
You're absolutely right Carl, there's not a lot of stuff we can do with huge sums of money (well except paying child support). Kinda makes it boring that we'd earn so much money just to pay $850 for a solar panel. Even if we get cars later, I bet they'd make it like max a $1000.
But I'm counting on bills to go over the roof though.
This is why im so baffled why the game needed tiny living with so many perks. I dont know why i would want to make this game even easier.
@@ourevilone I was just thinking of how this pack will combine with tiny living to make some of the easiest rags to riches gameplay ever, which is super disappointing to me. We definitely don't need this game to be any easier.
I like this pack better than I did, but it's missing the negative aspects. This would have been a perfect pack for the Burglar to come back. Or some kind of sinister side story.
I know the gameplay is right up my alley! If only it wasn't so one-sided. 😕
Also after the way EA has neglected the sims community Im not giving them any (more) if my money either.
How would a burglar have anything to do with eco lifestyle?
The repo man is I'm the update
@@RosheenQuynh It's sup[posed to be a deprived post-industrial neighbourhood. At least before the crunchies & hipsters move in and price everyone out their homes. It would have an increased crime rate.
@@RosheenQuynh bad industrial areas are more prone to crime/ burglar... that could've worked
I honestly feel like the game would be better if they rebalanced jobs, money and item expenses
I kinda hate that they removed ideal mood for jobs, before you kinda have prep your sims' mood before they go to work.
@@peppermintbutler8205 yeah! They keep trying to make the game easier but it just ends up boring
@@peppermintbutler8205 I knew something was missing! I remember looking at my tasks for an occupation I hadn't used in awhile and wondered what mood I needed to be in again. I thought I had imagined it. They really don't need to make this game any easier. 😅
Man I feel like this is the next big thing they need to fix! It would def be a lot of work on their end but would change the game so much for the better!
Yeah, this has been a common complaint since the beginning of Sims 4's launch; that it was way too easy to amass huge sums of money way too quickly. They really need to make it more challenging to obtain a large home with high-end items, at the moment it doesn't feel very rewarding compared to previous titles.
Thank you so much for making this video because I personally didn't want to watch the entire stream and just wanted a simplified version of it only covering what's important.
You make the best summaries Carl!
I want someone to love me the way Carl loves the inventory update.
This is still on a gameplay pack level, not expansion pack level. Theory: they made the trailers shallow on purpose so they could show more things on livestream so people think they actually get something that‘s worth 40 $. Thank you for the overview and your honesty, Carl, it‘s much appreciated!
Wouldn’t be surprised if your theory was true.
It's not tho we have never gotten a game pack with this much depth and options. I feel like they tried with this pack and I'm actually very excited to buy it cuz I literally only play off the grid
Honestly tho, the best part about your channel is that you don't do what other annoying youtubers do and say "don't forget to like and subscribe" before you even say anything of substance in the video. As long as you stay humble, honest and unfiltered like this, I'll keep coming back to your videos for a long time
The way you laughed at the meat made me laugh so hard I cried
Christina K same 😭
🤣😭😂
I saw your comment first and when I heard it I still cackled 😂😂
While watching the livestream I saw one of the loading screens said 'No, I don't want free earbuds' and I thought of you. Great video, as always!
I enjoy your summaries so much.
They are funny, to the point and relateable.
Thank you for having kind of more "analytical" view. It is very refreshing and enjoyable. I don't need another "ooohh I really love that hair"-simmer.
Same! 👍🏾
why did I read that last part in a certain person’s voice? ya we all know. But in general I think there’s space for all and I enjoy Carl’s approach a lot.
@@melz6625 I totally agree. I like to watch those simmers too.
But they are sometimes just too similar to one another so it can get boring.
That's why I'am actually happy to have found this channel. The videos are so good in a different way and so well thought through. Who else can't understand why he hasn't Millions of subs yet :)
@@ElenMira While Carl's website, carls-sims-4-guide.com, has been a great resource since Sims 3, Carl's YT channel is only a year old. Give it time. Many people who consult his site frequently for game info, aren't aware yet that he has a channel here. :)
@@HughLlewellyn Thank you. I didn't know the channel is so young. :-)
Carl: "I won't linger here because I wear T-shirts and polos, and nothing else..."
Um, you said nothing about pants! 😂
On another note, THANK YOU for mentioning that there is a person that wants to make the neighborhood more industrial. This is absolutely my first time hearing of it (since I didn't watch the livestream) even though I have watched other Game Changers' videos.
I think a lot of people do. Strangerville is liked for its low income vibe, and every other world is already pristine
Carl's Sim Guides When is the update with the bills and utilities. You said it’s base game also I think you mentioned it was on June 2
This expack would just make me want to do it out of spite for the hipster bullcrap overload in this and past expansions, and how...stereotypically and one-sided...all this is presented. Some of the features look really nice, but I just don't want a smug mechanic in my Sims game.
@@eacaraxe You can turn the smog and environmental effects off. You don't have to play with them.
lmao Carl doesn't need pants =D
It kind of sucks the expansion packs are almost always limited to one particular world. In The Sims 3, most big changes like ocean swimming, supernatural creatures or house boats weren't limited to one world. You could use them / add them to any world. It makes expansions feel very stand alone and not as if you were added more and more layers to the game.
Well yeah the sims 2 and the sims 3 were the only games that reeeally did that huh?
I think you forgot the part where they said pollution affects all worlds? People just don’t like to listen I guess
jfb 7920 but not the community upgrades. Besides once you do something once in the sims 4 , like the upgrades or makers career, players would never revisit it since its the same thing every time. In the other games it was fun to add in other features into a previous world or pack because it was new and exciting.
The only sims 4 pack that has this effect is seasons.
The purple penguin I wish the smog was thicker and had a stronger effect. I would love it to have a proper haze effect that makes the sims sick and actually makes it worth it to want to live in an eco-friendly town. Regarding the idea of trash and not being everywhere, there is a landfill lot trait that can be placed on various lots to get a trashy neigbourhood in other towns
@@FB792 You get the pollution but not the trash. Which seems a wierd choice.
dang I was looking forward to Gotham San Myshuno :(
Yo that would have been crazy. Add gangs and adult entertainment places and have a man dressed as a llama and you would have had the Gotham
I mean the sky will be brown and it wont look nice isnt that enough?
Me toooo 😭😭😭 I have no reason to buy this pack now
@@aturchomicz821 definitely not for me. From what I understand there won't be trash in the streets, there won't be crappy versions of non-playable buildings in the set dressing, it sounds like it's literally just smog and coughing sims. I was actually considering spending $40 on this if they had implemented the trash and different buildings in the rest of the main worlds, but I'm definitely not spending $40 just for the smog and hacking sims. The gameplay in the new world doesn't interest me. I'm only interested in the CAS, build items, and what I thought was going to be a small reworking of the other worlds to give them a totally run down and trash filled look. So, I'm back to waiting for a sale.
@@m.e.881 I too was hoping that this would be more apocalyptic in nature. But its not.
17:28
I think it’s ironic that the in game expenses are way too cheep in a recycled and unoriginal pack that costs 40 bucks
Mega B R U H
@@aturchomicz821 our real world matrix was set dystopian real painfully of hell realistic
Nah
I think the 'fizzy juice' is kombucha :D. I make kombucha with fruit I grow in my garden in real life and it's actually very tasty! Now, that being said... Even though I am the person this expansion portrays (I take stuff from the dumpster to restore and repurpose it, I grow food, craft, make kombucha, am an activist, live an eco lifestyle in general) I don't really see the appeal in this one BECAUSE I do that in real life. I want TS4 to give me experiences I cannot have in real life. Doing the same stuff I do IRL seems boring to me. I guess that's why I love all the fantasy stuff.
I might be in the minority here but I wasn’t too thrilled about the overhaul of gardening with seasons. I liked the grind of gardening. I feel like they made it too easy and now it looks like they did it again with this pack. I have a garden and because it’s so easy to maintain, I actually forget I have it there.
I also dislike the overhaul of the gardening skill with Seasons. I loved the gardening skill until that happened. Every Sim I played had a garden, now I just don't bother and buy what I need form the CL vendors or PC seed packets.
Playalot that’s exactly how I was. They took the joy out of finally getting that spliced plant. Now you can just get the actual seed from a festival, through the phone or rare seed packets. They also don’t produce 10 per harvest any more. I believe it’s down to 5 now. What I did like was the new evolve aspect but that’s about it.
@@LeticiaSPandaMcfly6 Some plants only give one (rare) and others 4 etc so yes, I dislike the lower rate of harvestables on each plant too. Disabling Seasons helps a little but it really was the pre-patch update that killed it for me. tbh I don't think I've spliced a plant since the update either. So it's a definite 'no' from me! :) It some ways I like that you can evolve a plant from a distance but that also feels a bit too easy as well.
Playalot I’m with you 100% on everything you mentioned! It was a bit overkill. Hopefully they make stuff more challenging in the game for however long they decide to keep going with this iteration.
My biggest issue with gardening is before it was based on actual time passing on the lot you were at. Now it’s 5 AM always, so if you play a lot but leave it to play another at 4, you never get the harvestables from all of that gameplay. Visiting a community lot at 5 AM? Nothing to harvest until the next day. I hate that. Never ever getting 10 also is dumb. I wish the gardening hadn’t been messed with in a patch.
The meat wall cracks me though. And I might be as excited as Carl for the inventory sort.
Aww so I wont be able to see a trashed San Myshuno? Thats whats im excited about tho.. 😕
Well it will be possible to make it smogged sooo
@@aturchomicz821 but it's not the same
same :(
I really love what they are doing with this pack/patch, but theres some things that i feel need to be said
As much as this free patch and pack is definitely better than we initially believed, it still does not address core issues in the game. Like deep personalites of sims and day to day activities that bolster who are sims are and how they interact with their household.
The patch is a good addition, and the pack adds a lot to the communities but revamps to the sims personalities, hobbies, love loves is very much needed. A generations pack is desperately needed as well.
Good on Maxis, but we have some ways to go.
I would love a pack that deepens the sims personalities!
And the children ... the poor children just go to school, do homework, and repeat
It's clear that Maxis as we knew it, is dead. Only EA remains. 😩
@@namaste_charlei weve already known that. The studio was shut down after they finished most of the sims 3 and the creator left. Ea reinstated the studio to make the rest of the sims 3 dlc and work on the sims 4
Its not the same people
@@christopherdelacruz9728 I iterate this because there are a lot of people that still think Maxis exists. Many will deny that Maxis is gone. The spirit of it definitely is no longer there.
Does it make me a bad person if I don’t want to care about the environment in a game? *conflicted face*. Ps! I think that juice is supposed to be kombucha 🤮
I think you could ignore it a lot and occasionally repeal a policy
I don't think so. I already try to care about the environment and all in real life; I really don't want to play it in a game, too. It's too overwhelming when I have to deal with it in a game I'm playing to escape that whole thing for a while.
@@BooDotBoo right, they could've just give us cars and I would be happy.
BooDotBoo you can turn it off, or not buy the pack.... I look forward to playing passively as well as actively. Like I wanna just play my sims like normal and see how it affects the world. I appreciate that gameplay affects the world around you
@@BooDotBoo to be fair, it is a LIFE simulator
Thank you for that summary! I have to say the live stream made me understand why it’s an expansion and not a game pack. This whole idea is not my cup of tea (which is totally fine) but I am happy that this can be integrated in day to day gameplay - if you like playing environmentally conscious. It still feels like this pack “fixes” things that are already in game, but I guess it’s better to have off-the-Grid being fixed in a pack than not at all?! I might pick this up when it’s on sale for the new world and the new hobbies.
16:01 poor Thomas J indeed. Thanks for that My Girl reference, i appreciate it as much as I do your sims content. Great and wonderfully witty breakdown of the livestream, Carl. Thank you
Thanks for this, I fell asleep halfway through the livestream. The best part of the video was your laughter, I couldn't help but laugh along.
I lost it when the jerky thing clicked, had like 7 takes that were too incoherent to use. Haven't laughed till I cried in a while.
I think the updates are great and it looks like this expansion pack has more to offer than what we could see in the trailer.
But...6 years until we got some of these updates?
Markus Hansson I know. Firefighters could've come with get to work
Exactly my gripe about it. These changes coming in the patch should have been included in base game from day 1! And here we all are, losing our minds with excitement that EA has granted us these great boons. It's like we all have Stockholm Syndrome and we're fawning over EA tossing us tiny scraps. It makes me feel so conflicted. I'm like Grrrrrrr... OH THANK YOU MASTER... but grrrrrrr.
"You will rest easy knowing your sofa is made of carrots" 😅
😭😭😭😭😭 I want garbage to appear in the old basegame desert world. And I want candle making to be a separate skill. I want us to be able to combine different ingredients in the fizzy maker. I want to create my own NAP. I want to swim in that marble space water. I want a compost bin. I want to be able to get real parts from recycled stuff, like wood or metal or fabric, together with the bits and pieces, and that they are needed as ingredients to the stuff we can fabricate. I want to be able to fabricate stuff with bits and pieces (and mentioned ingredients) on the children creativity table, like smaller things kids can create. I want the new freelancer career to also include flower arrangements, knitting. I want a food freelancer career too, like the same but with different meals. 😁
I want it to cost money to travel to other cities/worlds.
Yes. This is the sort of gameplay I'd pay $40 for. This would make it an expansion pack in my eyes.
I started to forget why I was so disappointed in this pack after watching so many other UA-camrs talk about how much they love the new hairs, or the build items. And yeah, that's fine, I think they look great, too! But they either get the packs for free, or it's a business expense for them. I have my own business expenses that don't involve buying sims games. I have my own family to take care of, and spending $40 for this pack as is just seems out of the question for me. You totally put this into perspective! There's so much missed potential here!!
I'm sorry, I'll stop ranting now! 😬 I just miss the love I used to have for this game 😔
Sims 2 has compost bins. I don't understand how a supposedly more advanced game has so much less the its prior incarnations.
Seriously- if they had to have only 2 couldn't they have made the 3D printer tied to handiness and the candlemaking be separate
Give the modders time after the expansion comes out. I'm sure some of these things will exist. How sad is it that the modding community is so necessary to make an expensive game like this play the way it should? Also I've had candle making in my game for years. Thanks icemunmun. :)
@@HughLlewellyn I always play modded game so I know the possibilities, I have even created some small mods myself, but I think it's sad that it's not there in the game from the beginning.
You're a great, informative Sims UA-camr. I don't even play The Sims 4 anymore, but I'm still subscribed to you for the news :)
"That I'm calling a NAP. Which is what I wanted to take when he jumped into CAS." Omg🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
You are a legend in the sims community along side a few others you are the person I normally get all my sims info from so yeah you deserve everything good that has/will happen.
*Sims
From what I've seen in the livestream and other Game Changer videos, this pack just looks like a building pack to me... :/ Like it feels like this pack is aimed more towards the builders in this community tbh.. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing.. There's a lot of cool Build&Buy items in this pack. I'm sure lot of people can use to these items to build all types of lots. However, for someone like me who isn't a builder, I'm personally having a hard time finding the value in this pack.. I don't see a lot of gameplay and stuff to do in live mode, you know? And the items that do offer some gameplay, I just see myself using them once and then never touching them again. It would've been great if they added more skills and traits (especially negative ones) in this pack or something idk.. I want to love this pack, I really do, but the more things I see from this pack the more I don't want it. Like I'm more excited for the patch update than I am for this pack.. :(
Anyways, thank you for the video! I like how you made even a summary video entertaining to watch!
SOOOOOO...
Is there anything to do in this pack? It seems most of the features are just aesthetic and like adding a different coat of paint to the same ol' game...
Just a lot of fluff and no depth. Per usual.
Atleast theres decent clothing options
@@foxglovearts1129 for women ...
@@ladyyananumber1200 lmao you're absolutely right. When was the last time we didnt use stupid amounts of CC for male sims?
The first pack I know for sure I'm not gonna buy. Environmentalism is a good thing - irl. In a game? No thanks, I play for the things I can't do irl, like having alien babies or whatever. We coulda worked as the Grim Reaper, and this is what we got? Insane.
Yeah totaly. If they want to do more realistic things, then this is also not the way to do it. I feel like they don't know what environmentalism entails at all.
I would have liked if EA pledged to plant trees for every copy sold.
This pack still feels like they’re wanting people to pay for a PSA on saving the environment. Like I don’t want to buy a pack where the main concept is Sims asking if I want to hear about the environment.
I feel the same. This pack could have had a lot more to save and build up a town, not just eco stuff.
I can't help but sing the Captain Planet ending theme song, myself. 😂
Yeah, I'm generally environmentally friendly in real life and I'm turned off by the fact they're only letting you play as a hippie. They could have at least done a "polluter" trait that hated eco friendly stuff instead of the samey Recyler and Eco Friendly traits (I heard 4 traits in another summary)
🤣 “why 5? I have no fricken idea!”
Five finger discount! Duh! ;)
Mmmm... I think I'll pass on this one. The theme doesn't appeal to me and it doesn't look like there's much to do.
Even if it turns out to be good the theme is still kinda zzzzz and I say this as a person who understands climate issues.
B-But SEPTUM PIERCINGS!!! FINALLY I AM REPRESENTED!!!
@@shangri-la9458 CC :)
@@CarlsSimGuides I could tell that when you got to the meat wall segment, you were done. 😂
I'm definitely gonna wait for a sale on this one. There's certainly some gameplay stuff that interests me, but there's also a lot of stuff I don't really care about. And I'm also someone who spends a lot of time and effort in both cas and build/buy, and most of the items coming with this pack aren't things I see myself using. Much as I'd love those piercings right away... I'll restrain myself until it's at least 50% off
Hydroponics would be nice in Oasis Springs where you do have to water plants a lot.
Bills and utilities!!!!!
Finally!!! My sims are paying like 30000 simoleons for nothing. Now I can track my utilities like I do my amazon package
I know right! My family is paying $7000 for a 2 bedroom house.
It's not all bad because the mother is an author and makes great money. But the bill system as it is doesn't make any sense (to me)
Lady Yana Number 1 For now it goes by how espensive items you have in the house. I got tired of living in my own sim house and lived in the city where rent stay the same and does not go up
Let's call the Sims 4 for what it is: A building simulation game
Time to build a windmill park and capitalise on the energy production.
Oh no, we don't do that around here, wanna talk to comrade Kalashnikova?
@@moch.farisdzulfiqar6123 What, building windmill parks, or capitalising on said parks?
Everyone's making these review videos. I prefer yours over others.
Lol, massaging your meat always improves things lol
Not having trashy neighborhoods other than the expansion neighborhood is a really big letdown. I got super excited thinking that there were going to be noticeable visual changes in the other neighborhoods. Especially because the expansions that I tend to buy are expansions that have gameplay changes that affect the game as a whole rather than something more specific. Now, I'm not really sure if I want to pick this up right away or just wait. Thanks for this video though, Carl. Very informative!
bug huggin hippie... that will be my new twitter name, thank you very much :D
Noo. Don’t do it.
I’m joking. As you where
You saved me from watching the whole stream. So Thank you! I love all of the videos you do!
I love your coverage on the Sims things especially the personality you bring to it all
That laugh at 12:46 .. made me laugh out loud too 😂
IDK from this video that 40 bucks sounds like its not worth it.
I agree, the windmills and solar panels (water collectors too) should cost a lot more... maybe 10 times as much would be a good start?
Good stuff as always. I like the level of analysis, the good bad and ugly. Thanks for your work as always.
Well I am a console player I am NOT a fan of that new feature. I've learned my controls, they are not that hard. I don't need them poping up the control reminders like I'm some noob. It's insulting really. If you need the controls you pressed down on the left joy stick the controls are there. This really upsets me. I don't need more crap popping up on my screen. Who asked for this?!
My complaint is unwarranted. You can turn that crap off in the game menu options.
HUZZAH for the patch!
Also if you're on console look for a few BIG sales, I got Get Together for 50%!
I'm a console player as well! Tomorrow is actually my birthday, and I'm quite disappointed that THIS is the pack that comes out on my birthday lol but I'll definitely check out the sales and maybe just get a different one(or two, depending on the sale lol) as my bday present to myself lol
I love your videos, Carl. Since I began the Sims your website always popped up!
I wonder if the sink breaks & is constantly leaking water will that also increase your bill?
Combining SimCity with The Sims is what it sounds like to me. I love this idea. I look forward to you playing one of your vampires a week after release
Thanks Carl! I love your videos , tutorials, ect.!
I had to Edit when you started talking about the meat! I am literally crying because I'm laughing so hard!
✌❤🙏
I read it 7x.i wrote the script and didn't realize until I got to reading it aloud how funny the shriveling jerky part was...
@@CarlsSimGuides it was so funny! Genius in fact!
I love that you are always so blatantly honest with your reviews. Very refreshing.
I never know when the live stream is and probably watch the VOD later. I look forward to the videos like this (that you make) that cut down the fluff and give the info we (or I) want
Yea that livestream was cringey.
Took me like 4 hours to watch it
You are the absolute best I’m sooo happy your followers are growing
This pack is all about recycling, aka recycling features and animations from other expansion packs lmao.
BWAH NAILED IT
Nah
Always informative. Thank you! Love that you "cut to the chase" :D
When Carl says that the windmills are so relatively cheap and yet so helpful...I think that’s the developers emphasizing a point...
Thanks for providing all this great info!
Youre really the best sims channel
The Hydroponic rack reminds me of the Sims 2's Slacker Career reward.
It was weird back then, because even if it was a reward for the SLACKER career, the plants in it would still die of neglect.
I Love your description of the meat wall!! Neglect it and it becomes jerky! I think the EA developers have been in quarantine way too long,lol!
I love your videos. You say what I think but no one else says. And you make me laugh. I'm not interested in the gameplay aspect of this pack. I find it boring. But I thought I might buy it for the CAS and Build items. Nope. All the furniture and clothes are from the "rags" part of rags to riches. They could have thrown in a few nice items for those who aren't into the rags lifestyle. Not enough difference between the new traits and aspirations either. This expansion will be the first one I've passed on since I started playing Sims.
I’m really glad they didn’t add nectar making in this pack like I heard some people say they were doing. I’m not sure if we’ll even get nectar making back since we got this fizzy drink stuff, but I’d really like to see it return in a pack that makes sense for it to be in. Hopefully we can get another world like champs les sims in a game pack or something with nectar making.
Tbh as someone who doesn't care about the environment all that much, I am looking forward to pretending I do in a game lol. This pack is definitely a hit or miss but for those that are into it this pack will be a lot of fun.
It's human nature to take things for granted until they are gone.
@@BrycenStone whatever you say
I think this expansion is is going to be fun for rags to riches. Especially if you need to craft most of your furniture.
This EP looks like a bunch of GFXs and shallow gameplay features you'll get tired of in 2 hours. A total waste of money, if you ask me.
Could not agree more. It’s so shallow, yet after the livestream so many commenters were like, ‘Wow! The trailers didn’t do this justice! There’s so much here!’ I was like, ‘What were you watching?!’ Half of the two hour stream was spent in CAS or Build/Buy and then they managed to show literally EVERYTHING else that the pack includes in the other hour! One hour’s worth of new gameplay does not an expansion make!
@@HerHollyness they always do that in their livestreams though, apparently alot of people out there care about either build/buy or CAS. I disagree with both of you actually, so far from what ive seen from the base game updates to all the new crafting stuff it seems like a rags to riches player's dream.
@@HerHollyness I'm kinda used to Sims 4 fans getting hyped and trying to hype others up and then feeling disappointed when there's nothing to do after 2-3 hours of playing. Sims 4 packs are *EXTREMELY* shallow. They're mostly rehashed animations, recycled mechanics, poorly implemented mechanics, non-existent difficulty/challenge, shallow traits, etc. It's always the same, year after year after year. It's been almost *SIX* years since The Sims 4 was released and people are celebrating because they're finally adding fire fighters (a base game feature in Sims 1, 2 and 3). I'm just so over The Sims 4 at this point. Hopefully, Paralives and the game Rod Humble is working on for Paradox (we don't know if it's a life sim yet) will bring some needed fresh air to this dying genre.
@@shadybrain3424 I play rags to riches nearly every time these days. But it's mostly because I feel the game is far too easy otherwise. The features of this pack certainly fit the theme of rags to riches, but I'm not sure it will increase the difficulty of that style of play. In fact, it looks like it will be even easier to start with no money and make a fortune. And that's already very simple to do, so I was hoping any new developments on that front would make it a bit harder to acquire easy wealth.
@@rodh1404 yeah i agree, they just need to do a rebalance of the economy, how much is made vs how much items cost.
Oh man that is disappointing. I thought the trash would show up in all worlds. :( Well back to waiting for this pack to go on sale.
if fizzy lifting drinks isn't an easter egg i'll be surprised.
hopefully the power and water bills will be much higher than we expect, after all if we do gardening, washing and science stuff in our houses for example thats alot of power and water! throw in pet baths, hot day sprinklers, saunas and winterfest (christmas) light decorations those bills will hopefully shoot up... hopefully.
though the materials thing does sound pretty interesting, i wonder if they will have an impact on energy usage along side seasons? i mean they'v hinted at alot of cross pack interactions what with degrees influencing stuff, power, skill objects like the rocket and such all doing environmental stuff so defo willing to dip toes into this one and see how deep it goes
Thank you for making this video. It really helped to put what they are offering into perspective. I'm kind of glad the other neighborhoods won't be trashy! And I love the "meat" wall.
It’s more interesting then I thought it would be.
“If you neglect the meat it’ll dry up and turn into jerky”
Carl: *Heartwarming laughter*
After the trailer got slaughtered the gurus did a good job in trying to show that the pack isn't literal garbage.
And they also get a polite golf clap for having a ladder that will be added to the base game for those who'll skip the pack but still have a ladder to use.
You in the loop on the other patch additions?
@@CarlsSimGuides Besides the ladder the bill and utilities features are supposed to be coming with the patch but if SimGuruGeorge or Jill tweeted anything about the fireman coming to I haven't seen it.
@@CarlsSimGuides the base game patch is way more exciting than the expansion pack
rewatching this for a little challenge i'm doing & i do love your little jabs. "which i am calling a nap...which is what i wanted to take when he went into CAS" LOL
I passing on this one as it's not for me feel we got enough in island living
Seeing that meat-wall made me want werewolves in Sims 4...
Come to think of it werewolves would fit just right with hippies. Material hunting, living off the land, dressing like you live in the woods.
It would just be a vampire with body hair and better animations, why didnt EA think of that
Plantsims!!
I do love werewolves in Sims and want them in game, but Plantsims would have been perfect for this pack
You have to buy a separate game pack for that. But Lady Yana is right we should've gotten plant sims with this.
I LOVEEEE the CAS and build/buy in this expansion. It's SOOO GOOOD! Unfortunately I'm dealing with a lot of bugs when I do gameplay.
The absolute best thing about the first time I watched this video was right in the middle of your delighted announcement of the inventory changes, you said "I am genuinely excited about this..." and it cut to a bra ad with a closeup shot of a woman's chest. 🤣
YES ! acid rain and fly death!! I wanted that!
3:30 am eastern standard time wtf
Yeah. Late for me!
Maybe Carl did this video after watching AEW Double or Nothing? 😀😆
I think it’s fair that you can’t just fully trash other worlds. That would probably involve A LOT of work and basically rebuilding every other world....
I do like this pack. It still feels like a true expansion and I like the extra challenge to take care of the environment on top of regular gameplay...
Fantastic video! You have a really great presenting style and very engaging.
Hello environmentally conscious sim, say hello to Hungry, my cowplant, feel free to have some cake . . . .
This was both informative and funny. When you get going you really go!
LOL you always make me laugh. 11:02 When I was watching the stream I yelled the very same thing at my monitor :P
How the hell are you not a game changer?!
Cuz he gives honest reviews
I think he is, he’s mentioned it before in other videos
I think he is? He thanked EA Game Changers for early access to the upcoming patch in the beginning of his last video. Does that include the pack? Maybe.
Carl is a Game Changer and has been for a very long time due to his Guides on both TS3 and TS4. He gets early access to all packs to give him a day or two to write the guides so they are up before the packs go live.
i wonder who voted for this pack luckily its an option to buy =) thought tho why is there baths and not showers and dumpster diving sounds really disgusting and dangerous
I love your channel!!!
How are you NOT a Game Changer with your Origin ID bouncing around an early-access copy of Eco Lifestyle?!! You ARE the PRIME SOURCE of all Sims information. I've been consulting Carl's Guides since Sims 3! When you google "sims 4 'fill in the blank' ", your guides are often the 1st result. You ARE a game changer in every sense of the word. My game wouldn't be what it is without your guidance. Seriously EA, wtf? Thank you Carl, for all you do.
About the pack... I'm VERY excited about the patch. The expansion... I'm still meh. Part of me thinks I need meat wall jerky in my life. Maybe I'll get it eventually. Or not. :D
I couldn't sit through the full live stream. Thank you for this.
I’m sure the sims equivalent of a vegan being someone who eats trash and prefers freebies won’t anger or upset anyone 😅
It's a pun. Totally different thing. If someone is upset about it, they don't understand words.
Fregans are a different thing- they are real people that like to dumpster dive and will reuse things they find there including eating food that appears to still be good. They're not as big as they used to be- they were a phenomenon maybe 10 years ago
I don't think I've been earlier to your videos! What a strange time to post though, half past 9 in the morning?
It’s 2:30 am where I am. Madness.
@TheGschultz people not ready yet release
@@spooky2toes83 cheat code only moveobject good as well
It's 4am here so even worse.
4am here lol
Thank you so much!! I always wait for your summary vid! 😊