Forza Horizon 5 vs Gran Turismo 7 vs The Crew Motorfest - Porsche 911 GT3 RS (992) Sound Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 170

  • @MotoGamesTV
    @MotoGamesTV  Місяць тому +7

    Real life for comparison:
    ua-cam.com/video/2weCqspnVOI/v-deo.html
    ua-cam.com/video/sjF9BwRmN34/v-deo.html

    • @Eugenio6460
      @Eugenio6460 Місяць тому

      @MotoGamesTV para vos cual de los 3 sonidos suena mejor?

    • @MotoGamesTV
      @MotoGamesTV  Місяць тому +4

      @@Eugenio6460 GT7

    • @Eugenio6460
      @Eugenio6460 Місяць тому

      @@MotoGamesTV hace un top 3 del mejor sonido al peor

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому

      ​@@MotoGamesTVI also pick Gran Turismo 7. The GT3 RS in GT7 sounds matched the real life counterpart.

  • @john7156
    @john7156 Місяць тому +132

    Gran Turismo has really come a long way with their engine sounds in my opinion.

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому +6

      From mosquito engine sound in GT5 all the way to amazing engine sound in GT6 SPEC II MOD to GT7.

    • @klockenberg2299
      @klockenberg2299 Місяць тому

      @@purwantiallan5089 GT Sport is when the change happened so it's not GT7.

  • @thecayman8567
    @thecayman8567 Місяць тому +49

    GT7 the best sound and cockpit view. I just saw 6 diferent one on the car show, and some of them been doing launch control, so GT7 sounds like absolute copy of real one

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому

      Absolutely agree with you, @thecayman8567.

    • @parthsharma6495
      @parthsharma6495 Місяць тому +1

      nah bro crew motorfest got the best cockpit view in any racing game ever.

    • @thecayman8567
      @thecayman8567 Місяць тому +1

      @ I mean I never played GT7, but what I heard in real life and what’s in the game. It’s just identical. As for cockpit view, the crew doesn’t have that much detail, and it’s looking ugly when you choosing an interior colours, like 2008 game

    • @parthsharma6495
      @parthsharma6495 Місяць тому +1

      @@thecayman8567 the interior colour part is true.. but man just seeing the wheel turn full 360 degrees and driving in cockpit view feels way better than any game. i feel like motorfest isnt a hardcore racing game but way more fun than any other racing games. Ps. you can watch the GT3 RS real life pov video and then compare it with these 3 games, the crew motorfest is just accurate

  • @Ada-xo3dy
    @Ada-xo3dy Місяць тому +51

    0:42 gave me goosebump, easily winner.

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому +1

      GT By Citroen Race Car '08 in GT7 also has amazing engine notes.

  • @juniorreis1078
    @juniorreis1078 Місяць тому +190

    Gt7 is high level..

    • @Uolizo
      @Uolizo Місяць тому +22

      Because it doesn't need to render a open world as big as FH5 n TCMF

    • @llJeezusll
      @llJeezusll Місяць тому +13

      True
      But GT cars have always had higher level detailed cars compared to even motorsport.
      Doesn't make it a better game though. Will always be more of a Forza fan but cant deny the amazing work the GT team puts into their cars

    • @andreasmoller9798
      @andreasmoller9798 Місяць тому +10

      Gt7 is another league, the only good forza nowdays is the horizons, motorsport is a flop sadly,

    • @ZoqqerFabian
      @ZoqqerFabian Місяць тому +1

      @@andreasmoller9798But Motorsport has the same car models…

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@llJeezusllTHE CREW MOTORFEST is not far behind GT7 surprisingly terms of how this car sounds.

  • @LuisRivas-yb1gq
    @LuisRivas-yb1gq Місяць тому +119

    Not Forza using the old 991 GT3 RS on the screen instead of the 992 😭
    Classic Turn 10 "attention to detail"

    • @MotoGamesTV
      @MotoGamesTV  Місяць тому +51

      I'm pretty much sure that this is on Playground Games, same as Focus RS logo on the wheels.

    • @AKK5I
      @AKK5I Місяць тому +9

      BUILT

    • @Razgriz2118
      @Razgriz2118 Місяць тому +10

      @@AKK5I FROM

    • @Rustic_3851
      @Rustic_3851 Місяць тому +9

      @@Razgriz2118 THE GROUND UP

    • @ZOFRACING
      @ZOFRACING Місяць тому +8

      @@Rustic_3851not the same game

  • @AedannTracy
    @AedannTracy Місяць тому +38

    Actually happy to see motor fest as part of the top 3

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому +14

      68% of the car sounds in THE CREW 3 MOTORFEST actually are fantastic. Including Ricciardo's 2017 RB13.

    • @AedannTracy
      @AedannTracy Місяць тому +5

      @ agreed

    • @darkninja9499
      @darkninja9499 Місяць тому +2

      The crew peakfest

  • @andreasmoller9798
    @andreasmoller9798 Місяць тому +34

    Strangest thing of all is that pd added the gt3 rs almost a year before the other 2, most of the time they are always way later to add new up to date cars.
    Gt7 gets the win here in every aspect,
    Not only does the gt3 sound quite accurate in gt7, but can also be experinced in vr, you can see how oil temps and stuff like that change while driving it, you can also manually change the drs just like reallife

    • @Uolizo
      @Uolizo Місяць тому +2

      Bro its a motorsport sim ofc the details in track, cars and sound has to be on point this is literally such an off comparison they must just compare gt7 to FM and TCMF to FH5

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Місяць тому +9

      @@Uolizo nope it all depends on talent pg are lazy they add Ford focus rs badge lol

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому +2

      GT4, GT3 and Group 1 cars on GT7 all also have awesome car details.

    • @sofwanlutfy4050
      @sofwanlutfy4050 Місяць тому

      Not really strange. It simply implies that PD got time-limited exclusive rights to GT3 RS, which Playground Games and Ubisoft did not get. Such practice is nothing new. See Porsche exclusivity by EA games, which lasts for over a decade, hence why you see every other racing game either uses RUF or Gemballa as replacement. Even some games nowadays were launched first in a certain platform/store and released in others way later, and I'm not talking about games that are made under the name of the platform/store e.g. Sony games like Horizon Zero Dawn.

  • @nader91
    @nader91 Місяць тому +16

    going by the mugello footage as reference GT7's onboard sound is the closest to the real life thing. FH5 is there but the transmission whine should not be that loud.

  • @AXEL-101
    @AXEL-101 Місяць тому +25

    Sounds good in gran turismo

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому

      Also, FXX K EVO on GT7 sounds equally perfect like on Project CARS 2.

  • @purwantiallan5089
    @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому +4

    The 911 GT3RS 2023 on Gran Turismo 7 sounds the best.

  • @Rustic_3851
    @Rustic_3851 Місяць тому +13

    Gran Turismo 7
    - First major racing game to have this car
    - Extreme car model detail
    - Sound is extremely accurate to the real thing
    - Touchscreen’s turned off. Doesn’t show the visual of the car in the screen like the 2 other games did, but either way, it’s not a big deal anyways
    - No factory wheel color options sadly, but at least you can paint it yourself in GT Auto to match with the real ones
    - DRS actually works
    - The whole gauge displays are insanely realistic, like IRL. But why was it set to Normal mode? Concerning that the game itself is about track racing? But at least that display changes realistically while driving.
    The Crew Motorfest
    - Offers different wheel colors thru custom menu
    - Good quality model, but no “GT3 RS” factory vinyls sadly, unless you fix it via Livery menu
    - Sounds good
    - Its touchscreen shows the car itself. Wow
    - DRS only works if you use Nitrous. It’s supposed to engage in higher speeds like IRL
    - Why it didn’t show the Speed and PDK shifter digital display in the lower part of the Tachometer? And it shows G-Force because it’s in Track mode, but why is it static? It doesn’t move when the car moves. Wtf?
    Forza Horizon 5
    - Another good modeling, has colors with or without “GT3 RS” vinyls, and factory wheel colors. But aside from modeling, why is the “RS” badge on its wheels taken from Ford Focus RS and not from Porsche? That’s a tiny mistake right there!
    - Sound needs improvement
    - Why does it show 991.2 on the touchscreen? That’s strange
    - Just like GT7, the DRS works there as well
    - Gauge displays are shown, and it’s in Track mode as well with the G-Force display. Comparing to Motorfest, the G-Force in FH5 actually moves like it should.
    Overall, GT7 is the winner.

    • @purwantiallan5089
      @purwantiallan5089 Місяць тому

      Overall 10/10 despite the damage model is absent in GT7 (even GT6 & 5 have cosmetic damage models).

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Місяць тому +1

      The one in gran turismo 7 is weissage package

    • @Rustic_3851
      @Rustic_3851 Місяць тому +1

      @@purwantiallan5089 Damage modeling in GT7 is only scratches and light cracks, it’s a very tiny visibility. No body deformations and rollover physics. Licensing must’ve caused that. TCM and FH5 have less body deformations in their damage modeling.

    • @Rustic_3851
      @Rustic_3851 Місяць тому

      @@olavofernandes7286 Yep, it is. You’re right!

    • @potato6691
      @potato6691 Місяць тому

      for the crew motorfest its under exclusive livery, just move your cursor to the left and it should bring you to the far right of the list, they have 3 gt3 rs livery iirc

  • @AntoineGevel-gn2pw
    @AntoineGevel-gn2pw Місяць тому +2

    Bro the logo on the cockpit vue in Gt7 is crazy

  • @blackmamba-123
    @blackmamba-123 Місяць тому +54

    1 Gt7
    2 Crew motorfest
    3 Forza

  • @farhanshameel7810
    @farhanshameel7810 Місяць тому +6

    played this car in all 3 games and not only is it my favourite to drive in all 3, its now my favourite in the world. sounds wise, a good mix between all 3 games would be perfect.

  • @Fumze
    @Fumze Місяць тому +7

    You could also do downshifts for comparison bro

  • @Mudar-o6h
    @Mudar-o6h Місяць тому +1

    2:25 you need to enable drs by holding R3

  • @BandoDraco43
    @BandoDraco43 Місяць тому +3

    Motorfest sounds like an helicopter lmao

    • @lordass9245
      @lordass9245 Місяць тому

      you have weird helicopters where you live

  • @Ty2late
    @Ty2late Місяць тому

    And you can make MotorFest exhaust sounds more Unique with the Audio signatures which is cool

  • @petrolhead9123
    @petrolhead9123 Місяць тому +1

    And all those who think GT7 has the best sound, you still haven't heard how it sounds with the racing exhaust 😎

  • @sanslar
    @sanslar Місяць тому +5

    в the crew у порше ещё и подруливающая задняя ось.

  • @CirocObama.94
    @CirocObama.94 Місяць тому +8

    It's just crazy. We live in a time where Gran Turismo has the best racing sounds at the moment

  • @LP-770
    @LP-770 Місяць тому +1

    I hate how nothing works in the interior on Motorfest. I wish they had more attention to detail in the cockpits

    • @lordass9245
      @lordass9245 Місяць тому

      i mean the wheel has full rotation range, the mirrors work, the shifters move both on manual and automatic cars, the characters actually step on the gas and clutch pedals, they can roll down the window and relax their arm when cruising, they have a rearview mirror adjust animation, the displays show actually in game time, some cars have lights on icons on their displays when you turn them on, the koenigseggs on wheel displays actually are giroscopically adjusted when turned unlike horizon 5, the G force measure things actually work ( at least on most cars that have them) and so on : ]

    • @nivity9673
      @nivity9673 Місяць тому

      Tf should work there?

    • @LP-770
      @LP-770 Місяць тому

      @ The shifting dial. The whole interior isn’t accurate to begin with

    • @lordass9245
      @lordass9245 Місяць тому

      @@LP-770 what the hell is a shifting dial

  • @crunchie2475
    @crunchie2475 Місяць тому +9

    Forza sounds unrealistic as always

  • @belhedizied8937
    @belhedizied8937 Місяць тому +2

    Gt7 wins easily, quality over quantity any day of the week 👌

  • @somerandomdude2085
    @somerandomdude2085 Місяць тому

    That gt3s in horizon sounds rough imo compared to motorfest and gt. I hope Playground goes back and manually update the sound cause I know they can do better.

  • @domepugliese
    @domepugliese Місяць тому +1

    nice vid, although some samples of the real car (with stock exhaust) would be very useful. Like in this case, many people say TCM sound is better, even if Forza is (strangely), and it's very close to the real car.
    GT is very good, but the sound is still a bit too... digital...?

  • @beastlyfn5167
    @beastlyfn5167 Місяць тому

    How come the crew doesn’t have the gt3 rs logo on the back of the car

  • @Luldric
    @Luldric Місяць тому

    The crew está a otro nivel y no solo gráficamente. Por qué será que los proplayer juegan a the crew motorfest?

  • @Tritonal92
    @Tritonal92 Місяць тому +1

    Man... the car sounds from Forza sound so bad.

  • @major3336
    @major3336 Місяць тому

    I’ve loved GT since GT3 but the cars just sound the same to me now. They all have that weird compression or reverb effect that I don’t like at all. Forza honestly sound really good with this car, but TCM always sounds so good. There’s maybe 4 cars at the most in TCM that I’ve found that have weird/bugged/ unsatisfying sounds. All the rest sounds amazing. GT has usually had plenty more from what I’ve played in the past and seen on YT for GT7 that are meh sounding. Forza is the same as GT. Only few cars that seem satisfying to me audio wise, from what I’ve researched on YT anyway.

  • @maximilianoarancibia6263
    @maximilianoarancibia6263 4 дні тому

    Son juegos totalmente distintos, no hay un ganador, es mas de gustos.

  • @rsr-warrior
    @rsr-warrior Місяць тому +5

    Historical era it seems, everyone is getting the Porsche 911 sound about right...so glad I got a PS5 tho!

  • @Jaysupa-w1n
    @Jaysupa-w1n Місяць тому +1

    GT7 🙌🏽

  • @tsebomoloi3410
    @tsebomoloi3410 Місяць тому

    This car has a soft limiter

  • @Mudar-o6h
    @Mudar-o6h Місяць тому

    GT7 #1 🏆 🥇🎖🏅
    FH5 # 2 🥈
    Moterfest # 3🥉

  • @DmxWhereMyDogsAT
    @DmxWhereMyDogsAT Місяць тому +2

    I think motorfest GT3 RS is only one with adaptive DRS wing movement when nos applied... But GT7 defs sounds the best

    • @shadowniki8038
      @shadowniki8038 Місяць тому

      Fh5 has drs movement at ~ 195 km/h, look carefully😊

    • @lilshax7297
      @lilshax7297 Місяць тому +3

      @@DmxWhereMyDogsAT GT7 have DRS mouvement too

  • @YM-oj6dd
    @YM-oj6dd Місяць тому

    GT7 🎉

  • @olavofernandes7286
    @olavofernandes7286 Місяць тому +1

    Gran turismo 7 won

  • @rollsroyce8385
    @rollsroyce8385 Місяць тому +1

    Gt7 ❤❤❤❤

  • @cyberdemonass8479
    @cyberdemonass8479 Місяць тому +1

    All good😸

  • @kaiherrmann9481
    @kaiherrmann9481 Місяць тому

    Lol. 3 Games, 3 totally different sounds. From natural to weak.. and GT7

  • @crunchie2475
    @crunchie2475 Місяць тому

    gt7 is unbeatable

  • @ThatCrippledGuy_
    @ThatCrippledGuy_ Місяць тому

    I don’t think that’s the 992 cuz the 992 has active wing

  • @LukasXc
    @LukasXc Місяць тому +1

    2:23 WTF, GT7 has unrealistic RPM limit sound. This has always happened.

    • @andreasmoller9798
      @andreasmoller9798 Місяць тому

      Yet gt7 wins this camparsion for the most accurate gt3 rs sound

    • @LukasXc
      @LukasXc Місяць тому +1

      @andreasmoller9798 Yes, I agree that the GT7 has a good sound in this car (it rarely happens), but the RPM limit sound has always been horrible in Gran Turismo.

    • @KaueBrGames
      @KaueBrGames Місяць тому

      ​@@LukasXcIt depends on the car, you will hear the cut of the Porsche gt3 rs 991

    • @A.3bv
      @A.3bv Місяць тому

      @@LukasXcI love forza horizon but the sound in gt7 very very realistic the upshift sound same the real gt3

  • @HamzaSaleem-ez6dl
    @HamzaSaleem-ez6dl Місяць тому +35

    Best sound: GT7😍
    Worst sound: Forza🤮

    • @MrEcvilibrum
      @MrEcvilibrum Місяць тому +1

      worst The Crew Motorfest

    • @luxyt1255
      @luxyt1255 10 днів тому

      @@MrEcvilibrum😂😂

  • @jeffrytdi9040
    @jeffrytdi9040 Місяць тому +2

    GT7 PDK gearbox is more real.

  • @nick.i.am97
    @nick.i.am97 Місяць тому +3

    Forza Horizon & The Crew MotorFest = Arcade Games
    Gran Turismo 7 = Real Simulator

  • @johnhenry9453
    @johnhenry9453 25 днів тому

    This bro dont know how to downshift or what

  • @kevingame3198
    @kevingame3198 Місяць тому +1

    Apparently this car is gonna be in fortnite

  • @agm4678
    @agm4678 Місяць тому +12

    The crew 😍

  • @lilshax7297
    @lilshax7297 Місяць тому +3

    GT7 win ez

  • @hiragahs7525
    @hiragahs7525 Місяць тому

    Forza é fraco de mais no quesito áudio

  • @rTrickz
    @rTrickz Місяць тому

    Grab turismo is ass

  • @AntoineGevel-gn2pw
    @AntoineGevel-gn2pw Місяць тому

    Gt7 feeling when you drive make me fall asleep its so annoying no feeling of driving fast nothing compare to forza and The crew 😂 if this game has a good feeling of driving it would be the best game ever

  • @LittleSaenz6
    @LittleSaenz6 Місяць тому

    GT7 is definitely the least realistic, that exhaust sound sounds very fake, it sounds like it was recorded through a plastic tube 😂😅

  • @WTFWHATara
    @WTFWHATara Місяць тому +2

    Exterior camera doesn't sounds good in GT7.
    too high-pitched and muffled ua-cam.com/video/sjF9BwRmN34/v-deo.html

    • @tescoshortage
      @tescoshortage Місяць тому +1

      Considering that GT7 mostly uses synthesized engine sounds as opposed to recording loops or ramps, I say they did a pretty damn good job. I think it sounds fine at higher RPMs

    • @LuisRivas-yb1gq
      @LuisRivas-yb1gq Місяць тому

      I agree, it sound a lil bit too high
      The 991 sounds much better.

    • @andreasmoller9798
      @andreasmoller9798 Місяць тому +1

      If absolutly dosent sound muffled thats for sure.

    • @LuisRivas-yb1gq
      @LuisRivas-yb1gq Місяць тому +2

      Compared to the other games where it sounds raspy (like a fukin inline 6) it does sound KINDA muffled lol ​@@andreasmoller9798

    • @andreasmoller9798
      @andreasmoller9798 Місяць тому

      @@LuisRivas-yb1gqnope gt7 is the closest one to real life, loudest dosen’t mean the best.

  • @NXVARRO559
    @NXVARRO559 Місяць тому

    The gt7 glaze is wild that game sounds like shit and doesn’t even look that good either

  • @flyrydagoon9419
    @flyrydagoon9419 Місяць тому

    All forza have is a highway lol just why I don't support there games lol 😂😂😂😂weak

  • @dnice362
    @dnice362 Місяць тому +11

    I think all around the clear winner is forza

    • @FanatecSystem
      @FanatecSystem Місяць тому +51

      lmfaoo

    • @saeedalshamsi1483
      @saeedalshamsi1483 Місяць тому +31

      What? You kidding right? GT7 is the most accurate game to display the car. Sound and interior with the dashboard and the screen info and DRS and and. The others just trying to

    • @dnice362
      @dnice362 Місяць тому +6

      @ most of the time I do agree with that. But here I feel forza a little better

    • @dnice362
      @dnice362 Місяць тому +1

      @ most of the time I agree

    • @cnegi
      @cnegi Місяць тому

      Noob

  • @nicog4638
    @nicog4638 Місяць тому

    Gt7 sounds so bad honestly 😂
    Same with motorfest knowing that all cars have the same burble sound and the real life car sounds nothing like in motorfest or gt forza also didn't get it perfect but did it best

    • @andreasmoller9798
      @andreasmoller9798 Місяць тому +1

      Gt7 did the best, stop with the cope, you are the biggest delusional forza fanboy there is,
      Gt7 has the most accurate sound for all 3, horizon 5 is actully last between all 3,

    • @deven2333
      @deven2333 Місяць тому

      Forza dickfan

    • @joescivic
      @joescivic Місяць тому +1

      He's only on these videos to be wrongly negative against GT7. He knows nothing and says this same nonsense on every video with GT7 even if GT7 sounds like the actual thing. 😂😂😂

    • @nicog4638
      @nicog4638 Місяць тому

      @joescivic go argue with a wall bru
      If you have ears and can hear you'll hear that thr real life car sounds nothing like gt or the crew they make it sound good in game but not like their real life counterparts

    • @deven2333
      @deven2333 Місяць тому

      @@nicog4638 go cry to wall

  • @bookbrain9863
    @bookbrain9863 Місяць тому

    horizen is so best, gt7 is hit as usual

    • @deven2333
      @deven2333 Місяць тому

      Forza is for kids

    • @Jack_ss27271
      @Jack_ss27271 Місяць тому

      @@deven2333 he is a kid he can’t even spell horizon correctly and his sentence don’t make sense

    • @deven2333
      @deven2333 Місяць тому

      @@Jack_ss27271 forza kids literally glazing so much