What I don't get is why an emulsionated oil in sump would cause issues with octane level. The injectors get the fuel from the tank, not from the sump... or pcv return would make so much emulsion injestion that would lower octane intake to the point of detonation?
Can this happen on cars that aren’t direct injection? I’ve been hearing a slow but fast hard rattling and I feel in on my steering wheel and pedal after I put test pipes on my g37
i had an auris 1.2t 2018 6mt. never lugged the engine always drove in the city with second and third gear arround 2200-2600rpm.. usually i was hitting full throttle arround 2600 rpm when i wanted to have some fun. car suddently started rattling very much arround 2000rpm eventually with 84000km i heard a bang.. engine wrecked. i am pretty sure that the dealership never used proper oils.. toyota said 0w20 and they always tried to put 5w30 i had to be on top each service to make sure that 0w20 was used. i never let my oils pass the 7500km mark.. always used to change them with a filter arround 6000 euro. had to sell the car for scrap pennies. i m so sad guys. Having broken trust to toyota i m thinking of purschasing another brand (maybe also japanese based) but i am atterly horrified and cannot withstand such huge economic disaster again. From what i ve read LSPI can be prevented or even reversed by doing the following - Always change oils before 7500km that are either GF6 spec or API SP (usually heavier oils) - Strictly never full throtlle under 2700rpm. Drop a gear if you want to use full throttle - Use liquid moli or similar injection cleaner stringly containing PEA because this is where the magic lies - Carbon is the reason this happens along with non LSPI mitigating oil and driver errors in low RPM @dsport Are the above correct guys? My question is how to clean a direct injection turbo engine without opening the engine. Thank you for your time guys and for letting this video out in the open. wish i ve seen it earlier so i can question and challenge malpractices in the dealership. I am so horrified of this issue with modern engines. This is horrible and dealerships are totally unaware or act like it. Never trusting toyota again in my life.
IMPORTANT NOTICE : For those who have a GASOLINE Opel turbocharged engine : Dexos 2 (based on ACEA C3) is NO LONGER ALLOWED because of LSPI risks. You MUST use Dexos 1 gen2 (no matter the brand, the important is that the oil respects the Dexos 1 gen2 requirements). Dexos 2 remains allowed ONLY FOR DIESEL engines.
...how do you ID Dexos 1 vs Dexos 2? Is it directly on the label, or do you have to go the oil manufacturer's site and find the oil type there, then go buy that oil? Oil bottle labels are 90% marketing to get you attention, so how do you ID the right oil?
@DSPORT Do you know why this only occurs at low piston speeds? Ive been researching LSPI for a while and can't find elaboration on this anywhere. If you know of any articles you could link or info you could provide it would be much appreciated!😁
What fuel additive would you suggest for a 2018 Alfa Romeo Guilia Ti Sport 2.0? I had an oil change at 10k and 17k miles. Found out after the fact they used Mobil 1 0W-30 Advanced Full Synthetic. Think I will use API SN PLUS and change every 5k miles from here on out. I expected SN PLUS to be used the first two times, but was fooled. I have always used premium fuel. I drive very aggressively. I get it up to 5,000 or 6,000 rpm every few red lights. Thanks!
Hi guys, my Ford Fiesta ST makes max torque at 2500k RPM. Is it bad to go WOT at that low of RPM? The power in that low range 2500-3k is so amazing, but am I ruining my motor?
Very interesting and informative. A couple questions though: Why does this happen most at low speed? Is it due to the slow airflow speed into the combustion chamber and long time between Sparks, giving the fuel more time to mix with the oil? Also, how is there enough oil above the piston rings for the oil to dilute fuel octane, and yet the oil typically isn't burning in non LSPI scenarios? Does a larger ring gap, and therefore a larger region of the cylinder wall that hasn't been scraped down to a film of oil, affect the likelihood of LSPI? Thanks again for the cool video.
Yes, & Yes. Also remember most cars have a crank case ventilation system that will reintroduce un-burnt crank case gasses back into the intake track and these gases almost always have an oily residue, along with the EGR and thats where your soot comes from although egr soot is less of an issue these days.
Yes I can confirm this as a owner of a 2013 Hyundai Accent 1.6 gamma gdi the engine only lasted 80,000 miles and that’s with me being aware of the issue 6 years ago When the car only had 10,000 miles on it I did everything I could to combat the problem including installing a oil catch can switching to premium fuel installing a cooler thermostat and cooler spark plugs.
When I tank LSPI no notciable LSPI occurs. (Was very noticable before). Does this mean I can safely drive at low rpms or should I still avoid it? Also, I have an NA indirect injection car. I thought LSPI was mostly a problem with DI and turbo vehicles
My car is port injected honda IDSI 2004 engine It still knocks at low rpms with AC on. In other words high torque at low rpms triggers LSPI. WHAT can i do
What I don't get is why an emulsionated oil in sump would cause issues with octane level. The injectors get the fuel from the tank, not from the sump... or pcv return would make so much emulsion injestion that woukd lower octane intake?
@@antunez726 I've been lucky with a faulty injector at 17k miles for my 18 hatch LT. I'm tuned from BNR, KN intake and use only shell premium, Amsoil Signature Series along with Amsoil fuel additives.
@@SkudaLaRoo Have you tried E85? I run it all summer long every summer since I got my engine replaced 2 years ago. I get no check engine light and the car runs amazing, no more hesitation and no lag even when I try to lug the engine.
ARE YOU LUNATIC? NOBODY PUTS MOLY IN OILS-- ITS EXPENSIVE,,,, so they sure use graffite instead and they call it moly oil. other oils that have normal brand have no moly inside. Unless you buy it in pure form as an aditive you gonna get nothing of real moly in your engine oil.
I would like to ask that guy how come Amsoil is the ONLY oil company that makes a 0W-30 that has all that API SN PLUS/Dexos Gen2 stuff. My Veloster N's oil cap and owner's manual calls for 0W-30. Even though I don't think it's completely necessary to run 0W-30 (like running 5W-30 would be fine), it just annoys me that there really isn't another 0W-30 out there in the market that has API SN PLUS certs.
Hey, check out the American Petroleum Institute's website's directory. You can see all of the oil companies and the oil grade they offer, and you can choose the Viscosity you're looking for. Here is the link engineoil.api.org/Directory/EolcsSearch
Can someone please define “low speed” is this happening at say 2,000 rpm or say 5,000 rpm? Low speed pre ignition sounds to me like it’s caused by lugging the engine, now let’s say your engine makes peak torque at 5,500 rpm and peak power at 7,500 rpm, is low speed pre ignition happening at say 5,000 rpm? Or are we talking about someone lugging an engine down at say 2,000 rpm?
ST1 Owner, here👋🏻 I have a question for those more educated in this LSPI subject than I... Would deceleration in-gear also be considered LSPI? I’m used to NA VQ motor where I could accelerate and decelerate whenever I wanted. Just trying to not blow my motor!
You will not typically incur LSPI while the engine is at a low level of load. Deceleration usually implies low load, so you're probably safe from LSPI while decelerating. Lean surges or something else might catch you, but probably no LSPI
Mobil1 5w-30 ESP has 1050 or less of calcium as all their non race oils. They may not be D1 G2 buy they would pass it if they tested it. It is also on the heavier side of the 5-30 scale @100C.
Leland Holton explain please, my OCD is literally killing me, I was thinking over what kind of damage it could do to my engine and I had enough of it that I forced myself to test my theory on my own car (2007 Golf GTI). I tried to floor it in six gear at 5 mph, rev was around 500 rpm, engine knocked like crazy, I did it couple of times, and during the crazy test engine either just stalled or sped up over 5 mph that it no longer knocks, I plugged the scan tool and spark advance was like -25 degrees. Car worked fine, didn’t feel any difference after the beating. I wonder if anyone had actually broke their engine by low rev engine knock right then and there, or it was actually caused by carbon buildup, and other factors that gradually contributed to the failure. I already made an appointment with a psychologist today, don’t want to keep doing this to my car.
@@davidgruen7423 I can't figure out if a problem in my car is LSPI. Cause no one explains what it feels like. If I floor it in 2nd gear at low rpm, at a certain point it lurches forward violently a few times (like interrupted power delivery) and then it stabilises. This has happened a few times but the car still runs fine. Can't find any information to confirm if this is LSPI or something else.
@@lamenamethefirst that ain’t it, it’s common on manual cars, all you have to do is to push in the clutch a little when that happens, and make sure maf sensor is clean.
Do I listen to a multi billion dollar car company that tells me to change my oil every 10k miles, or do I listen to a couple of youtube guys who say 3k miles. Hmmm
Let us know in the comments below if you have any questions or additional information. 👍
What I don't get is why an emulsionated oil in sump would cause issues with octane level. The injectors get the fuel from the tank, not from the sump... or pcv return would make so much emulsion injestion that would lower octane intake to the point of detonation?
Can this happen on cars that aren’t direct injection? I’ve been hearing a slow but fast hard rattling and I feel in on my steering wheel and pedal after I put test pipes on my g37
i had an auris 1.2t 2018 6mt. never lugged the engine always drove in the city with second and third gear arround 2200-2600rpm.. usually i was hitting full throttle arround 2600 rpm when i wanted to have some fun. car suddently started rattling very much arround 2000rpm eventually with 84000km i heard a bang.. engine wrecked. i am pretty sure that the dealership never used proper oils.. toyota said 0w20 and they always tried to put 5w30 i had to be on top each service to make sure that 0w20 was used.
i never let my oils pass the 7500km mark.. always used to change them with a filter arround 6000 euro. had to sell the car for scrap pennies. i m so sad guys. Having broken trust to toyota i m thinking of purschasing another brand (maybe also japanese based) but i am atterly horrified and cannot withstand such huge economic disaster again.
From what i ve read LSPI can be prevented or even reversed by doing the following
- Always change oils before 7500km that are either GF6 spec or API SP (usually heavier oils)
- Strictly never full throtlle under 2700rpm. Drop a gear if you want to use full throttle
- Use liquid moli or similar injection cleaner stringly containing PEA because this is where the magic lies
- Carbon is the reason this happens along with non LSPI mitigating oil and driver errors in low RPM
@dsport Are the above correct guys?
My question is how to clean a direct injection turbo engine without opening the engine.
Thank you for your time guys and for letting this video out in the open. wish i ve seen it earlier so i can question and challenge malpractices in the dealership.
I am so horrified of this issue with modern engines. This is horrible and dealerships are totally unaware or act like it. Never trusting toyota again in my life.
Lake Speed once again, so informative. Saving our engines! Thanks, Lake!
You have got to love Lake. He is amazing
Great video.Extremely informative, thank yo ufor so thoroughly explaining everything. I learned a lot from this.
Thank you, we're glad it was useful and beneficial to you 🙏
IMPORTANT NOTICE :
For those who have a GASOLINE Opel turbocharged engine : Dexos 2 (based on ACEA C3) is NO LONGER ALLOWED because of LSPI risks.
You MUST use Dexos 1 gen2 (no matter the brand, the important is that the oil respects the Dexos 1 gen2 requirements).
Dexos 2 remains allowed ONLY FOR DIESEL engines.
also some port injected engines are affected by this
...how do you ID Dexos 1 vs Dexos 2? Is it directly on the label, or do you have to go the oil manufacturer's site and find the oil type there, then go buy that oil? Oil bottle labels are 90% marketing to get you attention, so how do you ID the right oil?
@@K03sport
It's clearly written on the bottle
Yes, dexosc1 gen3 for only direct injected vehicles. Prior direct injection(2016) still can use dexos 2. According to opel dealer here.
@@aciddiver1978
Yes
Hello, what would be the maximum limit of calcium to be calm?
@DSPORT Do you know why this only occurs at low piston speeds? Ive been researching LSPI for a while and can't find elaboration on this anywhere. If you know of any articles you could link or info you could provide it would be much appreciated!😁
Awesome information about fuel to oil break down.
Thank you 🙏
What fuel additive would you suggest for a 2018 Alfa Romeo Guilia Ti Sport 2.0? I had an oil change at 10k and 17k miles. Found out after the fact they used Mobil 1 0W-30 Advanced Full Synthetic. Think I will use API SN PLUS and change every 5k miles from here on out. I expected SN PLUS to be used the first two times, but was fooled. I have always used premium fuel. I drive very aggressively. I get it up to 5,000 or 6,000 rpm every few red lights. Thanks!
Hi guys, my Ford Fiesta ST makes max torque at 2500k RPM. Is it bad to go WOT at that low of RPM? The power in that low range 2500-3k is so amazing, but am I ruining my motor?
Very interesting and informative. A couple questions though:
Why does this happen most at low speed? Is it due to the slow airflow speed into the combustion chamber and long time between Sparks, giving the fuel more time to mix with the oil?
Also, how is there enough oil above the piston rings for the oil to dilute fuel octane, and yet the oil typically isn't burning in non LSPI scenarios? Does a larger ring gap, and therefore a larger region of the cylinder wall that hasn't been scraped down to a film of oil, affect the likelihood of LSPI?
Thanks again for the cool video.
Yes, & Yes. Also remember most cars have a crank case ventilation system that will reintroduce un-burnt crank case gasses back into the intake track and these gases almost always have an oily residue, along with the EGR and thats where your soot comes from although egr soot is less of an issue these days.
is this still available? i have an RS5 and now doing some research before my first oil change.
Nice to see you guys are producing some longer videos keep up the good work ...there people out there with an attention span I promise ! 😄
😂 Thanks Benjamin. Glad you like it, we'll try to get more long videos going 👍
This is the 3rd time this video has popped up in my feed.
It's almost like UA-cam knows you had an LSPI problem once or twice haha
Does LSPI occur with DI naturally aspirated engines as well? And if so, is the issue less common than with a turbocharged engine?
Yes I can confirm this as a owner of a 2013 Hyundai Accent 1.6 gamma gdi the engine only lasted 80,000 miles and that’s with me being aware of the issue 6 years ago When the car only had 10,000 miles on it I did everything I could to combat the problem including installing a oil catch can switching to premium fuel installing a cooler thermostat and cooler spark plugs.
@@Ezekiel-OffRoad My 2013 accent had LSPI under load too. I could hear it pretty clearly. Kick it down a gear and it would be fine.
When I tank LSPI no notciable LSPI occurs. (Was very noticable before). Does this mean I can safely drive at low rpms or should I still avoid it?
Also, I have an NA indirect injection car. I thought LSPI was mostly a problem with DI and turbo vehicles
My car is port injected honda IDSI 2004 engine
It still knocks at low rpms with AC on. In other words high torque at low rpms triggers LSPI.
WHAT can i do
what speed is low speed?
Low engine speed/low revs
So which European spec oil do i need to use to prevent LSPI? It killed my engine too..
What I don't get is why an emulsionated oil in sump would cause issues with octane level. The injectors get the fuel from the tank, not from the sump... or pcv return would make so much emulsion injestion that woukd lower octane intake?
They say LSPI can occur when you lug the engine. Can LSPI occur in automatic transmission cars?
Absolutely. It's a condition that occurs in turbocharged direct-injection engines regardless of the gearbox.
My 2017 Cruze is automatic and got LSPI which cracked the pistons.
@@dsport This is why I didnt buy a turbo charged 2019 Kia forte. Cvt tranny, thank God no turbo.
@@antunez726 I've been lucky with a faulty injector at 17k miles for my 18 hatch LT. I'm tuned from BNR, KN intake and use only shell premium, Amsoil Signature Series along with Amsoil fuel additives.
@@SkudaLaRoo Have you tried E85? I run it all summer long every summer since I got my engine replaced 2 years ago. I get no check engine light and the car runs amazing, no more hesitation and no lag even when I try to lug the engine.
Any word on commercialization of a low calcium / high molybdenum 40W oil?
ARE YOU LUNATIC?
NOBODY PUTS MOLY IN OILS-- ITS EXPENSIVE,,,, so they sure use graffite instead and they call it moly oil.
other oils that have normal brand have no moly inside.
Unless you buy it in pure form as an aditive you gonna get nothing of real moly in your engine oil.
I thought LSPI was different from detonation. Why are they using the terms interchangably?
I would like to ask that guy how come Amsoil is the ONLY oil company that makes a 0W-30 that has all that API SN PLUS/Dexos Gen2 stuff. My Veloster N's oil cap and owner's manual calls for 0W-30. Even though I don't think it's completely necessary to run 0W-30 (like running 5W-30 would be fine), it just annoys me that there really isn't another 0W-30 out there in the market that has API SN PLUS certs.
Hey, check out the American Petroleum Institute's website's directory. You can see all of the oil companies and the oil grade they offer, and you can choose the Viscosity you're looking for. Here is the link engineoil.api.org/Directory/EolcsSearch
We did another video with Lake Speed where we addressed your question. 👍
Thank you.
ua-cam.com/video/TkqWtfyRA74/v-deo.html
Can someone please define “low speed” is this happening at say 2,000 rpm or say 5,000 rpm? Low speed pre ignition sounds to me like it’s caused by lugging the engine, now let’s say your engine makes peak torque at 5,500 rpm and peak power at 7,500 rpm, is low speed pre ignition happening at say 5,000 rpm? Or are we talking about someone lugging an engine down at say 2,000 rpm?
ST1 Owner, here👋🏻 I have a question for those more educated in this LSPI subject than I... Would deceleration in-gear also be considered LSPI? I’m used to NA VQ motor where I could accelerate and decelerate whenever I wanted. Just trying to not blow my motor!
You will not typically incur LSPI while the engine is at a low level of load. Deceleration usually implies low load, so you're probably safe from LSPI while decelerating. Lean surges or something else might catch you, but probably no LSPI
TGDI 1.4 TURBO for opel astra j is popping like pop corn here in Egypt,, i have one and I m worried sick.
There should be no oil on the cylinder wall on an Ecotec motor during compression. But maybe a 2 stroke that is mixed with oil.
Mobil1 5w-30 ESP has 1050 or less of calcium as all their non race oils. They may not be D1 G2 buy they would pass it if they tested it. It is also on the heavier side of the 5-30 scale @100C.
Yep, I’ve popped 2 ecoboost engines because of LSPI.
Ouch! Sorry Leland. Hopefully this video series helped in any way. Let us know if you have any questions.
Leland Holton explain please, my OCD is literally killing me, I was thinking over what kind of damage it could do to my engine and I had enough of it that I forced myself to test my theory on my own car (2007 Golf GTI). I tried to floor it in six gear at 5 mph, rev was around 500 rpm, engine knocked like crazy, I did it couple of times, and during the crazy test engine either just stalled or sped up over 5 mph that it no longer knocks, I plugged the scan tool and spark advance was like -25 degrees. Car worked fine, didn’t feel any difference after the beating. I wonder if anyone had actually broke their engine by low rev engine knock right then and there, or it was actually caused by carbon buildup, and other factors that gradually contributed to the failure. I already made an appointment with a psychologist today, don’t want to keep doing this to my car.
Which one? Theirs several
@@davidgruen7423 I can't figure out if a problem in my car is LSPI. Cause no one explains what it feels like. If I floor it in 2nd gear at low rpm, at a certain point it lurches forward violently a few times (like interrupted power delivery) and then it stabilises. This has happened a few times but the car still runs fine. Can't find any information to confirm if this is LSPI or something else.
@@lamenamethefirst that ain’t it, it’s common on manual cars, all you have to do is to push in the clutch a little when that happens, and make sure maf sensor is clean.
Dexos 1 Gen 2
We don't care, tell this to engine manufacturers to fix it. OK? WE paid for a working product not for warning videos after paying for the car. OK?
this why i love my big V8s, dont have to deal with this LSPI BS in turbocharged engines
True, you don't have to worry about that. 😃👍
And LSPI occurs more with gasoline direct injection engines, not any turbocharged engine
@@dsport Is LSPI present in engines that employ dual injection system, MPI + GDI?
Emulsify oil and gasoline, and Now add alcohol and boom!
Do I listen to a multi billion dollar car company that tells me to change my oil every 10k miles, or do I listen to a couple of youtube guys who say 3k miles. Hmmm