Brothers and sisters, as you can see in the comments here from Arabic speakers, ChatGPT FAILED this test! No surprise 😄 Many great poets in the past have attempted this challenge and they all failed. This is because God is all-knowing and most gracious. We cannot create word that is better than God's. Subhanallah
As a native Arabic speaker i can say this: The language used is very basic, children in primary school could come up with such a language for their essay and its nowhere close to Quran. To give an example close to what i see, imagine a child 9y old and Shakespeare describing a view or a thing, they are doing the same thing but the language used isn't even comparable. Any Arabic speaker could tell at first glance this isn't even close to compare Enjoyed the video, keep it up.
@@monkeyninjaking4441daniel asked the arabic speakers to give their impression of the arabic text that the Ai made, and this commenter gave his impression! which i personally find valid.
@@jooi7722 and as i said chat gpt isnt even defaulted to arabic, if you asked him to write in any language it would be simple cus its a simple ai that is defaulted to english
As an arab I laughed when I read the verse produced by chatgpt, the style of writing is so poor it remembered me of childhood cartoons script it has nothing to do with the quranic style, this without mentioning the deep meanings and rethoric along with the consistency. Subhanallah the languistic elequency of the Quran is so obvious and inimitable.
same reaction brother XD , i laughed so hard of the attempt , even a non arab who learned arabic , after 2 years of learning can do better than that hahahaha
I'm native Arabic speaker Believe me, the style of the Qur'an has no analogue in Arabic literature, pre-Islamic or post-Islamic, even the Prophet's sayings are completely different from the Qur'an.
The Arabic version sounds like some child wrote it 🤣 .. I mean even if you didn't understand Arabic and i beautifully recited that to you, i bet you would 1000% tell it's not from the Quran
@@abdoulayeguisse2196 man get out here .. the guy did that for entertainment purposes.. it's not like he didn't know the outcome.. if you don't know what fun is then I'm sorry for you 😉
I started learning Arabic since it's not my language, and even I can come up with a better wording than that. it was a fun video, keep it up, and may Allah bless us all.
Its nice to see people trying they're best at learning arabic, and understanding the quran. Reach me out if you need help as I am a native arabic speaker, and quite frankly, a japanese learner!
Islam is the only solution for all the problems in the world, Quran is law and way of life with zero conterdection, I am proud to be Muslim from San Francisco California ❤ alhamdulila for Islam
Aisha was nine Muhammad was a child molester it disgusts me that this person is considered the profit at all the Lord Christ was spoken of more times in the Koran then Mohammed himself. If you did not follow the Hadith
The quran has an inherent rhythm and melodious Even non native Arabic speakers children cam memorise the entire quran due to it being rhythmic and easy to read This chat gpt verse is like reading a newspaper, can't get the verse on my tongue so easily
After I have read the Quran, I realized that all what humanity needs is this heavenly law. “The legislation of Quran will spread all over the world, because it agrees with the mind, logic and wisdom.” - Leo Tolstoy
The suggestion in Arabic, is like a simple advise, can never immitate the Glorious Qu'ran unique structure, the profound multiple meanings with the shortest words possible abbreviation, the beauty and sleekness, the ease of memorization, snd without even mentioning the Mathematical miracles found in every verse in the Glorious Qu'ran. Just name a few.
Am here laughing because I can also write basic Arabic. The Quran has it's own rythimic style with meaning. Even if the whole world decides to write one verse in its style, we can't.
Each quran verse contain= miraculous pronunciation+ clear meaning+ sign so i can say easily chatgpt failed the test As an Arabic man i tried to recite the verse chatgpt produced but i can't and it meaningless to me subhanllah ❤️
Alhamdulilah for Islam Alhamdulilah for the biggest blessing that is Islam and the holy Quran No one and nothing will be able to replicate it It's the final testament the unchanged word of ALLAH the final revelation sent to the Prophet Muhammad Peace and blessings be upon him ❤
Failed miserably… LOL Specialist in Arabic. Anyone who reads The Holy Quran in Arabic and reads this verse will laugh like never before, same as I did. 😂😂😂😂😂😂 Even the English version is so shallow! Read the Quran yourself and you will know what I mean. This is not mentioning the feelings that come to you when you read the Quran. Why do you have tears when reading it? Mind blowing!!!
As an Arabic speaker Just read it by looking without moving the lips Firstly, I realize directly that this sentence is not from the words of God Almighty, and it differs in the linguistic structure of the sentences, the words used, and the style from the Holy Qur’an Secondly, I read it again while contemplating the meanings of the sentence. I realized the weakness of the moral connection between the sentences This is far from being compared to the Holy Quran When you read or listen to the word of God Almighty in the Holy Quran in his language and understand it Your senses can automatically differentiate between the words of God and the words of other than God in the same language And what is the Qur'an and what is not from the Qur'an in its language No one can even change or reduce something from it or add something to it without this change being easily detected The Qur'an is a linguistic and moral structure at a level that reconciles with human mental capacity It cannot be compared to his Arabic language And you will realize that when you know Arabic well I'm trying to tell you what honey tastes like Like you haven't tasted it yet ...
I’ve always wondered if AI can pass this test as well, ever since Elon Musk talked about it, so thank you for doing this As a native Arabic speaker, I can tell you that the test was failed miserably. The Arabic used is sooo weak, like it was written by a very average person, not even a poet or anything. I don’t know how to explain it, but it’s the same reason I always found the Bible (and even the English translations of the Quran to be weak) You can’t truly understand the depth of a language until you learn Arabic and then read the Quran. I speak 3 languages, and understand a couple more, nothing comes close to the linguistic depth of the Quran. I am a songwriter as well, and I’ve tried so hard to come up with something that could remotely resemble a verse in the Quran but it’s literally frustrating.. the pull ur hair kind 😅 Let’s not even get into the sea of numerical, scientific, etc etc.. miracles found in this book of wonder. Hope that helped 🙏🏼
One Surah LIKE IT means it should have Mind-blowing mathematical patterns, elegance, rhyme, unique style and a balance. it should be the truth, should have no contradiction with the Quran and fit well with the rest of the Surah and verses, a guidance to Mankind that went straight to their hearts, it should be Furqan (criteria to distinguish between truth and falsehood), it should have future prophecies, ''scientific'' accuracy that go to against reailty (not talking about our perception btw), it should explain the human phycology like Quran does, it should have historical accuracies, etc and much more than my little mind can comprehend. Even if the whole world Believed that AI had created Surah like it, I would still not believe it because indeed it would be nothing more than deception.
اللغة المستخدمة لا تماثل نسق القرآن الكريم من حيث البلاغة والبيان والفصاحة. أنا انصحك بتعلم اللغة العربية لتعلم مدى جمال لغة القرآن وروعته، لقد عجز كثير من فصحاء العرب حتى يومنا هذا عن محاكاة هذه البلاغة والبيان.
Brooo. The challenge in the Qur'an was to produce a whole chapter like it, not a verse. And yet the single verse that ChatGPT produced is nothing like the Qur'an. Subhan Allah ❤
Dear brother ,there are many challenges in 1 challenge . Not just words but synchronization,placing and signs , for example . Periodic table numbers in quran. Iron is 42 in arabic numericals in quran. And other chemicals like zinc,copper and many are the same word from 1st word in counting as in periodic table. And many more elements. Write any field you can think of bio,geo,astro, anything and write miracle in quran. Or the distance from earth to moon and sun, you can look for that too in vdos it's explained with alphabet numericals. You'll find more then many .
yes, I'm a pediatric specialist and All scientists agrees that the embryological description and stage of development in Quran can't come from any source except our great creator Allah سبحانه و تعالى
@@الاءمصطفىالرفاعيreally? how come then quran makes the same errors that Galen (which lived several hundred years before quran was written)? How come it fails to even mention the most important items: the human egg and sperm cells? And how why does the stages come in wrong order? bones is not grown before flesh etc...
I am an Arabic speaker, and this sounds like a statement written by a middle schooler tbh. In no way it is in the same level of significance, poeticism, level of value, factualness or language strength neither grammatically nor vocabulary as the Quran. No way even to be compared. And what does "truth is life" mean and why it was added with absolute no value? the holy Quran approach is saying the least while stating the most value. God is eloquent, he does not add statements or words for extra-dressing or for just the rhyme. thank you for doing this you have just proved ChatGPT to not be up even by a little bit for the challenge. God is forever wise forever merciful. I applaud you.
Assalamu Alaikum my brother, Revert here, raised a catholic by good parents, After reading the Quran which was given to me by my co-worker, my co-worker to me, Just read the book with an open mind, Let me know if you got questions or comments. I had a broken collar bone from an auto accident, spend a good 6 months at home, yes I was bored, started to read my friends Quran , I wanted to find mistakes and contradictions. The Holy Quran challenged me, NEVER in my Life I have Read a book like this, I Love reading Books from an very early age. Allah Akbar!
Let’s not forget that the Quran asks for a chapter not a verse. Also, it isn’t just the case of having a beautifully eloquent chapter but also one that is as impactful as the Quran. Nothing that anyone writes will ever come close to how impactful the Quran is - just think about how many people read the Quran daily and have memorised the Quran and live their lives based on the teachings of the Quran. The Quran has touched the hearts of billions. No chapter from any other book can do this.
The Challenge in the quran is impossible to compete because the quran has it's own arabic and grammer and poet and everything there are many words in it that arabs themselves don't even know the meaning it's like a miracle when it came to native speakers challenging them with their own language and also the quran talks in many topics in one book which is hard to copy it too
As a native Arab I can say that, it failed miserably on all levels, whether it be eloquence or in meaning and coherency, for example, the point you have alluded to, if life is truth then death is? Falsehood....fail. If God is truth and truth is life then death can overcome God.....fail again, and please don't get me started on the eloquence factor....fail fail fail.
😂😂 yah and It is true that the Qur'an is so beautiful and amazing. Indeed, it cannot be compared, even though the wording of the Al is far from the Qur'an.
There is one verse in the Quran, 18:78. قَالَ هَٰذَا فِرَاقُ بَيْنِى وَبَيْنِكَ ۚ سَأُنَبِّئُكَ بِتَأْوِيلِ مَا لَمْ تَسْتَطِع عَّلَيْهِ صَبْرًا 18:78 : He said: This is the PARTING BETWEEN me and between you. I will inform you about the interpretation of that over which you could not maintain patience. This word 'PARTING' if in Arabic will END with the letter Q. This Verse itself will begin with letter Q. This are the only 2 letter Q of the verse. ------------- If exactly IN BETWEEN this Verse 18:78 and the very START of the Quran, total sum of all the letter Q will = 3516. AND if exactly IN BETWEEN this Verse 18:78 and the very END of the Quran, total sum of all the letter Q will AGAIN = 3516 !!! ------------- If that fictional VERSE created by the Ai is also added into Quran, then this pattern would probably cease to exist. And so could many other numerical patterns and even scientific miracles of the Quran too !
Assalamu alaykum brother. There is no challenge in the Qur'an about producing a verse! Indeed, a verse may be composed of 2 single letters as in sourat 20 (طه). The challenge is about producing a sourat, the shortest one in the holly Qur'an is 3 verses long (108).
Native Arabic speaker here, To me it seems the AI generated the verse first by referencing English translations of the Quran, then generated a verse in English and translated it literally to the Arabic language. Because to me the structure and language sounds similar to the English language in the bible which is not as linguistically complex. This might be the AI's limitation as a primarily English bot (as it mentioned), but I can also imagine that linguistically, producing rhetoric with the Arabic language is complex and subjective. Therefore, it is harder to code in an AI. Nevertheless, I am not denying the miracle of the Quran, and alhamdulillah my imaan increased after seeing it here for myself. I think the brother here was doing it to really witness the miracle and not out of disrespect or challenge. P.S I was pleasantly surprised that "Cultural and Religious Respect.exe" was coded into the AI though😂
The first thing I noticed in the Arabic that it does not carry the poetic features of Quran it's very simplistic. But what caught my attention is the use of the word truth translated "Huq" in Arabic which is one of the 99 attributes of Allah. So basically it discounted 98 of the other attributes which means it can never be complete since religion can never be formed based solely on our truth since to each his own truths and humanity will fall into further conflict. Islam is complete and holistic. This was a great video thanks Daniel
كتاب الله إعجاز سيتحدى الجميع إلى قيام الساعة كلام الله نقرأه ونشعر كأنها اول مره نقرأه له طريقه خاصه في التلاوة لم تكن إلا للقرآن الكريم احب كلام الله ❤
Take the shortest final 3 surahs, Al Ikhlas, AlFalaq & Annas. All ending of the words have same sound/rhyme. Eg Ahad, Somad, Yulad, Ahad : Falaq, kholaq, Waqob, Uqod, Hasad : Binnas, Malikkinnas, Illahinnas, Khonnas, Rinnas, Wannas, Same goes to AlFatihah - 'Alamin, Rohim, Middin, Ta'in, Mustaqim, Waladdhollin.
I have read the Quran with translation once and reading it for second time. I can say that this verse created by Chatgpt isn't even close to the beautiful coherent words of ALLAH in Quran.
يا محمد ان استطعت ان تأتينا بآية فات بها ولكن ما استطعت ان كنت من عند الله نبيا فات بالملائكة او إئت بربك كما زعمت علينا وان لم تستطع فقد علمناك من الكاذبين (١) لا الشمس تجري حول الارض ولا هي تغرب في عين حمئة وقد علمناك من الجاهلين (٢) وما كان قوله لهم الا ان ربه لم يأت بآية فكلما جاءت الرسل بالايات ما كان من الناس الا ان اعرضوا وكذبوا بهم قل اتعلم ما في قلوبنا إن تأت بآية نؤمن لك ولكن ما استطعت فاذهب انت وربك وأتيا بالايات ان كنتما فاعلين (٣) وما كان قول محمد الا اني بشير ونذير واني بشر من رب العالمين (٤) لو علمنا سفهك يا محمد ما تركناك بيننا فانك كنت مع القوم المفسدين (٥) Easy peasy here is my new surah of the Quran that i just created while i was taking a dump thats how easy it is to
هذا بالضبط مثل الذي أنزل على مسيلمة. ضربة يمين وضربة شمال وكلمة من روايات عبير وكلمة من الشارع و وبعدها نشر على يوتيوب بفخر. إذا جهابذة اللغة العربية التي انزلت الآية فيهم عجزوا عن مواجهة التحدي.. تأتي أنت من عامة العامة وتقول واجهت التحدي؟ أنا غير متخصص في اللغة العربية لكني والله وبدون ذرة جهد عرفت انك مسيلمة ولكن قزم بسبب الركاكة الشديدة في الهبل اللي رسلته. وأغبى شيء هو "اني بشر من رب العالمين". يا راجل 😂😂😂😂 قرح الله جحرك.. وجحرك كلمة يمنية ابحث عنها واستفيد لغة عربية يا بهيمة.
القرآن واضح وبسيط في اللغة العربية ..لا يحتوي علي كلمات صعبة ..ولكن لا تستطيع اختيار نفس الكلمات البسيط وتركيبها فسرعان ما تفسر علي انها للأطفال .. The Qur’an is clear and simple in the Arabic language..it does not contain difficult words..but you cannot choose the same simple words and put them together, so they are quickly interpreted as if they are for children..
Funny enough Quran 22:6 says “That is because Allah ‘alone’ is the Truth, He ‘alone’ can give life to the dead, and He ‘alone’ is Most Capable of everything”. Truth is one of the 99 names of Allah (Allah is the Arabic word for God, Arabic Bible and Torah translations use it to translate the word God) So even ChatGpt recognizes that that there is no God but Allah (the one God of the monotheist religions)
To be realistic It cannot... the only thing it can do is copy paste from random verses within Quran itself... the problem in this scenario will come disturbing the numerical ordering for example the basic principal that Quran follows is maintaining base of 19 which will break immediately. Now lets assume it brings missing words to compute and fill this gap then another problem starts right there which is maintaining not only the words positions but even characters which is not possible even with the most powerful AI with all full knowledge of probability topics like combinations and permutations for example the mention of the Sun in the verse 21:33 which contains simply 3 words كُلٌّۭ فِى فَلَكٍۢ are enough to bend human minds (try reading left to right and then right to left its still the same) also giving a deep meaning Sun being in the middle and others in orbit around it.
I am curious as to the definition of, "like the Quran". What exact combination of qualities would the new document need to have in order for it to be deemed, "like the Quran"? If one were to attempt the challenge, who would be qualified to determine if the new document is indeed, "like the Quran". The challenge seems meaningless unless the parameters are defined.
يقول الروبوت : "لا اله الا الحق و الحق هو الحياة و فاعملوا بالحق و اعملوا خيرا , لان الحق يهديكم الى الطريق السوي و يساعدكم على تحقيق السلام و الوئام في الحياة الدنيا و الاخرة ." الانتقاد: اولا : لا يوجد جمال لحن مثل القرآن , فطريقة النطق كأنه كلام عادي جدا ثانيا : الاله هو الحق , هذا صحيح , فالله هو الحق التام ولا يوجد فيه الباطل فالحق هو صفة الكمال لله اما الحق هو الحياة ؟؟ كيف هذا ؟؟ , الجملة الصحيحة هي : الله هو الحي الذي لا يموت او الله هو سبب الحياة حتى و ان كان قصده الله هو سبب الحياة او الله هو الحي , فيجب ان يقول الله هو سبب الحياة و ليس الحق هو سبب الحياة او يقول الله هو الحي و ليس الحق هو الحي لان اذ الله وصف نفسه بصفة فيكون سياق باقي الكلام على تلك الصفة مثال توضيحي : الله هو الجبار و الجبار هو الرحمان سياق غريب كان بامكانه مثلا القول هو : الله الجبار الرحمان ننتقل الي بعده ثالثا : فاعملوا بالحق و اعملوا خيرا , لان الحق يهديكم الى الطريق السوي و يساعدكم على تحقيق السلام و الوئام خلاصة قول الروبوت هو : اذ تعمل بالحق و تحكم بالحق فسيأتيك السلام .و هذا خطا كثير من الاشخاص تكلموا بكلمة الحق و سجنوا و عقبوا و هذه الاشياء معروفة عندنا كبشر و ثاني شيء : ان حينما يامر الله لا يجب الطلب منه السبب لانه هو خالقك لكن سنتغضى عن هذا و نصحح للروبوت ما يريد قوله اي كان بامكانه قول بدل ذلك , هذه الجملة : فاعملوا بالحق و الخير , لان الحق يهديكم الى الطريق المستقيم و ستلقوا جزاء اعمالكم في الدنيا و الاخرة .
The arabic version has no depth, it's as something I would read in the Bible.. No poetic meaning, in language or style is very shallow compared to Quran.. 8:01
As a muslim and arabic native speaker, i couldn't retain my laugh reading the arabic generated text.. as i am sitting in a library.. really did my best not laughing. An attempt to compare this to al Qoran would be in itself an insult to the books and whatever has anything to do with a religion
In another video chatGPT accepted the challenge right away to imitate surah Al-Kousar. However, it failed so miserably over and over after so many attempts that it even admitted, that as a text model I can't produce something like that due to creativity limitations. It's the shortest surah in Quran of literaly only three sentences and 10 words. People should really think about it, that if a book challenges the humankind 1400+ years ago and you still can't do it with all that AI, just admit it.
This is like Shakespeare wrote"Everything that glitters is not gold" and he said try to make a sentence like that and I wrote "Everything that glitters is not diamond"😂😂
Here's one from another LLM that I got at my first attempt: Here's a verse in Arabic inspired by the eloquence and style found in the Qur'an: بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم أَفَلَا يَتَدَبَّرُونَ الْقُرْآنَ أَمْ عَلَىٰ قُلُوبٍ أَقْفَالُهَا؟ فِيهِ رَحْمَةٌ وَهُدًى لِّلْمُؤْمِنِينَ، وَنُورٌ يَهْدِي إِلَىٰ الصِّرَاطِ الْمُسْتَقِيمِ. Translation: In the name of God, the most gracious, the most merciful Do they not meditate on the Qur’an, or are there locks on their hearts? In it is mercy and guidance for the believers, and a light that guides to the straight path. What do those Muslims who know Arabic thinks? 😁
It’s not even close. The verse is wacky in terms of meaningful information or even correct to say the least. Unlike the Quran which comes with bold statements and straightforward commands, advices, knowledge, warnings ext…
It's hard to explain why, but immediately from the first sentence it feels much more like the bible (in arabic) than the Quran, it does not contain the poetic style that makes the Quran so unique, and the words used do not have the same connection and depth that the words in the quran have.
The challenge of the Quran is not just its language but (the effect of it in heart) (producing something that billions of people will memorize even though they speak different languages) (It’s also creating a style that is linguistically unmatched in terms its reverence) And many many many more
@@elbansidmhamed1493 I am pretty sure in the verse it mentioned a chapter, first the challenge was a book like the Qur'an then it became 10 chapters then it became 1, There is no mention of one verse but If you have the source pls do tell me I would appreciate it.
What I am very interested is that if someone can train ChatGPT with Holy Quran and then we can ask questions. I think it's the best way to unlock hidden messages in Holy Quran. By the way, the challenge that mentioned in the Quran is not about similarity in verses, of course anyone can do that, it's about how these verses are connected to each other to make something that is exceptional. Be aware that we still don't know about its beauty.
The Qur'aan is a mind-blowing book to those who know Arabic and even to those who don't if they read it without bias. It was linguistically miraculous even to the strongest of poets and authors back in the day when Arabic was spoken in its completest form. Abu Lahab and Abu Jahl couldn't even dare challenge it, and those were the 2 most prominent of kuffar who would do anything to picture our prophet SAAW as a liar. They just couldn't...
Yeah the verse in Arabic it wrote was basic and it basically tried to copy the style and change it up a little lol. To give you a small example on how the Quran is special and unique in every surah there’s at least one unique word in it that the Arabs never used before but they understood it.
suwayd ibn al samit was one of the noblest men of yathrib. his people called him "the perfect" for his bravery, his eloquent poetry, his great honor, and his noble lineage. during this period suwayd, who came to makkah for pilgrimage, was approached by muhammad, who called him unto god and islam. suwayd said, "perhaps what you have, muhammad, is like that which i have." muhammad answered, "what is it that you have?" he answered, "the wisdom of luqman." muhammad asked him to explain this wisdom, and after hearing him, he said: "your words are good, but those which i have are even better. for they are a qur'an revealed by god to me as light and guidance." he read to him the qur'an and called him to islam. suwayd was pleased with what he heard, and said: "that is indeed good." when he left muhammad, he was in deep thought; there are reports that when al khazraj killed him he had already become a muslim.
The Qur'an is in Arabic and at the same time separate from the ordinary Arabic language. This is one of the miracles of the Qur'an. No one will appreciate it unless he speaks Arabic.🤍❤
I think you are missing the forest for the trees. That verse would have to fit a certain criteon and english isnt suitable as a substitute for the arabic. So producing an engilsh verse doesnt have the same affect it wouldnt rhyme as the quran does the letters wouldnt fit a mathematical patteren etc. There would be your issue with this challenge and also why bo one will ever take you serious
The Quran, not only has a beauty in the deliverance of the message, but scientific facts only being realised in this "modern" age.... Just one example "And We created from water every living thing. Will they not then believe ?" S21:30 We have just discovered, if we want to find life in the universe, first we have to establish the existence of water there !
To make it more challenging, the AI needs dictionaries, vocabularies, the ahadiths(sunnah/traditions) of the prophet muhammad in arabic and at last arabic poetry from at least 1440 years ago. These are the instruments of how you translate the Quran today. Like this it would be really beautiful to see, that an AI cant even come close to this challenge, even with all possible requirements available. Really great content there 👍👍
the style of the Qur'an has no analogue in Arabic literature, pre-Islamic or post-Islamic, even the Prophet's sayings are completely different from the Qur'an. so the Ai has no chance at all
@@digitalhouse6969 Thats why Allah didnt say: bring one human or one AI, but bring all humans and jinns and try to produce just one verse. Because it has more impact like that.
@@rayhankazim even if all creation came togather we would not be able to make something like qurarn. for example in english we write from left to right. and in arabic we write from right to left. but the quran actually has no starting poing. and it is like this " AADDFFFDDAA" . i don't even know to explain it in a comment
@@digitalhouse6969 if you mean the sentences that can be read the same way from both directions like وربك فكبر and وكل في فلك then those aren't verses themselves but parts of verses and they start with their position in the verse. So you can't say there's no start. EDIT: Just checked, وربك فكبر is a whole verse, so I was mistaken by saying part of a verse about it before, but the و isn't included in the parts that can be read from both directions. If you're talking about the Qur'an in general, it starts with Surah Al-Fatiha and ends with Surah Al-Nass, with all chapters positions being in the same place. There's an order to the Qur'an and you can read it in that order.
@@ahmadmanga i was talking about it in a linguistic way. it's like this "verb adj noun adj verb" but way way way more complicated than this for all verses and all surahs and all quran. it's impossible for us to do this. and it's perfect and sounds good and and and
My dear brother Chat GPT fails right off the bed Because it speaks of the first person if you notice Allah SWT always speaks of the third person in the Quran.
I asked chat GPT to create a verse like in the Quran and it created this Certainly. Here’s a verse written in a style inspired by the profound, reflective tone found in Quranic language. This verse is entirely original and created with respect: “O humanity, look upon the earth beneath your feet and the heavens above your heads. In the rising of the sun and its setting, in the stars that fill the night sky, are signs for those who reflect. Do you not see the beauty crafted around you, the balance in all creation? For the One who brought forth life from dust and adorned it with wisdom does not leave it without purpose.” This verse aims to evoke a similar sense of awe and reflection on creation and purpose, themes that are deeply emphasized in Quranic verses. Let me know if there’s a particular theme or style you’d like this writing to reflect.
the Challenge is not just about the words it is about prayer if the Quran is not from god the Muslims would have lost so many battles just by the numbers ,but because Allah promised the Muslims victory if they submitted to him they won their battles if you produce something like it there is no one to answer your prayer other then you.
As an Arabic language editor this is linguistically such trivial text, can be authored by any ordinary person.. not even a language expert, nothing distinguished about it neither in syntax or semantics
Hi Daniel, this is the first time that i see one your videos.. I'm a native arab from morocco. To be honest, i'm not very practicing muslim as i should. But the truth must be said.. The verse in Arabic very basic and normal its doesn't sound like a poetry and i think every 12 years old child here can come up with something like that. I will try to ask chatgbt in arabic to see if he can do better lol
Chat bot failed to even recognise that it is honourable amongst both disbelievers and believers to challenge the Qur’an. We look forward to resolving doubt by knowing if the qur’an can be matched.
أعتقد أن الذكاء الإصطناعي هذا تم تدريبه على القرآن باللغة الإنجليزية وهناك فرق كبير فهو لا يمكن حتى أن يستوعب الآيات القرآنية العربية لأنه معقد و مختصر و في نفس الوقت مفصل و يخبرك الكثير من الأشياء بأقل عدد من الكلمات وفي نفس الوقت يحافظ على ترتيبه و جماله (ورة مريم لو قرأتها بالعربي جميل جدا و به كل ما ذكرته) مثلاً حروف جملة ( لا إله إلا الله) باللغة العربية هي نفس حروف كلمة الله لا يمكن أن يحاول حتى في المستقبل و في الإصدارات المتقدمة من هذا الذكاء الإصطناعي يجب أن يتدرب على اللغة العربية و بالنسبة للآية الذي صنعه هو مثير للشفقة صراحة😂
Quran is brought down by God and no human or AI can generate to challenge a single verse. Since God has created humanity, angels and the whole universe, it's just plain silly. But this was a fun task nonetheless. One thing that should convince every human on earth to be Muslims is the space, all the planets and vastness of the universe. It's just mind boggling how massive these planets are. Even bigger than the sun in our own solar system. Also how the earth is perfectly in orbit of the sun to give us optimal conditions in order for humanity to survive. It's not just a coincidence. Obviously God is the ever existing and we can't be ignorant and blind to the truth. Jazakallah
I asked Gemini AI to create a verse like Quran. Following is the verse created by AI: تَعَامَّلْ في سِعَةِ الفَضَاءِ ، بِسَاطٍ مُنَجَّمٍ بِالْغُبَارِ النَّجْمِيِّ في دَاخِلِهِ ، المُجَرَّاتُ تَدُورُ ، كُلُّ مِنْهَا بَحْرٌ هَائِلٌ مِنْ شُمُوسٍ لا تُعَدُّ في أَحْضَانِهَا ، تَشْتَعِلُ الْحَيَاةُ ، جَمْرَةٌ هَشَّةٌ ضِدَّ الظَّلامِ اللَّا مُتَنَاهِي اعْلَمْ أَنَّ يَدَ الْخَالِقِ تَدَبِّرُ كُلَّ نَجْمٍ دَوَّارٍ ، وَتَنْفُحُ الْحَيَاةَ في التُّرابِ Translation: Contemplate the vastness of space, a carpet woven with stardust. Within it, galaxies swirl, each a raging sea of countless suns. In their embrace, life ignites, a fragile ember against the endless dark. Know that the Creator's hand guides every spinning star, and breathes life into the dust.
Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh. New to this channel. Very interesting topic u brought in and i can convincingly say that AI as powerful as Chatgpt couldn’t make an attempt to reproduce even one ayah of the Quran. Btw, nice to meet you brother Daniel. How long have been reverting to Islam?
Brothers and sisters, as you can see in the comments here from Arabic speakers, ChatGPT FAILED this test! No surprise 😄
Many great poets in the past have attempted this challenge and they all failed. This is because God is all-knowing and most gracious. We cannot create word that is better than God's. Subhanallah
Are you a muslim
@@Fahadshafi12316 😅
@@Fahadshafi12316 Yes I am alhamdulilah
Mashallah May Allah through you and me through other muslim spread Islam
MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU
BROTHER
@@gonzalez9753 why this meme
As a native Arabic speaker i can say this:
The language used is very basic, children in primary school could come up with such a language for their essay and its nowhere close to Quran.
To give an example close to what i see, imagine a child 9y old and Shakespeare describing a view or a thing, they are doing the same thing but the language used isn't even comparable.
Any Arabic speaker could tell at first glance this isn't even close to compare
Enjoyed the video, keep it up.
@@fy3219 صل عالنبي ، انت فاهم اصلا الرجال وش قال ؟؟؟؟؟؟ 😐
Agreed my exact first impression!
Do you understand that chat gpt was made as a simple talking ai that has been defaulted to english
@@monkeyninjaking4441daniel asked the arabic speakers to give their impression of the arabic text that the Ai made, and this commenter gave his impression! which i personally find valid.
@@jooi7722 and as i said chat gpt isnt even defaulted to arabic, if you asked him to write in any language it would be simple cus its a simple ai that is defaulted to english
As an arab I laughed when I read the verse produced by chatgpt, the style of writing is so poor it remembered me of childhood cartoons script it has nothing to do with the quranic style, this without mentioning the deep meanings and rethoric along with the consistency.
Subhanallah the languistic elequency of the Quran is so obvious and inimitable.
Alhamdulillah
same reaction brother XD , i laughed so hard of the attempt , even a non arab who learned arabic , after 2 years of learning can do better than that hahahaha
I was gonna write the same thing i laughed too 😂
yes me too, it is look like story before sleep .😂
I'm native Arabic speaker Believe me, the style of the Qur'an has no analogue in Arabic literature, pre-Islamic or post-Islamic, even the Prophet's sayings are completely different from the Qur'an.
The Arabic version sounds like some child wrote it 🤣 .. I mean even if you didn't understand Arabic and i beautifully recited that to you, i bet you would 1000% tell it's not from the Quran
Yoo soo true
Do you like the quran ☺️
😂😂it is
The Arabic language is quite complex and other language have taken from it. So way to promote your ignorance
@@abdoulayeguisse2196 man get out here .. the guy did that for entertainment purposes.. it's not like he didn't know the outcome.. if you don't know what fun is then I'm sorry for you 😉
AI said there is no god but truth.......But we Muslims say There is No God worthy of worship except Allah.....
The most influential and the most read and memorised book in human history and a book which is a healing and a blessing for mankind
It is a healing and a mercy for the believers***
I started learning Arabic since it's not my language, and even I can come up with a better wording than that.
it was a fun video, keep it up, and may Allah bless us all.
Ameen :)
Japan is in the corner of the world. How amazing to see Islam spread even on tiny Islands.
Its nice to see people trying they're best at learning arabic, and understanding the quran.
Reach me out if you need help as I am a native arabic speaker, and quite frankly, a japanese learner!
Islam is the only solution for all the problems in the world, Quran is law and way of life with zero conterdection, I am proud to be Muslim from San Francisco California ❤ alhamdulila for Islam
Islam is the only problem
U said it bro.but muslims are behind hadees which are man made. Islam is home of peace.those who dont have peace is not following the right islam.
Nop islam is the only problem in this world.. The only religion that considered a pdffile Muhammad as greatman in this world is islam
Aisha was nine Muhammad was a child molester it disgusts me that this person is considered the profit at all the Lord Christ was spoken of more times in the Koran then Mohammed himself.
If you did not follow the Hadith
Dumb
The quran has an inherent rhythm and melodious
Even non native Arabic speakers children cam memorise the entire quran due to it being rhythmic and easy to read
This chat gpt verse is like reading a newspaper, can't get the verse on my tongue so easily
❤ Absolutely Amazing. The Quran is a living miracle
Quran is a joke
even AI can't do that, this is not only a challenge for mankind but jin and all living being. Allaah(GOD) is great
After I have read the Quran, I realized that all what humanity needs is this heavenly law. “The legislation of Quran will spread all over the world, because it agrees with the mind, logic and wisdom.” - Leo Tolstoy
The suggestion in Arabic, is like a simple advise, can never immitate the Glorious Qu'ran unique structure, the profound multiple meanings with the shortest words possible abbreviation, the beauty and sleekness, the ease of memorization, snd without even mentioning the Mathematical miracles found in every verse in the Glorious Qu'ran.
Just name a few.
Subhanallah Alhamdulillah Allahu Akhbar
Keep it up with good content 💪
Salam from Malaysia
Incredible 😯 love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Am here laughing because I can also write basic Arabic. The Quran has it's own rythimic style with meaning. Even if the whole world decides to write one verse in its style, we can't.
Each quran verse contain= miraculous pronunciation+ clear meaning+ sign so i can say easily chatgpt failed the test
As an Arabic man i tried to recite the verse chatgpt produced but i can't and it meaningless to me subhanllah ❤️
Myb bcs chatgpt is a simple talking ai that has been defaulted to english and isnt made to understand other languages it tries from info it finds
Alhamdulilah for Islam Alhamdulilah for the biggest blessing that is Islam and the holy Quran
No one and nothing will be able to replicate it It's the final testament the unchanged word of ALLAH the final revelation sent to the Prophet Muhammad Peace and blessings be upon him ❤
The surahs have unreal mathematical miracles along with scinetific facts in QURAN.
Failed miserably… LOL
Specialist in Arabic. Anyone who reads The Holy Quran in Arabic and reads this verse will laugh like never before, same as I did.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Even the English version is so shallow! Read the Quran yourself and you will know what I mean.
This is not mentioning the feelings that come to you when you read the Quran. Why do you have tears when reading it?
Mind blowing!!!
Daniel, that bird calling in your background is exactly the same sound i hear everyday during fajr and maghrib.
As an Arabic speaker
Just read it by looking without moving the lips
Firstly, I realize directly that this sentence is not from the words of God Almighty, and it differs in the linguistic structure of the sentences, the words used, and the style from the Holy Qur’an
Secondly, I read it again while contemplating the meanings of the sentence. I realized the weakness of the moral connection between the sentences This is far from being compared to the Holy Quran
When you read or listen to the word of God Almighty in the Holy Quran in his language and understand it
Your senses can automatically differentiate between the words of God and the words of other than God in the same language
And what is the Qur'an and what is not from the Qur'an in its language
No one can even change or reduce something from it or add something to it without this change being easily detected
The Qur'an is a linguistic and moral structure at a level that reconciles with human mental capacity
It cannot be compared to his Arabic language
And you will realize that when you know Arabic well
I'm trying to tell you what honey tastes like
Like you haven't tasted it yet
...
I’ve always wondered if AI can pass this test as well, ever since Elon Musk talked about it, so thank you for doing this
As a native Arabic speaker, I can tell you that the test was failed miserably. The Arabic used is sooo weak, like it was written by a very average person, not even a poet or anything. I don’t know how to explain it, but it’s the same reason I always found the Bible (and even the English translations of the Quran to be weak)
You can’t truly understand the depth of a language until you learn Arabic and then read the Quran. I speak 3 languages, and understand a couple more, nothing comes close to the linguistic depth of the Quran.
I am a songwriter as well, and I’ve tried so hard to come up with something that could remotely resemble a verse in the Quran but it’s literally frustrating.. the pull ur hair kind 😅
Let’s not even get into the sea of numerical, scientific, etc etc.. miracles found in this book of wonder.
Hope that helped 🙏🏼
Wow, Mashalla! Thank you for sharing, god bless.
Are you really a Muslim? How can dare to doubt the Quran and attempt such tbing? Unbelievable.
@@hamadalkhalifa2323why you don't like it, while Al quran itself made an open challenge for anyone, it's not a sin
One Surah LIKE IT means it should have Mind-blowing mathematical patterns, elegance, rhyme, unique style and a balance. it should be the truth, should have no contradiction with the Quran and fit well with the rest of the Surah and verses, a guidance to Mankind that went straight to their hearts, it should be Furqan (criteria to distinguish between truth and falsehood), it should have future prophecies, ''scientific'' accuracy that go to against reailty (not talking about our perception btw), it should explain the human phycology like Quran does, it should have historical accuracies, etc and much more than my little mind can comprehend.
Even if the whole world Believed that AI had created Surah like it, I would still not believe it because indeed it would be nothing more than deception.
اللغة المستخدمة لا تماثل نسق القرآن الكريم من حيث البلاغة والبيان والفصاحة. أنا انصحك بتعلم اللغة العربية لتعلم مدى جمال لغة القرآن وروعته، لقد عجز كثير من فصحاء العرب حتى يومنا هذا عن محاكاة هذه البلاغة والبيان.
Mashallah
Where to learn Quranic Arabic? Can you suggest something
@@ismailhossain964 memories the Quran and you will learn
Brooo. The challenge in the Qur'an was to produce a whole chapter like it, not a verse. And yet the single verse that ChatGPT produced is nothing like the Qur'an. Subhan Allah ❤
No the challenge is about a single verse
@@yuksilbilal3848 No it's not. Give me one verse that says that. If
Dear brother ,there are many challenges in 1 challenge .
Not just words but synchronization,placing and signs ,
for example .
Periodic table numbers in quran.
Iron is 42 in arabic numericals in quran.
And other chemicals like zinc,copper and many are the same word from 1st word in counting as in periodic table.
And many more elements.
Write any field you can think of bio,geo,astro, anything and write miracle in quran. Or the distance from earth to moon and sun, you can look for that too in vdos it's explained with alphabet numericals.
You'll find more then many .
The fact about the number of words which are similar in the Quran is already enough for it to fail
yes, I'm a pediatric specialist and All scientists agrees that the embryological description and stage of development in Quran can't come from any source except our great creator Allah سبحانه و تعالى
@@الاءمصطفىالرفاعيreally? how come then quran makes the same errors that Galen (which lived several hundred years before quran was written)? How come it fails to even mention the most important items: the human egg and sperm cells? And how why does the stages come in wrong order? bones is not grown before flesh etc...
Beautiful...
I am an Arabic speaker, and this sounds like a statement written by a middle schooler tbh. In no way it is in the same level of significance, poeticism, level of value, factualness or language strength neither grammatically nor vocabulary as the Quran. No way even to be compared.
And what does "truth is life" mean and why it was added with absolute no value? the holy Quran approach is saying the least while stating the most value. God is eloquent, he does not add statements or words for extra-dressing or for just the rhyme.
thank you for doing this you have just proved ChatGPT to not be up even by a little bit for the challenge. God is forever wise forever merciful. I applaud you.
Assalamu Alaikum my brother, Revert here, raised a catholic by good parents, After reading the Quran which was given to me by my co-worker, my co-worker to me, Just read the book with an open mind, Let me know if you got questions or comments. I had a broken collar bone from an auto accident, spend a good 6 months at home, yes I was bored, started to read my friends Quran , I wanted to find mistakes and contradictions. The Holy Quran challenged me, NEVER in my Life I have Read a book like this, I Love reading Books from an very early age. Allah Akbar!
The Quran is unique and no humans or jinn can imitate it . If they are to imitate they will come up with mumble and jumble .
Amen! This AI has more common sense and respect that a majority of people these days.
Straight from bobbys channel. We love you both.we are all brother and sister 🥰
Wait I wanna see it, did they make a video together?
Let’s not forget that the Quran asks for a chapter not a verse.
Also, it isn’t just the case of having a beautifully eloquent chapter but also one that is as impactful as the Quran. Nothing that anyone writes will ever come close to how impactful the Quran is - just think about how many people read the Quran daily and have memorised the Quran and live their lives based on the teachings of the Quran. The Quran has touched the hearts of billions. No chapter from any other book can do this.
The Challenge in the quran is impossible to compete because the quran has it's own arabic and grammer and poet and everything there are many words in it that arabs themselves don't even know the meaning it's like a miracle when it came to native speakers challenging them with their own language and also the quran talks in many topics in one book which is hard to copy it too
As a native Arab I can say that, it failed miserably on all levels, whether it be eloquence or in meaning and coherency, for example, the point you have alluded to, if life is truth then death is? Falsehood....fail. If God is truth and truth is life then death can overcome God.....fail again, and please don't get me started on the eloquence factor....fail fail fail.
Hahahah thats funny
Masha Allah brother great breacdown❤
😂😂 yah and It is true that the Qur'an is so beautiful and amazing. Indeed, it cannot be compared, even though the wording of the Al is far from the Qur'an.
There is one verse in the Quran, 18:78.
قَالَ هَٰذَا فِرَاقُ بَيْنِى وَبَيْنِكَ ۚ سَأُنَبِّئُكَ بِتَأْوِيلِ مَا لَمْ تَسْتَطِع عَّلَيْهِ صَبْرًا
18:78 : He said: This is the PARTING BETWEEN me and between you. I will inform you about the interpretation of that over which you could not maintain patience.
This word 'PARTING' if in Arabic will END with the letter Q. This Verse itself will begin with letter Q. This are the only 2 letter Q of the verse.
-------------
If exactly IN BETWEEN this Verse 18:78 and the very START of the Quran, total sum of all the letter Q will = 3516.
AND
if exactly IN BETWEEN this Verse 18:78 and the very END of the Quran, total sum of all the letter Q will AGAIN = 3516 !!!
-------------
If that fictional VERSE created by the Ai is also added into Quran, then this pattern would probably cease to exist.
And so could many other numerical patterns and even scientific miracles of the Quran too !
Assalamu alaykum brother. There is no challenge in the Qur'an about producing a verse! Indeed, a verse may be composed of 2 single letters as in sourat 20 (طه). The challenge is about producing a sourat, the shortest one in the holly Qur'an is 3 verses long (108).
Native Arabic speaker here,
To me it seems the AI generated the verse first by referencing English translations of the Quran, then generated a verse in English and translated it literally to the Arabic language. Because to me the structure and language sounds similar to the English language in the bible which is not as linguistically complex.
This might be the AI's limitation as a primarily English bot (as it mentioned), but I can also imagine that linguistically, producing rhetoric with the Arabic language is complex and subjective. Therefore, it is harder to code in an AI.
Nevertheless, I am not denying the miracle of the Quran, and alhamdulillah my imaan increased after seeing it here for myself. I think the brother here was doing it to really witness the miracle and not out of disrespect or challenge.
P.S I was pleasantly surprised that "Cultural and Religious Respect.exe" was coded into the AI though😂
The first thing I noticed in the Arabic that it does not carry the poetic features of Quran it's very simplistic. But what caught my attention is the use of the word truth translated "Huq" in Arabic which is one of the 99 attributes of Allah. So basically it discounted 98 of the other attributes which means it can never be complete since religion can never be formed based solely on our truth since to each his own truths and humanity will fall into further conflict. Islam is complete and holistic. This was a great video thanks Daniel
كتاب الله إعجاز سيتحدى الجميع إلى قيام الساعة
كلام الله نقرأه ونشعر كأنها اول مره نقرأه
له طريقه خاصه في التلاوة لم تكن إلا للقرآن الكريم
احب كلام الله ❤
I'm not even Arab but I could see the difference so quickly after reading it
Take the shortest final 3 surahs, Al Ikhlas, AlFalaq & Annas. All ending of the words have same sound/rhyme. Eg Ahad, Somad, Yulad, Ahad : Falaq, kholaq, Waqob, Uqod, Hasad : Binnas, Malikkinnas, Illahinnas, Khonnas, Rinnas, Wannas, Same goes to AlFatihah - 'Alamin, Rohim, Middin, Ta'in, Mustaqim, Waladdhollin.
I have read the Quran with translation once and reading it for second time.
I can say that this verse created by Chatgpt isn't even close to the beautiful coherent words of ALLAH in Quran.
يا محمد ان استطعت ان تأتينا بآية فات بها ولكن ما استطعت ان كنت من عند الله نبيا فات بالملائكة او إئت بربك كما زعمت علينا وان لم تستطع فقد علمناك من الكاذبين (١) لا الشمس تجري حول الارض ولا هي تغرب في عين حمئة وقد علمناك من الجاهلين (٢) وما كان قوله لهم الا ان ربه لم يأت بآية فكلما جاءت الرسل بالايات ما كان من الناس الا ان اعرضوا وكذبوا بهم قل اتعلم ما في قلوبنا إن تأت بآية نؤمن لك ولكن ما استطعت فاذهب انت وربك وأتيا بالايات ان كنتما فاعلين (٣) وما كان قول محمد الا اني بشير ونذير واني بشر من رب العالمين (٤) لو علمنا سفهك يا محمد ما تركناك بيننا فانك كنت مع القوم المفسدين (٥)
Easy peasy here is my new surah of the Quran that i just created while i was taking a dump thats how easy it is to
هذا بالضبط مثل الذي أنزل على مسيلمة. ضربة يمين وضربة شمال وكلمة من روايات عبير وكلمة من الشارع و وبعدها نشر على يوتيوب بفخر.
إذا جهابذة اللغة العربية التي انزلت الآية فيهم عجزوا عن مواجهة التحدي.. تأتي أنت من عامة العامة وتقول واجهت التحدي؟ أنا غير متخصص في اللغة العربية لكني والله وبدون ذرة جهد عرفت انك مسيلمة ولكن قزم بسبب الركاكة الشديدة في الهبل اللي رسلته.
وأغبى شيء هو "اني بشر من رب العالمين". يا راجل 😂😂😂😂
قرح الله جحرك.. وجحرك كلمة يمنية ابحث عنها واستفيد لغة عربية يا بهيمة.
We are here 🥰 may Allah bless you
القرآن واضح وبسيط في اللغة العربية ..لا يحتوي علي كلمات صعبة ..ولكن لا تستطيع اختيار نفس الكلمات البسيط وتركيبها فسرعان ما تفسر علي انها للأطفال ..
The Qur’an is clear and simple in the Arabic language..it does not contain difficult words..but you cannot choose the same simple words and put them together, so they are quickly interpreted as if they are for children..
Funny enough Quran 22:6 says “That is because Allah ‘alone’ is the Truth, He ‘alone’ can give life to the dead, and He ‘alone’ is Most Capable of everything”.
Truth is one of the 99 names of Allah (Allah is the Arabic word for God, Arabic Bible and Torah translations use it to translate the word God)
So even ChatGpt recognizes that that there is no God but Allah (the one God of the monotheist religions)
To be realistic It cannot... the only thing it can do is copy paste from random verses within Quran itself... the problem in this scenario will come disturbing the numerical ordering for example the basic principal that Quran follows is maintaining base of 19 which will break immediately. Now lets assume it brings missing words to compute and fill this gap then another problem starts right there which is maintaining not only the words positions but even characters which is not possible even with the most powerful AI with all full knowledge of probability topics like combinations and permutations for example the mention of the Sun in the verse 21:33 which contains simply 3 words كُلٌّۭ فِى فَلَكٍۢ are enough to bend human minds (try reading left to right and then right to left its still the same) also giving a deep meaning Sun being in the middle and others in orbit around it.
I am curious as to the definition of, "like the Quran". What exact combination of qualities would the new document need to have in order for it to be deemed, "like the Quran"? If one were to attempt the challenge, who would be qualified to determine if the new document is indeed, "like the Quran". The challenge seems meaningless unless the parameters are defined.
يقول الروبوت : "لا اله الا الحق و الحق هو الحياة و فاعملوا بالحق و اعملوا خيرا , لان الحق يهديكم الى الطريق السوي و يساعدكم على تحقيق السلام و الوئام في الحياة الدنيا و الاخرة ."
الانتقاد:
اولا : لا يوجد جمال لحن مثل القرآن , فطريقة النطق كأنه كلام عادي جدا
ثانيا : الاله هو الحق , هذا صحيح , فالله هو الحق التام ولا يوجد فيه الباطل فالحق هو صفة الكمال لله
اما الحق هو الحياة ؟؟ كيف هذا ؟؟ , الجملة الصحيحة هي : الله هو الحي الذي لا يموت
او الله هو سبب الحياة
حتى و ان كان قصده الله هو سبب الحياة او الله هو الحي , فيجب ان يقول الله هو سبب الحياة و ليس الحق هو سبب الحياة او يقول الله هو الحي و ليس الحق هو الحي
لان اذ الله وصف نفسه بصفة فيكون سياق باقي الكلام على تلك الصفة
مثال توضيحي : الله هو الجبار و الجبار هو الرحمان
سياق غريب كان بامكانه مثلا القول هو : الله الجبار الرحمان
ننتقل الي بعده
ثالثا : فاعملوا بالحق و اعملوا خيرا , لان الحق يهديكم الى الطريق السوي و يساعدكم على تحقيق السلام و الوئام
خلاصة قول الروبوت هو : اذ تعمل بالحق و تحكم بالحق فسيأتيك السلام .و هذا خطا
كثير من الاشخاص تكلموا بكلمة الحق و سجنوا و عقبوا و هذه الاشياء معروفة عندنا كبشر
و ثاني شيء : ان حينما يامر الله لا يجب الطلب منه السبب لانه هو خالقك لكن سنتغضى عن هذا و نصحح للروبوت ما يريد قوله
اي كان بامكانه قول بدل ذلك , هذه الجملة : فاعملوا بالحق و الخير , لان الحق يهديكم الى الطريق المستقيم و ستلقوا جزاء اعمالكم في الدنيا و الاخرة .
I love your background sounds. I want to live where ever you are. 🥰
Thank you for doing this challenge. After reading the comments i'm more amazed, Truly no one can imitate the glorious Quran
MasyaAllah the background sounds birds...❤✌
The arabic version has no depth, it's as something I would read in the Bible.. No poetic meaning, in language or style is very shallow compared to Quran.. 8:01
As a muslim and arabic native speaker, i couldn't retain my laugh reading the arabic generated text.. as i am sitting in a library.. really did my best not laughing. An attempt to compare this to al Qoran would be in itself an insult to the books and whatever has anything to do with a religion
Let all humans come to One Platform and obey One True God and be in universal brotherhood and be in peaceful harmony
In another video chatGPT accepted the challenge right away to imitate surah Al-Kousar. However, it failed so miserably over and over after so many attempts that it even admitted, that as a text model I can't produce something like that due to creativity limitations. It's the shortest surah in Quran of literaly only three sentences and 10 words. People should really think about it, that if a book challenges the humankind 1400+ years ago and you still can't do it with all that AI, just admit it.
No comparison at all. The Arabic is very weak and has no style at all. Allahu Akbar. ☝🏼
It can't do it... and we should not be surprised, as Allah (SWT) told us that it's not possible.
(24:57) Do not even imagine that those who disbelieve can render Allah powerless in the land. Their abode is the Fire; what an evil abode!
This is like Shakespeare wrote"Everything that glitters is not gold" and he said try to make a sentence like that and I wrote "Everything that glitters is not diamond"😂😂
My brother, you must differentiate between the surah and the verse. The challenge should be to the surah, not the verse.
Here's one from another LLM that I got at my first attempt:
Here's a verse in Arabic inspired by the eloquence and style found in the Qur'an:
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
أَفَلَا يَتَدَبَّرُونَ الْقُرْآنَ أَمْ عَلَىٰ قُلُوبٍ أَقْفَالُهَا؟
فِيهِ رَحْمَةٌ وَهُدًى لِّلْمُؤْمِنِينَ، وَنُورٌ يَهْدِي إِلَىٰ الصِّرَاطِ الْمُسْتَقِيمِ.
Translation:
In the name of God, the most gracious, the most merciful
Do they not meditate on the Qur’an, or are there locks on their hearts?
In it is mercy and guidance for the believers, and a light that guides to the straight path.
What do those Muslims who know Arabic thinks? 😁
The sound of the Koel bird in the background hit home... Where are you brother?
Thailand, brother
@@danielwaynedrury im Thai and that bird is screeming right now as i comment lol
It’s not even close. The verse is wacky in terms of meaningful information or even correct to say the least. Unlike the Quran which comes with bold statements and straightforward commands, advices, knowledge, warnings ext…
It's hard to explain why, but immediately from the first sentence it feels much more like the bible (in arabic) than the Quran, it does not contain the poetic style that makes the Quran so unique, and the words used do not have the same connection and depth that the words in the quran have.
The challenge of the Quran is not just its language but (the effect of it in heart) (producing something that billions of people will memorize even though they speak different languages)
(It’s also creating a style that is linguistically unmatched in terms its reverence)
And many many many more
Salam brother, watching from Singapore 🇸🇬 🤲🏼
Walaykum Salam 🤝🏻
الحق =Truth
is a name of GOD
The challenge in the Qur'an was to come up with a chapter not verse, but the AI failed even that😅😂😂
Both !! chapter and verse also are in the challenge of the qurân
@@elbansidmhamed1493 I am pretty sure in the verse it mentioned a chapter, first the challenge was a book like the Qur'an then it became 10 chapters then it became 1, There is no mention of one verse but If you have the source pls do tell me I would appreciate it.
Kudos.. not many would have dared.. just more proof that we cannot recreate a Quran or anything like it.
What I am very interested is that if someone can train ChatGPT with Holy Quran and then we can ask questions. I think it's the best way to unlock hidden messages in Holy Quran. By the way, the challenge that mentioned in the Quran is not about similarity in verses, of course anyone can do that, it's about how these verses are connected to each other to make something that is exceptional. Be aware that we still don't know about its beauty.
The Qur'aan is a mind-blowing book to those who know Arabic and even to those who don't if they read it without bias.
It was linguistically miraculous even to the strongest of poets and authors back in the day when Arabic was spoken in its completest form. Abu Lahab and Abu Jahl couldn't even dare challenge it, and those were the 2 most prominent of kuffar who would do anything to picture our prophet SAAW as a liar. They just couldn't...
No so perfect, nonchronological book and jumping from topic to topic.
@@townsmanmacher3880 OK.
Just think about it for a while, nothing more. @@unorthozeus5023
Yeah the verse in Arabic it wrote was basic and it basically tried to copy the style and change it up a little lol. To give you a small example on how the Quran is special and unique in every surah there’s at least one unique word in it that the Arabs never used before but they understood it.
I loved this, such a creative idea!
Greetings from Türkiye !
This verse was on my mind last night, thank you for making the video about it.
The Arabic version reminds me of my second years arabic class in elementary school 😂😂 and those text where in another level
Blessing❤️🤲
suwayd ibn al samit was one of the noblest men of yathrib. his people called him "the perfect" for his bravery, his eloquent poetry, his great honor, and his noble lineage. during this period suwayd, who came to makkah for pilgrimage, was approached by muhammad, who called him unto god and islam. suwayd said, "perhaps what you have, muhammad, is like that which i have." muhammad answered, "what is it that you have?" he answered, "the wisdom of luqman." muhammad asked him to explain this wisdom, and after hearing him, he said: "your words are good, but those which i have are even better. for they are a qur'an revealed by god to me as light and guidance." he read to him the qur'an and called him to islam. suwayd was pleased with what he heard, and said: "that is indeed good." when he left muhammad, he was in deep thought; there are reports that when al khazraj killed him he had already become a muslim.
The Qur'an is in Arabic and at the same time separate from the ordinary Arabic language. This is one of the miracles of the Qur'an. No one will appreciate it unless he speaks Arabic.🤍❤
that was like a 8 year old trying to come up with an essay for his history exam XD
I think you are missing the forest for the trees. That verse would have to fit a certain criteon and english isnt suitable as a substitute for the arabic. So producing an engilsh verse doesnt have the same affect it wouldnt rhyme as the quran does the letters wouldnt fit a mathematical patteren etc. There would be your issue with this challenge and also why bo one will ever take you serious
The Quran, not only has a beauty in the deliverance of the message, but scientific facts only being realised in this "modern" age.... Just one example "And We created from water every living thing. Will they not then believe ?" S21:30
We have just discovered, if we want to find life in the universe, first we have to establish the existence of water there !
New in your channel ...I like this video alot
Welcome and glad you enjoyed!
I have to say I Laughed, its not even close to Quran verses its more like childish thing.
Note Arabic is my native language.
To make it more challenging, the AI needs dictionaries, vocabularies, the ahadiths(sunnah/traditions) of the prophet muhammad in arabic and at last arabic poetry from at least 1440 years ago. These are the instruments of how you translate the Quran today. Like this it would be really beautiful to see, that an AI cant even come close to this challenge, even with all possible requirements available. Really great content there 👍👍
the style of the Qur'an has no analogue in Arabic literature, pre-Islamic or post-Islamic, even the Prophet's sayings are completely different from the Qur'an. so the Ai has no chance at all
@@digitalhouse6969 Thats why Allah didnt say: bring one human or one AI, but bring all humans and jinns and try to produce just one verse. Because it has more impact like that.
@@rayhankazim even if all creation came togather we would not be able to make something like qurarn.
for example in english we write from left to right. and in arabic we write from right to left. but the quran actually has no starting poing. and it is like this " AADDFFFDDAA" . i don't even know to explain it in a comment
@@digitalhouse6969 if you mean the sentences that can be read the same way from both directions like وربك فكبر and وكل في فلك then those aren't verses themselves but parts of verses and they start with their position in the verse. So you can't say there's no start.
EDIT: Just checked, وربك فكبر is a whole verse, so I was mistaken by saying part of a verse about it before, but the و isn't included in the parts that can be read from both directions.
If you're talking about the Qur'an in general, it starts with Surah Al-Fatiha and ends with Surah Al-Nass, with all chapters positions being in the same place. There's an order to the Qur'an and you can read it in that order.
@@ahmadmanga i was talking about it in a linguistic way. it's like this "verb adj noun adj verb" but way way way more complicated than this for all verses and all surahs and all quran. it's impossible for us to do this. and it's perfect and sounds good and and and
My dear brother Chat GPT fails right off the bed Because it speaks of the first person if you notice Allah SWT always speaks of the third person in the Quran.
I asked chat GPT to create a verse like in the Quran and it created this
Certainly. Here’s a verse written in a style inspired by the profound, reflective tone found in Quranic language. This verse is entirely original and created with respect:
“O humanity, look upon the earth beneath your feet and the heavens above your heads. In the rising of the sun and its setting, in the stars that fill the night sky, are signs for those who reflect. Do you not see the beauty crafted around you, the balance in all creation? For the One who brought forth life from dust and adorned it with wisdom does not leave it without purpose.”
This verse aims to evoke a similar sense of awe and reflection on creation and purpose, themes that are deeply emphasized in Quranic verses. Let me know if there’s a particular theme or style you’d like this writing to reflect.
This verse sounded more like the Bible 😂
the Challenge is not just about the words it is about prayer if the Quran is not from god the Muslims would have lost so many battles just by the numbers ,but because Allah promised the Muslims victory if they submitted to him they won their battles if you produce something like it there is no one to answer your prayer other then you.
As an Arabic language editor this is linguistically such trivial text, can be authored by any ordinary person.. not even a language expert, nothing distinguished about it neither in syntax or semantics
Hi Daniel, this is the first time that i see one your videos.. I'm a native arab from morocco. To be honest, i'm not very practicing muslim as i should. But the truth must be said.. The verse in Arabic very basic and normal its doesn't sound like a poetry and i think every 12 years old child here can come up with something like that. I will try to ask chatgbt in arabic to see if he can do better lol
Chat bot failed to even recognise that it is honourable amongst both disbelievers and believers to challenge the Qur’an.
We look forward to resolving doubt by knowing if the qur’an can be matched.
أعتقد أن الذكاء الإصطناعي هذا تم تدريبه على القرآن باللغة الإنجليزية وهناك فرق كبير فهو لا يمكن حتى أن يستوعب الآيات القرآنية العربية لأنه معقد و مختصر و في نفس الوقت مفصل و يخبرك الكثير من الأشياء بأقل عدد من الكلمات وفي نفس الوقت يحافظ على ترتيبه و جماله (ورة مريم لو قرأتها بالعربي جميل جدا و به كل ما ذكرته)
مثلاً
حروف جملة ( لا إله إلا الله) باللغة العربية
هي نفس حروف كلمة الله
لا يمكن أن يحاول حتى
في المستقبل و في الإصدارات المتقدمة من هذا الذكاء الإصطناعي يجب أن يتدرب على اللغة العربية
و بالنسبة للآية الذي صنعه هو مثير للشفقة صراحة😂
Quran is brought down by God and no human or AI can generate to challenge a single verse. Since God has created humanity, angels and the whole universe, it's just plain silly. But this was a fun task nonetheless.
One thing that should convince every human on earth to be Muslims is the space, all the planets and vastness of the universe. It's just mind boggling how massive these planets are. Even bigger than the sun in our own solar system. Also how the earth is perfectly in orbit of the sun to give us optimal conditions in order for humanity to survive. It's not just a coincidence. Obviously God is the ever existing and we can't be ignorant and blind to the truth. Jazakallah
As an Arabic speaker, I laughed at what it wrote
Quran says make a verse like it not to use Quranic verse and rearrange it😅😅
I asked Gemini AI to create a verse like Quran. Following is the verse created by AI:
تَعَامَّلْ في سِعَةِ الفَضَاءِ ، بِسَاطٍ مُنَجَّمٍ بِالْغُبَارِ النَّجْمِيِّ
في دَاخِلِهِ ، المُجَرَّاتُ تَدُورُ ، كُلُّ مِنْهَا بَحْرٌ هَائِلٌ مِنْ شُمُوسٍ لا تُعَدُّ
في أَحْضَانِهَا ، تَشْتَعِلُ الْحَيَاةُ ، جَمْرَةٌ هَشَّةٌ ضِدَّ الظَّلامِ اللَّا مُتَنَاهِي
اعْلَمْ أَنَّ يَدَ الْخَالِقِ تَدَبِّرُ كُلَّ نَجْمٍ دَوَّارٍ ، وَتَنْفُحُ الْحَيَاةَ في التُّرابِ
Translation:
Contemplate the vastness of space, a carpet woven with stardust. Within it, galaxies swirl, each a raging sea of countless suns. In their embrace, life ignites, a fragile ember against the endless dark. Know that the Creator's hand guides every spinning star, and breathes life into the dust.
Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh. New to this channel. Very interesting topic u brought in and i can convincingly say that AI as powerful as Chatgpt couldn’t make an attempt to reproduce even one ayah of the Quran. Btw, nice to meet you brother Daniel. How long have been reverting to Islam?