Even if broodscale wasn't a may ability, rosie cotton can end these combos any time by simply targeting something else with the +1/+1 counter ability. You can also replace broodscale with scurry oak or herd balith to the same effect.
Actually, Scurry Oak might be better yause you don't need Jinney Fey to get creatures that actually do damage. Depends on if your payoff is a large spell or just attacking.
@hordenmeisterAO If Jennie Fae is in the command zone specifically, I think broodscale is better, since the point of turning them into cats is that they also get haste, so it effectively wins on the spot. In any other deck, I definitely see a case for including scurry oak and/or herd baloth over broodscale, because the extra mana is slightly less valuable than having guaranteed lethal on board.
That lizard pisses me off. I bought four collector booster boxes 2 gift bundles 2 pre release kits and a normal bundle. Didnt pull even one of that card.
Blade of the Bloodchief or Tarian's Soulcleaver works better for the generic cost for any mono green decks or decks that don't use white also Tarian's Soulcleaver gives Basking Broodscale Vigilance for a BIG attack and a BIG blocker
I'll use that combo but with flashraker, who cares about making cats when I can just fling a damage to each opponent for each colorless creature I create. 😊
I still don't understand why Rosie isn't partnered with samwise gamgee. The synergy alone is good, but they're actually partnered in the movies. Not the books though, those take a very different route...
Don’t unterstand the excitement of combos. If everyone does it we’re in cedh territory. The only scenario that makes sense to me is when you want to end a long ass game. In that case you’ll have to sometimes finish the game way too soon or play sub optimal (e.g. don’t tutor for the combo), even don’t play the cards in your hand or not play optimally- which is a deck building flaw imo
You say you dont understand combos but then say building the deck sub optimally or playing sub optimally also dont make sense. Cant really have it both ways imo The combo can be in a deck without tutors entirely intentionally as a means to keep power levels lower. Drawing the two cards in a normal game isnt exactly likely. It can end games early but people can also If a game does end early, GG lets go next
@@MrXaoras Yeah, either or. Because with broodscale, you dont have to make a token. So you can just end it there. Or you can just put a 1/1 on a token or your commander, etc. Yeah.
If I have to go out, it had better be due to cat stampede
Even if broodscale wasn't a may ability, rosie cotton can end these combos any time by simply targeting something else with the +1/+1 counter ability. You can also replace broodscale with scurry oak or herd balith to the same effect.
Actually, Scurry Oak might be better yause you don't need Jinney Fey to get creatures that actually do damage. Depends on if your payoff is a large spell or just attacking.
@hordenmeisterAO If Jennie Fae is in the command zone specifically, I think broodscale is better, since the point of turning them into cats is that they also get haste, so it effectively wins on the spot. In any other deck, I definitely see a case for including scurry oak and/or herd baloth over broodscale, because the extra mana is slightly less valuable than having guaranteed lethal on board.
I lost to this combo on Arena
I imagine people just scoop at that point 🤣
me too, thought i was gonna get the dub, but alas :(
I have a similar combo with Jinney Fey, Requiem Angel, Goblin Bombardment, and a sac creature
Oh yeah! Absolutely a great combo
Shalai & Hallar says everyone dies without having to do anything. 😂
That lizard pisses me off. I bought four collector booster boxes 2 gift bundles 2 pre release kits and a normal bundle. Didnt pull even one of that card.
What??? That’s insanely bad luck friend
"Meow" 😂
I have both of these cards, oh my god!!
You can make this better by next turn making them all 5/3 juggernauts
LOL true. But also, what next turn? 🤣
@ fair but its funny imagine you end turn cause summoning sickness they go thank god thats over and then you pop out graaz, the unstoppable juggernaut
@ you can also run baylen every 4 tokens is 3 +1/+1 counters and trample
Baylen is for sure a great commander for this
@ yep you can also run all 5 token doublers with the deck as well for bonus chaos
Time to add broodscale to my Baylen deck I suppose!
Oh its gooooood
I'm well aware of this combo, I just use Scurry Oak instead of Broodscale
Works pretty well! Cmc is hardly different
I use this combo in my Marath deck lol. (got all 3 of them)
That one guy who has a Bile Blite......
At that rate they should just take out Rosie or the broodscale
Riot Control.
Don't worry, I'll see myself out.
Good ol' Eldrazis and Hobbits lol
A match made...somewhere. Not the shire - that's for sure
even if it wasnt a may ability you could just target one of the cats to get the counter to end the chain
Rosie can be subbed out for Cathar's Crusade if needed.
Yep. Just a lot more mana
I've gone against this along with a scurry oak 😅
That’ll do it tbh
We did it guys we broke rosie cotton
Just tried this to see if it works lol I'm putting this into a hydra deck for infinite hydras with infinite power/toughness
Only 10,000? Those are rookie numbers. I'm naming 1 Googleplex
Googling googleplex brb
Blade of the Bloodchief or Tarian's Soulcleaver works better for the generic cost for any mono green decks or decks that don't use white also Tarian's Soulcleaver gives Basking Broodscale Vigilance for a BIG attack and a BIG blocker
this works super well. But one big boy is easier to block or kill than thousands of cats
If you play simic, you can do some silly stuff with Essix. Any tokens you create become copies of a creature you control 😅
HEHEHEHE I see no problems here!
@TopdeckTech no problems at all 😉
It's worth noting that you don't need cats if you have a mana sink win condition as this rosie broodscale combo produces infinite colorless mana.
Of course. This is just one of many ways to play the combo. And one of the most straightforward
Can you do this in legacy?
that's cool and all, but what if i make 10,000 cats and then cast craterhoof
Why cast craterhoof when you can have a trillion cats? 😂
goddamit *sigh opens card kingdom*
So, Broodscale beats Scurry Oak because of the CMC? We're not using the eldrazi spawn's ability so either should be fine.
Yep! Broodscale is just newer
All that just for me to drop Massacre Girl or I'll use Day of Judgement. 🤣
Nono - the cats have haste. You dont get another turn 🎉🎉🎉
Cats are fine an all for the haste, but I still make the doggos for the meme.
Deck aint called "Baha Men" for nothing.....
WHO LET THE DOGS OUT!?!?!?
This is the only way to build decks
Or play divine visitation, and create 4/4 fliers with vigilance
But why when I could just make 300 power on board, swing with haste, and win? No need for vigilance or flyers when nobody has enough blockers
“Untap, upkeep, draw, soo, I will cast farewell and choose all modes, any responses?”
Well the cats have haste. So in this scenario, the untap never happens. We all just die to claws and fur
I'll use that combo but with flashraker, who cares about making cats when I can just fling a damage to each opponent for each colorless creature I create. 😊
That’s true. But fleshraker is just a nasty card lol
wife got the best of ya, eh?
Im always terrified of this combo. Always. 4 mana? Getouttahear
I usually just do a billion and stop, i thought that a trillion was a little excessive. 10,000 is not enough to piss off your friends😂
I still don't understand why Rosie isn't partnered with samwise gamgee. The synergy alone is good, but they're actually partnered in the movies. Not the books though, those take a very different route...
I believe Sam and Rosie end up together still, no?
So the only reasons to turn them into cats are haste and eldrazi dislike?
Turn them into cats to attack with haste and win, yeah
Don’t unterstand the excitement of combos. If everyone does it we’re in cedh territory. The only scenario that makes sense to me is when you want to end a long ass game. In that case you’ll have to sometimes finish the game way too soon or play sub optimal (e.g. don’t tutor for the combo), even don’t play the cards in your hand or not play optimally- which is a deck building flaw imo
You say you dont understand combos but then say building the deck sub optimally or playing sub optimally also dont make sense. Cant really have it both ways imo
The combo can be in a deck without tutors entirely intentionally as a means to keep power levels lower. Drawing the two cards in a normal game isnt exactly likely.
It can end games early but people can also
If a game does end early, GG lets go next
Isn't that an infinite combo that doesnt stop
Broodscale is a “may” ability - so you can end it when you choose if uninterrupted
@@TopdeckTech ah ok
@@TopdeckTech you also have to target the counter trigger so you can always put it on one of the other tokens to stop the loop
@@MrXaoras Yeah, either or. Because with broodscale, you dont have to make a token. So you can just end it there. Or you can just put a 1/1 on a token or your commander, etc. Yeah.
Come on that card reads go infinite on a stick. You poke it and might scare the card into making infinite tokens
Absolutely
Weird hat
Rosie and Jinnie Fay, crazy cat ladies.
LOL the hardest truth.