I was actually waiting for someone to put ciel's twin in a cosplay, although I already really like your real Ciel and how nasty he is. Both Alois and Astre now look like choir children in comparision. He just straight up tore into Alois for no reason and nearly revealed his identity to Astre. Big mistake Ciel! Even astre is thinking oh shit Alois is going to try and kill you now Ciel!
I love all of your videos with Ciel and Astere, you get Ciel's personality so well and develop Astere's responses perfectly. I wish I could find an rp partner who did Ciel as well as you do ❤️ I can't wait to see more from you!
+Ashlee Loves The name Astre comes from an art book or something where Yana was talking about naming Ciel. It was the only other name with a translation. And he's been shown a lot with starts and star symbolism. And Astre is French for star. Which fits with Ciel being French for sky.
Ah, I had it wrong when I made this. But it's most likely Astre. The name Astre comes from an art book or something where Yana was talking about naming Ciel. It was the only other name with a translation. And he's been shown a lot with starts and star symbolism. And Astre is French for star. Which fits with Ciel being French for sky.
@{Cotton Kayda} We can't say for sure, for or against the name Astre. It's just a theory and our best guess currently. For the longest time, I was convinced that they BOTH were named Ciel and that the parents did that since our Ciel was meant to be the "spare" anyways.
@@HexManiacQuinn Yea but I feel bad because OUR Ciel was the youngest son in the Phantomhive family so he didn't get that much attention like he's older brother did cause he is the "spare". He's older brother did came back but as a doll(or whatever idc bout that) so OUR Ciel still has the right to be the Earl of the Phantomhive.I'm not quite sure about that but I remember OUR Ciel turned into a demon😮
@@hidayahqistina3236 That... is in the separate continuity not just for the anime, but for the original anime storyline for season 2 before they started adapting manga chapters. Ciel becoming a demon, I mean.
Yes! That's right!! When I made this, those chapters in the manga were not out yet, and honestly I don't remember what you may be referring to in this video, but you're totally right on real Ciel's death.
I have to admit its too bad Alois doesn't exist in the manga or him and Faux Ciel could team up and distroy actual Ciel. Although why does Faux Ciel let Alois hang around in these videos? is he a bit attached to him at this point?
Honestly, I just really love expanding on Ciel's and Alois's relationship as if season two didn't happen the way it did or they got over it because Ciel could understand that they were similar, and Alois is more like a side character much like Soma or one of the boys from Weston. He annoys Ciel, but ultimately, Ciel is lonely and doesn't mind the company.
SquirrelMnkyMushroom so true. Season 2 should exist in the manga. I hated Alois at first then I started to like him. He a brat and shouldn’t act that way but he went through a lot and wants a friend
If you ever continue this you should have Alois show up and say; 'oh Astre/Ciel its been ages' Ciel or Astre; I saw you yesterday Alois 'Really? Because it feels like its been six years'
+Moonlight Princess It's all theories. And I was actually saying it wrong here. His name is most likely Astre (pronounced as-tra because French) Yana has left a lot of hints and symbolism supporting this. Astre means star, so it would fit with Ciel, which means sky.
What? I've read every chapter, and it's my understanding that Lord Sirius is not Our Ciel. His name hasn't been revealed yet. We've only got theories at this point.
@@ILovePanta123 Oh. I mean I'm into the manga and theory so I didn't know. I've only seen up to book 3, and I've never heard about the theory. Which it strange considering I go to anime club every Friday and we talk about Black Butler a lot. What do you mean it was a theory?
@@nimue5061 A twin theory. But it was confirmed. No longer a theory. When the manor was set on fire not one but two Phontomhive children went missing. But wen Astre (Our Ciel) showed up and found out his brother still missing (Missing or dead i don't know) as planed he took his brother place. He became Ciel and no body knew. Well except him of cores.
Well he always called him "Master Ciel" even wen there alone. So my guess he didn't know ether.(Or maybe he did but pretended like he didn't) And how it worked? Well they *are* identical sooo. Look that's all I can tell you. Like I said I only know what I read on comments and online debates. Sorry.
It's a Black Butler cosplay with a mash-up of characters exclusive to the anime and manga respectively - aka, manga-onlys wouldn't know Alois and anime-onlys wouldn't know the whole twin-Ciel thing.
I was actually waiting for someone to put ciel's twin in a cosplay, although I already really like your real Ciel and how nasty he is. Both Alois and Astre now look like choir children in comparision. He just straight up tore into Alois for no reason and nearly revealed his identity to Astre. Big mistake Ciel! Even astre is thinking oh shit Alois is going to try and kill you now Ciel!
His real name is Sirius its stated in the manga
He said “you stuck me for a Jim “ and I screamed!
Same
I screamed when he said that and Aster.
I think his names is James but they refer t9 him as that name
@Star Song It's actually Astre, they butchered the pronunciation
When the real ciel thought his mane was he was right. Aloise's real name is Jim
In the anime or in the reality
@@siennariyoamantiad6907 anime
*"Basically friends"*
Oh my.....
And to think that Earl Trancy would stumble upon my two Masters.
When your bf meets your bro for the first time. Also, damn is Ciel savage!
I love all of your videos with Ciel and Astere, you get Ciel's personality so well and develop Astere's responses perfectly. I wish I could find an rp partner who did Ciel as well as you do ❤️ I can't wait to see more from you!
Thank you so much!!
SquirrelMnkyMushroom It was my pleasure! I'm just speaking the truth ^^
Same here
wait wait where did you get the name Astre "ciels" name hasn't been identified yet
+Ashlee Loves The name Astre comes from an art book or something where Yana was talking about naming Ciel. It was the only other name with a translation. And he's been shown a lot with starts and star symbolism. And Astre is French for star. Which fits with Ciel being French for sky.
Is Aster OUR ciel's really name?
Ah, I had it wrong when I made this. But it's most likely Astre. The name Astre comes from an art book or something where Yana was talking about naming Ciel. It was the only other name with a translation. And he's been shown a lot with starts and star symbolism. And Astre is French for star. Which fits with Ciel being French for sky.
Okay! I’m writing a book about the twins and I wasn’t sure what to call OUR Ciel. Thanks! You helped a lot!
@{Cotton Kayda} We can't say for sure, for or against the name Astre. It's just a theory and our best guess currently. For the longest time, I was convinced that they BOTH were named Ciel and that the parents did that since our Ciel was meant to be the "spare" anyways.
@@HexManiacQuinn Yea but I feel bad because OUR Ciel was the youngest son in the Phantomhive family so he didn't get that much attention like he's older brother did cause he is the "spare". He's older brother did came back but as a doll(or whatever idc bout that) so OUR Ciel still has the right to be the Earl of the Phantomhive.I'm not quite sure about that but I remember OUR Ciel turned into a demon😮
@@hidayahqistina3236 That... is in the separate continuity not just for the anime, but for the original anime storyline for season 2 before they started adapting manga chapters. Ciel becoming a demon, I mean.
Actually it is believed that the real Ciel was killed in order to summon Sebastian for the Ciel that we now know.
Yes! That's right!! When I made this, those chapters in the manga were not out yet, and honestly I don't remember what you may be referring to in this video, but you're totally right on real Ciel's death.
@@PocketLeaves okie doki
“ he will be back “ 💙
Ciel that was so embarrassing!!! Don't do that again!!! Agh
oH hElLo chiLd
Female ciel Phantomhive jajajajaj you are so cute!
F por Alois
Part 2 please
Ciel is so SASSY
I have to admit its too bad Alois doesn't exist in the manga or him and Faux Ciel could team up and distroy actual Ciel. Although why does Faux Ciel let Alois hang around in these videos? is he a bit attached to him at this point?
Honestly, I just really love expanding on Ciel's and Alois's relationship as if season two didn't happen the way it did or they got over it because Ciel could understand that they were similar, and Alois is more like a side character much like Soma or one of the boys from Weston. He annoys Ciel, but ultimately, Ciel is lonely and doesn't mind the company.
SquirrelMnkyMushroom so true. Season 2 should exist in the manga. I hated Alois at first then I started to like him. He a brat and shouldn’t act that way but he went through a lot and wants a friend
If you ever continue this you should have Alois show up and say;
'oh Astre/Ciel its been ages'
Ciel or Astre; I saw you yesterday
Alois 'Really? Because it feels like its been six years'
youre so good istg
Aaah, thank you!
Well this is deep in a weird wayyyyy
Why am I only finding this now
I just want to see were there story goes from here
Plz make a part 2 of this plz!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
l am a big fan of you
So the twins name is aster? Did they confirm it im so confused
+Moonlight Princess It's all theories. And I was actually saying it wrong here. His name is most likely Astre (pronounced as-tra because French) Yana has left a lot of hints and symbolism supporting this. Astre means star, so it would fit with Ciel, which means sky.
i was thinking the same thing i was so confuzed because his name hasn't been conformed
Hey, where is ciel's eyepatch
This is manga Ciel (SPOILERS),
as in "our" Ciel's twin brother who he stole the identity of. Our Ciel's real name has yet to be revealed in canon.
Our ciels real name is Sirius its in the manga
What? I've read every chapter, and it's my understanding that Lord Sirius is not Our Ciel. His name hasn't been revealed yet. We've only got theories at this point.
443 like love it :)
thanks for the likes :)
What is happened😵
Twins? I'm sorry I haven't caught up on Black Butler....can someone explain..please?
It was (but not anymore) a theory. I just got these off comments and online debates. I only seen the Netflix one.
@@ILovePanta123 Oh. I mean I'm into the manga and theory so I didn't know. I've only seen up to book 3, and I've never heard about the theory. Which it strange considering I go to anime club every Friday and we talk about Black Butler a lot. What do you mean it was a theory?
@@nimue5061 A twin theory. But it was confirmed. No longer a theory. When the manor was set on fire not one but two Phontomhive children went missing. But wen Astre (Our Ciel) showed up and found out his brother still missing (Missing or dead i don't know) as planed he took his brother place. He became Ciel and no body knew. Well except him of cores.
But how does that even work? I mean what about Sebastian?
Well he always called him "Master Ciel" even wen there alone. So my guess he didn't know ether.(Or maybe he did but pretended like he didn't) And how it worked? Well they *are* identical sooo. Look that's all I can tell you. Like I said I only know what I read on comments and online debates. Sorry.
Wait is his name really Aster? I haven't been able to find his name anywhere
It was a popular fan theory. His actual name has yet to be revealed in canon though.
Wait is his name actually Aster???
No... it's just the most prevalent theory we have at the time. As of yet, our Ciel's name is unconfirmed.
WTF IS THIS
It's a Black Butler cosplay with a mash-up of characters exclusive to the anime and manga respectively - aka, manga-onlys wouldn't know Alois and anime-onlys wouldn't know the whole twin-Ciel thing.