I know I keep commenting this, but I truly can't commend you enough for these videos. These are the most important videos people in the market for smart watches should be watching.
This channel beats any so-called pro tech channels hands down. This is the real methodology coming from a real scientist not from a tech junk. I have recommended this channel to all of my friends and family members. I am really hoping that you will get calls from apple and samsung very soon. Best of luck sir. Hats off to you. Love from India
It is CRAZY how the AW’s sleep stage tracking can be so accurate considering how infrequently the AW measures heart rate during the night. This indicates that wrist movement on its own is a great proxy for sleep stages. A perfect example of machine learning opening humans’ eyes to the potential of hidden correlations. Regarding GPS tracking, I think that for running Apple is relying more on the accelerometer to measure distance and pace than on GPS. Whoever has used the Stryd pod knows that accelerometers are better than GPS.
I've never used Apple products but it may be time to ditch the Android and Fitbit. Fitbit wants to charge monthly premiums for what's basically bad data. Apple has obviously put a lot of time and money into their health metrics on their AW. It's very impressive to see what they're able to do with sensor data on your wrist. I wish the battery life was better and it's cool that the AW Ultra has extended battery but my guess is they need to burn more power to get good sensor data. If you don't have good sensor data how can you have any kind of accurate health metrics? Apple is not only getting good data but they're figuring out how to write the software to use it most effectively. It's very impressive and I think it's time for me to just bite the bullet and learn how to use Apple products.... And how about this guy's channel? Apple should be paying him because he's not a fanboy and is simply showing their product capabilities. It's actually crazy how much better Apple is than Garmin and Fitbit when it comes to accuracy.
@@ericy1005 i agree, accuracy is the only thing that makes me want to buy apple watch. I don't like iphones, but for watch you have to buy. This is the only thing holding me back. I'm not gonna buy a phone just for using watch.
You are the best reviewer ever. People need to know that blindly buying any cheap smartwatch (especially those *sponsored* ones in amazon , flipkart etc) that shows inaccurate information is such a waste and why Apple indeed makes the most scientifically proven smartwatches that can really save lives..and has saved many already :)
Yeah since this thing will die sooner or later buying the inaccurate one is just dumb better buy real watch at that point. Sadly i will never own apple products just out of my principle, since their stance on repair is just horrible.
Issue here is you cannot activate an Apple Watch without an Apple device. That alone steers the vast majority of people away and makes the Apple Watch a tie-in purchase. I only want to use the watch. I have no interest in being part of the Apple ecosystem.
I rarely comment on UA-cam videos, but I wanted to say you’re doing a great job comparing these devices. Looking at your numbers makes it a lot easier to ignore all the marketing noise and the multitude of uninformed opinions on the internet. Thanks!
This is a proper review. Tired of other channels talking how good are their trackers without comparing them to a professional one. Keep the good work coming!
Thank you so much for this analysis, Rob! After watching it, I decided to buy the SE 2022, and after 3 months of use, I'm quite satisfied with its performance.
Hey man, I just discovered his channel and I really like it! I'm looking for the best sleep tracker, has he ever said which one it is?
Рік тому+3
Do you think an SE is better than Series 7. I think a lot of people interested in getting a new apple watch might want to know which one of these 2 is a better pick.
This guy is by far the best you tube reviewer I've seen in a long long time... Totally unbiased & driven purely by data from thorough scientific analysis. Buddy is there a patreon where I can support you?
would like to see additional test on running and swimming hr. No worries about retesting all the previous models, but use a few common ones as a starting point would be great!
I am an android user since I had my first smartphone and now is srsly thinking of getting apple watch just because of how great the sleep tracking is but I know It would have incompatibilities with my phone (pixel) I'm just hoping the pixel watch would at least good as the apple watch or better than fitbit devices
@@Hlphlia.Mtnoia I wouldn’t count on it since the pixel watch is basically Fitbit. Fitbit was very inaccurate. I have a very big friend who doesn’t move much if at all during the day yet they have more steps than me by far. I have an active job. Maybe my Apple Watch is the inaccurate one and the fit bit is accurate who knows 😂.
Aww yeah part of me wants to be optimistic for the pixel watch but then reality kicks in that apple devices are more often than not is the superior. I own fitbit inspire 2 and noticed how it counts steps that I didn't take, for example I would wake up from my sleep and see that I have 32 steps when I was sleep the whole time? 😂
One of my curiosity is wether if the new SE 2022 can understand wether you are riding an e-bike or a normal bike, considering different calorie burn rates...
Insane good reviews, Rob! Will you also do one for the new Amazfit lineup? Allegedly, they heavily upgraded their sensors (and now support chest HR straps via bluetooth) and the Watches were always interesting aside from the weak sensors.
I follow you since the very beginning and think you’re the best wearable reviewer out there, especially for the accuracy of your scientific and statistical approach. However, for the sake of the quality of your videos, I would really appreciate to see bigger samples in your “full scientific reviews”. For example, a sleep monitoring test with a sample of two nights may be more appropriate for an “early scientific review”. I know the new Apple Watches have just been released and it’s a very hot topic right now, but on the other hand it’s difficult to understand the overall precision of a tracker in so little time. I’m writing this “critical” comment because I really think your videos are the gold standard for any wearable user!
how is this channel not on the same subscriber count as MKBHD or MrWhosetheboss?? you give INSANE value to viewers! keep up the good work, used your amazon links to buy some stuff - hope it helps!
Can you specify if you used the GPS + Cellular watch or the GPS only watch? This is mostly for the GPS tracking portion of the video. Also thanks for the comprehensive review and statistics comparisons
Since the time I have found your channel I have not looked at any other tech channel or review for smart watches. This is all that's needed and anytime I am thinking of buying anything you are the first point to check. Absolutely fabulous 🎉 .
Man, I love this reviews, they are so precise, and the best of all is that you compare results with other devices, which at the end of the day is what matters the most 💪
I have an Apple Watch ultra and just picked up a 2nd gen SE for sleep tracking because the ultra is a bit too heavy on my wrist. This is such a great review!
Appreciate your thorough work! Does the calorie counter work similarly between the Apple Watch SE and Series 8? Or does the blood oxygen monitor provide a more reliable calorie expenditure measurement?
22:16 this reminds very much of when I play the piano while wearing my Fitbit inspire 3. It would pretty much always count A LOT of false steps. Had to take the watch of my wrist. Haven’t tried it my Apple Watch SE 2022 so far. Edit: The Apple Watch has the same curse as the Fitbit. It’s like it counts every key on the piano I press as a step.
So I fully understand it doesn't have ECG, but single lead ECG is not that accurate anyway, but I know Apple watch has the ability to warn you of irregular heart rate issues which have nudged people to the doctors to get full tests and is great pre Warner. Is the SE good enough to potentially give you the warnings you need to get checked out? I love to hear your thoughts on this matter?
@@pursnikitty I think like you mention it does, but ide love for these guys who review these products to look into this aspect deeper, as I feel for lots of people not knowing what Irregular heart rate detection can actually pick up on, like for example it can be a pre Warner for Afib or even a MI I think it is really important and for people with a family history or personal history of heart conditions is something they should understand more, testers always go into the ECG side of things but whilst it's a handy tool, it's limitations are it's a 1 lead ECG, most hospitals even prefer 12 lead Vs the 9 lead I've worked with in the ambulance service. With articles out there stating Apple watch Samsung watch saved my life people are not realising that it's the heart rate irregular detection thats mainly been the alert that gets people to their docs or hospital. Nice to know the 3 has it 👍
Thank you again for your work! In the spirit of most scientific methodology-do you account for different bands across Apple Watches, or do you use a standard, single band for all testing to equalize any potential fitting differences which might impact accuracy rather than the sensors themselves tracking differently? Put another way, you do standardize Apple Watch testing using a single band for all testing, or has each Apple Watch been tested with different band types inserting potential differences in fit across tracking? Given that all Apple Watches seem to perform similarly, I imagine the difference may not be huge, but I wonder how it may alter results (one way or another), if at all?
Got a brand new Apple Watch SE 2nd Gen for $150...waiting on it being delivered. My primary hope is to replace my Garmin Forerunner, which I use for all of my running. The only thing I'm a little worried about is the battery life of the SE 2. Outside of that, it just seems in every capacity it's a far better watch from a running/fitness perspective than any of the low-range Garmin (e.g., like the forerunner 45). Plus, all of the integrative features within the Apple ecosystem for productivity and general use with my iPhone.
I ve always been saying the same thing but i dont care im saying it again, you are the best (by light years) yt channel on smartwatches and u need more recognition a lot more!! I even ( for fun) tried to find something bad in your videos couldnt , editing/infos/clarity of the infos… EVERYTHING is there and well explained. I wish you all the best bro
I typically do NOT comment on videos, but I absolutely love your analysis! I was, "on the fence" about purchasing the 8 or the SE 2022 and after your review the SE 2022 seems like a better fit for me. THANK YOU~
This channel is SOOO GOOD, I am such a data person so you to put this information out in such a readable and understandable way is amazing! I also love how you included the first Generation SE watch. I had no idea there was too but I’m happy to see the first generation isn’t to far behind the new 2022! I would love to have the ECG and I work in a cardiology office however I love the sleep tracking now with the REM, Core & deep sleep function. Thank you!!
I also looked up some specs and it seems they have mostly (looks like different “S” Chips) the same specs! I’m hoping that means it works the same! Thank you again
Hi Rob, there is one more thing I would like to see in your reviews. Can you mention about the maximum frequency of measurement of health metrics in continuous tracking mode (7/24) ? How frequent can the device measure metrics like heart rate, blood oxygen, temperature, etc ? Usually this info is not given by the manufacturer and we only find it out after we buy and when we start using the device and its app.
Thank you very much for making this video. I’ve been comparing the Apple Watch SE 2022 and the Fitbit Inspire 3 the last couple of days (I just got the Apple Watch as it will replace my Fitbit). I noticed quite a bit deviation especially when it comes to sleeptracking. Your video cleared up a lot of questions I had 😄.
Lieber Rob, dass wäre so schön wenn du die ganze Videos auch mal auf deutsch drehen würdest. Ich kenne vielen die nicht Englisch können aber möchten gerne über deine Tests mehr verstehen und bessere Entscheidungen bei Kauf von Smartwatches zutreffen.
Hi Rob, I am totally impressed by the work you are doing. Could you add a short information to your reviews on how long the battery lasts during your tests and how often you need to recharge the batteries? One sentence and your subjective opinion would be absolutely enough. I think then your tests would be complete.
thank you bro apple se 2 is on sale here in DK so i was planning to buy the garmin instinct 2 but now im going with apple se 2 as im a kidney transplant patient with high blood pressure so always wanna have a accurate sensor watch for my heart rate
You really are a legend, I have been waiting for this video ever since you said the se was getting another review. This has definitely helped me choose the best watch so thank tou
I like your channel because you show actual facts if the claims of the watch are actually accurate! I don't like tech influencer speaking only about personal opinions on a device.
Please test the fitbit sense 2 when it comes out as it will be my sons birthday present for his 18th birthday and I want to truly know of its good for him. Thank you and love your vids, keep up the hard work.
Hey! Thanks so much for those videos, so useful...currently trying to decide between a Google Pixel watch and the fitbit sense 2...are you going to review them? 🤞🙏🏻
Great job on these videos. Nice to see someone actually reviewing the health tracking of these watches not just the features they offer. I'm really surprised by apple's new sleep tracking. Will you review the new Fitbit Sense 2? I'm really curious how it compares to the original Sense, which has really bad HR monitoring (especially during workouts)
@@TheJoy___ right now it is the apple watch. They just released an algorithm based on Machine Learning that is currently the vast sleep analysis algorithm in a watch. If you don't have an iPhone or don't want an apple watch, then a FitBit is the best choice for sleep tracking.
Thank you for providing this information to the public! I can say that your videos have really helped me improve my life over the past years (with the help of your reliable information!)
I love the Apple Watch Health tracking. The only issue I have is when it’s tracking steps. As I am a full time wheelchair user, I have my watch set to pushes instead of steps. However, I do seem to get many steps during my day. Don’t know why this happens & i’m not sure if that effects my pushes count. Do other wheelchair users have this happen to them
@@gbasar1032 I do love my Apple Watch. It does really help me manage my disability pretty well. The steps issue is the only thing that iv’e noticed, but I just ignore them. I should submit feedback to Apple
@@WheelieGayJay hey, don't call yourself disabled. I didn't say anything because I don't want to sound cliche and all but I really admire you. And okay, I will buy one, probably SE 2 since it fits my budget well and only recently I bought iphone 13 also so am very new to the ecosystem. Can you please reply one last time about battery life? I mean I know the watch has to be charged daily but what I mean is that the watch will last 2-3 years right? I am not rich or above middle class so if I invest good amount of my money, I would appreciate if the product lasts for some time. :)
I rarely subscribe to youtubers much less comment, but your approach to review is what I was exactly looking for! It helped me chose this watch for me and my dad. Tysm! I would also like to request, is it possible to retest the older version of the apple watches since, it can be that better tracking might also be a result of new os 9 which might have under the hood improvements for new and refined algorithm for sleep tracking? Would love to see that comparison! Anyways cheers mate! Keep those reviews coming
Really impressive level of detail, data and clarity. The deepest and most comprehensive review of these types of devices that I’ve seen anywhere. Very well done. The historic comparisons to other watches are also very helpful. I don’t quite get your comment on steps while weight lifting, though: presumably you have to walk between exercises as you get off the bench, change weights, change exercise, etc - surely those are legitimate steps. Or am I missing something!?
Hey, great content, thanks! Just wondering, did you ever do some research on the ECG and Bloodpressure functions? For many people I think it would be quite relevant before buying.
Hey, thanks for the great video. Very well explained and nice graphics to show the results. I was just wondering: which software do you use to create these nice graphics? Do you program them yourself or is there any software out there for that? Thanks!
Hi. Which watch in your opinion is close to accuracy calorie counting algorithm. I know none of them are 100% accurate, but some are definitely better than others.It is important for me.Not necessarily just the ones from this review .... considering everything you've dealt with
The best smart watch review channel period! Numbers and stats don’t lie! Thank you for making this video now i know which apple watch i am going for. 😎
I just bought the apple watch se2 (upgraded from a series 3) and ws wondering how accurate the sleep tracking was because the data I get from autosleep is different but I'm now relieved and will trust apple.
Thanks for your amazing videos! I have used a Fitbit inspire 2 for a few months, I am mainly interested in sleep tracking. I have now purchased an Apple Watch SE (WatchOS 10) because, according to your tests, it seemed more precise on sleep tracking. Since a few days, I am testing both devices when I sleep (one per wrist) and, at least for recognizing awake time, in my experience the Fitbit works better: when I am in bed, trying to get asleep, breathing deeply, both the devices tend to mistake this as "light sleep" (even if I am sure I am awake), for the AW, however, this error seems much more evident. Also, during the night, the Fitbit record several micro awake periods that AW does not, I can't say which device is wrong, though. Any comments, advice or settings I could have missed? I am thinking about returning the AW (I am not very interested in the other smartwatch features) and continue using the Fitbit but I would like to be sure I am using the most reliable sleep tracker of the two. Thanks again!
As a pre-doctoral data scientist, I love to see people actually analysing data rather than reading out the manufacturers specs. Thank you!
So true! I'm only a college student, but if I want specs, I'll check them out myself. These videos are great!
I know I keep commenting this, but I truly can't commend you enough for these videos. These are the most important videos people in the market for smart watches should be watching.
Thanks so much Devon!😊
@@TheQuantifiedScientist You're welcome!
The best reviewer! Nothing like this on UA-cam
💯
I’m glad I found your channel, best review and test for smart watch.
This channel beats any so-called pro tech channels hands down. This is the real methodology coming from a real scientist not from a tech junk. I have recommended this channel to all of my friends and family members. I am really hoping that you will get calls from apple and samsung very soon. Best of luck sir. Hats off to you. Love from India
It is CRAZY how the AW’s sleep stage tracking can be so accurate considering how infrequently the AW measures heart rate during the night. This indicates that wrist movement on its own is a great proxy for sleep stages. A perfect example of machine learning opening humans’ eyes to the potential of hidden correlations. Regarding GPS tracking, I think that for running Apple is relying more on the accelerometer to measure distance and pace than on GPS. Whoever has used the Stryd pod knows that accelerometers are better than GPS.
It does make sense, the GPS can only be so accurate and won’t pick up on if you’re not walking or running in a straight line
I've never used Apple products but it may be time to ditch the Android and Fitbit. Fitbit wants to charge monthly premiums for what's basically bad data. Apple has obviously put a lot of time and money into their health metrics on their AW. It's very impressive to see what they're able to do with sensor data on your wrist. I wish the battery life was better and it's cool that the AW Ultra has extended battery but my guess is they need to burn more power to get good sensor data. If you don't have good sensor data how can you have any kind of accurate health metrics? Apple is not only getting good data but they're figuring out how to write the software to use it most effectively. It's very impressive and I think it's time for me to just bite the bullet and learn how to use Apple products.... And how about this guy's channel? Apple should be paying him because he's not a fanboy and is simply showing their product capabilities. It's actually crazy how much better Apple is than Garmin and Fitbit when it comes to accuracy.
@@ericy1005 i agree, accuracy is the only thing that makes me want to buy apple watch. I don't like iphones, but for watch you have to buy. This is the only thing holding me back. I'm not gonna buy a phone just for using watch.
For me Apple Watch sleep isn’t tracking accurately. It really depends on the person and algorithm
@@wayne1516 how come ?
You are the best reviewer ever. People need to know that blindly buying any cheap smartwatch (especially those *sponsored* ones in amazon , flipkart etc) that shows inaccurate information is such a waste and why Apple indeed makes the most scientifically proven smartwatches that can really save lives..and has saved many already :)
Thanks so much Ripunjoy 😄
Yeah since this thing will die sooner or later buying the inaccurate one is just dumb better buy real watch at that point. Sadly i will never own apple products just out of my principle, since their stance on repair is just horrible.
Hey man, I just discovered his channel and I really like it! I'm looking for the best sleep tracker, has he ever said which one it is?
@@TheJoy___ currently the apple watch itself is the best one haha
Issue here is you cannot activate an Apple Watch without an Apple device. That alone steers the vast majority of people away and makes the Apple Watch a tie-in purchase. I only want to use the watch. I have no interest in being part of the Apple ecosystem.
I rarely comment on UA-cam videos, but I wanted to say you’re doing a great job comparing these devices. Looking at your numbers makes it a lot easier to ignore all the marketing noise and the multitude of uninformed opinions on the internet. Thanks!
This is a proper review. Tired of other channels talking how good are their trackers without comparing them to a professional one. Keep the good work coming!
Awesome stuff Rob. Nice to see someone that is actually testing these devices not just saying a few keynote stats from Apple. Just ordered an SE 2022!
How are you liking it?
Was considering the SE2 but then I got a series 7 for less than the price of the SE2 👀
Hi Lars! Yeah, that is a good choice!😊
@@TheQuantifiedScientist is the ECG on the SE better than the series 7?
Don't forget to test again the Mi band 7 and huawei band 7 because there are new firmwares that you did not have on your early testing of both bands.
Please re-check measurements for apple watch 6-7 because measuring algorithms might be updated for older watches as well
Thank you so much for this analysis, Rob! After watching it, I decided to buy the SE 2022, and after 3 months of use, I'm quite satisfied with its performance.
Only problem for me is battery life how long do you get I know they advertise 18 hours but do you get more or less as I want to wear it to sleep
You never let us down Rob. Thanks again for such a comprehensive review.
Hey man, I just discovered his channel and I really like it! I'm looking for the best sleep tracker, has he ever said which one it is?
Do you think an SE is better than Series 7. I think a lot of people interested in getting a new apple watch might want to know which one of these 2 is a better pick.
Finally a review for SE. I really like the technicality of your reviews. Keep it up.
This guy is by far the best you tube reviewer I've seen in a long long time... Totally unbiased & driven purely by data from thorough scientific analysis. Buddy is there a patreon where I can support you?
Was waiting for this to come out before buying it. Thank you for posting so quickly!
Hope you enjoy it Nathan!😊
would like to see additional test on running and swimming hr. No worries about retesting all the previous models, but use a few common ones as a starting point would be great!
Would be super interesting to see how the upcoming Google Pixel Watch compares against all the other wearables you tested.
I am an android user since I had my first smartphone and now is srsly thinking of getting apple watch just because of how great the sleep tracking is but I know It would have incompatibilities with my phone (pixel) I'm just hoping the pixel watch would at least good as the apple watch or better than fitbit devices
@@Hlphlia.Mtnoia I wouldn’t count on it since the pixel watch is basically Fitbit. Fitbit was very inaccurate. I have a very big friend who doesn’t move much if at all during the day yet they have more steps than me by far. I have an active job. Maybe my Apple Watch is the inaccurate one and the fit bit is accurate who knows 😂.
Aww yeah part of me wants to be optimistic for the pixel watch but then reality kicks in that apple devices are more often than not is the superior. I own fitbit inspire 2 and noticed how it counts steps that I didn't take, for example I would wake up from my sleep and see that I have 32 steps when I was sleep the whole time? 😂
One of my curiosity is wether if the new SE 2022 can understand wether you are riding an e-bike or a normal bike, considering different calorie burn rates...
Insane good reviews, Rob! Will you also do one for the new Amazfit lineup? Allegedly, they heavily upgraded their sensors (and now support chest HR straps via bluetooth) and the Watches were always interesting aside from the weak sensors.
I follow you since the very beginning and think you’re the best wearable reviewer out there, especially for the accuracy of your scientific and statistical approach.
However, for the sake of the quality of your videos, I would really appreciate to see bigger samples in your “full scientific reviews”. For example, a sleep monitoring test with a sample of two nights may be more appropriate for an “early scientific review”.
I know the new Apple Watches have just been released and it’s a very hot topic right now, but on the other hand it’s difficult to understand the overall precision of a tracker in so little time.
I’m writing this “critical” comment because I really think your videos are the gold standard for any wearable user!
These reviews are truly amazing interms of depth and analysis!
Quick question, are you considering analyzing the new pixel watch when it comes out?
how is this channel not on the same subscriber count as MKBHD or MrWhosetheboss?? you give INSANE value to viewers! keep up the good work, used your amazon links to buy some stuff - hope it helps!
Can you specify if you used the GPS + Cellular watch or the GPS only watch? This is mostly for the GPS tracking portion of the video. Also thanks for the comprehensive review and statistics comparisons
Since the time I have found your channel I have not looked at any other tech channel or review for smart watches. This is all that's needed and anytime I am thinking of buying anything you are the first point to check. Absolutely fabulous 🎉 .
we need Fitbit Sens 2 bro
Man, I love this reviews, they are so precise, and the best of all is that you compare results with other devices, which at the end of the day is what matters the most 💪
Thank you for bringing unbiased credibility and evidence based analysis back to reviews
Do you already have the "Amazfit GTS 4"? Xiaomi are saying that the new sensor is comparable to a chest band (But i doubt).
Review Fitbit sense 2 and pixel watch
I have an Apple Watch ultra and just picked up a 2nd gen SE for sleep tracking because the ultra is a bit too heavy on my wrist. This is such a great review!
Gespannt auf das Review 😊
Hope you liked it!😊
Appreciate your thorough work! Does the calorie counter work similarly between the Apple Watch SE and Series 8? Or does the blood oxygen monitor provide a more reliable calorie expenditure measurement?
22:16 this reminds very much of when I play the piano while wearing my Fitbit inspire 3. It would pretty much always count A LOT of false steps. Had to take the watch of my wrist. Haven’t tried it my Apple Watch SE 2022 so far.
Edit: The Apple Watch has the same curse as the Fitbit. It’s like it counts every key on the piano I press as a step.
Ok, only 9 days have passed and I've chosen my favorite YT channel of 2023 already. Nice work
review fitbit sense 2, please 😁
Could u plz review some affordable smatwatches?
What about the older Apple Watch SE during weight lifting after Watch OS 9 . Is it improved ?
So I fully understand it doesn't have ECG, but single lead ECG is not that accurate anyway, but I know Apple watch has the ability to warn you of irregular heart rate issues which have nudged people to the doctors to get full tests and is great pre Warner. Is the SE good enough to potentially give you the warnings you need to get checked out?
I love to hear your thoughts on this matter?
My series 3 doesn’t have ECG and has notifications for high, low and irregular heart rates, so I imagine this one does as well.
@@pursnikitty I think like you mention it does, but ide love for these guys who review these products to look into this aspect deeper, as I feel for lots of people not knowing what Irregular heart rate detection can actually pick up on, like for example it can be a pre Warner for Afib or even a MI I think it is really important and for people with a family history or personal history of heart conditions is something they should understand more, testers always go into the ECG side of things but whilst it's a handy tool, it's limitations are it's a 1 lead ECG, most hospitals even prefer 12 lead Vs the 9 lead I've worked with in the ambulance service.
With articles out there stating Apple watch Samsung watch saved my life people are not realising that it's the heart rate irregular detection thats mainly been the alert that gets people to their docs or hospital.
Nice to know the 3 has it 👍
Hi Rob! Are you going to review the FitBit Sense 2 continuous EDA sensor? And/or any other continuous EDA trackers? (though I couldn’t find any!)
Thank you again for your work! In the spirit of most scientific methodology-do you account for different bands across Apple Watches, or do you use a standard, single band for all testing to equalize any potential fitting differences which might impact accuracy rather than the sensors themselves tracking differently? Put another way, you do standardize Apple Watch testing using a single band for all testing, or has each Apple Watch been tested with different band types inserting potential differences in fit across tracking? Given that all Apple Watches seem to perform similarly, I imagine the difference may not be huge, but I wonder how it may alter results (one way or another), if at all?
Hey man, I just discovered his channel and I really like it! I'm looking for the best sleep tracker, has he ever said which one it is?
@@TheJoy___ looks like AW is the best
Can you do a review about the amazfit gtr 4 pleas
Got a brand new Apple Watch SE 2nd Gen for $150...waiting on it being delivered. My primary hope is to replace my Garmin Forerunner, which I use for all of my running. The only thing I'm a little worried about is the battery life of the SE 2. Outside of that, it just seems in every capacity it's a far better watch from a running/fitness perspective than any of the low-range Garmin (e.g., like the forerunner 45). Plus, all of the integrative features within the Apple ecosystem for productivity and general use with my iPhone.
Where did you get it from? Is that deal still available?
When will you test Amazfit GTS 4 or GTR 4 ?
Pixel watch next please!
I ve always been saying the same thing but i dont care im saying it again, you are the best (by light years) yt channel on smartwatches and u need more recognition a lot more!!
I even ( for fun) tried to find something bad in your videos couldnt , editing/infos/clarity of the infos… EVERYTHING is there and well explained. I wish you all the best bro
I typically do NOT comment on videos, but I absolutely love your analysis! I was, "on the fence" about purchasing the 8 or the SE 2022 and after your review the SE 2022 seems like a better fit for me.
THANK YOU~
Why not just get a series 7?
@@Yzyenthusiast good question! Because I'm not a fan of buying old tech brand-new...if I was looking used, I wouldn't have ANY problem with the 7.
Just got the series 8 to replace my 1st gen SE hopefully it’s much better at tracking my sleep.
My first gen se has been really good tracking my sleep through the Pillow app
This channel is SOOO GOOD, I am such a data person so you to put this information out in such a readable and understandable way is amazing! I also love how you included the first Generation SE watch. I had no idea there was too but I’m happy to see the first generation isn’t to far behind the new 2022! I would love to have the ECG and I work in a cardiology office however I love the sleep tracking now with the REM, Core & deep sleep function. Thank you!!
I also looked up some specs and it seems they have mostly (looks like different “S” Chips) the same specs! I’m hoping that means it works the same! Thank you again
Hi Rob, there is one more thing I would like to see in your reviews. Can you mention about the maximum frequency of measurement of health metrics in continuous tracking mode (7/24) ? How frequent can the device measure metrics like heart rate, blood oxygen, temperature, etc ? Usually this info is not given by the manufacturer and we only find it out after we buy and when we start using the device and its app.
Hey man, I just discovered his channel and I really like it! I'm looking for the best sleep tracker, has he ever said which one it is?
Thank you very much for making this video. I’ve been comparing the Apple Watch SE 2022 and the Fitbit Inspire 3 the last couple of days (I just got the Apple Watch as it will replace my Fitbit). I noticed quite a bit deviation especially when it comes to sleeptracking. Your video cleared up a lot of questions I had 😄.
One of the best channels I’ve come across 👌🏼 thank you for your thorough evaluation!
I think you should also update the Apple Watch 7 to watch OS 9 and retest s7 again, so all the Apple Watch are in same firmware
Lieber Rob, dass wäre so schön wenn du die ganze Videos auch mal auf deutsch drehen würdest. Ich kenne vielen die nicht Englisch können aber möchten gerne über deine Tests mehr verstehen und bessere Entscheidungen bei Kauf von Smartwatches zutreffen.
Hi Rob, I am totally impressed by the work you are doing. Could you add a short information to your reviews on how long the battery lasts during your tests and how often you need to recharge the batteries? One sentence and your subjective opinion would be absolutely enough. I think then your tests would be complete.
I bought some watch se 2nd gen after watching your videos
I was really interested in the ability of the Apple Watch SE to track my sleep. This review has given me the clearest answer. Thanks a ton!
Hey, thanks for all the reviews. When is the new Amazfit GTS/GTR 4 review coming out? (BIO TRACKER PPG 4.0)
Liked the video before even watching, cause the effort you put in testing these watches are crazy!
I'm sold on the SE 2, thanks to you! I'll be placing an order now.
Hands down the best guide for buying smart watches, it tells you what you need and where to find it!! - Superb!
thank you bro apple se 2 is on sale here in DK so i was planning to buy the garmin instinct 2 but now im going with apple se 2 as im a kidney transplant patient with high blood pressure so always wanna have a accurate sensor watch for my heart rate
There are the same prices between AW7 and SE 2nd gen. What should I buy?
I have been thinking these for 3 days.
Could you help me please Rob?
Thanks
Wondering whats your opinion on EMF radiation on these devices, something you have any opinion about?
Hi Rob, will you be reviewing the new FitBit Inspire 3?
Great analysis, thank you very much for all the work you put into making this informative video!
Great effort 🎉 thank you
Best Apple Watch SE review on UA-cam! Very glad I purchased this.
You really are a legend, I have been waiting for this video ever since you said the se was getting another review. This has definitely helped me choose the best watch so thank tou
I like your channel because you show actual facts if the claims of the watch are actually accurate!
I don't like tech influencer speaking only about personal opinions on a device.
Please test the fitbit sense 2 when it comes out as it will be my sons birthday present for his 18th birthday and I want to truly know of its good for him. Thank you and love your vids, keep up the hard work.
Hey!
Thanks so much for those videos, so useful...currently trying to decide between a Google Pixel watch and the fitbit sense 2...are you going to review them? 🤞🙏🏻
Great job on these videos. Nice to see someone actually reviewing the health tracking of these watches not just the features they offer. I'm really surprised by apple's new sleep tracking.
Will you review the new Fitbit Sense 2? I'm really curious how it compares to the original Sense, which has really bad HR monitoring (especially during workouts)
Hey man, I just discovered his channel and I really like it! I'm looking for the best sleep tracker, has he ever said which one it is?
@@TheJoy___ right now it is the apple watch. They just released an algorithm based on Machine Learning that is currently the vast sleep analysis algorithm in a watch. If you don't have an iPhone or don't want an apple watch, then a FitBit is the best choice for sleep tracking.
Thank you for providing this information to the public! I can say that your videos have really helped me improve my life over the past years (with the help of your reliable information!)
I love the Apple Watch Health tracking. The only issue I have is when it’s tracking steps. As I am a full time wheelchair user, I have my watch set to pushes instead of steps. However, I do seem to get many steps during my day. Don’t know why this happens & i’m not sure if that effects my pushes count. Do other wheelchair users have this happen to them
Thanks for the info. I guess I will just save money and not buy one.
@@gbasar1032 😅😂🤣
@@gbasar1032 I do love my Apple Watch. It does really help me manage my disability pretty well. The steps issue is the only thing that iv’e noticed, but I just ignore them. I should submit feedback to Apple
@@WheelieGayJay hey, don't call yourself disabled. I didn't say anything because I don't want to sound cliche and all but I really admire you. And okay, I will buy one, probably SE 2 since it fits my budget well and only recently I bought iphone 13 also so am very new to the ecosystem. Can you please reply one last time about battery life? I mean I know the watch has to be charged daily but what I mean is that the watch will last 2-3 years right? I am not rich or above middle class so if I invest good amount of my money, I would appreciate if the product lasts for some time.
:)
Which is the best fitness band/watch for Apple? I don’t care about calling features etc. just please recommend the ones most accurate
Amazing analysis robbie❤
Thank you! You've made the task of choosing my next watch so simple.
Thanks! You're review is so helpful, I've decided to buy the apple watch SE
I rarely subscribe to youtubers much less comment, but your approach to review is what I was exactly looking for! It helped me chose this watch for me and my dad. Tysm!
I would also like to request, is it possible to retest the older version of the apple watches since, it can be that better tracking might also be a result of new os 9 which might have under the hood improvements for new and refined algorithm for sleep tracking? Would love to see that comparison!
Anyways cheers mate! Keep those reviews coming
You're the reason why i chose the perfect health device. Kudos!
Really impressive level of detail, data and clarity. The deepest and most comprehensive review of these types of devices that I’ve seen anywhere. Very well done. The historic comparisons to other watches are also very helpful.
I don’t quite get your comment on steps while weight lifting, though: presumably you have to walk between exercises as you get off the bench, change weights, change exercise, etc - surely those are legitimate steps. Or am I missing something!?
Hey, great content, thanks! Just wondering, did you ever do some research on the ECG and Bloodpressure functions? For many people I think it would be quite relevant before buying.
Hey, thanks for the great video. Very well explained and nice graphics to show the results. I was just wondering: which software do you use to create these nice graphics? Do you program them yourself or is there any software out there for that? Thanks!
Hi Rob, will you review the new Amazfit GTR4 and GTS4?
amazing review, very glad to come across this, my se is already on the way :D
Very interesting results, have you tested or are you planning to test the Amazfit GTR 4?
Hi. Which watch in your opinion is close to accuracy calorie counting algorithm. I know none of them are 100% accurate, but some are definitely better than others.It is important for me.Not necessarily just the ones from this review .... considering everything you've dealt with
The best smart watch review channel period! Numbers and stats don’t lie! Thank you for making this video now i know which apple watch i am going for. 😎
I'm trying to build something with Snowflake and Python - I was curious on how you export the data out?
Rob I am reviewing this before making my choice between watches. You sir have my business!
I just bought the apple watch se2 (upgraded from a series 3) and ws wondering how accurate the sleep tracking was because the data I get from autosleep is different but I'm now relieved and will trust apple.
Excellent analysis. Consistent and thorough. Thanks.
I love your work. I'm looking forward to the review of the pixel watch. Let's see if Android can catch up
Finally I can see a true video about health features
Thanks for your amazing videos! I have used a Fitbit inspire 2 for a few months, I am mainly interested in sleep tracking. I have now purchased an Apple Watch SE (WatchOS 10) because, according to your tests, it seemed more precise on sleep tracking. Since a few days, I am testing both devices when I sleep (one per wrist) and, at least for recognizing awake time, in my experience the Fitbit works better: when I am in bed, trying to get asleep, breathing deeply, both the devices tend to mistake this as "light sleep" (even if I am sure I am awake), for the AW, however, this error seems much more evident.
Also, during the night, the Fitbit record several micro awake periods that AW does not, I can't say which device is wrong, though.
Any comments, advice or settings I could have missed? I am thinking about returning the AW (I am not very interested in the other smartwatch features) and continue using the Fitbit but I would like to be sure I am using the most reliable sleep tracker of the two. Thanks again!
Would you rather recommend the SE2022 or the older flagship-versions series 7 or 6?
Awesome testing, really enjoy your channel. Getting a SE watch thanks.
thanks, you convinced me to buy the se. I just want to use it for health and exercise tracking.