The second movement of this concerto (in my opinion) is a dialogue between two lovers, with absolute, pure, untainted, heartful love to each other. And, this version, thanks to the conductor, filled my heart with the true joy of love.
The 2nd movement is used as incidental score for some scenes of the Peter Weir's movie ''Picnic at Hanging Rock'', especially when two young lovers share scene.
I was about to click off this suggested video from some unknown orchestra and soloist but after hearing a few notes it sounded right and nice. The orchestra accompanied the piano excellently, melding together in unison as if like brothers. The pianist treated this composition as a piece of art, free of the annoying overboard pomposity as usually interpreted by others. There are no dynamic struggles nor timing lag between the orchestra and the piano. The orchestra is not overbearing too. It truly embellishes the piano and not just tag along. The synergy here is strong and without arrogance. Finally, Beethoven concerto #5 is played right, by both the orchestra and the pianist. Bravo !!
Agreed. Quite amazing on all ends. I will say though- Frankfurt RS is pretty high up there in popularity. Aimard is more niche, but very important in the industry. Friends with Ligeti, many Ligeti's etudes were written for Aimard or under his guidance. And his Bach WTC is top 10! He's a force to be reckoned with.
Frankfurt Symphony…one of the very best orchestras…certainly a now familiar and (so reliable for no interruptions of the performances)😊…I have come “to know some of musicians…thanks to the wonderful videographer “…the Beethoven #5 piano concerto is always a balm for my spirit……no matter how many times I’ve listened to it…✨
Un incomparable concerto, qu'on ne se lasse jamais d'entendre et qui nous transmet sa beauté et son énergie. I like how this conductor leads his orchestra, sobre and yet efficiently. Salutations depuis Montréal.
So enjoyable to hear the laser-like clarity of every note, phrase, and the connection between soloist and orchestra. This is the cleanest PC 5 I think I've ever heard from both soloist and orchestra. I really wish I could have heard it live. Many thanks to the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, Maestro Afkham, and brilliant pianist Aimard!
Best Emperor, one of the best piano performances ever heard. This is the pianist. I am so grateful we human kind have Maestro Aimard. Thank you so much for the video.
Thank you, thank you very much hr-Sinfonieorchester, for uploading the complete concerts, do not know how grateful I am, very few orchestras upload the complete videos to UA-cam, and even rarer when it comes to top quality musicians, and this concert for me is very Special since it is my favorite, I used to believe that the Berlin Philharmonic was the best and they had no rivals, but you have changed my opinion!!
my believe is that many good orchestras like berliner or vienna have very similar performance skills, soloists and conductors are the key to a truly outstanding concert among others.
Beautiful. Just beautiful. One of my favorite Beethoven piece. Amazingly well played and great quality of both sound and video. Thanks hr-Sinfonieorchester.
J'ai entendu cette oeuvre jouée au moins 50 fois avec une quinzaine de pianistes MAIS CELUI-CI est vraiment le plus posé-pas d'excès de vitesse ni de virtuosité de bout en bout comme chez Lang Lang et bien d'autres...Bravo!
5:42 - 8:53 From the main theme: From a sad loss To a hopeful opportunity to a Mystic Encounter to a Child Lullaby to Big Celebration to a Time of Studying and Progress to Wild Ride with a Horse to a Dreamy Walk in the Dark Woods to a Morning Awakening and finally back to main theme xD
Wow. Superb. Such a tight connection with pianist and orchestra. Perhaps the best Emperor I've heard.Absolute clarity in every note. In the first lock down here in Australia I listened over 5 nights to 5 different pianists playing this piece and at that time Hélène Grimaud with Paavo Järvi won my heart ~but a year later, Pierre-Laurent takes Gold. Couldn't help a funny thought ~ here's the Orchestra all dressed up, white bow ties and all, but a an dressed as the Plumber walks in and steals the show :)
Das ist eine der perfektesten Liveaufnahmen dieses Konzertes, die ich kenne. Penibel bis ins Detail gearbeitet (Orchester und Solist), auch die hr-Techniker haben einen tollen Job gemacht. Allein die Spielfreude im 3. Satz scheint etwas kontrolliert-gebremst, andere wie Gulda oder Kissin lassen sich da mehr mitreißen, was speziell bei Gulda auf Kosten der Perfektion geht. Aber das ist schon Kritik auf extrem hohen Niveau - das Video sorgt (zumindest bei mir) für Freude und beglückende Momente.
Good point. It's nice to hear performance so clear, classical in taste and fantastic balanced, so you can notice many details which are mostly hidden in bombastic-romantic versions.
The music and this performance speaks for itself. Words of superlative that I may contribute would be entirely inadequate. Highest praise for pierre-Laurent Aimard and David Afkham.
A great performance - technically perfect, essential and intelligent (without pretentious tricks or sinnlos Streiche), emotionally nuanced, brilliant sense of ever-dynamic yet cohesive flow of tempi, resulting in a magnificent story - from the beginning to the end. Thank you!
I am surprised in positive way, that Mr. Aimard, whom I know especially from XXth century repertoire, is playing Beethoven with such a deep understanding of this piece, including sound aspects of piano from the beginning of XIXth century familiar to composer himself.
Maravillosa la conjuncion , Pianista, Director y Sinfonica interppretando a una de las grandes creaciones de DIOS, ...Beethoven , . q' vive en nuestra mente y ❤ ❤❤
He escuchado esta obra maestra ya no sé cuántas veces y su poder de emoción no se acaba nunca. Extraordinaria interpretación! Aunque hasta ahora la interpretación de Zimmerman y Bernstein es mi favorita.
Great performance! For enthusiasts of Beethoven's concertos, highly recommend Barenboim with Klemperer; the 5th ends with the Choral Fantasia sung by the John Aldis choir--which is very rare.
@@wingcap1448 No, not necessary. It was supposed to be a joke. There are many young female pianists, and there are always plenty of comments on their physical looks. My comment is not meant to derogate this excellent artist in any way.
Muy bien... Pero el pianista en muchas ocasiones hace un ruido, como si estuviese tartamudeando; y esto opaca la melodía... Se escucha mas fuerte en el segundo movimiento. Lastima... Pero fantástico!!
Благодарю Франкфуртский оркестр за великолепную музыку! Не зря у Бетховена голландские корни; его музыка отличается от уравновешенной музыки других немецких композиторов.
@@margots.597 I'm not even good enough to play. But that doesn't need to prevent me from being a focused observer and commenting on what I've observed. And again. Everyone has off days. Even if I did play, I'd be no different. I used to play baseball. And though I was a perennial all-star, I had off days too. Didn't bother me to acknowledge it.
![[UA] NAVI проти G2 Esports | Blast Premier Fall Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QWlIm4FGESQ/mqdefault.jpg)
The second movement of this concerto (in my opinion) is a dialogue between two lovers, with absolute, pure, untainted, heartful love to each other. And, this version, thanks to the conductor, filled my heart with the true joy of love.
The 2nd movement is used as incidental score for some scenes of the Peter Weir's movie ''Picnic at Hanging Rock'', especially when two young lovers share scene.
I was about to click off this suggested video from some unknown orchestra and soloist but after hearing a few notes it sounded right and nice. The orchestra accompanied the piano excellently, melding together in unison as if like brothers. The pianist treated this composition as a piece of art, free of the annoying overboard pomposity as usually interpreted by others. There are no dynamic struggles nor timing lag between the orchestra and the piano. The orchestra is not overbearing too. It truly embellishes the piano and not just tag along. The synergy here is strong and without arrogance. Finally, Beethoven concerto #5 is played right, by both the orchestra and the pianist. Bravo !!
Well said ! I also discovered this by accident and what a lovely surprise
Agreed. Quite amazing on all ends. I will say though- Frankfurt RS is pretty high up there in popularity. Aimard is more niche, but very important in the industry. Friends with Ligeti, many Ligeti's etudes were written for Aimard or under his guidance. And his Bach WTC is top 10! He's a force to be reckoned with.
Frankfurt Symphony…one of the very best orchestras…certainly a now familiar and (so reliable for no interruptions of the performances)😊…I have come “to know some of musicians…thanks to the wonderful videographer “…the Beethoven #5 piano concerto is always a balm for my spirit……no matter how many times I’ve listened to it…✨
Un incomparable concerto, qu'on ne se lasse jamais d'entendre et qui nous transmet sa beauté et son énergie. I like how this conductor leads his orchestra, sobre and yet efficiently. Salutations depuis Montréal.
So enjoyable to hear the laser-like clarity of every note, phrase, and the connection between soloist and orchestra. This is the cleanest PC 5 I think I've ever heard from both soloist and orchestra. I really wish I could have heard it live. Many thanks to the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, Maestro Afkham, and brilliant pianist Aimard!
Me conmueve hasta las lágrimas. ¿Cómo es posible tanta belleza? Beethoven es mi héroe.
Вы послушайте 5 концерт Бетховена . Играет Поллини и Карл Бем 1978 год Дойче граммофон 😊😊
So brilliant Gefühlvoll und Kraftvoll habe dieses Klavierkonzert noch nie gesehen und gehört
🙏🙏🙏👍Danke
Hör dir mal die Version von Alina Bercu an ❤
Best Emperor, one of the best piano performances ever heard. This is the pianist. I am so grateful we human kind have Maestro Aimard. Thank you so much for the video.
Thank you, thank you very much hr-Sinfonieorchester, for uploading the complete concerts, do not know how grateful I am, very few orchestras upload the complete videos to UA-cam, and even rarer when it comes to top quality musicians, and this concert for me is very Special since it is my favorite, I used to believe that the Berlin Philharmonic was the best and they had no rivals, but you have changed my opinion!!
my believe is that many good orchestras like berliner or vienna have very similar performance skills, soloists and conductors are the key to a truly outstanding concert among others.
Cologne Symphony orchestra also Releases full concert and the singapore symphony also!
Oh I love this concerto so much. It’s so distinctly beethoven. So fulfilling❤️
the integrity of the performer towards the piece and richness of the Orchestra go hand in hand. love this interpretation 💙💞💙💖💙
One of the best performances I've ever heard.
Beautiful. Just beautiful.
One of my favorite Beethoven piece. Amazingly well played and great quality of both sound and video.
Thanks hr-Sinfonieorchester.
J'ai entendu cette oeuvre jouée au moins 50 fois avec une quinzaine de pianistes MAIS CELUI-CI est vraiment le plus posé-pas d'excès de vitesse ni de virtuosité de bout en bout comme chez Lang Lang et bien d'autres...Bravo!
oui certes
mais personnellement je préfère l interprétation plus féminine d Hélène GRIMAUD
@@quattro26 Votre choix est donc fait-personnel et indiscutablre!Bravo!BPrenez baucoup de plaisir à l'écouter
5:42 - 8:53
From the main theme: From a sad loss To a hopeful opportunity to a Mystic Encounter to a Child Lullaby to Big Celebration to a Time of Studying and Progress to Wild Ride with a Horse to a Dreamy Walk in the Dark Woods to a Morning Awakening and finally back to main theme xD
I just love the artist, the orchestra and the conductor...they don't just play, they talk to each other. Total dedication.💞
Wow. Superb. Such a tight connection with pianist and orchestra. Perhaps the best Emperor I've heard.Absolute clarity in every note. In the first lock down here in Australia I listened over 5 nights to 5 different pianists playing this piece and at that time Hélène Grimaud with Paavo Järvi won my heart ~but a year later, Pierre-Laurent takes Gold. Couldn't help a funny thought ~ here's the Orchestra all dressed up, white bow ties and all, but a an dressed as the Plumber walks in and steals the show :)
Das ist eine der perfektesten Liveaufnahmen dieses Konzertes, die ich kenne. Penibel bis ins Detail gearbeitet (Orchester und Solist), auch die hr-Techniker haben einen tollen Job gemacht. Allein die Spielfreude im 3. Satz scheint etwas kontrolliert-gebremst, andere wie Gulda oder Kissin lassen sich da mehr mitreißen, was speziell bei Gulda auf Kosten der Perfektion geht. Aber das ist schon Kritik auf extrem hohen Niveau - das Video sorgt (zumindest bei mir) für Freude und beglückende Momente.
1st movement
0:45 begins | 4:00 bird | 8:16 Toy Story | 15:43 | 17:06 gentle awe | 20:44 *head shake ending
2nd movement
21:35 begins | 25:52 gentle moment |
3rd movement
27:44 begins
Exquisite - and those muted strings😢
Quite a sophisticated performance of this eternal masterwork without superfluous romanticism. But it is still Beethoven!
really?... wowy... almost like they knew what they were doing, or something 🤔
@@richardcarew4708 Probably they knew. Both the soloist and the conductor are highly intelligent.
Good point. It's nice to hear performance so clear, classical in taste and fantastic balanced, so you can notice many details which are mostly hidden in bombastic-romantic versions.
The music and this performance speaks for itself. Words of superlative that I may contribute would be entirely inadequate. Highest praise for pierre-Laurent Aimard and David Afkham.
Thnak you for the sharing of this beautiful piece in its entirety
un sommet de musicalité,admiration,avec un tempo de gloire,pierre-laurent esr aimé des dieux
A great performance - technically perfect, essential and intelligent (without pretentious tricks or sinnlos Streiche), emotionally nuanced, brilliant sense of ever-dynamic yet cohesive flow of tempi, resulting in a magnificent story - from the beginning to the end. Thank you!
sure, but conductor was geat as well
@@peterectasy2957 agreed
hermosa presentación y gracias por subir los conciertos completos. Muchas otras orquestas lo suben por partes y no es lo mismo.
I am surprised in positive way, that Mr. Aimard, whom I know especially from XXth century repertoire, is playing Beethoven with such a deep understanding of this piece, including sound aspects of piano from the beginning of XIXth century familiar to composer himself.
Maravillosa la conjuncion , Pianista, Director y Sinfonica interppretando a una de las grandes creaciones de DIOS, ...Beethoven , .
q' vive en nuestra mente y ❤ ❤❤
Esto es una cena top chef para alma y corazon
Obrigado amigos e amigas musicistas!
He escuchado esta obra maestra ya no sé cuántas veces y su poder de emoción no se acaba nunca.
Extraordinaria interpretación!
Aunque hasta ahora la interpretación de Zimmerman y Bernstein es mi favorita.
Magnificent performance!
Obrigado por mais esta excelente postagem. Brilhante. Concerto para piano "Imperador" é sempre um enorme prazer ouvir.
Great recording! Many thanks!
So many thanks for your superb videos!!
Love it!!!
Un pur bonheur ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Wat 'n wonderlike uitvoering van hierdie wonderlike, musiek!
An excellent performance in an excellent video !! THANKS !!❤❤❤👏⭐💵😀🎁💰💳💴💶💸👏👏
ME GUSTA MUCHO LO DELEITÓ GRACIAS.
Superb just because of this spectacular, unpretentious rendition...
THANKS ! !❤
Diese Musik macht g,üblich.❤
Great performance! For enthusiasts of Beethoven's concertos, highly recommend Barenboim with Klemperer; the 5th ends with the Choral Fantasia sung by the John Aldis choir--which is very rare.
well done---- loved it
There is only one brand of concert pianos as far I can see,on the main scenes.This remains me of the standardition of 50/60Hz grid.
Awesome!
Just brilliant
ouf …. one of the best vraiment impressionnant quelle classe
Excellent performance! His brow is up when it's Major and down when it's Minor fun fact.
Not as photogenic as some female virtuosos, but what a performance! Superb interpretation, plus excellent video and sound.
Was that first remark really necessary?
@@wingcap1448 No, not necessary. It was supposed to be a joke. There are many young female pianists, and there are always plenty of comments on their physical looks.
My comment is not meant to derogate this excellent artist in any way.
Nothing better.
1:51 the orchestral parts begins here
참 좋습니다.
0:45 begins here
1:52 / 5:03 / 10:00 / 12:12 [2nd theme]
13:17 / 17:40
DANKE SCHÖN !👏👏👏👏
very well done
AMAZING!
Maravilla
we make beautiful music through mutual cooperation... and babies.. and all the other good things in life 😌
Peace y'all ✌☮ Namaste
favolous
fabelhaft
♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Superbe❤
Inmortal
3:04 5:21 5:49 6:20 11:28 14:42 15:09 18:37 !!! 19:31 !!! 21:36 24:50 29:23 33:23 35:23 37:27
Grossartig
I. Allegro 00:36
II. Adagio un poto moco 21:30
III. Rondo 27:52
my favorite interpretation after glenn goulds performance
listen, why is it not said where the concert is performed?
Alte Oper in Frankfurt am Main
That pianist from Shine?
Eine wunderschöne Version. Aber die von Alina Bercu gefällt mir besser.Der zweite Satz gefällt mir hier nicht so gut.
🎹🎼 👌🏼
20:00 Claude Debussy found.
0:43 Begins
A tone - poet ; our's bosom
13:59 Recap
3:00
6:48
3:19
9:18
Si no lo es yo la declaro la mayor pieza musical creada.
Para deleite de la humanidad.
Lo que aún nos quede.
E morto!
wirklich Fünftes?
Muy bien... Pero el pianista en muchas ocasiones hace un ruido, como si estuviese tartamudeando; y esto opaca la melodía... Se escucha mas fuerte en el segundo movimiento.
Lastima... Pero fantástico!!
La emoción de los músicos también es parte de la música. Es como darle vida y forma.
WHO CAN BE HIM ?
HA HA HA HA
HQ imperial music.
Благодарю Франкфуртский оркестр за великолепную музыку! Не зря у Бетховена голландские корни; его музыка отличается от уравновешенной музыки других немецких композиторов.
Hate it!!!!!
conductor looks pretty upset with his soloist. everyone has off days I guess.
Where can I hear and see you play ?
@@margots.597
I'm not even good enough to play.
But that doesn't need to prevent me from being a focused observer and commenting on what I've observed.
And again. Everyone has off days. Even if I did play, I'd be no different. I used to play baseball. And though I was a perennial all-star, I had off days too. Didn't bother me to acknowledge it.
DAMEIN:Not at all!