KAREN READ: The Commonwealth’s New Theory as of 1/4/24 - Is your head spinning yet? Attorney Reacts

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 314

  • @JayEastwood-s2c
    @JayEastwood-s2c 9 місяців тому +31

    Hi Melani,
    Former military and firefighter paramedic here. Just a few comments after listening to your UA-cam:
    -It is common practice for military/fire/medics/ police to move a downed victim by grabbing their belt to lift and drag. The missing belt could be to exclude an assailant's blood or DNA from the belt.
    -John O'Keefe(JO) had blood and vomit on his underwear. This often occurs when the belt lifts up during a carry/drag and the vomit/blood drips/falls into pants. Seen it many times over 30 years.
    -The dog bites on JO's arm is consistent with an attack from a dog while JO is standing (see elbow) and downward tear lacerations. Then his upper arm shows tooth lacerations that are perpendicular to his arm. This means he was on the floor and the dog was attacking from a 90° angle; impossible feat for the dog to do while JO was upright.
    - JO presents with "boxer" injuries / bruising to the back of his hands consistent with holding closed fists to protect his face/head, and the laceration to the back of his head is consistent with a shod foot ( steel toe boot) kick all while curled up on the floor as the dog attacked his upper arm.
    -the head injury/bleed likely caused a seizure where he vomited ( possibly aspirated) and became hypoxic which lead to cardiac arrest ( taking into consideration alcohol and exposure to cold).
    -tow truck driver went on phone conference stating Karen Reads car had no damage. Also, his time of arrival and departure conflicts with Proctor's version.

    • @AttorneyMelanieLittle
      @AttorneyMelanieLittle  9 місяців тому +10

      Thank you for sharing your experience and thoughts!

    • @jojosalemma
      @jojosalemma 9 місяців тому +5

      Thank you for your insight. You should be on a panel with your experience and knowledge of injuries !!

    • @Wildfl0wer347
      @Wildfl0wer347 8 місяців тому +2

      ❤❤❤

    • @ashleydaige4193
      @ashleydaige4193 7 місяців тому

      @65cj55 ^^^

    • @keco7081
      @keco7081 6 місяців тому +2

      GR8 perspective! ❤

  • @UEPilot38
    @UEPilot38 9 місяців тому +29

    Walk my dog by that spot regularly. Sad I come from a family of local PD and two brothers MSP and I am a retired OSHA investigator and this case stinks to high heaven!😢

    • @AttorneyMelanieLittle
      @AttorneyMelanieLittle  9 місяців тому +4

      Where's Chloe??

    • @poisunsushi4401
      @poisunsushi4401 9 місяців тому +3

      She’s probably at Coffindaffers or maybe she’s at that farm where dogs have room to run we all heard about as kids 😂 🐕

    • @UEPilot38
      @UEPilot38 9 місяців тому +2

      Check the pool that was filled in 😏

    • @UEPilot38
      @UEPilot38 9 місяців тому +1

      When selling the house why were people not allowed to take photos of the inside of the house while touring the inside??

    • @LeanneM-ku6zg
      @LeanneM-ku6zg 9 місяців тому +2

      That right there!!!
      Have you ever heard a realtor say, you can take a tour of the house, but you are not allowed to take pictures?
      Maybe a celebrity. Not a ranch in Canton, MA.

  • @cheryl7925
    @cheryl7925 9 місяців тому +16

    To Adams comment, if Brian Alberts innocent with nothing to hide, as a decent human being and first responder you go outside to see if you can help. How did Brian Albert know it wasn’t one of his kids or kids friends out there? Common sense says Brian didn’t go out because he already knew who it was and why he was there

  • @wrestlersmom6466
    @wrestlersmom6466 9 місяців тому +15

    Melanie I just want you to know it’s never to late to cover this case, I’m thankful you are, I am a long time sub of TB, I think the more people who learn about the case it’s a good thing, that goes for any case imo. 🙏💜

  • @debrannanderson7657
    @debrannanderson7657 9 місяців тому +24

    Greg Anderson even had to down size his house by selling it, just so he could take Maya’s case to trail. So he made sacrifices as did his family. I think that tells you how much he believed in her case. I truly respect this Man.

  • @sngray11
    @sngray11 9 місяців тому +21

    Replay crew! 🫶🏽 Thank you Melanie and your incredible community for helping me to not feel like I am in the twilight zone. 💞

  • @jusalilbettathanmost3613
    @jusalilbettathanmost3613 9 місяців тому +13

    Hope the ME gets wrapped up with the feds as well. For abandoning SOP. Why no samples from wounds. Any of his wounds. If the Judge keeps this going after 1/18/24. I hope she gets a longer sentence than the actual perpetrators. Her father/brother defended Chris Albert in his vehicular homicide. Found guilty of killing a man an leaving the scene. She should've rotated out like she has everytime she was supposed to. She's in charge an the only one not to rotate the last time. Why did she want to stay on this case? She should've excused herself when the defense motioned it months ago. She knew any other judge would've torn the prosecution apart. My opinion an facts fyi..

    • @Jw_617
      @Jw_617 9 місяців тому +1

      She treats Lally like a child in class 😂

  • @dougtaft2775
    @dougtaft2775 9 місяців тому +10

    The thing ppl were forgetting when talking about Brian not going out, like alpha fox, according to their story, Brian would have no idea why all the cops and ambulance and FD were there... For all he knew his kid or sister could be dead, or in an accident, or a million different things, because no one new John was missing or dead at that point right?!?!!

  • @TrueCrimeJunkie496
    @TrueCrimeJunkie496 9 місяців тому +8

    Took me all day to watch because I kept getting interrupted. This is THE craziest case I've ever been invested in!! Thank you SO much Melanie for this & I can't wait until tomorrow :)

  • @joshavery4402
    @joshavery4402 9 місяців тому +6

    Scenario. Officer O'Keefe walks in the home. The dog doesn't recognize him attacks his arm. O'Keefe starts hitting the dog to get him off the husband in the home comes to only see the victim hitting his dog. He freaks out. Being drunk and practicing MMA losing his senses and starts beating on the victim throws him out. Thinking he just gave him a beat down n no more. Realizing hours later he was unconscious and injured more then they realized frozen and succumbed to his injuries. End of story. Drunk people do dumb stuff all the time. Instead of coming clean the household is trying to damage control

    • @astrialindah2773
      @astrialindah2773 5 місяців тому

      It's not dumb it's criminal.... As a society we need to quit excusing drunks & addicts.. . People that need to start being responsible for who they are consistently not just when they are sober 😡

  • @SassySouthernSusan
    @SassySouthernSusan 9 місяців тому +7

    Autopsy pics are chilling! Heartbreaking to think what he suffered at the hands of fellow LE’s 💔

  • @thescibsters2049
    @thescibsters2049 9 місяців тому +3

    “Looking out the kitchen window”. The kitchen is in the back of the house facing the backyard. 😮

  • @LisaMarie042
    @LisaMarie042 9 місяців тому +9

    I'm in the Niagara region of southern Ontario. My ex and his cousin worked at a military and police dog training training facility in Fort Erie called Baden K9 Tactical Schools. The dogs, German Shepards, and Belgian Malinois, are trained using German commands like "Sitz" (sit), "plutz" (down). Those are def dog bites, not scrapes from a car at very slow speed and pavement, esp since they're only in one side. Dogs attack on one side as seen in the video, they're trained to go for the arm. There are bodycam videos here in YT of a dog being deployed. It's not rocket science.

  • @NancyBarry-qn8zn
    @NancyBarry-qn8zn 9 місяців тому +8

    The neighbor is law also, but he told them there wasnt anything to see on his camera, so, they said "ok."

  • @jjgidds
    @jjgidds 9 місяців тому +16

    My thoughts on Jennifer Koffendaffer and her "Karen Read is a nobody" remark...for those in the back: THAT'S EXACTLY THE REASON THEY'RE TRYING TO PIN IT ON HER:. She's nobody; she's a throwaway person; she's every one of us: ie, the perfect scapegoat. Except...they didn't count on people paying such close attention to the fiction they're trying to sell and not buying it. I don't think any critical-thinking jury would ever find Karen Read guilty.

    • @edwardscott3262
      @edwardscott3262 9 місяців тому +4

      Reed isn't a nobody. She's exactly the type of person the victim may have confided in before his death.
      They did this out of fear that she knew why they beat him.
      I assume from how everything went down they didn't intend to kill him. Just teach him a lesson with a beating and toss him in the front yard to later wake up.
      Reed might know why they killed him. Not that it matters though. They will get away with it. Reed is probably going to prison too.
      There's tons of cases like this from all across the country. All the changing witness statements, evidence kept from the defense, everything crooked and shady never really matters much with a jury. Or even the general public who only cares about the headlines.
      It almost always results in convictions. If the innocent person is really lucky they later get exonerated before retirement age. If not they spend the rest of their life in prison for a crime they didn't commit.
      Seriously this channel should cover some old cases where now known innocent people were sent to prison. It's way too easy to for prosecutors and police to convict an innocent person in this country. And it always goes like this.
      We've errored way too far towards the state. Every rule people think exists I've seen broken by crooked unethical prosecutors with the help of their friendly crooked judge.
      I've seen a man go to prison after narcotics detectives illegally searched his house without a warrant. They got one after but never bothered to lie about any exigent circumstances because they never planned on getting caught.
      Despite the house alarm catching them red handed the judge ruled the evidence in under inevitable discovery.
      Russ Faria is another good example. Pam Hupp left bloody hand and footprints at the scene. The prosecutor just didn't turn over the pictures to the defense. Every state witness lied on the stand.
      In the end even when caught nobody involved in framing an innocent husband who just lost his wife faced any punishment. The prosecutor even still has her bar license.
      Nobody who does this type of thing to innocent people fears any repercussions because they full well that is so rare.

    • @michaelaconnell4915
      @michaelaconnell4915 9 місяців тому +1

      @edwardscott that is incredibly sad and scary.

    • @cheryl7925
      @cheryl7925 9 місяців тому +1

      My thoughts exactly! They thought, small town, no one will pay attention to this case, it will fly under the radar. Boy did that theory backfire on them.

    • @Barb417
      @Barb417 9 місяців тому +1

      So 11 people in the house, State Police, local police, emergency workers, investigators and their family members have all made a pact to lie about KR?
      I guess none of them care about the risk of losing their jobs, pension and jail time.
      Jurors make decisions based on common sense.
      That smirk will go away.

    • @astrialindah2773
      @astrialindah2773 5 місяців тому

      ​@@edwardscott3262😢😢😢 sad but true.

  • @maureengunn7952
    @maureengunn7952 9 місяців тому +8

    I think you’re terrific Melanie! Some people can’t face the truth.

  • @debrannanderson7657
    @debrannanderson7657 9 місяців тому +12

    Watching on replay. This case has so many inconstant statements by others it’s mind blowing. It makes you think this whole case is sus.

  • @rubellite1862
    @rubellite1862 9 місяців тому +5

    I guarantee Chloe and the concrete from the basement floor are buried in Brian Albert's brothers filled-in underground pool space

  • @jandries9053
    @jandries9053 9 місяців тому +15

    I think Coffindaufer is going to be eating her words! I just find it amazing that anyone can come to a definitive decision on the defendant’s guilt when it hasn’t even gone to trial. Clearly, she did not examine witness statements and the changing narrative of the prosecution.

    • @edwardscott3262
      @edwardscott3262 9 місяців тому +1

      Our courts are way less fair than people think. Innocence isn't a get out of jail free card people falsely believe.
      It's sadly way easier to convict an innocent person than it should be.

  • @melaniedavenport4869
    @melaniedavenport4869 9 місяців тому +7

    So, his body was covered with snow, but the pieces of plastic was on top of the snow

    • @JovinMyHeart4Eva
      @JovinMyHeart4Eva 8 місяців тому

      Is that what they said did they say the pieces of plastic was on top of the snow? Good call. I didn't hear that part. Yes, any investigator could do math on that one. This is awful.

  • @goddessbeautybytia
    @goddessbeautybytia 9 місяців тому +5

    About the tow of Karen's car, in addition to it being an MSP investigation, there were TWO CLOSER MSP barracks that they could have brought her car to but they didnt, they chose to have it towed to Canton PD in the midst of the blizzard!?!?! Whyyyy??? Then shortly after they found pieces of taillight at 34 Fairview..hahaha..Give me a break!!

  • @-F0RBIDDEN
    @-F0RBIDDEN 9 місяців тому +4

    Need to pull the wifi router diagnostics from the house. If they indeed had cameras it would be listed as connected.

  • @happydance77
    @happydance77 8 місяців тому +1

    Dig up the filled in pool on Fairview…they may find the dog, blood stained carpet, the Google Nest cams, and who knows what else?

  • @jeanettelawson6336
    @jeanettelawson6336 9 місяців тому +13

    I listened to the whole Live as I was building furniture. I was doing the ole lady feedback. When Melanie got excited and her voice would change, I must have followed suit . My son's dogs went on defense mode trying to break through the door and biting the handle, until they got the door open. They ran around the garage barking looking for the other person (Melanie). Then the stood in front of radio growling. Note to self, Keep Headphones on.

  • @pattypeters2686
    @pattypeters2686 9 місяців тому +8

    Abrasions? Absolutely not!! These are from an animal. ME has no idea about a fight and that is unprofessional. What type of ME iS this- not all ME's are required to have the same qualifications! 🙄

  • @MrsWild29
    @MrsWild29 9 місяців тому +6

    I seem to recall that the blood samples were collected in red solo cups…. Is my memory incorrect? If that’s what happened - where did they get those cups if the Albers never even opened their doors for all the commotion?? That in itself is beyond suspect how the house wasn’t searched, nobody questioned etc. stinks to high heaven

    • @MrsWild29
      @MrsWild29 9 місяців тому +1

      Ha ha that’s what happens when you comment BEFORE listening to the whole program!! My bad

    • @astrialindah2773
      @astrialindah2773 5 місяців тому

      ​@@MrsWild29lol., and I liked your comment before I've listened to the whole thing😂

  • @lydiaanderson824
    @lydiaanderson824 9 місяців тому +1

    I have been watching your channel since the first Kevin Costner divorce episode. I have grown to love how much time you take to thoughtfully review and discuss the documents and topics. Love your questions and observations.

  • @Kam-Mass
    @Kam-Mass 9 місяців тому +3

    Exactly! Kerry Roberts followed Ms Reads Lexus behind it - she would have seen a “shattered” one missing 37 pieces of red tailight gone from it. OR she only saw a crack in it from hitting John’s Traverse! And why go ALL the way back to JO home, when frantically worried about his existence/safety?

  • @kevinkeene9158
    @kevinkeene9158 9 місяців тому +7

    Thanks for doing this. You have been doing a thorough analysis of the Karen Reed case. It’s clear u respect common sense. Of course it’s 2024 and I’m congratulating somebody for having common sense.😂I mean that with the upmost respect. We live in strange times where logic is hard to come by, so again thank you. Given what we know right now, this case against Karen Reed should absolutely be dismissed. It would be so dangerous to convict someone like herself based on such a butchered investigation and inconsistencies. It would set a dangerous precedent. I don’t have to tell you that. If they can convict her based on what we know, future prosecutors would cite this case, and more innocent people would be sent to jail, or even worse, be placed on death row. Ps sorry I got timed out the other night. I promise to keep it respectful😁

  • @melaniedavenport4869
    @melaniedavenport4869 9 місяців тому +5

    You can bet some of the other officers were like "uncles" to these children and could easily manipulate them to agree with the narrative

  • @UEPilot38
    @UEPilot38 9 місяців тому +4

    She deleted over 50 calls that she made during that night as well as the google search

  • @someonepassingthrough4700
    @someonepassingthrough4700 9 місяців тому +2

    @Attorney Melanie Little I have been watching your channel starting with the Maya vs. JHACH and I keep coming back for more! I love how you bring the cases to light using your knowledge/real world insight! I didn't know anything about the Karen Read case until you brought it to us and OMG 😅 The scandal is blatant imo. How they didn't throw this out already boggles the mind 😮 And don't get me wrong I back the Blue as well, even without family in Law Enforcement, I have many in Military and I also have family members that are going through their own cases. But in Life there are corrupt people no matter what field.. Anyway Thanks for all you do ❤

  • @anniesenol9858
    @anniesenol9858 9 місяців тому +4

    Had to catch you on the replay today. Thank you for helping me understand this case.

  • @cindyb1427
    @cindyb1427 9 місяців тому +5

    Thank you for covering this because I really think I am going insane because the stories continue to change from the prosecution

  • @NonnaRobynMcG
    @NonnaRobynMcG 9 місяців тому +3

    I just hope and pray that all these discrepancies are mentioned by the Defense 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @LaurenLively
    @LaurenLively 9 місяців тому +6

    If he wasn’t answering his phone and she had dropped him off with friends, I guarantee you she was pissed!!

  • @NancyBarry-qn8zn
    @NancyBarry-qn8zn 9 місяців тому +9

    Haters everywhere!! It's great to have such class & brains, recognizing this, we need you, they have trash, we have class lol

  • @daniellecasario7356
    @daniellecasario7356 9 місяців тому +1

    I cannot stop watching your videos! This case is insane! I am so glad to have found you and PLEASE tell me what kind of lipstick you wear! It is amazing! ❤😊

  • @patriciaseybold7396
    @patriciaseybold7396 7 місяців тому

    I’m enjoying re-listening to this case this morning.

  • @sue4260
    @sue4260 9 місяців тому +4

    It's like living under the mob from what I can see. I watched the community council meeting or whatever they call it over there. Dodgy as....💖🇬🇧💖🇬🇧

  • @ladymmm100
    @ladymmm100 9 місяців тому +5

    So, they saw everything- they saw when she pulled up, where she pulled up, they saw her sitting in the car with John, they also saw her making 3point turn (well, at least sometimes they did, other times they didn’t), they even saw her taking off, yet somehow they missed when she hit him backing up with impressive speed of 24mi/h so much so that her tail light smashed into pieces?! Interesting… very interesting…

  • @phoebebeach1194
    @phoebebeach1194 9 місяців тому +10

    Wouldn’t Jennifer McCabe have called and called before they left to search for John until she spoke to her sister inside the house to see if by chance John had spent the night there??

    • @AttorneyMelanieLittle
      @AttorneyMelanieLittle  9 місяців тому +4

      Great point!

    • @-F0RBIDDEN
      @-F0RBIDDEN 9 місяців тому +4

      Okay Girls , let's role play here for a min. If a friend calls us and says "have you seen my boyfriend"? "I can't find him, he never came home last night and he's not answering my calls".
      What is the first thing You would do?
      Now compare that to what Jenn McCabe did
      Does it seem legit or does it seem really weird and not make sense?
      PRETTY SUS IF YOU ASK ME!!

    • @phoebebeach1194
      @phoebebeach1194 9 місяців тому +2

      @@-F0RBIDDEN not normal, weird and makes no sense!

  • @ThatRedhedd
    @ThatRedhedd 9 місяців тому +8

    The defense should request a copy of the police interview with Firefighter Katie McLaughlin on January 30th. The limited summary of this interview included in this motion includes cherry-picked bits & pieces of it.

  • @Auntie__April
    @Auntie__April 9 місяців тому +1

    Thank you for covering this case. I love your point of view.

  • @jandries9053
    @jandries9053 9 місяців тому +3

    Like you said, no photos of the underside of his arm!

  • @L_Dawg_614
    @L_Dawg_614 9 місяців тому +5

    I’m no professional, but I do not see how those cuts/scrapes/lacerations are the result of being hit by a car.

  • @smoore7768
    @smoore7768 9 місяців тому +2

    A lot of us have been here since you started. Ignore the complainers!!!! I wouldn’t change a thing and neither would other OG’s!! ❤❤

  • @TracyViolette
    @TracyViolette 9 місяців тому +3

    Fantastic coverage of this. Thank you !!!

  • @josiemiller6524
    @josiemiller6524 6 місяців тому +1

    My husband is a LEO. Like all first responders - they run TOWARDS all the scary things us regular folk run away from. I don’t know one decent human being, ‘regular folk’ or not, who would stay inside their house when there is a crime scene on their front lawn. I don’t think there is one single first responder, whether LEO, fire, EMS or nurse, who would sit quietly inside their house. It’s literally within their nature to RUN TOWARDS a situation like that, to attempt to render aid. It literally makes NO SENSE!!! Someone on the “other side” please - make it make sense!!!!!

  • @LurkeyLouWho
    @LurkeyLouWho 9 місяців тому +3

    I would definitely be outside trying to find out what’s going on if I seen all that action on my lawn. Especially if one of my children weren’t home. I would want to make sure it wasn’t one of my kids.
    Heck if all this action was going on at my neighbors house I’d be on the porch watching and wondering.

  • @islesofshoals3551
    @islesofshoals3551 9 місяців тому +4

    This was superb Melanie. Thank you. I'm still taking this all in and forming ideas. My Cousin Vinney is the best

  • @jandries9053
    @jandries9053 9 місяців тому +6

    Ms. McCabe states they were not arguing on page 6/7. So, she tells Karen they were arguing?!? Cover up!

    • @luckewoman0348
      @luckewoman0348 9 місяців тому +2

      Super odd that she went from stating their was no arguing in first statement to seeing an argument and having to tell Karen she knows about it?! What? Lol

  • @poisunsushi4401
    @poisunsushi4401 9 місяців тому

    I love seeing more people picking up this case. Your coverage is refreshing and thorough. Much appreciated ❤

  • @dollarmatian
    @dollarmatian 9 місяців тому +2

    If they borrowed leafblower and other items from the neighbour, I find it interesting that they did not speak to the occupants of the residence the body was found in front of at the time 🤔

  • @mlhjlhify
    @mlhjlhify 9 місяців тому +5

    It seems the statements are changing but what I really don’t know is on what end it’s being changed because the initial statements aren’t signed by the person giving it. Also, it’s very SUS that the owner of the house didn’t come out after hearing what happened, especially since they both were Boston PO. Also, the info regarding Collin in the statement seems extra voluntary. Voluntary info regarding other ppl, is interesting

  • @Fredburg4485
    @Fredburg4485 9 місяців тому +2

    I grew up in Canton and I see a lot of the main characters in this case frequently. Quite a few go to my gym. Other than the fist bump or head nod greeting that is part of gym culture we don't really interact. Everyone is innocent until proven guilty and that needs to be remembered even as bad as this case seems to be. I like the way you thoroughly cover this without rancor and name calling. This deserves the attention you are giving it.

  • @pennyjanelove9889
    @pennyjanelove9889 9 місяців тому +3

    I dont need to watch a 2nd Murdach trial. I've never been more convinced of someone's guilt.

  • @NancyBarry-qn8zn
    @NancyBarry-qn8zn 9 місяців тому +6

    No body cams, being audited, chief requests new kitchen = $$$$ (ludicrous)

  • @PEPE211606
    @PEPE211606 9 місяців тому +3

    How did Julie Nagle see from the kitchen see the car move across the front of house and to the edge of the yard .....from the KITCHEN is in the back of the house or XRAY vision ?????

  • @UEPilot38
    @UEPilot38 9 місяців тому +4

    I live around the corner from 34 Fairview.

  • @Kam-Mass
    @Kam-Mass 9 місяців тому +1

    The kitchen window is the back of the home, I have never understood that part of the “testimony” Nagle gave.

    • @Kam-Mass
      @Kam-Mass 9 місяців тому +1

      Also - Her testimony said when outside it that she had noticed that it had just started to snow but then says she traveled past the flagpole and saw something big and dark “IN THE SNOW” on the lawn. There wouldn’t even be snow on the lawn yet???

    • @pelletman65
      @pelletman65 9 місяців тому

      Many months later

  • @kalesmith3694
    @kalesmith3694 9 місяців тому +8

    Really enjoying your overviews of this case! Thank you

  • @NancyBarry-qn8zn
    @NancyBarry-qn8zn 9 місяців тому +5

    THE DOG WOULD BE GOING NUTS INSIDE THAT HOUSE!! HOW could they sleep? They also unlived Chloe during this i think

    • @sngray11
      @sngray11 9 місяців тому +2

      They didn’t unalive Chloe, but five months after John’s death, Chloe got into another physical altercation and they ended up rehoming her but no one is saying who or where she was rehomed to… so there may be a chance that she was unalived instead of rehomed but there is no definitive proof. 🤷🏼‍♀️

    • @jusalilbettathanmost3613
      @jusalilbettathanmost3613 9 місяців тому +1

      The feds know. They have alot more evidence than people think. I wouldn't doubt for a second. That they didnt follow any evidence leaving that house. Carpet, dog missing clothing items etc... They have it all. 99% conviction rate is because they have overwhelming evidence

    • @NancyBarry-qn8zn
      @NancyBarry-qn8zn 9 місяців тому

      @@sngray11 but how did they keep her quiet inside the house while all the noise outside, they said they were sleeping, so they slept thru the investigation, with a barking dog inside, I'm not understanding this. I used to think they rehomed her, but I don't know how

    • @astrialindah2773
      @astrialindah2773 5 місяців тому

      In one video that I watched it was said that the one girl and I'm sorry that I can't remember all the names........ There's so many characters in this that it is ridiculous
      .... The one that asked for a ride home when at first she said she didn't need a ride home and then she called her boyfriend to get a ride home, and people think that her boyfriend that picked her up and she took the dog at that point in time.... Which does make sense.

  • @LogicallyLegalThings
    @LogicallyLegalThings 9 місяців тому +1

    Replay crew! Just catching up on my day off

  • @TOYODA.NY2
    @TOYODA.NY2 9 місяців тому +1

    Another great listen, keep em coming !

  • @jandries9053
    @jandries9053 9 місяців тому +5

    No, you are not nuts! Those are not abrasions. A skinned knee is an abrasion! Yes, lacerations.

  • @nikkiharrison8769
    @nikkiharrison8769 9 місяців тому +2

    I want to know why solo many Lawyers & Police and or EX Police are afraid to go over all these Court Documents.???
    I really appreciate that you actually do read all the Court Documents & go over them. 😊

  • @Shelly-in-Tampa
    @Shelly-in-Tampa 9 місяців тому +3

    Om Long Island I was a gs troop leader Patchogue. What a great meeting when the canine visit came. The dogs had German names and were trained in Germany commands in German.

  • @rock90753
    @rock90753 9 місяців тому +3

    I didn't know calling Albert had a phone edge! I've been falling this case pretty closely and the hits keep coming! I'm 100% convinced now this was a total cover up. Worse than that, is trying to send an innocent woman to jail for murder

    • @goddessbeautybytia
      @goddessbeautybytia 9 місяців тому

      The plow driver said he knows what Brian Albert's Egde looks like cuz he's plows their road regularly each winter for the last few years & it was not his. But LOTS of the family & party-goers have Ford Edges. Lucky is color blind and said he could not specifically sat exactly what color it was but if he could give his best guess based on what colors he sees compared to what they really are.. his guess was that it was tan colored & one of the Albert's boyfriend, Tristan has a tan Ford Edge.

  • @_hellohooray
    @_hellohooray 9 місяців тому +3

    I remember thinking they purposely set the dog on him 😖. I haven't watched so I don't feel fair to comment. I would like to offer support if you want me to deep dive on something, see what I come up with I have some time next couple weeks 🤷‍♀️
    I hope justice is served.

  • @MrsDannunzio
    @MrsDannunzio 9 місяців тому +5

    Youre doing a great job!

  • @NancyBarry-qn8zn
    @NancyBarry-qn8zn 9 місяців тому +4

    Thats why they made up "by the yard" fake tow co

  • @margidaly8066
    @margidaly8066 9 місяців тому +2

    Hi from Alabama . Thanks I enjoy your channel

  • @esmereldapinchon1422
    @esmereldapinchon1422 9 місяців тому +17

    Missing notes. Missing video. The investigator with family ties not recusing himself? Outrageous. A Boston police officer left on a lawn. Homeowner didn’t even come out of the house? A brother officer deserves the best response and best investigation available. It’s not surprising that there has been such an outcry. With the feds involved, anyone who did anything to obstruct justice has to be scared.

    • @louisejeffries7155
      @louisejeffries7155 9 місяців тому +5

      Not only the officer
      Rumour says the judge is also connected and inserted herself
      Just talk for sure but we’ve all seen how that works out over time huh
      We’ll see I guess

    • @jusalilbettathanmost3613
      @jusalilbettathanmost3613 9 місяців тому +1

      The judge (Cannone)is in charge of the rotation that superior court does for cases. She didn't rotate out if the case like she has 100% of the time when she done before. Also rumor is when Chris Albert killed a man (brother of homeowner) while driving and evaded a BOLO for hours till he sobered up. His lawyer was either Judge Cannone's brother or father. Not 100% sure how to check that. X prob has Chris Albert's court doc for murder. Let that sit there for a min.

    • @KerryLama43
      @KerryLama43 9 місяців тому

      There is NO missing video. Dear lord.

    • @esmereldapinchon1422
      @esmereldapinchon1422 9 місяців тому +3

      @@KerryLama43 Nobody has ring cameras in the upscale suburb? Is there a police officer across the street? No cameras? Really?

    • @KerryLama43
      @KerryLama43 9 місяців тому

      @@kirks7143 she deleted the ring video.
      She did not drive by the library. Hence why there is no video of her car. 40-50 people would need to be involved in a conspiracy for this to work. It is not plausible. Not gonna argue with you. Just stop stating things that aren’t fact and leave his niece and nephew out of this. Both their parents died & now they have lost the only parent they have had. Leave them alone. I am sure They know better than you or me about their relationship.

  • @NonnaRobynMcG
    @NonnaRobynMcG 9 місяців тому +1

    Watching replay-JMs new statement just said her and MM were in the vehicle together but MM said he was inside looking out the window ???????

  • @dollarmatian
    @dollarmatian 9 місяців тому +5

    If there really is a nest camera, the police can require access to the footage from Google servers and view every minute of it without Brian Albert at all.

    • @astrialindah2773
      @astrialindah2773 5 місяців тому

      It seems like the defense would be aware of this????

  • @michelleleone1803
    @michelleleone1803 9 місяців тому

    thank you again for a wonderful and thought provoking session! You are amazing!

  • @sue4260
    @sue4260 9 місяців тому +2

    It's great you're covering this case. The Glarer is covering this. She would love to have you on his show, but says he doubts you'd want to go on there because everyone swears/cusses and he runs his show with no holds barred. Except doxxing of course and bullying in chat

  • @LeanneM-ku6zg
    @LeanneM-ku6zg 9 місяців тому +2

    I didn’t catch the very end so maybe I missed.
    In everything you did read I never caught the week later tail light piece..
    In this newly redacted report, does it mention the piece of tail light that was mysteriously found a week later by Berkowitz? The retiring Canton police chief.
    His name has been missing from many revcebt things I’ve read. Yet, it was one of the reasons things popped out as strange when first reported.
    It’s on reports. He said on a whim, he drove down Fairview and right there from his moving vehicle he noticed a large piece of tail light.
    (This is on record, not something someone just said)
    He also notified a reporter that mentioned the home owners name via email. Also, accessible info.
    He told the reporter to take out the home owners name because he is a pillar of the community.

  • @louisejeffries7155
    @louisejeffries7155 9 місяців тому +6

    The head lac is from falling backwards on to something that has an interrupted straight edge
    What are the steps at the house made of
    Where are the concrete steps or chipped hard wood step at that home?
    Where is the blood?
    Because there would have been some decent blood loss
    Interesting we’re doing medical exam with lines still in
    They worked hard on John
    Was he still alive when he got to hospital because they really have put effort into reviving him
    Which brings me back to the lividity which does not make sense
    Raccoon eye (or as I would say panda eye) appears 1 - 2 days post injury and fills the full orbital zone
    Bilateral is highly suggestive of basal skull fracture and what is referred to as coning (as in ice cream cone)
    While you can get unilateral panda eye is very rare in head trauma and thus the presentation is normally associated with trauma to the bridge of the nose (radix) or the orbital bone
    From what I remember of the picture there was no thought of panda
    This perhaps maybe why the medical examiner stated no other signs of assault
    Ie this has highest probability from assault (yes) but there is nothing else to back assault (ummmm)
    No sign of assault is of course barring, the bruising to the right hand pointing finger and mid finger medial to the MPJ
    I’m not sure how the medical examiner thinks this did happen
    I suggest John was thumped and fell backwards onto a sharp edge ie stairs
    I did consider the dog pushed as it jumped and John fell but the eye rules that out
    Plus the dog came at him from the side therefore John would have fallen sideways not backwards
    This would also apply if he had been hit by a car
    You don’t get hit from the side with enough force to fracture bone and fall backwards
    It’s Very odd very very odd

    • @AttorneyMelanieLittle
      @AttorneyMelanieLittle  9 місяців тому

      Thorough analysis, Louise!

    • @louisejeffries7155
      @louisejeffries7155 9 місяців тому

      Thank you Melanie

    • @AnnoyedGuy2000
      @AnnoyedGuy2000 9 місяців тому +3

      I dunno how true it, but Ive heard possiblity of exercise equipment in finished basement where the floor would end up being demo'd and replaced before the sale of the home....

    • @louisejeffries7155
      @louisejeffries7155 9 місяців тому

      @@AnnoyedGuy2000maybe
      I really don’t know
      I do know Malamud here says it was redone twice
      Once to prepare for sale is reasonable if it’s a bit tatty but twice you have to start asking don’t you think ?
      If it’s concrete, it wouldn’t matter if you did it 1000 times, it will still hold evidence, particularly if you’re looking for blood
      Now it’s will be up to the new owners, whether or not the police can search As we know police, don’t always pay for the damage done in a search
      Which means the prospect of that happening is usually and probably fairly low
      I think we may always be left with the question Why twice if that’s the case

  • @faerieraven6877
    @faerieraven6877 9 місяців тому +1

    Catching the replay ❤ one thing I'd like to see, if they exist, are photos of the underside of John's arm; are there teeth marks , bites, gouges there too? I still believe he was attacked by Chloe (not her fault either, but any family dog, especially a 'guard' dog will protect their owner) , because 2 others were bitten by her. Thank you for covering this 🙏💕

  • @NancyBarry-qn8zn
    @NancyBarry-qn8zn 9 місяців тому +4

    Yes MLS accurate

  • @nikkiharrison8769
    @nikkiharrison8769 9 місяців тому +3

    MELANIE LITTLE the DUI GUY + LARRY. He has had Aidan on his YT Channel before & has covered some of this Case. I would love for you both to do a Live Stream together. To go over the Court Documents & to see what you both think about it all. 😊

  • @jules4696
    @jules4696 9 місяців тому +4

    Rewatch crew. Melanie I'm having a difficult time with this case. While I don't have all the evidence from the state but what has been put out by the defense is very compelling to me. Everyone is innocent until proven guilty right? I just don't think the state has enough to pursue Karen Reed. I really believe she did not commit this "murder". Something smells fishy in Boston. I'm pro police and come from a LE family but this just doesn't look good on the Police Dept and their investigators. JMO

  • @susanvegnani1202
    @susanvegnani1202 9 місяців тому

    Hey if Karen never spoke to the cops off the rip...where would we be today?

  • @jandries9053
    @jandries9053 9 місяців тому +2

    University of Rochester Medical Center- An abrasion is a superficial rub or wearing off of the skin, usually caused by a scrape or a brush burn. Abrasions are usually minor injuries that can be treated at home. The skin may bleed or drain small amounts at the time of the injury or at times over the next few days if rubbed or scratched. OMG!

  • @smd4646
    @smd4646 9 місяців тому +1

    Here’s another thought regarding the tail light. I think almost NO ONE would know their tail light was cracked or broken unless someone told them about it. Her foot would have to have been on the brake to indicate something was amiss.

    • @smd4646
      @smd4646 9 місяців тому

      It’s just another piece of fabrication that the “bad guys” planted on Karen.

    • @smd4646
      @smd4646 9 місяців тому +1

      Just another thought. The skull laceration and fractures may have been caused by the weights seen in the basement. Goes along with the apple log of going up and down the stairs.

  • @UEPilot38
    @UEPilot38 9 місяців тому +1

    Melanie great show!

  • @NancyBarry-qn8zn
    @NancyBarry-qn8zn 9 місяців тому +4

    Sandra Birchmore 😢has some of the same players

  • @someonepassingthrough4700
    @someonepassingthrough4700 9 місяців тому +2

    Wish I could join but either way I'll be watching ❤

  • @pattypeters2686
    @pattypeters2686 9 місяців тому +4

    What part of a vehicle would leave those type of wounds 🙄 wheres the blood and skin evidence off the car / broken tail light etc. ??

  • @ENess-jk2cq
    @ENess-jk2cq 9 місяців тому +3

    Replay crew. The only thing I'd be yelling is call 911 and help. How long did it take ambulance to arrive?

  • @Kam-Mass
    @Kam-Mass 9 місяців тому +3

    So they did not even inspect the car for 3 days - where it was at Canton Police (parked in lot out back or do they have a bag inside) and we’re supposed to believe a hair or glass was found on it when anyone had access to it for 3 days where they did not even have jurisdiction mind you???

    • @Kam-Mass
      @Kam-Mass 9 місяців тому

      Bay not bag

    • @Kam-Mass
      @Kam-Mass 9 місяців тому +1

      I’m very curious what time she started leaving voicemail messages and what specifically she said on those earlier ones. She was supposedly calling him bc he was supposed to run in and then either run back out or call/text to let her know if all was good and he was staying. SO if she never hit him and he went into that home and she didn’t suspect a thing, and assumed he would get all those voicemail messages then she wouldn’t say anything like “Are you staying or what?” “Are you good, is it cool for me to leave and meet you back at your house in an hour or two latest etc. because if she thought he’d be fine and get those messages, she would never say anything that wouldn’t make sense to him - right? So whatever she said in those earlier messages may be telling…….. and the time that she started texting and calling will help to tighten the timeline too or help substantiate that he went into the home…???? I’m shocked they haven’t been leaked as most things are that are favorable to the CW. They leak to JC/Kate Peters supposedly…… but I’m not making any factual claims here.

    • @Kam-Mass
      @Kam-Mass 9 місяців тому

      Poor John’s partner committed suicide shortly after the death of his sister and brother in law I believe. I believe John found him, that poor man faced so much tragedy. I have a friend that knew his partner very well and as a result knew JO.

  • @dollarmatian
    @dollarmatian 9 місяців тому +1

    I really need to understand, did the Alberts say company that came from the bar stayed for an hour? I’m failing to understand how people could leave the residence and not see the body? Perhaps I am missing something.

  • @Victoria_yfps
    @Victoria_yfps 9 місяців тому +1

    Yes was also in the original CW statement of case.

  • @rosesroundup
    @rosesroundup 5 місяців тому

    Love your channel! Is the “not a fan of the cursey words” an attack toward EDB?

    • @AttorneyMelanieLittle
      @AttorneyMelanieLittle  5 місяців тому +1

      Not at all- I love what she does!

    • @rosesroundup
      @rosesroundup 5 місяців тому

      @@AttorneyMelanieLittle awesome! I love both of you. Thanks for all that you do.🥰

    • @AttorneyMelanieLittle
      @AttorneyMelanieLittle  5 місяців тому

      A lot of my viewers appreciate it because they can watch without headphones with kids in the room, play me at work and watch with their 95 yr old moms!

  • @micheleschlapfer2744
    @micheleschlapfer2744 9 місяців тому +2

    Great show!

  • @rickjason215
    @rickjason215 9 місяців тому +2

    I have a Toyota and if I back up to a person the car throws on the brake automatically. Lexus and Toyota have the same safety devices. She could not back up and hit a person.

    • @pelletman65
      @pelletman65 9 місяців тому

      Does her car have that though?

    • @vagariousedits5306
      @vagariousedits5306 9 місяців тому

      Agreed. All new models have this feature.

  • @heavyhauler6172
    @heavyhauler6172 9 місяців тому

    I love your pod Melanie ❤

  • @mamboqueen999
    @mamboqueen999 9 місяців тому +2

    Devil’s advocate - I have a 5’ friend who could bang back 7 drinks. She has a high tolerance. Are there receipts showing what the drinks were?
    Did they not test the glass found at the scene to see if it matches to the restaurant’s glasses?