@@andreaking7432well this commie is firmly on the side of the wealthy elite, the deficits that he’s suggesting are how they transfer wealth from the working class, although he’s too dumb & ideological to realise it.
He's wrong right off the bat. NHS, Schools aren't free - I pay an absolute fortune in national insurance, income tax and council tax which pays for all them things
Well yes. His teaching has the potential to influence young people. However, not all of the young people will agree with him. I find the younger people are not as stupid as some people think. Millenials have taken some of this lefty stuff as read but, younger people are increasingly questioning it.
He does know what he is talking about but he is an obnoxious twat. His "theories" are probably mathematicaly correct but in my opinion do not work in the real world
That speaker is deluded. Of course we don't pay for our healthcare etc when we get to the till, but we've already pre-paid through taxes and other services through local rates, etc. How does he think they are paid for? It's not free at all. Well, unless you're an illegal immigrant that is and then it is completely free.
Best statement i have read , i fell of my chair laughing , you are so Right, that Leftie Idiot , this is why we need these woke idiots to be buried under the sand forever , what i do not understand is why does not ever body see that we should only help hard working people , i am sorry but this oh we must feel sorry for you is only creating more and more laziness in our society and that is a fact , invest money in our own country like state funded training to teach school leavers a trade , it does not work with businesses doing it , simply because young people are not loyal to their masters. they leave after you have invested 50/80k training them , lets be honest a business does not make money from an apprentice he or she costs us money and when you get them to the finished article if that happens as most of them do not even have any common sense or a decent work ethic they leave because somebody has offered them 10.00 pounds a week more than you pay them , There master that taught them their trade, put up with them being late for work , waiting outside their house because they cant get their arse out of bed every day , feeding them at work because they cannot manage there money , small businesses simply will not and cannot afford to train young people anymore , and immigration does not help either, as cheap labour does nothing and only adds to the small businesses problem and makes things even worse. so stop sending our money abroad and do not waste our tax payers money on people that are not our problem, Invest Money here it is not rocket science , instead of saying if you do not pay we will take it away , try this one if you do not make the effort to work we will Stop your Benifits and not pay your rent and you will be on the street And Homeless Period ,
Exactly. And then there's the FACT that after having paid all that for 44 years, if you choose to retire overseas, that pre paid pension is frozen! Even though we don't use the NHS or any of the services domiciled pensioners receive. Disgusting inequity never addressed.
It's free but costs billions in the budget which is raised how? How can this guy talk about economy when he misses where the money comes from? "The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money" - Margaret Thatcher
Yeah and all those teachers, doctors and all the rest don't need and expect to be paid for their services. They're trustafarians who could be off skiing, or living large on their private islands. It's nonsense on stilts with a large dose of steroids.
If you listened to the interview closely, you would know that he was a chartered accountant for over 40 years before becoming an academic…. Open yours ears 👂 👌
@NigelHyphenJones and he's now an "academic". I'm more interested in how a chartered accountant becomes an academic. Was his expertise in insolvency and bankruptcies?
This guy is talking Bollocks! The Private sector creates the wealth from which the Public sector is paid. Don't even get me started on the pension disparity.
@LordPeg44 Tax revenues, obviously. However then people will say that the public sector also pay tax. But they pay Tax on The revenue taken from the Private sector which pays their wages.
In an Ideal world, the public sector should be balanced so revenue collected from the Private sector is greater than the cost of the public sector. It's not Rocket Science.
@@MiddleAgedBritobviously! Then why tax the private sector to excess? Reeves and starmer talked of growth then stunt growth with their policies and budget!
And he is clearly irrational, a control freak and defensive individual when called out. Never invite him back. He made my blood boil telling other people they were rude????! He needs to find a mirror, and fast! Love your work, Cristo. Merry Christmas from Aus. 🇦🇺
This bloke is living on another planet. The public sector is supported by the private sector. Anyone knows how tough it is to run a business now. I have price increases of up to 9% coming from suppliers in the coming year. I can see spiralling inflation in a very short time.
Just to educate you if It's at all possible. Politicians and media commentators tell us that it comes from taxes. Taxes are collected and the government spends that money - until it’s all gone. At that point, ‘there’s no money left to fund nurses pay increases’. However, there’s a flaw in that understanding. That isn’t how currency-sovereign governments work. Taxes don’t pay for government spending. So, what is the reality of it all? In the UK, what happens in practice is that the government asks the Bank of England to spend whatever is required to fulfil their policy agenda. And, unlike the tax story told by politicians, the government can never run out of money. The UK government has a monopoly on the production of UK pounds and the Bank of England has a legal responsibility to respond to every government request. So, despite what you hear on your TV or read in our paper, lack of finance is never a barrier to government spending.
he deserved to be thrown off, the made has his head in the sand , completely sold out to the public sector. I don't know how long ago he worked in the private sector but doubt he was popular, too full of himself
Condescending man. I couldn’t understand his argument. Isn’t it the private sector that pays for everything. That’s why the public sector are public servants.
His constant grin and smiling tells it all - I had someone at work exactly the same ... his phrase was "you have a view, I have a view, but my view is right" and he genuinely believed that was always always the case because "he knew better than others" - insufferable ....
Is this the same ‘economic expert’ who told Sturgeon and the SNP that their economic policies were sound and couldn’t fail for an independent Scotland?
For much of his early career he was an accountant in Downham Market, Norfolk. In 1985 he co-founded an accountancy firm which became Murphy Deeks Nolan. The company was sold in 2000. Murphy was also the founder of a company that became the European distributor for the game Trivial Pursuit.[3] Murphy has since admitted that the manufacturing operation he set up in Ireland to manufacture Trivial Pursuit was there to avoid UK taxation, something of which he is now ashamed and was a turning point in his career towards anti-tax avoidance campaigning.
Murphy has the most convoluted understanding of economics and the causes of inflation I've ever heard. Absolute rubbish...,,increased wages driven by a growing economy cannot increase inflation unless the money supply is increased by the Gov't.
Labour are taxing to death what little is left of our manufacturing industry, making us reliant upon China. This horrible, vindictive Murphy has praised Labour for their all-out assault on our farming industry. The UK cannot rely entirely upon foreign imports indefinitely. It can now only be a matter of time before there will be food shortages in the UK, as farmers are forced to cut back on essential investment and instead pay unrealistic, high inheritance taxes which will cripple family farms. Labour have also slapped hefty taxes on other inputs such as fertilizer, which farmers cannot re-coup from the big supermarkets due to farmers being price takers and not price makers.
What a nasty self opinionated man I have paid for all those things he lists. It’s called tax. I do not want this person on air again. Well done for throwing him off the show. Love your show Keep on doing what you are doing. Xx happy Xmas and new year
Saying the government needs to spend more money is outrageous. Growth comes from saving and investments done by individuals and companies. A government can't actually ''grow'' an economy because it can only print, tax or borrow money in order to spend money in the first place. It can run a government monopoly but the incentive to make money by itself is supplanted by the political need to satisfy your supporters.
Oh for goodness sake they haven’t stopped spending money .The problem being its all going out of the country. There is not enough people in this country paying tax to support our large population.
Far too many of these far-left activists on the media spouting hard-left socialism.
It’s not the left vs right. It’s about the working class vs the wealthy elite
@@andreaking7432Hi_tler said the same thing.
Why do you think they had him on in the first place?
@@andreaking7432well this commie is firmly on the side of the wealthy elite, the deficits that he’s suggesting are how they transfer wealth from the working class, although he’s too dumb & ideological to realise it.
That'll be the same Socialism that brought you the NHS .
This man is the reason why Labour are only in power for 1 term,good on ya Christo 👍
You can’t handle the truth because it’s not what you want to hear honestly you lot are wet .
@ good to know u have so much support on here 🤣
He's wrong right off the bat. NHS, Schools aren't free - I pay an absolute fortune in national insurance, income tax and council tax which pays for all them things
He's horrible
Here, Here!. The guys an idiot.
We pay for it all....nothing FREE...
Totally agree, where does this silly man think his counsel tax goes?
Agree! He’ just a piece of shite that talks! What an ignorant man!
What a rude, arrogant, condescending man.. Obviously a Labour lover
this guy is supposed to be a stand in teacher for economics ? that is EXACTLY why our kids are all stupid today.
they've been stupid for 120 years.
Pmsl
Well yes. His teaching has the potential to influence young people.
However, not all of the young people will agree with him.
I find the younger people are not as stupid as some people think. Millenials have taken some of this lefty stuff as read but, younger people are increasingly questioning it.
He does know what he is talking about but he is an obnoxious twat. His "theories" are probably mathematicaly correct but in my opinion do not work in the real world
Our kids are not all stupid.
A lot of adults are though
This phrase, "the more I know people, the more I love my dog," is so true HERE!
How patronising is the guest? Well done for blocking him. He is not used to working with people.
Talk about a Champagne Socialist!
You can't handle truth-bombs.
@@garyh1572 FO!
There was no truth though lol! What does a grubby socialist know about truth.
And yet guests like Murphy are routinely at the top of media outlets' rolodexes, which is the more fundamental problem.
Printing money to pay for public sector workers is an inflationary action. It inflates the money supply.
That speaker is deluded. Of course we don't pay for our healthcare etc when we get to the till, but we've already pre-paid through taxes and other services through local rates, etc. How does he think they are paid for? It's not free at all. Well, unless you're an illegal immigrant that is and then it is completely free.
How we got here governments borrowing money they haven't got. And encouraging the public to do the same.
Best statement i have read , i fell of my chair laughing , you are so Right, that Leftie Idiot , this is why we need these woke idiots to be buried under the sand forever , what i do not understand is why does not ever body see that we should only help hard working people ,
i am sorry but this oh we must feel sorry for you is only creating more and more laziness in our society and that is a fact , invest money in our own country like state funded training to teach school leavers a trade , it does not work with businesses doing it , simply because young people are not loyal to their masters.
they leave after you have invested 50/80k training them , lets be honest a business does not make money from an apprentice he or she costs us money and when you get them to the finished article if that happens as most of them do not even have any common sense or a decent work ethic they leave because somebody has offered them 10.00 pounds a week more than you pay them ,
There master that taught them their trade, put up with them being late for work , waiting outside their house because they cant get their arse out of bed every day , feeding them at work because they cannot manage there money , small businesses simply will not and cannot afford to train young people anymore , and immigration does not help either, as cheap labour does nothing and only adds to the small businesses problem and makes things even worse.
so stop sending our money abroad and do not waste our tax payers money on people that are not our problem, Invest Money here it is not rocket science , instead of saying if you do not pay we will take it away , try this one if you do not make the effort to work we will Stop your Benifits and not pay your rent and you will be on the street And Homeless Period ,
Exactly. And then there's the FACT that after having paid all that for 44 years, if you choose to retire overseas, that pre paid pension is frozen! Even though we don't use the NHS or any of the services domiciled pensioners receive. Disgusting inequity never addressed.
The very definition of someone who loves the sound of their own voice. Absolute tool.
There seems to be a lot of these tools about, case in point , Starmer, well, his father definitely was a tool maker...
He is probably relayed to Starma, the son of a toolmaker.
Who? Christo? Absolutely.
@@fynnandfynner your problem is you can’t handle the truth if the truth isn’t on your side you tool
@@gregoryfrancisjames5071 Boring Greg is off again.
Am so glad to hear that schools and health are free...... ill stop paying my taxes then. Thanks Richard
It's free but costs billions in the budget which is raised how? How can this guy talk about economy when he misses where the money comes from?
"The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money" - Margaret Thatcher
Yeah and all those teachers, doctors and all the rest don't need and expect to be paid for their services. They're trustafarians who could be off skiing, or living large on their private islands. It's nonsense on stilts with a large dose of steroids.
It's nonsense on stilts.
What a toe rag, he’s so condescending he’s got to be a stupid know all, must be a stupid leftie
Well said!
Non of the services the chap says are free are free, we pay taxes and NI, we all pay.
HE'S A COMPLETE DOILEM.
What a rude guest with a big mouth a big head.
Just a typical lefty, to be honest. They don't let anyone say anything against their diatribe. I feel bad for his students.
Well done Christo. I think his students should be seeking a refund.
OMG he teaches!
How arrogant and rude can’t watch him sorry
How is there SO much arrogance in such a failing party.
He's an academic.. totally detached from normal human beings. A sad case of I am always rightness.
This cisto is a howmoh, you think that’s normal?
And likes the sound of his own voice.
If you listened to the interview closely, you would know that he was a chartered accountant for over 40 years before becoming an academic…. Open yours ears 👂 👌
@NigelHyphenJones and he's now an "academic". I'm more interested in how a chartered accountant becomes an academic. Was his expertise in insolvency and bankruptcies?
Exactly - Brilliant comment. In my experience, many "Academics" are so arrogant and out of touch and have no clue about the real world.
I have shedloads of books behind me, none of which I've read or understood...
..........or coloured in. 🥴
Mills & Boons books probably 😂
This guy is talking Bollocks! The Private sector creates the wealth from which the Public sector is paid. Don't even get me started on the pension disparity.
Do you mean wealth or tax revenues?
@LordPeg44 Tax revenues, obviously. However then people will say that the public sector also pay tax. But they pay Tax on The revenue taken from the Private sector which pays their wages.
In an Ideal world, the public sector should be balanced so revenue collected from the Private sector is greater than the cost of the public sector. It's not Rocket Science.
@@MiddleAgedBritobviously! Then why tax the private sector to excess? Reeves and starmer talked of growth then stunt growth with their policies and budget!
What… you mean you can’t tax yourself into prosperity……..I’m gutted 🤓
Well done Cristo! Absolutely apt description of that Insufferable, Condescending, Pious Prig! 👍
Well done, Cristo, you did a good job of keeping you're cool faced with that bloke.
Cisto likes the man dem, it’s not normal. It’s an abomination
And he is clearly irrational, a control freak and defensive individual when called out. Never invite him back. He made my blood boil telling other people they were rude????! He needs to find a mirror, and fast! Love your work, Cristo. Merry Christmas from Aus. 🇦🇺
NHS is far from free. Education is far from free. Where did he study economics?
He worked with Rachael from accounts .
😂😂😂😂😂@@sharondonaldson9335
And paid for by our fathers and grandfather's before...
he's awful isnt he
WMU
Walter Mitty University
This man sums up new Labour Party voters.
The aggressive brashness of this guest is a massive turn off, a strong air of arrogance with this guy.
Not only that, he’s wrong 😂
Yeah! That and the fact he was completely talking bullocks is beside the point!
Standard leftist
@@michaelgardiner9960Good luck convincing him.
Arrogant muppet.
And straight up wrong.
It is not free. Taxpayers pay for it or the government borrows it and adds to the country debt. Stupid
So a chartered accountant thinks, NHS,State schools ect are free...Funded from fresh air or tax payers...
I think that's why he is out of work.😂
What an arrogant prat.
He is not a Chartered Acoountant!
Nothing is free bloody fool
@andrewstrand2748 I hope he isn't any accountant. 🙄
Cristo called it right!
Obnoxious condescending and rude.I bet the company who employed him was glad to see him go.
If you can do. If you can't teach.
@@phillipneale5256 you are 100% correct 🍻
@@Padhraig62 you can’t handle the truth if it’s not on your side muppet
Lefties are entitled to their views, however misguided or delusional they may be.@@catherinemartin6258
Lefties are entitled to their views, however arrogant, misguided, or delusional they may be. @catherinemartin6258
Well said Cristo😊
Hes come on all fired up! what a condescending pr**k!
Good for you Christo🇬🇧 We're with you.
It is very important when you are spouting an ideology to talk very loudly and without pause because as we all know this is how propaganda is pushed.
Those things are paid for. It is paid for with. OUR TAXES
This guest is so pompous even his voice and manner of talking is annoying and patronising.
He reminds me of J.P. Donleavy's definition of a psychiatrist....."This smug son of a bitch".
And there was me thinking the NHS was funded by huge taxation, universities by tuition fees and care homes are between 1k and 1.5k per week !!!!
This bloke is living on another planet. The public sector is supported by the private sector. Anyone knows how tough it is to run a business now. I have price increases of up to 9% coming from suppliers in the coming year. I can see spiralling inflation in a very short time.
Same I totally second that .
If he can't debate the topic at hand without attempting to insult the host then he's the weaker one for it all.
What a prat.
Beware those academics with books in the background.
dude doesnt realise taxes pay for everything. ppl pay for the nhs.
Far left group think..
Exactly, we pay for all services one way or another.
What an insufferable moron.
Just to educate you if It's at all possible.
Politicians and media commentators tell us that it comes from taxes. Taxes are collected and the government spends that money - until it’s all gone. At that point, ‘there’s no money left to fund nurses pay increases’. However, there’s a flaw in that understanding. That isn’t how currency-sovereign governments work. Taxes don’t pay for government spending.
So, what is the reality of it all?
In the UK, what happens in practice is that the government asks the Bank of England to spend whatever is required to fulfil their policy agenda. And, unlike the tax story told by politicians, the government can never run out of money. The UK government has a monopoly on the production of UK pounds and the Bank of England has a legal responsibility to respond to every government request. So, despite what you hear on your TV or read in our paper, lack of finance is never a barrier to government spending.
Not just taxes but gilts and loans i.e. Debt that future taxes pay for.
No private sector = no public sector.
Typical academic
Well done Christo.
It must be the fairies who pay for public services! What a 🤡
he deserved to be thrown off, the made has his head in the sand , completely sold out to the public sector. I don't know how long ago he worked in the private sector but doubt he was popular, too full of himself
Wow..I thought we had some really nutty Left-Wingers in the States. You boys and girls in the UK got us beat with this guy.
It’s great here, come and join us!
You're so lucky you're gonna have Trump again, his recent speeches have been the only sensible words for for 4 years.
For an academic he's pretty thick
I think he went to the University of Two Short Planks.
Bean counter- insufferable pratt
I wouldn't trust him to count beans
@@MartinParsons-tr6wiMe neither.
Condescending man. I couldn’t understand his argument. Isn’t it the private sector that pays for everything. That’s why the public sector are public servants.
What a stupid thig to say. We pay thrugh taxaton
Only the Private Sector pays income tax.
@@gordonhamilton727and pensioners
His constant grin and smiling tells it all - I had someone at work exactly the same ... his phrase was "you have a view, I have a view, but my view is right" and he genuinely believed that was always always the case because "he knew better than others" - insufferable ....
Got to be a candidate for plank of the week…see why he doesn’t work in the private sector
Haha 100%. Great comment.
This is just embarrassing 🙈
Murphy is an absolute clown.
In saying that you are clearly a dealer in cars with square wheels.
@@Ludus57 a.k a. Union puppet on the thread
He is a very rude person with very little people skills
‘wage increase for a civil servant is not inflationary ‘ ....whose paying them
How rude and arrogant
The public sector doesn’t pay into the system they take out, the money they receive comes from the private sector taxpayers.
We pay for everything with income tax, VAT, council tax, road tax, etc. etc.... the list is long.
Great job Cristo.
Horrid man.
Yes being against pay rises is abhorrent
The slip that portrays his real belief system: "Those things are provided FREE" - oh really 😂
The reason that the UK private sector is failing is it is run by accountants rather by people who know what they are talking about.
I totally agree with that. These people are just been counters.
WAT AN IGNORANT PRATT. CONDESCENDING N GLAD YOGOT RID !!!
Is this the same ‘economic expert’ who told Sturgeon and the SNP that their economic policies were sound and couldn’t fail for an independent Scotland?
Compare sick pay in public sector against the private sector it is frightening
Well done throwing him off your show...👍
Its so adorable that you think this is real.
ere Dori, so you siding with the howmoh?
@@Paddystinian1 What's a howmoh?
For much of his early career he was an accountant in Downham Market, Norfolk. In 1985 he co-founded an accountancy firm which became Murphy Deeks Nolan. The company was sold in 2000. Murphy was also the founder of a company that became the European distributor for the game Trivial Pursuit.[3] Murphy has since admitted that the manufacturing operation he set up in Ireland to manufacture Trivial Pursuit was there to avoid UK taxation, something of which he is now ashamed and was a turning point in his career towards anti-tax avoidance campaigning.
Loves the sound of his own voice , and prefers to talk at you, rather than to you.
Murphy has the most convoluted understanding of economics and the causes of inflation I've ever heard. Absolute rubbish...,,increased wages driven by a growing economy cannot increase inflation unless the money supply is increased by the Gov't.
What a terrible man
Your guest said "do you pay for NHS and Education?...No". Actually we do through taxes.
Very unprofessional from this former chartered accountant.
ICAEW don't like their members bringing them into disrepute. This joker is on thin ice.
Labour are taxing to death what little is left of our manufacturing industry, making us reliant upon China. This horrible, vindictive Murphy has praised Labour for their all-out assault on our farming industry. The UK cannot rely entirely upon foreign imports indefinitely. It can now only be a matter of time before there will be food shortages in the UK, as farmers are forced to cut back on essential investment and instead pay unrealistic, high inheritance taxes which will cripple family farms. Labour have also slapped hefty taxes on other inputs such as fertilizer, which farmers cannot re-coup from the big supermarkets due to farmers being price takers and not price makers.
Way to go Cristo! So happy to see you today - a real asset to the TalkTV!
Well Done Cristo--Merry Christmas btw.
Oh my god....Richard is very aggressive, I wouldn't have patience with him either
❤ brilliant good on you
Cristo, you are the man and I so respect you.. Well done Sir...
Well said Cristo
What a rude guest he needed telling and I am so glad you told him what a prat
Omg! He came on with attitude right from the start!
Richard Murphy's arrogance and condescending demeanour is off the scale.
Those services are not provided free they are funded by the taxpayer.
Well done Christo, right back in his box
NHS is free , what planet is he on ... what is national insurance, why do we pay it...
‘The state should be bigger’ - good grief
We have too many parasites as it is, who produce nothing but dung.
He only wants people to think Labour are not to blame.Does not understand that economy contracts if you attack job creators ie Private Sector
Dick Murphy, what a plick he is 👏
The Nhs Is not free, we pay for it.
Talks like a guy who never got a punch in the face.
Bet he got a list of volunteers now
@@waynegriffith9124
Lmao I’m ready to queue.
Yep never been slapped
😂😂
I think that’s long overdue 🤣😂🤣
What a nasty self opinionated man I have paid for all those things he lists. It’s called tax. I do not want this person on air again. Well done for throwing him off the show. Love your show Keep on doing what you are doing. Xx happy Xmas and new year
Well said christo that guy so annoying to listen to got to go thinks everything is free
That's just typical of these lefties. They aren't free, they are paid for by your money and mine.
What a arrogant piece of work, a big headed know all
He almost said "people to import" ... shows true labour colours
I'm all for a referendum to remove the Thames flood barrier.
Richard Murphy's grasp of economics of nil.
As is his grip on reality
And yours is even less.
@garyh1572 if you think Murphy is speaking the truth and is correct, then you have ZERO grasp of either!
@James_Rivett "Gary" is a public sector union troll.
@@James_Rivettgood, get him told!
So an ‘academic’ blames the private sector for the state of the economy! What a tool
I understand Richard Murphy is a professor at Sheffield University. I hope this isn't how he lectures his students.
You can’t handle the truth because the truth isn’t on your side 😂
Explains a lot 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏻! Get him back next year when the economy has tanked and show what nonsense he is spouting !
I'd imagine this is EXACTLY how he conducts his lectures - browbeating and bullying anyone who might dare to have a different opinion.
Universities are more like brainwashing factories these days. By the time they graduate, they have short crazy coloured hair and septum piercings.
Saying the government needs to spend more money is outrageous. Growth comes from saving and investments done by individuals and companies. A government can't actually ''grow'' an economy because it can only print, tax or borrow money in order to spend money in the first place. It can run a government monopoly but the incentive to make money by itself is supplanted by the political need to satisfy your supporters.
Oh for goodness sake they haven’t stopped spending money .The problem being its all going out of the country. There is not enough people in this country paying tax to support our large population.
No its not. £22 billion is going on carbon capture.