"Going into management is not worth the hassle!" | Jamie Carragher | Off Script
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 бер 2020
- SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/SSFootballSub
PREMIER LEAGUE HIGHLIGHTS ► bit.ly/SkySportsPLHighlights
Jamie Carragher finally got his laptop working (with the help of his daughter!) and jumped onto a video call with Geoff Shreeves to discuss Gary Neville's management career, the reasons he's avoided going into coaching and Thierry Henry's time in charge of Monaco and Montreal.
Watch Premier League LIVE on Sky Sports here ► bit.ly/WatchSkyPL
►TWITTER: / skysportsfootball
►FACEBOOK: / skysports
►WEBSITE: www.skysports.com/football
MORE FROM SKY SPORTS ON UA-cam:
►SKY SPORTS FOOTBALL: bit.ly/SSFootballSub
►SKY SPORTS BOXING: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub
►SOCCER AM: bit.ly/SoccerAMSub
►SKY SPORTS F1: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyF1 - Спорт
You know what we need in these times? A long Neville + Carragher podcast series. Just the two of them without a presenter and have them talk for more than an hour. They can talk about all kinds of things. Their careers, Gary's Valencia days, different managers they trained under, specific matches they played, do deep dives into styles of different managers. The possibilities are endless.
poor Geoff lmao, you've shafted him here.
“Different mangers they trained under” hah you surely only mean Carragher, as he’s the only one of the two that actually had different managerS
@@mfjosh6422 England manager so technically he's played under more than one
Boring
Deepy Ram hahaha fair play
That's a great point about Thierry Henry and glad to hear Carragher being so honest about it too!
Henry's problem was that he expected the players to be as good as him. He was very demanding and the players rebelled. Most top players do not make good managers. Fergie, Klopp, Wenger, Mourinho.....all very average players, but top managers
@@mediacenterman8583
Plenty of successful managers who were former top players.
Some just have it others doesn't.
@@mediacenterman8583 seems the common thing to say these days but it's not true.
Zidane, ancelotti, guardiola, Cruyff, rijkaard, conte, dalglish...the list is endless of former world class players who turn world class managers
@@connorf4035 fair point
people need to drop the notion that great players should make great managers. Both Carra and Gary were top players in their days, no doubt. but being a manager is about having a holistic and strategic vision, being continually schooled on tactics, man-management/motivation, conflict management, scouting, analyses, dealing with the media, press, owners and club board, etc. It takes a different kind of personality to be a manager, and it's good that both Carra and Gary are saying they aren't cut out for it. It shows a different insight that few fans haven't seen before.
Carragher could definitely have done reasonably well as a manager.
@@pluckychicken7656 at Liverpool, probably.
If Carra went to Valencia he probably would have been sacked after 3 months too
I'd disagree about the 'great players' part.
After listening to carra the last few weeks he sounds like a lazy player and now I understand why he sucked a lot
@@gethcreator751 both won trophies and were some of the best in their positions.
@@wrightplacewrighttime.5834 I know but listening to carra over the last few weeks he makes himself sound like a lazy coward too afraid to try anything
Day 5 of isolation.
And it's impossible to get pickles out a jar wearing boxing gloves.
That made me giggle
Chuckle
not if you can punch hard enough
@James Newstead
Or take the lid off.
Only thing I've read recently that made me instantly smlie😂
In these times of lockdown/Covid-19 on the news 24/7, these conversations with Jamie, Geoff and Gary are fantastic. Candid, honest and real. Keep it up gentlemen, you are giving a lot of people (including me) a conversation to look forward to between work and family life. Thank you.
Louis Van Hal great interviewer!!!
Appreciate what Jamie said about his particular personal motives and drives for getting into football in the first place, like the comment about "fear of failure driving [him] on". It's always exciting to hear about the psychology of individual players.
I don't know if this makes sense, but IMHO I believe that players who are done (mentally) by the time they finish their playing careers (physically) will not want nor need to enter into management, but players who end their playing days (physically) without being done (mentally i.e. they could and would have carried on but for the physical restrictions) are more prone to enter the field of management. They still have that urge/drive. Most people are mentally done before they're physically done, for footballers who become managers, I feel the reverse is true.
Carra is right. Managers like Poch, Dyche, Howe, Big Sam and many others have massively over-achieved but won't get due credit.
You try to do what howe has at Bournemouth on a shoestring budget with a capacity of about 20,000.
I'm nota Bournemouth fan but have some respect. Taking a team that was about to fold up the divisions is not over achieving it's a miracle and no stroke of luck.
Howe will fulfill his potential when he outgrows the cherries.
Why would he leave when he is still young has a safety net with the chairman who he gets on with very well.
@@jao7719 Eh? "have some respect"? I just praised him, said he massively over-achieved lol
Ja O
They don’t have a shoe string budget, lmao if you stay up in the prem you get 100’s of millions from the TV deal.
They have wasted so much money on average players from Liverpool etc.
They get credit every other week, what are you on about? when have you ever heard any of those guys are doing bad jobs?
Top pundits Gary and Jamie.
Gary said himself the other day he took it for granted but he realises now to never take it for granted.
Jamie “I’m not trying to get the garden in” Carragher
Neville looks like Emery in the thumbnail.
Kolasi TANK mid table to Arsenal:
Spoiler alert. It's Emery
@Kolasi TANK mot
Too right Singh Neville the bhenchodah Sala
jamie's stacked these days
This was a great interview. Very informative
Thankyou for the longer content
Thanks, always wondered Carra opinion on management
All class from Carragher. Didn’t beat around the bush about fellow pundits but wasn’t rude or insulting. Great listen!
This was quality, nice one sky
Joel can you pleeeaase pleeease Subscribe to my UA-cam channel
Imagine reading Alan Smith’s book. You’d have to take a look at yourself.
Or you've read every other single book ever written ..twice..and you're stuck on a desert with only that book..and you know you're not going to run out of jacks roll or firewood
What a player! Until he got injured
@Martial_is a beast 9 yeah hes achieved a lot hasnt he? Premier league titles big chamipons league performances..hasnt he ? Have I got marital mixed up with someone else?
Martial is only 24. Wind your neck in. The other guy is confusing his Alan Smiths. The book behind Shreeves is by the Sky commentator/ex Arsenal and Leicester one.
@@jimmycampbell78 huh?
Shreeves the only man to have books facing the wrong way lol 😂
Lmao!!!
Partly to big them up, partly just to make the place look tidier, haha.
Richard Dunne yeah you can tell they were all originally in the space behind the Carragher book
Very honest. I really like Carra. I especially love when him and Neville get tin a room. Their dynamic is exceptional
Carragher hitting the gym these days
Boxing several times a week, apparently. Heard it when him and neville were asked who would win in a fight 😄
hes on the gear
the man is BUFF
@@jamesbackhouse9506 A man in shape so he must be on the gear, You're a joke you fat lump.
@@bobross6602 😂😂😂
Carra and Gnev are the best pundits on tv, why give that up to be managers of average teams. MNF wouldn't be the same without them....
nor would their bank balances ;)
Carra does a lot of talking but says very little. His punditry sucks imo
Ali H false premier league managers make so much more than pundits are you crazy
Carra and Gnev are arrogant, egotistical, ignorant assholes;
arrogant, egotistical, ignorant assholes don't make good managers.
In management there's no Monday morning quarterback's if's, and's and but's, where you can never be wrong;
there's living with the consequences of your decisions.
This drivel of self serving excuses turned my stomach.
@@mlsarchitect sir Alex was one of the most arrogant egotistical people in football and he dominated the league for 2 decades. Jose Mourinho, the most arrogant man on the planet and is one of the best managers ever ......
I miss Football this weekend even though it was a International break Liverpool would won the title, but given people are dying all over the world some things in life are more important then Football YNWA
Jose : Boot it anywhere.
Carra : ✌
i love how jeff has sneaked his carra book in the background
And conveniently Souness also.ridiculous lol
Kiss ass
Did they both put on their kids tee-shirts as a thank you ?
23 November 1991 ifolge nrk's arkiver ;) midt I smoroyet sending.... husker jeg saa det som ung,naar jeg vokste opp I Norge ;)
Brilliant interview.
geoff shreeves is a good interviewer
Definitely! Mixes formality and informality very well. These sort of dialogue should continue once this blows over in my opinion.
@wildebest DONT LISTEN THEN
Almost as if it's his job
@wildebest lmao what an insult "girl pants" I bet he's soooooooo scared
collins mugodo best I’ve seen him in a long time. Fair play.
I remember Alan Hanson doing a documentary on football a few years ago and he said virtually the same thing about becoming a manager as Carragher.
8:36 Jose: hold my beer
Carragher is the number one pundit.
A true asset to Sky Sports.
true ass you mean
@@thefinalwhistle1623 name a better pundit.
I'll wait...
Mad that they managed to get Darren Farley on via Skype
Daniel Raza
Lol 😂
Yeeeee course
😂😂😂the casually placed autobiographies of Carragher Souness and Smith 😂😂😂
On my FM15 save he became the West Brom manager and won the league in 2020
Carra usually so quick with the digs @ G Nev he missed the chance to comment on his book being on show wonder if he will tweet it out
Carragher is only saying this because he couldn’t control a heated dressing room he would probably start telling jokes in the middle of it
It's because none of his players would understand what he's saying
Or gob on them!
Nah I think the complete opposite and he’s said it himself multiple times. He’s too straight forward and real with people. If you’re not pulling your weight he’ll tell you how it is. He can’t deal with pre-Madonna’s. He takes football very seriously and thinks everyone should give their all for the team/club. He couldn’t deal with personalities like Neymar or Balotelli.
Jamie's got a sickass house and the only place he can charge his phone and talk on skype at the same time is the kitchen. This drives me nuts.
it is something to say about someones character who could criticise other managers but could not be bothered to go into it and experience it first hand.
if you dont like punditry dont turn off after the match and dont give your opinions to your friends either if you dont think you can criticise someones performance if youve not managed, presumably the same applies to playing
lovely framed family photo over Carra's left shoulder there...
Thank god Jeffs mic quality isn’t dreadful his time
Managers need to be good at reading people, getting in their heads and understanding how they think. You have to manipulate younger men into wanting to give their best for you, to buy into your ideas. Some are good at this, Ferguson was the master and Pep is now, his players hang on his every word. Clearly Neville at Valencia the players never took him seriously.
Would love to know what managers he found hopeless pundits at 8:29
Gary defo spoke him out of it 😂🤣
Jeff seems like a bang on bloke.
Little bit too much Sky pundit autobiography placement there Geoff.
Yes, sickening
management is very rewarding if your any good at it.
All in favour of sky to broadcast prem games from 1992 till now on their channels and youube
Ive heard a few EPL legends say Thierry Henry is the greatest player to play in the premier league. 🔥✍️✍️
great content
Hopefully Roy Keane or Souness are on this next. Please ⚽️👍
Couldn't imagine either of them doing this without smashing the lap top
Its such a relief to hear a former top sportsman admitting that hes not into management. So what. In todays society, its such a taboo to say that there are things in this world youre no good at. Its not about doing what other people think is better, its about doing what feels right for you and what youre good at.
No it's not a taboo, gtfoh. Everyone already knows these ex footballer pundits don't have what it takes to be managers. It's not news.
7:09 IVE GOTTA WRONG THIS RIGHT xD
😂😂😂 Technology, I can imagine Carragher getting ‘Scouser angry cause he can’t get it started’ 🤨😂
In a nutshell, he doesn’t want to go into management. You’re welcome.
Purplestorm25
bit like that alright.
watched it all hoping.
😂
Carra made Geoff has his biography on the shelf lmao
Good talk
Good quarantine content
YEEEAAAAAHHHHH COOUUURRSSEEEEEE!!
Same as Stevie G lol
Quick comment on the title. So true for footballers who have made enough money to not need to have a managerial job afterwards. So many former top players have made fools of themselves as managers, while they could've just been relaxing as pundits or doing other things outside football.
That "Carra" biography looked like it was placed there just for this interview
den525 it was there for the (great) Gary Neville interview
G Nev sound like a good rapper name
Gary Neville: "Valverde toyed with me like puppet"
Yeah that's when you know you're gonna get sacked,when Valverde does that to you.
Hamza Orakzai without the facade of having to play “The Barca Way” and having to work with a squad that’s so poorly constructed and lopsided, Valverde is a hell of a manager. Don’t allow a poor fit of club/manager form your overall opinion of his quality
Probably not a bad manager. More a case of expectations so high at Barcelona following Enrique, Guardiola, and rickard. (can't spell it)
@@rickybeans8504 Rijkaard
He literally won them the league in both his full seasons lol
I am a barca fan and while we hated valverde for his style of play and the lack of a plan b when the team were pressed hard, he's a good manager. He did win us 2 league titles in his years in charge of the club management
More great content thanks
Stevie G has entered the chat 😁
Britain produced some legendary english and scottish managers in the past. Fergie was the last one. Where are the next generation of english and scottish managers gonna come from?
Carragher doesn't need to go into football management. He's already getting a cushy wage packet at sky for being a pundit.
Yeah he took the easy route. I wonder in 10 years will he regret it, look at all the young former players who are now managers ala lamps, arteta, terry, giggs, gerrard, even Rooney is getting involved. Jamie is still young man, is his plan to be a pundit for 25 years? At least Gary and shearer took a stab at it before deciding it wasn’t for them.
patluff to be fair it’s not worth hassle it brings
Exactly, and he's not very ambitious, never won much in his career, so punditry is good.
What manager is to much stress, pundit is much better job as you can’t lose it, Neville is such good pundit he would always be allowed back but if you went for manager job and sacked after 6 months you don’t have anything
Dan Edwards money is not comparable. It’s hard to leave the game and many of the top players are ambitious. Ego is big thing, being a coach is being centre of attention which many performers enjoy. Also you can always become a pundit after you’ve been sacked with a huge payoff. Look at Tim Sherwood for instance.
"Some of them are hopeless" 😂
Geoff shreeves is awesome. Replace Martin Tyler with him. More Geoff please!
Hope we can surpass from this pandemic soon and go back to normal life....🔜🔜
For some reason I always used to think Carra wound be Steven Gerrard's assistant.
I hope you come to manage my team one day janie
Cheers Geoff
Some managers don’t make good pundits but being a manager is 1000x harder.
Can't seem to find the one with Geoff talking to Gary ???
Scrap that just found it right under my nose 🤦🏼♂️
Lol the resolution is terrible.
I understand what he means.
Coaching isn't an easy thing.
Geoff shreeves makes me wanna turn the video off and will then ask a great question😂
Jamie needs to put respect on Mou
Jamie in good shape
They haven't mentioned the main reason people go into management because they love football!
Carras airpods about to fall out any minute @27:05
The difference between Jamie and Gary is... Gary was used to winning... all he wanted to do was win regardless of which club they manage or whether it's realistic... While Jamie? probably be a better manager as he's used to not winning.
We need live sport back soon!!!!!!@
He's right. It's not worth the hassle, if you have millions in the bank. But look at people like Sam Allardyce, who was not wealthy, who started off managing semi pro/low level teams, but worked his way up to become a multi millionaire premiership manager. I'm sure he'd say it is worth the hassle
Seeing Jeff without a suit is weird🤣
why do your coaching badges carra if you don't wanna be a manager?
1 day Steve G will getbthe Liverpool job and Carra will be his No2.
You heard it here 1st
Samboy666 no everyone has known it for about 15 years 😂
Jamie Carragher what a legend 👊💯
Too right top class charver the lad
That frame needs a pic of Juergen
It is if you know what you are doing.
TAKEN. TAKEN. TAKEN over my life.
I'm a liverpool fan and Carragher did I sterling job for the club..but @8.45 comparing managing a football club against punditry...?? Really??
When Gerrard is Liverpool manager and McAllister retires Carragher takes his place as assistant manager calling it now
No.
"Even the running down the line. That's not the liverpool way of doing things"
Didnt klopp run on the pitch when they scored against Everton last season?
No he doesn't need management when he can get an enormous amount of money every season for criticising players and teams every week on sky sports or mnf
💯
Social Meeja
Could listen to Carragher and Neville all day.
Managers get paid less than top players.. why would Jamie or Gary take a massive pay cut to be a manager of a less than top team, there already financial made so what's the motivation to get up early ever day and do a proper job with way more accountability than when they were a player