Hari bol. BRILLIANT explanation. Short but very wisely widely explained. Enough to remove doubts and confusion. I lost my young son 10 months ago. Extremely confused and in emotional trauma, very hard to digest why did it happen. But thank you so much. That's why our society needs saints like you. Hare Krishna
Perfect. My very own analogy which I came up with around 2010 when I started taking significantly more interest on this subject: Imagine you have been given a box full of different fruits. Say an orange, an apple, a pear. You can pick only one from the box. You have the freedom of choice to pick whatever from the box. But you cant pick up a pineapple. As its not even in the scope in the first place.
Dear wise person, I believe that everything is predefined. For example, there were and are many person around the world who are more talented than even Alberta Einstein, but the didn't get the recognition, fame or money like Einstein. There are so many talented person who didn't get succeeded, even after doing hard work.
Getting fame is also pre destined and if one has to gain more then what is pre destined then one has to do some spiritual practices as a help from divines forces
Misconceptions of karma is reward & punishment. Real meaning of Karma is cause & effect of fundamental nature of existence. Besides, I like this philosophy of cow being tie with limited length of rope to illustrate the nature of possible free will. Thank for this video😇😇😇
It also reminds me of stoicism. Something are under our control( how to think, how to respond ). Other remaining are out of our control ( covid19, natural disaster, other people & gravity)
Everything is predestined. If a system is observed from an outside perspective it would be clear that it is destined a particular future because of the phenomenon and interactions affecting one another only inside the system isolated from outside. But if we are in the system itself we dont have the knowledge of the other consciousnesses and our own self to determine the future and even if we have it our future thoughts cant be determined by ourselves by present thoughts because of the infinite loop and hence people feel the free will. Yes it is for the insider but not for the universe.
Man's Will or God's Will A person once asked the Master, "How can we ascertain whether something is man's will or God's will?" Sri Ramakrishna replied: "Suppose a man has made arrangements to go to Varanasi and is ready to leave. In the meantime a message comes from his country home that his brother is about to die and if he wants to see him, he should come immediately. He cancels his trip to Varanasi and hurriedly returns home. Now you decide whose will it is." -Ramakrishna As We Saw Him
Hahaha........ If you live unconsciously then life looks predestined. We are not animal to live compulsively. The past karma, i have created and it has its influence, BUT in this life if i live conciously then i can create such a strong good karma to influence my past karma. It is possible. Otherwise there is no way for man's enlightenment. Namaste.🙏🙏🙏
everything in life is pre destined , we have no choices period , even to the minut thought or action was written in your book and me writing this comment or what led me to it
There is no perfect answers as no-one knows. All these are theories. Human mind always wants logic. Hence the search. People never say don't know, but always gives smart answers.
what about if the length of rob are different then it is predestined that longer the length of rob can enjoy more it is direct proportion. then every things is predestined
Is the crime done by a criminal predestined? Is the rape and other violence occurred predestined ?? If so, then any one can say that what he is doing is only the wish of god !! Think about that..
Anupam Bhattacharyya it's upto the person. U can kill/ rape someone who did something bad in your past life or choose to forgive them and avoid committing the murder/rape. Forgiving someone can avoid accumulation of bad karma.
Hello sir..if you understand three karmas:sanchita(stored or accumulated) karma,prarabda(predetemined) karma,agami karma( free will),you will easily understand sir .Bhagavad geeta explains clearly..so which ever stronger ,that works in real time..sorry for bad english or mistakes
Paratman is the supreme consciousness. Simpler to describe it by the structure: A group of conscious beings interact in a sense or rules to form a greater being of consciousness. It can be though like this. Every part in our body can be thought of a consciousness being. They interact to form a consciousness bodies that is us. And we interact with other conscious bodies to form a greater conscious body that is larger. And this structure goes infinitely and the paramatma is the universe itself which has its own consciousness.
God is no selfish thing having deeds that if you pray you get a desire fulfilled. Paramatman is the consciousness of the universe itself. It doesnt matter what you do that consciousness feels nothing of your deeds unless yoir karma is strong enough to ripple across the future consequences for the paramatman. Basically all of us and our environment constitute the paramatman. Praying the paramatman is not to fulfill a desire but to respect paramatman that is the universe itself. It induces a sense of belief and confidence to perform our strong dharma that is our responsibilities to our desires. The karma of our actions then resonates back to the outcomes which not juat depends on ourselves but the whole paramtman that is everyone and everything around us. If rapes, murders happen then that is the karma of our bad actions of all of us not just ypurself. If a good person gets bad outcome, then as i said karma is not limited to one it is outcome based on everything. So it is the result of the action of a bad people. But the same actions lead to his bad karma in his future no matter what but the period and effects depend on everything
Right Guruji..Our life is scripted but how better we act as per the script given is also a subject matter of our whole identitification..I would conclude by figuring Destiny=50% and Karma=50%..
Guru g no disrespect for u but moral of the story is life is totally predestined no free will works see I am 39 in my life till no gf came and still I am unmarried I tried several times there are also so many problems but It will b long as I see many boys have so many gf and they enjoy there life but anyways now I left hoping I understood everything it's all pre-planned
Think about this. If everything is freewill and nothing is destiny then we would all use our freewill to get everything we want in life and yet it's only a few people who are successfull. Only 1% succeed so only they are using their freewill and the rest have gone to sleep?
Listen life philosphy is about seeking not evidence. Take analogy suppose you don't know what sweet tastes like and I know how sweet tastes like as I ate sugar one day. Now I came to you and said that I experienced sweet I ate sugar and now you will ask that "can you give me the proof that sweet exists" basically you cannot believe in sweetness unless you try sugar and you will only be convinced to try it if you surrender yourself before me and believe me. So the answer is that firstly you need to surrender yourself to a guru (you cannot find your guru when the right time comes you will meet him believe me just like Vivekananda met paramhans)and believe in him and his ways to get to the god and then you will experience nobody can give you the evidence for that divine experience you need to experience it yourself to believe it.
I was searching for this question in terms of Einstein's view on "Time". It's very difficult to grasp the concept of space-time, actually we need to practice our mind, I myself practicing from ten years, I don't think this kind of Religious people know anything about this subject, he is talking on this subject with his limited knowledge, I don't know why people follow this kind of people.
Hare Krishna 🙏 This particular concept the speaker is talking about is from Srimad-Bhagavatam. He is only elaborating on that particular concept. These concepts of time and other allied subjects are already discussed in our Vedic scriptures. One only has to read and comprehend them. For a detailed study of time, you can refer to - Srimad-Bhagavatam Canto 3, Chapter 11 - Calculation of Time, from the Atom prabhupadabooks.com/
99.99% realised gurus like the above call themselves realised but they are not realised. everything is predestined and not combination of freewill and destiny.
Where did the guru in this video claimed that he is realized? Don't concoct and assume things.. Your controversial statement has to be backed by a reference.. Else its as useless as your baseless statement is
Yes. Everything is predestined. If a system is observed from an outside perspective it would be clear that it is destined a particular future because of the phenomenon and interactions affecting one another only inside the system isolated from outside. But if we are in the system itself we dont have the knowledge of the other consciousnesses and our own self to determine the future and even if we have it our future thoughts cant be determined by ourselves by present thoughts because of the infinite loop and hence people feel the free will. Yes it is for the insider but not for the universe.
Paratman is the supreme consciousness. Simpler to describe it by the structure: A group of conscious beings interact in a sense or rules to form a greater being of consciousness. It can be though like this. Every part in our body can be thought of a consciousness being. They interact to form a consciousness bodies that is us. And we interact with other conscious bodies to form a greater conscious body that is larger. And this structure goes infinitely and the paramatma is the universe itself which has its own consciousness.
There is nothing good and bad in the world you define what it is properly. We have ourselves created a set of actions which when implemented leads to our survival as well as our environment sustainably for the future. If someone who disregard then karma obviously follows it not just for himself but for others.Those rules are termed as good and if not bad but even that is relative among comparisons of situations. So assume it as good or bad as per your wish but there exist one and that karma of your actions will definitely strike back to all of us but you would have to face most of it for your actions.
Yes good can be said as bad or bad can be said as good by examples because good or bad are relative and also perspective to the rules we created but karma doesnt change over time. After observations over time we have identified what kind of actions can lead to our sustainance and our environment and termed them as good and others bad. It is your will to perform actions, not by othees. People are just spreaders of knowledge but they dont control. Realization of the knowledge and applying it your actions is your wish
Hare Krishna 🙏
This is The Best Answer. I am Astonished.
हरे कृष्ण हरे राम। 🙏🏻🪔💫
Hari bol.
BRILLIANT explanation.
Short but very wisely widely explained.
Enough to remove doubts and confusion.
I lost my young son 10 months ago.
Extremely confused and in emotional trauma, very hard to digest why did it happen.
But thank you so much.
That's why our society needs saints like you.
Hare Krishna
Perfect. My very own analogy which I came up with around 2010 when I started taking significantly more interest on this subject:
Imagine you have been given a box full of different fruits. Say an orange, an apple, a pear. You can pick only one from the box. You have the freedom of choice to pick whatever from the box. But you cant pick up a pineapple. As its not even in the scope in the first place.
Dear wise person, I believe that everything is predefined. For example, there were and are many person around the world who are more talented than even Alberta Einstein, but the didn't get the recognition, fame or money like Einstein. There are so many talented person who didn't get succeeded, even after doing hard work.
Getting fame is also pre destined and if one has to gain more then what is pre destined then one has to do some spiritual practices as a help from divines forces
The situations are pre destined except the choices we make in these situations which is based on our free will.
This is what Prabhu Ji told in Video.
Prabhuji's lecturer is pure nectar
Wow ..just amazing..how perfect the answer is... experienced many times..can relate...!!!
Excellent explanation of freewill.. Just so clear
Wonderful message, thanks so much
Misconceptions of karma is reward & punishment.
Real meaning of Karma is cause & effect of fundamental nature of existence.
Besides, I like this philosophy of cow being tie with limited length of rope to illustrate the nature of possible free will. Thank for this video😇😇😇
It also reminds me of stoicism. Something are under our control( how to think, how to respond ). Other remaining are out of our control ( covid19, natural disaster, other people & gravity)
hare krishna. thanks for sharing
I must've been really mean to puppies in my last life to deserve this one.
Everything is predestined. If a system is observed from an outside perspective it would be clear that it is destined a particular future because of the phenomenon and interactions affecting one another only inside the system isolated from outside. But if we are in the system itself we dont have the knowledge of the other consciousnesses and our own self to determine the future and even if we have it our future thoughts cant be determined by ourselves by present thoughts because of the infinite loop and hence people feel the free will. Yes it is for the insider but not for the universe.
i think this comment is correct
wow that's a logic argument...nice
Excellent explanation sir Jai Shri Krishna 🙏🙏
Nicely explained.. Hare Krishna..!!!
Man's Will or God's Will
A person once asked the Master, "How can we ascertain whether something is man's will or God's will?" Sri Ramakrishna replied: "Suppose a man has made arrangements to go to Varanasi and is ready to leave. In the meantime a message comes from his country home that his brother is about to die and if he wants to see him, he should come immediately. He cancels his trip to Varanasi and hurriedly returns home. Now you decide whose will it is."
-Ramakrishna As We Saw Him
It's kinda confusing !
@@nainapareek9350 it’s a play, it’s a Leela .. Advaita🙏
@@NoFear.Mr.T yes it is, but i want to know that what was the right answer, what is the final verdict? Was it by luck or by karma?
@@nainapareek9350 there is no right or wrong .. truth appearing (looks) as right and wrong.
perfect sir
Hahaha........
If you live unconsciously then life looks predestined. We are not animal to live compulsively.
The past karma, i have created and it has its influence, BUT in this life if i live conciously then i can create such a strong good karma to influence my past karma. It is possible. Otherwise there is no way for man's enlightenment. Namaste.🙏🙏🙏
3 minutes video changed entire my mind..
What if my setbacks and failures mean I will never succeed? This can be interpreted many ways…
thank you so much guruji
everything in life is pre destined , we have no choices period , even to the minut thought or action was written in your book and me writing this comment or what led me to it
@Aryan Kumar punishing is also pre destined...everything you will say is pre destined get it???
So, predestined = constrained? Wow, just the kind of clarification I was looking for!
There is no perfect answers as no-one knows. All these are theories. Human mind always wants logic. Hence the search. People never say don't know, but always gives smart answers.
@@vishaldeshmukh8798 why they cannot be wrong?
@@charantej7135 because the gita is the word of God. God cannot be wrong
JAi prabhupadh
Perfect explanation.. With simply said 👏👌
what about if the length of rob are different then it is predestined that longer the length of rob can enjoy more it is direct proportion. then every things is predestined
well said
Is the crime done by a criminal predestined?
Is the rape and other violence occurred predestined ??
If so, then any one can say that what he is doing is only the wish of god !!
Think about that..
Anupam Bhattacharyya it's upto the person. U can kill/ rape someone who did something bad in your past life or choose to forgive them and avoid committing the murder/rape. Forgiving someone can avoid accumulation of bad karma.
Hello sir..if you understand three karmas:sanchita(stored or accumulated) karma,prarabda(predetemined) karma,agami karma( free will),you will easily understand sir .Bhagavad geeta explains clearly..so which ever stronger ,that works in real time..sorry for bad english or mistakes
Paratman is the supreme consciousness.
Simpler to describe it by the structure: A group of conscious beings interact in a sense or rules to form a greater being of consciousness. It can be though like this. Every part in our body can be thought of a consciousness being. They interact to form a consciousness bodies that is us. And we interact with other conscious bodies to form a greater conscious body that is larger. And this structure goes infinitely and the paramatma is the universe itself which has its own consciousness.
God is no selfish thing having deeds that if you pray you get a desire fulfilled. Paramatman is the consciousness of the universe itself. It doesnt matter what you do that consciousness feels nothing of your deeds unless yoir karma is strong enough to ripple across the future consequences for the paramatman. Basically all of us and our environment constitute the paramatman. Praying the paramatman is not to fulfill a desire but to respect paramatman that is the universe itself. It induces a sense of belief and confidence to perform our strong dharma that is our responsibilities to our desires. The karma of our actions then resonates back to the outcomes which not juat depends on ourselves but the whole paramtman that is everyone and everything around us.
If rapes, murders happen then that is the karma of our bad actions of all of us not just ypurself. If a good person gets bad outcome, then as i said karma is not limited to one it is outcome based on everything. So it is the result of the action of a bad people. But the same actions lead to his bad karma in his future no matter what but the period and effects depend on everything
🙏🙏
According to me everything is predestined........
Right Guruji..Our life is scripted but how better we act as per the script given is also a subject matter of our whole identitification..I would conclude by figuring Destiny=50% and Karma=50%..
Correct
Hare Krishna 🙏
Prove that life is predestined .
Guru g no disrespect for u but moral of the story is life is totally predestined no free will works see I am 39 in my life till no gf came and still I am unmarried I tried several times there are also so many problems but It will b long as I see many boys have so many gf and they enjoy there life but anyways now I left hoping I understood everything it's all pre-planned
Think about this. If everything is freewill and nothing is destiny then we would all use our freewill to get everything we want in life and yet it's only a few people who are successfull. Only 1% succeed so only they are using their freewill and the rest have gone to sleep?
Is there any proof of predestination ??? no one can proof that life is predestined .All are some statements without any evidence .
Listen life philosphy is about seeking not evidence. Take analogy suppose you don't know what sweet tastes like and I know how sweet tastes like as I ate sugar one day. Now I came to you and said that I experienced sweet I ate sugar and now you will ask that "can you give me the proof that sweet exists" basically you cannot believe in sweetness unless you try sugar and you will only be convinced to try it if you surrender yourself before me and believe me. So the answer is that firstly you need to surrender yourself to a guru (you cannot find your guru when the right time comes you will meet him believe me just like Vivekananda met paramhans)and believe in him and his ways to get to the god and then you will experience nobody can give you the evidence for that divine experience you need to experience it yourself to believe it.
Exurb1a made a good video on this called why is the milk gone
I was searching for this question in terms of Einstein's view on "Time". It's very difficult to grasp the concept of space-time, actually we need to practice our mind, I myself practicing from ten years, I don't think this kind of Religious people know anything about this subject, he is talking on this subject with his limited knowledge, I don't know why people follow this kind of people.
Hare Krishna 🙏 This particular concept the speaker is talking about is from Srimad-Bhagavatam. He is only elaborating on that particular concept.
These concepts of time and other allied subjects are already discussed in our Vedic scriptures. One only has to read and comprehend them.
For a detailed study of time, you can refer to - Srimad-Bhagavatam Canto 3, Chapter 11 - Calculation of Time, from the Atom
prabhupadabooks.com/
99.99% realised gurus like the above call themselves realised but they are not realised. everything is predestined and not combination of freewill and destiny.
You are atheist so you can't understand such things (Spiritual Wisdom)
Where did the guru in this video claimed that he is realized? Don't concoct and assume things.. Your controversial statement has to be backed by a reference.. Else its as useless as your baseless statement is
Kundan Pai nonsense. Everything is not predestined. Think it through !!
Yes. Everything is predestined. If a system is observed from an outside perspective it would be clear that it is destined a particular future because of the phenomenon and interactions affecting one another only inside the system isolated from outside. But if we are in the system itself we dont have the knowledge of the other consciousnesses and our own self to determine the future and even if we have it our future thoughts cant be determined by ourselves by present thoughts because of the infinite loop and hence people feel the free will. Yes it is for the insider but not for the universe.
Paratman is the supreme consciousness.
Simpler to describe it by the structure: A group of conscious beings interact in a sense or rules to form a greater being of consciousness. It can be though like this. Every part in our body can be thought of a consciousness being. They interact to form a consciousness bodies that is us. And we interact with other conscious bodies to form a greater conscious body that is larger. And this structure goes infinitely and the paramatma is the universe itself which has its own consciousness.
I think it's not believe in your will
So your a slave to your mind for the rest of your life ? So your just a helpless person?
Are you also not?
👎👎👎👎
why they can't say anything without examples ??
you can prove bad as good and good as bad by examples.
dharm ke naam pe ye log dandha karte hai
@@ashwithb5118 God bless you my dear
Examples are for dull people like u to understand... Otherwise, the concepts are crystal clear
@Nishant what type of an idiot are you?
There is nothing good and bad in the world you define what it is properly. We have ourselves created a set of actions which when implemented leads to our survival as well as our environment sustainably for the future. If someone who disregard then karma obviously follows it not just for himself but for others.Those rules are termed as good and if not bad but even that is relative among comparisons of situations.
So assume it as good or bad as per your wish but there exist one and that karma of your actions will definitely strike back to all of us but you would have to face most of it for your actions.
Yes good can be said as bad or bad can be said as good by examples because good or bad are relative and also perspective to the rules we created but karma doesnt change over time.
After observations over time we have identified what kind of actions can lead to our sustainance and our environment and termed them as good and others bad.
It is your will to perform actions, not by othees. People are just spreaders of knowledge but they dont control. Realization of the knowledge and applying it your actions is your wish