Thank you Nitin Ji for making this video. I realised recently that not many in our new generation know the context. This is very well made video, its unbiased and doesn't shy about all the gray elements in this whole saga.
Thank you Nitin. Actually it was Sanjay Gandhi and Zail Singh who created 'Sant' Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. Much later, Amarinder Singh twice set up meetings between Rajiv Gandhi and Bhindranwale, but these were aborted on both occasions at the centre's behest leaving Bhindranwale miffed! Mark Tully and Satish Jacob's very readable account, 'Amritsar, Mrs. Gandhi's Last Battle' relates happenings leading upto the very unfortunate storming of the Golden Temple.
Sir with all respect to your age and knowledge. I hope u know akali dal and it's style and ideology of politics. And Bhinderwala was to counter the akali and bring peace and stability. But he went out of control like shaikh. You know how Chinese betrayed india. It's like the same
Basically, this charge that India is interfering with Canadian internal affairs needs to be put in context. It is the Canadian citizens who are inciting violence, breeding separatism and creating religiously intolerant tones. If Indian government linked agents need to be held accountable, what about Canadian citizens?
1> Attacking golden temple was the worst decision , golden temple is sacred to both Sikhs & Hindus. 2> Raising a man with extreme views as a opposition to Akali , and for what "votes" , I mean the state should not consider people of this country as sheep's. 3> There could be many other ways to sort this out any political parlay with Akali could have saved us this mayhem for the time to come. 4> I hope sense prevail to our political masters , that there decisions affects the people of this country but not them , who make those decisions in there comfortable government bungalows.
Yes, the Australian government is asleep at the wheel. It has no understanding of South-Asian politics. It wants friendly relations with India at the same time as it supports people who want the LAC with Pakistan and China moved south and east of Delhi. It is important PM Modi makes it publicly clear to Australia that our support of Khalistan proponents is a declaration of war against India.
Bhopal Gas tragedy 5800 official died and more then 25000 died as per unconfirmed reports . Government of day buried people / animal on same large pits . Photo journalist took photo sold to world over & won international awards .
Thanks for the video Nitin. As someone living in Surrey British Columbia, the recent warnings to hindus to leave has left a lot of us extremely worried. We don't understand when the relations between these two communities soured. We know that the first male child in Hindu family was given to Sikhs. We know we fought shoulder to shoulder against mughals. When and how did this animosity start? We first heard during bhindranwale killing of Hindus. But why? Can you make a video on the origin story please.
Seems made up. Who gave the warnings? you guys learned alot from Israel. Sikhs have been given warnings from the RCMP. Have hindus? There were no killings by SANT Bhindrrawale . Sikhs fought the mugal because we defended our land, stop your lies.
In canda their movements are for more than three decades. I support Raw if it did the act. What mossad, cia, mi6, kgb does. India did the same if its true. Jai bharat jai hind
Political ambitions are okay but , they should not become a tool in the hands of western neo nazism. Khalistan is not political ambitions, it is a well laid out trap by AUKUS, USUK..... bla bla groups. Indira Gandhi's, Beyant Singh murder was not a Sikh thing, it was much more .
A very short primer on the Khalistani insurgency in Punjab, useful for the utterly or somewhat clueless folks. You missed out one key political figure who was tough as nails, whom everyone else seems to have forgotten too ( Am I the only one who remembers?! Ye Gods! And I still flunked UPSC Prelims!! )- the Punjab Governor & Chandigarh administrator Siddhartha Shankar Ray, who served from 1986 - 1989, when Punjab was under President's Rule for more than 4 years (2nd President's Rule for Punjab in the 80s - 1st one was 1983 - 1984). Ray was instrumental in fighting the Naxalites as CM of West Bengal & was regarded as a troubleshooter of the Congress Party. Given that he was a ex- Presidency + UK - educated lawyer, he knew the nitty gritties of domestic & international law very well. Ribeiro & KPS Gill had a free hand with their "bullet for bullet" (totally needed whatever the f*** anyone says) approach knowing that they had solid political cover. People of Punjab know what they went through the entire 80s & that's why there is no appetite for Khalistan in Punjab anymore, so much so that the pure Sikh parties like Akali Dal have also been kicked out by Sikhs for their rampant corruption. Also, another key event that Bhindranwale threatened to destroy for maximum reputational damage was the 1984 Asian Games in Delhi. The Haryana Congress CM Bhajan Lal said that in order to reach Delhi, these terrorists have to go through Haryana first & they simply couldn't. The 1984 Asian Games was incident free.
Mr.Nitin this is not expected of you. It seems that you are trying to malign some political party. Crowd and love of people for their pm cannot be ascribed to any political party .
These are facts my dear friend. There have been multiple reports about the connection and few well researched books written as well. If we don't speak the truth and bury our heads in the sand, we will never learn from our mistakes.
Thank you Nitin Ji for making this video. I realised recently that not many in our new generation know the context.
This is very well made video, its unbiased and doesn't shy about all the gray elements in this whole saga.
Nitin has missed several aspects of insurgency in Punjab and perhaps roots of secession by sikhs.
Thank you Nitin. Actually it was Sanjay Gandhi and Zail Singh who created 'Sant' Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. Much later, Amarinder Singh twice set up meetings between Rajiv Gandhi and Bhindranwale, but these were aborted on both occasions at the centre's behest leaving Bhindranwale miffed! Mark Tully and Satish Jacob's very readable account, 'Amritsar, Mrs. Gandhi's Last Battle' relates happenings leading upto the very unfortunate storming of the Golden Temple.
Sir with all respect to your age and knowledge. I hope u know akali dal and it's style and ideology of politics. And Bhinderwala was to counter the akali and bring peace and stability. But he went out of control like shaikh. You know how Chinese betrayed india. It's like the same
Fascinating and comprehensive account of the background to the recent events. Wish more of this kind of information was available for current events.
Very good Nitin Sir ji 🙏. Jai Swadeshi ! Jai Jai Swadeshi !! Jai Swaraj !!! Jai Dharma !!!!
Basically, this charge that India is interfering with Canadian internal affairs needs to be put in context. It is the Canadian citizens who are inciting violence, breeding separatism and creating religiously intolerant tones. If Indian government linked agents need to be held accountable, what about Canadian citizens?
Aapka swagat Hai Nitin ji
Love you Nitinji❤❤❤❤
1> Attacking golden temple was the worst decision , golden temple is sacred to both Sikhs & Hindus.
2> Raising a man with extreme views as a opposition to Akali , and for what "votes" , I mean the state should not consider people of this country as sheep's.
3> There could be many other ways to sort this out any political parlay with Akali could have saved us this mayhem for the time to come.
4> I hope sense prevail to our political masters , that there decisions affects the people of this country but not them , who make those decisions in there comfortable government bungalows.
Yes, the Australian government is asleep at the wheel. It has no understanding of South-Asian politics. It wants friendly relations with India at the same time as it supports people who want the LAC with Pakistan and China moved south and east of Delhi. It is important PM Modi makes it publicly clear to Australia that our support of Khalistan proponents is a declaration of war against India.
Another very senior Officer named Shri C.G.Vaidya, head of the IB used to stay in Pune and had a security guard till his natural death in Pune.
India must deal with canada sternly. Enough is enough.
Wtf you gonna do. Make more spam calls lmao. You cant even fight the chinese. You are nothing without sikhs
Well narrated
How sikhs glorify Bhindrawala is a matter if concern for punjab and indian govt.
the facts that you commented 4 different times mean u a bum ong.
Bhopal Gas tragedy 5800 official died and more then 25000 died as per unconfirmed reports . Government of day buried people / animal on same large pits . Photo journalist took photo sold to world over & won international awards .
Very nicely explained
Thanks for the video Nitin. As someone living in Surrey British Columbia, the recent warnings to hindus to leave has left a lot of us extremely worried. We don't understand when the relations between these two communities soured. We know that the first male child in Hindu family was given to Sikhs. We know we fought shoulder to shoulder against mughals. When and how did this animosity start? We first heard during bhindranwale killing of Hindus. But why? Can you make a video on the origin story please.
Seems made up. Who gave the warnings? you guys learned alot from Israel. Sikhs have been given warnings from the RCMP. Have hindus? There were no killings by SANT Bhindrrawale . Sikhs fought the mugal because we defended our land, stop your lies.
Hindu majority country still hasn’t made a truth reconciliation for 1984 Sikh genocide
Bhinderanwala was a sant go watch subramanian Swamy interview on him
In canda their movements are for more than three decades. I support Raw if it did the act. What mossad, cia, mi6, kgb does. India did the same if its true. Jai bharat jai hind
There's is nothing wrong with Sikhs having their own political ambitions.
There is nothing wrong untill someone is peaceful, violence will never be and should never be tolerated in any form.
@@HerculesKumar88 Exactly why India should be questioned after this extra judicial murder, just the tip of iceberg of Indian repression of Sikhs.
Political ambitions are okay but , they should not become a tool in the hands of western neo nazism. Khalistan is not political ambitions, it is a well laid out trap by AUKUS, USUK..... bla bla groups. Indira Gandhi's, Beyant Singh murder was not a Sikh thing, it was much more .
@@sardar_gurjothe was a bloody terrorist.
Dog got killed.
F### him .
F### khalistan.
@@lonesurvivor4755 Why don't you guys take the responsibility then?😅 Is Indian deep state coward?
Good
China's role in supporting Pakistan to support the K gang needs attention and programs to explain to your readers
❤❤❤❤❤ nitin sir ❤❤❤❤❤
Baby Trudeau must grow up to the realities of the future
A very short primer on the Khalistani insurgency in Punjab, useful for the utterly or somewhat clueless folks. You missed out one key political figure who was tough as nails, whom everyone else seems to have forgotten too ( Am I the only one who remembers?! Ye Gods! And I still flunked UPSC Prelims!! )- the Punjab Governor & Chandigarh administrator Siddhartha Shankar Ray, who served from 1986 - 1989, when Punjab was under President's Rule for more than 4 years (2nd President's Rule for Punjab in the 80s - 1st one was 1983 - 1984). Ray was instrumental in fighting the Naxalites as CM of West Bengal & was regarded as a troubleshooter of the Congress Party. Given that he was a ex- Presidency + UK - educated lawyer, he knew the nitty gritties of domestic & international law very well. Ribeiro & KPS Gill had a free hand with their "bullet for bullet" (totally needed whatever the f*** anyone says) approach knowing that they had solid political cover. People of Punjab know what they went through the entire 80s & that's why there is no appetite for Khalistan in Punjab anymore, so much so that the pure Sikh parties like Akali Dal have also been kicked out by Sikhs for their rampant corruption.
Also, another key event that Bhindranwale threatened to destroy for maximum reputational damage was the 1984 Asian Games in Delhi. The Haryana Congress CM Bhajan Lal said that in order to reach Delhi, these terrorists have to go through Haryana first & they simply couldn't. The 1984 Asian Games was incident free.
Agreed. One small correction Asian Games were in 1982 not 1984
@@nitingokhale184 Thanks for correcting me. 1982, I'll remember that from now on! 😊
Mr.Nitin this is not expected of you. It seems that you are trying to malign some political party. Crowd and love of people for their pm cannot be ascribed to any political party .
These are facts my dear friend. There have been multiple reports about the connection and few well researched books written as well. If we don't speak the truth and bury our heads in the sand, we will never learn from our mistakes.
Not an honest explanation.
nice