Is Dr. Zakir Naik too arrogant to engage in meaningful dialogue?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 жов 2024
- Farnood Alam is a journalist and columnist based in Islamabad, recognized for his contributions to major publications across Pakistan. His writing covers a wide array of topics, including education, environment, health, politics, human rights, interfaith harmony, women’s rights, and cultural criticism. Interestingly, he is an alumnus of Binnori Town madrassa in Karachi.
With over 12 years of experience as a Media and Content Manager at the International Committee of the Red Cross, Farnood has honed his expertise in humanitarian issues.
He spearheaded the Humanitarian Reporting Initiative, a collaborative project with the Centre of Excellence in Journalism at IBA. This initiative aims to enhance the ethical reporting skills of local journalists on critical themes such as climate change, sexual and gender-based violence, and misinformation. Since its inception in 2017, the project has successfully engaged over 400 journalists from across Pakistan through workshops, fellowships, awards, and global webinars.
In addition to his journalistic endeavors, Farnood is a highly qualified consultant with over a decade of experience in designing, supervising, and developing training programs.
Currently, he contributes as a columnist, blogger, and analyst for the Urdu service of Deutsche Welle (DW) and the leading newspaper Daily Jang. He also serves as the Director of Cyclorama Media, a production house based in Islamabad.
*****************************
Jamshed Iqbal is a peacebuilder, trainer, and developmentcommunication expert whoo fostersg non-violent resolutions to faith and identity-based conflicts. He has provided consultative services to various national and international organizations engaged in peacebuilding initiatives. With nearly a decade of experience in religious peacebuilding and training programs, Jamshed has authored several training manuals and articles that contribute to this field.
Specialties: An internationally recognized writer, translator, and motivational speaker, Jamshed is known for his analytical skills and his ability to communicate complex ideas with clarity. He addresses themes of peace, democracy, and identity-based conflicts at both scholarly and accessible levels.
*****************************
Sabookh Syed is an Islamabad-based journalist, anchor, and political and religious analyst with over 25 years of experience in leading media organizations across Pakistan. He currently serves as the editor of ibcurdu.com, a prominent Urdu-language news website.
Previously, Sabookh hosted the show "Mutabadil Bayania" (Alternative Narrative) on Aap News, where he engaged in discussions on contemporary issues. Prior to this, he worked as a Special Correspondent and Anchorperson at Geo News for a decade, covering religious political parties, jihadist organizations, and significant events, including the conflict in Balochistan, military operations in Swat and Waziristan, the Red Mosque incident, and the operation against Osama bin Laden.
In addition to his media work, Sabookh remained affiliated with the University of Virginia as a Pakistan-based research coordinator. He has been selected as an Iqbal Research Fellow at the Institute of Research and Development (IRD), where he will author a book as part of the fellowship.
Throughout his career, he has contributed articles to various national and international newspapers and magazines and has appeared on multiple TV channels as an expert on religious and political issues, including jihadist organizations.
*****************************
Shakil Chaudhary is a journalist, author, and researcher. He is an alumnus of Government College, Lahore. Subsequently, he studied international relations at Quaid-i-Azam University Islamabad and media at the London School of Economics. He has worked for several English-language newspapers.
He has written a critically acclaimed bilingual book, Handbook of Functional English (Ferozsons), to help those who wish to improve their English skills. Prof. Tariq Rahman, one of the finest linguistic scholars in South Asia, has praised it in these words: “This book is an excellent guide for the South Asian user of the English language."
If you want to see his most popular videos, here are the links to them.
• Javid Baig: Massive development is ha...
• Why didn't Jinnah implement Islam in ...
• Prof. Hoodbhoy: Pakistan is not a nor...
• Shahid Siddiqui: The partition ruined...
You’re welcome to follow him on Facebook and Twitter.
/ shakil.chaudary
/ shakchaudhary
Dear Friends,
If you find my videos valuable, please share them with your friends and subscribe to the channel. I welcome your comments, but please use civil language; being uncivil does not make your argument more convincing. Feel free to disagree with me or my guests, but do so respectfully. Rudeness discourages my guests from returning to the channel. If you wish to present an opposing view on my show, please send me your contact details.f
Here are the links to my most popular videos:
ua-cam.com/video/hWJugbilQd8/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/hRDiEe90z6Y/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/sqHGMhJkygc/v-deo.html
You are welcome to follow me on Facebook and Twitter.
facebook.com/shakil.chaudary
twitter.com/ShakChaudhary
Sir aapko, parvej hoodboy sir ko, arzoo kazmi jaise logo ko ek baar Jakir Naik k lecture me jaker questions kerne chahiye....😊🙏
@@arya.bharat
Azroo kazmi kseko muh dkha k lyk nh hy , woh anti national lgti hy mjko
Zakir nayak se zyada hate speach karnw wala hai koi kya. Poora jehadi hai wo
@@DrStrange234why? Aisa kya keha unhone!
Mai mumbai se hu or zakir ne khub khub chanda liya hai saudi Arabia se or totally fake program karta tha.. Khud ke aadmi he hindu ban kar question karte they.. Paise ka bhukha hai💰
Convertion to any religion is an act of killing a whole culture, tradition and civilization of that innocent people.😢😢😢
And also converted firstly become antinational also.
Isn't it stunning that four learned people are discussing a fool.
Are they really learned😅
@@sanatani_bhau74 we have to assume it. Because they are discussing a fool.🤣🤣🤣
when a person is influencing millions towards separatism extremism radicalism and terrorism he is a negative celebrity.
They are not discussing a fool but trying to somehow normalise and establish Islamists covertly. Read between the lines....what appears as is is not always so
I am very much disappointed by the rude behavior of Dr. Zakir Naik. I must salute to patience of Indian people, who tolerated this person so long.
ZN is like this from the begining. However, he markets religion and emotion of people of same faith.
He is mutter fkker who under Congress rule poisoned Muslim brotherhood mind converted people on tv
Zahil Nalayak finally reached his destination .... Being an Indian our humble request is Pakistani Government should provide parmanent citizenship to Zakir Naik 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Correct bro ... Zahil nalayak should be made president of Pakistan and his joker son fariq naik should be made president of Bangladesh. These Islamists deserve these jokers so much
Exactly
Do Business by using Islam ???
Refused to take it.
Can’t agree more .
Sabookh Sahab thinks that all religions in this world are mirror images of the PEACEFUL RELIGION ! (6:35 mins)
Pakistan to India : Please trade
India to Pakistan: Ok take Zakir Nayak 😂 We Indian hindus are knowing your islam deeper than all of you Al taqia doesnt work now😂
Zakir sir follow and preaching the real islam .
Yes youtube earning is haram
You are haram by commenting here and leading to youtube earning
😂 he is guru of non muslims, because of him we know reality of islam@Vert-t6t
ex muslim sameer ke saamne wajidi bhi bhaag chuka hai aur hug bhi
Pakistan doesn’t give this right to preach to any other religion.
Jakir Nayak is the next version of Baba-e-Qaum. He is one of the great Islamic scholars of 21th century... continously exposing the beauty of Islam.
Zakir Naik , earlier used to live in India and had amassed huge wealth through his oratorical skills in Islamic theology. He had good hold on pulse of Muslim crowds and because of secular nature of Indian state many non Islamic people also used to attend his discourses . It is believed that these non-Muslims were planted in audience to ask questions to suit extending his arguments. They were tactics for converting illiterate, poor Hindus or mislead them . This made him to acquire huge donations. He attracted people mostly on the basis of his ability to quote Islamic Scriptures, famous books other religions and twist everything for glorification of Islam . Students admired him for his ability to “ ratta “ and swiftly transiting from Urdu , Hindi to English.
Pakistani scholars, educationists , madarsa managers are great admirers of “ Ratta “ methodology in education , theology and philosophy. This is how they prevailed on government to invite him to Pakistan with full honours of a State Guest. In Malaysia he is hardly heard because of language issues, this trip gave him chance revive his skills . But nevertheless a very mean man, made people to regret their government decision
Dr. Zakir Naik is an asset for Pakistan. he should stay and preach in Pakistan forever. He will enlighten lot of people.
Sir, what an amazing panel you have. Appreciate their deep knowledge and liberal thought.. Respect to all. Such people are missing among Indian muslims in India.
Zakir Naik is Allah's gift to Islam. Allah created him by his own hands and in his own image. He clarifies what Allah wants to show.
Subhan Allah.
A regressive country invites a preacher with a regressive mindset to address its people for progress. Doesn't this sound strange?
Yaar aapko kya pata Islam ke bare me ? Yahi quran aur hadid me likha hai, ankh kholo
Only one speaker is speaking his one sided views. Why other 2 speakers are called.
Hello main India se hun Pakistan Ek liberal Mulk Hai vah Islamic hai hi nahin aur Halat Aise ki Ban Bhi Nahin Sakta Hai Ek Islamic scholar se aap log liberalism Chahte Hain I am very shocked
I'm also Indian
You are right. Pakistani name ka Muslims
Ye log serf Islam ke name per 4 se 5 shadi krta bus
Apne fyda ke lye Islam use.
Sir,Us Jakir Joker ko aap log apne desh me citizen bana lijye.Kaise apke log uska bakwaas jhelte h.
Malaysia k citizen hy Dr Naik , pakistan state visit pr ay hy only for tour not to stay .
@@DrStrange234waha bhi zakir ka public speech ban hai.
@@incredibleindia9844
Nh hy , they don't understand urdu hindi there only local malay , Dr sahab gives speech in english , Main fan base to india pakistan bangladesh hy unka
Jakir Naik translated as Joker Nalaayak.😂😂😂
We want zakir nayak vs adam seeker ex muslim movement zindabad
Exmuslim Sahil podcast❤❤
This fellow Sabookh is as good 😅 as Zakir Naik. A journalist not only asks question but analyses the answer with wisdom and logic.
The points of farnood alam is well appreciated
Talk with ex muslim sahil
Ex muslim sahil ❤️❤️❤️
Zakir Naik has bookish knowledge not practical knowledge🌺🌺🌺
آپ حضرات ڈاکٹر ذاکر نائیک کو مباحثہ کی دعوت دے دیں تاکہ پبلک دونوں کا نقطہ نظر جان کر خود فیصلہ کرے۔
I do not agree with some of the things your speakers are saying. Ie
1. Every majhab dawat deta hai conversion ke liye. We hindus do not do that. If you want to become hindu, that is your choice. To the best of my knowledge jews also do not do that. And conversion is done by criticizing and claiming that others will go to hell (an out right falsehood and lie) and by creating fear that kafirs will go to hell and burn their.
2. kafir word itself is derogatory in islam. They why muslims get upset when others criticize Islam, Mohammad and kuran, Allah and muslim practices ie 4 wives, cousin marriages, marriages of 6 year girls etc
3. Truth Islam structure is built on lot If lies, it is self righteous, demeaning other religion, total closed door system which unwilling to change and improve. It gone to extent that there cannot be any reformer other than Mohammed. How can one predict future?
4. Dividing the world into muslims and kafirs, try to impose muslim parameters on others.
5. New concept called religious tolerance is another foolish concept. It just tolerates other but it is not prepared to accept.
All this ideas are not only foolish but outright non sensical. That is the reason Islam is at conflict both within and outside its confines. It has promoted perpetual violence, killing, forced conversions, utter ill will.
Its positive contributions to humanity are minimal. India and hindus had suffered from islam tremendously. It expansion was always through sword, deceit and falsehood.
Internet is great blessing to understand most religions in proper perspective.
Few days back Ratan tata died and he was parsi who came yo india to save themselves from Islamic persecutions. If they had remained in iran, their contributions would have been in negativity killing, and saving burqs, hijab and ill will towards Israel. Look at how they thrived in india which induan muslims foolishly think they are being persecuted.
What nonsense.!!!
Exmuslim sahil 🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Adam seeker Urdu ko suno jaake 🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Your guest is drawing parallels between Dr. Hoodbhoy & Zakir Naik.
Currently they are on the same..
nice discussion ❤
A bunch of fools taking against a genius.
Pahle he Pakistanis me kum zeher bhra hua tha jo aur zehreela (insaan) to nahi keh sakte … terrorist he keh sakte hai …. jo bula liya
Ghamidi Sb is a much better scholar of Islam.
Pakistani muslim hate zakir now , indian muslim still love zakir why ?
There can be no meaningful dialogue when the matter at hand is bereft of logic. Logic is an anathema to blind faith, when he can't reason he becomes aggressive, lest he reveals the truth and agrees that he is illogical.
🎉 please accept whole time,wo ab aap ke sath ही रहेंगे वापस नहीं आयेंगे
Sabookh Syed uses a lot of words to say very little.
Jahi joker na laik 😂
It looks strange that Sabookh and Jomshed are are busy in discussion ignoring others including coordinator.
Zakir nayek apni jagah pe bilkul sahi hai, kyuki yahi apke mohammad sahab ne kaha hau, aur esse bhi ghatiha aapke hadid kuran me likha hai
Posting old video is cheating.
Shakil sir in 3no main ek exmuslim sahil bhi hona chahiyetha tab maja ata islam aakhir hain ky
Hahahahhahahah😂😢😅😂😅😂😅😂😅😅😂
Pakistan ki Majority toh Zakir Naik k piche hee hai,kuch tabka he hai toh iske khilaf hai wo bhi kuch kuch maalmle mein... mostly Pakistani muslim and Indian muslims isko bahot maante hai
Zakir nalayak h ye indians ke liye, please give him permanent resident I Pakistan
@@PRASHANTKUMAR-g7q6n main koi Pakistani ni hun jo residence dun , mere hisaab se toh Indian muslim or Pakistani muslims ko pakistan mein ek saath rehna chahiye kyunki yea log ek hee type k hai
@@infynvn Aur apni behen ko Bajaru bna dena, Shayad hm bhi Lahore aaye to unke darshan kr aaunga
Sala k2o ka channel kyu recommend ho raha hai ! Fukir nayak said exactly what your book and religion says and your wasool did and said . Then why do you have an issue with him?
Arbo se tumahara koi nata Nahi ye kabool kr lo itna hi bahut hai
Please allow jaid hamid beside zakir naik..will be a great comedy show 😅😅😅
Every one has been diverted from the actual issue that the girl had asked a question about...... and put behind what Zakir Naik said in reply, ok lets agree that Zakir Naik put it in not the right words..... why don't the Muftis and maulanas who are pointing fingers at him answer the actual question that the girl asked?????
A great show with a brilliant panel.
सर ये गिफ्ट हा प्लीज accept
Ignorant as well as arrogant -- and unmitigatedly foolish!! He's in Pakistan, I gather, as part of the Govt. initiative for developing the country's youth. Good luck with that. What a waste of resources and loss of international, especially India's, goodwill.
dard jab dil mein ho to davaa kiijiye
dil hi jab dard ho to kyaa kiijiye. 😭😭
In sahab se puchen aap ne kitno ko imandari se barabri di hay ya nahin🎉🎉🎉
Shakil saheb none of them your guest going condemn Zakir Naik thats why they avoid the main subject
Dr. Zakir sahib what a joke
One guest looks mad or something 😂😂
❤️❤️
Mr Sabookh looks like a molvi. He doesn't allow to speak others.
Mr.Sabookh, please let evrryone speak. You are not the only guest we need to listen.
Ab ye youtuber zakir naik pr 10 episode nikalega😂😂😂
Shakil Sahib, 100 of Programm on jakir on U tube. It is now boring to listen to such a,person like syed. He is pain in the neck.
He is not only arrogant but super confident that no deeni intellectual from Pakistan has dum to take him upfront to counter his utter nonsensical jargon. He has clearly challenged on stage. Only you criticize him in these shows. Why don't you call him in your shows and ask for explanation what you find illogical.
Zakir ko aap Pakistan ka citizen bana lijiye na saheb.
Ek kitab se bahar sochne ki aukat nhi h is isme.
💕💕💕
Dr Joker Nalayak
Pagal party
❤
My humble request … kindly check immediately when he says sura no so and so and Aayat no so and so . Mostly wrong
Ur Pakistani are kalnaik people and Zakir is real naik
Ye syed akela bakwas kar raha hai kisi ko baat nahi karne deta very irritated
Bahi a Banda India me agar hota to adha India muslim hojata
Zakir Naik is right.
Mr. Syed took almost ten minutes to say something which he could have said in less then one minute.
Mr Sabookh Sayad is absolutely correct ki duniya ka har mazhab dusre ko convert karta hai. But it doesn't include dharma.
Where does a hindu, sikh ,Jain and budh convert anybody ? They never want to convert This bimari is only with Muslims and christianity
@@mohanrao6You are 100% correct.
Please provide him pakistan citizenship.then he also become president of pakistan
😂
Sabookh syed sir debate toh bahut acchi baat hai usese solution bhi nikalta hai.....
But problem ye hai ki Jakir Naik debate or cross question allow nahi kerta....
Aise logo se baat kerta hai jo jyada pedhe likhe nahi hai...
UA-cam per bahut se intellectual log hai jo islam ki acchi jankari rekhte hai unse wo baat nahi kerta....
Ex muslim Sahil and Adam seeker ne usko bahut baar Islam per debate kerne k liye bulaya but wo nahi aata....🙄
Why so much obsession about Islam… if you belong to a particular faith uski baat karo na… or ye ex Muslim kya hota hai… Muslim saath lagana kyun zaruri hai… khud ko atheist bolo, agnostic bolo… saaf pata Chalta hai ise kahaan se funding milti hai unhe
@@bookofeverything3204 1- bcz Puri duniya me jo terrorism hai usme 99% muslims hi involved hai...
2- 100 % terrorist organisations ka nam Islam or Mohamad k uper hai...
3- normal muslims hemesha ya toh terrorism ko support kerte hai ya unka silent rehker support kerte hai unke khilaaf khuch nahi bolte...
4- Christianity, hinduism mei reformation hui hai but muslims reformation nahi kerte...
5- Kuran mei Allah khud kafiro se nafrat kerne ki baat kerta hai or Muslims us kitab ko sacchi kitab manker kafiro se nafrat kerte hai..
@@arya.bharat 1. Who told you 99% Muslims are terrorists… u got any substantive research… btw what is a terrorist (one nation’s terrorist another nations freedom fighter???)…
2. Why do Hindus in red corridor fight??? What about communists??? What is happening in Myanmar and Manipur… what about Ukraine?? What about Wagner group??? What about Tamil Tigers??? What about NSCN (IM) ?What about Irish freedom movement?? Is is that when only Muslims fight they are referred to as terrorists just because you are unable to defeat us even with much greater strength…
3. So called terrorists have political grievances which they combine with Islam mostly wrongly … it has no basis in Islam but it doesn’t mean all of them are wrong… a lot of them have genuine political grievances… why on earth did US invade Iraq??? What was it expecting??? Wouldn’t militias be formed to fight against foreign occupation… why Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan? So mujahideen formed… Israel killed 50k in a year? Now what is it expecting in return , flowers??? It is just that Muslims aren’t cowards… they fight back even if they lack power which isn’t allowed btw in Islam…. In Islam you are obliged to fight only when you have substantial resources and strength to fight… but it is human instinct to fight back… who dropped atom bomb??? Who invaded Vietnam, Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan??? Who is involved in regime changes in the world? Who caused hunger despair by using sanctions on countries??? Gunda gardi kon karta hai Muslims??? Who caused death and destruction in two world wars??? Muslims??? Who did holocast??? Who ki**ed scientists world over during Cold War??? Muslims??? Who is shamelessly defending Isr**el and its inhumane actions???
4. Muslims don’t need reformation… if a religion needs reformation, usko kachre k dibbe me Jake phenk do because it implies from the outset it was wrong and misleading
5. Nafrat kon kis se karta hai sab Jante hai… agar itni hi nafrat muslims kafiron se karte to unhe convert karne ki koshish kabhi nhi karte… u know there is a hadees if someone kills a dhimmi (a non believer under Islamic rule), he won’t even smell paradise… nafrat kafir karte hai muslamanu se… that is what Quran says never trust Jews and it is evident in today’s world…
ذاکر بھائی اپنے آپ کو مسلمان ثابت نہیں کر سکتے۔ پاکستان میں
جو کسی بھی فرقے کو نہیں مانتا وہ مسلمان ڈاکٹر کو مانتے ہیں
ڈاکٹر ذاکر نایک کو ماننے والے سبھی جاہل ہیں۔ 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Shakil sahab
You are such a learned person, why so dumb topic like Zakir naik
Philosophy of this land is.......Go and seek yourself What is the Ultimate Reality in which ever way you want
Ap sab Pakistan fault log Ho bus Tv par Baker baat karna bhati Ho
So musalman ka farz hai ke jake dushron ko bole ke wo galat hai?
Syed is going on and on and on... is he saying anything new? Still awaiting pearls of wisdom or intellectually stimulating talk.
He was brought to Pakistan by your army or govt to avoid the problems u face, enjoy him😂
Laden amriki, bagdadi amriki, hamas amriki, hizbulla amriki ye to musalman aur maulana kahta hai😂😂😂
Namaste🙏
Shakil sir islam dhram se phle Saudi Arabia ka apna ek alag relegion tha mtlb saudi arabia bhi converted hai bt Hinduism ek asa religion hai jo kbhi bhi converted nahi hai ek hindu proud se ye kah sakta hai ki me ek hindu hu bt koi bhi religion ho usko ye kahna padta hai i am converted
Excellent Alam sb
choudhary sahb yeh chasma lgaya huva to desadgrd ha.
is ko kyo bulaya ha
Yes arrogant but more than that he knows he can't answer good questions. He afraid to face real debaters.
Majority of people in this world agree there is only one God. Is there anything you want?
Dawat ka kaam Maulana wahidudin khan Saab se seekho
Osama bin laden se kyu ni seekhna hai?
Banna toh tumhe jihadi he hai
Bagdadi se kyu nahi? Aakhir mein wo jungali Janwar zombie hi baneyga
aap jo krna chahte ha kariye koi kaya krta ha aap ne kia lena jo sahi karega uska bhi Allah jo galat karega uska bhi Allah.aap kon
Good job keep it up.
Well why you do not challenge Zakir Naik on his face. Go and ask questions to him and defeat him with your knowledge. Zakir Naik and Ahmed Didat woke Muslim Ummah up and they have defeated European and Hindu scholars who have been maligning Islam for last two to three centuries since Muslim countries were colonized. They have made common Muslim understand his religion and proud of its history and its traditions. Just shut up and stop back biting.
Discussion is least😊 interested
I and many others find it very interesting
This pack of hyenas is after Dr Naik, because he has challenged their monopoly. It clearly shows if such a pack is given power they will establish fascism and limit freedom of speech. Most of those pictured arr against Pakistan. Ghamdi sahib also appears to be a supporter of those who articulated mutahida quamiat and Akhand Bharat. Constantly praising Abul Kalam and attacking Iqbal
Samajh me nahi a raha kha hu pakistan channel per ya indian channel per
Mukalma nahin Zakir Nalayak to taqrir karta hai swal ka jabab nahin deta
Very thought provoking presentation on issue. Gems of Pakistan.