MAMAMOO - Yes I Am (Line Distribution)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2024
- What do you think about the line distribution of Yes I Am?
Don't miss any updates even on Twitter!
Follow me: ultimatekpop_
Song: Mamamoo - Yes I Am
Outro: Mamamoo - AZE GAG
Album: Purple (2017)
I do NOT own anything. All rights reserved to RWA Entertainment.
![[MV] 마마무(MAMAMOO) - '나로 말할 것 같으면(Yes I am)'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hTMlLDAclTI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MV] 마마무(MAMAMOO) - '나로 말할 것 같으면(Yes I am)'](/img/tr.png)
THIS SONG IS FUN AF. And Hwasa looks like a fucking queen
jiminism she is QueenTM
Like nope shes a literal queen since birth
For some reason Moonbyul's lines still stood out because of where her lines were positioned, making her presence in the song memorable.
Migikun more lines and no presence is not important .Her lines her rap is always memorable because it balance with the vocalist and add something else to the song♡
yes! i hate when people only look at the numbers and judge based off of that because it's way more complicated than who got the most seconds or highest percentage of lines in the song.
im a car Preach ! ! every part of the song was made to be ,whein soft voice contrast with solar and hwasa voice so she make the bg notes or adlibs who give texture to each of them voice ,plus it show how strong her vocals are ,while moonbyul rap is the key point of the song who connect all the vocal together !it's really well done . I mean it's 4 peeps signing least then 4 minute how can u do better ?
im a car Using WJSN: Cheng Xiao only sings "tell me why" on "I Wish" yet it's one of the catchiest parts in the song lol
Welp MAMAMOO'S presence is still better than BLACKPINK'S to me....
VOCALS ARE BETTER IN MAMAMOO
VISUALS ARE BETTER IN MAMAMOO
CONCEPT IS BETTER IN MAMAMOO
LINES IS FAIRER IN MAMAMOO
THERE COMBINING THERE TALENTS INSTEAD OF BATTLING EACHOTHER....
The song is distributed for what works for each song. It's different every time. You can't expect them to have equal parts every time if one song suits a certain person more than the other.
Ni Lam i personally believe they should just create a song fit for mamamoo not the other way around, where the line distribution is more equal
Hwasa just has this queenly vibe, like she won't hesitate to cut you
Also don't be salty that she gets a lot of lines, it's bc she sings and raps like joy from red velvet
She wouldn't hesitate to cut you, but she also wouldn't hesitate to hug the life out of you lol
It's better to use WJSN Exy as example because Joy's vocal ability is not good as Hwasa
XuanYi MeiQi Chinese Billianaire Couple that's true I guess but I'm just talking about both rapping and singing in general not talent wise but yes exy is very talented 😌
XuanYi MeiQi Chinese Billianaire Couple also the fact that joy usually gets most of the lines in rv due to that and so does hwasa and they're both lead rappers unlike exy
Hwasa is a baby offstage, wtf you on about lol
Hwasa, the longer the hair the longer the lines
lol
Sunshiner Fany lmaooo 😂😂👏👏👏
Sunshiner Fany ikr 😂
Sunshiner Fany OMG HAHAHAHA
YASSS GURRL HAHAHA
Hwasa is a singer and rapper while moonbyul is only a rapper and their style of rap is totally different, the song would be very different if Moonbyul take Hwasa's rap part. I think that's fair because Moonbyul has line as a a rapper, in some groups the main rapper as less lines than that.
(no hate i love both moonbyul and hwasa)
tbh, this song suits hwasa's raps really well
yes, i love it so much !!
I agree w this 100%, even if Moonbyul doesn't really have much, but I think it's kind of sufficient
Clara A but usually those groups consist of alot of members, while here each member gets around a minute of lines except moonbyul who always gets the least. Here, she only got 20 seconds which is way lower than the other members. For a group with only four members, the line distribution can be better.
Tiffany Huynh yes of course it could be better ! But I don't think it's Hwasa's fault, her rap is amazing and it suit the song so well !!
For the girlgroups I was thinking of Sistar and Girl's Day for example who are 4 and the rapper didn't get that much lines
me as a moonbyul stan *pretends to be shocked*
😂😂😂 same
MOONSTAR IS MINE DON TOUCH ME same
MOONSTAR IS MINE DON TOUCH ME I see you whenever there's a moonbyul related video and when there's a video about mmm that needs to be a meme
MOONSTAR IS MINE DON TOUCH ME same
Also Moonbyul is mine fight me
mamamoosun ღ WHAAAT REALLY???? I want to buy the album so I am avoiding spoilers, but now I am so tempted!!!
Its cause of their ad libs and harmonies and also on the live stage Moonbyul does all the Yes I Am parts live too
chill moonbyul had her own songs on the album XD
finally someone notice MAMAMOO beside BLACKPINK :')
Zahri Tsaniyal Baqy
Yes! :')
lol did you really have to comment this?
Usopp Sama because Mamamoo and Blackpink are having their comebacks at the same time, and everyone is making videos on Blackpink, not Mamamoo
we all know that in vocals, mamamoo slays... but blackpink is just so overrated right now, their comeback wasn't as good as this one in my opinion, but yeah, everyone stans the group that they like, in my case i love mamamoo so i hope they can win something with this comeback. #SupportMamamoo #SupportBlackpink
Tabi Magné Me, as a Blink I have to agree, AIIYL is one of their worst songs and I love this Comeback from Mamamoo.
Everyone complaining about the distribution but it really works for this song.
Moonbyul has good parts(+ a solo song on the album) and her rap sounds amazing so it's not really like she's under utilized or anything.
I think they separated it well for the style
Moonbyul lines are perfect! And this is coming from someone who is biased towards her a lot!
Hwasa raps and sings great??? And she's beautiful? She's perfect
Why are y'all complaining about Moonbyul having the least lines ? Most groups rappers don't even get more than 10 seconds, or 1 part, whereas Moonbyul gets 2 parts and nearly 28 seconds! Also, SHE IS RAPPING, NOT SINGING. Rappers go through their lines much quicker than singers. Also, there are no main/lead vocalists, or main/lead rappers. Mamamoo are rappers, vocalists and dancers. There is no lead or main at all, and they've said this themselves. So please, stop complaining about Moonbyuls rapper lines. It's not fair to compare them to vocalist lines. Just enjoy the song, I'm sure that is wanted MMM would like. Not people arguing about a bunch of lines.
IdrysLTS but the thing is she complained about this alry 😂😂😂😂 but i get your point. lets just enjoy the music.
When she complained she said 4 min performance with only one part (that is when she feels awkward that means it doesn't have dance as well) so that only apply to immortal ballad songs and the other one I can think off is Love Lane (in which she didn't have lines in the original song), ... but I don't think it is a problem now as they gave her more lines than the vocal line in their latest immortal ballad song.
Good job idrys
And also she is the main dancer so she does get PLEANTY of spotlight!
I understand why everyone is upset bc Moonbyul didn't get nearly as many lines (she is my UB so I particularly understand the pain).. HOWEVER, she got an ENTIRE SONG to herself where she raps AND SINGS!!! I know some are upset that Hwasa is rapping instead of Moonbyul in certain parts but Hwasa has such a unique sound to her rap, and if Moonbyul did it, it wouldn't have the same effect! Also, I'm seeing some comments about Wheein not having many noticeable parts and again, she got a whole song to herself on the EP. RBW knows what they're doing with these girls, and they're clearly happy with how it's going. We should all just support MMM as much as possible because they deserve to be topping every chart possible. Hwaiting Mamamoo 💖💖
the "yes i am" is MoonStar's line
MoonByhul*
@@astiantorianto2265 Moonbyul*
WOW HWASA KILLING IT
sigh. i knew it...wheein got the least prominent lines.
(and yes, moonbyul. but like someone mentioned below, the way her lines were positioned, her lines stood out)
oh well, maybe next time. fighting, Mamamoo.
even if wheein had the least lines she had the chorus which stood out to me and I'm sure many others.
*shares the chorus with the others :(
but okay. I'll stop. i think i'm annoying people, semi ranting about this :P
Rabea Sarwar she may have the least lines as vocal in the group but she has many featuring songs than the other 3 members lol.
Rabea Sarwar she had her moderato in the memory album. she had darada in purple album.
MOONSTAR IS MINE DON TOUCH ME
don't mind me. I'm just being sad and whiny. :p
And I know. I love them both! wish the public would love them more too
I DON'T CARE IF BYULIE GETS LESS LINES BECAUSE LITERALLY EVERY PIECE OF HER RAP IS ICONIC SO
Hwasa is the lead rapper so I think it’s fair they gave her a rap
Hwasa is so beautiful and you cant say you dont agree
Always agreee
First💕 I love this song💜
get it hwasa
Hwasa queen ♡
So far all 'Yes I am' line distribution videos thumbnails are moonbyul❤️ cutie pie
Some of y'all need to chill the reason why moonbyul didn't get as many lines this time I'd because she has her own Like 2-3 minute song on the album and even then moonbyul got more lines than normal. Stop complaining about this it's really dumb, her lines are positioned in the song to where she doesn't even need that many but she actually is remembered for it cause they are in the place where everyone will remember where she is.
I dont think thats why she has the least lines if you compare to other albums but i agree with where her lines are positioned
Tiffany Huynh she's a rapper. Rappers usually have the least time on the songs because they take more breath and use a lot of words in a short time. That's normal
I hate when people complain about the line distributions, like tbh they all had a good amount of lines tbh and all of their lines stood out (to me at least). And for everyone complaining about Byul's lines, you guys ... she's a RAPPER!! Of course she most likely has least lines because she only raps and when you rap you say words faster unlike singers who draw out the words and hit notes. The reason why Hwasa has the most lines is because she both sings and raps in this song. I mean at least Moonbyul wasn't a Bora and had what I would say a good amount and well placed lines for a rapper (I loved bora of SISTAR but starship did her dirty with those little 10 secs they gave her in EVERY song! Luckily this isn't moonbyul's case). Plus Byul had her own full song on the album so I feel that's fair enough. Now can we all just chill and enjoy this bop by these four amazing queens!!!
Hwasa run the song so bad. And i love it!!!
Although Moonbyul has the least lines, her voice is really distinct and stands out, so having a smaller distribution makes her part more tasteful and memorable in my opinion :)
hwasa ❤
No matter what, I stan Moonbyul
Short or long lines it doesn't matter. They all did a great job. They even broke a record bc of this song (Unique listeners for the past 24hrs on melon they're the first girl group to do, so proud of my QUEENS)
MAMAMOO FIGHTING!! 💪🏼🔥
There's a part in Hwasa's first verse where Moonbyul hypes her for 0.2 seconds. You see her lips moving in the group shot around 0:48(?). And she sings this part as well in the live stages.
Some people have been saying that Moonbyul's and Jisoo's cases are completely different and rappers rap fasters than singer sing...but both of them got to sing half of one verse + 1/4 of one verse for Jisoo and 1/2 of the bridge for Moonbyul (both are about the same long)
FINALLY
that looks very fair! :)
one of the the good things we have about this era is that we finally get a moonbyul solo 😁😁
Calm Down guys!
Moonbyul have a solo in the new mini album ♡
They should of just given the "yes I am" parts to Moonbyul so it would of been a little even.
Ferrari_98 they gave it to her on the live version
Actually, she is the one that says it, just this user didn't include it.
Moonbyul was singing (yes i am) every time
thanks for the LD but i am so disappointed moonbyul my bias has gotten last in every song except for one which im not sure about can u please do a line distribution for Girl Crush by mamamoo i want to see if she makes it to third place
she got more lines in 1 cm and dabdab. the other songs? less than 20 secs lol.
she had her own song on the album so i think its fair XD
brian nugroho fair point
Anthony Azuike rappers usually get the least lines because their parts are a little more complicated and takes a lot of breath. Moonbyul is great in this MV. She almost her own song inside it.
Anthony Azuike but she got her own song on the album
fair enough
I'm a Byul bias but I think the line distribution is fair. To other stans stop being immature lmao, Mamamoo themselves contributed to the lyrics, so they themselves know who will fit this and that. Don't be like other fandoms pls. Let's support all members and don't let the unnecessary jealousy come into you. Never say bad things to other members or put unnecessary hate just because Byul had the least lines. Byul herself would be dissapointed of you knowing how much she cares for her members. I don't want our fandom to be divided. She already got her solo so RBW is definitely listening to her concerns ok?
Agree!. hwasa is also rapper why she can’t rap? Ridiculous thinking!
Moonbyul slayed the song it's totally her style
Îs wheein the visual or smt????She îs și beautiful !!!Solar moonbyul and hwasa slay So much too
moonbyul has a sing line now in paint me
I think moonbyul had a fair amount of lines, let's not forget she raps
Wow this looks quite fair.
that feeling when everybody sang for at least 20 secs and youre still stuck in 1.5...and that feeling when 2 of them reached a minute and you're not even halfway
MOONBYUL ,GOD DAMN ,PLEASE SING !!!!!
In the live performance, the "yes I am" part is sang my moonbyul
I really like this line distribution PLUS wheein did a duet and Moonbyul has her own song on the album!
That's probably why they have the least lines
MY NAME IS MOONSTAR
moonbyul sings the "yes I am" parts
Hwasa... She is always the most
No she is not always most line did you listen all of their song?
moonbyul is shaking
Moonbyul looks like SinB on thumbnail
Y'all complain on moonbyuls lines but she got a solo on the album and her lines in this song are like the ones that stand out the most so sush.
All the 'Yes I am's are by MB
WHy line distribution are not counting Yes Iam as Moonbyul's part 'cause in lives she sing this part - and, althought the voice is distorted in the song for the MV/CD - is her voice.
Moonbyul also says all the "yes I am" and a bunch of lines throughout the singing
I would say that this song is actually really fair
MOONBYUL ! MY QUEEN 😍👑
Stop complaining! Moonbyul has won a solo song on the album, this is a good.
wheeIn tho 😍
If rbw actually let byul sing (which is actually what they trained her for) shed have more lines but more lines and no presence idnt important tbh
3:07
chill byul stans. even if byul's line is only "my name is moonstar" "my baby" fan girls will still scream her name. lets enjoy the music alright ;)
edit: also i think Yes I Am is fairer than in Mr. Ambigous lol. bye.
Well, as a rapper line stan, even though Moonbyul has the least line distribution, her part is the always one that stands out.
so fair😱😍
You guys need to chill about my ByulE
don't forget that moonbyul got a solo in their album! go listen :D
Solar,Wheein,Hwasa- Yes I Am (ft. Moonbyul)
wheein and moonbyul got least line but they got solo.. chill guys
At least Moonbyul sings the Yes I am part live on stage so it kind of evens out
poor wheein
remember guys, moonbyul has her own full song on the album too !!
But it’s not popular as the other girls solos especially now
hi
moonbyul gets the least lines in mamamoo. but if she debuted in a different group, she would have been their main vocal and would get the most lines cos shes good at singing as well. but, shes perfect in this group and her lines are special so no worries. shes my bias anyways. 😊
Mae Mae A Main vocal??
poor moonbyul they always give him few lines, he could sing ma since he has a nice voice
@The Fangirl yes, she is a good vocal. FOR ME
@The Fangirl
didn't you hear an eclipse ??
@The Fangirl
For me, but if you don't like it, there's nothing wrong, that's fine
@The Fangirl
ohh sorry, I speak Spanish but I use the translator, I may be wrong
can u make one using a live performance? thank youuu
Poor Moonbyul :(
hwasa got 69 seconds... the perfect number lol
EXID's BLINK lol
Nice
And your comment 96 like now
I messed it up xD
3:11 banana;)
Why are all Mamamoo lines all evenly spread out? As for Moonbyul, she is the lead dancer as well so you would expect it.
Using this to learn their names lol.
Why has no one talked about how Moonbyul and WheeIn sing/ say the say "Yes I Am" during the live versions
Pobre moonbyul 😢😢😭
i see byul i click lol...am such a trash 😂😂😂
As a moonbyul trash, I dont really care if she has the least line, atleast she get to do a little bit of singing in the song and it was focused on her. And she get to have a song in the album just for her
moonbyul deserves more lines
Justice for moonbyul!!!!
I swear Moonbyul gets the least lines in all Manamoo songs~ PLEASE give her some extra lines~!
Moonbyul is the new Jisoo 😂😂 they are almost the same in both seconds and percentages 😂
Lol now I'm gonna get so much hate for "comparing" them bye
But Moonbyul is the rapper, so her lines get noticed more and are faster than singing line, that's why she always is the last, while in blackpink the rappers (in this case just lisa) are always (as far as I remember) first, which makes the line distribution even unfairer, because they have way more lines than the singers if you don't watch just the seconds they get (poor Jisoo...)
from the distributions ive seen of them, Jennie, Lisa and Rose each get like 25 if not more percent of the song and then Jisoo is all the way in the back
Chichu the Chicken it's funny and sad at the same time. i hope Jisoo gets more line in their next song.
It would make more sense if you said that Jisoo is the new Moonbyul since Mamamoo debuted first but since both groups still exist they're on the same level and one of them didn't get replaced but I'm probably just analyzing your comment too much lol
Chichu the Chicken wait let me correct jisoo is the new moonbyul because mamamoo debuted before BLACPINK😃. No hate tho
i think the distribution was quite fair...byul stans need to chill... don't forget she's a rapper... she speaks 12 words in 2seconds in her raps while the girls sing 5 words for 30 seconds...more seconds mean more words for a rapper n it gets complicated...also people saying she could have been a main vocal in another group are just too delusional unless u r really aiming for her to go b part of "visual" groups with no solid vocal lines...i get that she has a pleasant tone but her singing is nowhere near main vocal worthy...yes she is good with low notes n can hold a tune but do u guys really think she can outsing yuju or eunji or jihyo or wendy or any main vocal of other group for that matter...?...like i get mamamoo is talented but at the end of the day... mamamoo has 3 outstanding singers n 2 amazing rappers n (2 impromptu informal rappers)...just call spade a spade...moonbyul got fair amount of lines for a rapper...other rappers barely get 10sec for rapping...n her singing is below average no matter how much pleasing u like her voice...thats just the truth....lets not get too carried away with the delusions folks....
moonbyul had her own songs on the album so they purposely cut her lines
ah..is this the reason moonbyul join that deep blue eyes program?
*pretends to be shocked that moonbyul is last* every moomoo or even a normal mamamoo fan knows that moonbyul is last because shes a rapper :)))))))) im extra gay for hwasa now
very unfair for moonbyul
To those complaining, watch their lives lmao.
Nct 127 cherry bomb?
Muhamed avdol!!!!!! ?????