I just saw this film today at my local cinema. This is the type of film that makes you want to go to the movies. Outstanding! The audience left speechless.
I just went to see it. Everyone was speechless because it ended before there was any resolution and I thought "This is it?" when the screen went blank.
Saw this movie today.slow moving, quiet, powerful with injustice and raw emotions of pain and the fear of community to acknowledge whats on their doorstep. Powerful.
@mb4310 you say that, but some of the American reviews want me to tear my hair out. Completely missing the point thinking it will be more action fared or like the Magdalene laundries.
I saw this film yesterday...it is the type of film that stays with you....Murphy, I am sure, will get another Oscar nomination. Watson,, also , as supporting actress
An incredible book that has such a big impact through a small amount of writing. Claire Keegan is so talented and people should definitely read this book before watching the film.
The Magdalene sisters, made in 2002, by Peter Mullan, a Scottish director and actor, left me in a proper perpetual state, so much so I had to buy a book to delve deeper in to the subject. Fair play to the cast of the movie, those ladies truly brought it to life. No doubt Cillian will do a justice of delivering one of many horrific stories that went on behind those doors.
Guess you can't really understand what someone is going through unless you've been through it yourself. Maybe it doesn't necessarily make you more compassionate than someone who hasn't been through it, but it definitely gives you an inside perspective.
He's amazing so I went to the show this week. I had heard of this history, but I wasn't really sure what I was seeing until it ended. I was shocked that it only ended in 1998 and I was a 90s teen. A good reason to keep your daughters locked up and hidden away during their teen years. Well, it's a bit like Sleeping Beauty though you can't predict where the spinning wheels will be found if you catch my drift.
You multiply this Story 56 , 000 times . Jesus Christ for the Love of God , you begin to realise how effective the Catholic Church was in crippling Ireland for so long . As his wife says , you ignore what is going on to improve your lot in life . Fortunately the Moral Compass kicks in just in time . The question the audience is left with , Where is the accountability ? That is not Hindsight , That is being a breathing , living Human . Who is going to fight for the Victims ? It is the Church that must be made to feel the Shame that they have been so intent on making all of us feel .
한석봉. 내가 글을 쓸 테니 그대는 떡?을 썰어라. 가 아니라..내가 떡을 썰테니 석봉?이는 글을. 쓰거라. 어둠속에서 뭔..미친 짓을 동화로. 나온것처럼..Murphy..내가..놀아줄테니까..너는..디카 쟥..잭..처럼 안춥고 따뜻하다고. 착각하는 연습으로 버티거라. 이런 적선 느낌..하얀 눈밭보다..더 좋은..반가운 머피..좋으닷..강아지보다 좋으닷..춥게. 살아서 따뜻한 몸..머피..따뜻하게 살아서 오히려 너무 추운..?나..아무렇지않은척..웃어야되는데..그나저나..메밀묵 먹고 덜 지루하고 즐겁다고 아주 잠시라도 착각을 추천드려요. 나는..또 우연히..라도..찹쌀떡? 처럼 달콤한..머피의. 소통 적선을..즐기러..우연히라도 찹쌀떡..소리는 듣기싫은데 음식은 먹고 힘내고 싶어요. 몸이 아프니까 단게 땡기고 필수..그대는 건강하니까 안달고 안 자극적인 게 보고싶은? 또는 먹고싶은..느낌적인 느낌. 나는 찹쌀떡 그대는 메밀묵..이렇게 우리는..냉정과 열정 사이..로맨스..환상의 커플..나:찹쌀떡 (먹고싶어요)=Murphy:메밀묵 (추천드려요) 이참에 능력있으시면 음식을 바꿔보세요. 더 건강해져서..나랑 또 스푸너리즘. 대충..stumbling 해줘서..놀아주기..마치..디카트리오 오브제..견디기 쉽게.
Milking the "bad, evil, church" narrative for all its worth. This film is a story of personal trauma more than anything else. If anything, the nuns saved those girls, after their parents literally threw them out. They didn't have to, but they did.
It’s not that simple. The fledgling Irish state didn’t have the funds needed to support all the social services and entered into a symbiotic relationship with the Catholic Church, which gave the church unprecedented power. Societal and church pressure combined to create a highly repressive, misogynistic society.
I just saw this film today at my local cinema. This is the type of film that makes you want to go to the movies. Outstanding! The audience left speechless.
I just went to see it. Everyone was speechless because it ended before there was any resolution and I thought "This is it?" when the screen went blank.
Saw this movie today.slow moving, quiet, powerful with injustice and raw emotions of pain and the fear of community to acknowledge whats on their doorstep. Powerful.
Plsss plss read the book before watching. It's such a short novel, otherwise you might not get the full conext unless ur irish.
Agreed - read the book before seeing it ❤
Also agree!
You DO NOT need to read the book. The movie tells it's story beautifully. You will be fine, the story is UNIVERSAL.
@mb4310 you say that, but some of the American reviews want me to tear my hair out. Completely missing the point thinking it will be more action fared or like the Magdalene laundries.
@@rehnumachowdhury3629that’s just people wanting marvel movies. i’ll read after / cos i like going in blind
Emotive performance from Cillian, id love to see a film about the Irish famine, he'd be perfect ❤
I saw this film yesterday...it is the type of film that stays with you....Murphy, I am sure, will get another Oscar nomination. Watson,, also , as supporting actress
56000 young women affected (probably an underestimate) and, of course, their babies many found buried in mass graves
An incredible book that has such a big impact through a small amount of writing. Claire Keegan is so talented and people should definitely read this book before watching the film.
Can’t wait to see this film.
What excellent interview questions!
Cannot wait to see this film in the US
Save your money, it was torture with most of the movie having nothing to do with the main point. The trailer is nothing like the movie.
@@elizabethwilliams3813 why would you watch a film trailer before seeing a film like this?
It's worthwhile.
The Magdalene sisters, made in 2002, by Peter Mullan, a Scottish director and actor, left me in a proper perpetual state, so much so I had to buy a book to delve deeper in to the subject. Fair play to the cast of the movie, those ladies truly brought it to life. No doubt Cillian will do a justice of delivering one of many horrific stories that went on behind those doors.
I had nightmares from that movie
Guess you can't really understand what someone is going through unless you've been through it yourself. Maybe it doesn't necessarily make you more compassionate than someone who hasn't been through it, but it definitely gives you an inside perspective.
I'd love to see Cillian Murphy make a file from the book, "Plentiful Country: The Great Potato Famine and the Making of Irish New York."
Excellent movie, haunting my thoughts days after!
Want to see this in Australia 🌏
Saw the move last night and it was fantastic
Small Things Like These lingers with you long after the credits roll, that's for sure.
He's amazing so I went to the show this week. I had heard of this history, but I wasn't really sure what I was seeing until it ended. I was shocked that it only ended in 1998 and I was a 90s teen. A good reason to keep your daughters locked up and hidden away during their teen years. Well, it's a bit like Sleeping Beauty though you can't predict where the spinning wheels will be found if you catch my drift.
And I want to see this in Austria !
You multiply this Story 56 , 000 times . Jesus Christ for the Love of God , you begin to realise how effective the Catholic Church was in crippling Ireland for so long . As his wife says , you ignore what is going on to improve your lot in life . Fortunately the
Moral Compass kicks in just in time . The question the audience is left with , Where is the accountability ? That is not Hindsight , That is being a breathing , living Human . Who is going to fight for the Victims ? It is the Church that must be made to feel the Shame that they have been so intent on making all of us feel .
I can't see it as it's not showing in my area(cinema) but why is that? ❤
Hola soy iluminati ❤
한석봉. 내가 글을 쓸 테니 그대는 떡?을 썰어라. 가 아니라..내가 떡을 썰테니 석봉?이는 글을. 쓰거라. 어둠속에서 뭔..미친 짓을 동화로. 나온것처럼..Murphy..내가..놀아줄테니까..너는..디카 쟥..잭..처럼 안춥고 따뜻하다고. 착각하는 연습으로 버티거라. 이런 적선 느낌..하얀 눈밭보다..더 좋은..반가운 머피..좋으닷..강아지보다 좋으닷..춥게. 살아서 따뜻한 몸..머피..따뜻하게 살아서 오히려 너무 추운..?나..아무렇지않은척..웃어야되는데..그나저나..메밀묵 먹고 덜 지루하고 즐겁다고 아주 잠시라도 착각을 추천드려요. 나는..또 우연히..라도..찹쌀떡? 처럼 달콤한..머피의. 소통 적선을..즐기러..우연히라도 찹쌀떡..소리는 듣기싫은데 음식은 먹고 힘내고 싶어요. 몸이 아프니까 단게 땡기고 필수..그대는 건강하니까 안달고 안 자극적인 게 보고싶은? 또는 먹고싶은..느낌적인 느낌. 나는 찹쌀떡 그대는 메밀묵..이렇게 우리는..냉정과 열정 사이..로맨스..환상의 커플..나:찹쌀떡 (먹고싶어요)=Murphy:메밀묵 (추천드려요) 이참에 능력있으시면 음식을 바꿔보세요. 더 건강해져서..나랑 또 스푸너리즘. 대충..stumbling 해줘서..놀아주기..마치..디카트리오 오브제..견디기 쉽게.
It’s just a movie folks !
It's reality. The theocracy still rules/ruins lives.
Milking the "bad, evil, church" narrative for all its worth. This film is a story of personal trauma more than anything else. If anything, the nuns saved those girls, after their parents literally threw them out. They didn't have to, but they did.
If that's naive narrative you want to take.. well you are know better than the church
Why did their Parents throw them out? Because of sin in the eyes of the church.
bull
It’s not that simple. The fledgling Irish state didn’t have the funds needed to support all the social services and entered into a symbiotic relationship with the Catholic Church, which gave the church unprecedented power. Societal and church pressure combined to create a highly repressive, misogynistic society.
You have really missed the point of this film and should maybe read up on the wider context of what it was depicting