UN Special Rapporteur: ‘I have a word limit in my report, otherwise we could write an encyclopaedia’
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 бер 2024
- In a QA session held in Geneva on Wednesday, UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese said that she could write an “encyclopaedia” on the atrocities committed by Israel in the occupied Palestinian territories.
She added that if the International Criminal Court is serious about investigating what Israel has done in Gaza since October 7 “it will be busy for decades”.
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEastEye_TG
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
They said it on Camera and we're watching it on camera. We don't need their written word...
With the last name Liberman. Lol. These Z people are just wayyy too much.
@@nexus-qb3bu You are not supposed to say that even if it is true. I believe it is against the community standards of UA-cam
What we need are proofs - official statements, something simple
@@user-ch5xq3lt9kactions speak louder than words.
@@user-ch5xq3lt9kyou really don’t. Statements like: “there are no innocents in Gaza” “we will starve them. They will get nothing, no water, no food, no fuel, no medicine.” Those to already clearly show genocidal intent. They were all said in the very beginning! Read the court documents from the ICJ case. It is clear as day.
What a profoundly idiotic question.
That question was prepared by his masters ...or he is just plain stupid
Yes,and his body gestures is idiot too
It's not idiotic..it just proves that she is a liar...genocide IS in hamas official charter..
Not surprising. That’s how Genocide deniers talk.
It doesn't prove anything. In any way. That's an idiotic statement @user-yi8fo7vx7o
Thank you Francesca Albanese. Grazie!
For being an antisemetic liar
@@alizakesslergo to your room and cry
@@alizakesslerwhat a loser
@@alizakesslerwhat a loser. Hail......😅
@@alizakesslerwhat loser. Finish the sentence hail.....
This man is stupid. He tried to play hide and seeks with highly crafted lady from Italy 😂
and he's a german
@@user-fx5cd4px3kGermany went from a genocider to a genocide supporter. Some people just never learn.
@@user-fx5cd4px3k He is more than mere German. UA-cam prevents me from saying.
Perhaps he has génocide in blood
Wrong. It was a brilliant question. He knew exactly what he was doing, and he knew exactly how Ms. Albenese would reply. Great journalist
There isn’t enough paper in the world.
Francesca Albanese your courage is contagious. We stand with you in your defence of truth.
She is a disgusting liar who supports Hamas
She is either ignorant or a liar...either way she shldn't be representing un...GENOCIDE IS IN THE HAMAS OFFICIAL CHARTER
❤May Allah give Francesca Albanese the best health. Salam to you al from your Afghan brother!❤
And it is obvious that a servant of I....L asked that question.
Sure she is!! Hateful!!!
Albanese is a well-known bigot who was forced to apologize on more than one occasion for anti-Jewish posts and remarks.
Calling IDF as animals is an insult for animals.
Let me guess you never been to Israel
@@User9681e - Netanyahu let the attack happen on his own country, despite knowing about the attack 3 days before it happened.
- Music festival was organised with lot of foreigners just 3 miles away from the border. On whose order?
- Music festival was extended by one day as the attack did not happen when it was thought to happen. On whose order?
- Noticing that music festival casualty were less, used IDF to increase the casualties in the music festival. On whose order?
What a dumb question!
His follow up was going to be....
Do you condemn hamas?
@@anasjaved871 yea forgot that almost like a gutteral throat clearing as you say it.
Guys an idiot. Trying to look intelligent with his glasses hung low
@@tecdesigns8183never seen Tadhg Hickey? He‘s a diamond in that😂😂
@@Sylvia-ps8tgyep😂
The only thing I want from the ICJ is to announce a guilty verdict, so we can move on demanding an arms embargo.That's the only way the ICJ and ICC can save their credibility. Enough with dragging their feet. Gaza needs help now, not in April, not next year or in 20 years. The time is now.
Israel will do whatever they want . Nothing will stop them
@@alizakessler last time gas chambers stop them, be carefull what you wish.
@@alizakesslerAn arms embargo would.
@@bliss448 nope. That won't stop them at all
It already failed
That literally is one of the DUMBEST QUESTIONS EVER ASKED. He's sitting there like he's about to ask a thought provoking question and he comes up with that?
They are the “best” ones too 🤦♂️
No he is right
@@alizakesslerthen the makes you dumb too, if you think thats an good question
@@alizakesslerduhhhh i don't understand why everyone is against this question duhhh
You couldn't get any further from truth. It was a leading question and the journalist knew what her answer would be! Great journalist, brilliant journalism.
What a very stupid question to ask. Even if he was trying to be cynical, still very stupid
He was obviously grifting.
He'd probably rule serial killers as innocent because they never submitted an official document announcing their intent.
He is right. She has no proof because she is a liar
@@alizakesslershe’s literally submitted a report of facts.
@@alizakesslerYou are ploughing a lone furrow there. The cold bath awaits.
@@alizakessler He is either plain stupid or there is something very sinister about his question. There is zero papers from Nazis stating they want to commit genocide and they never explained what the final solution actually is yet they committed most heinous and horrific genocide in history of humankind, which raises a questions what was his true intent when asking such an absurd question.
My Dad worked at the UN in Geneva. He would have been so honored having the chance to meet and work by your side...
She's an antisemetic liar
Thank un watch for exposing the downfall of the un
What we are seeing in Gaza is disgraceful at every level. Despite the censorship, gaslighting, misrepresentation of historical facts and attempts to redefine words, reality cannot be denied. Never before in human history have we witnessed hate as extreme as the Israeli people are demonstrating today.
What we saw Hamas do on October 7th is disgusting and no one is talking about it
Humans will always need to please to confirm their humanity, and that's what religion is about.
Absolutely. When I look at israel now I see the most sickening characters,the most sickening abuses,the most sickening atrocities,entitled,liars ruining peoples lives if they don’t agree with them all whilst playing victim
@@alizakessler ,...are you kidding? You won't quit talking about it.
@@alizakesslerYOU don't get to tell us what to think! Who do you think you are?!!
the way she responded to him did not only answer his question but also showed how silly of a question it was. Brilliant respond. 👏 keep going until war criminals and their allies are brought to justice. Free palestine 🇵🇸
He still needs a "document" to see whats happening in Gaza?
Stupidity has no limits.
She has such good comebacks. History will remember her
🙌Francesca Albanese is a hero of humanity🙏
I agree 👍
Not to rise up is to be complicit. Bravo lady for your courage.
Bravo forl ying
@@alizakesslerGo steal that’s what you good at
@@fightclub50000 it's Palestinians stealing Israel's land
@@alizakesslernice one Adolf
You'd know all about that wouldn't you? Lying is second nature to you zio lot!!!@@alizakessler
Lately I'm struggling about the phrase, "there is no stupid question ". This is a prime example of STUPID QUESTION
It's not stupid....genocide is actually in hamas official charter...pls go chk it out
The question is an implicit participation in committing the crime
As an Italian, i'm so proud of Francesca. The UN couldn't have a better special rapporteur than her.
UN watch has the proof there is no genocide
I am not an Italian and yet I am so proud of her.
Love greeting from the Middle East.
He wanted to make her claim of genocide unfounded and unsubstantiated, but she outwitted him with an ingenious rebuttal. Her courage and integrity are exemplary for others.
A brave lady who has done more than all Arab rulers combined.
A lady who doesn't stop lying
@@alizakessler I am sure you can cite at least 5 examples.
@@jawwadkazi7525 everything she said. She lies about genocide. She says Hamas is allowed to murder jws and Israel can't defend itself
And the West leadership as well
@@alizakesslerHasbara bots need new lines 🤖🤖🤖
Protect her at all cost.. I can't imagine what threats she got for her courage to speak out, she has heart of steel ♥️
That was the most insane and ridiculous statement I've ever heard from the journalist
I'm glad he asked that question. First, it made him the dumbest reporter ever and secondly, it gave her a chance to elaborate on the word limit else an encyclopedia would've be required.
Genocide is in hamas written charter
What's happening will haunt everyone for a long time to come
What a stupid, stupid question!! Well responded to madame!
ماهو السؤال
Respect for such a courageous and honorable lady. She is a true leader.
Thank you Francesca.
GOD bless Francesca Albanese ❤
Very interesting, intelligent woman.
Jan Dirk Hebermann. You should be fired.
She should be fired for lying
@@alizakessler lol
@@alizakessleryou should be banned for spamming.
@@alizakessler Read the report before you make the accusation. Israel is clearly committing war crimes, including genocide.
@@covakoma1064 you mean for saying the truth?
The world needs more heroes like her. God bless you Francesca
She is brilliant and resilient. God bless her for not being intimidated and is standing strong
Thank you for your work! She is the only one who stands up to the huge machine of propaganda and justification of genocide! Everyone needs to help her
This woman makes Giorgia Meloni look mentally challenge. Amazing woman.
Nothing amazing about being an antisemetic liar
Amazing...she knows that genocide is actually in hamas official charter yet she chooses to ignore it...amazing
@@user-yi8fo7vx7o “these people wrote about genocide, which justifies us actually doing a genocide against them” dude cmon now
@@user-yi8fo7vx7oWriting something, saying something, it only shows intent, it doesn’t show action. Hamas has failed to turn their intent into action due to various failings, but Israel has done the actions.
That was one very stupid question, which I hope does not catch on in legal circles.
"Your honour, I urge you to discount the forensic evidence and multiple witness testimony as my client never actually filed an official paper stating his intent to murder the victim."
Not a stupid question
@@alizakessler it is in fact a profoundly stupid question
Excellent response!
I'm surprised she didn't use the example of the NAZI's genocide.
@@matthewbaynham6286 Because that's from a pre-UN charter era, that's it I suppose
@@matthewbaynham6286It would be a low blow, and she would be entirely justified, and it would lead to the usual hypocritical cry of antisemitism.
@@matthewbaynham6286 if you think that nowadays a country will acknowledge a genocide in writing, you are extremely naive. The prohibition of genocide is now part of jus cogens (highest norms of international law that applies to the entire international community and to which no derogation is allowed). If you want some references though, go check the application made by South Africa before the ICJ - there are hundreds of references…
@@NoBS-rf1gd I don't think you neither read or understood my comment.
Question from a German journalist, of course. Trying to find an excuse for his friends.
Don't forget that Germany has a huge Zio lobby.
This is the way how they argue when you put the in the corner with undeniable evidence, this is how a lot of German journalist and citizen as well ofcourse not all , they are so ignorant
Grateful for Francesca Albanese 🍉speaking up! many powerful people, prime minsters, presidents, royals and ministers wouldn't dare to say a word that is not in favor of the occupying regime!
She's a liar and an antisemite and it's not an occupying regime
The journalist, whoever he is, sums up Western idiocy, naivety or hypocrisy - depending on how kind you want to be.
Hypocrisy and ignorant
This woman is a legend. 🌺
This woman is a liar and supports Hamas
She is the worst and most obvious antisemite
She is the worst and most obvious antisemite
This lady is courageous
Thank you 🙏 for telling the truth 📢🍉🍉🍉🍉
Being against genocide is antisemitic, antisalad
There is no genocide. LYing about Israel is antisemetic
@@alizakessler Yea, ok, please provide an example of a lie.
The lie that there existed a Palestine state. Name some Palestinian leaders before Arafat, or one from late 19 th century.
The lie that Idf forcibly expelled Arab muslims in 1948, when infact it was caused by 5 Arab states atracking Israel. Had Israel lost that war there would be no Israel and no Jews.
The 5 armies lost the war causing the displacement. The displacement of Arab Muslims was not due to Idf forcing them out when Idf won the war. They were instructed to leave their homes by Arab leaders.
Here's a fact you are not going to like..
quote from Syrian Prime Minister Haled al-Azm in 1948, feel free to check the source yourself:
“SINCE 1948 WE HAVE BEEN DEMANDING THE RETURN OF THE REFUGEES TO THEIR HOMES. BUT WE OURSELVES ARE THE ONES WHO ENCOURAGED THEM TO LEAVE. ONLY A FEW MONTHS SEPARATED OUR CALL TO THEM TO LEAVE AND OUR APPEAL TO THE UNITED NATIONS TO RESOLVE ON THEIR RETURN.”
But the world is lied to with the narrative of the disastrous Nakba. The disaster was Arab muslims intolerance of a Jewish state in the middle of Arab muslim countries.
Arab muslims logic goes like this. " If we win the war we destroy you completely and you lose everything, if we lose the war, we demand return of our losses" Sadly this truth is being drowned out with the constant lies.
The truth, let's repeat it. Arab muslims have never wanted a Jewish state. They believe only they can rule as majority.
But as a minority muslims always demand their share.
Muslims were 9% in Britush India in 1941 yet demanded a state and were given one.
Jews were 19% in the 1931 British census of Palestine/ Jordan. But no Jews cannot have a state!
Does that answer your question?
@@MysterD515
@@alizakessler ,...are there any other countries that we are forbidden to criticize? Or just one special place?
@@alizakesslerIsraelis originated from Europe, they're not Semitic.
Absolutely true, if any institution tries to disclose what happened in Gaza, it will take decades. I agree with the UN reporter.
Trying to gaslight someone who's aware and not affraid to call for bs is a suicide
Very happy this question was asked, and the response was perfect. These are the kind of statements we hear regularly in the west, trying to excuse or downplay Isreali actions.
Truth shall prevail over falsehood
Amazing, brave woman!!
Nothing brave about lying
@@alizakesslerwhich is why you run away every time someone asks you to name a lie in her report. 😂
@alizakessler The writing is on the wall. Zionism is in its final days. You can accuse everyone of lying or antisemitism or whatever. Nobody is listening to your lies anymore.
@@alizakessler No lies here except your Zionist ones. Just read Likud charter it is all about genocidal intent.
Rapporteur puts reporter in his place. This has happened previously, notably in Australia when she responded to similar idiotic questions at her National Press Club address.
You are correct. It was brilliant to watch.
She demolished that bum
Madam.. you've took the meaning of "roasted" to another level.
Such a smart journalist!!. Thank you madame, you've seen straight into his soul and intent 🧐
What a stupid question being asked by that old man..with his smug like it's something a big shot lawyer could have said 😂😂
No it's not stupid
@@alizakessler owh really...?it's like asking did the murderer write down his intention to kill somewhere in writing to prove his innocence.if no writing then that negates the intend?.like where in court of law?🤣 The action speaks louder.
@@alizakessler OK! We need a rebuttal from you, not just the silly repetitive: “she’s lying.” Come on…. Give us your best shot.
Brave woman thank you.... Agim Sahit Mehmeti Kosova
She just excoriated the entitled journalist in utter precision. La ringrazio.
It's great your report has facts all the US have is name calling. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Love this lady, she say it like it is. The world needs more people like her
It’s funny how UA-cam will not let people support Palestine. Or denounce iz real.
The CIA, Google, being evil, you know how it is.
Or spread the fact that they worked with funny moustache man back then
@hanzdolo4328,...constant rephrasing and respelling are needed to keep your words alive.
This woman is an intellectual champion!
This woman is a sick liar who supports Hamas
She is a liar...she did not mention that genocide is really in hamas official charter..
@@user-yi8fo7vx7o The Likud party charter also calls for genocide -what is your point?
He would not have asked that to any Israeli claiming genocide on October 7th
There is no genocide
True, there are many, throughout 75 years.
ISRl is committing genocide and ethnic cleansing on.Palestinians.there are official reports.You live in a denial....@@alizakessler
@@alizakessler the ICJ wouldn’t have to tell Israel to be sure to avoid committing genocide if there weren’t one, bud.
@@andyghkfilm2287 They are anti-Semitic. They haven't told Hamas to stop attacking and they haven't condemned Hamas who wants genocide of jws. They said Hamas should release the hostages but they still haven't
Thank you... You proved your honesty an professionality
GOD BLESS YOU
If the whole thing wasn't so monumentally tragic, the questioner would easily pass as a prime joker.
German guy has made fun of himself such idiocy
No it's a good question...hamas official charter IS genocide..
@@user-yi8fo7vx7omaybe, but the ongoing genocide is being perpetrated by Israel not Hamas. Hamas is a terrorist entity, Israel is supposed to be a developed civilized country, we don't expect them to carry out a genocide, but it is..
@@user-yi8fo7vx7oEven if that were true, would a genocide by one party excuse the genocide of any opposing party.
Amazing woman ❤ . Free Palestine ❤ .
The world will never forget the genocide the Nazis committed. Similarly, the world will never forget the genocide that Israel has and is still committing in Gaza. The difference is that the West helped Israel to commit the atrocities.
I like this smart woman very much ❤
The standard of proof required to use everyday clear concepts against the interests of power is astonishing
Great question, misinterpreted by many here. Ms. Albenese is a true heroine!
I'm intrigued actually.. Could you expand a little? Genuinely curious.
Was it a 'leading' question you think?
@@nottheweather438 that's exactly what I believe was happening. One would have to be either very ill-informed or just plain stupid to expect such a document to exist, in my opinion. Thanks for the question
For this answer alone, I'll love her forever.
Look at how he sits, his potbelly, his lack of a spine, how he talks down to her. And look at her, the energy, the will, the marrow of her words and meaning. She just wipes the floor with his face
Good woman.
This is what a woman leadership is like. Amazing. Great example to girls and other women and MEN!
"Don't interrupt the enemy when they are making a mistake"
fits this nicely, Israel made the huge mistake of openly and proudly stating their true intentions about the entirety of Palestine and Gaza included.
They let their politicians and political activist say inflammatory things like erase Gaza, build settlement there or even Arabs should not be here.
If UN is truly justice, then it will take the claims of genocide as dead serious and with utmost importance. Just hope that it is not corrupt and a puppet.
UN ALWAYS BEEN A USELESS PUPPET SINCE ITS CREATION…. Unfortunately
Her reply is GOLD GOLD GOLD to this dummy.. love the look she gives him also GOLD GOLD GOLD
I can't believe that a journalist can ask such a stupid question! It just highlights the total support for Israel and the disdain for Palestinians... As if they are not human!!
"ICC busy for decades". Wow Brave lady!!!
She quickly shut that Yarpie journalist up.
German media 😂🤣😂😂
And ?
Because Germany is a bit uptight in things Israel, because of their dark past, but it is about Zionism, not Judaism (german reporter doubting Ms Albanese in the beginning)
Stupid question
A typical Italian woman... Strict, fearless and strong, with a supernatural sarcasm powers😅
Grazie Francesca, ben detto!
The dumbest question and the smartest and most amusing answer ever i heard at least for some recent past may be.
Her brilliance, honesty, courage, assertiveness and professionalism is a rare thing to find in the current world and in her position especially. It is a treasure.
Bravo
❤May Allah give Francesca Albanese the best health. Salam to you al from your Afghan brother!❤
Lots
Of women like her fought the nazists in Germany but were silenced and killed. Not this time , not in our name!
That man is a legit journalist???
He's a moron
Germany is all hysterical and going down (for the USA)
Amazing person. We need more like her🙏🏻
What a response 👏👏brave and well informed lady
What an impressive human being she is!
What a beautiful soul!!
Never ask a man about his salary, a woman about her age or Israel about its evidence.
Isriael about its terriorist acts.
Merci et que Dieu Vous Bénisse Madame .
Nothing about that on the French TVs, just the usual sentence "Israel as the right to defend itself" and our national liar bernard henri levy.
And all the frecnch mainstream medias are complicit with isrl"s atrocities.
No need for a document, we have all the videos online to prove it
Do you have a WRITTEN document? What passes for "journalist" today.
She obviously doesn't have one because she's lying
@@alizakessler Hahahaha. Yeah, sure.
@@emmanuelenyinwa1443 she's a known liar
@@alizakessler An Israeli supporter calling another person a liar is like the devil calling another person a sinner.
@@alizakesslerI can recommend a good speech therapist for your stammer!
Well done... Speak for the truth and the truth should be spread for the world to know. Justice for Palestine.
Don’t let anyone bully you