@@AndrewBergSax there are compilations on yt of suga saying his name before his verse haha. once he featured on someone's song and the song was about to be released when he told them "i need to change something" and they were really confused that it was just him whispering his name in the beginning 🤣 but he kinda stopped doing it recently.
Very true.... They have such a versatile discography you can't help but listen to every song and along the way find your own song(s) and the fact that I've seen many people including myself starting to like even love the songs which are completely not our cup of tea....I mean I'm still shocked.... I don't know how they do it, but then again they are BTS 😂😂😂
Anyone who says there is nothing in the BTS discography for them 1) hasn't actually listened to the BTS discography, 2) has a (hopelessly) closed mind due to pre-conceived ideas, or 3) is actively trying hard not to like them. (There is a fourth option - racism/xenophobia - but any of the first three don't *automatically* mean the fourth is true, in my opinion. It *can* be the underlying reason, but isn't always the reason.)
@@OT7_DopeOldARMY I think it's probably they have listened to English songs and made up their minds that they only make songs lyrics like that and also what you said preconceived notion
DYNAMICS 🤩 I'm not sure if you're a musician or picked up this term from my video last week, but either way it makes me happy to see someone talking about it. Haha. Also I completely agree that they do a great job!!
Thanks 💜💜💜 I watched a reactor who said "the flute is kinda distracting" which would make sense because Pluto doesn't want you to forget it - flute is Pluto. It made so much sense to me :) It was buzzing around in the background like a busy bee as if to say "don't forget about me"
@@AndrewBergSaxI love it too and you’re right Andrew I never expected I would love these type of songs or rapping at all but now I accepte that It's BTS to me
@@AndrewBergSax "Flute - Pluto" is a wordplay since these two words sound almost the same in Korean accent. There's no "f" sound in Korean, p is usually used to substitute f. Also they sometimes can't just finish a word with a consonant, so they often add some vowel at the end of the word. These things make the word "flute (플루트)" sound almost like "Pluto (플루토)".
The music industry says they aren't real rappers/singers because they don't fit standard genres. But BTS will continue to love music and stay in orbit even if the rest of the solar system won't acknowledge them.
This is one of the VERY few songs where I would actually have recommended the studio version, not that they don’t still absolutely kill this live, but the production (which they do recreate fairly well for stage) is just so good at creating the ‘vibe’ of the theme - especially in J-Hope’s verse.
Currently at universal right now so I’ll watch this later! Just wanted to say that this is one of my favorite songs, especially the bridge with Jin and Hobi, so I hoped you guys enjoyed! 💜
Hip-hop, beatboxing...flute. Hmmmmm...this isn't K-pop anymore, is it? What a smart, groovy song! Loved your and Caitlin's thoughtful, informed reaction! I especially appreciate what you notice in the background, Andrew.
Zizi K. said on 6/23/21 Kpop is not a genre actually, it's an industry because groups can choose whatever genre they want. I know you can listen to like one or two songs from a singer or group and get the gist of their sound but with BTS, their discography is so varied that you need to listen to a variety of the music to get who they are.
@@AndrewBergSax Zizi K. said on 6/23/21 Kpop is not a genre actually, it's an industry because groups can choose whatever genre they want. I know you can listen to like one or two songs from a singer or group and get the gist of their sound but with BTS, their discography is so varied that you need to listen to a variety of the music to get who they are.
Every time I hear this song I always mentally picture the seven of them in a 1970's conversation pit with a burnt orange aesthetic while sipping martini's lol
Bc you watched live version you didn't see or hear a lot of stylistic choises in song bc they don't do that live, like Suga and Jin part that are like voice from space 🔭🌌 (they use this effect like phone) and Suga little wisper of his name that fans love and this little conversation inside his verse 😋 and Jhope rap is little faster and more in face (I don't know how to better explain it).😉 I don't know if you now heard album version but I curious what you think of this, live is great and they sing so good it and they don't do this song normaly, they did it for muster only, so I'm happy that there is live version. Jin and Jimin shine for me here💜. I don't know if someone told you but this song was choose by NASA for their space playlist to listen in space stacion/prom. They were looking for songs that were great represenation of cosmos and this is one of them. 😁
Everything about this song is unexpected it’s a 70s flute jazz fun song about poor Pluto. So very geeky and clever. You two are as always a pick me up to watch!
I agree, Andrew. when you commented about Jimin and then Jin and later V singing without "backing" and it's one of the reasons why I like the vocal artistry of this song. I feel like if they tried to not belt those notes full out they would not be in the right orbit. I love this song, it is a very adult-sounding song to me. Great reaction Bergs💜💜
"YOU'LL LIKE OUR MUSIC IF YOU LISTEN TO IT WITHOUT PREJUDICE" -Min Yoongi(Suga, BTS) Hi, i am back. Good reaction, ty. I think u might be remembering this quote. I used to paste a lot of info for baby Army on the 1st few vids. =0p Yw, lol. Really cool song. Smooth. Jazz or blues vibe for me. They all sound so good. It's a bop. Loved hearing your thoughts. Hugs. Love u both. Stay safe. -NY USA Army💟
i agree, I have been saying that BTS is their own genre. My personal taste is folk/classic rock, but I enjoy other styles also. I haven't found a BTS song I don't enjoy, and I think I have heard them all now. I even like the rap songs, I have never been a rap fan. The mix of genres and BigHit/Hybe allowing them to experiment and letting each member shine while supporting each other is magic.
I KNEW IT!!! T-T why do I always get confused when people are wrong? XD (next, you'll love Rain and prob Am I wrong :D) Jin+JHope+...JK! = Jamais Vu :) You'll like it too! (well, I do like all their songs but you know what I mean) HA! I got it from the counterpoint thing, since I always feel the distress they are portraying by being demoted Pluto in the instrumental track vs vocal track. It's just all "weird" but fits. For those interested: the "culprit" of the demotion was Mike Brown (my bias xD), I got to know him on a caltech online course (a MOOC from Coursera: The Science of the Solar System) where apart from talking about the topic he took his time to explain how all came to happen in 2006 :_) and it hurt him as much as everyone else to accept the consequences lol
Yes!! I was surprised the votes were so wrong 😂 and I agree about it all being weird but that it fits together. And I love the background info on the pluto decision. Haha
@@AndrewBergSax Right? T-T And I self-doubt myself all the time lol. Yes, I was so "angry" when it all happened, I liked the number 9... but again, I guess people were angry with Copernicus and Galileo back then too xDDDD Also getting to know THE guy for 1 semester was eye-opening. See you tomorrow, I guess! (?)
This is one of my faves!! So glad you reacted to it.. the kyrics, the melody.. so so good! That's so true, SUGA said that if you just listen to their music without any prejudice, you'll definitely find a song that you'll really love. Every BTS song is a masterpiece on its own, you have a song that can soothe your every mood. Plus lyrics and music production are very well thought out.
@@AndrewBergSax i've found this so far (picture of a magazine interview/profile, where this quote is printed): twitter.com/Canada_BTS/status/860357956457693184?s=20&t=6cSNHRG7ifo-oySz7ZcxEg
Interesting that people say it has a jazzy feel. It feels like Bossa Nova to me, but that's what I'm more used to. It's a really great song, and so poetic.
Ah, this song! So glad you enjoyed it! . I did discover it when I was starting to look properly into their lyrics (meaning I found proper translators) and I was blown away: "sorry, is this a take on unrequited love using Pluto's downgrading as a planet, with Bossa Nova sexy vibes? Who are this people???!!" Loved your reaction, love from the UK! Borahae!
Andrew, I have missed your musical reactions and so to see you came back with THIS reaction put a huge smile on my face. This song is in my top 10 BTS songs for its witty metaphor and the back and forth between the rap verses and vocal chorus that is glorious to my ears. THANK YOU to you and Caitlin.
I loved this reaction !! 134340 is my most favourite song ever. Just a little request : could you react to the spotify version too ? I would love your analysis
SOOO glad you reacted to this, it's really a shining gem in BTS's discography imo! The way the music reflects the message in the pluto metaphor (some ppl posted great comments about the flute's role) is one of the most genius things I've ever seen! And yes true BTS has something for everyone. Thanks for sharing this with us! CFA
I love this song! I like the “exposed” parts a lot, because it gives the song a lonely feel. As if you are just drifting and circling all alone in space. I really love the flute too. Edited to add : Some of my favorite lyrics are “Us is just the plural form of u, perhaps I was never there from the start”
I think what you *might* be thinking of at 11:20 is Yoongi's "You'll like BTS music if you listen without prejudice." quote. Or maybe not, but that's definitely one armys bring up a lot, because it's very true 😊💜
I discovered this song a couple of years ago. I LOVE the flute! On a different channel, there was a comment that the flute was annoying. I was surprised as I thought it was what gave the song the jazz vibe. And the lyrics. This song if one my top BTS songs. Enjoy your reactions. 💜
Darnit! I was hoping for "What's poppin', girl?" 😆 I'm here for the hip-hop flute and the armography! The smoky layers of mist bit is actually one of my favourite lines from the song. 👍
You are so right, there is such a different vibe to each song and their performances add another layer on top of the music and musicality, on top of the lyrics. Glad to see Caitlin on this song with you, it was a great song for her insight, the visual of a fire that has been put out was perfect, and you balanced it so well with your musical insights. I have a playlist that currently has 90 BTS group and solo songs and I think I counted at least 15 missing from this list. Keep updating your spreadsheet, you have about 85 songs to go, ha ha! And I would watch every video you make. Keep up the great work, I love your videos!
This song is one of my favorites such sweet voices. Jimins voice is out of this world such a beautiful voice . I love all my boyz they all have amazing voice BTS ARMY 4EVER 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Yay!!! my "let's rope some physicists into BTS content" song! hehe 🤗 Caitlin's reaction to RM's little dance in the intro 😁 I'd say your bias is showing 😉 And yeah, I love the way the lyrics are constructed in these different layers of meaning. The exposed chorus vocals for "I'm just orbiting you"... oh yeah, I'd be terrified to attempt that. There's barely anything in that range that they can reference against. "There is something for everyone" yeah. I think the quote you're remembering is from Yoongi? And I also vaguely remember you sharing a music guide on your Twitter at some point, with songs sorted by genre, on a huge mind map? It is one way how I have managed to trick people in the past, I played some songs that didn't fit the stereotype, and suddenly people were interested and asked me what this music was 👀 And obviously, that flute here is THE scene-stealer of the song for me, every time. I love how it's written to counterbalance whatever the song melody is doing (though I should now use the proper term "counterpoint", since you just taught me this one) 😉 Thank you for another lovely and entertaining video! Also thank you for the dedication to studying the lyrics beforehand! And then the additional comments on the lyrics are just so wonderful to hear, and gain a new perspective on them 💜 🥕 CFA
Ohhh I forgot about that big mind map thing! I can't remember if I retweeted it or some tagged me, but now I'm curious to look through since it's been a while! As far as counterpoint, I'm sure a lot of classical musicians would hear me say that and scoff because "true" counterpoint has a lottt of rules and stuff.... but I'm a jazz musician, and jazz musicians say here are the rules, now let's get rid of them and just make it sound good 😂
@@AndrewBergSax i saw it on your account, so you did retweet it 😁 Ah, those pesky rules... (Your description of jazz vs classics sounds almost the same as how somebody once described contemporary dance to me: take all the training and foundations from ballet, but then forget about rules and just do whatever you want to express a story)
Since we're watching you react to a clip, the music we're hearing is generations from the original concert (Magic Shop fan meeting in Osaka, I believe) but I thought I heard a second flute that played a more melodious line than the obvious first flute (I played your reaction back to listen to the drum section behind the vocal/rap line, as you pointed out and thought I caught the second flute). I watched the Busan Magic Shop concert, they did not perform this song (regretfully!) but what a show! If you're looking to react to a concert on your Patreon, that would be a number one choice. Number two would be Wembley Speak Yourself tour (with the Young Forever interaction).
I am happily drunk by Jimin's unique, beautiful, and powerful voice and his aristocratic and elegant visuals. Jimin, who owns all the beauty, is healing in itself.🥰😍
Haha I didn't watch yet, I will in a moment, but I wanted to say that I was so sure that it would be 134340. I don't know why people thought that it would be UGH!... I think that hints about lyrics analize made people think like that, but! Hint about music was quiet big clue for Pluto plus this lyrics hints, that all was enough for me. I'm so shook that so many people were wrong.💜 Ugh! have great lyrics, I love this song, but I don't think this hints were fitting to this song. 😉
I've been recommending this song repeatedly. Like how could a jazz musician not listen to BTS' most jazzy/loungey number. Thank you 🤣🤣🤣. One thing though, their arrangements for live is always different from the studio recording 🤗
@@AndrewBergSax I know, i watched all your videos kkkk I mean a reaction with Caitlin, can be others BTS older songs from the HYYH era tho. I love when you guys do a reaction together, she not only completes the critical analysis, picking up things you don't see or isn't your area, but also her energy perfectly matches yours. You guys, as your own person, really complete each other. In short, it's more fun with both. The dogs to, we dont forget the dogs.
The first few times I heard this song, I didn't like it. I think because it was confusing to me. Like, what does the background instrumentals have to do with the melody they're singing in the chorus? Do you think that's why people describe it as 'jazzy'? Loved that you both reacted to this together! Both of you had really interesting observations. The more I learn about the song, the more I like it. Actually, while I was watching your reaction, I was noticing the bass guitar the most during that last part of the song. #Armography #WhatsPoppinGirl #Unresolved CFA
Yeah it's interesting, the more I think about it, the more I think that it includes a lot of similar qualities to jazz, even though I don't think it necessarily sounds like stereotypical jazz to me. Like the use of the flute to me is just part of the layering to keep the song more interesting. I also have some other thoughts I might talk about in the livestream this weekend if I remember! It's too much to type out 😅 Also I love your hashtags 😂
This song is "the one" that make me fall harder for BTS... I mean how can science explained in to sort of one sided love mixed with lovely music and flute too... They are geniusly talented... 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Y'all need to do the storyline, it's very complicated. You have to go back to 2013 .When they started . no more dream. They're debut song. ua-cam.com/video/rBG5L7UsUxA/v-deo.html Every song is related from the beginning to the end. ( not the last songs, butter, permission to dans, Life goes on, Coldplay, Dynamites) this are songs mate during covid, to amuse the people, feel good songs. The storyline will keep you busy for sure. Why are you never talking about V. Please notice him. love and greetings from a Army from Belgium
I've actually talked about V a lot on other videos!! Stigma is one of my favorite solo songs and in my Learn Music with BTS video, I spent about half the video talking about him 😊 And we plan on looking at the BU at some point, but I know it will be harder to focus on the music aspects of the songs if we're focused the entire time on trying to see the connections in the storyline, so we're holding off for now
Whenever Yoongi whispers “ˢᵘᵍᵃ” before his verse, I know my ears are about to be blessed 💕
Ohhh I'll have to listen back for that!
@@AndrewBergSax he does this before many of his raps start once you hear it a few times you start to listen for it.
@@AndrewBergSax there are compilations on yt of suga saying his name before his verse haha. once he featured on someone's song and the song was about to be released when he told them "i need to change something" and they were really confused that it was just him whispering his name in the beginning 🤣 but he kinda stopped doing it recently.
@@fruehlingsbotin in Stay Alive he did it but many miss it
@@marinal. I'll have to listen for it, thnx.
Very true.... They have such a versatile discography you can't help but listen to every song and along the way find your own song(s) and the fact that I've seen many people including myself starting to like even love the songs which are completely not our cup of tea....I mean I'm still shocked.... I don't know how they do it, but then again they are BTS 😂😂😂
That is so true!! There are so many songs I never thought I would like based on the genre alone, but here we are. Haha
@@AndrewBergSax that's BTS for you... No one can do it like them...
Anyone who says there is nothing in the BTS discography for them 1) hasn't actually listened to the BTS discography, 2) has a (hopelessly) closed mind due to pre-conceived ideas, or 3) is actively trying hard not to like them. (There is a fourth option - racism/xenophobia - but any of the first three don't *automatically* mean the fourth is true, in my opinion. It *can* be the underlying reason, but isn't always the reason.)
@@OT7_DopeOldARMY I think it's probably they have listened to English songs and made up their minds that they only make songs lyrics like that and also what you said preconceived notion
@@AndrewBergSax nice, lol. Love that.
Jhope and Jin’s dynamics are magical! Intense and captivating!💜💜
DYNAMICS 🤩 I'm not sure if you're a musician or picked up this term from my video last week, but either way it makes me happy to see someone talking about it. Haha. Also I completely agree that they do a great job!!
@@AndrewBergSax I’m a musician ☺️
Thanks 💜💜💜
I watched a reactor who said "the flute is kinda distracting" which would make sense because Pluto doesn't want you to forget it -
flute is Pluto. It made so much sense to me :) It was buzzing around in the background like a busy bee as if to say "don't forget about me"
Haha oh that's an interesting way of thinking about it! I actually loved the flute throughout, it made the song much more unique 😀
@@AndrewBergSaxI love it too and you’re right Andrew I never expected I would love these type of songs or rapping at all but now I accepte that It's BTS to me
Haha - I remember that reaction, and that comment just made me 🤦♀️.
@@AndrewBergSax same
@@AndrewBergSax "Flute - Pluto" is a wordplay since these two words sound almost the same in Korean accent. There's no "f" sound in Korean, p is usually used to substitute f. Also they sometimes can't just finish a word with a consonant, so they often add some vowel at the end of the word. These things make the word "flute (플루트)" sound almost like "Pluto (플루토)".
The music industry says they aren't real rappers/singers because they don't fit standard genres. But BTS will continue to love music and stay in orbit even if the rest of the solar system won't acknowledge them.
This is one of the VERY few songs where I would actually have recommended the studio version, not that they don’t still absolutely kill this live, but the production (which they do recreate fairly well for stage) is just so good at creating the ‘vibe’ of the theme - especially in J-Hope’s verse.
somehow i have a feeling Andrew has listened to the Spotify version of this since recording 🤞😅
BTS Bossa Nova + genius lyrics, one of their hidden gems, love that you reacted to this!
I agree! This song definitely feels like a hidden gem
Currently at universal right now so I’ll watch this later! Just wanted to say that this is one of my favorite songs, especially the bridge with Jin and Hobi, so I hoped you guys enjoyed! 💜
We did enjoy, and I hope you enjoy Universal! Say hello to Hogwarts for me 😀
This is such a cool song. I love how they can take current events and turn them into the most amazing music!
Yes!!! This is so true!!
@@AndrewBergSax nods
Seokjin live 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Hip-hop, beatboxing...flute. Hmmmmm...this isn't K-pop anymore, is it? What a smart, groovy song! Loved your and Caitlin's thoughtful, informed reaction! I especially appreciate what you notice in the background, Andrew.
Thank you! This is definitely not your typical pop song 😂
@@AndrewBergSax Kpop is not a genre. People keep forgetting 😖
Zizi K. said on 6/23/21
Kpop is not a genre actually, it's an industry because groups can choose whatever genre they want. I know you can listen to like one or two songs from a singer or group and get the gist of their sound but with BTS, their discography is so varied that you need to listen to a variety of the music to get who they are.
@@AndrewBergSax Zizi K. said on 6/23/21
Kpop is not a genre actually, it's an industry because groups can choose whatever genre they want. I know you can listen to like one or two songs from a singer or group and get the gist of their sound but with BTS, their discography is so varied that you need to listen to a variety of the music to get who they are.
They have surpassed pop long ago
Every time I hear this song I always mentally picture the seven of them in a 1970's conversation pit with a burnt orange aesthetic while sipping martini's lol
Hahaha great image and I totally agree
Bc you watched live version you didn't see or hear a lot of stylistic choises in song bc they don't do that live, like Suga and Jin part that are like voice from space 🔭🌌 (they use this effect like phone) and Suga little wisper of his name that fans love and this little conversation inside his verse 😋 and Jhope rap is little faster and more in face (I don't know how to better explain it).😉
I don't know if you now heard album version but I curious what you think of this, live is great and they sing so good it and they don't do this song normaly, they did it for muster only, so I'm happy that there is live version. Jin and Jimin shine for me here💜.
I don't know if someone told you but this song was choose by NASA for their space playlist to listen in space stacion/prom.
They were looking for songs that were great represenation of cosmos and this is one of them. 😁
Everything about this song is unexpected it’s a 70s flute jazz fun song about poor Pluto. So very geeky and clever. You two are as always a pick me up to watch!
I agree, Andrew. when you commented about Jimin and then Jin and later V singing without "backing" and it's one of the reasons why I like the vocal artistry of this song. I feel like if they tried to not belt those notes full out they would not be in the right orbit. I love this song, it is a very adult-sounding song to me. Great reaction Bergs💜💜
"YOU'LL LIKE OUR MUSIC IF YOU LISTEN TO IT WITHOUT PREJUDICE"
-Min Yoongi(Suga, BTS)
Hi, i am back. Good reaction, ty. I think u might be remembering this quote. I used to paste a lot of info for baby Army on the 1st few vids. =0p Yw, lol. Really cool song. Smooth. Jazz or blues vibe for me. They all sound so good. It's a bop. Loved hearing your thoughts. Hugs. Love u both. Stay safe. -NY USA Army💟
Love 134340!!!
Yes! It's such a creative song!
i agree, I have been saying that BTS is their own genre. My personal taste is folk/classic rock, but I enjoy other styles also. I haven't found a BTS song I don't enjoy, and I think I have heard them all now. I even like the rap songs, I have never been a rap fan. The mix of genres and BigHit/Hybe allowing them to experiment and letting each member shine while supporting each other is magic.
I KNEW IT!!! T-T why do I always get confused when people are wrong? XD
(next, you'll love Rain and prob Am I wrong :D)
Jin+JHope+...JK! = Jamais Vu :) You'll like it too! (well, I do like all their songs but you know what I mean)
HA! I got it from the counterpoint thing, since I always feel the distress they are portraying by being demoted Pluto in the instrumental track vs vocal track. It's just all "weird" but fits.
For those interested: the "culprit" of the demotion was Mike Brown (my bias xD), I got to know him on a caltech online course (a MOOC from Coursera: The Science of the Solar System) where apart from talking about the topic he took his time to explain how all came to happen in 2006 :_) and it hurt him as much as everyone else to accept the consequences lol
Yes!! I was surprised the votes were so wrong 😂 and I agree about it all being weird but that it fits together. And I love the background info on the pluto decision. Haha
@@AndrewBergSax Right? T-T
And I self-doubt myself all the time lol.
Yes, I was so "angry" when it all happened, I liked the number 9... but again, I guess people were angry with Copernicus and Galileo back then too xDDDD
Also getting to know THE guy for 1 semester was eye-opening.
See you tomorrow, I guess! (?)
This is one of my faves!! So glad you reacted to it.. the kyrics, the melody.. so so good!
That's so true, SUGA said that if you just listen to their music without any prejudice, you'll definitely find a song that you'll really love.
Every BTS song is a masterpiece on its own, you have a song that can soothe your every mood. Plus lyrics and music production are very well thought out.
Oh that's the line!! I know I've read it a million times, but I don't think I've seen the clip of him saying it before
@@AndrewBergSax i've found this so far (picture of a magazine interview/profile, where this quote is printed):
twitter.com/Canada_BTS/status/860357956457693184?s=20&t=6cSNHRG7ifo-oySz7ZcxEg
@@AndrewBergSax "YOU'LL LIKE OUR MUSIC IF YOU LISTEN TO IT WITHOUT PREJUDICE"
-Min Yoongi(Suga, BTS)
@@AndrewBergSax sent the magazine clip on Discord. 🙂
Nobody can walk a stage like BTS…. Confident, bold, full of swag, yet still down to earth.💜💜💜
Yesssss!! Pluto finally!!!!
Thanks for the reaction! I purple u! 💜💜💜
💜💜💜
THIS is the one I've been waiting for!
Interesting that people say it has a jazzy feel. It feels like Bossa Nova to me, but that's what I'm more used to.
It's a really great song, and so poetic.
Yeah, I thought more like neo soul or losing hip hop, but I can see the bossa nova feel as well!
@@AndrewBergSax huh, interesting. I also think jazz or blues.
Just the lyrics….like who thinks to write a song about a planet???? ONLY RM & BTS!!! These guys just blow my mind every time💜💜💜💜 loved this rxn!
my favorite BTS song!!!! looooovei it!!! lyrics is sooooo sick
This is my favorite bts song, I'm glad you guys reacted to it:)
I really like it! It is extremely interesting and nice to listen to
@@AndrewBergSax sweet
This is such an amazing song and I live for these B-sides gems that gives their catalog depth
This is my favorite song! It’s such an amazing song lyrically & musically! Thank you for the reaction 💜
This is the most genius song ever"
There is magic in their in ears lol
Yes, I loved the flute. But others claim it doesn't fit. To me the flute gives the outer space feel.
what? i love this flute! 😲
So beautiful song 💜 Thank you so much 💖 Love you two💜💜💜
I got it right!!! I voted for Pluto!😉😅 I love this song so much!😍 thanks for reacting🥰
Ah, this song! So glad you enjoyed it! . I did discover it when I was starting to look properly into their lyrics (meaning I found proper translators) and I was blown away: "sorry, is this a take on unrequited love using Pluto's downgrading as a planet, with Bossa Nova sexy vibes? Who are this people???!!" Loved your reaction, love from the UK! Borahae!
Andrew, I have missed your musical reactions and so to see you came back with THIS reaction put a huge smile on my face. This song is in my top 10 BTS songs for its witty metaphor and the back and forth between the rap verses and vocal chorus that is glorious to my ears. THANK YOU to you and Caitlin.
I loved this reaction !! 134340 is my most favourite song ever. Just a little request : could you react to the spotify version too ? I would love your analysis
SOOO glad you reacted to this, it's really a shining gem in BTS's discography imo! The way the music reflects the message in the pluto metaphor (some ppl posted great comments about the flute's role) is one of the most genius things I've ever seen! And yes true BTS has something for everyone. Thanks for sharing this with us!
CFA
I just love that song so much, thank you for reacting to it 💜
I love this song! I like the “exposed” parts a lot, because it gives the song a lonely feel. As if you are just drifting and circling all alone in space. I really love the flute too.
Edited to add : Some of my favorite lyrics are “Us is just the plural form of u, perhaps I was never there from the start”
namjooon flexing his wordplay game 🤩
Ohhh I like those lyrics too! And I completely agree about the lonely feel of those moments
Jin V👑👑👑💜💜💜🇦🇷
Wanna enjoy this song in an even MORE fun way?! Imagine it's Ron Burgundy on the flute!😉 💜 #flutesolo
😂
I think what you *might* be thinking of at 11:20 is Yoongi's "You'll like BTS music if you listen without prejudice." quote. Or maybe not, but that's definitely one armys bring up a lot, because it's very true 😊💜
That's it!
I discovered this song a couple of years ago. I LOVE the flute! On a different channel, there was a comment that the flute was annoying. I was surprised as I thought it was what gave the song the jazz vibe. And the lyrics. This song if one my top BTS songs. Enjoy your reactions. 💜
Darnit! I was hoping for "What's poppin', girl?" 😆
I'm here for the hip-hop flute and the armography! The smoky layers of mist bit is actually one of my favourite lines from the song. 👍
we have to hold out for another week, for "what's poppin' girl", it seems 😔
Hahahahaha I guess we'll have to just keep waiting for that day 😂
You are so right, there is such a different vibe to each song and their performances add another layer on top of the music and musicality, on top of the lyrics. Glad to see Caitlin on this song with you, it was a great song for her insight, the visual of a fire that has been put out was perfect, and you balanced it so well with your musical insights. I have a playlist that currently has 90 BTS group and solo songs and I think I counted at least 15 missing from this list. Keep updating your spreadsheet, you have about 85 songs to go, ha ha! And I would watch every video you make. Keep up the great work, I love your videos!
Hahaha yeah, I just did a quick check and it looks like I have about 210 songs to go, according to my list 😂 And thank you so much!
재발 이노래좀 무대에서 자주 불러 주라 방탄 아들들아 넘 조아여
BTS are their own "genre" in music. there is no other genre that discribes thrm.
I've been waiting soooooooo long for this one!
Hahaha it was recommended a lot in the beginning of my journey and I finally had to check it out!!
I have been waiting for you two to do this song. I love it. One of my favorites. Thank you so much
Pls react to their 'Rise of bangtan' live japan epilogue (Attack on bangtang).It's so funny & chaotic😂
This song is one of my favorites such sweet voices. Jimins voice is out of this world such a beautiful voice . I love all my boyz they all have amazing voice BTS ARMY 4EVER
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Yes!!! Jimin's voice really works well for this style!
@@AndrewBergSax yep yep =0]
Yay!!! my "let's rope some physicists into BTS content" song! hehe 🤗
Caitlin's reaction to RM's little dance in the intro 😁 I'd say your bias is showing 😉
And yeah, I love the way the lyrics are constructed in these different layers of meaning.
The exposed chorus vocals for "I'm just orbiting you"... oh yeah, I'd be terrified to attempt that. There's barely anything in that range that they can reference against.
"There is something for everyone" yeah. I think the quote you're remembering is from Yoongi? And I also vaguely remember you sharing a music guide on your Twitter at some point, with songs sorted by genre, on a huge mind map?
It is one way how I have managed to trick people in the past, I played some songs that didn't fit the stereotype, and suddenly people were interested and asked me what this music was 👀
And obviously, that flute here is THE scene-stealer of the song for me, every time. I love how it's written to counterbalance whatever the song melody is doing (though I should now use the proper term "counterpoint", since you just taught me this one) 😉
Thank you for another lovely and entertaining video! Also thank you for the dedication to studying the lyrics beforehand! And then the additional comments on the lyrics are just so wonderful to hear, and gain a new perspective on them 💜
🥕 CFA
Ohhh I forgot about that big mind map thing! I can't remember if I retweeted it or some tagged me, but now I'm curious to look through since it's been a while!
As far as counterpoint, I'm sure a lot of classical musicians would hear me say that and scoff because "true" counterpoint has a lottt of rules and stuff.... but I'm a jazz musician, and jazz musicians say here are the rules, now let's get rid of them and just make it sound good 😂
@@AndrewBergSax i saw it on your account, so you did retweet it 😁
Ah, those pesky rules...
(Your description of jazz vs classics sounds almost the same as how somebody once described contemporary dance to me: take all the training and foundations from ballet, but then forget about rules and just do whatever you want to express a story)
Since we're watching you react to a clip, the music we're hearing is generations from the original concert (Magic Shop fan meeting in Osaka, I believe) but I thought I heard a second flute that played a more melodious line than the obvious first flute (I played your reaction back to listen to the drum section behind the vocal/rap line, as you pointed out and thought I caught the second flute). I watched the Busan Magic Shop concert, they did not perform this song (regretfully!) but what a show! If you're looking to react to a concert on your Patreon, that would be a number one choice. Number two would be Wembley Speak Yourself tour (with the Young Forever interaction).
You two are my favorite couple on the youtube, you just radiate good and honest energy. 💜
Thank you! That means so much to us 💜
I really hope you listen to the studio version too!! It’s such a lovely song!!
I guessed right on the poll. I just knew it about Hobi's rap.
Hahaha one of the few who got it! 🤩
I relate to this song so much
Yeah, these lyrics really can hit you in the feels
V from BTS plays the saxophone.
I am happily drunk by Jimin's unique, beautiful, and powerful voice and his aristocratic and elegant visuals. Jimin, who owns all the beauty, is healing in itself.🥰😍
this is the analogy.
us: the sun
BTS: pluto.
someone else: eris
.the sun no longer considers pluto because the sun found a bigger planet that is eris
Haha I didn't watch yet, I will in a moment, but I wanted to say that I was so sure that it would be 134340. I don't know why people thought that it would be UGH!... I think that hints about lyrics analize made people think like that, but! Hint about music was quiet big clue for Pluto plus this lyrics hints, that all was enough for me. I'm so shook that so many people were wrong.💜
Ugh! have great lyrics, I love this song, but I don't think this hints were fitting to this song. 😉
Haha I was surprised too! I thought I made it too easy 😅
Yay for being the first one here! 💜
You win a gold star! 🌟 😀
i miss you both! hope you are doing good. 💜
PLEASE do UGH at some point I'm sure you would find so much to talk about even though it's rap.
excitedd!!
😀
I've been recommending this song repeatedly. Like how could a jazz musician not listen to BTS' most jazzy/loungey number. Thank you 🤣🤣🤣. One thing though, their arrangements for live is always different from the studio recording 🤗
I guessed it right 😎
One of the few! 😎
Plz react to Serendipity live. It's awsome live...everyone's solos are awsome
I'm due for another Jimin solo soon!
@@AndrewBergSax oh my gosh so excited!
*React to 'Over The Horizon' by Suga, Samsung asked him to produced it!*
check the channel, Andrew did a whole analysis of the track already 😉💜
The flute reminds me of Will Ferrel in Anchorman lmao
Please react to ddang and tear with Catlyn the lyrics are amazing.
Yes!! Those two are on my list!
@@AndrewBergSax I can’t wait too see your reaction those two are some of my favorite songs
😀😀
Thanks for the reaction.
Please, bless us with a reaction to house of cards.
It was one of the first BTS songs Andrew reacted to 😉:
ua-cam.com/video/ayNY-OX3qEQ/v-deo.html
I've actually already done that one! I think it was one of my first 5 BTS reactions 😊
Friend! Go find it in the archives! It was really early on!
@@AndrewBergSax I know, i watched all your videos kkkk
I mean a reaction with Caitlin, can be others BTS older songs from the HYYH era tho.
I love when you guys do a reaction together, she not only completes the critical analysis, picking up things you don't see or isn't your area, but also her energy perfectly matches yours.
You guys, as your own person, really complete each other.
In short, it's more fun with both.
The dogs to, we dont forget the dogs.
Armoreography hahahaha I like it! 🙂💜💜💜
Hahaha Caitlin thinks of the most random words 😂
Hola ya que estas reaccionando a los tesoros escondidos reacción porfa a LOOK HERE... TOMOROW... BUTTERFLY... 💜
The first few times I heard this song, I didn't like it. I think because it was confusing to me. Like, what does the background instrumentals have to do with the melody they're singing in the chorus? Do you think that's why people describe it as 'jazzy'?
Loved that you both reacted to this together! Both of you had really interesting observations. The more I learn about the song, the more I like it. Actually, while I was watching your reaction, I was noticing the bass guitar the most during that last part of the song.
#Armography #WhatsPoppinGirl #Unresolved
CFA
i forgot about #unresolved ! 😲
😣
Yeah it's interesting, the more I think about it, the more I think that it includes a lot of similar qualities to jazz, even though I don't think it necessarily sounds like stereotypical jazz to me.
Like the use of the flute to me is just part of the layering to keep the song more interesting. I also have some other thoughts I might talk about in the livestream this weekend if I remember! It's too much to type out 😅
Also I love your hashtags 😂
This song is "the one" that make me fall harder for BTS... I mean how can science explained in to sort of one sided love mixed with lovely music and flute too... They are geniusly talented... 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Please react to BTS Butter Grammy performance.
Just did! 😀
Junkook love
Namjoon😊❤
Wait….will you guys be going to vegas for the concert(s)???
Unfortunately no! We already have a few trips planned this year and we're also moving soon so we need to save our money 🙁
Y'all need to do the storyline, it's very complicated. You have to go back to 2013 .When they started . no more dream. They're debut song. ua-cam.com/video/rBG5L7UsUxA/v-deo.html Every song is related from the beginning to the end. ( not the last songs, butter, permission to dans, Life goes on, Coldplay, Dynamites) this are songs mate during covid, to amuse the people, feel good songs. The storyline will keep you busy for sure. Why are you never talking about V. Please notice him. love and greetings from a Army from Belgium
I've actually talked about V a lot on other videos!! Stigma is one of my favorite solo songs and in my Learn Music with BTS video, I spent about half the video talking about him 😊
And we plan on looking at the BU at some point, but I know it will be harder to focus on the music aspects of the songs if we're focused the entire time on trying to see the connections in the storyline, so we're holding off for now