here is what i have to say(i loved having garam in the group she was a nice person) [dont hate on hybe they had to protect garam the only thing they had to do is kick her out] Le Sserafim is a five member kpop girl group (used to be six members) that consists of Chaewon, Yunjin, Sakura, Eunchae, Kazuha and (left) Garam. The girl group debut May 2, 2022. but before they debut each member trained for a long time but Garam in specific (the girl in the middle laughing in the video) trained for a year. After a long time of training, practicing and finally debut, one of Garams pre debut classmates stepped up and said that Garam bullied her in school. HYBE tried their best to defend her but after a long time of fighting, everyone was on the classmates side, they really had no choice but to remove Garam from the group. If they didnโt remove her there were chances the group would have to disband as a whole. After she had already been kicked out, people found out that she was innocent. Skip forward a few months and now people try their hardest to forget her but itโs really not possible she was a really talented girl and deserved so much better. Their are people in this cmmt section saying that they feel bad even when they probably wrote one or two hate comments toward her at some point. I probably forgot a lot but thatโs basically the just of it. I hope you all know that sheโs an innocent person and herself was actually the victim of bullying. The only reason people believed she was the bully was because of something she said to the bullyโs but she was defending her friend. The ex classmates also edited photos of her to make it look like she was a mean person. She was only defending her friend and got so much hate and even d3ath threats. I feel so bad for her, if you were a hater or believed she did something wrong you should be ashamed of yourself. Basically haters ruined a 16-year old girls life after she had trained for a year to get where she was. EDIT: she was honestly kind of a bad kid but she still didnโt deserve death threats, her bullies were worse than her anyways.here is what i have to say(i loved having garam in the group she was a nice person)
IT BROKE MY HEART WHEN SHE SAID : "MY DREAM ONLY LASTED 14 DAYS" IT BROKE MY HEART HATER'S BROKE A 16 - YEAR OLD CARER THAT'S INSANE BUT I WISH HER THE BEST OF LUCK AT THE ACTING SCHOOL ๐๐ญ
Imagine working so hard for your dream, training meticulously with so much effort for so long, and one jealous person comes along to snatch it all away
not only one person, but all those people behind the phone that doesn't have anything most important to do in their lifes than destroying a 16 years old girl's dream just because they believe in everything in the internet without being sure about the true and without knowing what really happened.
I especially feel bad for Eunchae, they had such a great bond and Garam was the closest to her age. Eunchae and Garam couldve been the little sisters in the group and best friends, but now its just Eunchae with the rest being adults(which is still great, but if I were her i would be deeply upset)
What made me tear up even more is that during a weverse magazine, Garam would leave school early to pick up Eunchae, have something to eat together before they both go to the HYBE building ๐ญ๐ญ
She was my bias in the group the first girl I saw in the group. She deserves better. With her leserafim hits different. I hope she is doing well. We will always support you Garam ๐
Garam was also my first bias and all my friends said yes, she bullied and I always said that it didn't make any sense because she was too young for that , and in the end she was pronounced innocent and now she is no more
@@lowlianne There is a video where Chaewon was talking about shooting their M/V and in a board, Chaewon drew all the six members of le sserafim and while talking about it Chaewon looked.like she was gonna cry
Yea actually during the concert in hk, I think is a fan holding a board to let chaewon to do sth and chaewon did the pose that garam used to do๐ฅฒthey still remember garam.
I donโt think any of yโall understand that the fimmies KNEW Garam. We fans may have seen her as an idol for a couple weeks, but those girls knew her for a long while! She trained with them, shared their struggles, and formed friendships with all 5 of those girls. And haters took her away from them!!! Le Sserafim cared about Garam and no body can convince me otherwise; no one. They had a wonderful bond in their early debut stages and it breaks my heart to look back on those old videos knowing Garam, someone they probably considered as a good friend or even a close sister, was forced to leave their group. All because of fake rumors.
All the people who were against her at the beginning ,and at the end where she was innocent are terrible because then they were for garam , they are not real fans
My own heart would break if something like that happened to me, they went through thick and thin, fought together and in the end made their debut together and then something like this happens
I wish one day we can see garam again on Camera with le sserafim members It whould have been better if hybe whould just let garam speqk herslef and instead of hating on her just wait till the turth comes out lke hwat did they get by ruing a 16 year olds life she worked so hard i think it was the wirst for Manche since garam was the only one who is most close to her age if the turth had came out much earlier then none of this whould have happened #justiceforgaram
Yaah guys I just noticed that I made many tipping mistakes sorry for that and englsih is not my first language I wanted to say "like what did they get by ruining a 16 year olds life .... I think it was the worst for Manche (Eunchae) since garam was the one who was most close to her age if the truth had come...."
Garam responding and giving a statement wouldn't have made the situation any better, it would've made the situation worse, she would've still received all that hate for the rest of her career and would've gotten death threats. People really need to have a neutral stance on any sort of bullying allegation before the truth is revealed by the company. I know that HYBE isn't so dumb to debut such a member knowing there history with previous girl groups. They would have also not made such bold statements like Garam being the victim and the classmate being the bully(they might have not explicitly said that but that's what they were trying to say) without them having some solid proof of the fact
OHHH....LE SSERAFIM MEMBERS MISS THEIR CUTIE๐ฅน๐ฅน๐ฅน I'LL NEVER FORGIVE THE PERSON WHO RUINED GARAM'S LIFE AND CAREER๐ข๐ข๐ข BUT I'LL NEVER FORGET HERโค๐ข๐
@Emixplays That's the nature of the business. IF there is any controversy, the company doesn't want to be caught in the crossfire. What they should've done, especially since the CEO knew Garam well, was temporarily dismissed her until she was cleared of the charges and the allegations stopped. Now I love Le Sserafim as the 5 that they are, but Garam's life is moving on and she's now going to a school for music and acting/film. So, maybe we will see her on the stage again someday as a singer, but maybe she will turn to acting full-time and get some solid roles. One other thing, the current Le Sserafim members REALLY need to focus on working on improving their vocals. I love their choreos and their music, but they really struggled at the recent Coachella. It showed that they are not quite ready for that big show yet vocally as a whole. Eunchae and Kazuha have the biggest potential to be great singers, and Eunchae did cry in frustration after because of her struggles at Coachella, which also means that she will want to get better. Sorry for the long-ass reply.
Garam was happy and energetic girl in a k-pop group but people's wanted to tore her to shreds i just wish one day she'll be with the le sserafim again๐๐ป
I think everyone missed her after that and I think that part is just missing now , I'm so happy that they make such beautiful songs but every time I think what would happen if Garam was still there
If the news that it was fake could come out sooner! Even though they maybe kicked her out for popularity still isn't fair, because she worked so hard to get here and just kicked her out is so sad!!!!!!! Ahhhhh, this is making me cry, just reading all of yall comments, and listening to the music. (It's making me shake right now, I can't type correctyly when I'm shaking! I hope this doesn't happen to any idol again!
Guys I know itโs so sad on what happened.. but big news! Garam is debuting as an actress now! Letโs all forget the past and support her in her new career.
@@Happy-go-lucky-d3u so basically there was a member of Le SSERAFIM called Garam, she got accused of bullying as soon as her teaser picture was uploaded, HYBE eventually kicked her out of LSRFM
I feel so bad for Garam, she didn't deserve the hate that came with the rumors, I'm so grateful for completely ignoring that scandal, I'm glad the scandal is cleared up. I heard Garam will be an actress, I'll support her forever.
Here to spread the message. @ John Jackson for credit Garam is declared innocent of bullying and violence in the official school disciplinary report, therefore, she should have stayed in Le Sserafฤฑm. Garam defended a friend verbally who pleaded for help when Eunsoo took hidden photos of Garam's friend in her underwear and hacked a facebook account to post them online under another name to incriminate an innocent student. Eunsoo's rich father used his influence to push through a disciplinary committee that was biased against Garam. Yet, the level 5 offense that Garam received for defending her friend with a cuss word or two carried 0 severity points for violence and was the most common one given at her school, while Eunsoo's very rare level 8 offense carried 16-20 points in severity of violence which was beyond suspension. Yet, the rich father used his influence to get Eunsoo to transfer schools before the punishment could be implemented and jealous Eunsoo bullied Garam at the new school by getting boys in online chat rooms to threaten violence against her and keep inviting her so she couldn't leave the chats. Garam also had insults and obscenities written on her desk at school. Eunsoo's intense jealousy of Garam debuting in her favorite kpop company was one of the primary driving forces for the lies and corruption to drive Garam out, but another pivotal reason the powers in kpop and South Korea were so rabid in going after Garam is that she stood up to the rich elite's perverted "right" to post child porn online, use blackmail to control girls' lives, and incriminate others by stealing their identity to post it so they don't get caught. In their demented minds, this is what they call a perpetrator of crimes. As a result, Eunsoo's rich father purchased a dirty law firm to file a fraudulent lawsuit with the ulterior motive of destroying Garam's career since it coincided with Garam's debut in Le Sserafim and had nothing to do with the stated intent which was accusing Garam of bullying, since the school incident happened four years before and was caused by the violent actions of sexual harassment and theft of a facebook account by Eunsoo. According to the Korean Broadcasting System (KBS), Garam was by far the hardest hit target by Kakao Organization affiliated with Starship with 336 slanderous articles written to destroy her reputation. Kakao is currently under investigation by the FTC for reverse viral marketing. Kakao falsely claimed that Garam was an ex Starship trainee who was removed for bullying other members which was a lie. Furthermore, Kakao is responsible for the slanderous picture and article claiming that Garam had written down with Ive and other famous kpop groups on a blackboard, even though Garam is not seen in the picture and even though she hadn't attended that school since 2018 which was long before the group IVE even formed. Finally, they are responsible for lies about Garam bullying other Le Sserafim members. it is obvious that there was a coordinated conspiracy to cancel Garam, especially with the fake evidence and fabricated photos spread all over the internet by the fake victim, Eunsoo, her rich father's purchase of a dirty law firm to file a fraudulent lawsuit with the ulterior motive of destroying Garam's career, and Kakao's viral flooding of the internet with negative and slanderous articles against Garam who was innocent of the false allegations. While Hybe appeared to defend Garam in a superficial sense by putting out an official statement that recounted Garam's version of the story, it was done in an impersonal way with statements like According to Garam. Furthermore, it was issued too late, since it also announced that she was being placed on hiatus. However, the real incompetence and undermining by Hybe came from their refusal to let Garam make the public statement she requested in mid-April and their refusal to let her release the official school disciplinary report which she also had available in mid-April. Even worse, Hybe's complete betrayed of Garam came when they refused to release this critical information even after Eunsoo's side released a cropped and marked on part of the school disciplinary document which only indicated Garam's offense. Furthermore, they didn't release the testimonies of the many students that supported Garam's innocence. Hybe also never filed lawsuits for libel or slander against all the false information and incriminating faked photos posted by the fake victim (real bully) or against the death or sexual assault threats that were posted online which badly damaged Garam's reputation and traumatized her psychologically, especially since she rarely left her dorm room during the time of her hiatus because of anxiety and depression. This downcast condition and isolation persisted for an extended period even after Garam left Hybe and went home. This cyber witch hunt fueled with malicious lies didn't give Garam's side of the story which would have been based, if it had been allowed to take place, on official school evidence, direct testimony and the emotional resonance of Garam's personal appeal. The effect was to create great hype at the moment of debut but to destroy the mental health of Garam who was falsely accused and served as the scapegoat for the group. There is even a haunting scene in an ad in which Garam falls really hard on a car which suggests that she is Hybe's fallen sixth angel, since Le Sseragim means six angels. Then after a long hiatus and a period of silence, Hybe dumped Garam with no attempt made to clear her name, even though they had all the evidence to do so and even though they had used the excuse of an upcoming trial against Eunsoo as the reason not to reveal the evidence to exonerate Garam. The defender against sexual exploitation, Garam, was severely punished and Eunsoo, the sexual offender of Garam's friend and facebook hacker was rewarded. Therefore after Garam's unjust cancellation and while sunk in the depths of depression, it was left up to Garam with the help of her faithful friend Yudimi to muster up the strength to clear her name by releasing the official school disciplinary report and Garam's explanatory statement in August, in which Garam refuted many of the falsehoods by saying she never drank or smoked, never bullied or ordered anyone around, never transferred schools and never used violence. She also had the honesty to admit that she would have handled the defense of her friend a bit differently now that she had the perspective of more maturity but was adamant that in principle she had done the right thing because her parents had taught her the importance of defending a friend in a time of adversity. But honestly, Garam's actions seem really honorable and reasonable considering the severity of the offense: yelling and saying a couple of cuss words at Eunsoo for posting half nude photos of her friend as a profile pic online and hacking a facebook account to incriminate another student. Better yet, I thought of Garam's actions as a wise lesson posed as a question: If every member of a group and its fandom had the guts to defend a targeted member the way Garam defended her friend against a powerful and perverted enemy like Eunsoo, wouldn't all these unjust bullying cancellations like of Jimin, Soojin and Garam come to an end? In Garam's closing address in her letter, she thanked her fans with a harbinger of hope, GaramDream. And the strength of Garam's and Yudimi's efforts freed from Hybe's draconian restrictions turned the tide of public opinion in Garam's favor. Presently, there are some hopeful signs such as Garam giving thanks to her fans on her birthday for her video banner in Seoul on November 16, and 6 days later the first beautiful photos of Garam in her yellow school uniform appeared on twitter. My hope is that if Garam wishes to return to music that she will go into jpop in Japan, as I think it would be safer and give her far more freedom of expression and action. Garam is also quite popular there, comments are more positive for her there than in South Korea, there are far fewer risks, and Japanese songs are longer with storylines that include acting in the videos, which is a great fit since she is currently studying acting at the School of Performing Arts. Plus, the big money influences and propaganda and cancellation campaigns waged against her in kpop will have far less influence in Japan and she will have better protection in Japan from the depravity of lies, misogyny, jealousy and hypocrisy. However, I will support her in whatever she decides to do especially if it is kpop or kdrama because she will need a lot more protection then. Garam is one of my very favorites because of her great beauty and charisma on stage and her fabulous singing, dancing, and her strong integrity of character at such a young age. Her soothing sweet vocals with a touch of sassiness in Blue Flame and Sour Grapes are like a delightful dream and her beautiful ferocity in Fearless is captivating. Her heartbreaking story and efforts to rise again from great persecution are a true inspiration and remind me of an epic movie, so it is certainly no coincidence that she is studying to be an actress. I just wish her the best of success, happiness with love and trust from family and friends, and warmth and understanding from all over the world.
Im so gald i stayed true to garam and didn't hate her she was very nice i know she wouldn't have done that shes was amazing I'll never forget her i hooe she's happy and healthy wherever she is she literally worked so hard why would she bully someone if she knew she wanted to become s kpop idol i bet she knew b4 hand that kpop idols can't do that so why would she?she wouldn't have done that i miss her so much i didnt knew her long but ik she didnt deserve this she worked really hard only to have her dreams crushed i hope that class mate get whatever karma is coming to him/her
I became a fearnot after garam left but when i came to know that she was accused of bullying and ppl came to know that she was innocent i never beleived those stupid scandals those ppl ruined her life she was rlly angel and nice girl poor her she doesn't or did not receive this much hate when i watched this video i literally started crying kazuha still remembers her i think u should have added another video of chaewon she also drew pic of 6 members after garam left i still keep remembering her and i still consider her as member i hope she debut in another group or soloist luv u garam unnieโคโคโคโคโค๐๐ i will always support u
i fell like my heart brakes everytime i see lsdm without grama . euchar lost her bff.grama was the sunshine of the group. after grama left eunchae lost her hopes and her smile.grama was eunchaea emotional support
Even tho im not a Le ssearfim fan i loved Garam so much just like the fans and it shows how much Garam had a dream of being a kpop idol but it seems like her haters classmates hated her and i feel like a pang of sadness when read the captions and the comments it made me tear up๐ข
Gidle before 6members LE SSERAFIM before 6members Soojin stayed 3years Garam stayed only 1 months maybe They look like sisters same same but different I wish both groups ot6 will come againโคโคโค
I feel so bad for garam like why ruin a 16 years old hard work she deserves so much better and the way that kazuha made a heart where garam shouldโve stand like they used to was just so heartbreaking
tbh I feel like everyone was invisible and Garam was highlighted as the main character and when she left all other members got their spotlight and now Eunchae became the main member. They were almost like Ive where Wony was highlighted a lot that makes other members invisible. I think it was best she left and now going to debut as actress. She does have a star quality and actress material. So everything went well after all๐
When Garam said "my dream only lasted in 14 days.." broke my heart..i wasn't Lesserafim fan when she was in le sserafim but..i anyways miss her..if she was in Lesserafim she will be my bias..but she isnt...lets make purple ocean for Garamnie.. ๐ญ๐ญ๐ญ
Some people just ruined the perfect to be life of 16 year old girl haram.She was so talented and kind to all.๐ฅบ๐ฅบ The things happen -One of her classmate make a false accusation of her bullying kids .Hybe defended her but stills all was on his classmate side and she got kicked out.If she wasn't kick out all group would be disband.That kind soul left her dreams ,idol life,fame, for some unknown 5 girls .Thats show how sweet heart she is โคโค Later after months the accusation become false but it runied the life of her .She was so good .I have even known to that she got death threats . ๐ข๐ข๐ข Miss u garam โคโคโคโค Kazuha will never bale to forgot her ๐ข๐ข๐ข๐ข๐ข
Imagine that you worked so hard to achieve your dreams and finally after you do someone come and breaks it into pieces in no time. I don't actually know them but after reading the pinned comment i felt like crying. That bully just ruined someones hard work and shattered their dream.๐ข๐ข
For real like how much jealous they can get just let her live her life when she became successful they had to ruin it for her. Toxicity everywhere I mean I get it she wasn't an angel in her childhood but she apologized and was trying to improve๐
i really cannot take these kind of bullies, really. i was a fan of kpop for 2 years but stopped liking afterwards because such things always happens to celebrities. now I like cpop, Chinese boy groups and girl groups. however, my idol left the group upon debuting in less than 48 hours. i really want to stop such people from being so mean. In fact, this incident made my idol, who was a forever cheerful kind of person, have social stress and he requested to leave the group. The company still wants him back, so they still try to include past memories in their videos, but its still unintentionally hurting him when he sees these memories that he knew that it will never happen again. Never in his life will he be able to be with them and fulfil his dream. i really want to put a stop o this. when I heard about garam, I already felt very upset. and now, with a innocent 18 yr old who trained under the company for 7 years leaving? i really cannot take it. what does others want from them? if they end up feeling bad for their past actions , are they ever able to return them time and their effort to be joining the group? if its a no, then why do it?
I really wished she wouldโve been able to come back bc maybe she would have, le sserafim hasnโt felt like le sserafim since she left and she doesnโt deserve it, she didnโt do anything wrongโฆ
i left le sserafim cause garam left after i saw illit i remember garam in wonhee and moka so i stanned illit Cause they remind me of the old days i used to stan garam:(
here is what i have to say(i loved having garam in the group she was a nice person) [dont hate on hybe they had to protect garam the only thing they had to do is kick her out]
Le Sserafim is a five member kpop girl group (used to be six members) that consists of Chaewon, Yunjin, Sakura, Eunchae, Kazuha and (left) Garam. The girl group debut May 2, 2022. but before they debut each member trained for a long time but Garam in specific (the girl in the middle laughing in the video) trained for a year. After a long time of training, practicing and finally debut, one of Garams pre debut classmates stepped up and said that Garam bullied her in school. HYBE tried their best to defend her but after a long time of fighting, everyone was on the classmates side, they really had no choice but to remove Garam from the group. If they didnโt remove her there were chances the group would have to disband as a whole. After she had already been kicked out, people found out that she was innocent.
Skip forward a few months and now people try their hardest to forget her but itโs really not possible she was a really talented girl and deserved so much better. Their are people in this cmmt section saying that they feel bad even when they probably wrote one or two hate comments toward her at some point. I probably forgot a lot but thatโs basically the just of it. I hope you all know that sheโs an innocent person and herself was actually the victim of bullying. The only reason people believed she was the bully was because of something she said to the bullyโs but she was defending her friend. The ex classmates also edited photos of her to make it look like she was a mean person. She was only defending her friend and got so much hate and even d3ath threats. I feel so bad for her, if you were a hater or believed she did something wrong you should be ashamed of yourself.
Basically haters ruined a 16-year old girls life after she had trained for a year to get where she was.
EDIT: she was honestly kind of a bad kid but she still didnโt deserve death threats, her bullies were worse than her anyways.here is what i have to say(i loved having garam in the group she was a nice person)
Ty for your explanation for anyone who don't know what happened. โค๏ธ
@@winterficationTy for the pin
@@U.r_favvv yw. And rip to your hand ๐คฃ
@@winterfication hahaha
โ@@winterfication hi bestie
,โค๏ธ๐ ๐ ๐๐โฅ๏ธ๐ธ
"My dream lasted for 14 days,i will cherish those days forever"
- Kim Garam
๐ข๐ข๐ข๐ข๐ข
She deserved better..
๐ญ
I hope she debuts in another company...
....๐ข
IT BROKE MY HEART WHEN SHE SAID : "MY DREAM ONLY LASTED 14 DAYS" IT BROKE MY HEART HATER'S BROKE A 16 - YEAR OLD CARER THAT'S INSANE BUT I WISH HER THE BEST OF LUCK AT THE ACTING SCHOOL ๐๐ญ
Where did she said this?
Source?
Help I LITTERALLY see u everywhere
โ@@waqasnazarbhatty7928 she said it in an instagram post she made through her friend's account back in 2022
"My dream stayed for 16 days."
Its so sad.โค
Like imagine ruining a teenagers life for a stupid rumour๐ข๐ญ
We love you garamโคโค
@@lix_strayberryhi stay
My heart just shattered ๐๐๐ญ
๐ณ๐ฒ๐น๐ถ๐ ๐ฏ๐ฒ๐ฟ๐ฟ๐?๐โ@@lix_strayberry
@@lix_strayberryit not a rumor. Its a fact. Look up the all of articles in korean and say. Otherwise if u dont know about anything shut the fuck up.
โI was happy when i was an idol for 2 weeksโ - Kim Garam ๐๐๐๐๐๐
๐ข๐ญ
๐ข๐ข๐ข๐ข๐ข l miss you ๐ข
๐๐๐๐ are u this kind of liyer
โ@@SAIKABHAT-ey2vdCan't even spell "liar" bruh
Why she left it or the company eliminate her why ?
"Thank you to everyone for the two week of heaven. ."
-Kim Garam
Kazuha remembers herโคI miss garam so mach๐ข๐ข๐ข๐
Yeah i loved their duo so much ๐ฅ imagine Eunchae,Garam and Kazuha three maknaez would be so iconic ๐ฅ
@@winterfication yeah! And garam was so beautiful!๐ขโค
@@tbilservici-pr6dr Yes and her voice was amazing โค๏ธ
@@winterfication yeah so soft and satisfating!
@@tbilservici-pr6dr True โค๏ธ
Imagine working so hard for your dream, training meticulously with so much effort for so long, and one jealous person comes along to snatch it all away
๐๐๐
๐ข๐ญ๐ญ
not only one person, but all those people behind the phone that doesn't have anything most important to do in their lifes than destroying a 16 years old girl's dream just because they believe in everything in the internet without being sure about the true and without knowing what really happened.
I especially feel bad for Eunchae, they had such a great bond and Garam was the closest to her age. Eunchae and Garam couldve been the little sisters in the group and best friends, but now its just Eunchae with the rest being adults(which is still great, but if I were her i would be deeply upset)
True ๐ฅ
What made me tear up even more is that during a weverse magazine, Garam would leave school early to pick up Eunchae, have something to eat together before they both go to the HYBE building ๐ญ๐ญ
@@JessPlays56 omg i Didn't knew the fact before and this is Just so whole some ๐ญ๐ญ๐ญ๐ญ
@@JessPlays56 hopefully theyre still friends, this situation is so sad but if they are still friends that would make it a tad bit better
And they look alike
She was my bias in the group the first girl I saw in the group. She deserves better. With her leserafim hits different. I hope she is doing well. We will always support you Garam ๐
Yeah i feel bad for Garam ๐ฅ Le sserafim feels like one of the part is incomplete in the group without Garam โค๏ธ
same๐ญ
Garam was also my first bias and all my friends said yes, she bullied and I always said that it didn't make any sense because she was too young for that , and in the end she was pronounced innocent and now she is no more
Sometimes i just feel so targeted because Garam and Soojin and jinni were all my biases and now they are goneโค๏ธ๐ญ
@@K-cado20 I feel with you, they were my bias too ๐ญ
The members remember her! Even chaewon remembers her:(
Fr ๐ญ
why wld they not remember her bro they trained n debuted together what are you on
@@lowlianne There is a video where Chaewon was talking about shooting their M/V and in a board, Chaewon drew all the six members of le sserafim and while talking about it Chaewon looked.like she was gonna cry
โ@@winterficationyeahh i remember......
Yea actually during the concert in hk, I think is a fan holding a board to let chaewon to do sth and chaewon did the pose that garam used to do๐ฅฒthey still remember garam.
Kazuha still misses garam and garam stays in zuhas heart. And she left the half heart for garam so kind and sweet.
All of Le Sserafim does
Ruining a 16 year old life is brutal
They only kept her for two week after years of training โน๏ธ
The groupโs best 18 daysโฆ ๐ข
That's so sad, she just wanted to make her dream come true, with her first fan where she waved, she was so happy
the fact that the people who are defending her are the same people who said death threats to her too. people are so ignorant
pov garam was your bias๐ฅบ
real
Mine๐ข
Fr ;-;
โคtruth
Is meee ๐
Garam didnโt deserve this ๐ข #justiceforgaram
#justiceforgaram(can we please make a chain to show our respect) ๐
#justiceforgaram continue this chain and whoever destroys it is disrespecting themselves
#justiceforGaram
#justiceforgaram
#justiceforgaram
#justiceforgaram
#justiceforgaram
#justiceforgaram
#justiceforgaram
#justiceforgaram โค
#justiceforgaram
I love you Kazuha for remembering Garam โคโคโค i love you two.
I donโt think any of yโall understand that the fimmies KNEW Garam. We fans may have seen her as an idol for a couple weeks, but those girls knew her for a long while! She trained with them, shared their struggles, and formed friendships with all 5 of those girls. And haters took her away from them!!!
Le Sserafim cared about Garam and no body can convince me otherwise; no one.
They had a wonderful bond in their early debut stages and it breaks my heart to look back on those old videos knowing Garam, someone they probably considered as a good friend or even a close sister, was forced to leave their group. All because of fake rumors.
All the people who were against her at the beginning ,and at the end where she was innocent are terrible because then they were for garam , they are not real fans
My own heart would break if something like that happened to me, they went through thick and thin, fought together and in the end made their debut together and then something like this happens
Same.. I miss garam with these 5 girls in Le Sserafim
This video made me cry so hard ๐ข. The song fits perfectly
๐ญ๐ญ๐ญ
Same!!
What's the name of this song?
@@yummyshop422
'Hurts So Good' by Astrid S ๐
@@yummyshop422
'Hurts So Good'
They took one of Her wings, now the five remaining are bonding and going stronger than ever. That's Le Sserafim ๐
Yeah โค๏ธ
I wish one day we can see garam again on Camera with le sserafim members It whould have been better if hybe whould just let garam speqk herslef and instead of hating on her just wait till the turth comes out lke hwat did they get by ruing a 16 year olds life she worked so hard i think it was the wirst for Manche since garam was the only one who is most close to her age if the turth had came out much earlier then none of this whould have happened #justiceforgaram
Yaah guys I just noticed that I made many tipping mistakes sorry for that and englsih is not my first language I wanted to say "like what did they get by ruining a 16 year olds life .... I think it was the worst for Manche (Eunchae) since garam was the one who was most close to her age if the truth had come...."
Garam responding and giving a statement wouldn't have made the situation any better, it would've made the situation worse, she would've still received all that hate for the rest of her career and would've gotten death threats. People really need to have a neutral stance on any sort of bullying allegation before the truth is revealed by the company. I know that HYBE isn't so dumb to debut such a member knowing there history with previous girl groups. They would have also not made such bold statements like Garam being the victim and the classmate being the bully(they might have not explicitly said that but that's what they were trying to say) without them having some solid proof of the fact
โ@@nabyabarman8374now She is proven as innocent and there are many billboards in kore to show support for her she is now going to be an actor
No one can forget one the person they love๐ข
Kazuha is big heart ๐ฅบโค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธ
They ruined a 16 year oldโs life
She doesnโt deserve this I love her sm ๐ขโค
The fact that Kazuha still always makes a half hearth for Garam they really miss her they didn't forget her poor garam deserved better
As a Fearnot I'm missing Garam very much ๐ข๐ข
Same with ne too ๐ข
MY GIRL DESERVED BETTER !!
HYBE REALLY FUCKED UP
OHHH....LE SSERAFIM MEMBERS MISS THEIR CUTIE๐ฅน๐ฅน๐ฅน I'LL NEVER FORGIVE THE PERSON WHO RUINED GARAM'S LIFE AND CAREER๐ข๐ข๐ข
BUT I'LL NEVER FORGET HERโค๐ข๐
Itโs sad that she was innocent but still got kicked out because of the rumours
@Emixplays That's the nature of the business.
IF there is any controversy, the company doesn't want to be caught in the crossfire.
What they should've done, especially since the CEO knew Garam well, was temporarily dismissed her until she was cleared of the charges and the allegations stopped.
Now I love Le Sserafim as the 5 that they are, but Garam's life is moving on and she's now going to a school for music and acting/film. So, maybe we will see her on the stage again someday as a singer, but maybe she will turn to acting full-time and get some solid roles.
One other thing, the current Le Sserafim members REALLY need to focus on working on improving their vocals. I love their choreos and their music, but they really struggled at the recent Coachella. It showed that they are not quite ready for that big show yet vocally as a whole.
Eunchae and Kazuha have the biggest potential to be great singers, and Eunchae did cry in frustration after because of her struggles at Coachella, which also means that she will want to get better.
Sorry for the long-ass reply.
miss you garam please come back soon ๐ฅน๐
I also want her to come in le sserafim again. But she is focusing on her acting, and i hope she is doing well โค๏ธ
Garam was happy and energetic girl in a k-pop group but people's wanted to tore her to shreds i just wish one day she'll be with the le sserafim again๐๐ป
I miss garam so so much and Kazuha misses her too๐ฅฒ
The way she always sticked with garam makes me feel sad ๐ข
@@redvelvet__ me too๐
I think everyone missed her after that and I think that part is just missing now , I'm so happy that they make such beautiful songs but every time I think what would happen if Garam was still there
Hybe tried to protect her, fans always have something to do to spoil the career. Garam was my bias too. I hope these haters go to hell
Also her real fans tried to protect her, but we failed ๐ Hope this happens to the haters who hated Garam.
If the news that it was fake could come out sooner! Even though they maybe kicked her out for popularity still isn't fair, because she worked so hard to get here and just kicked her out is so sad!!!!!!! Ahhhhh, this is making me cry, just reading all of yall comments, and listening to the music. (It's making me shake right now, I can't type correctyly when I'm shaking! I hope this doesn't happen to any idol again!
Awwe i miss her so much๐ญ
Yeah me too ๐ญ๐ญ๐ญ
Me three Iโm making a concert at school with my cousin and using only songs with her in it in memory ๐ข
@@13suns955 aww hope u perform well โค๏ธ. And appreciate that there are people who didnโt forget Garam ๐ฅ
She was my bias tho๐ญ
She was also my bias๐ญ
Garam was my bias. When I got know that Garam left the group, it made me so sad and I also cried ๐ข๐ญ๐
- Love you Garam โคโจ
Guys I know itโs so sad on what happened.. but big news! Garam is debuting as an actress now! Letโs all forget the past and support her in her new career.
I feel bad for Garam, I donโt know if the bullying thing is real but Le Sserafim didnโt deserve thisโฆ
Oh wait it isnโt real
What happened can anyone pls tell i ddint understand the short
@@Happy-go-lucky-d3u so basically there was a member of Le SSERAFIM called Garam, she got accused of bullying as soon as her teaser picture was uploaded, HYBE eventually kicked her out of LSRFM
@@Ani_offcl oh thx
@@Happy-go-lucky-d3u np ๐
I feel so bad for Garam, she didn't deserve the hate that came with the rumors, I'm so grateful for completely ignoring that scandal, I'm glad the scandal is cleared up. I heard Garam will be an actress, I'll support her forever.
Here to spread the message. @ John Jackson for credit
Garam is declared innocent of bullying and violence in the official school disciplinary report, therefore, she should have stayed in Le Sserafฤฑm. Garam defended a friend verbally who pleaded for help when Eunsoo took hidden photos of Garam's friend in her underwear and hacked a facebook account to post them online under another name to incriminate an innocent student. Eunsoo's rich father used his influence to push through a disciplinary committee that was biased against Garam. Yet, the level 5 offense that Garam received for defending her friend with a cuss word or two carried 0 severity points for violence and was the most common one given at her school, while Eunsoo's very rare level 8 offense carried 16-20 points in severity of violence which was beyond suspension. Yet, the rich father used his influence to get Eunsoo to transfer schools before the punishment could be implemented and jealous Eunsoo bullied Garam at the new school by getting boys in online chat rooms to threaten violence against her and keep inviting her so she couldn't leave the chats. Garam also had insults and obscenities written on her desk at school.
Eunsoo's intense jealousy of Garam debuting in her favorite kpop company was one of the primary driving forces for the lies and corruption to drive Garam out, but another pivotal reason the powers in kpop and South Korea were so rabid in going after Garam is that she stood up to the rich elite's perverted "right" to post child porn online, use blackmail to control girls' lives, and incriminate others by stealing their identity to post it so they don't get caught. In their demented minds, this is what they call a perpetrator of crimes. As a result, Eunsoo's rich father purchased a dirty law firm to file a fraudulent lawsuit with the ulterior motive of destroying Garam's career since it coincided with Garam's debut in Le Sserafim and had nothing to do with the stated intent which was accusing Garam of bullying, since the school incident happened four years before and was caused by the violent actions of sexual harassment and theft of a facebook account by Eunsoo.
According to the Korean Broadcasting System (KBS), Garam was by far the hardest hit target by Kakao Organization affiliated with Starship with 336 slanderous articles written to destroy her reputation. Kakao is currently under investigation by the FTC for reverse viral marketing. Kakao falsely claimed that Garam was an ex Starship trainee who was removed for bullying other members which was a lie. Furthermore, Kakao is responsible for the slanderous picture and article claiming that Garam had written down with Ive and other famous kpop groups on a blackboard, even though Garam is not seen in the picture and even though she hadn't attended that school since 2018 which was long before the group IVE even formed. Finally, they are responsible for lies about Garam bullying other Le Sserafim members. it is obvious that there was a coordinated conspiracy to cancel Garam, especially with the fake evidence and fabricated photos spread all over the internet by the fake victim, Eunsoo, her rich father's purchase of a dirty law firm to file a fraudulent lawsuit with the ulterior motive of destroying Garam's career, and Kakao's viral flooding of the internet with negative and slanderous articles against Garam who was innocent of the false allegations.
While Hybe appeared to defend Garam in a
superficial sense by putting out an official statement that recounted Garam's version of the story, it was done in an impersonal way with statements like According to Garam. Furthermore, it was issued too late, since it also announced that she was being placed on hiatus. However, the real incompetence and undermining by Hybe came from their refusal to let Garam make the public statement she requested in mid-April and their refusal to let her release the official school disciplinary report which she also had available in mid-April. Even worse, Hybe's complete betrayed of Garam came when they refused to release this critical information even after Eunsoo's side released a cropped and marked on part of the school disciplinary document which only indicated Garam's offense. Furthermore, they didn't release the testimonies of the many students that supported Garam's innocence. Hybe also never filed lawsuits for libel or slander against all the false information and incriminating faked photos posted by the fake victim (real bully) or against the death or sexual assault threats that were posted online which badly damaged Garam's reputation and traumatized her psychologically, especially since she rarely left her dorm room during the time of her hiatus because of anxiety and depression. This downcast condition and isolation persisted for an extended period even after Garam left Hybe and went home.
This cyber witch hunt fueled with malicious lies didn't give Garam's side of the story which would have been based, if it had been allowed to take place, on official school evidence, direct testimony and the emotional resonance of Garam's personal appeal. The effect was to create great hype at the moment of debut but to destroy the mental health of Garam who was falsely accused and served as the scapegoat for the group. There is even a haunting scene in an ad in which Garam falls really hard on a car which suggests that she is Hybe's fallen sixth angel, since Le Sseragim means six angels. Then after a long hiatus and a period of silence, Hybe dumped Garam with no attempt made to clear her name, even though they had all the evidence to do so and even though they had used the excuse of an upcoming trial against Eunsoo as the reason not to reveal the evidence to exonerate Garam. The defender against sexual exploitation, Garam, was severely punished and Eunsoo, the sexual offender of Garam's friend and facebook hacker was rewarded.
Therefore after Garam's unjust cancellation and while sunk in the depths of depression, it was left up to Garam with the help of her faithful friend Yudimi to muster up the strength to clear her name by releasing the official school disciplinary report and Garam's explanatory statement in August, in which Garam refuted many of the falsehoods by saying she never drank or smoked, never bullied or ordered anyone around, never transferred schools and never used violence. She also had the honesty to admit that she would have handled the defense of her friend a bit differently now that she had the perspective of more maturity but was adamant that in principle she had done the right thing because her parents had taught her the importance of defending a friend in a time of adversity. But honestly, Garam's actions seem really honorable and reasonable considering the severity of the offense: yelling and saying a couple of cuss words at Eunsoo for posting half nude photos of her friend as a profile pic online and hacking a facebook account to incriminate another student. Better yet, I thought of Garam's actions as a wise lesson posed as a question: If every member of a group and its fandom had the guts to defend a targeted member the way Garam defended her friend against a powerful and perverted enemy like Eunsoo, wouldn't all these unjust bullying cancellations like of Jimin, Soojin and Garam come to an end? In Garam's closing address in her letter, she thanked her fans with a harbinger of hope, GaramDream. And the strength of Garam's and Yudimi's efforts freed from Hybe's draconian restrictions turned the tide of public opinion in Garam's favor.
Presently, there are some hopeful signs such as Garam giving thanks to her fans on her birthday for her video banner in Seoul on November 16, and 6 days later the first beautiful photos of Garam in her yellow school uniform appeared on twitter. My hope is that if Garam wishes to return to music that she will go into jpop in Japan, as I think it would be safer and give her far more freedom of expression and action. Garam is also quite popular there, comments are more positive for her there than in South Korea, there are far fewer risks, and Japanese songs are longer with storylines that include acting in the videos, which is a great fit since she is currently studying acting at the School of Performing Arts. Plus, the big money influences and propaganda and cancellation campaigns waged against her in kpop will have far less influence in Japan and she will have better protection in Japan from the depravity of lies, misogyny, jealousy and hypocrisy. However, I will support her in whatever she decides to do especially if it is kpop or kdrama because she will need a lot more protection then. Garam is one of my very favorites because of her great beauty and charisma on stage and her fabulous singing, dancing, and her strong integrity of character at such a young age. Her soothing sweet vocals with a touch of sassiness in Blue Flame and Sour Grapes are like a delightful dream and her beautiful ferocity in Fearless is captivating. Her heartbreaking story and efforts to rise again from great persecution are a true inspiration and remind me of an epic movie, so it is certainly no coincidence that she is studying to be an actress. I just wish her the best of success, happiness with love and trust from family and friends, and warmth and understanding from all over the world.
damn. Give Garam her career back..
loved this comment๐ฏโค๏ธ
Im so gald i stayed true to garam and didn't hate her she was very nice i know she wouldn't have done that shes was amazing I'll never forget her i hooe she's happy and healthy wherever she is she literally worked so hard why would she bully someone if she knew she wanted to become s kpop idol i bet she knew b4 hand that kpop idols can't do that so why would she?she wouldn't have done that i miss her so much i didnt knew her long but ik she didnt deserve this she worked really hard only to have her dreams crushed i hope that class mate get whatever karma is coming to him/her
I miss her ๐ข๐ฅบ๐
Look I donโt know a lot abt LE SSERAFIM but this is a heart breaking story ๐ข
I love how kazuha was still making a heart for garam
I became a fearnot after garam left but when i came to know that she was accused of bullying and ppl came to know that she was innocent i never beleived those stupid scandals those ppl ruined her life she was rlly angel and nice girl poor her she doesn't or did not receive this much hate when i watched this video i literally started crying kazuha still remembers her i think u should have added another video of chaewon she also drew pic of 6 members after garam left i still keep remembering her and i still consider her as member i hope she debut in another group or soloist luv u garam unnieโคโคโคโคโค๐๐ i will always support u
I miss you very much Garam Unnie! I wish you the best in Acting school โก
i fell like my heart brakes everytime i see lsdm without grama . euchar lost her bff.grama was the sunshine of the group. after grama left eunchae lost her hopes and her smile.grama was eunchaea emotional support
"my dream came true for 14 days, ill cherish those days forever." - Kim Garam
Even tho im not a Le ssearfim fan i loved Garam so much just like the fans and it shows how much Garam had a dream of being a kpop idol but it seems like her haters classmates hated her and i feel like a pang of sadness when read the captions and the comments it made me tear up๐ข
The fact that the girls were adjusting themselves to adapt the situation after garam left ๐ข
eunchae nd garam bond ๐ฅบ๐คง
Gidle before 6members
LE SSERAFIM before 6members
Soojin stayed 3years
Garam stayed only 1 months maybe
They look like sisters same same but different
I wish both groups ot6 will come againโคโคโค
I feel so bad for garam like why ruin a 16 years old hard work she deserves so much better and the way that kazuha made a heart where garam shouldโve stand like they used to was just so heartbreaking
For me still lesserafim is incomplete ๐ข,garam I miss you๐ข
I donโt to say this but f- that girl who who said she got bullied by garam โน๏ธ
"My dream lasted for 14 days.I will always cherish those wonderful and lovely days๐ข"
-Kim Garam๐ข
I miss Garam
The fact Kazuha did not realize...
Canโt wait to see her be actors
tbh I feel like everyone was invisible and Garam was highlighted as the main character and when she left all other members got their spotlight and now Eunchae became the main member. They were almost like Ive where Wony was highlighted a lot that makes other members invisible. I think it was best she left and now going to debut as actress. She does have a star quality and actress material. So everything went well after all๐
Sometimes i just feel so targeted because Garam and Soojin and jinni were all my biases and now they are goneโค๐ญ
Famous Last Words Of Kim Garam
"i Was Happy Being An idol for 2 weeks" ๐ญ๐คง๐คง
Its so sad seeing them this broken only fearnots and neverlands get what i mean..
they miss her so much so do we itโs sad ๐ข
"My dream only lasted for 2 weeks,but I will cherish those days forever"
~ Kim garam
Aww i just read the whole story about Garam and i really feel bad ๐ขโค
When Garam said "my dream only lasted in 14 days.." broke my heart..i wasn't Lesserafim fan when she was in le sserafim but..i anyways miss her..if she was in Lesserafim she will be my bias..but she isnt...lets make purple ocean for Garamnie..
๐ญ๐ญ๐ญ
๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐
For Garam๐๐ป
Bring Garam backkkkk ๐ข #GiveGaramAChance
Some people just ruined the perfect to be life of 16 year old girl haram.She was so talented and kind to all.๐ฅบ๐ฅบ
The things happen -One of her classmate make a false accusation of her bullying kids .Hybe defended her but stills all was on his classmate side and she got kicked out.If she wasn't kick out all group would be disband.That kind soul left her dreams ,idol life,fame, for some unknown 5 girls .Thats show how sweet heart she is โคโค
Later after months the accusation become false but it runied the life of her .She was so good .I have even known to that she got death threats . ๐ข๐ข๐ข
Miss u garam โคโคโคโค
Kazuha will never bale to forgot her ๐ข๐ข๐ข๐ข๐ข
Imagine that you worked so hard to achieve your dreams and finally after you do someone come and breaks it into pieces in no time. I don't actually know them but after reading the pinned comment i felt like crying. That bully just ruined someones hard work and shattered their dream.๐ข๐ข
For real like how much jealous they can get just let her live her life when she became successful they had to ruin it for her. Toxicity everywhere I mean I get it she wasn't an angel in her childhood but she apologized and was trying to improve๐
"I am happy even though my dream only lasted 2 weeks"
~ Kim Garam
Garam we miss you ๐ฟ
We miss her so much I feel her pain it make me cry I feel everyday
It must be hard losing someone who could have been a sisiter for you๐ข
LE SARAFILM LOST THEIR SMILES ๐ฅบ๐ญ
i really cannot take these kind of bullies, really. i was a fan of kpop for 2 years but stopped liking afterwards because such things always happens to celebrities. now I like cpop, Chinese boy groups and girl groups. however, my idol left the group upon debuting in less than 48 hours. i really want to stop such people from being so mean. In fact, this incident made my idol, who was a forever cheerful kind of person, have social stress and he requested to leave the group. The company still wants him back, so they still try to include past memories in their videos, but its still unintentionally hurting him when he sees these memories that he knew that it will never happen again. Never in his life will he be able to be with them and fulfil his dream. i really want to put a stop o this. when I heard about garam, I already felt very upset. and now, with a innocent 18 yr old who trained under the company for 7 years leaving? i really cannot take it. what does others want from them? if they end up feeling bad for their past actions , are they ever able to return them time and their effort to be joining the group? if its a no, then why do it?
The forgotten member of lesserafim
Iโm sure le sserafim still have a little space for Garam in their heartsโคโคโค
I hope she becomes successfull in actingโค
It's very sad ๐ข
It's great that they dousn't forget her โค
My fisrt bias in le sserafim
I miss Garam so much, I want her to come back to LE SSERAFIM
I really wished she wouldโve been able to come back bc maybe she would have, le sserafim hasnโt felt like le sserafim since she left and she doesnโt deserve it, she didnโt do anything wrongโฆ
I miss garam so much ๐ข
I miss her so much
She was My bias and she will be forever
I wish her success and happiness wherever she is. Fighting Garam โค
Kazuha really misses her I think garam also misses kazuha
I'm still here for Garam , my second bias Forever โพ๏ธโค
i left le sserafim cause garam left after i saw illit i remember garam in wonhee and moka so i stanned illit Cause they remind me of the old days i used to stan garam:(
" My dream lasted 16 days I'll cherish those days forever "
- Kim Garam ๐ข
Imagine working hard to be an idol just to get kicked out bc of hate.๐ข I feel bad for her
Guys! For the last clip, let's fill in that heart for them! ๐โค
we will always miss Garam she was so sweet โค๐ข
They are no longer fearless๐๐
He missed her so much... How about we raise hashtags and demand her return to the band?
The contracts terminated and Garams apparently becoming an actress
@@Ilynot ooh ๐ it's okay
I love you garammmโคโค i bias i will never forget you i will never replace u ๐
The fact garam was my bias I hate those people who did that to her she was natural and made to be a kpop idol and also she was Eunchae best friend.
Kazuha literally didnt remember gam is gone and made a heart for her