@@gamersault I'm going to ruin the ARG series for you. 😅 This arg came out after a FNAF Corn Comic the art and plot are basically identical. Would you like the name of it?
Fun fact: Jay and Dino were inspired by plushies owned by the game's creator and his girlfriend. They confirmed they couldn't kill off the pair which is why Dino and Jay survive.
@@MrBurger157 I mean, like, if I was him, I would take that opportunity to leave the group earlier on. I don't care if these 'friends' call me a loser, though, I'll still go home anyway.
@@gamersault It's those dang pumpkins, I tell you, Pumpkin Rabbit knew what he was doin' >:(( (tysm for for replying to my comment, it's literally a dream come true :D)
What a coincidence, its also been four years since they last killed. Since they're last photo was in 1979 and the current Halloween takes place in 1983. Ngl,if I was them I would be just as insane. Imagine not eating in four years! Maybe it’s to keep a pact or something.
@@gigachad1661 My theory: I think the book kept them alive no matter what. They weren’t held back by bodily-limitations like animals and humans do where they need to eat and sleep, so they appeared and represented themselves as normal individuals, but are actually demons from hell that somehow made a deal to become human-like individuals in this world. Even if their bodies were burned, the book would revive them as their souls are pacted with the book from the possible deal they made with someone summoning them on Halloween night. Until the book was finally burned, killing them for good, sending them back to hell, where they clearly didn’t want to go back to. Motive: Killing kids is probably just sports for them, but I think it also gives them a lifespan like the Other Mother from Coraline where they are able to live for a long time until they need to feast on the soul of a child (easy prey), in this instance, every year on Halloween, the day they we’re summoned. Because the soul of a child is fresh and the soul will take a while to grow old, feeding the couple the child’s essence to continue living for a long time. They don’t eat them but they consume their souls somehow.
Fun fact: the reason bon was walking at Ralph like that was because he was mocking the scarecrow and messing with Ralph because later, he gets turned into a scarecrow
I remember hearing about an old superstition where people believe that you can capture a person's soul in a picture, I have a theory that maybe that is how the Waterson couple was able to both trap their victims souls in the mannequins and control them. Because they did have a odd tradition of taking their victims photos and sticking them in a photo album.
I honestly love the Pumpkin Rabbit's new design in this sequel his old one made him look like a recolor of Bon kudos to Martin for bringing him back in the creepiest way!
i like the way the creator makes the spooky monsters they always have tiny heads and big bodies mostly the torso being long and how the pumkin rabbit gets more messed up and withered over time
@@justsomejoyousj I'd like to think he just wasn't able to get his foot out because of the extreme panic and fear he was going through so he just couldn't coordinate his movement with what he was thinking. (at least not fast enough)
@@sporkcheese6649 In my view, you're right. If he wasn't so panicky and fearful, and saying in his mind: "All right, let's take this nice and slow", then he'll slowly get his foot out of the pumpkin faster than he could and bolted away through the fence gate of the Watermans' backyard. One time, I feel like him, placed in his situation(Not with the batman costume that Ralph wears. I ain't Vengeance). I was younger at that time, and you know these pumpkins? Like, lined up in rows? I was at home(if my memory served right), and accidentally got stuck, my foot in one of the pumpkins. I didn't realise, I wasn't running like Ralph did in TROPR, but carelessly walking. I began panicking, and tried getting my foot out. I knew that if i panicked too much, I wouldn't get my foot out quicker. (Edit: Sorry if the comment's long, I feel like this pumpkin memory is a bit.. traumatising, but that scene with Ralph's final moment on screen reminds me of that time.)
Don’t get why everyone is calling Ralph a dog, “specifically “the dog”, considering he looks more like a fox or something and Jay is much more clearly a dog
5:09 In the video, if you listen close, you can hear what sounds like Ducky calling Tammy’s name beyond the door. I’ve seen some people theorize that TPR can mimic or replicate other’s voices.
The scrapbook was likely the crux of the contract they made. So once it was destroyed, their debts were to be immediately collected, destroying their very souls.
Maby by showing hospitality to the kids (giving them candy and letting them stay the night) before killing them. the kids were unknowingly putting their souls in debt to the rabbit and sheep. Taking the photograph binds the souls to either the house or to the rabbit. Then, once they die, the "debt" can only be repaid through possibly indefinite servitude. Fucking brutal if so.
I don't think paco and ralph were stucked in the house after their death, my assumption is that they too also were released Since there were no mannequin of their own on the basement
@SunTheUser idk, Martin doesn't seem to put much attention on stuff that isn't important to the scene. In that scene the important thing was the pumpkin rabbit and the witch sheep mannequins. But I could be wrong
@@sarawalten7949 there were a scene in which the rabbit took picture of the children from the window earlier on, which is unnoticed by many So the chances is quite siding on my assumption
Jay's dad had a sherrifs badge on his jacket... They said earlier in the Halloween video from this year that the townsfolk were the ones who "took matters into their own hands" after Tammy and Ducky's disappearance. With Jays dad being a policeman at the least, the "sheriff" at the most, he was very likely to have been there while Rachel and Lorenzo were set ablaze. Most likely was involved in investigating the disappearances.. The big thing to remember is that no one found any evidence of the kidnapping n murders, and that they set them ablaze because of a hunch + info from Tammy's sister. Billy and TVA died in 1974, the pumpkin bear who was implicated to be the last child to die before Tammy and Ducky died in 1978.. Billy was shown in the short teaser to have been instructed by the couple to fetch ingredients for a spell...and it involved a photo of -someone(s)-. Some children are scarecrows..some are used as puppets to gain trust from the victims.. We see this with Ducky and I wanna say Paco, the priest child, in this video. But what if we also saw it with Billy and TVA in the first Halloween special with Tammy and Ducky? What really gets me is the use of the children after they perish. Some are gruesome decor. But why? Maybe their bodies were far too decayed/mangled to be of any more use? And the mannequins...they have to represent trapped souls. There were a ton inside the house..but Ralph encountered one outside when he was going for his ball
I think it's clear that the book had something "special", so I suppose it makes the bodies look like mannequins when ppl are around or when the lights are on, that's why the police couldn't find any bodies and why Lorenzo and Rachel turned into mannequins too when Jay's dad came in
he 1000% had something to do with their deaths. Considering the quote that kept getting repeated throughout the video, that Jay's dad eventually said at the end, I'm willing to bet those exact words was something he said to convince the townsfolk to kill them.
I love how Martín changed the designs of the children, in the mysterious house they looked too much like deviant art fan art but now they look so unique and I would do anything to protect my boy Dino
@@lionelschweetz4844what’s funny is that Jay and Dino are based off real plushies that Martin and his gf own while the other kids were created later on
Ducky's right, Tammy should have listened to him. And, who knocks at the door of a decrepit house? The place is likely derelict or abandoned. That should be a giant crimson flag.
By the way, as I found out on Twitter, Pumpkin Rabbit looks more like a dog or a wolf than a rabbit due to the shape of his muzzle and nose when his mask falls off. It's pretty cool how he plays the wolf in sheep's clothing analogy!
In the mysterious house, the couple just… seemed too supernatural to be scary. However, in the return of the pumpkin rabbit, their dialog seemed more human, and that made it scarier too feel like a live person would want to do that to kids.
i disagree i feel they are only scary because they are supernatural, that way you have no idea what are their capabilities or motives. you feel maybe they always know where you are and what you are going to do and there is nothing you can do to stop them. on the other hand if they are real people then it's just oh it's a bunch of mentally ill people who've had terrible lives and they have all the limitations you do. thats not scary to me at all
The Mysterious House and The Return of The Pumpkin Rabbit are some of the best analog horror videos I've ever seen. I wonder if this is the final video we'll see about The Pumpkin Rabbit or if it will continue next Halloween.
@@kuruumss well maybe not the first victims but the most memorable ones Who knows, the watermans may think those two are special and probably cripple them instead to puppeteer them as “friends” like how they’re shown in the Mysterious House Could be a callback to Susan being stuffed into Banny where TVA and Billy are paralyzed and kept in mocked up versions of their costumes to slowly rot
I remember watching it and going "At least that kid has some sense!" Only to be forced to watch poor Ralph get killed 😢 Sometimes you do everything right and still wind up murdered
26:35 fun fact:That's not a mannequin.Those are the remains of Paco.Not only did they destroy my poor boy's face,they beheaded and split his torso through
@goobagombi9893 It could be that Pacos head is on the mannequin, since the head is similiar to Pacos, and Martin didnt show us what happened to Paco, so he just decided to show his corpse.
@@goobagombi9893 in my defense,old bodies that were shown in both specials always seemed like ,how do I say it,stretched.For example,the corpse of the fox always seemed off to me bc of the torso.It almost looks like the bodies "age" and "grow" even after the victims are killed or they are just that maimed by PR.Or it could be a style choice on Martin's part so that's why I usually didn't pay it any mind
This might be my second favourite episode that i have see with episode 3 being my favourite for now, by the way pumpkin's cupboard scare is my new favourite in the walten files
You know what? I wasn't going to say this, because it sounds weird, but, while the way Ralph died was horrific, it was intensely interesting: he fought through a good number of horror troupes, and STILL failed. THAT is unfortunate reality. Like, it sucks, and it's sad, but, sometimes you just can't win, even when you do the best you can. Edit: Omg, I just realized it was Mrs. Waterman singing Hush Little Baby. I thought Paco was singing it to himself, as like a technique for self-soothing! I'm a dingus, for heaven's sake! XD
I really wish I didn’t get recommended this at 2 am and had to see that thumbnail lol also the part where they burn their house down is probably to me is now the creepiest thing in waltine flies
There’s a a lot of similarities with the Nightmare on elm street series. Before Freddy was killed, he would kidnap the children of springwood and bring them to his boiler room at the factory where he worked at and would kill them. He would soon be arrested for the murders but was let go due to the arrest warrant not being signed which caused the town to outrage. The parents of the children he killed would track him down and burn him alive taking justice into their own hands. But then Freddy came back and started his killing spree again by going after the teenagers of springwood in their dreams, and every time he claimed a victim, Freddy absorbed their souls inside of him because he fed off of them to grow more powerful Just how the Waterman’s kept the souls of the kids trapped within their memory book, they were burned alive but would not stay dead In Nightmare 4 the dream master, Alice defeated Freddy by showing his reflection in the mirror, that enabled the souls of the children inside of him to be freed, he was basically torn apart by them just how the kids attacked witch sheep and pumpkin rabbit after they were freed
This whole video seems to have a lot of references to horror films, the main girl is wearing a good guy outfit from Child’s play, Pumpkin Rabbit is dressed as Leather Face, the scene with the rabbit leaning on the door is based on the shining and the book burning is DEFINITELY a reference to Evil Dead with the necronomicon burning
@ true And the fact that it’s set in Halloween is reference to the 1978 movie And how michaels killing spree affected the town of Haddonfield Martin really took a lot of Inspiration from the classics
If you let your KIDS trick or treat ALONE at night, then I'm sorry, but you signed your children's death warrent. I didn't go trick or treating alone until I was thirteen, and even then, I wasn't as dumb as these kids. If there were a haunted murder house, I ain't NEVER GOING ANYWHERE NEAR IT.
@lionelschweetz4844 I can assure you, a lot of families by then weren't even allowing their kids to be alone trick or treating. Adults don't leave their doors open anymore before that time period. My mother and uncle remembered trick or treating with my grandparents
@lionelschweetz4844 they weren't trick-or-treating by themselves until they turn too 13, and they also had to have a group of kids going together. they can't be in Paris
Yeah when I watched Ducky and Tammy discussing about going to that house or not, I can't help but wonder where the hell are their parents? Don't they ever warn their kids that they should be more wary and not go to unfamiliar places without permission or anything like that?? Especially at night ?? Plus, kids go missing every Halloween in town, how come these adults still got the fucking nerve to let the kids go trick-or-treating alone at night?? While I won't deny that the Pumpkin Rabbit & Mysterious House is an excellent analogue horror series, but the plot in it is still that same old dumb lame cliché. "Oh look at that creepy suspicious house ! Lets hurry and go there ! I am pretty sUrE everything's going to be FINE!! :D"
I can’t watch the end of the mysterious house without hearing the thicc pumpkin rabbit meme. Also idk if you’ve noticed this but the blue hippo in the mysterious house wasn’t one of the corpses and I didn’t see them in return of the pumpkin rabbit so maybe they got away
Yeah, something i didnt really comprehend was billy and tva's role in the story, are they adults?, kids? In the second installment you can see a photo of what appears to be a kid version of Billy and TVA in a photo with the pumpkin rabbit. But when Jay reaches into Billy's mouth, his body appears to be fully grown. The timeline of the killings also seemed kinda messed up. Naybe im just not paying attention but im almost positive tammy and ducky werent killed before billy and tva since they are both in the house before tammy and ducky die
This one was absolutely more intense than I think I was ever expecting what incredible quality and voice acting!! I absolutely love the style/aesthetic of TWF and these Halloween specials are filled with such love
the song that play before the pumpkin bunny came is "the streets of cairo" 12:19 "the waterman house has been empty ever since" there's a little light like when someone took a picture using a camera in the window😶 edit: oh so it was in the video nevermind forget what I write about the camera light
Gamersault is that one entity travel to many universe of many horror thingy or along horror and being immortal, just to gather many lore just to tell to us :3
I know that the new sequel is better for sure, love the new Pr design. But my nostalgia loves the Original more, just by a bit more. I am also disappointed that Martin didn’t voice PR again, but he sounds similar to the OG voice.
Something doesn't make sense here... In "the mysterious house" Lorenzo was already burned before the townsfolk burned them. When did he have a burned face? Even in "the return of the pumpkin rabbit" he still has those scars.
It could be from that bear child, since in the prequel he looked the most traumatized and probably but up some kind of fight. But that’s just speculation.
If anyone is asking why they also take pictures of their victims before they die. It's believed that taking a photo of a living person traps their soul in either the picture or in the place it was taken at while they are alive or after they die.
I just want to say..That I love your channel really! I've been watching ever since I was 10 and it just gets better and better every year..The way you explain makes it creepier but just makes me want to watch more of your videos!
Its funny how people are just focusing on how Ralph is the only one who did not enter the house and die first. But what about Paco? Paco atleast had some resistance going into the house. You can hear the regret in Paco’s voice (Which is probably because he entered the house peer pressured) when Rachel was singing. Which is almost as bad as Ralph’s death.
What Ralph should have done is waited for his friends to come out (by that I mean once they entered and didn't come out in o lets say 2 minutes) you run away and get the bloody mob again. Secondly if your ball goes behind said scary house welp sucks to suck get a new ball.
Will you cover the main Walten files series as a analysis since the lore is confusing to me btw you did a great job in this video as you always do ,Love from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳
It is just me but did Jay father did not think what to happen to Paco and Ralph like what did he not know what happened to the other two last night and all so did not question why Dinoface is cover in his own blood and scratches
Then, why can't the couple at least Ducky and Tammy phone their parents to let them know that they are staying over at some creepy couple's house? Hopefully, that would get their parents rushing over to pick up their kids because nobody wants to be left apprehensive by a way too friendly couple.
Theory: I think The Watermans have already been burned alive and have survived by some odds. This would explain why the pumpkin Rabbits face looks mutilated or burnt.
Wooly went crazy here 😲
when im done with you your gonna be named gaysault
pls
@@CantSitzDyl bro chill 💀
@@gamersaultplease talk about the Walton files pls you gonna like it
@@gamersault I'm going to ruin the ARG series for you. 😅 This arg came out after a FNAF Corn Comic the art and plot are basically identical.
Would you like the name of it?
Fun fact: Jay and Dino were inspired by plushies owned by the game's creator and his girlfriend. They confirmed they couldn't kill off the pair which is why Dino and Jay survive.
On God is that true?
@@captainstardust1387 It’s real.
@@captainstardust1387Go check n chill w that ong shi
I would've actually never watched the Walten Files again if Dino didn't survive. /j ☠ Thank god for sentimental plushies.
Man Ralph was the smartest person around, but the plot said he was too strong and had to kill him cuh
@@Jaymix07 The plot denied him his destiny
i mean not going in the house was smart. Goin in the backyard was pretty dumb
@@MrBurger157 I mean, like, if I was him, I would take that opportunity to leave the group earlier on. I don't care if these 'friends' call me a loser, though, I'll still go home anyway.
Ralph is literally the only one who's got sence to not go into the murder house, press F to pay respect for him he could've had a happier ending 😭😭😭
F
@@gamersault It's those dang pumpkins, I tell you, Pumpkin Rabbit knew what he was doin' >:(( (tysm for for replying to my comment, it's literally a dream come true :D)
F
F 😭
Those dang pumpkins always being evil little bastards
This type of horror is really something else where instead of sudden jumpscares the creeps are slowly build upon and i hate every bit of it
You should see the charisma special…. It’s worst
@@pedrorosa9893 speech 100
Why would you be scared of puppet dog puppet cat
I hate it and I love it gets the blood pumping
These are quite legit snuff films with physiological horror.
Rip my boi ralph gone but not forgotten, his brain was too big for this universe.
The plot betrayed him
✊😔
@@Exploding_Bagelswhy did ducky decide to cannabalise that child man 😢
@Exploding_Bagels 😔✊
This now has to be my favorite new walten files video and it's been 4 years ever since the first halloween special came out. What a improvement made
What a coincidence, its also been four years since they last killed. Since they're last photo was in 1979 and the current Halloween takes place in 1983. Ngl,if I was them I would be just as insane. Imagine not eating in four years! Maybe it’s to keep a pact or something.
@@gigachad1661 My theory: I think the book kept them alive no matter what. They weren’t held back by bodily-limitations like animals and humans do where they need to eat and sleep, so they appeared and represented themselves as normal individuals, but are actually demons from hell that somehow made a deal to become human-like individuals in this world.
Even if their bodies were burned, the book would revive them as their souls are pacted with the book from the possible deal they made with someone summoning them on Halloween night. Until the book was finally burned, killing them for good, sending them back to hell, where they clearly didn’t want to go back to.
Motive: Killing kids is probably just sports for them, but I think it also gives them a lifespan like the Other Mother from Coraline where they are able to live for a long time until they need to feast on the soul of a child (easy prey), in this instance, every year on Halloween, the day they we’re summoned. Because the soul of a child is fresh and the soul will take a while to grow old, feeding the couple the child’s essence to continue living for a long time. They don’t eat them but they consume their souls somehow.
@@INFP-Turdone of the best theories on the rotpr
15:36 if Ralph had an even bigger brain: “welp guess the ball belongs to the murder house now”
Sadly he was controlled by the makers to get him killed
Nah he didn’t even think they’d come back, I think seeing him was more scary because well…. They died
Or "Nah, id get it in the morning"
@@XxChamoy_69litterally
@@faz10doyh
I knew Jay would survive the second she hid in that cupboard directly after hearing a scream
Fun fact: the reason bon was walking at Ralph like that was because he was mocking the scarecrow and messing with Ralph because later, he gets turned into a scarecrow
THAT IS NOT A FUN FACT😭😭😭
hate to be that guy but thats not bon
Pumpkin Rabbit and Bon are 2 different people.
using this fact: The Pumpkin Rabbit later then uses Ralph (now becoming a scarecrow) to tease Jay and Dino in the basement to distract them
That’s what I was thinking! That part actually made me laugh
I remember hearing about an old superstition where people believe that you can capture a person's soul in a picture, I have a theory that maybe that is how the Waterson couple was able to both trap their victims souls in the mannequins and control them. Because they did have a odd tradition of taking their victims photos and sticking them in a photo album.
I honestly love the Pumpkin Rabbit's new design in this sequel his old one made him look like a recolor of Bon kudos to Martin for bringing him back in the creepiest way!
i like the way the creator makes the spooky monsters they always have tiny heads and big bodies mostly the torso being long and how the pumkin rabbit gets more messed up and withered over time
And Witch Sheep's new redesign too?! I love seeing the revamps!!
Getting his leg caught in a pumpkin and unable to get it out? The plot did Ralph (the dog) so dirty! 😭
I like to believe that some of the pumpkins were laced with traps, like a bear trap or glue that would prevent him from getting out quicker.
@@justsomejoyousj I'd like to think he just wasn't able to get his foot out because of the extreme panic and fear he was going through so he just couldn't coordinate his movement with what he was thinking. (at least not fast enough)
@@sporkcheese6649 In my view, you're right. If he wasn't so panicky and fearful, and saying in his mind: "All right, let's take this nice and slow", then he'll slowly get his foot out of the pumpkin faster than he could and bolted away through the fence gate of the Watermans' backyard.
One time, I feel like him, placed in his situation(Not with the batman costume that Ralph wears. I ain't Vengeance). I was younger at that time, and you know these pumpkins? Like, lined up in rows? I was at home(if my memory served right), and accidentally got stuck, my foot in one of the pumpkins. I didn't realise, I wasn't running like Ralph did in TROPR, but carelessly walking. I began panicking, and tried getting my foot out.
I knew that if i panicked too much, I wouldn't get my foot out quicker.
(Edit: Sorry if the comment's long, I feel like this pumpkin memory is a bit.. traumatising, but that scene with Ralph's final moment on screen reminds me of that time.)
Don’t get why everyone is calling Ralph a dog, “specifically “the dog”, considering he looks more like a fox or something and Jay is much more clearly a dog
@@crustpunkjesuschrist his snout and ears if he was a fox he would’ve been like an orange type if color
5:09 In the video, if you listen close, you can hear what sounds like Ducky calling Tammy’s name beyond the door. I’ve seen some people theorize that TPR can mimic or replicate other’s voices.
It isn't a theory at this point because TPR tried to do it to Jay with Ralph's voice in the second video
@ fair enough
The scrapbook was likely the crux of the contract they made. So once it was destroyed, their debts were to be immediately collected, destroying their very souls.
Maby by showing hospitality to the kids (giving them candy and letting them stay the night) before killing them. the kids were unknowingly putting their souls in debt to the rabbit and sheep. Taking the photograph binds the souls to either the house or to the rabbit. Then, once they die, the "debt" can only be repaid through possibly indefinite servitude. Fucking brutal if so.
It’s like when Facilier’s necklace got broken and all the souls dragged him to hell.
Seeing the animation in Return of the Pumpkin Rabbit I forgot how the first episode was basically a slideshow. He really improved!
I don't think paco and ralph were stucked in the house after their death, my assumption is that they too also were released
Since there were no mannequin of their own on the basement
Maybe their mannequins were just in the dark with the others
@sarawalten7949 the creator won't do those kind of stuff, hiding something as like that away from camera view, right?
@SunTheUser idk, Martin doesn't seem to put much attention on stuff that isn't important to the scene. In that scene the important thing was the pumpkin rabbit and the witch sheep mannequins. But I could be wrong
@@sarawalten7949 there were a scene in which the rabbit took picture of the children from the window earlier on, which is unnoticed by many
So the chances is quite siding on my assumption
@@SunTheUser but their picture was in the photobook which got burnt
Jay's dad had a sherrifs badge on his jacket...
They said earlier in the Halloween video from this year that the townsfolk were the ones who "took matters into their own hands" after Tammy and Ducky's disappearance. With Jays dad being a policeman at the least, the "sheriff" at the most, he was very likely to have been there while Rachel and Lorenzo were set ablaze.
Most likely was involved in investigating the disappearances..
The big thing to remember is that no one found any evidence of the kidnapping n murders, and that they set them ablaze because of a hunch + info from Tammy's sister.
Billy and TVA died in 1974, the pumpkin bear who was implicated to be the last child to die before Tammy and Ducky died in 1978..
Billy was shown in the short teaser to have been instructed by the couple to fetch ingredients for a spell...and it involved a photo of -someone(s)-.
Some children are scarecrows..some are used as puppets to gain trust from the victims..
We see this with Ducky and I wanna say Paco, the priest child, in this video. But what if we also saw it with Billy and TVA in the first Halloween special with Tammy and Ducky?
What really gets me is the use of the children after they perish. Some are gruesome decor. But why? Maybe their bodies were far too decayed/mangled to be of any more use?
And the mannequins...they have to represent trapped souls. There were a ton inside the house..but Ralph encountered one outside when he was going for his ball
I think it's clear that the book had something "special", so I suppose it makes the bodies look like mannequins when ppl are around or when the lights are on, that's why the police couldn't find any bodies and why Lorenzo and Rachel turned into mannequins too when Jay's dad came in
Pumpkin rabbit said that Tammy would be punished. Maybe the punishment is being turned into a scarecrow
he 1000% had something to do with their deaths. Considering the quote that kept getting repeated throughout the video, that Jay's dad eventually said at the end, I'm willing to bet those exact words was something he said to convince the townsfolk to kill them.
Not to mention, Lorenzo and Rachel have been killing kids since 1950
22:42 the pumpkin rabbit used Ralph’s head and mimiced his voice to try and trick jay
I think the one that was being mimicked was Paco. Ralph was the superman kid that stayed outside.
@@Weird_al_lover_62 batman*
@@Weird_al_lover_62Was it rlly Paco? I thought he was killed by the Witch sheep and Ralph killed by pumpkin rabbit
@gigglinggiggler oh wait yeah.
I love how Martín changed the designs of the children, in the mysterious house they looked too much like deviant art fan art but now they look so unique and I would do anything to protect my boy Dino
Makes things a bit sadder, because they look like little plushies now.
@ bro Jay is the sweetest looking goober out there
@@lionelschweetz4844what’s funny is that Jay and Dino are based off real plushies that Martin and his gf own while the other kids were created later on
I honestly like the old designs i think the new ones look better tho
Lesson learned. Never, but NEVER let your kids go trick or treating alone
W/ supervision, ofc:)
Ducky's right, Tammy should have listened to him. And, who knocks at the door of a decrepit house? The place is likely derelict or abandoned. That should be a giant crimson flag.
Tammy was a little dumdum
@@sarawalten7949 And naive.
I guess she thought the old house looked like that on purpose since is Halloween, thinking “oh, they’re getting into the Halloween spirit”
@@cheyblake2475 Yeah but who builds abandoned houses in the middle of freaking nowhere?
Well, to be fair, it was Halloween. So, can you really blame her for wanting to do more trick or treating?
Kids. Go to the grocery store tomorrow. The candy goes on sale that you can buy a large mix bag with your allowance
Poor Ralph, he didn’t even go in but died first :(
R.I.P.
By the way, as I found out on Twitter, Pumpkin Rabbit looks more like a dog or a wolf than a rabbit due to the shape of his muzzle and nose when his mask falls off. It's pretty cool how he plays the wolf in sheep's clothing analogy!
In the mysterious house, the couple just… seemed too supernatural to be scary.
However, in the return of the pumpkin rabbit, their dialog seemed more human, and that made it scarier too feel like a live person would want to do that to kids.
i disagree i feel they are only scary because they are supernatural, that way you have no idea what are their capabilities or motives. you feel maybe they always know where you are and what you are going to do and there is nothing you can do to stop them. on the other hand if they are real people then it's just oh it's a bunch of mentally ill people who've had terrible lives and they have all the limitations you do. thats not scary to me at all
The Mysterious House and The Return of The Pumpkin Rabbit are some of the best analog horror videos I've ever seen. I wonder if this is the final video we'll see about The Pumpkin Rabbit or if it will continue next Halloween.
To be honest, because of the ending I don’t know how the couple could come back. But even if it doesn’t continue its still a good analog series.
Maybe we’ll see a prequel centered around the origins of the Waterman’s, with Billy and TVA being their first victims
"I always come back" Pumpkin Rabbit probably
@@omegbeefNot the first but yeah
@@kuruumss well maybe not the first victims but the most memorable ones
Who knows, the watermans may think those two are special and probably cripple them instead to puppeteer them as “friends” like how they’re shown in the Mysterious House
Could be a callback to Susan being stuffed into Banny where TVA and Billy are paralyzed and kept in mocked up versions of their costumes to slowly rot
Nice, When I first watched the first part years ago I thought that the series ended then and there. Im now glad that the universe got a good ending.
I hope Martin Walls later does a later episode that explains what their motives are
All great horror stories are ones where little is explained.
I remember watching it and going "At least that kid has some sense!" Only to be forced to watch poor Ralph get killed 😢 Sometimes you do everything right and still wind up murdered
26:35 fun fact:That's not a mannequin.Those are the remains of Paco.Not only did they destroy my poor boy's face,they beheaded and split his torso through
thats def a mannequin because he did not have arms that long 😭😭🙏🙏
@goobagombi9893 It could be that Pacos head is on the mannequin, since the head is similiar to Pacos, and Martin didnt show us what happened to Paco, so he just decided to show his corpse.
@@SauliusB that's what i meant, but albert thought that it was paco's head and body, its for sure his head but not his body
@@goobagombi9893 in my defense,old bodies that were shown in both specials always seemed like ,how do I say it,stretched.For example,the corpse of the fox always seemed off to me bc of the torso.It almost looks like the bodies "age" and "grow" even after the victims are killed or they are just that maimed by PR.Or it could be a style choice on Martin's part so that's why I usually didn't pay it any mind
i love paco sm only bc thats the name of my dog irl 😢
I don't think I am sleeping tonight. But man you explained it in a great way. Love your videos!
That scene of Ralph‘s death is probably the most sinister thing ever made
5:48 those anyone who don’t know that pumpkin rabbit standing on the door behind her
why didnt i see this 4 years ago
Fr 😭
This might be my second favourite episode that i have see with episode 3 being my favourite for now, by the way pumpkin's cupboard scare is my new favourite in the walten files
Bro when they burned the book I was LETS GOOoOo IM SICK OF THERE ASS
BERLEEZY reference 😭😭🙏
KEEP SPRAYING
Lily got what she deserved, she cut off my boy Louis’ tongue out
@@tmcj3432 I was just about to mention that
@@Recroommusicsal oh, okay
You know what? I wasn't going to say this, because it sounds weird, but, while the way Ralph died was horrific, it was intensely interesting: he fought through a good number of horror troupes, and STILL failed. THAT is unfortunate reality. Like, it sucks, and it's sad, but, sometimes you just can't win, even when you do the best you can.
Edit: Omg, I just realized it was Mrs. Waterman singing Hush Little Baby. I thought Paco was singing it to himself, as like a technique for self-soothing! I'm a dingus, for heaven's sake! XD
I really wish I didn’t get recommended this at 2 am and had to see that thumbnail lol also the part where they burn their house down is probably to me is now the creepiest thing in waltine flies
Martin has said the Halloween and Christmas video are not canon to the Walter files, but have lore hints towards it
So what's the point of these being made?
@@doctor9551 fun maybe?
There’s a a lot of similarities with the Nightmare on elm street series. Before Freddy was killed, he would kidnap the children of springwood and bring them to his boiler room at the factory where he worked at and would kill them. He would soon be arrested for the murders but was let go due to the arrest warrant not being signed which caused the town to outrage. The parents of the children he killed would track him down and burn him alive taking justice into their own hands. But then Freddy came back and started his killing spree again by going after the teenagers of springwood in their dreams, and every time he claimed a victim, Freddy absorbed their souls inside of him because he fed off of them to grow more powerful
Just how the Waterman’s kept the souls of the kids trapped within their memory book, they were burned alive but would not stay dead
In Nightmare 4 the dream master, Alice defeated Freddy by showing his reflection in the mirror, that enabled the souls of the children inside of him to be freed, he was basically torn apart by them just how the kids attacked witch sheep and pumpkin rabbit after they were freed
This whole video seems to have a lot of references to horror films, the main girl is wearing a good guy outfit from Child’s play, Pumpkin Rabbit is dressed as Leather Face, the scene with the rabbit leaning on the door is based on the shining and the book burning is DEFINITELY a reference to Evil Dead with the necronomicon burning
@ true
And the fact that it’s set in Halloween is reference to the 1978 movie
And how michaels killing spree affected the town of Haddonfield
Martin really took a lot of Inspiration from the classics
If you let your KIDS trick or treat ALONE at night, then I'm sorry, but you signed your children's death warrent. I didn't go trick or treating alone until I was thirteen, and even then, I wasn't as dumb as these kids. If there were a haunted murder house, I ain't NEVER GOING ANYWHERE NEAR IT.
To be fair, this takes place in the 70s and 80s.
I stopped at 13 and just bought treats
@lionelschweetz4844 I can assure you, a lot of families by then weren't even allowing their kids to be alone trick or treating. Adults don't leave their doors open anymore before that time period. My mother and uncle remembered trick or treating with my grandparents
@lionelschweetz4844 they weren't trick-or-treating by themselves until they turn too 13, and they also had to have a group of kids going together. they can't be in Paris
Yeah when I watched Ducky and Tammy discussing about going to that house or not, I can't help but wonder where the hell are their parents? Don't they ever warn their kids that they should be more wary and not go to unfamiliar places without permission or anything like that?? Especially at night ?? Plus, kids go missing every Halloween in town, how come these adults still got the fucking nerve to let the kids go trick-or-treating alone at night?? While I won't deny that the Pumpkin Rabbit & Mysterious House is an excellent analogue horror series, but the plot in it is still that same old dumb lame cliché. "Oh look at that creepy suspicious house ! Lets hurry and go there ! I am pretty sUrE everything's going to be FINE!! :D"
I can’t watch the end of the mysterious house without hearing the thicc pumpkin rabbit meme. Also idk if you’ve noticed this but the blue hippo in the mysterious house wasn’t one of the corpses and I didn’t see them in return of the pumpkin rabbit so maybe they got away
That’s what I thought too. Maybe they changed the victims.
There's also an Angel dog in the album but their corpse is nowhere to be found. Maybe some were able to escape
Maybe that's why people acted on a "hunch" with next to no evidence.
@@Zaw517 wait now that I’m rewatching it the Hippo was there but only at the end. You see a super short glimpse of him.
@@lewafflez5356they also appear in the scene when the spirits kill the couple but their face is extremly mangled
11:59 Absolute Chad Townspeople
Ye!
Fr fr
Yeah, something i didnt really comprehend was billy and tva's role in the story, are they adults?, kids? In the second installment you can see a photo of what appears to be a kid version of Billy and TVA in a photo with the pumpkin rabbit. But when Jay reaches into Billy's mouth, his body appears to be fully grown. The timeline of the killings also seemed kinda messed up. Naybe im just not paying attention but im almost positive tammy and ducky werent killed before billy and tva since they are both in the house before tammy and ducky die
Their bodies just seem to be stretched out, because Ducky also seems to be way bigger in the new episode, but he was an average height child
The couple seemed to have been using the souls of the kids as messed up puppets using the photobook.That's why they were "alive"
Theyre kids corpses being puppeted. Like duckys was in this episode
25:20 this sound is the first recorded audio ever [ Au Clair de la Lune (1860) ]
MORE WALTEN FILES MY DAY IS MADE
This one was absolutely more intense than I think I was ever expecting what incredible quality and voice acting!! I absolutely love the style/aesthetic of TWF and these Halloween specials are filled with such love
Ralph did not deserve that 😭
That really got me...I gotta be honest...Ralph deserved to be the last man standing...but he was done dirty
@ RIP Ralph 🫡
@@haydenper yeah, poor ralph
I guess it shows that not even irl logic can save you sometimes
@@faz10do yup, sometimes people just gotta die no matter what.
The camera flash at 10:32 is use to trap the souls of the children in the book.
Only the ones that looked at the camera I think
Ralph was my favorite I really expected him to be the one to figure it out
Its funny to hear you talk about ralph getting killed by plot
RIP ralph
RIP, He deserved better 😞
the song that play before the pumpkin bunny came is
"the streets of cairo"
12:19
"the waterman house has been empty ever since"
there's a little light like when someone took a picture using a camera in the window😶
edit: oh so it was in the video nevermind forget what I write about the camera light
Gamersault is that one entity travel to many universe of many horror thingy or along horror and being immortal, just to gather many lore just to tell to us :3
Fun fact you can actually see the pumpkin rabbit when she's talking to billy
I think Freddy Krueger had the same fate of being burned alive by the parents/townfolks once. At least the couple didn't become dream demons.
...or did they?
They technically did because they lived off of memories of terror from other people
Wait if the town killed mr.and mrs.waterman how were they in the house 4 years later. @Skividi_toylet
I really like your analysis
This is so good. Also F's in the chat for Ralph
i feel like the plot is about the penguin and jay reliving what happened to their best friends
I just realized that in the main series, children are perfectly safe around the animatronics. But in the mysterious house, and FNAF they aren’t.
2:57 I can't unsee Spring Bonnie/Springtrap/William Afton.
Fun fact, did you know that the Walton file was actually based on poppy playtime
I know that the new sequel is better for sure, love the new Pr design. But my nostalgia loves the Original more, just by a bit more. I am also disappointed that Martin didn’t voice PR again, but he sounds similar to the OG voice.
I noticed pr rabbit has a tie instead of a bow in this too.
Time PR was voiced by the old Ducky voice actor from The Mysterious House
why is this so graphic and eerie
it gives me chills
Something doesn't make sense here...
In "the mysterious house" Lorenzo was already burned before the townsfolk burned them. When did he have a burned face? Even in "the return of the pumpkin rabbit" he still has those scars.
It could be from that bear child, since in the prequel he looked the most traumatized and probably but up some kind of fight.
But that’s just speculation.
Yet another great video as usual
Why the devs had to do Ralph like that. Sad day for common sense.
The devs????
@@VozGanzo13 the story writters
buddy said the devs 😭
If anyone is asking why they also take pictures of their victims before they die. It's believed that taking a photo of a living person traps their soul in either the picture or in the place it was taken at while they are alive or after they die.
WE ARE SO BACK AT THE WALTIN FILES!
I just want to say..That I love your channel really! I've been watching ever since I was 10 and it just gets better and better every year..The way you explain makes it creepier but just makes me want to watch more of your videos!
Imo Ralph had the most terrifying end, I couldn't even imagine
Bro got the Susan Woodings treatment:(-
If it had a moral of the story it would be: “if you do bad things, it will catch up to you eventually”
Its funny how people are just focusing on how Ralph is the only one who did not enter the house and die first. But what about Paco?
Paco atleast had some resistance going into the house. You can hear the regret in Paco’s voice (Which is probably because he entered the house peer pressured) when Rachel was singing. Which is almost as bad as Ralph’s death.
Are gonna talk about "The Walten Files" created by Martin Walls/Paredes
Maybe...depends how my audience reacts to this video and if they enjoy it
@gamersault My Favorite Character is Bon the Rabbit and Jack Walten
@gamersault oh yes pls talk about the files is the best analog horror out there
It’s not done yet
@magicman3163 yes ik but he can make some theories on it
i just noticed at 10:32 their a camera flash in the window.
I do have to say, I like the covering of other mediums. Games along with videos like analog horrors.
The fact that the watermen are huge is terrifying
Cant wait for the Christmas one
What Ralph should have done is waited for his friends to come out (by that I mean once they entered and didn't come out in o lets say 2 minutes) you run away and get the bloody mob again. Secondly if your ball goes behind said scary house welp sucks to suck get a new ball.
yellow rabbit, comes back from death, kills kids...anyone else getting dejavu?
and dies because of fire
@Skividi_toylet this is all feeling very familiar...
12:18 I saw a flash look closely at the window that's the moment one of the watermans took a picture of the group
Will you cover the main Walten files series as a analysis since the lore is confusing to me btw you did a great job in this video as you always do ,Love from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳
This is the first Walter Files video in which the protagonists actually win against the villain.
She pumpkin my rabbit until I return😩😩😩
hahahhahaa
Same tbh
22:24 *gulp* erm…. She’s right behind me isn’t she?
“What is this, some kind of Return of The Pumpkin Rabbit?”
It is just me but did Jay father did not think what to happen to Paco and Ralph like what did he not know what happened to the other two last night and all so did not question why Dinoface is cover in his own blood and scratches
He did but all he was worrying about in that moment was getting the kids out of that house
Fun fact: Around 12:18 you can see a flash come from one of the windows, more than likely the picture taken at the end.
Spoiler.
yup...it was the picture taken of the group. The Waterman's were on the lookout and ready to trap their souls
I love how the house has the carpet pattern from "The Shining"
Shoutout to Jay and Dino, actual heroes right there. Rip Paco and Ralph.
Then, why can't the couple at least Ducky and Tammy phone their parents to let them know that they are staying over at some creepy couple's house? Hopefully, that would get their parents rushing over to pick up their kids because nobody wants to be left apprehensive by a way too friendly couple.
Look at the year, kid. It's 1997 o 1998. Do you think a phone existed in that period?
@@karyltiffanyfloresPhones existed since the 80s…
Justice for my boy Ralph he ain't do nothing✊️😔
Shoutout to Ralph, my boy deserved to survive🗣️🗣️
I think it was confirmed in a sketch that witch sheep poured acid on pumpkin rabbit's face, also they are not people in costumes, they are animals too
It's like in our world like human serial killer couple that kills kids. But in this universe animals are like humans
Ralph be like: should i choose my ball or my life.... OH WELL FORTUNE FAVORS THE BOLD
Off topic but Dino was so cute, did not want bro to die😭
Ur acting like he did die tho
He's alive 😋
I am pretty sure the mannequins are supposed to be dead bodies
Yeah, specially considering the Waterman's also turned into mannequins
Theory: I think The Watermans have already been burned alive and have survived by some odds. This would explain why the pumpkin Rabbits face looks mutilated or burnt.
I've never heard of this series
Really? U gotta go back and watch from the beginning it’s really good and creepy
@YoooAwp I'm serious I've never heard of this or seen a reaction to it
@ I’d recommend watching yourself and then watching nexpos breakdown of it tho it might be a little bit outdated
Calm little subtle foreshadowing at the start
I would love to see this as an whole indie game someday.... Its a very good concept and story to be made into a game
I think jay lost to plot armor aswell. Idk how pumpkin rabbit knew he was in that cupboard, but bro couldve thugged ot out until morning
Because it dropped a bowl while closing it? If im not mistaken
This is why people only trick or treath on malls where I live
Where I live people don't trick or treat at all sin its not very Christian as they say lol
amazing video man