Did a White Hole Create Our Universe? Carlo Rovelli Explores Cosmic Mysteries
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 гру 2023
- Forget everything you thought you knew about the Big Bang. This video cracks open a mind-bending theory that challenges the textbook cosmos: what if our universe wasn't born in a fiery explosion, but rather spewed forth from a cosmic fountain called a white hole?
Dive with us into a reality where gravity can flip the script, where black holes aren't the only cosmic vacuum cleaners. We'll explore the fascinating science of white holes, theorized to be the exact opposite - spewing out matter and light with explosive force. Could they even be time-reversed black holes, bridges through spacetime connecting us to another universe?
This journey gets even wilder when we consider the information paradox: what happens to matter swallowed by a black hole? Could it be encoded and released by a white hole, like echoes whispered across the fabric of reality? This opens the door to a mind-blowing possibility: our universe's origin story might not be a simple point of singularity, but a complex cosmic dance involving information, energy, and maybe even parallel universes!
The implications are staggering. If white holes are real, does our existence become part of a vast, infinite cycle? Do we live in a cosmic tapestry woven from countless universes, birthed and reborn through these mysterious fountains? It's a philosophical rabbit hole that challenges our understanding of creation, existence, and our place in the grand scheme of things.
But even if white holes remain theoretical, their pursuit pushes the boundaries of our knowledge. This quest is a testament to the human spirit, our insatiable thirst to unravel the universe's deepest secrets. Whether they exist or not, white holes remind us that the cosmos is far more wondrous and mysterious than we currently comprehend.
Join us on this intellectual adventure as we explore the science, philosophy, and sheer awe-inspiring wonder of white holes. It's a journey that will leave you questioning everything you thought you knew about the universe, and your place within it. Buckle up, grab your cosmic compass, and let's explore the biggest secret hiding in the shadows of the cosmos!
Don't forget to like, subscribe, and hit that notification bell to stay tuned for more mind-bending cosmic mysteries!
Subscribe to Science Time: / sciencetime24
#whiteholes #universe #origins #cosmology #bigbang #science #philosophy #mystery #informationparadox #mindblowing #spacetime - Наука та технологія
Yes it did. Spewing energy and mater from either another section of our larger and eternal universe (beyond what we call observable), or from another universe (black hole ripping through the fabric of one, ejecting as a white hole into another).
You should really credit Brian Cox in the video at 4:57 to 7:12, like you do Rovelli.
I like Carlo Rovelli, his books are amazing to read, and deeply thought provoking, he comes across as a scientist with poetic, imaginative insight. Thank you for this intriguing video.
Yes. Think “The Great Attractor” to get a rough idea. There is even a Very Large dipole signature in the CMB. Really one of the coolest theories out there. Seems many people have independently came up with it or heard from someone I’m not aware. But some fail to take it further and acknowledge the possibility of a cyclic Universe... Torus shaped.
Black holes are based on a mathematical misconception. General Relativity predicts dilation, not singularities. Most people don't know that Einstein said that singularities are not possible. In the 1939 journal "Annals of Mathematics" he wrote -
"The essential result of this investigation is a clear understanding as to why the Schwarzchild singularities (Schwarzchild was the first to raise the issue of General Relativity predicting singularities) do not exist in physical reality. Although the theory given here treats only clusters (star clusters) whose particles move along circular paths it does seem subject to reasonable doubt that more general cases will have analogous results. The Schwarzchild singularities do not appear for the reason that matter cannot be concentrated arbitrarily. And this is due to the fact that otherwise the constituting particles would reach the velocity of light."
He was referring to the phenomenon of dilation (sometimes called gamma or y) mass that is dilated is smeared through spacetime relative to an outside observer. It's the phenomenon behind the phrase "mass becomes infinite at the speed of light". Time dilation is one aspect of dilation.
Dilation will occur wherever there is an astronomical quantity of mass because high mass means high momentum. There is no place in the universe where mass is more concentrated than at the center of a galaxy. Dilation is the original and correct explanation for why we cannot see light from our own galactic center.
It can be shown mathematically that dilation is occurring in our own galactic center. This means that there is no valid XYZ coordinate that we can attribute to it, you can't point your finger at something that is smeared through spacetime. More precisely, everywhere you point is equally valid. This is the explanation for dark matter, the missing mass is dilated mass.
Einstein wrote about dilation occurring in "large clusters of stars" which is basically a very low mass galaxy. For a galaxy to have no/low dilation it must have very, very low mass (or low mass in its center). It has recently been confirmed in 5 very, very low mass galaxies to show no signs of dark matter. For the same reason binary stars will always have predictable rotation rates.
What we see in modern astronomy has been known since 1925. This is when the existence of galaxies was confirmed. It was clear that there should be an astronomical quantity of light emanating from our own galactic center. It wasn't until the 1960's when television and movies started to popularize black holes did the concept slowly became mainstream.
Seemingly very few scientists believed in a physical singularity. From what I've understood, It was just such a mind bending idea that it got widely repoted in popular media, leading normies like me to believe it was an established hypothesis.
Yes, it's always been a stubbornly persistent fictional term. The recent discovery that very, very low mass galaxies have normal star rotation rates is virtual proof that dilation is occurring in common spiral galaxies. This is the obvious explanation for the "missing mass" problem.@@VikingTeddy
In 2020, Roger Penrose won a Nobel Prize for “The Singularity Theorem” for *proving* that “Black Hole formation is a robust prediction of Einstein’s general theory of relativity”
General Relativity predicts dilation not singularities. It's the reason Planck, Einstein, Dirac, Schrodinger, Heisenberg, Bohr, Feynman and every other physicists between 1925 and 1960 didn't believe in singularities.
Dilation explains dark matter. It also explains the CMB. If the WMAP satellite was positioned outside the bounds of our galaxy it would record a background radiation of zero or near zero.
@@Scissors69
@@Scissors69
even mainstream is questioning singularities now. ‘Roy Kerr’
This video is a mind-bending exploration of some of the most profound questions about the cosmos. Carlo Rovelli's insights into the possibility of a white hole creating our universe are both enlightening and thought-provoking. It's remarkable how he breaks down complex scientific concepts into digestible and fascinating explanations.
The way this video delves into cosmic mysteries and theories is truly engaging. It leaves viewers with a sense of wonder about the vastness and intricacies of the universe. Carlo Rovelli's passion for the subject matter is palpable and contagious, making this a must-watch for anyone curious about the origins of our universe.
Kudos to the creators for delivering such an intellectually stimulating and captivating video! 👏🌌🧠
So what is it?
We know space time is affected by collisions of BH & neutron stars Further more Space time is denser around large clumps of matter like galaxies. My theory is BH suck in space time for eons this explains the thinning of space time between galaxies and we perceive this as expansion When the the balance hits a critical point of space time verses matter and all hell breaks loose as a white hole
Don't ever let anyone tell you that anything is 'settled science'.
More of an expansion and less of an explosion. If you can't get that right, everything that follows feels purely speculative.
Yep.
Oh no! Soon we will be arguing over which one is better the white hole or the black hole🤔 cosmic thinking.
In another universe, you wrote this comment
Um, the other end of a black hole is the white hole... 🤷
They literally show a white hole connected to a black hole but fail to acknowledge it. GR even says a whitehole should exist even though that theory is mostly nonsense. 😊
Sí sí yo creo eso pero no sabemos si sea real o es un truco dice Chus y creo en eso
You always say this great event happened in space that created the universe but you never ask where the space came from. Space is just as much an object as form.
They ask that very obvious question all the time.
No such thing as space 🤏There is NO space without time. Solve the time puzzle rule the existence🤏 Time is truly the engineers/creator secret.
Photon of light doesn’t feel time. It just exists. So space itself is relative & not only time 🤏
@@voraciousfredsure thing. Space is clear and timeless. Yet dynamic in its creativity. Like a clear screen displaying the universe within it, on it. Space being uncreated is most certainly god. And its creation is the display of what we call reality or the phenomenal universe. Without the primal creative space there could be no form. And without form there would be nothing. I call it the nondual space-form reality. Because emptiness / space is dynamic and purely intelligent it is bound to create / manifest itself as a universe. Thanks for your comment.
@kodeone I don't think you are learning anything from these videos.
Black hole meets white hole?
So….then did a white hole create our universe!?
Happy Merry Christmas & Happy New Year ~ 2024 ~ ! 💝 💯 👏 🎉 🎃 🙏 🚀 👍 🤖 🎅 ✝ 🎄 🌝 !
Hmmm 2 comments missing already, I wonder what thoughts are being suppressed
God bless similarity reverse golden rose boom and never heard of it before I was dead on earth today justification justice ⚖️ I don't know if there's anyone else in the world 🌎 there's no way of getting the glory of Jesus Christ almighty salvation lord judge Messiah beautiful spirit thank you god
????
Since it's not an implosion or an explosion, wouldn't a better name fo the 'Big Bang' be a Displosion?
Pure science fiction ours imagination knows any boundaries just the creation in our mind and speculation ( anyone's can do it)
No. Brian Cox created the Universe.
Everything and anyone can do it in they own imagination ( so simple)
@albin2232 The scottish actor?! Geezo, what a guy.
No, it was just your mom farting. XD
If we don't observe, it doesn't exist 😉
Black hole is a downward triangle like a female. While hole is a upward triangle like a man. So, when we combine them, we have a STAR with 6 spokes. Ahh.. now I understand why son of Shiva (man) & Shakti (female) is called Shanmukha (six faces) / Karthikeya (Cluster of six).
This is about astrophysics. Not astrology or mythology
@@__cypher__ - I know. But personifications by our ancestors helps us today to understand why did so, when things become more clear nowadays with scientific advance. Ex. Sun's chariot with 7 horses was one of the fastest. Now we know, sunlight can be spilt into 7 colours & indeed sunlight is one of the fastest.
White hole is the stupidest idea I have ever heard of 🤪
Are you not familiar with religion that shit is just an excuse for not learning anything
A white hole 😅. How dumb are we prepared to be in our desperation to deny that God made and sustains it all?
There is no evidence for that at all. All of science would be happy to see these caveman fairytales as real if there was evidence they were.
Science deals with the natural world, physical evidence and able to prove and disprove things. God cannot be tested by science, god is supernatural and outside the natural world.
God?😅😂
@@voraciousfred no god didn't. A human wrote that into a fictional book saying that a god said it.
So, by definition, God is responsible for the pain and suffering experienced by innocent children who die of cancer? If God is omnipotent, can He create a rock that He can not lift?
So what is it?