In this format for sets race to 4, one rack is a lot. And since its winner break, its even more crucial. If you're saying one rack is nothing, then why not Biado admit the foul and concede the rack? Should be no problem since one rack is nothing.
@@desdesdes123Chung also choked in the most crucial sets, don't forget that. That cost him alot in the 3rd set and Biado absolutely capitalized on that mistake.
Agreed, it's the referees obligation to be positioned in a way that makes it possible to see if there is a foul committed, not the players obligation to move or show the ref what's up.
Yes agree, same with other sports like in basketball when a player commits a foul or in boxing when a fighter hits below the belt, thats why theres a referee its their job to enforce the rules of the game.
@@Carlost_Biadog in a match for first place and the money at stake, couldn't they hire another referee? If there were ever a crisis of conscience in a game, this was it. If he calls the foul, he loses the turn, maybe the game, opponent and referee both missed the foul, and he could have called it on himself, that's fair. But it didn't change the outcome of the difficulty of the rack, nobody saw it but the camera and it is history at this point. I'm just saying that it was the responsibility of the referees and the tournament sponsors or whoever is in charge of the rule set to enforce the rules. That's basically all. It's a lot to think about isn't it?
To the Admin of this YT: Channel. Don't be biased also publish the battle between Chou vs. Chezka. Where Chou intentionally Sharking. Chieh-Yu Chou drinks a coffee as Chezka lines up her shot on the six-ball and misses. (CENTENO vs. CHOU ▸ 2024 PBS WOMEN SHOWDOWN) at (59:35)
Throughout this tournament Carlo Biado played better pool than anyone has ever played in any major tournament in at least the past ten years. It was a masterful performance perhaps equaled only by the incomparable Effren Reyes in his prime. To play at that level requires skill and concentration that few can achieve. That he touched that ball probably didn't even consciously enter his mind.
I think he knows he fouled here but let’s give him the benefit of the doubt, he might not be aware of it because of his laser focus on the game. It happens to all sports, refs made mistake 😢 Carlo’s performance from day 1 to finals is simply amazing!
Don't use other sports as an excuse for his lack of integrity. This has nothing to do with the referee. We all know he could've own up to his foul, even if there isn't a referee. He clearly felt the ball when he twitched.
@@Carlost_Biadog intentional dropping the ball or intentional foul and unintentional foul like in this video are a complete different argument. Your emotion is too high that is why your thinking is too low 😅😂lol.
@@Carlost_Biadog 1. Not intentional. 2. No one saw the foul, not even the referee and commentator and Carlo Biado probably doesn’t know or maybe in his mind he taught he felt but was unsure since the ball kept in the same position and since he was in pressure and with adrenaline pumping that time. 3. A Single mistake by Referee doesn’t give a win to KPC. KPC did not dominate the game. 4. Biado destroyed all your players from Wu Kun Lin, chang jung lin and KPC plus he defeated Gorst, SVB and Oi in the same fashion. One mistake by the ref will not make a big difference. 5. Give the credit when credit is due.
@@Carlost_Biadogthree of your Taiwanese players was destroyed bu biado. They will not win if the ref saw the foul. Even if you put Ko pin yi he will get destroyed too in that competition since carlo played pretty amazing from day one. Don’t cry too much. Save your energy when China will make Taiwan as their province 😅😂
does not affect the game result, this happen in the early first set.. because even in the crucial stage, KO is still on the game and have opportunity to win it , and just miscues in the most crucial time.. even its clearly a foul, even if its called, the game will not be affected . it happens , even on other games, thats why there is a referee to call the game. but because a lot is crying over it.. ok its your choice not to move on this moment and stay lock on that uncalled foul..
Are you inane? It would've been a different story if he admitted the foul. He could've still won, or could've lost but with grace. No one knows for sure now, because he cheated. This is a sports, that display class and integrity. Referee or not, it's still the player that up holds the value of the sports. People aren't debating over the result of the match, but calling out the integrity of this very player.
insane?@@Carlost_Biadog for what are you saying is insane... if theres an issue, tell that to organizer, it is not players fault to not call a referee's job to do.... even the one who takes the video, and the audience , and also comentary should have reacted that way .. if theres an issue, it is not full responsibility of a player, get it
your just showing one scenario,and pushing it to one particular person. if something being pair is what you want, dont push too hard mate, cause its a problem organizer should be aware of next time, and not you... sports is sports, thats why there is always referee in any sports and games...
hahaha@@Carlost_Biadog , well i dont mind you doing it, cause it is evident that every sports need someone like you, so you can expose all what you want.. its your choice and beliefs and im not doing something like that in anyway. cant accept it, go on and push it hard?
All the pinoys here saying "oh its just one foul", "he didnt feel it" bla bla. If the opponent did that, yall will go crazy. Typical.... and look at his reaction in the replay, he obviously knew he touched the ball but did not have the sportsmanship to own up to it. Biado is a very good player, but probably needs to up his professionalism.
I don't entirely blame the ref for not having called out the foul shot by Carlo since she was more focused watching Biado taking a shot at the 7 ball. As the video showed, the ref's view on the 8 ball was entirely out of her sight as it was blocked by Biado while he was dealing with the 7 ball. In fact even Kho Ping Chong didn't have a clear sight of what happened to the 8 ball because it was being blocked by Biado's body. It's unfortunate that the ref was at the wrong place when this happened.
Taiwanese people are upset about Biado's accidental foul that wasn't noticed by Biado and the referee or even the commentators. But, I've never heard the Taiwanese criticize their players for cheating, especially when Chou intentionally sharked during Chezka's game. The fact that Biado demolished all Taiwanese PROS to reach the Finals and dominated and won the recent Taiwanese Open 2024. This is the main reason why the Taiwanese are expressing so much hate and frustration over Biado's single accidental and uncalled foul. What a sour losers.
Carlo has no character whatsoever. He fouled, knew that he fouled, then went on as if nothing happened. Guys like him are why pool is not taken seriously in professional sports.
The ball moved a whole ONE CENTIMETER. And it was 100% make-able from the previous position of this one. It was not intentional. The ball was 5 inches out from the tip of the rail. He could have made it from either place with his eyes closed.
He touched that ball and it was a foul. Regardless of intentional or not, whether it was easy or hard to make the shot had nothing to do with the fact that it was a foul and he knew…..very dishonest win and he did not serve the title. Cheater……
@@mikehuffman4456 Did you bet your whole life savings in this match against Carlo? I see you here and you keep on crying about it? I play a lot of pool and those kind of things, most of the time youre not aware, you dont feel it.. move on man, those kind of things happen. To Judge one person just because of that.. Wow..
A foul is about the cue ball and the object ball. There's a separate rule on a still ball and it doesn't necessarily mean ball in hand. The players can both agree to replace the ball to its original position or just leave it in the new position besides that 8 ball hardly moved a place, it wouldn't have changed much in the game
c) Touching a still object ball: Any still object ball moved can only be moved back to its original position with the permission of the opponent. The opponent may exercise the option of keeping disturbed ball(s) in new position if they so choose. Only after receiving consent from the opponent, the player who has committed the error may move the disturbed object ball(s) back to original position. If the player who has committed the infraction touches any of the disturbed balls without consent of the opponent, it will result in a ball in hand foul to the opponent.
I had a dude try to move the 8 ball(barbox 8 ball) into a better position to make a easy run out. Was so obvious he was trying to cheat. He moved it like 2 feet.
hahah. is it all balls foul or not? in filipines they just respot that 8 ball.watch their matches with those chalk marks. but yeah, he felt it, thats why a ref is there. $75 000 is lot. i have notime to be sportsmanlike. ref got to book me. cant jail myself bruv
1. Not intentional. 2. No one saw the foul, not even the referee and commentator and Carlo Biado probably doesn’t know or maybe in his mind he taught he felt but was unsure since the ball kept in the same position and since he was in pressure and with adrenaline pumping that time. 3. A Single mistake by Referee doesn’t give a win to KPC. KPC did not dominate the game. 4. Biado destroyed all your players from Wu Kun Lin, chang jung lin and KPC plus he defeated Gorst, SVB and Oi in the same fashion. One mistake by the ref will not make a big difference. 5. Give the credit when credit is due.
That's the problem of the ref whether carlo knew it or not. We have to give him the benefit of the doubt. They're there for a reason, we can't have players calling fouls on themselves nor against each other because it will be more chaotic. It's just the same with a non-call in basketball, treat it as breaks of the game. It happens all the time in basketball, players there don't even admit making fouls are we saying ban them for being dishonest???? That's precisely why we have game officials that' is within their territory not players'.
Hell no. This isn't basketball, this isn't a fast paced active sports where a multitude of motions take place. Cuesports is a play by play, one motion sports, there is no consequences to breaking the play. Hence, your reasoning is not a fair comparison. It was an accidental touch for sure. As for whether CB knew it or not, his physiological responses clearly showed that he was aware. That abnormal twitch upwards in his arm was the dead giveaway. Anyone who has touched a ball/anything accidentally, twitch/jerk in some way. You may aruge that he may thought it was the pocket or rail, but he literally moved the ball into a new position, the force he had exert onto the object means he would've felt the difference between a ball and any other objects. Now I have made my 2 cents, I look forward to your logical retort.
Definitely a foul. At this high level of pool the noncall could be costly... but there was no way ko or ref could've seen it, it wasn't in their line of sight. You really expect Biado to be honest and say "hey guys i brushed the 8 so it's ball in hand for Ko". Nah, 99% of pros won't do that.
Ref ideally should've been standing on the other side of Carlo for the best vantage point. Not sure she would've caught it anyway but certainly not from where she was standing.
biado is dishonest if he felt it.. well game is either clean or dirty.. just move on.. no sports is clean.. I hope he may regret it and apologize to what happen. but then it is what it is.. he is also showed how good he is in the tournament so still congrats to him
@@Carlost_Biadog hahahaha and you knew all that from a video????? Hahahaha you're not even him how'd you know he actually felt that during that intense moment. Just cry your heart out hahaha
It is a foul but I would give Carlo the benefit of the doubt here. The 8 ball barely moved. He barely brushed the 8 ball and if he's focused on making the 7 ball, chances are he won't notice it. It's the refs job to see these things. I'll give Carlo a pass on this one. I don't believe he was aware of what happened.
if world class player can be so "touchy" that can make defence shot so delicate no way world class player not "feel" touching the ball bro but carlo dont have responsible abt this, ref, monitoring technical team , tournament director does
Fue falta sin duda, pero el árbitro está mal posicionado, debió estar en el lado opuesto de la mesa y observar el 8 y no la bola que va a tirar el jugador, otra observación es que en Filipinas ellos pueden mover y lo regresan a su lugar y no es falta para ellos
In snooker, it is a foul, always. In pocket billiards, some matches are "set" to "all fouls" and some are set such that an inadvertent contact with a ball is not a foul.
In intense games especially crucial ones the players are totally focused they wouldn't notice those things especially one that is out of his sights. And again, that's the fault of a referee, that's precisely why they're there
So with your logic, he could've shifted the ball into the pocket and it's not a foul because the ref didn't see it. He should continue playing dishonestly?
@@Carlost_Biadog again that's stupid, that's assuming he actually felt it during an intense and crucial situation besides the fact that the player is in extreme focus, slight brushes like that could easily escape someone in that state and conditions
@@Carlost_Biadog if that's your logic then why not call out basketball players too who obviously don't call fouls on themselves when they clearly know they hit the opposing player?????????? If the ref doesn't see it shouldn't the player raise his hands and call a foul on himself?????? Your logic is flawed. That's the duty of the ref because players can foul knowingly or unknowingly, there's a reason why they're there
@@Carlost_Biadog dishonest???? You should establish intent first and if he knew that happened, stop calling people dishonest when you're clearly just a regular person just like us all. Clear the log out of your eyes first
No it is not a foul because there is a referee. In any sports only the referee can call a foul. The ball was not displaced in its original place so there is no effect to the opponent.
@@Carlost_Biadog hence it has to disgussed whether its ALL ball foul. i pinoy, that 8 ball is just respotted coz it not the object ball. but he def felt it. but its the ref job to call him out. intergrity with $75 000 on the line, mehhh
I'd be more upset if Carlo called foul himself. It's not a cue ball foul. I had my shirt fall on a ball as I made a shot. The ball never moved so I said nothing, but technically it's a foul. Thing is, I give the same slack to my opponent.
I don't care who wins, it's "HONEST"....Joshua Filler just said “Luckily, I lost, because I wouldn’t want to win like that. That’s my honest opinion - I hate cheating, I hate moves or whatever”.
That dude needs some reffing lessons.. and biado definitely felt it
Yeah tell that to shane van boening too fouling on the 8ball vs pagulayan
Yea that's bullshit biado definitely felt that 8ball move
@@clintenye5203shane could have easily not noticed that.
He knew he fouled . He look straight down after he shot. He cheered and knew it.
Right.Maybe because of tihis ball ，winner was not him
For one touch? Lol. What set and what rack was that? 😅. So one touch in a single rack is an automatic lost for all racks and sets? 😂
In this format for sets race to 4, one rack is a lot. And since its winner break, its even more crucial. If you're saying one rack is nothing, then why not Biado admit the foul and concede the rack? Should be no problem since one rack is nothing.
@@desdesdes123Chung also choked in the most crucial sets, don't forget that. That cost him alot in the 3rd set and Biado absolutely capitalized on that mistake.
He definitely knew he touched that ball
Yeah tell that to shane van boening too fouling on the 8ball vs pagulayan
Yes, no doubt. You could see, how fast he gets his Hand to the top and not in the natural way in the back. He knew, he was making a foul.
The player was dishonest, and the referee was a scarecrow.
The referee was not in the strategic position to observe everything that is in the table. Not to be charged to Carlo Biado.
Agreed, it's the referees obligation to be positioned in a way that makes it possible to see if there is a foul committed, not the players obligation to move or show the ref what's up.
So with that logic of yours, if he had move and drop the ball into the pocket, he should also continue playing?
@@Carlost_Biadog nope
Yes agree, same with other sports like in basketball when a player commits a foul or in boxing when a fighter hits below the belt, thats why theres a referee its their job to enforce the rules of the game.
@@Carlost_Biadog in a match for first place and the money at stake, couldn't they hire another referee? If there were ever a crisis of conscience in a game, this was it. If he calls the foul, he loses the turn, maybe the game, opponent and referee both missed the foul, and he could have called it on himself, that's fair. But it didn't change the outcome of the difficulty of the rack, nobody saw it but the camera and it is history at this point. I'm just saying that it was the responsibility of the referees and the tournament sponsors or whoever is in charge of the rule set to enforce the rules. That's basically all. It's a lot to think about isn't it?
To the Admin of this YT: Channel. Don't be biased also publish the battle between Chou vs. Chezka. Where Chou intentionally Sharking. Chieh-Yu Chou drinks a coffee as Chezka lines up her shot on the six-ball and misses. (CENTENO vs. CHOU ▸ 2024 PBS WOMEN SHOWDOWN) at (59:35)
Throughout this tournament Carlo Biado played better pool than anyone has ever played in any major tournament in at least the past ten years. It was a masterful performance perhaps equaled only by the incomparable Effren Reyes in his prime. To play at that level requires skill and concentration that few can achieve. That he touched that ball probably didn't even consciously enter his mind.
I think he knows he fouled here but let’s give him the benefit of the doubt, he might not be aware of it because of his laser focus on the game.
It happens to all sports, refs made mistake 😢
Carlo’s performance from day 1 to finals is simply amazing!
Don't use other sports as an excuse for his lack of integrity. This has nothing to do with the referee.
We all know he could've own up to his foul, even if there isn't a referee. He clearly felt the ball when he twitched.
@@Carlost_Biadog For one touch? Lol. What set and what rack was that? 😅. So one touch in a single rack is an automatic lost for all racks and sets? 😂
@@Carlost_Biadog intentional dropping the ball or intentional foul and unintentional foul like in this video are a complete different argument. Your emotion is too high that is why your thinking is too low 😅😂lol.
@@Carlost_Biadog 1. Not intentional.
2. No one saw the foul, not even the referee and commentator and Carlo Biado probably doesn’t know or maybe in his mind he taught he felt but was unsure since the ball kept in the same position and since he was in pressure and with adrenaline pumping that time.
3. A Single mistake by Referee doesn’t give a win to KPC. KPC did not dominate the game.
4. Biado destroyed all your players from Wu Kun Lin, chang jung lin and KPC plus he defeated Gorst, SVB and Oi in the same fashion. One mistake by the ref will not make a big difference.
5. Give the credit when credit is due.
@@Carlost_Biadogthree of your Taiwanese players was destroyed bu biado. They will not win if the ref saw the foul. Even if you put Ko pin yi he will get destroyed too in that competition since carlo played pretty amazing from day one. Don’t cry too much. Save your energy when China will make Taiwan as their province 😅😂
看卡洛的動作很流暢，無法確定是否本人知道自己已犯規，但這情形能確定一件事「裁判很不專業」連移動也不動，完全沒專業精神
他當下眼睛馬上查看右手下方其實早就知道了，因為身體擋住裁判沒被判犯規趴他才繼續打
does not affect the game result, this happen in the early first set.. because even in the crucial stage, KO is still on the game and have opportunity to win it , and just miscues in the most crucial time.. even its clearly a foul, even if its called, the game will not be affected . it happens , even on other games, thats why there is a referee to call the game. but because a lot is crying over it.. ok its your choice not to move on this moment and stay lock on that uncalled foul..
Are you inane? It would've been a different story if he admitted the foul.
He could've still won, or could've lost but with grace. No one knows for sure now, because he cheated.
This is a sports, that display class and integrity. Referee or not, it's still the player that up holds the value of the sports.
People aren't debating over the result of the match, but calling out the integrity of this very player.
insane?@@Carlost_Biadog for what are you saying is insane... if theres an issue, tell that to organizer, it is not players fault to not call a referee's job to do.... even the one who takes the video, and the audience , and also comentary should have reacted that way .. if theres an issue, it is not full responsibility of a player, get it
your just showing one scenario,and pushing it to one particular person. if something being pair is what you want, dont push too hard mate, cause its a problem organizer should be aware of next time, and not you... sports is sports, thats why there is always referee in any sports and games...
@@KuyaEddyReels inane is a word lol. Debate all you want, his lack of integrity is forever here for the world to see. Get it?
hahaha@@Carlost_Biadog , well i dont mind you doing it, cause it is evident that every sports need someone like you, so you can expose all what you want.. its your choice and beliefs and im not doing something like that in anyway. cant accept it, go on and push it hard?
He probably didn’t even feel that.
You always feel it when you hit the ball. Everyone does, even if u play first time pool you know you touched the ball.
All the pinoys here saying "oh its just one foul", "he didnt feel it" bla bla. If the opponent did that, yall will go crazy. Typical.... and look at his reaction in the replay, he obviously knew he touched the ball but did not have the sportsmanship to own up to it. Biado is a very good player, but probably needs to up his professionalism.
pinoy is the best at andromeda galaxy , just accept it
Biado plays dishonestly. Having made a mistake and knowing for sure that he had touched the 8th ball, he still skipped it to continue playing.
I don't entirely blame the ref for not having called out the foul shot by Carlo since she was more focused watching Biado taking a shot at the 7 ball. As the video showed, the ref's view on the 8 ball was entirely out of her sight as it was blocked by Biado while he was dealing with the 7 ball. In fact even Kho Ping Chong didn't have a clear sight of what happened to the 8 ball because it was being blocked by Biado's body. It's unfortunate that the ref was at the wrong place when this happened.
Ref had the opportunity to move to get a clear view of biado leaning over the 8 ball. but they didn't do so. Just kinda stood there. Strange.
Maybe carlost bribed the ref
Taiwanese people are upset about Biado's accidental foul that wasn't noticed by Biado and the referee or even the commentators. But, I've never heard the Taiwanese criticize their players for cheating, especially when Chou intentionally sharked during Chezka's game. The fact that Biado demolished all Taiwanese PROS to reach the Finals and dominated and won the recent Taiwanese Open 2024. This is the main reason why the Taiwanese are expressing so much hate and frustration over Biado's single accidental and uncalled foul. What a sour losers.
Carlo has no character whatsoever. He fouled, knew that he fouled, then went on as if nothing happened. Guys like him are why pool is not taken seriously in professional sports.
As a good player like Filler, he must be honest.
Haha, Very soon, here comes the double standard. The Marboys and Pinoys angry at Filler's unhonest touch in US OPEN 2024 vs Roda.
Biado miscalculated there, he thought he had enough clearance.
If only Ref saw it, Ko will have chance to come back.
For one touch? Lol. What set and what rack was that? 😅. So one touch in a single rack is an automatic lost for all racks and sets? 😂
Nah it's 10 ball, you know how unpredictable this game is. If it's 9 ball KO might have a chance to comeback because of how consistent his break is
Ball don’t lie.
Thanls you admin Gut job👍👍👍
The ball moved a whole ONE CENTIMETER. And it was 100% make-able from the previous position of this one. It was not intentional. The ball was 5 inches out from the tip of the rail. He could have made it from either place with his eyes closed.
He touched that ball and it was a foul. Regardless of intentional or not, whether it was easy or hard to make the shot had nothing to do with the fact that it was a foul and he knew…..very dishonest win and he did not serve the title. Cheater……
@@mikehuffman4456stop crying nothing you can do 😂😂😂 he is already the champion
@@mikehuffman4456 Did you bet your whole life savings in this match against Carlo? I see you here and you keep on crying about it? I play a lot of pool and those kind of things, most of the time youre not aware, you dont feel it.. move on man, those kind of things happen. To Judge one person just because of that.. Wow..
@@mikehuffman4456 Is it the end of the world to you? LOL!!
@@mikehuffman4456 For one touch? Lol. What set and what rack was that? 😅. So one touch in a single rack is an automatic lost for all racks and sets? 😂
A foul is about the cue ball and the object ball. There's a separate rule on a still ball and it doesn't necessarily mean ball in hand. The players can both agree to replace the ball to its original position or just leave it in the new position besides that 8 ball hardly moved a place, it wouldn't have changed much in the game
c) Touching a still object ball: Any still object ball moved can only be moved back to its original position with the permission of the opponent. The opponent may exercise the option of keeping disturbed ball(s) in new position if they so choose. Only after receiving consent from the opponent, the player who has committed the error may move the disturbed object ball(s) back to original position. If the player who has committed the infraction touches any of the disturbed balls without consent of the opponent, it will result in a ball in hand foul to the opponent.
All of a sudden, a lot of people are already questioning the integrity of Carlo.
Nope not questioning. As it clearly shows he does not possess any shred of integrity.
cancel culture at its finest.
@@jet688 I mean for someone who cheated his way to $75 bands. Should've seen it coming.
This is another reason why pool is not taken too seriously, if you can get away with cheating, it’s okay!!
of course the ref doesnt see it and its unintentional, just move on biado demolished 3 Taiwanese
Yeah now we all know how much a pinoy would cheat just to move on 😂
@@Carlost_Biadogkeep crying Bro😂😂😂
Biado lie
@@魏菘甫 he’s the Champ
I had a dude try to move the 8 ball(barbox 8 ball) into a better position to make a easy run out. Was so obvious he was trying to cheat. He moved it like 2 feet.
Nobody is disputing it.
😅😅😅
He did not deserve that win
For one touch? Lol. What set and what rack was that? 😅. So one touch in a single rack is an automatic lost for all racks and sets? 😂
every pool player would have felt it..
It's not a foul if it isn't called.
Doesn't matter if it seen or not.
So you're saying if the foul is not called, it isn't a foul. But it is a foul in the first place. 😂
Unsportsmanlike conduct
So much for personal integrity than. It was a foul, he knew it.
hahah. is it all balls foul or not? in filipines they just respot that 8 ball.watch their matches with those chalk marks.
but yeah, he felt it, thats why a ref is there. $75 000 is lot. i have notime to be sportsmanlike. ref got to book me. cant jail myself bruv
Yeah that's a lot of pesos, sounds like a good trade for integrity 🎉😂
Unsportsmanlike conduct!
1. Not intentional.
2. No one saw the foul, not even the referee and commentator and Carlo Biado probably doesn’t know or maybe in his mind he taught he felt but was unsure since the ball kept in the same position and since he was in pressure and with adrenaline pumping that time.
3. A Single mistake by Referee doesn’t give a win to KPC. KPC did not dominate the game.
4. Biado destroyed all your players from Wu Kun Lin, chang jung lin and KPC plus he defeated Gorst, SVB and Oi in the same fashion. One mistake by the ref will not make a big difference.
5. Give the credit when credit is due.
Not intentional??? Bud unsportsmanlike conduct
That's the problem of the ref whether carlo knew it or not. We have to give him the benefit of the doubt. They're there for a reason, we can't have players calling fouls on themselves nor against each other because it will be more chaotic. It's just the same with a non-call in basketball, treat it as breaks of the game. It happens all the time in basketball, players there don't even admit making fouls are we saying ban them for being dishonest???? That's precisely why we have game officials that' is within their territory not players'.
Hell no. This isn't basketball, this isn't a fast paced active sports where a multitude of motions take place. Cuesports is a play by play, one motion sports, there is no consequences to breaking the play. Hence, your reasoning is not a fair comparison.
It was an accidental touch for sure. As for whether CB knew it or not, his physiological responses clearly showed that he was aware. That abnormal twitch upwards in his arm was the dead giveaway.
Anyone who has touched a ball/anything accidentally, twitch/jerk in some way. You may aruge that he may thought it was the pocket or rail, but he literally moved the ball into a new position, the force he had exert onto the object means he would've felt the difference between a ball and any other objects.
Now I have made my 2 cents, I look forward to your logical retort.
well it's not biado's fault that the referee is on his back.. that was a blindspot.. 😂😂😂
Loosers side always looking for mistakes.
Indeed it was a foul.
And he knew it too.
3 - 1 score so Even its a foul or not biado will win it anyway same result
😂😂😂
Hahaha
你病的不輕
Hahaha
the ref not up to std
at least she need position herself in other angle
how can u watch from that angle?
He even look at it, this dude has no shame
Definitely a foul. At this high level of pool the noncall could be costly... but there was no way ko or ref could've seen it, it wasn't in their line of sight. You really expect Biado to be honest and say "hey guys i brushed the 8 so it's ball in hand for Ko". Nah, 99% of pros won't do that.
It's a referee mistake on this situation she suppost to be at back of the Player not on the side that is why.even commentors not mention it..
Cheated, plain and simple
For one touch? Lol. What set and what rack was that? 😅. So one touch in a single rack is an automatic lost for all racks and sets? 😂
@@RichardCriticalysis Unsportsmanlike conduct! Is there a difference if such a foul happens in the last rack?
Ref ideally should've been standing on the other side of Carlo for the best vantage point. Not sure she would've caught it anyway but certainly not from where she was standing.
biado is dishonest if he felt it.. well game is either clean or dirty.. just move on.. no sports is clean.. I hope he may regret it and apologize to what happen. but then it is what it is.. he is also showed how good he is in the tournament so still congrats to him
That's a still ball, it's a different rule and it doesn't result to a ball in hand
Surely he didn't know that happened, carlo is not that kind of player, and that's why there is a ref. That's the job of a referee
He twitched upwards, that's a straight giveaway he felt it. Owning up to your foul is not a ref job, it's a player's integrity.
@@Carlost_Biadog hahahaha and you knew all that from a video????? Hahahaha you're not even him how'd you know he actually felt that during that intense moment. Just cry your heart out hahaha
It is a foul but I would give Carlo the benefit of the doubt here. The 8 ball barely moved. He barely brushed the 8 ball and if he's focused on making the 7 ball, chances are he won't notice it. It's the refs job to see these things. I'll give Carlo a pass on this one. I don't believe he was aware of what happened.
If you are a billiard player you know when you touch another ball. and I mean VERY WELL.
He felt it lol he looked right at it
if world class player can be so "touchy" that can make defence shot so delicate
no way world class player not "feel" touching the ball bro
but carlo dont have responsible abt this, ref, monitoring technical team , tournament director does
Total dishonest. He does not deserved the title
Coward
Fue falta sin duda, pero el árbitro está mal posicionado, debió estar en el lado opuesto de la mesa y observar el 8 y no la bola que va a tirar el jugador, otra observación es que en Filipinas ellos pueden mover y lo regresan a su lugar y no es falta para ellos
It's referee's fault. He needs seminars and trainings
if he touch it with his shirt I would have give him benefit of doubt. but the contact is with his bare skin, 100% he would have felt it
In snooker and English pool, that's cheating.
In US pool i guess it's not.
Fouls are on the cue ball and object ball
Yup, lost respect for Biado on this.
He touched it , saw it , but continued .....
Anything to win ... no sportsmanship
Bullshit. Inadvertent contact with a not in play ball is not a foul in some match events.
You are talking nonsense. Cry over an spilled milk.
Didn’t make a difference. Happens. I woulda given my opponent ball in hand. Because that’s my character
It always happen when they lose...trying to find reason for losing...bwa haha
Fault of the referee not biado wrong positioning of the ref.
what a shame.
Foul?
In snooker, it is a foul, always. In pocket billiards, some matches are "set" to "all fouls" and some are set such that an inadvertent contact with a ball is not a foul.
TAIWANESE ARE CRYING BIADO STILL CHAMPION 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 EZ MONEY $75K DOLLARS 💸💸 😂😂😂😂
Dirty win
Danghag referee
IS IT REQUIRED THAT THE PLAYER WILL CALL FOR HIS ON MISTAKES? THEN DON'T PUT A REFEREE
If you are a honest player you will call the foul by yourself even if the ref or opponent didn't see it.
Shut up and accept defeat.
犯规不承认 一生中的污点
What a cheap player this guys is. No respect at all. Cheap cheap cheap.
Part of the game
In intense games especially crucial ones the players are totally focused they wouldn't notice those things especially one that is out of his sights. And again, that's the fault of a referee, that's precisely why they're there
So with your logic, he could've shifted the ball into the pocket and it's not a foul because the ref didn't see it. He should continue playing dishonestly?
@@Carlost_Biadog again that's stupid, that's assuming he actually felt it during an intense and crucial situation besides the fact that the player is in extreme focus, slight brushes like that could easily escape someone in that state and conditions
@@Carlost_Biadog if that's your logic then why not call out basketball players too who obviously don't call fouls on themselves when they clearly know they hit the opposing player?????????? If the ref doesn't see it shouldn't the player raise his hands and call a foul on himself?????? Your logic is flawed. That's the duty of the ref because players can foul knowingly or unknowingly, there's a reason why they're there
@@Carlost_Biadog dishonest???? You should establish intent first and if he knew that happened, stop calling people dishonest when you're clearly just a regular person just like us all. Clear the log out of your eyes first
@@Carlost_Biadog and you clearly know little about the game and surely not a player hahahaha
No it is not a foul because there is a referee. In any sports only the referee can call a foul. The ball was not displaced in its original place so there is no effect to the opponent.
So the PINOY can touch all the balls on the table and if the referee doesn't see it, it's not a foul?
@@Carlost_Biadog hence it has to disgussed whether its ALL ball foul. i pinoy, that 8 ball is just respotted coz it not the object ball. but he def felt it. but its the ref job to call him out. intergrity with $75 000 on the line, mehhh
I'd be more upset if Carlo called foul himself. It's not a cue ball foul. I had my shirt fall on a ball as I made a shot. The ball never moved so I said nothing, but technically it's a foul. Thing is, I give the same slack to my opponent.
Hard believe kelly fisher player herself didn't catch that when she reffed that match
Pbbbbbbbttttt!
Using Ai i could make more fouls to any billiard games...full of shit this guys
Haha, AI? I think Biadoo know the truth.
@@nonolin7735yeah all his peenoy defenders claimed god hacked the Livestream and altered the video. It was an act of God to show his true nature. 😂
Doesnt matter...its destiny...you think if the ref calls it foul he would have won?
Ko will still lose...its not his night nor his destiny
I don't care who wins, it's "HONEST"....Joshua Filler just said “Luckily, I lost, because I wouldn’t want to win like that. That’s my honest opinion - I hate cheating, I hate moves or whatever”.
No foul
Dishonest player .. fake champ