THE FIVE BIGGEST RULE CHANGE BACKFIRES

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • Do you know what the Cobra Effect is? It is an anecdotal example of how a solution that was implemented made a problem much, much worse. It happens too in sports.
    Can we get 10000000 likes?
    My Patreon: / fivepointsvids
    Follow me twitter: / fivepointsvids
    Don't forget to like my page on Facebook:
    / fivepointsgaming
    I would very much like it if you subscribed for my somewhat funny sports videos.
    This video is about rule changes in sports that made the problem worse and features the NBA, the NFL and FIFA

КОМЕНТАРІ • 372

  • @MrCubFan415
    @MrCubFan415 6 років тому +19

    Biggest cobra effect: NFL’s new “roughing the passer” rule

  • @JonSmith-hk1bq
    @JonSmith-hk1bq 6 років тому +38

    You missed a big one with the NHL's crease rule change in 98-99. First, it was a solution in search of a problem from its inception. It caused several goals during the season to be disallowed for no competitive reason. Then the NHL had the bad luck of it NOT being called when Brett Hull scored a Stanley Cup-winning goal in triple overtime (that they didn't even bother to review) and having that series tainted forever. That was a complete botch from beginning to end.

    • @henrythehappyoctopus
      @henrythehappyoctopus 6 років тому

      THANK YOU for mentioning this

    • @Flabberjacks
      @Flabberjacks 5 років тому

      im a little late but i think they seen/knew what happened but how do you call a goal back like that?

    • @JedForge
      @JedForge 5 років тому

      Hey at least it generated a very funny commercial as a promotional for the following season! ;)

    • @Humbilly
      @Humbilly 5 років тому

      The original rule change process started in about 1991. Before the season, Bettman sent out a memo.
      It cleared up the issue, but so few people were aware of it that even the commentators were wondering why it wasn’t reviewed.
      Bettman couldn’t get out of the Arena, and Buffalo, fast enough.

    • @BronchoKyle
      @BronchoKyle 5 років тому

      Dallas Stars 1999 Stanley Cup Champs 😁😁😁

  • @TeemoOneTrick
    @TeemoOneTrick 6 років тому +67

    Are we just gonna ignore that he said sudden deaf not sudden death

  • @robertleite6650
    @robertleite6650 6 років тому +91

    That's what happened in OKC. The snake breeder raised KD and then released him into the wild, creating a bigger problem.

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому +11

      LOL

    • @sushirs6770
      @sushirs6770 6 років тому +2

      Robert Leite LOL

    • @jimbo-fk4dq
      @jimbo-fk4dq 6 років тому +5

      KD is just chasing rings, like Sonic, because he misses Seattle... Too soon?

    • @stpbasss3773
      @stpbasss3773 5 років тому

      @@jimbo-fk4dq what does Seattle have to do with rings or anything

    • @jimbo-fk4dq
      @jimbo-fk4dq 5 років тому

      @@stpbasss3773 KD started with the Seattle Supersonics, before they'd eventually move to OKC and become the Thunder.
      I think the joke went over your head.

  • @haiksimitian5755
    @haiksimitian5755 6 років тому +8

    I lost it when I saw Donald Sterling.😂

  • @thegoodtony3339
    @thegoodtony3339 6 років тому +19

    This video was all the classic funny shit I expect from this channel!

  • @wadehiers
    @wadehiers 6 років тому +2

    you missed one major league backfire in the MLB. in 2014, coinciding with the expansion of the instant replay rules, MLB made a change to the rules defining what is a caught baseball and what is not. The new rule stated that for a ball to be ruled as a catch (either a fly ball caught as an out, or a thrown ball caught with a foot on a base for a force out), the ball must be cleanly transferred to the throwing hand. Under this rule, if a first baseman bobbles the ball transferring to his throwing hand, EVEN IF it does not fall to the ground, then the ball is not considered secured or caught. This rule had numerous instances where it broke the game in the first few weeks of the 2014 season that prompted MLB to fix it by the end of April that same season.
    The example that comes to mind for me was the Texas Rangers playing the Mariners, Mariners at bat, bases loaded, ball is hit to pitcher, pitchers throws home for the force out at the plate. Catcher cleanly catches the ball with his foot on the plate, and transfers to throw to 1st for the double play. He bobbles the transfer and chooses not to throw. The Mariners challenge the out call at the plate and won that challenge.

  • @jimbo-fk4dq
    @jimbo-fk4dq 6 років тому +8

    To be fair, Mozgov deserves his contract. Not because he is that great or brings that much value to a team, but it softens the blow of Blake Griffin cupping the back of his head.

  • @leelantern805
    @leelantern805 6 років тому +29

    the nba is a joke, don't know why fans in 90% of the markets bother watching at all. sad I use to love watching basketball

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому +10

      The game is tight. The league is not.

    • @altpersonas
      @altpersonas 6 років тому +2

      FivePoints Vids college basketball > NBA tbh

    • @iron1349
      @iron1349 6 років тому

      Makes me glad St . Louis doesn't have am NBA team

    • @CONSOLETRUTH2
      @CONSOLETRUTH2 6 років тому +2

      I could give you a reason such as its a simple game that doesnt take a lot of smarts to play and it values FLASH/STYLE over substance but then I would get run out of this thread and called a possible racist. So you can probably guess as to why basketball/NBA is so popular.
      I will say, as someone already pointed out, college ball is far superior to the NBA in every way. I mean we finally saw a 16 not only beat a 1 but the OVERALL NUMBER 1 of the tournament. Plus in college in the post season, if you choose style over substance all the time you will be bounced pretty quickly.

    • @CONSOLETRUTH2
      @CONSOLETRUTH2 6 років тому

      @@iron1349 i live in Vegas and there has been some talk of trying to get an NBA team here after how well our NHL team did but most locals dont want an MBA team and when people ask me why I tell them to look up news stories of the 2007 NBA All Star game/weekend and what a cluster fuckmthat was and how horrible the "fans" were/acred here in Vegas as ut was held here that year.

  • @LordBitememan
    @LordBitememan 6 років тому +59

    Future entry: the NHL's expanded draft lottery for the top 3 picks. So the worst team in the league can actually drop to the 4th overall pick now. That wouldn't be a problem if teams were tanking like crazy, but they've stopped tanking now. And it's not a hypothetical either, Colorado didn't tank but dropped to 4th in 2017. Meanwhile Philadelphia, a team nearly emerged from its rebuild, got a player at #2 that had been projected at one point to go first overall. Ottawa lost out on a #2 pick to Carolina in 2018. And just wait till a contender with an injured superstar barely misses the playoffs and lands a generational player.
    Which means that bad teams are going to stay perennially bad, and will be stuck year in year out moving good but not great players at the trade deadline because nothing ever seems to come together.

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому +5

      Good point

    • @calciofan2012
      @calciofan2012 6 років тому +4

      LordBitememan boohoo, its a sport, its competitive. Why should the losers be rewarded in the first place? If your team sucks, get better management. Many teams have proved that they could stay competitive without high draft picks and others have been bad even while having several 1st overall picks (Edmonton)

    • @LordBitememan
      @LordBitememan 6 років тому +10

      "Many teams have proved that they could stay competitive without high draft picks"
      The Stanley Cup winners since the lockout:
      Carolina Hurricanes: Eric Staal, 2nd overall, 2003, Andrew Ladd, 4th overall, 2004.
      Anaheim Ducks: None of Note
      Detroit Red Wings: None of Note
      Pittsburgh Penguins: Marc Andre Fleury, 1st overall, 2003, Evgeni Malkin, 2nd overall, 2004, Sidney Crosby, 1st overall, 2005, Jordan Staal, 2nd overall, 2006
      Chicago Blackhawks: Jonathan Toews, 3rd overall, 2006, Patrick Kane, 1st overall, 2007
      Boston Bruins: Tyler Seguin, 2nd overall, 2010
      LA Kings: Drew Doughty, 2nd overall, 2008
      Washington Capitals: Alexander Ovechkin, 1st overall, 2004, Nicklas Backstrom, 4th overall, 2006.
      Literally only two teams managed to win a Cup in the salary cap era without at least one top five pick on their roster. And that was at the beginning of the era. Since then the teams winning the most were the ones with multiple top five picks on their roster, and with 2015, 16, 17, and 18 being won by Chicago, Pittsburgh twice, and Washington now, there hasn't been a team with only a single top five pick winning the Cup since LA did it in 2014.
      Everyone loves to talk about Edmonton's woes as if it someone negates the fact that we're literally watching top five draft picks hoist the Cup every year. Here's the reality of Edmonton's situation: they got really lucky at the unluckiest time to do so. Taylor Hall was a quality pick, but not the franchise player he was billed as. Other than Seguin the next picks in that top five were Gudbranson to Florida, Ryan Johansen to Columbus, and Nino Niederreitter to the Islanders. None of those players are with those teams today. That indicates that Hall and Seguin were the class of a fairly shallow draft. In other words, you weren't pulling generational players like Crosby, Kane, and Ovi out of 2010. And that was the good year for Edmonton. In 2011 they got the windfall of. . . Ryan Nugent Hopkins, a player who has never put up more than 25 goals or 56 points. That's a first overall. After that you had Landeskog, who didn't turn the fortunes in Colorado around either, Huberdeau is also a serviceable player, but Florida is the Barkov show now, the Devils turned Adam Larsson into trade bait, and Ryan Strome didn't materialize into anything in New York either. In 2012 they were blessed to land the services of Nail Yakupov. . . who plays in the KHL today. And down the list you got, human bandaid Ryan Murray in Columbus, Alex Galchenyuk to the Habs who at least hit 30 goals once, Griffin Reinhart to the Islanders with his all of 2 assists in 37 games, and Morgan Rielly to the Leafs, so there's one that panned out.
      The point of that exercise is look at those 2-5 picks in those years. Some were serviceable players, sure. But there's no Eric Staal there, no Jonathan Toews, or Evgeni Malkin, or Drew Doughty, or Nicklas Backstrom. Edmonton couldn't make hay out of some very bad draft years where nobody at the top was reversing course. Edmonton lands McDavid in the 2015 draft, after a rookie season they make the playoffs and even advance to the second round. Toronto gets Auston Matthews in 2016, suddenly they're on the way up, making the playoffs, looking like a force to be reckoned with. Winnipeg lands Laine at #2 the same year, and in the 2018 playoffs they're a conference finalist. The Devils land Hischier in 2018, suddenly they're back in the playoffs. Some draft years are better than others. Some top picks are game-changers and some are just supporting cast or outright busts. It doesn't change the fact that this is a build through the draft league, and the importance of that has only grown over time in the cap era.

    • @aramondehasashi3324
      @aramondehasashi3324 6 років тому

      Bitememan - What system would you like to see?

    • @LordBitememan
      @LordBitememan 6 років тому

      Aramonde Hasashi- Return to the limited lottery system, where only the first overall was in play and teams could only rise so many spots if they won it. That way the teams that most need the help are the only ones in serious contention for the top pick, and teams losing the lottery can still get access to talent you can eventually contend with.

  • @bl2809
    @bl2809 6 років тому +20

    The “Buster Posey” rule can’t block the plate

    • @stevenb.7926
      @stevenb.7926 6 років тому

      Brian Lightell ask ray fossee how that worked out for him.

    • @bl2809
      @bl2809 6 років тому

      But that's completely different tho. That was in the All Star Game so it was meaningless game so I would definitely guess that Ray wouldn't expect Rose to treat it like Game 7 of the World Series. And that rule is completely useless bc it was made to help catchers so they wouldn't get hurt as much but now they can't block the plate even if the runner will out by 50 feet.

    • @mattschumacher4581
      @mattschumacher4581 6 років тому

      Brian Lightell I think the rule has gotten better now that everyone understands it. And I think it’s made for some interesting plays at the plate like interesting slides and even jumping over the catcher.

  • @asd36f
    @asd36f 6 років тому +1

    The unlimited interchange rule in the Australian Football League. There have been complaints that the game is becoming ugly, due to congestion around the ball, leading to less free-flowing football. By having less interchanges, players will get fatigued, which will open up the game, and lead to higher scores and more attractive football.

  • @coltino99
    @coltino99 5 років тому +3

    How bout the CFL adding illegal contact as something you can challenge? When you change the rule mid season to fix it, you know it was bad.

  • @darkhawk4863
    @darkhawk4863 5 років тому +1

    I object: The NBA doesn't have a salary cap; it has a suggestion that you're free to break in a variety of ways. It's how Golden State intends to keep the league uninteresting and unwatchable for as long as possible: they've already stated "no one is going to outspend us". Thanks for the heads up, guess I don't have to worry about trying to figure out what's a foul and what isn't, since it won't matter.

  • @elliottryan13
    @elliottryan13 6 років тому +20

    The Catch Rule...pffff. I'm just gonna stop there.

  • @richspeck8932
    @richspeck8932 3 роки тому +1

    Instant reply in every sport has made things worse. It's used for situations it was never meant for and stops the game for way too long

  • @kirankagal
    @kirankagal 6 років тому +17

    Hell year those are my mavs!! That one championship will satisfy me for another few years until the warriors don’t own the league

  • @NJGuy1973
    @NJGuy1973 6 років тому +2

    "Major League Baseball has occasionally increased or reduced the size of the strike zone in an attempt to control the balance of power between pitchers and hitters. After the record home run year by Roger Maris in 1961, the major leagues increased the size of the strike zone from the top of the batter's shoulders to the bottom of his knees. In 1968, pitchers such as Denny McLain and Bob Gibson among others dominated hitters, producing 339 shutouts. Carl Yastrzemski would be the only American League hitter to finish the season with a batting average higher than .300. In the National League, Gibson posted a 1.12 earned run average, the lowest in 54 years, while Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Don Drysdale threw a record 58 and two-thirds consecutive scoreless innings during the 1968 season. As a result of the dropping offensive statistics, Major League Baseball took steps to reduce the advantage held by pitchers by lowering the height of the pitcher's mound from 15 inches to 10 inches, and by reducing the size of the strike zone for the 1969 season."
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strike_zone

    • @JayTemple
      @JayTemple 6 років тому +1

      The Designated Hitter was added because AL teams weren't selling enough tickets. The idea was that making every spot in the line-up a nominally capable hitter would sell. It did well enough to infest the rest of baseball except the NL. So, indirectly, we have Drysdale and Gibson, among others, to thank for the DH.

    • @NJGuy1973
      @NJGuy1973 6 років тому

      Yes, attendance was the most cited reason, even at the time.
      "Among the … hovering anxieties is the deepening disparity in quality and attendance between the two major leagues. Last year’s record total attendance did not conceal the fact that the National League outdrew the American by nearly five and a half million customers… The gap is widening this year… The difference between the leagues in quality and attractiveness of play is harder to prove, but it can be suggested: so far this spring, National League batters have hit over one hundred more home runs than their American League counterparts." - Roger Angell, The New Yorker, June 1972
      www.fangraphs.com/tht/a-tale-of-two-leagues-part-two-1956-2003/

  • @Paulafan5
    @Paulafan5 6 років тому +1

    The solution to tanking is that every team that misses the playoffs has an equal chance and have a wins (or points) system where if you don't meet certain standards you don't get full revenue sharing. Philly should not be rewarded for "allegedly" tanking for a bunch of seasons and now having a pretty good young line-up.

    • @felixmartinez9673
      @felixmartinez9673 5 років тому

      they can excuse with the injuries of Embiid, Simmons and so on, but even then, is still not a good excuse

  • @MrConverse
    @MrConverse 6 років тому +8

    Jesse James caught that ball.

    • @Edward_Nebiolo
      @Edward_Nebiolo 3 роки тому +1

      I was at that game and I really wanted to punch the refs with brass knuckles after the reversed the call

  • @a.arnold1413
    @a.arnold1413 6 років тому +39

    Biggest cobra effect of all time Cleveland bringing the Browns back

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому +4

      Hahahahahhaha

    • @tomlovin8931
      @tomlovin8931 6 років тому +1

      I agree. That team is called the Browns, but they are not the Browns.

  • @andrecurtis6625
    @andrecurtis6625 6 років тому +8

    Sudden Deaf????🤔🤔🤔
    Sudden Death???😀😀😀

  • @andrewwinslow9315
    @andrewwinslow9315 6 років тому +103

    Caution clock in NASCAR

    • @chucksneed1807
      @chucksneed1807 6 років тому +26

      Andrew Winslow Nascar would have it's own video, that's how much they fucked up

    • @andrewwinslow9315
      @andrewwinslow9315 6 років тому +8

      Yes 2 Jericho true. Brian France is up with Goodell and Bettman for worst Commissioners in sports. He's a fucking joke.

    • @alexmorris6954
      @alexmorris6954 6 років тому +6

      Andrew Winslow what about segmented racing?

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому +7

      Thats a good one damn

    • @98doom
      @98doom 6 років тому

      God I hate those

  • @elhonYT
    @elhonYT 6 років тому +9

    Why even watch the NBA

  • @wowantonlavey
    @wowantonlavey 6 років тому +1

    Best draft lotto/movement moments of all time. Biggest falls, rises, of course the great coin flip between the suns and the bucks.

  • @hawker7488
    @hawker7488 6 років тому +8

    Lead Story: The NFL has announced that the 'Wheel of Discipline' will be replaced.
    With a dart board.

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому

      Lol quite true

    • @jaewok5G
      @jaewok5G 6 років тому

      a live beheaded chicken

    • @ZhangtheGreat
      @ZhangtheGreat 6 років тому +1

      Player caught with a gram of pot
      *throws dart* Suspended for the season
      Player caught beating his significant other
      *throws dart* $200 fine

  • @nictipton1413
    @nictipton1413 6 років тому +2

    Kneeling against the flag should be punished.

  • @MrTuska567
    @MrTuska567 6 років тому +1

    2:29 Sudden Deaf lmao

  • @littleshrimpmafia5352
    @littleshrimpmafia5352 6 років тому

    Yo Wasup man this channel is dope u and tree r my favorite you tubers

  • @Nickleblanc41
    @Nickleblanc41 6 років тому +9

    FIFA: Players purposely run try the clock in extra time let’s just eliminate the golden goal rule.
    Random guy in the room: About we just play until someone scores
    FIFA: No that makes too much since.
    You can also replace FIFA with IIHF

    • @bondjames8225
      @bondjames8225 6 років тому +3

      The flaw in that is that a lot of these teams are playing two or three matches every ten days or so once champions league and domestic cups start. If two teams are very evenly matched and play for lets say, three and a half hours before someone finally scores, Both teams are sitting ducks for their next two matches at least.

    • @Nickleblanc41
      @Nickleblanc41 6 років тому +1

      bond james easy just allow for unlimited substitutions and to players to reenter the game in extra time

    • @Maenfy
      @Maenfy 6 років тому +1

      Nick Leblanc Who wants to see a 8 hours football game? Football isn't Tennis.

    • @Nickleblanc41
      @Nickleblanc41 6 років тому +1

      Mani 1610 Id rather see that then a shootout

    • @Colin-ut6cm
      @Colin-ut6cm 6 років тому

      Nick Leblanc football (soccer) fans dont want that american type shit were unlimited subs, golden goal and multiple overtimes are allowed

  • @ryanbranigan231
    @ryanbranigan231 6 років тому +54

    Nfl player Caught smoking Weed- suspended 4 games, plus heavy fines, do it again it's half a season, once more an entire season.
    NFL player charged with beating their wife/girlfriend (not on tape) and found guilty: suspended 10 games...
    Great example your setting NFL!
    #GoodbyeGoodell

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому +14

      2 games for knocking out your wife in elevator

    • @ryanbranigan231
      @ryanbranigan231 6 років тому +2

      FivePoints Vids did I mention it's *legal* in four states and all of canadia

    • @jaewok5G
      @jaewok5G 6 років тому +2

      buying a new cell phone - 4 games

    • @ryanbranigan231
      @ryanbranigan231 6 років тому

      Tristan MacLeod 'in Stephen A Smith's voice' THA WEEEEED

    • @firebreather-ur2nn
      @firebreather-ur2nn 6 років тому +3

      And apparently allegedly deflating footballs is worse than knocking out your wife in elevator

  • @SirDupree
    @SirDupree 3 роки тому +1

    Getting rid of the 3 point shot in Slam Ball.
    Slam Ball was a fun dumb sport about basketball with trampolines. I watched it because I thought it sounded stupid but I ended up enjoying it. In the second season to increase the number of dunks they got rid of the 3 point line. This actually made less dunks because without the 3 point shot to contend all the players just focused on stopping dunks. It completely ruined the silly sport.

  • @Edward_Nebiolo
    @Edward_Nebiolo 3 роки тому +1

    Tanking is a problem in the NFL

  • @chrism7574
    @chrism7574 5 років тому

    The golden goal rule had a simple solution, no penalty option at the end of an extra time period. Make it where your team has to score eventually or your opponent has to score eventually. If you just want to sit back and defend and make no effort going forward, eventually the other team will.

  • @Pb-ij4ip
    @Pb-ij4ip 6 років тому

    What the blazes is going on here!? I came here for a sports video and I get a history lesson!...that’s actually pretty cool.

  • @joshmorris6572
    @joshmorris6572 6 років тому

    The instigator rule in the NHL. It was put into place to protect people from fights but it just allows people to run at the young stars in the game.

    • @Paulafan5
      @Paulafan5 6 років тому

      Not really. You take a run at a star and you get suspended these days. You don't need goons in the game if you suspend players for taking cheap shots at stars.

  • @bundesautobahn7
    @bundesautobahn7 4 роки тому

    The first golden goal (I prefer to call it sudden death) in soccer (on a senior team level) was in Euro '96. It was a very lucky walkoff goal that won Germany that tourney.

  • @richspeck8932
    @richspeck8932 3 роки тому

    Hiring a former crack dealer as his minister of social justice is just another excellent idea that will go down in Goodell's regime

  • @coast2coast00
    @coast2coast00 6 років тому +1

    The 2016 qualifying change in F1.
    Years ago qualifying was just an hour or so session where the fastest lap you ran would set your grid position. This was a problem because if someone was clearly fastest they could do one lap and then just wait out the clock, leading to not many cars running.
    They changed up qualifying into 3 sessions, in the first 2 a number of the slowest drivers would be eliminated, with the faster drivers moving on to set new times to set the grid. This was good because even with clearly the fastest car a driver would have to do 3 separate runs, so there was always cars on track.
    In 2016 they decided to get more cars on track, instead of having the bottom number of cars eliminated in a session, they would be eliminated during the first 2 sessions, one by one every 90 seconds, and in the last session cars would be eliminated every 90 seconds, until it was just the final 2 fighting for pole. This failed to work because fast drivers who get blocked or make a mistake have no second chance and get eliminated right away. In a normal session the track gets faster and faster with more cars running (up to a second faster over 15 minutes) so all the cars wait til the last moment to put in their final best lap, but with cars being eliminated the track didn't evolve, and worse with the competition being eliminated, there was no reason for the fastest time to be afraid of loosing their position and everyone just sat in the garage and waited out the clock, with less action on track then ever before.
    After the first session, which ended with the exciting conclusion of one driver talking with his team on the pit wall, and the other getting weighed in the official's garage they changed back to the previous qualifying format.

  • @Sprrtan
    @Sprrtan 6 років тому

    Goodell is like that one teacher you had where you could kill someone in the middle of class and only get a warning.

  • @Gucesarl
    @Gucesarl 5 років тому

    4b. The Silver Goal
    For those that thought the golden goal was too harsh, the UEFA Euro 2004 came with an update: the silver goal. After the first half of OT, if a team end up leading, they would be declared winner. It solved? Nope. It actually met the worst possible scenario in the semifinal between Greece and Czech Republic, when the centerback Traianos Dellas scored the winning goal during stoppage time. It was abandoned right after the end of the tournament.

    • @psykkomancz
      @psykkomancz 5 років тому +1

      Yep this nonsense cost us gold medal :(

  • @romang.6978
    @romang.6978 6 років тому

    First golden goal was in 1996, by Oliver Bierhoff for Germany against the Czech Republic in the 1996 European Championship Final

  • @FOnewmike
    @FOnewmike 6 років тому

    All my favorite UA-camrs (including you) have uploaded today thanks for the awesome Wednesday FivePoints :)

  • @ryanpacatte6054
    @ryanpacatte6054 6 років тому +1

    One that I would have on here is how the mlb replay has turned into teams challenge players barely sliding or popping off the bag

  • @danielrobertson7821
    @danielrobertson7821 6 років тому +1

    Don’t make me say it. You already know my skate is in the crease on this one...Great vid!!!!

  • @nyquilljornan2004
    @nyquilljornan2004 6 років тому

    These rules backfired harder than Lions booth reviews

  • @gravityguy9545
    @gravityguy9545 6 років тому

    Your channel is awesome! You earn my sub and like.

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому

      Thanks man !

    • @gravityguy9545
      @gravityguy9545 6 років тому

      FivePoints Vids Don’t know if you’ve done a video on this, but maybe try the top 5 upsets in sports history and explain why they lost.

  • @Lcky-gu2gi
    @Lcky-gu2gi 2 роки тому

    "If it aint broke dont fix it" thats what happens when bored rich people got nothing better to do than ruin things thats already perfect

  • @mrmacross
    @mrmacross 5 років тому

    The lottery is a good example of multiple Cobra effects. Perhaps it's more accurate to say it was a series of one knee-jerk reaction after another. First they thought it was too awful to watch teams lose on purpose, so they put in a lotto. Then they decided that giving non-playoff teams shouldn't have equal probabilities, so they weighted it in favor of the worst teams. Then Orlando won back-to-back lottos, the second of which they had only a 1/66 chance of winning, so they stacked the odds more in favor of the really bad teams. All these re-adjustments has made it more advantageous to tank, so they had to revise the lotto yet again.
    I think the lotto is a decent idea in principle, but a lot of teams have found ways to use the lotto rules as justification to lose on purpose. Whatever problems it solves seems to be negated by new issues it introduces.

  • @bmoose566
    @bmoose566 5 років тому

    Baseball is a sport where the draft doesn't really do a whole lot for teams anyway it's just to stack the farm systems

  • @MusicalGixxer
    @MusicalGixxer 6 років тому

    Damn you always make me laugh, Five 😂

  • @mattmirelez5121
    @mattmirelez5121 3 роки тому

    Unfortunately we see the golden goal thing happening in the NHL as well. I can't tell you how many times I've watched an overtime and there might've been 2 or 3 shots on goal combined

  • @deadphoenix5678
    @deadphoenix5678 6 років тому

    The reformulation of the handball ruel in soccer. They tried to make the game more fair, but with formulations like "enlarging the size of your body", "natural potitioning of the arm", "movement towards the ball" and "too short distance to react" they confused the shit out of players, viewers and refs, who then seemingly randomly decided one way or the other. Also that is why sometimes defenders challenge offensive players keeping their hands behind the back - they are just making sure they don't intentionally touch the ball.
    Another soccer rule could be the video refferree - I really like the idea of more fairness to the game, but when they call out the players of both teams in the midst or the halftimebreak forcing some of them to leave the toilet (no joke, that really happened last season in germany) because the videorefferee decided that there was a foul worthing a penalty 7 (!) minutes ago and that the penalty has to be taken immediatly despite being the halftime break, you know something isn't right.

  • @CONSOLETRUTH2
    @CONSOLETRUTH2 6 років тому

    The NFL does the draft right. Team with worst record gets the higher pick unless like a 9-7 Giants team which would be around like maybe 17 or 18 normally, makes the playoffs and wins the super bowl which means they pick last.

  • @Jasel71
    @Jasel71 3 роки тому

    ---"making a football move...bitch"!!!!---
    1999 NFL Catch Rule

  • @chrisguardiano6143
    @chrisguardiano6143 4 роки тому

    The Golden Goal is still used in college and high school soccer although that might be changing for this upcoming season

  • @94nolo
    @94nolo 6 років тому +1

    NBA made the Sixers hire Bryan Colangelo, which caused Sam Hinkie to leave.
    Whoops. That backfired.

  • @TheGodfather441
    @TheGodfather441 6 років тому

    it's always a good day when fivepoints uploads

  • @dappurdudz
    @dappurdudz 6 років тому +1

    Welp we all know where this is going w/ the NFL

    • @dappurdudz
      @dappurdudz 6 років тому

      3:18 HAHAH THAT PHOTO i’m a packer fan; that sucks

  • @citizendeuce5889
    @citizendeuce5889 6 років тому

    We know what the real rule change that backfired for the NFL is, its name is Goodell. It also doesn't help that he cares more about the anthem than y'know anything that matters more than it

  • @spike852
    @spike852 6 років тому

    Love the vids man.
    The salary cap is the reason I don't watch the NBA. It's probably pretty entertaining, but when 26 teams can't ever be good enough to win it all, what's the point?

    • @Paulafan5
      @Paulafan5 6 років тому

      Small market teams have to spend more to get a free agent and as a result don't have the cap space to sign anyone else. The Raptors had the second best record in the NBA last season, but they can't attract a good free agent.

  • @okrajoe
    @okrajoe 6 років тому +1

    Salary caps stink - agree with that one.

  • @lilkris3008
    @lilkris3008 6 років тому

    F1 wanted more pit stops so they made Pirelli make tires that degrade faster... so the teams just drive slower and still pit the same

  • @deitznuts3306
    @deitznuts3306 5 років тому +1

    Bro if the instigator rule isn’t on here

  • @donaldjones9830
    @donaldjones9830 5 років тому +1

    Great video. Agree with all

  • @danielschell7177
    @danielschell7177 6 років тому

    Get that Cheddar today this video brought to you by Fan Duel

  • @kurumauzamaki2731
    @kurumauzamaki2731 6 років тому +7

    Definitely the home plate collision rule it’s like the football catch don’t know what is and isn’t interference

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому

      True but collisions have been reduced as a result

    • @kurumauzamaki2731
      @kurumauzamaki2731 6 років тому

      FivePoints Vids I didn’t mean the actual collision but like the one in Miami where Stanton threw someone out but he was called safe because of the rule

    • @Paulafan5
      @Paulafan5 6 років тому

      I'd rather a couple iffy calls than to watch someone horrible break a leg or end a guy's career. Pete Rose basically ended a guy's career in the all-star game running him over. It ain't football; it's baseball... We don't need home plate collisions.

  • @16ktsgamma
    @16ktsgamma 6 років тому

    Goodell punishments are the worst punishment known all around.

  • @JonxNgo
    @JonxNgo 6 років тому

    It's still suspect that the NBA lotto is done behind closed doors...

  • @georgemihaileanu8031
    @georgemihaileanu8031 6 років тому +2

    Sudden death not sudden deaf

  • @FooBarr1
    @FooBarr1 6 років тому

    the original MLB walk rule was created to force pitchers to pitch to the batter by penalizing them for avoiding him. It immediately became a defensive weapon and has remained one to this day.

    • @JayTemple
      @JayTemple 6 років тому

      ^^ This. I loathe the Designated Hitter rule, but the no-pitch IBB is worse. The DH changes the probability of various outcomes, but they're all still there. The no-pitch IBB actually removes some outcomes, like the one you said.

  • @pendejo6466
    @pendejo6466 6 років тому

    Why should the NFL punish players and intervene in situations for the court to decide? I'm talking about before players are charged and convicted.

  • @andressoto7340
    @andressoto7340 4 роки тому

    The first goleen goal was actually scored in 1996 in the European Cup.

  • @k1llez4fun65
    @k1llez4fun65 6 років тому

    The NHL draft lottery works really well (let’s ignore the Oilers for a second) and there weren’t a lot of teams purposely tanking (again, ignore the Oilers)

    • @Paulafan5
      @Paulafan5 6 років тому

      Oilers didn't tank, unlike the Penguins did for Mario. They just had the worst front office ever and the fact the 1st overall picks were duds (ie Yakopov and Nugent-Hopkins).

    • @k1llez4fun65
      @k1llez4fun65 6 років тому

      Paulafan5 they had like 4 #1 picks in 6 years

  • @davidgeier6365
    @davidgeier6365 4 роки тому +1

    If you kneel for the flag there should be punishment, I mean come on.

  • @K37-h1z
    @K37-h1z 6 років тому

    A recap of all 4 home run games

  • @zachmcphail1256
    @zachmcphail1256 6 років тому

    Keep up the good work

  • @FrancisSims
    @FrancisSims 6 років тому

    The catch rule didn't benefit the Patriots, they lost due to 2 controversial TD catches not going their way

  • @BeastOfMetal1989
    @BeastOfMetal1989 6 років тому

    I feel like the safety rules in the NFL are headed this way, too. Restrictions on how you can tackle lead to more awkward body positions, which may yet cause more injuries like Shazier's back breaker last year.

    • @FivePointsVids
      @FivePointsVids  6 років тому

      I actually have a few ideas on that, might do a vid on it

    • @BeastOfMetal1989
      @BeastOfMetal1989 6 років тому

      @@FivePointsVids I would definitely be on the lookout for it.

  • @wilhelmheinrich7502
    @wilhelmheinrich7502 6 років тому

    The 1979 NFL rule changes is my pick.

  • @Qball42
    @Qball42 6 років тому

    So what should the NBA do? Put in a hard salary cap or break it wide open like baseball? I know I want a hard salary cap but I imagine I am part of the minority.

  • @sharpperfect4984
    @sharpperfect4984 6 років тому

    Why cant the nfl give refs more judgment opertunities. The issue is the NFL is so afraid to give refs judgement opportunities, so they go out and make these very specific rules. Thats fine, until you realize not every play is the same. Why cant the NFL rule be “If it looks like a catch in real time, (replay allowed but in real time) then its a catch.” The refs arent stupid. They can look at it themselves, and determine what a catch is. They dont need specific guidelines. And if some refs abuse or just make multiple bad calls, then the NFL should fire them.

  • @HighCharityYT
    @HighCharityYT 6 років тому

    Goalie Interference in the NHL. Seriously. What the fuck is it supposed to be.

  • @pnessi570
    @pnessi570 6 років тому

    Ive gotten seven notifications from yahoo sports in the last month. 1 was for winbledon. The other 6 were for developments in the breaking news story of people fucking kneeling.

  • @Lava1964
    @Lava1964 6 років тому

    No teams tank in European sports leagues because the worst teams don't get rewarded--they get relegated.

    • @romiarkan450
      @romiarkan450 5 років тому

      +Cold Snap The USA is a big country. I think it's more to the fact that getting relegated would be bad for business. A lot of those relegated teams often can't sell as many tickets after they get relegated.

  • @maxcrss2845
    @maxcrss2845 6 років тому

    Haha Mavs got in on the action! :D

  • @mayohayo5974
    @mayohayo5974 6 років тому +22

    you should make a video about 5 athletes who are terrible at ring chasing ex. shaq, charles barkley etc.

    • @ryanbranigan231
      @ryanbranigan231 6 років тому +1

      Mayo Hayo Iginla

    • @jok3r906
      @jok3r906 6 років тому

      Mayo Hayo CP3

    • @nohbuddy1
      @nohbuddy1 6 років тому +5

      Shaq? He has four

    • @chrisbard8656
      @chrisbard8656 6 років тому +1

      Mayo Hayo Shaq wasn't ring chasing he was fat and old and he just went to a team who wanted him

    • @mayohayo5974
      @mayohayo5974 6 років тому

      AmericanNohbuddy ™ but after he left the heat he continuously went to teams who were at the top of their conferences

  • @YeeSoest
    @YeeSoest 6 років тому +2

    Soccer fans are calling for the Golden Goal to return, though!
    Not in a final but those quarter finals can use less penalties and more drama and YES, today's football is vastly different, teams wouldn't defend with 11 men !

    • @SyntaxButthole
      @SyntaxButthole 6 років тому +1

      I don't get what people don't like about a shootout, as a non-soccer fan I think it's the only really exciting part of the game.

    • @bondjames8225
      @bondjames8225 6 років тому +3

      As a soccer fan, the shootout sucks because its not playing football (soccer) its like a weird mini game outside of the match. Its essentially a coinflip and doesn't resemble the actual sport they played to get there. I see the shootout as an ugly, flawed, necessity.

    • @christianholbrook2686
      @christianholbrook2686 5 років тому

      Just play overtime, like every other freaking sport.

  • @MadAnthonyToronado
    @MadAnthonyToronado 4 роки тому

    Body in the basement? I need more information on that!

  • @eddixon2015
    @eddixon2015 6 років тому

    Anybody else feel like the NBA seems to have a ton of overlooked systemic issues?

    • @Paulafan5
      @Paulafan5 6 років тому +1

      They have the worst officiating by far of any pro league. And I never hear anyone in the NBA address it.

  • @kyleschofield5704
    @kyleschofield5704 6 років тому

    Jesse James caught that ball

  • @hatred8894
    @hatred8894 6 років тому

    The over time line NASCAR

  • @dsc4178
    @dsc4178 6 років тому

    One: if all there was to win the game was a golden goal, play to a winner like hockey playoffs, no team would play to tie because who wants to be on the pitch for 12 hours?
    Two: what about the NCAA rule that said if anyone was fouled with the ball it was 2 shots. Within a week teams simply fouled the worst player on the floor since it was 2 shots anyway. In a month they trashed the rule.

  • @basketballaddict2885
    @basketballaddict2885 6 років тому

    As a patriots fan I really want to be the Browns right now

  • @ClassicJukeboxBand
    @ClassicJukeboxBand 6 років тому

    My biggest Cobra Effect rule? The NFL's standing during the National Anthem, then recind.

  • @carlchrispin502
    @carlchrispin502 6 років тому

    no damn son in this vid...

  • @petermitchell2729
    @petermitchell2729 6 років тому

    I'm not saying the rules aren't bad, but they all aren't exactly making the initial problems worse.

  • @bioLarzen
    @bioLarzen 6 років тому +3

    "The first Golden Goal didn't happen until 1998"
    Germany won the Euro Champs with a golden goal - in 1996.

    • @kroby6
      @kroby6 6 років тому

      What he was saying was for the FIFA World Cup. The Europeans have their own competition that can play by a different set of rules set by UEFA. It’s similar to the MLS with their 1-on-1 shootouts for years.

    • @hoebertrabeck1621
      @hoebertrabeck1621 6 років тому

      if sherlock would have done some "research" (wikipedia) you would have noticed its 1993 not 1992 and how should you score a golden goal before 1998 if the rule isnt active???
      "The term golden goal was introduced by FIFA in 1993 along with the rule change because the alternative term, "sudden death", was perceived to have negative connotations. In a knockout competition, following a draw, two fifteen-minute periods of extra time are played. If either team scores a goal during extra time, the game ends immediately and the scoring team becomes the winner. The winning goal is known as the "golden goal". If there have been no goals scored after both periods of extra time, a penalty shoot-out decides the game. The golden goal was not compulsory, and individual competitions using extra time could choose whether to apply it during extra time. The first European Championship played with the rule was in 1996; the first World Cup played with the rule was in 1998."

    • @hoebertrabeck1621
      @hoebertrabeck1621 6 років тому

      The first golden goal recorded was on 13 March 1993 by Australia against Uruguay in a quarter-final match of the World Youth Championship.

  • @pierosanchez2010
    @pierosanchez2010 6 років тому

    Go Mavs! Once was worth it

  • @jeatig
    @jeatig 4 роки тому

    As long as we know what "IS" is!!