@@bigmoniesponge Kanye also isn’t dead,which I also think was a factor in him changing the score,swimming has like two and a half good songs and all of his criticism was valid.
Idk, I usually like his reviews but see all this just makes me think about how people only give other people their flowers after they’re dead, I’ve always like Mac miller and his Kids album will always have a spot in my heart
The thing about Macs two albums though, is due to the subject matter present it genuinely just changes the listening experience once he’s gone. It’s not a matter of pretending you like something, it’s a matter of genuinely changing your view because things have changed. As others have mentioned plenty of rappers have died that Fantano hated before and after their death.
Yeah honestly his biggest snub on the whole channel that’s insane. It’s not even my favorite project but lyrically and musically it’s easily arguable that it could be his best project
@@matheusmace_dg it's hard to listen to his recommendations when he shits on some of the best music ever created. Not just Mac Miller, tons of others too. I agree that the older I get, the more this dudes opinions just doesn't jive well with what I'm into.
@@fernandoreyes680 im not really into frat rap, so I'm not into KIDS. I also personally just can't say I love Divine Feminine, so I'd put that at like a 6 personally.
Mac was for sure one of the biggest talents of our generation, but he was pretty inconsistent overall. Wonderful ideas, but not the best execution. However, I think he still has some of the best rap albums of the decade
My opinions on Mac Miller albums KIDS: 7/10 Best Day Ever: 7/10 I Love Life, Thank You: 7/10 Blue Slide Park: 6/10 Macadelic: 7/10 Watching Movies With The Sound Off: 8/10 Faces: 10/10 GO:OD AM: 9/10 The Divine Feminine: 7/10 Swimming: 9/10 Circles: 9/10
@@jimikooke1420i feel like divine feminine receives the most love- it was my favorite project but upon a relisten- watching movies with the sound off is not my favorite ♥️
@@aylin2341i understand your opinion. Watching movies definitely takes some time to grow on you, still a great project imo i love the experimental route he took .i personally enjoy the album a lot , lot of beautiful tracks as well.
@@nagesh3132 oh my gosh. i never realized the typo haha. i meant that the divine feminine used to be my favorite but in my own personal opinion, i’ve recognized that it gets too much love. watching movies has become my favorite project of his upon re-listening ♥️
still convinced melon feels horrible for his swimming review and has an irrational guilt around it due to mac's passing shortly thereafter. not convinced we get his unbiased, true opinions on his mac miller reviews after macs passing
@@benjaminhansen7935 well it's been proven that a lot of artists do take fantano's reviews seriously and have taken some of his negative reviews to heart (most famously drake). he is, for all intents & purposes, the most important music critic today and is slowly becoming the music equivalent of Roger Ebert. It's not a stretch to say that Fantano may have worried his negative review of Swimming could've hurt Mac's feelings right before his overdose and may have played a role in his mental state at the time. A lot of people in Fantano's shoes would've been kept awake at night by the events that unfolded
I agree with Blue Slide Park being a 5. Macadelic, I gotta take another listen. But honestly, if I’m rating Mac albums, it’s definitely biased. Pretty much everything WMWTSO to Circles would be a 8.5/9-10/10 range. That man helped me, and still helps me so much with my inner demons. He just got it. He got depression. He got addiction. I could tell he wasn’t faking it. This was really who he was in his music, and I don’t mean that he was just a depressed addict and nothing more. No, he had a beautiful perspective on life, relationships, hope, optimism, etc. Even in his darkest times, Faces aside, there was always a little bit of hope bleeding through the cracks. Anytime I’m going through something and I just feel like I have no way out, it’s like he’s there with me, telling me “hey, everything’s okay. It’s all a part of your journey.” It’s just so wild how someone you’ve never met can have such an impact on you, and that’s why music and art in general is just so damn powerful. Celebrity deaths make me sad, sure, but this is one I don’t think I’ll ever truly get over. He inspires me, and for only being 26 is just unfathomable, because the lines he wrote and the emotion when he rapped/sang could only be done by a true student of life. It’s not about the years, it’s about what you do with the years. RIP Mac, I hope you knew how many hearts you touched, and will continue to touch, for generations and lifetimes to come.
Tbh i dont really think thats the case here. Im not a huge fan of fantano but I don’t think he cares much about other peoples opinions on artists/albums
That’s not really what happened tbh I don’t think fantano cares about someone’s passing, there’s been plenty of artists that passed that he was still harsh on even after their passing
I feel the exact opposite as you,I think macadelic,kids,watching movies with the sound off,good a.m,the Devine feminine and even blue slide park are leagues better than swimming and circles.
Correct Ratings on Every Album: KIDS: 7/10 Blue Slide Park: 5/10 Best Day Ever: 3/10 Macedelic: 5/10 Watching Movies With The Sound Off: 9/10 Faces: 10/10 GO:OD AM: 7/10 Devine Feminine: 8/10 Swimming: 10/10 Circles: 9/10
Anthony definitely just didn’t like Mac Miller. He gave KSI a 5 on his album and he gave swimming a 3 lol, you have to wonder how valid of an actual critic he is. I actually like Fantano I think he’s a dope person but maybe he’s out of his realm when it comes to hiphop
macadelic and faces are mixtapes the rest are albums but you can damn near put them in his discography and “of the soul” from bsp is such a great song the production and beat on that song is amazing but overall i think faces and go:od am is his best work. 💿 👼🏼
Ngl this guy has literally no idea what hes talking about, years later he gave faces an 8, and watching movies, swimming and the devine feminine are arguably some if his best work
Word schemes and lyrics and not much of a competition when people like em aren't putting out good or something decent and people like mgk and jack harlow, to name a few.
@slowcookerhomeplanet4326 mac does those he doesn't view a 6 a bad and plus he said it was to a light 7 but I could see him appreciate the album and score it different after macs death but he gave mac around 5,7s or better
@@Timeforceletsgo But he is maaad respectable for actually looking at music in a higher scheme then people who give out 10s to people like drake or any music that they here and say that's good once and just consider it a 10 and not look at anything besides if it's a "BANGER" .
I really dislike the idea of reviewing music. I understand that on a technical level you can review and be correct on how some music is but at the end of the day sounds and words will always have a different effect on every person in the world and that’s the most beautiful part of it.
How does the inherent subjectivity of music and art in general cause reviewing at large to be a bad idea? A review is literally just expressing your own thoughts and feelings on an album, just in a more structured way than usual. It isn't about being "right" and it never has been. Some of his fans on the other hand seem downright rabid. As soon as someone's opinion differs ever so slightly out of line with their own they go ballistic, like one person can't have a different opinion than others. Anyways, seriously, no shade or Amy hing I just don't understand your point at all. Music reviews as a concept being bad due to subjectiveness just doesn't compute for me ig.
Fantano doesn’t have integrity. You don’t jump from a 3 to an 8 because you are “enjoying it more these days.” He realized that his fans wanted a better score post- his passing.
WHATS YOUR FAVORITE MAC ALBUM ⁉️
MINE IS FACES
Swimming
kids
His rating on faces is the only time he’s ever upset me. I feel truly disappointed it’s such a great record
Watching movies with the sound off!!!
circles
Thank God he corrected his rating on the Swimming
Ikr I was fuming lol
Nah
im still not forgiving him tho, that 3/10 even for that time isn't justified lmao
@@chandler119 not really he’s down this with Kanye life of Pablo and other albums
And faces too with the reissue
he also gave a redux for faces and gave it a 8
Yeah and it ended up on his top 200 albums of the decade
Where did he give it an 8?
@@noahcoleman6385 his “Fantano” channel.
@@finnbobos356 link?
@@solunabackup if you just look up “Theneedledrop Faces” it’ll be one of the first ones to show up on his second channel.
3 to 8 on swimming ?! That's an insane jump. Goes to show what preconceived thoughts and or perspectives can do to sway
Nah im pretty sure it’s just mac’s dickeating fanbase harassing him until he changed his opinion by force.
@@JacksonThornhill idk man maybe he actually liked it more now. he thinks mbdtf is a 6 even with the redux.
@@shormere1612 I mean maybe,but knowing Mac’s toxic ass fanbase I wouldn’t be surprised if he just wanted the hate to stop.
@@bigmoniesponge Kanye also isn’t dead,which I also think was a factor in him changing the score,swimming has like two and a half good songs and all of his criticism was valid.
@@bigmoniesponge maybe,but knowing macs fanbase I wouldn’t be surprised
Idk, I usually like his reviews but see all this just makes me think about how people only give other people their flowers after they’re dead, I’ve always like Mac miller and his Kids album will always have a spot in my heart
He wasn't a fan of Xxxtentacion before he passed...he has still given negative takes about his music presently. So I don't think he's really faking it
Fake fans
He’s always disliked lil peep and still does to this day lmao
The thing about Macs two albums though, is due to the subject matter present it genuinely just changes the listening experience once he’s gone. It’s not a matter of pretending you like something, it’s a matter of genuinely changing your view because things have changed. As others have mentioned plenty of rappers have died that Fantano hated before and after their death.
Maybe you should watch the review instead of just looking at numbers
Macadelic 2/10 is such a terrible take
Such an underrated album. Definitely a decent 7 for me.
He really rated BSP higher than Macadelic🤣🤣🤣
Stg
Yeah honestly his biggest snub on the whole channel that’s insane. It’s not even my favorite project but lyrically and musically it’s easily arguable that it could be his best project
Its not the best mac album overall but there definitely some of his best songs on there an 4 is way to low
His Mac rating are my least favorite thing about him
It’s seem for me the older I get the less I value his opinions on music
Its kinda funny cuz its the exact opposite for me
@@matheusmace_dg yeah that’s true, I’ve definitely found some stuff from him before
@@matheusmace_dg it's hard to listen to his recommendations when he shits on some of the best music ever created. Not just Mac Miller, tons of others too. I agree that the older I get, the more this dudes opinions just doesn't jive well with what I'm into.
The older you get the less you care about anyone’s opinion
His opinions are atrocious
All the albums are so good, like their all at least a 7
BSP is not good I'm sorry
@@just-a-me1168 tracks 3-8 are all great
@@just-a-me1168 yeah I can understand BSP being like a 5. The rest are like at least a strong 7
@@fernandoreyes680 im not really into frat rap, so I'm not into KIDS. I also personally just can't say I love Divine Feminine, so I'd put that at like a 6 personally.
Mac was for sure one of the biggest talents of our generation, but he was pretty inconsistent overall. Wonderful ideas, but not the best execution. However, I think he still has some of the best rap albums of the decade
Big fan of melon but initially giving faces a 6 is absolutely wild
One of the best mixtapes of the 2010s
Apparently he changed his mind, because he included Faces on his Top 200 Albums of the 2010's
@@mauricioandres7470I believe on his side channel he made a video on the faces rerelease and gave it an 8
That’s literally what I said, it’s Mac’s best album/mixtape
My opinions on Mac Miller albums
KIDS: 7/10
Best Day Ever: 7/10
I Love Life, Thank You: 7/10
Blue Slide Park: 6/10
Macadelic: 7/10
Watching Movies With The Sound Off: 8/10
Faces: 10/10
GO:OD AM: 9/10
The Divine Feminine: 7/10
Swimming: 9/10
Circles: 9/10
Now that are good takes!
Good ranking but you should give more love to the divine feminine
@@jimikooke1420i feel like divine feminine receives the most love- it was my favorite project but upon a relisten- watching movies with the sound off is not my favorite ♥️
@@aylin2341i understand your opinion. Watching movies definitely takes some time to grow on you, still a great project imo i love the experimental route he took .i personally enjoy the album a lot , lot of beautiful tracks as well.
@@nagesh3132 oh my gosh. i never realized the typo haha. i meant that the divine feminine used to be my favorite but in my own personal opinion, i’ve recognized that it gets too much love. watching movies has become my favorite project of his upon re-listening ♥️
He also corrected his faces rating on the reissue and gave it an 8
giving faces a 6 is crazy looking back at it, opinion-aside
It’s his best album
I'm still surprised The Devine Feminine is so overlooked and not as loved as Mac's other works. It's personally my favorite album from him tbh
i feel like it’s not though!! i feel like i speak to people who don’t listen to mac or who love him that’s their favorite project
i hate to say it like this but i sadly don't think mac would have had gotten reconsideration had he not passed.
like everyone knows that swimming is miles better than circles.
@@youngsuitstrongly disagree with that second point.
Can't wait to hear how he feels about Balloonerism when that drops next month!
still convinced melon feels horrible for his swimming review and has an irrational guilt around it due to mac's passing shortly thereafter. not convinced we get his unbiased, true opinions on his mac miller reviews after macs passing
At the end of the day, it’s just a music opinion. His opinion at that time. Why feel bad about your own opinion?
And yep. I think we will. He gave XXX a shit score.
@@benjaminhansen7935 well it's been proven that a lot of artists do take fantano's reviews seriously and have taken some of his negative reviews to heart (most famously drake). he is, for all intents & purposes, the most important music critic today and is slowly becoming the music equivalent of Roger Ebert. It's not a stretch to say that Fantano may have worried his negative review of Swimming could've hurt Mac's feelings right before his overdose and may have played a role in his mental state at the time. A lot of people in Fantano's shoes would've been kept awake at night by the events that unfolded
Going from a 3 to a 8 is impressive.
Glad he changed it
how da fucc do u give swimming a 3 on any day
Watching movies is one of the most underrated albums from a mainstream artist ever
Shhhhh you’re going to spoil our secret😂
I agree with Blue Slide Park being a 5. Macadelic, I gotta take another listen. But honestly, if I’m rating Mac albums, it’s definitely biased. Pretty much everything WMWTSO to Circles would be a 8.5/9-10/10 range. That man helped me, and still helps me so much with my inner demons. He just got it. He got depression. He got addiction. I could tell he wasn’t faking it. This was really who he was in his music, and I don’t mean that he was just a depressed addict and nothing more. No, he had a beautiful perspective on life, relationships, hope, optimism, etc. Even in his darkest times, Faces aside, there was always a little bit of hope bleeding through the cracks. Anytime I’m going through something and I just feel like I have no way out, it’s like he’s there with me, telling me “hey, everything’s okay. It’s all a part of your journey.” It’s just so wild how someone you’ve never met can have such an impact on you, and that’s why music and art in general is just so damn powerful. Celebrity deaths make me sad, sure, but this is one I don’t think I’ll ever truly get over. He inspires me, and for only being 26 is just unfathomable, because the lines he wrote and the emotion when he rapped/sang could only be done by a true student of life. It’s not about the years, it’s about what you do with the years. RIP Mac, I hope you knew how many hearts you touched, and will continue to touch, for generations and lifetimes to come.
Frat rap Mac = mid. Anything else = good to great.
Bro really gave Mac his flowers after he passed, absolute brain dead for giving faces and swimming a low score
Macadelic is criminally underrated. I loved that mixtape the most out of any project he put out.
Yup honestly Macs best work imo. I’d give it a 9 easily
And this is how it looks to change your opinion on someone when they pass away and learn how much fans he had. Sad really..
Tbh i dont really think thats the case here. Im not a huge fan of fantano but I don’t think he cares much about other peoples opinions on artists/albums
Nah this album j needs a few listens fr fr
That’s not really what happened tbh I don’t think fantano cares about someone’s passing, there’s been plenty of artists that passed that he was still harsh on even after their passing
bro got possesed by demons on 0:26
Macadelic is fire.
Tbh I'm not a fan of Mac Miller rapping , I love swimming and Circles . But I love Faces in rap
I feel the exact opposite as you,I think macadelic,kids,watching movies with the sound off,good a.m,the Devine feminine and even blue slide park are leagues better than swimming and circles.
@@JacksonThornhillyeah me too, I think circles is overated
Faces, circles, swimming. Best 3. Divine and good am close
Yessir, for me it’s Faces, Swimming, and Wmwtso
hot take: he only started liking mac miller after his death
0:39 is he talking about delusional thomas with this?
yes
A 2 on Macadelic is wild😭
appriiiiciate
I was about to crash out that he gave swimming a 3, because it's one of my favourite Mac albums
Idk why anyone watches this dudes videos like he's a real critic and not just some random who thinks he knows about music
Name a greater redemption arc
Me taking a shit and wiping it. That’s a better redemption arc then this bullshit
Faces is at least a strong 8. Personally, I give it a 10
Correct Ratings on Every Album:
KIDS: 7/10
Blue Slide Park: 5/10
Best Day Ever: 3/10
Macedelic: 5/10
Watching Movies With The Sound Off: 9/10
Faces: 10/10
GO:OD AM: 7/10
Devine Feminine: 8/10
Swimming: 10/10
Circles: 9/10
Out of curiosity what would you give kids
@@shivipivi 7-8/10. probably the best frat rap album of all time
Bro this is literally perfect you nailed it, circles is a 10 for me personally but everything else you got just right
Macadelic stay disrespected🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@Miho51307 im glad it exists because it led to watching movies but it really isnt an amazing album bro
Faces a 6 is bonkers. Deserves a 9-10
he gave it a redux, he gave it an 8
@ “all the best rappers are usually dead”
from 3 to 8 is crazy
Was finna crash out wen he gave swimming a 3
He didn't review Kids 💀
Anthony definitely just didn’t like Mac Miller. He gave KSI a 5 on his album and he gave swimming a 3 lol, you have to wonder how valid of an actual critic he is. I actually like Fantano I think he’s a dope person but maybe he’s out of his realm when it comes to hiphop
Did he change the swimming rating after his passing?
Yeah. Most people and critics will dickride any dead artist. That's sad imo, as artists should get their flowers while they can receive them
a lil reminder he gave sexy redd a 10-10
macadelic and faces are mixtapes the rest are albums but you can damn near put them in his discography and “of the soul” from bsp is such a great song the production and beat on that song is amazing but overall i think faces and go:od am is his best work. 💿 👼🏼
No way he only gave faces a 6? And macadelic a 2?? Wtf is he on
why would he rate The Divine Feminine and literally almost everything SO LOW. I get why people dislike his opinions.
Didn’t u give the divine feminine and macadlic both lower scores then blue slide park?
Ngl this guy has literally no idea what hes talking about, years later he gave faces an 8, and watching movies, swimming and the devine feminine are arguably some if his best work
bsp being a 5 is crazy with how low his other ratings are.
So majority of his a albums have the same or higher score than MBDTF lol good one Melon
How does Fantano regard Mac as one of the best white rappers of all time with these ratings? 🤔
Word schemes and lyrics and not much of a competition when people like em aren't putting out good or something decent and people like mgk and jack harlow, to name a few.
@@randomdude1747tbf his score clearly raised for multiple albums idk if any other white rapper he says has 4 good albums
@slowcookerhomeplanet4326 mac does those he doesn't view a 6 a bad and plus he said it was to a light 7 but I could see him appreciate the album and score it different after macs death but he gave mac around 5,7s or better
This guy consistently gives L takes and follows the hip LA trendy style. MID, MAC has always been focused on his beat with melodies. Fucking mid takes
trendy style? he likes Death Grips, Mac is mor trendy you just want to act like you're not plain
@@penguinwolf3330Fantano has the worst takes.
@@Timeforceletsgo But he is maaad respectable for actually looking at music in a higher scheme then people who give out 10s to people like drake or any music that they here and say that's good once and just consider it a 10 and not look at anything besides if it's a "BANGER" .
This nigga definitely got some of the worst takes in music
Dude became friends with NFR and switched up 😂😂😂😂
I really dislike the idea of reviewing music. I understand that on a technical level you can review and be correct on how some music is but at the end of the day sounds and words will always have a different effect on every person in the world and that’s the most beautiful part of it.
How does the inherent subjectivity of music and art in general cause reviewing at large to be a bad idea? A review is literally just expressing your own thoughts and feelings on an album, just in a more structured way than usual. It isn't about being "right" and it never has been.
Some of his fans on the other hand seem downright rabid. As soon as someone's opinion differs ever so slightly out of line with their own they go ballistic, like one person can't have a different opinion than others.
Anyways, seriously, no shade or Amy hing I just don't understand your point at all. Music reviews as a concept being bad due to subjectiveness just doesn't compute for me ig.
i can never forgive fantano for his initial circles rating. im acting like i care enough to hate fantano though.
This guy has no idea
Kids is his best album that’s a fact not an opinion!
its incredible how his opinion on everything is garbage lol
Fr I never listened to something like the Divine Feminine before and I appreciate very much just to give it a mediocre score
macadelic a 2/10 and the divine feminine a 4/10 is just wrong
he did not review kids, did he?
this comment can have a sencond meaning lol
Hack Miller - the pretentiousness was strong with this one
faces is definitely not a 6
What about DT
How the hell did the Devine feminine deserve a 4 😢
TDF a 4? He’s on something
0:26 Longthony Longtano
Hot take: he only changed he’s option on Swimming because mac Miller passed away
Took him a really long time to realize that he died then
He definitely didn't. He brought a lot of valid changed points on the redux and I think he's right.
What Mac was saying on swimming probably hit him harder after he passed as well. Rip Mac
Bro doesn’t want to watch the redux review
@@Testify087he did a video on that soon after his passing, the album grew on him naturally years later
bro give a 4 for The Divine Femenine 💀💀
Fantano doesn’t have integrity. You don’t jump from a 3 to an 8 because you are “enjoying it more these days.” He realized that his fans wanted a better score post- his passing.
0:10 WHAT THE FUCK
Macadelic 2 ?????????
Maclib is common out
My guy hates mac
divine feminine a 4?????
Lol Devine feminine is my favorite album of all time if not top three. I almost threw up when I heard that
circles is a 10
2/10 for Macadelic....wtf am i missing somethin? That mixtapes at least an 8 or higher
BIG L
Does anyone actually watch this guy?
Now I see why his wife left him
You are edgy
Faces an 11
He’s getting punched in the face on sight.
This is emberassing
This dude got some of the worst takes in music
Just bad takes man lol
i can’t believe people actually take his opinions seriously 😐🗑️
Better then people who give 10s out to everything.
@@randomdude1747 nah not really
@p0tionseIIer Nah those opinions suck you
He has decent takes. Music is subjective not everything you like will get a 10 and that’s ok 👍
I actually agree with his original swimming review.I love Mac Miller,but personally swimming and circles for the most part are not my thing.
Eww
Anthony is the worst music reviewer
Rolling Stones exist
LMAO