But Not For Me (Coltrane's version)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 84

  • @samtedesco3529
    @samtedesco3529 Рік тому +9

    Coltrane would have been honored to have another tenor man emulate him so closely. You've picked up Coltrane's nuances really well Max. Super impressive playing.

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  Рік тому

      Thank you Sam for your beautiful comment but Trane is Trane! ❤️

  • @rovingeye5
    @rovingeye5 Рік тому +7

    Love Max's solos and the fact that he has posted two versions of this song, the regular changes and the "Coltrane" version. People forget that Trane was an original arranger as well as composer, in addition to his great improvising. Great solos from the rest of the band as well!

  • @mdsoulsounds
    @mdsoulsounds Рік тому +3

    Go MAX! All the family is swangin'!

  • @heikkinikula5941
    @heikkinikula5941 2 роки тому +4

    Swing and groove, Ireally can’t stand still if this is playing. I love the original Coltrane’s version and this comes very close😀🫡👍👍

  • @obergssin
    @obergssin Рік тому +7

    I never get tired of this version. I listen to it over and over. To me it epitomizes everything so great about your playing Max …. The sound, concept of harmony and the building of lines … everything came together so right in this tune.
    It is a great testimony and capture of your talent. I wish you all the best and thank you for your dedication, intent and bravery. Someday I hope to hear you live and thank you personally. Bravo Mr. Ionata ….

  • @ethanhill9460
    @ethanhill9460 4 роки тому +5

    Takes guts to cover my fav COLTRANE song which is a cover of a classic. I'd never attempt to bake carrot cake with my MA's recipe. Kudos to guys with guts.

  • @IOIOIOI505
    @IOIOIOI505 Рік тому +2

    So good.

  • @TonyAguirreJazz
    @TonyAguirreJazz 4 роки тому +5

    I love how both this and the other version had both quotes from Rollins and Coltrane. Huge fan!

  • @ethanhill9331
    @ethanhill9331 7 років тому +9

    Sounds as if it were almost Coltrane, and that's perfect. I'd $ to see and hear this guy perform. The song, a cover of a Gershwin tune, is my fav my fav my fav Coltrane cut. The band does justice to the original yet so with originality. This is a great cover of a cover.

  • @danielabdelnour8232
    @danielabdelnour8232 4 роки тому +3

    Great player . Inspired for life

  • @johnsharpe734
    @johnsharpe734 6 років тому +18

    Less than 8k views.......unbelievably low for such a brilliant performance. The whole band is great. I'm sure John Coltrane would have approved if he'd been around to hear your interpretation of 'But Not for me'Having seen Jerry Bergonzi live at his peak, I can hear his influences in your playing. I'm speading the word about Max Ionata to jazz musician friends in my area to listen to what your doing and hopefully see you live if you come to the uk

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  6 років тому +2

      Thank you very much John! Hope to deserve your kind words!

  • @hlib
    @hlib Рік тому +1

    so good...

  • @myingratealbinochild4825
    @myingratealbinochild4825 7 років тому +4

    Out standing band. Out standing performance !

  • @enochsakae8840
    @enochsakae8840 2 роки тому +1

    Wow! GOOD! Jazz music!

  • @jonahtakalua5166
    @jonahtakalua5166 3 роки тому +2

    Never seen a cover so close to Coltrane.

  • @jazzchamaeleon
    @jazzchamaeleon Рік тому +2

    Incredible and beautiful!!!

  • @mauriziosodano5907
    @mauriziosodano5907 2 роки тому +2

    Grande!!!

  • @mattdavis9801
    @mattdavis9801 5 років тому +6

    This band is amazing!

  • @johnsharpe734
    @johnsharpe734 2 роки тому +1

    Staggering playing by all guys…..

  • @Filippo-Parisi
    @Filippo-Parisi 4 роки тому +2

    Che spettacolo. Formazione super, e con tre grandi artisti italiani. Max, non ci sono parole, davvero. Commovente quanto suoni bene, quanto hai ricordato Trane pur rimanendo te stesso.

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  4 роки тому +1

      Grazie Filippo sei troppo buono!

  • @nigelnash4264
    @nigelnash4264 8 років тому +5

    At last areal heavyweight on the saxophone incredible sound ideas humility knowledge and what a fabulous rhythm section bravo Italian jazz Nigel Nash in britain

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  8 років тому +1

      Thank you :-)

    • @jackshore3735
      @jackshore3735 4 роки тому

      I believe Max Ionata is criminally underrated. Plays with no ego, wonderful quoting and magnificent line construction, and great interplay between himself and the rhythm section. A true master of his craft

  • @EmileRyjoch
    @EmileRyjoch 7 років тому +7

    Really love your playing, Max! Killer solo!

  • @jaco1290
    @jaco1290 4 роки тому +1

    Max sei uno spettacolo cool and very nice impro ciao da Paolo

  • @davidnazombe8589
    @davidnazombe8589 4 роки тому +3

    These guys are really amazing 👌👌

  • @BebopEngineer
    @BebopEngineer 7 років тому +7

    This is great playing by everyone! I am going to enjoy "camping out" on this YT channel for a long time. Please keep posting more stuff and many thanks for sharing this!!

  • @gruvnroe
    @gruvnroe 3 роки тому +3

    Thank You for Posting this. On the highest level. Thanks for taking the adds out. Can I buy the full recording ? Thanks Again.

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  3 роки тому

      Thanks Gary. I don't know if the recording is available at the club. Try to write to Duc Des Lombardes, Paris

  • @tltate
    @tltate Рік тому

    Such a badass!

  • @escultordemusicascultas5566
    @escultordemusicascultas5566 8 років тому +3

    Fantástica banda y gran saxofonista Max , todo un grande del saxofón, mi mas sincera enhorabuena a todos ...

  • @titolivio6832
    @titolivio6832 3 роки тому +2

    Un pezzo che amo particolarmente perché ne ricordo una versione di Thad Jones che ascoltavo da ragazzino. Avete rinnovato il mio piacere.

  • @alkuhseltsur9243
    @alkuhseltsur9243 5 років тому +3

    What a delightful interpretation! Just when I think that this kind of playing has faded away I find a gem like this where the tribute to the original Coltrane version is clear yet every musician is doing something unique and individual so you get an entirely new version. Along with a lot else that I like I think that the interaction between everyone and the drummer with the breaks is superbly crafted.

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  5 років тому

      Thank you very much Sir! Alvin Queen is one of the greatest drummer in the world and I will never forget those concerts together with him.

    • @alkuhseltsur9243
      @alkuhseltsur9243 5 років тому +1

      @@maxionata Thank you for letting me know his name. Really good work!

  • @bmonkey8
    @bmonkey8 Рік тому +1

    Will you ever be in the U.S?

  • @stefanobisogni4568
    @stefanobisogni4568 6 років тому +2

    Max io sono cresciuto ascoltando tutto il jazz e solo jazz, ma proprio tutto da quando avevo 13 anni. Adesso che ne ho 55 devo dire che mi dai grandi emozioni. Coltrane è il mio preferito e devo dire che tu sei il sassofonista che più lo esprime meglio tra tutti.
    Vivissimi complimenti

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  6 років тому

      Stefano Bisogni wow!! Grazie mille! Troppo buono 😊

    • @stefanobisogni4568
      @stefanobisogni4568 6 років тому

      Di nulla. Spero di sentirti di persona ma sono un po decentrato adesso. Prima abitavo a Milano

  • @latinkeys1
    @latinkeys1 3 роки тому +1

    I usually don't like upright bass slots but this guy is really good! All of these guys are fantastic. I love Max Ionata's playing. He got a unique style, he's different from most guys, his way of phrasing and the way he approaches harmony. I really enjoy it.

  • @TonySpruillSax
    @TonySpruillSax 8 років тому +4

    This is it.

  • @fingerdits
    @fingerdits 7 років тому +2

    Great player. Congratulations.

  • @wilsonchen910
    @wilsonchen910 Рік тому +1

    inserting ad in the middle of this song, are you fking kidding me yt ads?

  • @veriomagic
    @veriomagic 4 роки тому +1

    Stasera ti ho conosciuto di persona . che emozione.... Maestro

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  4 роки тому

      Saverio è stato un piacere per me. A presto 🎷😊

  • @Logan-Wolverine
    @Logan-Wolverine 3 роки тому +1

    Grandissimo Max!!! Cooooooltrane

  • @giovannidibenedetto2525
    @giovannidibenedetto2525 4 роки тому +1

    io vi amo!!!!

  • @jaumegelabert679
    @jaumegelabert679 8 років тому +3

    Assolutamente magnifico! so good! what a great band!

  • @TheRealMusic4Life
    @TheRealMusic4Life 6 років тому +1

    The Drummer has a great feel!! I'm taking a lot of notes from watching and listening. Thank you! Everyone is really great together. Also taking notes from the piano player!

  • @RandyResnick
    @RandyResnick 6 років тому +1

    Beautiful, Max. Well done!

  • @rosannabuzzerio9717
    @rosannabuzzerio9717 4 роки тому

    pezzo magnifico , suonato magistralmente...

  • @tombekistan
    @tombekistan 6 років тому +1

    Awesome Max !!!

  • @scottquickel8010
    @scottquickel8010 3 роки тому

    Nice.)

  • @UmbertoMLupo
    @UmbertoMLupo 5 років тому

    Grandiosi!

  • @personagonnbey2923
    @personagonnbey2923 8 років тому +3

    From 1st four bars to 2nd four bars!!!
    single drum note・・・single piano note

  • @studentewilliamnisi9447
    @studentewilliamnisi9447 5 років тому

    Bravi!

  • @raghavchari
    @raghavchari 7 років тому +2

    Nice! Love Coltrane changes on But Not For Me. Who is in the rest of the band?

  • @edoardobattaglia868
    @edoardobattaglia868 6 років тому +1

    grande max!! tutti e 4 dei grandi! trane lives

  • @davidscott1052
    @davidscott1052 Рік тому

    It's 26 2...or confirmation quotes

  • @dillpickle1960
    @dillpickle1960 4 роки тому +1

    great playing Max! What 's your mouthpiece set up on this? Cheers and keep up the inspiring playing

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  4 роки тому +1

      Thank you Philip! In this video I was playing with my Bari HR refaced by Filippo Bucci. Very soon will be released a new signature piece by Marmaduke Japan that is inspired by this piece.

    • @dillpickle1960
      @dillpickle1960 4 роки тому +1

      @@maxionata Hi Max, thanks for the reply; is that a 7* star opening? I understand that's your preferred tip opening choice. Anyway, great sound man. Stay safe and keep swinging!

    • @maxionata
      @maxionata  4 роки тому

      Philip Walton Yes it is.

  • @pierluigivicini9302
    @pierluigivicini9302 7 років тому +1

    Pazzesco!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @blackolivejazz
    @blackolivejazz 8 років тому +2

    Noel Jewkes likes it!

  • @carloalbertoproto
    @carloalbertoproto 4 роки тому +1

    pazzeschi

  • @charlesstenger5485
    @charlesstenger5485 4 роки тому

    But not for me making Giant Steps

  • @ride279
    @ride279 7 років тому

    I really love the piano solo in the original of this track, but this just sounds wrong on so many levels. You should be hearing every note, instead of rushing through the piano solo like you have to be somewhere...

    • @TheRealMusic4Life
      @TheRealMusic4Life 6 років тому +5

      @M.Alders, I'd have to respectfully disagree with you, even though I do know what you're saying. His piano solo here was beautiful. Very tasteful and going along with the vibe and the tempo. This isn't a recital where everything needs to be played note for note. Players should be able to add their own touch to the music, and I think he did just that. Little different than the original, of course.......that's what makes it beautiful. I heard plenty of original ideas in there while he still kept the main idea of the tune very clear, and that's what jazz is all about. Awesome piano player!

    • @lucas.w_musicc
      @lucas.w_musicc 5 років тому +4

      Every note was heard! He articulated each note finely!