CJI Chandrachud & SG Mehta Weigh In On Wealth Redistribution During Constitutional Bench Hearing

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 кві 2024
  • There was an interesting conversation between CJI Chandrachud and the solicitor general during a constitution bench hearing on 30th April, in which the topic of wealth redistribution which has been at the centre of a political faceoff between PM Modi and Rahul Gandhi came up. SG Tushar Mehta said that it would be rustic and juvenile to suggest that the nation's wealth could be computed by totally the wealth of all citizens, and then re-distributing it - something that the 9 judge constitution bench headed by CJI Chandrachud seemed to agree with. This came up while the constitution bench was hearing the process of interpretation of article 39(b) of the constitution, which basically allows the government to acquire and redistribute privately owned properties if they are deemed material resources of the community. Watch!
    #rahulgandhi #justicechandrachud #supremecourt
    Want to make your money go further & work harder for you? Here are 20 Personal Finance Strategies from Mint. Check out our new coffee table book authored by Neil Borate & the Mint Money team. Download your digital copy here! shorturl.at/dDUV1
    Mint is an Indian financial daily newspaper published by HT Media. The Mint YT Channel brings you cutting edge analysis of the latest business news and financial news. With in-depth market coverage, explainers and expert opinions, we break down and simplify business news for you.
    Click here to download the Mint App
    livemint.onelink.me/MrDS/p0kx...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 584

  • @pubgaf3356
    @pubgaf3356 Місяць тому +996

    PAPPU needs to go back to Thailand again to recharge his last 2 brain cells

    • @soumyapramanik1891
      @soumyapramanik1891 Місяць тому +38

      Nehi Thailand mein Jake itne moj karenge ki last 2 brain cells fused ho jayega

    • @gopaakrishnanmvenkataraman9129
      @gopaakrishnanmvenkataraman9129 Місяць тому +24

      One needs brain to have cells in it

    • @harshildhaduk3766
      @harshildhaduk3766 Місяць тому +20

      Is pappu having brain.
      I doubt it😂😂😂.
      Shame on Congress.

    • @vasudevabhats1600
      @vasudevabhats1600 Місяць тому +13

      Pappu, and Brain ? 😂😂😂

    • @NeuzEmo
      @NeuzEmo Місяць тому +6

      My neighbour name is PAPPU😝😝😝😝😝

  • @varadharajanranganathan3761
    @varadharajanranganathan3761 Місяць тому +699

    RaGa has no idea of how difficult to earn a monthly salary. An unemployable bum. Obviously he comes up with such bizarre ideas.. and we waste our precious time, discussing this..

    • @ronwilson5075
      @ronwilson5075 Місяць тому

      Rahul Gandhin never said anything about wealth redistribution. Please do a 'fact-check'. ua-cam.com/video/psjUzs_TFh8/v-deo.html

    • @sakalasiva
      @sakalasiva Місяць тому +48

      If you don't discuss today, tomorrow Congress may come to the power and do exactly same then you will have all the time to discuss about impact of it in addition to poverty. So you want to discuss now and make country aware of its negatives or experience it and then talk about it.

    • @GururajBN
      @GururajBN Місяць тому +43

      We have to discuss because there are a few crores of pappus in India who have been regularly voting for congress.

    • @sr2.044
      @sr2.044 Місяць тому +13

      However, the bizarre idea is we should promote discussion as many people like RaGa don't have the common sense to think more broadly.

    • @yoganandmantravadi1993
      @yoganandmantravadi1993 Місяць тому

      See how many pappu sit at home without voting
      Their wealth should be taken away

  • @SantoshSinghal-rz7gb
    @SantoshSinghal-rz7gb Місяць тому +703

    Hindu earn and congress distribute hindus money to in muslim only

    • @mrshah2832
      @mrshah2832 Місяць тому +7

      Bro when did government distribute wealth we are paying tax on each and every thing.

    • @user-vf3sh2jh4z
      @user-vf3sh2jh4z Місяць тому

      Kya pagal panti hai😂😂😂Kuch Bhi ho Hindu -Muslim

    • @Sam-dd1he
      @Sam-dd1he Місяць тому +1

      ​@@mrshah2832first go and read about WAQF ACT.
      Land ownership to pehle hi ja chuki h jwellery hi bachi h bas😢

    • @atntaltd
      @atntaltd Місяць тому +117

      @@mrshah2832 government giving salary to MAULANA , taxing mandir bur mosque is tax free ?
      inequality right there , lets redistribute WAQF property built schools , toilets and hospitals

    • @atntaltd
      @atntaltd Місяць тому +48

      @@mrshah2832
      9cr toilets ? who is using it ? dalit, muslims are the prime beneficiary , this is were your taxed money is going

  • @bose6483
    @bose6483 Місяць тому +441

    First khangress should return the money they have looted for 65 years from our nation .

  • @harshildhaduk3766
    @harshildhaduk3766 Місяць тому +158

    CJI is clearly saying respect privatisation.
    Government have no trees of money.
    Major portion of economic development is private investment.
    But shame on Congress.
    They will always criticise adani, Ambani.

    • @jdsriharsha295
      @jdsriharsha295 25 днів тому

      Kuch kehna hai av?

    • @moonku_1312
      @moonku_1312 24 дні тому

      Bhai ab Modi also criticizing what about that 😂

  • @leelajaala6448
    @leelajaala6448 Місяць тому +124

    Why the SC is wasting the national time on the stupid ideas floated by the headless chicken, I don't understand.

    • @pankajsamanta1602
      @pankajsamanta1602 29 днів тому +16

      It's important bro SC have to take the case and dismissed it otherwise if some day congress comes to power they will apply this rule

    • @thatspp4503
      @thatspp4503 27 днів тому +4

      SC is validating what the majority of hard-working and tax-paying citizens think. Its important for the CJI to clear the air since the idea itself was gross.

    • @georgecarlinn6288
      @georgecarlinn6288 16 днів тому +1

      It is not stupid idea it is an cunning idea which is waqf act

  • @gagswag
    @gagswag Місяць тому +311

    Wealth distribution sounds like a screwed up concept...it is not fair to take others hard earned money and distribute to someone else. Enough opportunities and discounts are being given to SC, ST, OBCs to improve themselves..

    • @sakalasiva
      @sakalasiva Місяць тому +65

      Sorry this money is not to distribute among sc,st,obc rather collect from all Hindus and give it to Muslims. Remember Manmohan Singh golden words Muslims have first right on resources of India.

    • @gagswag
      @gagswag Місяць тому +28

      @@sakalasiva yes..that is also true..maximum favors are given to that community and yet they act like victims..

    • @sr2.044
      @sr2.044 Місяць тому +24

      @@gagswag They always act like victims in a democracy until they are significant in number after that they will do everything to make you a victim and lastly they will demand shiria law. If you think otherwise look up to Bangladesh.

    • @pipipupu5104
      @pipipupu5104 Місяць тому +3

      ​​@@sr2.044 what's happened in Bangladesh

    • @Sangama333
      @Sangama333 Місяць тому

      They won't be taking from anybody
      But They will make portions from the budget and then distribute I guess
      More like freebies from government a/c

  • @jhkblr2600
    @jhkblr2600 Місяць тому +132

    Wealth Distribution was done in 1947 by Nehru through Zamindari Act. When CPIM came to power in West Bengal for the first time, they introduced the same and we have seen the downfall of Bengal since then.
    INC is now filled by jobless jerks of DU, JNU, SFI and they come up with ideas like providing reservations at secretary level jobs, reservations in private sector. Commie mindset needs strong strikedown

    • @catfish9391
      @catfish9391 Місяць тому +13

      Exactly I was going to support Congress. But now not anymore.

    • @user-wb8ql4ky7j
      @user-wb8ql4ky7j 29 днів тому

      Your last para😂,,, is the real BIG truth,,which some people don't understand​@@catfish9391

    • @abhaypatel4292
      @abhaypatel4292 27 днів тому +2

      Zamindari act was actually necessary very necessary and a really great way

    • @jhkblr2600
      @jhkblr2600 27 днів тому +3

      @@abhaypatel4292 and its bad economics. Small farmers did not and could not take benefit out of land holdings as they were very small. Units Economics could not work out and they remained poor and more marginalised.

    • @noobgamer-xl3jk
      @noobgamer-xl3jk 25 днів тому +2

      ​@@abhaypatel4292 It was actually necessary at that time but doing it now will scatter our economy.

  • @sierra_117rj
    @sierra_117rj 27 днів тому +18

    Disband WAQF board, and redistribute its property to people needed cuz the property under WAQF is of government plus some private.

  • @shivanepal1433
    @shivanepal1433 Місяць тому +38

    Zimbabwe distributed land and is facing the agricultural problems

  • @prasvasu4217
    @prasvasu4217 Місяць тому +77

    Thank you Justice Sir for shutting down this conversation. It is the 21st century; and politicians (leeches of the economy) can divide the vote bank by such junk ideas is honestly discouraging to see; especially in a growing democracy.

  • @WBSchoolOfMaths
    @WBSchoolOfMaths Місяць тому +106

    Man work hard to earn money and pappu want to snatch it and give it to the father of 10 children.

    • @ismartshankar215
      @ismartshankar215 28 днів тому +15

      That is why he is pappu idk why he is forcing peoples to vote for bjp 😂

    • @amankumar-ob6sh
      @amankumar-ob6sh 24 дні тому +3

      ​@@ismartshankar215bhai bjp hi thick hai kam se kam aise pagalo se toh acha

  • @harshildhaduk3766
    @harshildhaduk3766 Місяць тому +79

    USA economy Will collapse if Google,Meta, apple,tesla,etc will be out from USA or not encourage.
    Like that if private companies like TATA, Adani, Mahindra, Ambani,etc should also be encouraged.
    Because without all this indian economy will collapse.

    • @Ajor777
      @Ajor777 28 днів тому

      Why they wil be out, they are owned by Amecians.

    • @SahilSingh-nx5yx
      @SahilSingh-nx5yx 26 днів тому +10

      Exactly and some stupid people are busy in hating them for absolute no reason

    • @fact_tronix6993
      @fact_tronix6993 25 днів тому

      Bro but chronic capatalism nhi hona chahiye na dusra yeh chutiye congress vale jo Halla gulla macha rahe yeh toh modi ji se bhi jyada Ambanis ko uthane mai Lage Thai dhirubhai Ambani

    • @TheBatman565
      @TheBatman565 19 днів тому +1

      See economic inequality in USA and India
      In india its too much compared to USA

    • @fact_tronix6993
      @fact_tronix6993 19 днів тому +3

      @@TheBatman565 because India don't have that much companies compare to usa and china that why inequality is to much and for that level of companies India have to continuously built companies with fdi for over 40 years like america and china do

  • @NeuzEmo
    @NeuzEmo Місяць тому +167

    Never ever going to vote for congress

    • @Terabaap123.
      @Terabaap123. 28 днів тому

      Capitalist theives.......

    • @antareshmondal7157
      @antareshmondal7157 24 дні тому +1

      Why?
      Will you please explain sir?
      Jai shree Ram,Jai Hanuman, Jai Mahadev,Jai shree krishna.........,.........

    • @amankumar-ob6sh
      @amankumar-ob6sh 24 дні тому +5

      ​@@antareshmondal7157congress ko iss bar vote dene ka socha tha par jab se usne ye wealth vali bat boli ab toh jivan mai na du khangress ko vote

    • @SUBWAYWALAGAMER-rt5kp
      @SUBWAYWALAGAMER-rt5kp 23 дні тому +1

      ​@@antareshmondal7157bjp is better

    • @antareshmondal7157
      @antareshmondal7157 23 дні тому +1

      @@SUBWAYWALAGAMER-rt5kp chauvinism is not good for anyone.

  • @narayancrakshit2368
    @narayancrakshit2368 Місяць тому +31

    Fantastic assessment by respected cji.❤❤
    Rustic & juvenile R behold .......😊

  • @yourstrulytk12worldaffairs
    @yourstrulytk12worldaffairs Місяць тому +190

    It's equal distribution of poverty not wealth

    • @ChandranPrema123
      @ChandranPrema123 Місяць тому

      This is literally looting General Caste people and giving to illegal Immigrants from Bangladesh

    • @amit6468
      @amit6468 Місяць тому +30

      I will not take your share of poverty. Why should I? I earn my money with hardwork, no freebies for loosers.

    • @sh-chhotoo
      @sh-chhotoo Місяць тому +5

      First Rahul Gandhi give Congress party to non family person

    • @yourstrulytk12worldaffairs
      @yourstrulytk12worldaffairs Місяць тому

      @@sh-chhotoo
      Are wo naamdaar hain... Unpe.prashna mat karo... Humari aukat nahi hai naamdar ko question karne ki...

    • @yugeshncr3499
      @yugeshncr3499 29 днів тому +4

      Why should I engage with you?.....go and work hard man

  • @vasumanu
    @vasumanu Місяць тому +50

    It would be utter stupidity to suggest that wealth should be grabbed from one person and given to other...it is stealing the labour of one and giving to another may be lazy person..utter chaotic , demotivating and devasting step is suggested..this is what maoist and naxalbaries are also suggesting

    • @SM-sb9fg
      @SM-sb9fg 27 днів тому +1

      Exactly

    • @pratapkurup1113
      @pratapkurup1113 27 днів тому

      That seems the idea behind the move, to distribute the wealth between a certain minority and tukde tukde groups

    • @gauravg9810
      @gauravg9810 27 днів тому

      It is a planning to destroy Indian economy, congress is already taken over by China loving communists.

  • @TheDURWAS
    @TheDURWAS Місяць тому +23

    Abe paap, My parents stayed a slum in Mumbai... They worked for the past 30 years and saved a ton of money, paid loans hence they have wealth. Stop mocking people's hardwork.

  • @kamalsh6123
    @kamalsh6123 28 днів тому +12

    RaGa should put his theory into practice by first acquiring the wealth of the WAQF board and distributing it among the poor Indians of all faiths. Has he got the guts to do it?

  • @ChandraPradip
    @ChandraPradip 27 днів тому +9

    If this happens, mark my words, everyone who is earning well will leave India ASAP.

    • @SnehaSingh-qw2id
      @SnehaSingh-qw2id 23 дні тому

      Everyone can't leave no. That's what is the challenge.

  • @subhasiskumar6906
    @subhasiskumar6906 Місяць тому +30

    Did Congress won the election? Govt formed? Why the hell is this being discussed on supreme court 😆

    • @eklavyajain09
      @eklavyajain09 28 днів тому +7

      They're just discussing about interpretation of Article 39 and this was pointed out by SG as an example.

    • @vishalrao4073
      @vishalrao4073 28 днів тому +9

      ​@@eklavyajain09if someone is doing MBA and he gets any MNC job worth 12LPA or 25LPA, then if they will snatch all money from him and distribute it in few people who just did 10th or even who would be just 4th-5th class pass without any knowledge or experience....then why someone would do MBA or higher salary jobs and businesses.

    • @eklavyajain09
      @eklavyajain09 28 днів тому +2

      @@vishalrao4073 exactly my point too

    • @gauravg9810
      @gauravg9810 27 днів тому +3

      This gives us social security that concerned matters are time to time discussed in Supreme Court. Discussion is an important aspect of Democracy.

    • @BoomBoom-sc7ek
      @BoomBoom-sc7ek 25 днів тому

      ​@@vishalrao4073reason for good scholars going foreign
      This politicians is not even get matured to take what action should be they doing politics

  • @conscons5776
    @conscons5776 Місяць тому +32

    who would like to GENERATE WEALTH if this is to be implimented... its a failed policy of many nations.. and many will invest abroad than in india

  • @GururajBN
    @GururajBN Місяць тому +12

    Income and Wealth survey and its redistribution is juvenile economics. What else can one expect from the wise men of congress led by Rahul Gandhi? The idea seems to be “If we can’t lift the poor, let’s pull down the rich.”

  • @hrudairoshan
    @hrudairoshan Місяць тому +53

    You can never have equality of outcomes, so the govt should strive for equality of oppurtunity. So concentrate on public health, transportation, education, access to clean water and toilets

    • @subhrajitgupta5535
      @subhrajitgupta5535 Місяць тому +2

      Jaya Pakash narayan?

    • @atntaltd
      @atntaltd Місяць тому +1

      @@subhrajitgupta5535 old days are gone

    • @atntaltd
      @atntaltd Місяць тому +1

      @@subhrajitgupta5535 if you talk JP look at bihar
      where it is right now ?

    • @chaitanyavelamala7268
      @chaitanyavelamala7268 28 днів тому +1

      This sounds like something JP would say
      I meant Jordan Peterson

    • @atntaltd
      @atntaltd 28 днів тому +1

      @@chaitanyavelamala7268 yeah lots of western shit is gona come our way , we need desi JPs , like J sai deepak

  • @kantvx
    @kantvx 28 днів тому +6

    CJI speaks of “We” and “Policy” in the same sentence and there goes separation of powers in our republic.

  • @IM_NO_BODY_
    @IM_NO_BODY_ Місяць тому +15

    Why court giving their precious time to discuss about even when things not executed till now and also remake of RAGA in broader interpretation,
    And why court have enough time to discuss about even so many important case still pending please be focused on these cases

    • @arvinbhat8921
      @arvinbhat8921 Місяць тому +5

      So were you against SC discussing on NRC when it was not executed.

    • @castiel1115
      @castiel1115 Місяць тому +1

      What broader interpretation? It is explicitly said who will lose wealth and who it will go to, in their speeches. Also the opposition moves to court if Modi didn't shower for one day. Is this a one-sided judiciary?

  • @madhavant9516
    @madhavant9516 16 днів тому +2

    Let congress party and its leaders distribute all their wealth to whomsoever they want. That will be a good start.

  • @Kaafiristani
    @Kaafiristani 29 днів тому +11

    Brilliant just brilliant. Justice Chandrachud won a new fan in me.
    The Russia Dictated policies, like nationalization, 5 year plans, high taxation on entrepreneurship kept us in Ration Ki line, only after we adopted the US's free market economy model in 1991 did we prosper.

  • @anantsaini
    @anantsaini 29 днів тому +21

    Long Live Free Market Capitalism! Socialism Haye Haye!

  • @ashokp1027
    @ashokp1027 28 днів тому +7

    Give ur weath to whoever u want don't think about others , we pay tax our whole life .after death whatever left is for our family not for some unknown fellowa.they have produced 10 kids and it's their responsibility to take care of them not us

  • @sachbol3912
    @sachbol3912 Місяць тому +7

    REFORM JUDICIARY SO THAT BUDDIES WHO HANGOUT DONT CORNER AND HIJACK THE SYSTEM. THE SAMEVUNCH OF LAWYERS ACTIVIST AND JUDGES HAVE BEEN GRINDING THE SAME SET OF ISSUES THAT DONT SERVE NATIONS INTEREST BUT SERVE VESTED INTERESTS.
    A COMMON MAN SUFFERS DEPENDING ON DILAPIDATED JUSTICE SYSTEM AND LAWS. NO ONE FEARS LAW NOR RULE OF LAW

  • @ShashankSingh-hb8uf
    @ShashankSingh-hb8uf 27 днів тому +4

    4th june ko public karega vote distribution....😂😂😂😂 pata chl jayega

  • @dr_sriraviteja
    @dr_sriraviteja 27 днів тому +2

    Forget entire Nation, this kind of logic wouldn’t even be applied to a Family!
    The fact that this thought is even being discussed in 2024 is scary. Where r we going as a country n society?

  • @senthilkunnur
    @senthilkunnur 27 днів тому +3

    Congress should their policy in Karnataka first

  • @funtimefunny2153
    @funtimefunny2153 29 днів тому +4

    Even this super woke cji is bemused

  • @Madhugargeya
    @Madhugargeya 28 днів тому +3

    In such case i will eat all my wealth before i die. Also i will ensure i will not spend money in this country

  • @abhijitksinha8296
    @abhijitksinha8296 Місяць тому +3

    Extreme left, generally left and generally right, extreme right is the process.
    Now we are generally right.

  • @kalyanchatterjee1617
    @kalyanchatterjee1617 Місяць тому +1

    Guru, Mr Ram Churis and Disciple Rahul Bangles to note this observation.

  • @mandarp9472
    @mandarp9472 19 днів тому +1

    Individual wealth or assets are not for public consumption.
    Government already taxes everything using GST, Capital Gains Tax, Securities Transaction Tax, Customs duty, Service Tax.

  • @jrelax8236
    @jrelax8236 27 днів тому +3

    Kamaye koi aur khaye koi...where is the incentive then...socialism is a regressive philosophy...aaj ka Bharat needs capitalism with a degree of socialism...to move ahead...Nehru regime experimented a lot with socialism and enough of that pls...

  • @fawa.z
    @fawa.z 28 днів тому +2

    Wealth distribution will be immoral. Creating systems of spending on social causes will be more beneficial. Better schools, hospitals, good infrastructure. These are also wealth.

  • @eklavyajain09
    @eklavyajain09 28 днів тому +3

    Yaha ek mahine ki salary kamane me halat kharab ho jati hai aur wo v baant di jayegi ab?

  • @DEVENDRASAGARMAHTO
    @DEVENDRASAGARMAHTO 15 днів тому

    It is very easy to say distribution of wealth among people equally which is a difficult task.

  • @Sanatansister5623
    @Sanatansister5623 Місяць тому +12

    They will give the right to the wakf board to claim and occupy any property without allowing the owner to go to the court and file a case. But whenit comes to distributing resources they will not touch those 7 lakh crore of wakf lands

    • @krishnabhagath2405
      @krishnabhagath2405 Місяць тому +4

      Waqf board was allowed and made legal by khangress leaders so u don't u ask this question to khangress and the supreme court judge who made this as legal

    • @Sanatansister5623
      @Sanatansister5623 Місяць тому +3

      @@krishnabhagath2405 This is a question mark for Hindus, who never protest against such atrocities against their community, that's why Khangress was able to rule the Country for 60 years

    • @soumengorai8346
      @soumengorai8346 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@Sanatansister5623i know secular hindus have fault but Supreme Court can also remove it because people don't interested in any type of politics 😁

    • @Sanatansister5623
      @Sanatansister5623 Місяць тому

      @@soumengorai8346 Supreme court cannot remove any law, ite should be done through the Parliament. Supreme court will only follow the law from the Constitution and unfortunately the Constitution of this Country is Anti Hindu

    • @Sanatansister5623
      @Sanatansister5623 Місяць тому

      @@soumengorai8346 Supreme court cannot remove any law, ite should be done through the Parliament. Supreme court will only follow the law from the Constitution and unfortunately the Constitution of this Country is Anti Hindu

  • @santoshbannur
    @santoshbannur 23 дні тому +1

    What's the role of Judiciary in this. Why is Judiciary getting into politics..?

  • @cnxindustries3276
    @cnxindustries3276 12 днів тому

    Surplus law needed once again in every way

  • @Indobachi
    @Indobachi 28 днів тому +3

    Reservation is one part of this idea
    Becoz of that some people have birth privileges to own a luxury without earning it....

    • @atultejaswi22
      @atultejaswi22 26 днів тому

      After becoming rich , have guts to leave reservation

  • @Sagar_Retwal
    @Sagar_Retwal 29 днів тому +4

    I am brahmin from the poorer sides. My family does not own any lands. If I get fraction of wealth from adani who is a jain (minority) or Yadav's (OBC) Owaisi and Pataudi (Muslim minority). I don't mind voting for congress infact I will be the first to vote. who would want to work hard when you generational wealth and power like my dear idol Raga.

    • @ismartshankar215
      @ismartshankar215 28 днів тому +2

      Conceptually you are wrong because there is more jobless peace full people with 10 to 20 member in a single family ,so if this fking redistribute happens you didn't get a single penny infact your hardwork money goes to the uneducated jobless peacefull peoples
      Have some morals if you have guts then go outside do hardwork earn money income should be directly proportional to your hardwork only

    • @vidyamadamanchi7091
      @vidyamadamanchi7091 28 днів тому +1

      But they worked hard to get their wealth. You can do the same

    • @arohik1901
      @arohik1901 28 днів тому +2

      According to you success belongs to everyone, everyone have right on its wealth, but failure belongs to individual. If a person default on their loan , no one will try to help him or her. But that person becomes successful, everyone start hating and want share in it.

    • @adarsh_mishra451
      @adarsh_mishra451 26 днів тому

      ​@@arohik1901sister ,,, understand sarcasm 🫂

    • @adarsh_mishra451
      @adarsh_mishra451 26 днів тому

      ​@@vidyamadamanchi7091
      Our constitution can allow caste politics,,,reservations ,,, subsidies and schemes to a special group ??? Just because they are marginalised ,,,,,so this is also possible if congress wins 💪🏻🔱

  • @RK-es8oj
    @RK-es8oj 15 днів тому

    Yes, start from supreme court lawyers, they were drawing 25 lakhs per hour.. as fee...
    then people of India will appreciate.....

  • @Wiggie_Wiggie
    @Wiggie_Wiggie 24 дні тому +1

    It's a common sense. If you take all the wealth from Ambani, then how will he pay salaries to millions of Indians working in refineries, telecom, reliance marts , trends etc.
    How will they maintain profit and how will they expand?
    This is the most disastrous idea a government can think of. In odisha the govt has started giving rice to poor people at rs 1. This has made them so lazy that they don't want to do work. They have no will to get rich , they know that they have enough money to feed their generations because they have thousands of rs 1. 😑 This is the reality.

  • @nickhartnet4192
    @nickhartnet4192 28 днів тому +2

    Why are we tax payers having to pay for this nonsense, let Rahul pay for the court's time

  • @gopaakrishnanmvenkataraman9129
    @gopaakrishnanmvenkataraman9129 Місяць тому +8

    To create incentive for be idle or lazy is not the job of govt .
    Welath is respect earned not a gift of govt nor anyone
    Pride of nation and being prowd to contribute to nation development is one and the same

  • @t1621
    @t1621 21 день тому +2

    *Every Khangressi wants wealth distribution. They want everyone's wealth to be distributed except their own.* 😂😂😂

  • @krishnanvc5767
    @krishnanvc5767 Місяць тому +2

    Why are we becoming so stupid. Discussing and wasting time on a stupid idea taking Bharat back to the dark ages. WE DO NOT NEED A POL POT REGIME.The SC should THROW OUT THIS CASE.

  • @13rohitv
    @13rohitv 25 днів тому

    Wealth distribution from government employees & politician, that includes judicial department also will be perfect

  • @SM-sb9fg
    @SM-sb9fg 27 днів тому +1

    Taxes are being paid for the same purpose. Higher income higher tax..simple logic 🤔 how come big people are missing this?

  • @kamakshiyadav5980
    @kamakshiyadav5980 28 днів тому +3

    Already temples r taxed
    Middle class. Taxed
    Ab toh inheritance bhi taxed
    Pappu agar galti se bhi aaya toh tata bye bye

  • @saamywaad
    @saamywaad 12 днів тому +1

    Here people are talking about st, SC & obc and not even considering the ews reservation. 😅😅😅
    As a court you do not have right to decide political economy of Bharat. Are you an economist?

  • @meenusharma2288
    @meenusharma2288 25 днів тому

    This video should be viral

  • @hansvonmeinstien3660
    @hansvonmeinstien3660 23 дні тому +1

    Robert vadra worth around 2.1 billion and inheritance tax should be put on gandhi family first .

  • @Mhmdwazpedo21
    @Mhmdwazpedo21 23 дні тому +1

    Ambedkar ji wanted complete exchange of population after partition. He even compared muslims to german dictator.
    Ever wonder why?

  • @s.t.chandrasekharbabu132
    @s.t.chandrasekharbabu132 Місяць тому

    Equitable wealth is different from equal wealth.

  • @vidyamadamanchi7091
    @vidyamadamanchi7091 28 днів тому +1

    But the efforts are different right ? Somebody has put lots of effort, blood and sweat into wealth creation and somebody just sat and got wealth. So something very stupid is being discussed

  • @harshildhaduk3766
    @harshildhaduk3766 Місяць тому +3

    CJI best answer that interpretation of article in constitution evolved as per nature and time we are living.
    Some laws and interpretation of 1950 will not work as per 21st century.
    So modiji want to change some laws in constitution.
    So vote as per statement.
    "survival of the fittest "

  • @judewarner1536
    @judewarner1536 12 днів тому

    The problem is not so much Wealth distribution as it is Income distribution. There are HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS whose incomes are so low that they can neither actively engage with the country's national economy nor contribute to it. This actually inhibits the growth of businesses and thus reduces the potential GDP and the country's wealth to the DETRIMENT OF ALL.

  • @harip394
    @harip394 18 днів тому

    We are trying to follow failed idea, we have enough time to debate but supreme court do not have time to dispose pending cases.

  • @hrishikeshsarkar6513
    @hrishikeshsarkar6513 17 днів тому

    No businessman, no startup company will work hard when the Government distribute their money randomly. Even common people will be lazy. Instead of this, government should make policy on salary and tax slab for low and middle class people.

  • @lokendrapushpad4436
    @lokendrapushpad4436 4 дні тому

    Articles 39(b) and (c) do emphasize the redistribution of wealth and prevention of wealth concentration, but they do so within the framework of a democratic and mixed economy, aiming to balance individual rights with social justice. This is not equivalent to advocating for communism, but rather for a welfare-oriented economic policy where the state ensures that economic inequalities are minimized and resources are used for the common good.

  • @Chomusuke71
    @Chomusuke71 27 днів тому +1

    This is a bit unclear, the court is discussing on the interpretation of the article 39(b) and not on anything mentioned by the congress. It was about the fact that India is moving forward towards more of a free market than a socialistic approach and thus the article should be interpreted in similar light. The discussion wasn't political but the video tries to make it sound political and that the court is condemning a socialistic policy by mentioning congress' survey

  • @callmeYK
    @callmeYK 27 днів тому

    Why the lawyer in background has something unusual

  • @RafaelSoriaGarcia-gs8ud
    @RafaelSoriaGarcia-gs8ud Місяць тому

    रखना एक बुद्धिमान निर्णय लगता है।

  • @girishpai4538
    @girishpai4538 27 днів тому +1

    Does Raga know how hard it is to make wealth to Redistribute it why doesnt he redistribute his wealth of 10000 crore

  • @akapandeo
    @akapandeo 29 днів тому

    Nobody is asking for a rustic way of looking at the economy , common

  • @PinakiGupta82Appu
    @PinakiGupta82Appu 24 дні тому +1

    Wealth redistribution is a complex and potentially challenging policy to implement. It is a bit extreme, a recipe for disaster. There have been historical examples, such as in the Soviet Union under Stalin, where the state sought to abolish private property and seize the means of production through communist policies. In a communist system, the state owned everything, and individuals were expected to align themselves with the state's ideology, with no room for other political or religious beliefs. There was no discrimination as long as one aligned with the state's communist views.
    While this approach may have worked for a time, it raises concerns about individual freedoms and the potential for the state to essentially "enslave" its people, reducing them to mere cogs in the state's machinery. The motivations for personal development and progress could also be stifled in such a system.
    Once I had a conversation with a Bangladeshi person in 2019. That person asked me why India cannot get out of the labyrinth of sect politics while Bangladesh can do away with reservations. I explained to that person what is possible in Bangladesh due to its demographic composition is not currently feasible in India, at least at the moment.
    However, one thing must be kept in mind implanting a policy in a socialist democracy and partially capitalist country by grabbing it from a communist regime of a particular era in history will not be effective. In a more democratic and mixed-economy context, like that of India, the implementation of redistributive policies would be vastly different. Reservations, for example, are not inherently problematic in our situation, but they should be carefully designed and implemented based on objective criteria, such as financial instability, regional backwardness, and physical disabilities, rather than on discriminatory grounds.
    The benefits provided through reservations should be reviewed periodically to ensure they are still necessary and proportionate. The status of individuals benefiting from reservations should be periodically reviewed. Discriminatory reservations can create grievances and make certain groups feel marginalised, which goes against the principle of treating all people with equal dignity and respect, regardless of their background. People should be treated with dignity for everyone has equal potential, nobody is small.
    In summary, while reservations and related policies can be considered, their implementation must be carefully evaluated and tailored to the specific socio-political and economic context of a country. Blindly adopting approaches from communist regimes of the past, that too, after distorting the intent, may not be effective or desirable in a democratic, mixed-economy setting.

  • @hrishikeshsarkar6513
    @hrishikeshsarkar6513 17 днів тому

    CJI is absolutely right.

  • @nareshshingote8081
    @nareshshingote8081 27 днів тому

    But we don't need courts to talk on economic issues, rather they should focus on solving cases

  • @bharatbhandari8825
    @bharatbhandari8825 27 днів тому +1

    How see idea is good but this kind of especially Rahul idea is more brutal and dangerous whelth will be distributed but not from india but from the other countries earning from export by products is the only possible solution

  • @kamakshiyadav5980
    @kamakshiyadav5980 28 днів тому +1

    Congress needs to srsly get their priorities right

  • @rohitg4569
    @rohitg4569 23 дні тому +2

    We need to understand who the real pappy is Modi or Rahul?
    Rahul who just kept his plan that they're going to redistribute wealth there is no correct explanation for this we don't know even if he fulfill this or not it's just a promise that every politician kept
    Now Modi who banned 500 and 1000 notes in a night without having proper parliamentary discussion on this,who locked down the whole country instantly : Result: People going 1000km/hr to their villages without trains, vehicles
    Now decide who the real pappu is 🤡

  • @rajendrajasathy4356
    @rajendrajasathy4356 24 дні тому +1

    We still have time, make sure to Vote for BJP else Congress will loot our pockets and will make this a muslim nation....

  • @AnalystRK
    @AnalystRK 22 дні тому

    Congress should make example by donating its entire wealth to poor people. They should make condition that anyone who wish to join Congress or wish to stay in party should do by donating their entire wealth like Jain saints.

  • @narayanjoshi9346
    @narayanjoshi9346 26 днів тому

    CJI IS FORGETTING COMPLETELY ONE THING THAT GOVT INVESTMENTS AREN'T COST EFFECTIVE AND TIME BOUND IN PROJECTS. IN DEFENSE PRODUCTION L& T AND GODREJ ARE SUCCESSFUL IN EARLY DELIVERY OF ORDERS.

  • @nagraj2k1
    @nagraj2k1 14 днів тому +1

    What is the need for background music in this video? The tiktokisation of media continues…

  • @chinmaykapasia4806
    @chinmaykapasia4806 Місяць тому

    Tehata court nadia case no - ST -167-1 0/OKGI

  • @existential_bengali
    @existential_bengali 12 днів тому

    Progessive welath tax must be these, and the money must be reinvested in government free healthcare and education.... Supreme Court has no authority over public economic policy, supreme court judges must have public accountability.

  • @chinmaykapasia4806
    @chinmaykapasia4806 Місяць тому

    case no-

  • @AashraiRavooru
    @AashraiRavooru Місяць тому +1

    All good and correct but why is such a philosophical case even being heard, do we have no other pressing cases. Sounds more like a podcast than a courtroom.

  • @RaviKiran-lx2kw
    @RaviKiran-lx2kw 27 днів тому +1

    Pappus has20 crore immovable asset.. Let's acquire it first

  • @smitaghia443
    @smitaghia443 13 днів тому

    We are living in free India..dont dump laws on tax payers.

  • @ashishpandey8537
    @ashishpandey8537 26 днів тому +1

    Cji also knows that growth can only be done via privatisation pr yeh saale bolte hai desh bech diya 😂😂😂

  • @yourstrulytk12worldaffairs
    @yourstrulytk12worldaffairs Місяць тому +2

    Show me the convo cut your noise

  • @user-sh6cm7be1z
    @user-sh6cm7be1z 20 днів тому

    SC judges think they are above the government elected by the people. It is not their problem. If Congress forms government (0.1% chance), CJI will not be able to do anything if Rahul Gandhi decides to redistribute wealth. Remember Shah Bano case?
    Interestingly, most people are missing the main point: redistribution of wealth is already happening. Taxation is redistribution of wealth. It is a different matter that what Rahul Gandhi wants even Rahul Gandhi does not know. May be Sam Pitroda knows, but he will not speak to media anymore I think!

  • @avd2111
    @avd2111 29 днів тому +1

    Even Pakistan agrees with Raga on wealth distribution

  • @kartik5001
    @kartik5001 26 днів тому

    The CJI is a smart man

  • @RaviIndranSR
    @RaviIndranSR Місяць тому +1

    Even if the wealth is distributed the fool and his wealth will soon be seperated.

  • @abhijeethatti9095
    @abhijeethatti9095 21 день тому

    Before this Let Pappu and His Party Leaders Declare Their Assets and How Much Part Is Going Redistribute It and Also Same With CJI

  • @rkrishnamoorthy1785
    @rkrishnamoorthy1785 28 днів тому +1

    My view is Congress party should declare itself a communist party and if people vote for it Communism will be the policy.Why beat about the bush.Taking wealth in excess ( what is the bench mark has to be defined and how it should be computed)from the person and give it to a poor man and how this poor man should be defined for eligible to receive that wealth and in what way. A pathway to Erewhon.( No where)

  • @sayanmal2883
    @sayanmal2883 25 днів тому

    Former general secretary of Trinamool Congress party Kunal Ghosh has recently said in a TV interview aired on ABP Ananda that TMC party leaders knew that former education minister Partha Chatterjee was collecting money for school teacher jobs.He also Said that another person apart from Partha Chatterjee was collecting money for school teacher jobs and he is still a minister in West Bengal govt.The honorable supreme court should give order to take Kunal Ghosh into custody and ask him to reveal the names of the TMC party leaders involved in this institutionalized corruption. Meritorious candidates of West Bengal who are suffering,will loose faith in the supreme court if the persons involved in this scam go unpunished.Mamata Banerjee and her nephew Abhishek Banerjee are trying to project the interim stay order as their victory. People who got the jobs by submitting blank OMR sheet, rank jump people, people who were from outside the panel by giving bribe must be punished, otherwise the Meritorious candidates who are eligible for the jobs but did not get it because they could not pay money to the culprits will loose faith in the country and its justice system.

  • @ajayahuja3339
    @ajayahuja3339 23 дні тому

    The new government first task should be to replace wakf act with a minorities welfare act which will fund all welfare actives and disbursement to all minorities and disadvantaged group. The uplifting of everyone will pave the path to bring parity and also phase out any reservations to anyone except economically disadvantaged people

  • @KRISHNA17698
    @KRISHNA17698 18 днів тому

    Is Poppi involved in anti national activities ?
    He want to make India's condition like Pak..
    What is his intentions?
    When appropriate action will be taken proactively?