David Wood, Sam Shamoun & Anthony Rogers Vs Shaykh Uthman Ibn Farooq - Part 1
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 лис 2024
- 👉 If you like this video, please LIKE & SHARE it.
👉 PLEASE subscribe to this channel: bit.ly/2Yefu5S
💢💢 Watch our other videos:
💟 What is the purpose of life?: • What is the purpose of...
💟 Biblical Scholars vs Imam Uthman Ibn Farooq: • Biblical Scholars vs I...
💟 Was Muhammad A True Prophet?: • Was Muhammad A True Pr...
#Davidwood #SamShamoun #AnthonyRogers
Thank you for watching this video, click the "SUBSCRIBE" button for stay connected with this channel.
Subscription Link: bit.ly/2Yefu5S
Omg I’m dying of laugher 😂😂, sheikh Uthman humour is epic loool. He indirectly humiliated them. Cant wait to watch rest.
He made them into 3 boys. 3 different ones. Not 3 in 1.
@@OmniTranscend :D :D :D :D
Ali your debating skills have improved a lot.
Proper laughed my backside off when he said, some people do weird stuff to scripture like "eating it" which David Wood did to the Qur'an and when he heard that and giggled because he knows what he did that jahil...
Sam could not even stand it and he ran away
3 against 1. Wow. This is literally Tauhid vs Trinity
Which one is the holely ghost?
Indeed it is
@MADNUBLOL.
The comments of this video🤣🤣🤣
Wowww Best Comment Ever AllahuAkbar Tawhid Wins
Thank you brother. You helped me realize the truth. I am a ex-catholic but am now Muslim. Alhumdulillah.
God bless🙏😇
I'm glad for you
Welcome to islam brother
Alhamdulillah
Alhamdullilah,May Allah bless you,keep you guided and accept you as a Muslim.
David Wood helped me kickstart my journey with Islam…i reverted a year ago Alhamdulilah
Welcome to Islam🤎 Ramadan Mubarak
Alhamdulillah brother 🤲🏾 May Allah Bless you
Alhamdulilah brother, welcome in our Family
Ye dawid wood is a nice mean to islam
Welcome to the truth my dear brother 🎉
I am just wondering how tough it was for our prophets to deal with the nonbelievers. 😔
@Shareef agreed! Their logic is hilarious.
Well, he had people do the cuting and other things for him.
@@isaacleillhikar4566 this is what David and others did on their channel lol. If you chose to be ignorant even after seeing proofs then no one can help you.
@@ashfiahossain251 I was saying Mohamed had his followers deal with none muslims, using swords.
@@ashfiahossain251 And look at this proof Micah chapter 5 and Isaiah chapter 9. They're quoted in the gospel of Matthew. Stop listening to Zakir Naik for the gospel.
I'm a Christian yet I really love the attitude of Sheikh Uthman. He is calm, organized and compelling. These 3 people should really learn to listen and to respond to questions like Sheikh Uthman. I really love to watch more from Sheikh Uthman.
Hey brother you actually sound like a great person. I feel like conversations with Christians like you can be pretty productive. Are you a devout Christian or just a Christian on paper? Just wanna understand your background.
May Allah guide you to Islam 😊☪️ please do try learning more about Islam brother
@@lisarey1969 why are we not in hell right now why God made a judgement day 🤔
@@sonikamagar6157 thats a deep question with a long answer i suggest you watch some islamic videos on judgement day first
@@lisarey1969 Islam teaches us wrong
God takes our tests....... that's wrong
U buy a freeze on your own will so that it gives u cold water but if it is bad and doesn't give cold water don't u throw it out?
To do evil is worship Satan and hate God
So why are we not in hell right now
Romeo 3 10 everyone is a sinner, everyone has a sinned ( can anyone say that I have not sinned ) jhon 3 16 because God loved the world so much that he gave his only son for the world whoever is believe in him shall not perish but have an eternal life
Revalation 8 4 God is holy, holy, holy, greatest.good works done by people is also dirty in front of God ( can salty sea give sweat water)
So people fails to get heaven through their works
If u prove Revalation 8 4 is wrong than whole Christianity jhon 3 16 will be proved wrong
Please accept Jesus died for our sinns
The Muslim man absolutely smashed it. He was so cool, calm and composed.
He made much more sense.
Yes true, I’m almost halfway the conversation and I love how civil it is.
Bcuz syeikh studied for years and gain knowledges instead of just sitting behind screen with caplocks energy but a coward when f2f
@@sfdss6404 yea I saw what Anthony put out and it’s truly disrespectful and not honest ! I’m ashamed there are people like that damn!
So far I haven’t seen david in any video(idk if he talked about it elsewhere ) and if he didn’t talk behind sheikh uthman’s I respect him for that.
were is the Key of Hell and dead in your koran
thad satan stole from Adam
Jesus was sent to earht get the key from hell and
dead thad satan has stolen from adam
@@rankaandewarewijnstok1216 why does God needs the key from hell when he is the one created hell 🤣🤣🤣 Christians think before you talk
Maturity is when u realize these 3 people are helping us revert non muslims to islam.
So fax
we have to appreciate sheikh David wood for being a very helpful Daeeh to our cause🤣🤣
Maturity has nothing to do with truth. I could be the most loving, patient, mature atheist but still on my way to hell.
😉… he gave them the business like they were in the will !!!
Cooler than a fan , ahki . Cool 😎
Then you are going to hell straight without exit.
Let's not forget all of them came full with food water coffee etc... and the shekh alone fasting no water and food . Still managed to eat them alive with no salt 😄
Ramadan Mubarak everyone
Thanks for all the love ❤
Authentic Hadith says "When someone is fasting in the midst of others who are not, the Angels will pray upon that person until those people finish with their food".
May Allah preserve the Ajr for our Sheikh, Ameen.
And it didnt even break his fast as there was no nourishment lol
Allahu Akbar
আল্লাহ আকবর
It takes 1 lion to scare of horde of rats
" I am not a Debater , I am a Da'i. "
More people need to understand this
Arent you that instagram guy
@@smp5343 it's ok. Apply Burnol to Burnt areas.
@@xillerrz7328 Yes I am
But Uthman literally said in the beginning of the video “I will debate anyone”, and then he realized he was losing so he said “I’m not a debater” 😂😂🤦🏻♂️ 3:30 time stamp
@@GreekOrthodox7 he said he is a preacher. He will not initiate debates but if someone wants to challenge him they are welcome. Hi Greece.
Sheikh Uthman is not a shooter, My man is rocket launcher...
Respect 100%
Ayooo 😐
All 3 got destroyed
Totally agree.
Nah, he is the weapon of mass destruction George Bush was looking for.
This comment made me laugh🤣🤣
that joke Uthman made was hilarious and went unnoticed. He was like "there's three of you... or are you one?" lmaooo
😂😂😂😂
Gimme the second pls
😂😂🎉❤
@oussamalaf04 18:15
I'm catholic, but that was a good one lol its still Praise Jesus our Lord and Saviour tho
Bless David.. He has bought attention to Islam to people who have never heard of Islam and now have looked into Islam and hopefully have reverted to Islam.
Allah is the best planner
Sorry bud hes bringing people out of Islam and into the truth. Go look at his comment section on UA-cam if you don't believe me. Here's just one of the muslims who have left Islam:
@@galatians-2.20 He misguided Nabeel Qureshi which died in the wrong path at 34 after battling with stomach cancer. Allah is the best of all planners.
May Allah guide all of them
@@galatians-2.20
If you were a Muslim before, answer the easiest question about Islam What is salvation in Islam
Mashallah the way Sheikh Uthman handled them so calmly and beautifully. May Allah give every muslim the intelligence of Sheikh Uthman
ameen
Then you will all be dumber than a rock.
@@GreekOrthodox7 he asked Allah for intelligence of sheikh uthman not david wood , it seems you cant read.
@@GreekOrthodox7 A rock is smarter than your idol Paul.
Ameen
2022 and David Wood still helping people revert. Mashallah
🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣best comment 🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂
Allah'plan is the best planner.
David may plan, but God is the best planner. The videos of david woods channel is just showing their real truth of religion. They are against all religion, they show no respect and pretty much talking nonsense about Islam and Judaism.
I live on the same block as David wood and it was because of his videos I actually became Muslim, I have accepted Islam now
Liar
Alhamdulillah
MohamMad police be upon him (pbuh)
Masha Allah brother
Alhamdulillah
As a student of the Bible, I have to accept La ilaha illa or as Islam refers to it tawheed.
Now know that Muhammad is the messenger and you become Muslim.
Congratulations brother, you are a step away from Islam
@@adaradar3141 what?
Now I understand why the second half is part of shahada 🤯
@@superhydra8873 Yea, he is just a step away from Islam, if he could take the step, he would come to Islam
This sheikh is awesome. He’s cool, calm, collected and he lets hid knowledge flow. These other guys need to learn to listen and learn how to debate properly
Yeah that’s because he is confident and his religion and knows what he’s talking about. Liars get frustrated and go psycho just like these guys
@@jayd4ever how is he being deceptive he’s speaking only straight facts
Kindly search and read this article;
Example of sunni morality by shiapen
Sleeping with watermelons and animals, little girls and baby tell me if this is right?
Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.
John 14:6 KJV
Jesus answered them, I told you, and ye believed not: the works that I do in my Father's name, they bear witness of me. But ye believe not, because ye are not of my sheep, as I said unto you. My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me: and I give unto them eternal life; and they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand. My Father, which gave them me, is greater than all; and no man is able to pluck them out of my Father's hand. I and my Father are one. Then the Jews took up stones again to stone him. Jesus answered them, Many good works have I shewed you from my Father; for which of those works do ye stone me? The Jews answered him, saying, For a good work we stone thee not; but for blasphemy; and because that thou, being a man, makest thyself God. Jesus answered them, Is it not written in your law, I said, Ye are gods? If he called them gods, unto whom the word of God came, and the scripture cannot be broken; say ye of him, whom the Father hath sanctified, and sent into the world, Thou blasphemest; because I said, I am the Son of God? If I do not the works of my Father, believe me not. But if I do, though ye believe not me, believe the works: that ye may know, and believe, that the Father is in me, and I in him.
John 10:25-38 KJV
Sheikh is also going to Hell...he won't be calm then!
@@cassandragarcia5548 why ?
What did the sheikh have for iftar that day?
The iftar: Sam Shamoun, David Wood and Anthony Rogers with a pinch of humiliation.
Brother excellent example
Hahah
Seasoned with my dua from their Janazah😍
Hahaha
Sam is the food that was taken because he runs away a lot
I left hinduism then, accepted christian...
But, i had to leave christinity too, bcs, i found the truth...
Now, i reverted to Islam...
Praise be to Allah ❤❤
Welcome brother
Welcome brother
Allahuakbar ! Allahuakbar ! Allahuakbar ! Alhamdulillah… my brother Allah choose you to give syahadah . Praise to Allah😢❤❤❤
❤
Welcome brother
Uthman : “Is it not 3 of you here or is it only 1 of you guys”
Destroying trinity logic on his side bars 😂😂😂
Hahhaha i love u my brother uthman for the sake of ALLAH!!
Timestamp brother???
😂😂😂😂
@@Kramer_. 18:15 akhi
Epic na shaa ALLAH, 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
They thought they were going to end Shakh Uthmans career but instead made him famous.
Shaikh Uthman is so underrated.
@Charlee John : FYI this was Sam Shamouns public post on facebook :
//PRAYER WARRIORS PRAY FOR ME, DAVID WOOD, AND THE REST OF THE TEAM FOR MIRACULOUS INTERVENTION TODAY SINCE WE ARE GOING TO CONFRONT AND RECORD OUR ENCOUNTER WITH THAT MUHAMMADAN FAKE UTHMAN IBN FAROOQ AND ONE MESSAGE FOUNDATION IN ORDER TO SILENCE HIS LIES AND BLASPHEMIES AGAINST THE LORD JESUS, MUHAMMAD'S GOD AND JUDGE. ASK THE RISEN LORD TO KEEP US SAFE, TO ANOINT OUR WORDS, AND TO ENABLE US TO BE ABLE TO HAVE ACTUAL DISCUSSIONS WHERE WE EXPOSE THE LIES OF MUHAMMAD WITHOUT THIS TURNING INTO A SHOUTING MATCH OR RIOT.
MAY THE RISEN LORD PURIFY US TO GLORIFY HIM AND NEVER BRING SHAME OR DISHONOR TO HIS ALL HOLY NAME!
THANK YOU, SAINTS.//
He was already famous without David but now even more
@Charlee John Is English your first language?.. if it is can you give me the meaning of the word 'debate' ??
@Charlee John see the words expose lies / fake/warriors?
That's not how you preface a discussion.
Or may be that's how 'peaceful' xtians behave but civilized people dont.
@@cobrastrike945 didn't its Mather when these trinity get destroyed?even David Wood support ust.utsman???
David wood comes like a king, but uthman made him as a referee 😍🤣
Lol
Haha
😅
From this part, I See he is willing to learn. Even if he spread hate and abuse our Prophet, lets pray that he becomes Muslim and submit his will to God alone. Our prophet (pbuh) used to did same (praying for enemies) while his enemies were planning his death. And later many of his enemies like Umer became our caliph and spread Islam all over the arabia.
@@yufakhattak8439 ...Ameen!
I'm Catholic since I'm young and I've been following Sheikh's videos for some time and they've helped me get closer to the truth, God willing I'll soon make the shahada and finally serve and worship God as it really should be done.
I hope you returned back to islam? Insha allah!
Make your shadah now when you live
✝️ save from this demonic religion
Jesus is the Truth the way and life
Please read my comment and read the Gospels..
Sheikh Uthman is sharp. Very intelligent. I have to meet this man. Ramadan Mubarak everyone! Love from California
Yes he's street wise and MashAllah he's wise in Islam.
Say "MashaAllah" InshaAllah.
I say he knows the truth and truth will and shall always prevail
Ramadan Mubarak 😊
Thanks David Wood who introduced Qur'an , i, ve convert to Islam
Masha Allah, may Allah bless you and Allah is a best planner
Ma sha' Allah, my dear brother, may Allah bless you and protect you always.
MashaAllah , May Allah gather us all in Jannah.
Alhumdulilla
@@ukki7113 he is the best of decievers right?
وَقُلْ جَاءَ الْحَقُّ وَزَهَقَ الْبَاطِلُ ۚ إِنَّ الْبَاطِلَ كَانَ زَهُوقًا
And say: "Truth has (now) arrived, and Falsehood perished: for Falsehood is (by its nature) bound to perish."
You should better add the number and sura of the verse next time, in sha Allah!
@@3boys1family insha'Allah 👍
@🆓🇵🇸The Great Seljuks🆓🇵🇸 why you're laughing ?!
@🆓🇵🇸The Great Seljuks🆓🇵🇸 sorry mate ( surah al israa 17 ayah 81 )
@@jayd4ever i think that you're a hater who have an inferiority complex and can't stand it without typing some hate , nonsense comments " and that's from your s.t.u.p.i.d comments that you made " but anyway watch the lecture of dr zakir naik ( is the Qur'an the word of God ) may Allah guide you and heal you from your complex 🤲
Sam is not letting Usman to speak so he can show his viewers and tell "Look Usman is not able to answer my questions" *Shame on you Sam*
This is the same tactic Muslims use when talking to Christians
What do you mean.. When did u see Sam join the debate.??
@@RamiBawitlungyeah he didn't even really get to say anything I'd like to see them debate 1 on 1
Uthman afraid of sam thats the truth sam will embarassed him with their quran thats why he played victim all the time.
That because Sam was soooooo flustered that he didn't know what to say. He knew when he say something he will get humiliated. That would be bad....
They got humiliated so bad especially when David backed up Sheikh Uthman instead of his own friend😂😂 and notice how David is so respectful when he isn't behind a screen😬
I feel so bad for his friend ..😂 bro it really hurt when your friend don’t back u up and instead he start taking side of your enemy in this video it happened a lot ahah ...
Lol hipocricy runs on his veins.
@@GreekOrthodox7 - What page number is this on?
What is the book called??
Where were these sources from???
@@danoneall4013 that source is weak ibn Ishaq did not authenticate it even ibn Hajar spoke out against that source
An absolute beta male
To summarise, Shaykh Uthman answered every question without retracting or misquoting. The entire christian group was stunned by his intellect, rationality and his arguments, they did not anticipate such a knowledgeable person. May Allah accept the efforts of the daees from One Message Foundation.
Allah of the koran certainly would accept his efforts. And it is amazing that the video ended with him not answering the question about God couldn't or God wouldn't and you say he answered every question without "retracting or misquoting". Poor guy. His whole youtube career was on the line. He didn't tell you all but he was glad it was anthony (and david) and not shamoun. Amazing
On "intellect, rationality and his arguments" you seem more to refer to his glib talking persona smiling like a hyena all the time until he couldn't handle the pressure and had to remove his shades rather than refer to the depth of his logic itself. With your logic however I am sure even a stuttering einstein would be an idiot in your book. For you such a person would never be "stunning" enough and certainly not able to win a debate. Stop focussing on the dressings and appetizers and deal with the main course.
Whoever is wrong heads to hell sir, not to the timeout corner !!
Surah 17:81
And say: "Truth has (now) arrived, and Falsehood perished: for Falsehood is (by its nature) bound to perish."
@@ummzaynul370 And when will falsehood perish?
Hopefully for you not when you are standing before Jesus on that day. That is waiting a bit too long.
@@teachmetheway7081 lol, the sheikh handled them very well, Anthony should just need to attend the sheikh's course in aqidah to refute muslims theology, these video is akin to watching a post grad student talking to kindergarten kids, the gap in knowledge is very far and apart.
@@itisyouthatiadore obviously i beg to differ. anthony started shaky as would be expected. He was entering the sheikh's camp. he was not on his home turf.
However, grad student talking to kindergarten kids? Probably.
The Kids as is written were used to dumbfound the "wise". I am still waiting on his actual answer on trinity and God wouldn't or couldn't. Just had trash talk for the most part. Trash talk can't save you from a christless eternity.
This is what happens if you just sit behind the camera and do some google research instead of studying for years.
Be thankful to Sheik Google my friend. At least he give you answers instead of just saying "Only Allah Knows".Don't forget Sheik Google answers are coming from the muslim sources so don't blame Sheik Google if he expose lies.
@Omar ben Zubaid الــزُبَـيـدي Ahhh....Allah is all knowing that's why Allah forgot which one he created first wether its the mountain or the stars. One verse says mountain and another verse says the stars.
Also, read the complete Gospel my friend why Jesus said He doesn't know the time. Don't be like uthman.
@@apexibuzzichelli643 source?
@@apexibuzzichelli643 If jesus was God, then he would have known when the Hour is, Even Daivd Wood wasnt sure if the Explanation to that was correct
@@mohammadibrahim2461 Jesus is God but HE honors God the Father. Jesus said that God the Father is greater than Him..."
Heaven and earth will pass away, but My words shall not pass away. 36 But of that day and hour no one knows, not even the angels of heaven, nor the Son, but the Father alone. (Matt. 24:35-36).
Sheekh Osman is very attentive - he's aware of what's happening in the audience while still debating. Maasha Allah
you can definetly tell why sheikh uthman was called "The Shooter" lol he knows how to stand his ground, what a legend this man is
He's from the hood, i doubt he fears anything, he's seen it all
@@dariusbrock2713 i wonder if they really showed up thinking they gonna win the "debate" :D
They came, they saw, they thought they had a 'simple' muslim to deal with...remember these 3 guys (3 stooges) are the biggest online christian polemicists (preachers/debaters). They deliberately came with a plan to debate and video the sheikh but they planned and Allah plans and Allah is the best of planners.
They left with their tails between their legs.
@@ehre5740 lol David Wood fell short against Mohammad Hijab as well, i doubt he'll fair any better against any competent muslim debator
SHEIKH IS THE REAL GANGSTA HERE 😎
"I'll shake all of you" MaashAllah Sheikh Uthman real Shooter.
@@chrisnaidoo350 *1 Samuel 15:3*
*Now go and attack the Amalekites and completely destroy everything they have. Do not spare them. Kill men and women, infants and nursing babies'*
*EX CHRISTIAN HERE'☣️*
The fact that sam was silent and ran away after talking so much crap online 😭😭😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
He was debating with some other guys. David was being the moderator. Anthony was doing the debate.
@@isaacleillhikar4566 bullshit he was debating with less knowledgeable people. He pussied out.
@@tarekj5951 He sunk the top daaee of France. He had a million followers and after the debate, half of them left him.
@amine rami He's called Karim A'lhanafi and he had millions of followers.
Trinity vs Tauhid
Thanks to Islamophobia that they brought me back to Islam but much stronger alhamdulillah.
What is Islamaphobia?
@@andys3035were people misrepresent Islam with the goal to hide the truth of the oneness of God nobody knows why they do this but I believe they are hurt about the truth and makes them feel better to suppress Islam and the oneness of God Maybe they don’t wanna give up drugs,alcohol,able to sleep around,or just wanna carry what their grand parents had and that’s why people wanna suppress Islam and that’s the truth and nothing but the truth ☝️
_Masha'Allah, Sheikh Uthman._ *_When truth is hurled against falsehood, falsehood perishes, for falsehood, by its nature bound to perish. (The Noble Quran 17:81)_*
And the Quran stole that verse from the Talmud, like everything else. Nothing in the Quran is original, except for the verses that inspire the Islamic State.
@@GreekOrthodox7 *Quran didn't stole anything*
Quran confirms what has been revealed to all Prophets Abraham Moses Jesus Muhammad Peace Be Upon to all of them
@@GreekOrthodox7 as if we white boys haven’t stolen anything before 😂
@@GreekOrthodox7 stole? You literally have no idea, do you..
@@GreekOrthodox7 what???? Where did you get that from. You people and your false garbage. You make claims but cant prove anything. Deluded!
Im a Bible believer, but I like the charisma the sheikh was displaying and how he stood firm defending is faith. Its admirable
You are right. That guy is so grownded
May Allah open your heart to divine mercy and guidance.
@mz k thank you
@@sigmaman5216 may Allah guide you to his Truth bro. Amiin
may God show u the path
Very Proud to have Mr Usthman as a strong representative of our Religion! 💪
I totally agree
Allhum dulillah !
Alhumdulillah ☝
How can you be proud to follow a pedophile?
For those of u who dont know......dr zakir destroyed william campbell (who is the teacher of sam shamoun) in 2000😂😂😂😂
my friends reverted to islam after watching this video Alhamdulilah
Where??
No they didn’t bro
@@nathanwhalen3763 u have cameras set up in his room to know?
@@nathanwhalen3763also u been commenting from 3+ months ago from what I’ve seen🤣🤣🤣 give it a rest no one’s gonna give u attention. Ur just like that one with mental illness in the streets
@@nathanwhalen3763 Muslims are notorious liars.
I love how as soon as they're in public they turn out to be polite guys willing to discuss important issues in a civil manner.Meanwhile as soon as they open their laptop at home they become disgusting and vile.Where are their internet arguments when they come out in public??Exactly they know they are talking bs in their videos but they are cursed.
@Big Boss NO THEY ARE NOT CHRISTIANS.!!They are using christian audiance to attract people of other faiths. They are probably atheists. Also many christians like James White have spoken against David Wood on how he promote disharmony and hatred also he don't represent any christian values. So you should edit your comment and be Respectful to Christians because David Wood doesn't want us to co-exist together. ✌
So true!
They’re like that in their videos because their audience are blind followers. They can get away with saying anything.
@@yufakhattak8439 then we should have more Christians claiming that wood isn't a real Christian. I don't disagree with you.. But the problem here is that hardly any popular Christians online call people like wood out.. only a few do. Many laymen Christians out there in the world look up to people like wood because they think he's a swell and genuine Christian
I was going to say, that surprisingly they were very well mannered and civil.
Astagfirullah, their fans are so proud of them but they just can be brave in group. May Allah show them the right path, aamiin
This how they imagined coming to shaikh uthman : 😎😎😎
Reality : 🤡🤡🤡
🤣🤣🤣
😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 facts🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
When they come they were like :'HEH muslims are gonna be destroyed today'
When they got uno reversed😅😶😌😬😔😫
😆😆😆😆😆🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣 facts!
Alhumdulillah these 3 will become source of more people coming to islam.Everyone look how Allah is taking his work from the non-believers.
MHA fan...
Hmmmmmmmm seriously???? I dont think so .... Forget about how deceiving iuthman deceiving way to debate...just go straight to your main source and hadiths... Pls dont make me laugh
@@Melay-b4xCan't even spell his name right & you think people's ought to believe in you?
@@Melay-b4x but he literally repeated that he isnt debating, he is a DA I, YET, he answered all questions logically
Satan at his finest making people believe to join Islam
Before this I was muslim, After this I am more muslim.. Thanks David , Anthony and Sam..
Before this I was Christian, after this I am still Christian
@@kaydod3190 nice
Hahaha NOBODY CARES with ur paganic Black stone religion 😂
@@kaydod3190 PRAISE GOD JESUS CHRIST THE HOLY TRINITY IS A TRUEE GOD ☦️☝🏼
@@kaydod3190 1+1+1
After Ahmed Deedat, I am seeing a scholar making sense and constructive response-ability, and believe me I have listened to most of all. Alham du Lillah . Allah bless you. :)
I miss Ahemed deedat 😞 may we all be granted jannah so we have an eternity to talk 😍🤲🏾
zakir naik? he is deedats student lol. he is undefeated
Walahe brother thats my point of view he's so good answering questions 🤲🏾
@@ZainAli-vt7pp Zakir Naik is far from perfect but still quite respectable.
@@faznaz7455 I mean he’s pretty amazing too, I don’t think anyone on earth has memorised all the major religions scriptures like him. I’m not sure if he actually did anything bad or if India’s president just doesn’t like him because he’s a muslim
David Wood thinking he is making a grand entrance into the scene.
Sheikh Uthman : I don't know who you are. Are you famous or somthing ?
Epic lol!
Lol killed him straight off the bat
Oh boy 😂
@Paa Kofi Amponn sheikh destroyed them
@Paa Kofi Amponn Did you even listen to what he said clearly afterwards?
@@John_Six_Twenty-Nine You need to listen carefully.
Still to this day I wish Sam would’ve debated uthman this day. He talk a lot about Islam online but won’t bring it to a shaykh in person
He will cook him in seconds and get embarrassed, shameful walking in defeat
bull crap he will lose joker
@@c.e1187
@@c.e1187Sheikh was calling him not to go away but he didn't stay
sam switched from debater to spectator
@@c.e1187 it kill me how people forget about this video even Sam act like he never walked away
David wood made me Convert to Islam
AllāhuAkbar
Best comment
Good to know😅
Masha'Allah
That’s B.S
Sheikh Uthman is unbelievable. May Allah always protects and give him strength in his Dawah.
Ameen
Your god is fake.
@Koraisha Jeewoot corona free if you say ameen
What a hell is Islam.
ameen
Lol imagine David Wood getting ready in the morning, putting on his sunglasses, necklace and all, only to come up and basically stay quiet the whole time.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂
ahahahaha😂😂✋🏽
He's still licking his paws after the rinsing Hijab gave him..!! That's why he's keeping his nose out..!! 😂 😂
@@David-kz2im why David implement the same behavior in his videos?
As a Christian myself it is painful story see how my brother Christians behave so rudely with other faith people.that is not how Christians are suppose to behave. I apologise to my brothers and sisters of Muslim faith. 😏
Thanks sis np
*Many among the People of the Book wish they could turn you ˹believers˺ back to disbelief because of their envy, after the truth has been made clear to them. Pardon and bear with them until Allah delivers His decision. Surely Allah is Most Capable of everything.*
-Surah Al-Baqarah, Ayah 109
Subhanallah 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
SubhanAllah I just made sajda reading this. Allah Hu Akbar.
*xtians:* God is all knowing.
But is Jesus all knowing?
""But about that day or hour no one knows, *not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but ONLY the Father."* Mark 13:32
@@FreePalestine_____ La illaha ill Allah👏👏
1 John 2 verses 18-28
“Dear children, you have heard that the Antichrist is coming, and already many such antichrists have appeared. Therefore we know the last hour. I write to you, not because you do not know the truth, but because you do know and you know the difference between truth and lies. *And who is a liar? Anyone who says that Jesus is not the Christ, and also anyone who denies the Father and the Son is an antichrist.* Anyone who denies the Son does not have the Father. But anyone who acknowledges the Son has the Father also. For you must remain faithful to what you have been taught from the beginning. If you do, you will remain in fellowship with the Son and with the Father. And this is the promise that He made to us-Eternal Life. *I am writing these things to warn you about those who want to lead you astray.* But you have received the Holy Spirit, and He lives within you, so you need not anyone to teach you what is true. For the Spirit teaches you all that you need to know, and what He teaches is true-it is not a lie. So just as He has taught you, remain in fellowship with Christ, so that when He returns, you will be full of courage and not shrink back from Him in shame.”
OMG. This is epic. Brother Uthman handled it very nicely. Three of them came like big celebrities.. But brother Uthman made them like small boys in the end. Energy levels of Anthony came down drastically when he understood that Uthman has something in him to talk. Great job brother Uthman.
LOL Uthman is a joke, pretending like he didn’t know who they were 😂 he was scared and defensive from the beginning.
@@GreekOrthodox7 cryy more🤣🤣🤣
@@GreekOrthodox7 You should head down to the stall next and show everyone how it's done. That'll be great to watch.
@@GreekOrthodox7 Trinity. God plans god to be tortured to death by his own creation to save man from hell by 1st being born through the private parts of the mother he created. (Adam PBUH didn't need to be born through the private parts of a woman but the Christian god does?)
god loses power on Earth like not knowing fig season or day of judgement & god also became a curse. god says "I by myself can do nothing". god with a separate will to God, worships & prays to God to be saved. When it fails, god says to God, why have you foresaken me.
@@GreekOrthodox7 I think you missed the joke.
*Timestamps*
2:18 - “Hammertime”
2:38 - “They call me Shooter”
2:43 - “I was called Crook”
3:38 - Christian Prince ‘uncomfortable’ in revealing his identity..
5:10 - Do you believe Jesus is God or the son of God?
7:54 - Characteristics of Allaah
(Anthony’s misunderstanding that because Allaah has many characteristics, that somehow means he is not One :S)
15:45 - “I can tell you were a shooter”
17:59 - Sam 😂😂😂
21:08 - We don’t use kalaam to understand the attributes of Allaah
25:40 - Are Allaah’s attributes present in his creation?
26:36 - Was Jesus born from Mary’s womb?
39:55 - 🤣🤣🤣
44:45 - Imma put you on mute
47:00 - David Wood concedes on the Age of A’ishah (r) argument
52:15 - You know you like Islaam!
1:00:15 - LOTS!
1:02:05 - Why did Jesus need to become a human being..
1:05:46 - I’d be a Salafi if I was a Muslim (Wood)
1:06:54 - “Sam yaps alot”
1:12:18 - God is perfect
1:12:22 - Guess who’s back..?
1:14:00 - Against the nature of God, (eating, sleeping, dying etc.)
Jazakallah
Thanks akhi
TQ,TQ Nice work Bro.
Why is this not top comment
@@spikspak2889 too many debate in another comment
Ive been a Christian for 47 years and every time I watch your videos I get closer and closer to islam. Im pretty much muslim, but I still want to learn more. But videos like this are great! I love Islam ☪️
We call you to official accept Islām
@@OneMessageFoundation fr
@@OneMessageFoundation where are you located in San Diego I would like to come to the both and ask questions and take shahada?
Come to Masjid Ribat 7173 Saranac St, San Diego, CA 92115 you are welcome anytime Friday at 1 pm and Saturday at 8 pm are the best times. You can also call us @ 858-523-8546
@@OneMessageFoundation thank you for your support, information and I will be in san diego in two months inchallah I look forward to speaking with you. Much love and please continue to upload more videos, this is great content.
I can’t believe these guys flew to San Diego just to get there careers ended .. did they not know who Shaykh Uthman is?
Hahahah so true
💯 true
They planned and Allah planned, and Allah is the best of planner's
No bro they don't
@@babybaba445 hahaha they are humiliated by syeikh uthman...wahahahahaha
When you finally reach the boss level ❤️
@WorthToBeBeliever so am I Allahu akbar
@WorthToBeBeliever I didn't expect this 😳
@Amena Mao no really who would of thought that 3 people who just talk bs bout my religion would come and debate the man who destroyed trinity and the bible
😂
@WorthToBeBeliever lmaooooooooooo
Just like the Trinity they come in 3's against one Uthman
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
And somehow they are also one...
You made ma day 😂😂
Hahahahahaha. Nice comment
Lmao!!
Salaamu 3alaikum, I only have one thing to say to Sheikh Uthman Mashallah Mashallah so so respectfull and has a world of patience. May Allah bless you 😊
All three, thanks for sacrificing yourself and promoting this channel 😇
Salam. Pls share my channel's play lists.
Wood: u know who we are
Sheikh: I don’t know who u are, are u guys famous
😂😂.. killed it
This is DAVID WOOD!
syekh : are you famous or what?
🤣🤣
😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣😭😭
all three of them showing up against one guy was equivalent to admitting defeat
But according to them 3 = 1 LMAOO
Lol. Because they are insecure. They know very well that if Uthman had a one on one discussion with anyone of them they would get humiliated. That's why all three of them ganged up on uthman and he still humiliated them. Allahu akbar
@@mrhassanali3297 Allahu Akbar sheikh uthman must have really scared them
3 is 1 and 1 beats 3 LOL
@@chrisnaidoo350 don't get mad dude, just bcoz he roasted ur guy's as usual. 🤣🤣🤣
When you stand on the right side and have the knowledge This is what Sheikh Othman did while facing a group of people at the same time, and he was able to overcome every question and claim they presented, but they were unable to respond to anything. May God bless her and help him guide people
David if you see this, ramadan is almost over, it'll be the best time to accept Islam. Anytime is good but this month is tons of blessing. Just saying. I need part 2 : )
InshaAllah David will become Dawud. Aameen
Inshallha
@@naisa9705 aameenn🤲🤲🤲
@Mahir Ahnaf in fact his name is very good 'david'. And no need to change. It's the name of prophet dawud
Imagine how many Christians are gonna revert after watching this epic debate
SubhanAllah, im really proud to he muslim :-)
@@TheWillofD7978 Salam Abdullah, subhanallah Ti ho incontrato su you tube, incredibile 😂😂
@@TheWillofD7978 ti rendi conto che questo video l'ho avevo visto appena uscito e adesso lo sto rivedendo perché è fantastico😂. Machaallah sheykh uthman è incredibile, che Allah lo benedica🤲🤲
@@TheWillofD7978 me to I'm proud to be a Muslim, alhamdulillah 🤲
@@Abderrahman0502 hahaha
Ma come hai fatto?! Mi hai youtu-localizzato 😂 fa piacere di incontrarti in questo oceano chiamato youtube, eh dicono che il mondo è piccolo eh 😂
Fra ma questo shaik é incredibile, gli ha spenti a tutti sti ctistiani che dicono che Allah subhanahu wa taala é nato come un bambino 😂
Mi fa piacere che guardi anche questi dibattiti, se ne trae tanto beneficio. Alhamdulillah ala ni3mat l islam 🤲
I'm surprised david wood wasn't wearing his wife's clothes 😂😂😂
L0L
Ha 😃😁😊 হা ha
😂😂😂😂😂😂
I dont get your reference meme?
What do you mean by wife clothe?😂
@@justarshad8354 you can go to his channel. he use his wife cloth to mock islam
The biggest thank and credit goes to these 3 guys who just strengthen my Iman more and more whenever they speak. Keep up the good work
Usman explains so clearly and logically. I've learned a lot from listening to him.
@@chrisnaidoo350 what are you talking about ilm qalam do not mean philosophy 😂😂😂
@@chrisnaidoo350 HAHAHAHAA..WHY YOU HAVE TO SAY THAT MAN? 😂
why are u liking my comment.. i just telling u how stupid u are to say that
@@chrisnaidoo350 at least sheikh uthman got manners compare to you.. and you ask doni speak arabic? well i know some of them.. since in malaysia it is compalsary for us to take arabic language..so basically, 9 years of learning basic arabic
@@chrisnaidoo350 if you were that clever and think that you were better than sheikh uthman... i suggest you to break his idea in the video
David has become a little humble, May Allah Open his heart. Ameen
He can't debate. Useless.
Aameen
Yes may Allah guide him to islam and stop being stupid
he know, if he talking...he ended his career.... so dillema for david, accept the true or his career... 🤔
Aamiin
Subhan Allah, Sheikh Uthman is a lion in front of these hyenas, proud to be a Muslim ❤️
am I watching lion king again?
@@abdulmalik_al-habeshi hahaha exactly, it's the scene where Mufasa rips into the three hyenas thinking they can just walk and own the place
@@adelbertantonio2937 awww is someone sad their so called religious "experts" couldn't keep up with just one our lions? It's okay to cry, I know it hurts but it'll get better
@@ImranAli-db1pp Yeah exactly bro
@@adelbertantonio2937 who ran from who? He was there the whole time! Go troll somewhere else you goof, and please don't even try to come at us about making excuses, when your book contradicts itself on virtually every other page. Your whole religion is a sham so don't even try to act up, you're just embarassing yourself even more everytime you do.
18:13 “There’s not three of you here?” “Can you not count” “or is there one of you guys” 😂 one of the best uthman quotes
I’m dead he literally invited the third guy over 🤣 and plus he’s only talking to one person fr. Make it make sense
@@ezekielnsamba5213he’s making a joke about the trinity
Muhammad has 2 underage girls. Is it 1 or 3?
*Infinity War is the most ambitious crossover in history*
Shaykh Uthman: Hold my miswak
😂😂 i wanted to comment the same hahah
Underrated comment
🤣🤣
OMG this!
😂😂
" Im not shaking, you're shaking and I'll make all you guys shake!! Shaykh Farooq takes them to school
اللهم بارك
@@RiazKhan-gn4vo الشيخ عثمان اسد بارك الله فيه
@@المسلمالعربي-ق2ط Aameen.
@@RiazKhan-gn4vo Aameen
Hahaha bro i loved that part.
Alhamdulillah sheikh uthman your channel get famous among non Muslim with his visit. insyaAllah May this event open our Christian friends minds about the beautiful of Islam.
@@GreekOrthodox7
_The Qur'an per se says that this Book is not from the Shait'an, because Allāh knows people had and will say this._
@@GreekOrthodox7 y u jealous man🤣
Watch David Wood get busted on farid responds.
I LOVE DAVID WOOD, HE IS STILL TAKING CHRISTIANS OUT OF DARKNESS AND PUTTING THEM INTO LIGHT ISLAM.
Yea😂😂
It’s haram to love him, first ayat of Surah mumtahinah is the proof
Jesus is the way the truth and the life
This uthman is a great manipulator of telling lies. He did not even presented any valid argument about the topic of Jesus (God) being born through a woman. He only said about his belief without any logical support to establish its validity.
@donkeykong2.0 average human worshipper always commenting this😅😂
The way Shaykh Uthman described it is just so beautiful... May Allah help him in his dawah and give him a big reward for his continuous efforts... Allah Bless you... And May he guide all mankind to the truth...
@@jesusmatters4222 We do not believe that Allah is a human who came down as a baby and had to be taken care of, you paulists claim that we muslims limit God, but are we the ones who claim his death or the fact that he was born by a human being?
Alhamdulillah shaik very kind man humble respect,1 vs 4 but ma shaa Allah islam perfect Allah guide you
@@jesusmatters4222not how jesus become God jesus son of mery not God
Its all about career vs truth. FULLSTOP.
Sheikh has nothing to loose vs big donations +fame.
"If you write it, somebody could eat it or be weird" shot a silent arrow
it wasn't silent, that shot was ringing throughout the conversation in his wooden head 👌
You got my 100th like
Oooh! Shots fired!
Can anyone tell me where did he said that.
@@muhammadwafi329 watch from 16:55.
I went to the same church David Woods went to every Sunday and converted to Islam.
I like the fact the Wood has learned from his previous debates with a lot of Muslims who has hamulated him so he was standing polite...hahahah , Brother Uthman you are amazing Masha 'Allah.
@@Is-de6qk I think you mean behind the screen he becomes liar..he is just taking it as a career and he said it ,he is just pathetic disperate liar 🤣
You are so much into humiliation and other kinky stuff, is it what zIslam is about? How to humiliate your opponent!
@@XAE_A_Xii Well, when a jerk like Wood or Shamoun dedicates their platform to fabricate lies about my religion, and we all know that they are not truly seeking the truth, but rather getting paid for their lies, these liars must be humiliated and exposed, because we do not tolerate lies and fabrication like Christians.
@@XAE_A_Xii Second, he is not an opponent to anyone; liars intentionally lie and know that they lie, but they worship nothing but money, and many western countries fund these kinds of liars for a purpose; if they are seeking truth and coming to discuss, they will get our respect even if we disagree, but they have no respect even for themselves.
I reviewed david wood's reactions in this video and i'm 90% sure that he's leaning toward islam. Look how he agrees almost with everything that shaykh uthman is saying
Only ALLAH knows whats in his heart..hope he is not hypocrite.
May ALLAH open his mind and his heart..aamiiiiiin.insyallah 😊
No he’s not. Just check his UA-cam page.
He's a liar and deceptionist
May Allah guide David Wood towards the truth of Islam.
آمين آمين يارب العالميــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــن
@@kamarudinhj.dolmoin8578 how do you write this
“I’ll shake all you guys” -call him SHAKE Uthman 😤😌💪🏽
Hahaha bro that was probably my favorite part
Underrated comment
underrated
Bahut underrated comment hai bhai🤣😎
39:58 😙
Funny to see 4 poeple who made me accept islam 😅
yeah actually Christian apologist nabil al curachi made me look into my religion more and also his religion and now I'm Muslim through and through
This is the first time I have seen trinity destroyed physically.
Lol
Bhuhahahah😂
Impossible. But the True and Living God knows that Islam and the Quran is from Satan, and that Muhammad is in hell for being a false prophet, the most obvious one in history.
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
@@GreekOrthodox7 Satan tells us be good to our parents?Satan tells us to worship 1 God with no partners? Satan tells us to be respectful and kind? Satan tells us to believe in all the prophets from Adam? Satan tells us to nor murder? Satan tells us to not drink alcohol? Satan tells us to not smoke? Satan tells us to not listen to Satan? Satan says worship the God of Abraham 5 times a day? 😂😂
They call him "the shooter" for a reason ..... subhanallah, love from Indonesia 🇮🇩👍
He shoots answers back which make sense
Benar sekali.
He shoot their tot and shaken them their answer
Oh hey, nice to see Indonesian here.
As Salamu Aliaykum maybe Because He's Shooting the Straight TRUTH to Defeat their Falsehood
nemu orang indonesia di mari :D
This recording deserves an Oscar.
👌
☝️
Sam Running away is the best part bro🤣🤣🤣
He as always run away but when he is with his kafr friends he start blabbing and they thing he is making sense since they are as ignorant as he is.
He never ran if u watch the video Sheik wasn’t interested in debating with sam
@@trulyTH bro😂😂😂 he LITRELLY called Sam MULTIPLE times even at 17:57 he LITRELLY said "Sam come here you looked bored" 😂 Uthman was interested in debating all of them even the other guy that kept jumping in bro come on Sam could not handle Uthman and Sam knows that too😂😂😂 I have NEVER seen Sam so well behaved and quiet Normally behind screen his FULL of energy when he debates teenage muslims online he curses them etc i have never seen Sam so queit look at part 2 of the video at the end where they were ending the debate and Uthman invited them over for tea/coffee that is when Sam came 😂 how are you still defending Sam how are you saying Uthman did not want too debate Sam at 11:57 UTHMAN LITRELLY called Sam DIRECTLY and at 36:45 that guy tried too butt in and Uthman was also ready to debate him too 😂 and at 42:27 that guy kept jumping In and at 56:04 Uthman LITRELLY said "I'm waiting for Sam" and then he LITRELLY shouted out Sam's name 😂😂
How you saying Uthman did not want too debate Uthman?😂 Sam did not want too Debate Uthman the moment Sam went back home he done a UA-cam video calling out Uthman 😂😂😂😂 he could have said what he wanted when he was right their
Did you watch this video with the volume off? How you saying Uthman did not want to debate Sam 😂😂 you deffo love Sam the keyboard gangsta enough too say online but nothing to say In person hahaha rewatch the video with the VOLUME UP 😂😂
@user-nz6eg5yu2k Sam destroys teens 😂😂😂??? Sam DESTROYS your Scholars
He ate Daniel and another Muslim destroyed their carriers he will eat Uthman alive!
@@MojoKante exactly 👍
David wood is a future revert in disguise lol he aint feeling Anthonys arguments .
Insha Allah, may Allah give hidaya to him, I too felt that
Christianity isn't like islam where everyone has to agree to be executed, christians can debate and disagree on complex philosophical views dude
@@snowforest4159 ah seriously?? I watch many debate .christian people can't explain the arguments and then people christian hate it feel like he so true and not look the bible yourself just oppinion in your self
idk bro hes more like shaitan than a christian. hes an athiest disguised as a christian. hes here to manipulate people and i dont actually think hes a genuine person
@@christianjc4279 ignorant
Can't believe how David can be that much disciplined 😮
Fear can do wonders.
Munafiqun behaviour
He sure learning debating manners
He is future reverts 😁inshaAllah
@3.142
Inshallah
They came as a trinity, but got dealt with Ahad. 😀
Underrated comment
Hahah
Subhanallah
Carry on using simple Arabic term, so that Christian hooligans in the comment can't hackle.
@Kate` Butterworth Karen where does Arabic grammar come from?
This is prove David wood cannot win an debate face to face he looks a comedian when debating face to face
Half way in and shekh still have to keep teaching Anthony on how to engage in a conversation. Just don't Interrupt man "crook"
He is a ignoramus and that is being kind.
*Did you know that* prophet said in an authentic hadith that “Whoever recites Ayatul Kursi immediately after each prescribed prayer, there will be nothing standing between him and his entering Paradise except death.”
It's really that easy. Recite Ayathul kursi (which is verse 255 in Surah al-Baqarah - 2:255 )after every fard salah. Why would you miss this good deed? You didnt know this? Now you know. From now on never miss reciting Ayathul kursi after fard salah. I mean why would you miss this?
Source: islamqa
it was narrated that Abu Umaamah said: “The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Whoever recites Aayat al-Kursiy immediately after each prescribed prayer, there will be nothing standing between him and his entering Paradise except death.” This is how it was narrated by al-Nasaa’i in al-Yawm wa’l-Laylah, from al-Hasan ibn Bishr. It was also narrated by Ibn Hibbaan in his Saheeh from Muhammad ibn Humayr, who is al-Homsi, and is also one of the men of al-Bukhaari. The isnaad meets the conditions of al-Bukhaari.
I thank these 3 for strengthening my Iman and helping me learn more about my Deen..
this video explain the works of trinity, the father played by anthony inquiring shaykh what the tawhid is, the son played by david have a duty to be a referee, and holy ghost played by sam, he is not helping at all, he show up and disappear like a ghost
😂😂😂 well said
Amazing analogy 😂
Loooooooool
I forgot Sam was even there 😂😂😂
hahahahahaaa
Surat Aş-Şaf (The Ranks) - سورة الصف
يُرِيدُونَ لِيُطْفِـُٔوا۟ نُورَ ٱللَّهِ بِأَفْوَٰهِهِمْ وَٱللَّهُ مُتِمُّ نُورِهِۦ وَلَوْ كَرِهَ ٱلْكَـٰفِرُونَ
61:8
They want to extinguish the light of Allah with their mouths, but Allah will perfect His light, although the disbelievers dislike it.
May Allah bless my brother 🙌
I was seeing Mohammed Hijab vs David Wood and was thinking about bro Uthman to have a debate with him and suddenly this video pop up from nowhere and I see bro Uthman is debating with him...Alhamdulilah
Alhamdulillah....he humbled himself real good in this video
I get the feeling that David wood and Anthony had a fight on their way here😂😂😂😂
I guess and sam run away the trinity is in error 🤣🤣
And on their way back.
On which book should be on the Bible? or which book removed? Since they have different books Catholic has 73, Protestants 66, Mormon bible , Orthodox over 80+ etc
They came to try to end Shaykh Uthman and they left only increasing his views and subscribers Mashallah
Listen to the arguments still Christians won!
@@summerbreeze8618 how
@Can haktan
So True masha'allah.
@@summerbreeze8618
There was no arguments lol
@@abduallahamin2001 If there is no argument then how you abduls come into conclusion that they got busted hahaha silly
I was a Muslim, but when these three Christian legends showed up I became a better Muslim 😂. They flew all the way for this?