When Liu stabs herself at about 2:45 the choir starts singing the "parla, il nome" part, this is such a beautiful arrangement, if I'm correct the standard version is not pitched, choir is supposed to say those words in speaking voice, but this version adds so much to the drama, I get chills every time
This is surely a proof that interpretation matters so much! Having heard other versions from other sopranos (which technically may be even better) I think I'm in love with Mitchell's interpretation!
First time seeing this and I cannot stop crying. Madame's performance is captivating and so moving that it brought me to tears without knowing anything about the piece.
This has to be one of Thee BEST interpretations i've seen on youtube. Leona Mitchell does a fantastic job with aria... I felt every emotion she portrayed
Tu che di gel sei cinta Da tanta fiamma vinta L' amerai anche tu! L' amerai anche tu! Prima di quest' aurora Io chiudo stanca gli occhi Perche egli vinca ancora... Egli vinca ancora... Per non Per non vederlo piu! Prima di quest' aurora Di quest' aurora Io chiudo stanca gli occhi Per non vederlo piu!
I remember watching this on PBS and I was mesmerized by Ms. Mitchell's heavenly voice. She is by far my favorite "Liu" This was a top notch production and I loved the costumes!
Grazie Walter, di averci dato un altro brano cantato della americana Mitchell, una interprete meravigliosa di Liù, qui il suo debutto al Met. Conmoventi anche Domingo ed il splendido Plishka
Puccini was always in love in order to create. My husband and I visited his house in Italy. His life was written in an old notebook. There he told the whole world how much he had suffered because a Woman who worked with him committed suicide, because she loved him and, therefore without knowing the real relationship they have had, but it indeed was a tragic event in his life. I am truly sure that he wrote 2 Operas dedicating her a last good-bye. The Operas were: Madame Butterfly and Turandot.
In a DVD of great performances, this was Leona's 'night' as they say -- everything was as close to perfect for her as I've seen anywhere. She is so good, you really DO feel Timor's pain & confusion in his 'Sorgi' aria and as they carry her away...
YES, she was born to sing this role! I mean you forget that she is Leona Mitchell and totally immerse yourself in Liu's story. Extraordinary singing from one of the best to EVER do it!
That is SOOOO thrilling ! Two magnificent singers, perfect for this particular duet, singing their heart out ! Giacomini possessed a beautiful, very baritonal voice. Perhaps not ideal for the rest of the opera, which pictures Andrea as a youthful, sensitive man : think of Carreras, who sang (and recorded) the role at the very limit of his vocal power, but so moving and attractive, and of course of Corelli, the epitome of vocal sex-appeal. As for Eva Marton, she is here at her very best, and that is saying a lot.
Whew! I've been listening to different versions of Turandot and this clip gives me goosebumps. Mitchell is superb, Plishka is amazing, and the drama and emotion exuding from the cast is incomparable. I just ordered the DVD of the full performance!
What happened to her? She kind of dissappeared from the MET overnight (I think her last performance must have been around '93). But she was such a fine singer and the voice was still good shape 93......
Es tal la tensión que coge la música en esta escena que deja el corazón en un puño. Esta ópera es fantástica en todos los aspectos! La música, las melodías que utiliza, la orquestación, la instrumentación que usa (que no todo en la ópera son los cantantes, recuerdo que también hay una orquesta sin la cual sería imposible cualquier ópera), las arias y los números corales... Me llama la atención sobre todo el uso en esta ópera del saxofón y del xilófono en la orquesta. Increíble elenco por cierto.
Tu che di gel sei cinta Da tanta fiamma vinta L'amerai anche tu L'amerai anche tu! Prima di quest'aurora Io chiudo stanca gli occhi Perché egli vinca ancora Ei vinca ancora Per non Per non vederlo più! Prima di quest'aurora Di quest'aurora Io chiudo stanca gli occhi Per non vederlo più!
Incredible performance. She sings with such tenderness, conviction and humility that one cannot resist being moved to tears. Also acting and staging is completely natural with no contrived "pause" when Liu grabs the knife and stabs herself.
OH PERINI ROMANO ERA QUESTA LA ROMANZA CHE AVEVO SCELTO E CHE HO CANTATO QUEL GIORNO, RAMMENTI O DEVO MOSTRARTI QUEL REGISTRATORE, SI C' E' ANCHE IL NASTRO
Dragan Vidic Yes but Liù needs a voice that is lyric and has a dramatic thrust as well. Puccini’s Orchestration gets full at times and needs a voice that can soar over it. She’s the perfect voice for this role!!! She does better than “ the best she can” in this role and excels more than most here!!
@31122051, entonces lo correcto segun el gran bodiloto seria: 'canta meravigliosa ma alla americana'. Y digo yo, que significa 'alla americana'? Por que no escribe bodiloto un diccionario del bel canto y la lirica italiana? Seria un 'bombazo' editorial.
Inguaribile Romantico , she sounds spinto because that is what she is -a spinto soprano .I agree that this is not a typical sweet Liù , but just as great.Which of these Puccini roles is the hardest one to sing :Mimi , Musetta , Tosca , Butterfly or Liù?
Yes ,it is a very hard role.The only soprano I know that played both of them on stage is Caballé.But ,I do think that this role requires a dramatic ,not spinto soprano.Tosca is mostly played by spinto or dramatic soprano ,rarely lyric soprano.Mimi -lyric or spinto soprano Minnie -spinto or dramatic soprano Butterfly-lyric or spinto soprano Liù -lyric or spinto soprano Musetta-soubrette or lyric soprano
Teodora Pipin Liu is a very lyric role! As Mimi. But Puccini demand a spinto for climaxes in Butterfly and Manon Lescaut and Tosca. It's hard to find youthful voices with power for Mimi and Butterfly therefore often sung by spintos.
Maria La Divina always said that Puccini was hard on The Voice. And she was right was she ever wrong. Puccini wrote the most heartbreaking tearful operas. He had no equal never will. Toscanini knew him well. The last great composer. Eva Marton sang Turandot very well it was not perfect but in her prime she did a very good job. Dimitrova a true dramatic soprano also performed it's very well. I have both DVDs and you cannot compare greatness. Leona Mitchell had an incredible voice she sounded like leontyne price and Mirella freni. Who could ask for anything more. I agree she was not a lyric soprano but a lyrics spinto. Thank you for posting very much appreciated
@31122051 Hai veramente ragione carissimo amico!!! Conosco molto bene questa Turandot,ce l'ho in dvd e l'unico cantante che non mi piace in essa è il povero Simone Boccanegra per i suoi ACUTI FOLGORANTI. Troppo sprecato per una tessitura così centrale che al massimo arriva a Do sovracuto,lui poi è abituato a cantare anche fa e sol sovracuti, pensa un po'!!!Infatti ascoltati,da questa produzione,In questa reggia della Marton e vedi lui alla fine come la sovrasta facendo TARZAN!!!!!!!! Ciao ciao
Una de las mejores arias de la ópera turandot.. para mi Puccini en verdad supo representar el amor incondicional y verdadero. tanto asi incluso,dar la vida por el..( lastima que nunca sabremos que pasaría por la mente de el después de este acto.)
Too angry and "spinto"...I dont' get the sweetness and the vulnerability that a character like Liù requires, this is not Santuzza or Tosca, this is a humble slave dying for his loved, sharing her fragility!
You've got to be kidding me! Leona Mitchell and awful DO NOT go in the same sentence! She owns this role..and there is NO one else who sings it like "THIS"!
bella voce e bella interpretazione..
Definitely one of the best performances of Tu che di gel sei cinta " I've ever heard pierces the Soul.....
listening to her I get chills and tears! If I were Calaf I'd go with her
@@claudiokutufa589 But no! He had to go with the princess!
What a jerk!
When Liu stabs herself at about 2:45 the choir starts singing the "parla, il nome" part, this is such a beautiful arrangement, if I'm correct the standard version is not pitched, choir is supposed to say those words in speaking voice, but this version adds so much to the drama, I get chills every time
She is the best Liu for me. I love her voice, the acting, everything!!!
Sorry, I have to disagree, but I respect your opinion, I think Caballé is better in my opinion
Video wise, yes, she is the best
@@whovian1591 Totally I gree
This is surely a proof that interpretation matters so much! Having heard other versions from other sopranos (which technically may be even better) I think I'm in love with Mitchell's interpretation!
What an amazing performance. Everything is perfect, even the chorus and the orchestra!
She really captures the character! Her voice is amazing! Well done, miss Mitchel!
this is the best version of the aria/ cannot stop crying and admiring miss Mitchel in this role.
First time seeing this and I cannot stop crying. Madame's performance is captivating and so moving that it brought me to tears without knowing anything about the piece.
Absolutely stunning. I saw Mitchell sing Liu in the mid 1970's in San Francisco with Pavarotti and Caballe.
This has to be one of Thee BEST interpretations i've seen on youtube. Leona Mitchell does a fantastic job with aria... I felt every emotion she portrayed
Puccini man! I can't handle him sometimes times. It's just too good!
Lovely, nostalgic aria, so well sang. Maravigloso.
Tu che di gel sei cinta
Da tanta fiamma vinta
L' amerai anche tu!
L' amerai anche tu!
Prima di quest' aurora
Io chiudo stanca gli occhi
Perche egli vinca ancora...
Egli vinca ancora...
Per non
Per non vederlo piu!
Prima di quest' aurora
Di quest' aurora
Io chiudo stanca gli occhi
Per non vederlo piu!
Fantastic scene - fantastic interpretation, . I have listen it 1000 times, and it keeps me crying...
"Cansada cerraré los ojos para no verlos más...." .ALGÚN DÍA ASÍ SERÁ.
Hermoso.
her ending is really special, very sudden and determined
I remember watching this on PBS and I was mesmerized by Ms. Mitchell's heavenly voice.
She is by far my favorite "Liu" This was a top notch production and I loved the costumes!
oh my god!! Leona!! ..amaaaazing!!!
Thank you for uploading! My favorite performance of my favorite song in Turandot#
Grazie Walter, di averci dato un altro brano cantato della americana Mitchell, una interprete meravigliosa di Liù, qui il suo debutto al Met. Conmoventi anche Domingo ed il splendido Plishka
This performance is simply breathtaking.
What a cast, epic production! (RIP maestro Zeffirelli)
One of my most favorite performances of this aria! Magnificent!
She is one of the Best Liu's of all time!! Simply amazing!
Mi mancavano tanto le bellissime voci postate da te. Grazie, Walter.
Great Liu! great performance !
Leona Mitchell is wonderful!
Leontyne and Leona own this aria/role. Yes, two people can own something together! :)
This feels very genuine coming from her soul... and very beautiful
She is amazing!
Puccini was always in love in order to create. My husband and I visited his house in Italy. His life was written in an old notebook. There he told the whole world how much he had suffered because a Woman who worked with him committed suicide, because she loved him and, therefore without knowing the real relationship they have had, but it indeed was a tragic event in his life. I am truly sure that he wrote 2 Operas dedicating her a last good-bye. The Operas were: Madame Butterfly and Turandot.
Esta interpretación es hermosa!!!
Superb 💙
In a DVD of great performances, this was Leona's 'night' as they say -- everything was as close to perfect for her as I've seen anywhere. She is so good, you really DO feel Timor's pain & confusion in his 'Sorgi' aria and as they carry her away...
Probably, the best Liù I've heard so far.
Grazie, Walter.
YES, she was born to sing this role! I mean you forget that she is Leona Mitchell and totally immerse yourself in Liu's story. Extraordinary singing from one of the best to EVER do it!
So nostalgic, yet so lovely.
was fortunate to see Ms. Mitchell live in Orlando--FL what a joy it was and I shall always remember that glorious and passionate performance---
Puccini's final gift to the world
Mamma Mia un soprano di una voce Bellissima mamma mia
What a beautiful voice!
Incredibly amazing! such wonderful performance! !
What an amazing performance!
perfecta!! simplemente perfecta!!!!!!
I'm practicing this song...is amazing!!
I just fell in love wth it!!
普契尼《杜蘭朵公主》
抒情女高音 Liu (柳兒) ：
“Tu che di gel sei cinta”(公主你冰冷的心)
That is SOOOO thrilling ! Two magnificent singers, perfect for this particular duet, singing their heart out ! Giacomini possessed a beautiful, very baritonal voice. Perhaps not ideal for the rest of the opera, which pictures Andrea as a youthful, sensitive man : think of Carreras, who sang (and recorded) the role at the very limit of his vocal power, but so moving and attractive, and of course of Corelli, the epitome of vocal sex-appeal. As for Eva Marton, she is here at her very best, and that is saying a lot.
this is so beautiful
Never heard this role sung better!! Brava Leona!
😢 qué intensidad en la interpretación....me he puesto a llorar
Whew! I've been listening to different versions of Turandot and this clip gives me goosebumps. Mitchell is superb, Plishka is amazing, and the drama and emotion exuding from the cast is incomparable. I just ordered the DVD of the full performance!
Such a great Liu.
So poignant and lovely ❤
What happened to her? She kind of dissappeared from the MET overnight (I think her last performance must have been around '93). But she was such a fine singer and the voice was still good shape 93......
Extraordinaire scène du suicide de Liu ! Leona Mitchell y est magnifique. Bravo et merci…
The best Liù
I would never kill myself over a man. Especially if I could sing that well.
Haha 😂😂😂😂
Who cares?
@@PaterEcstaticus888 I care
@@esterbruno8604 And why do I care?
@@PaterEcstaticus888 Maybe you don't care, but i am 😉
My heart is breaking...
hermosa interpretacion
Lovely, nostalbic, emotional.
Es tal la tensión que coge la música en esta escena que deja el corazón en un puño. Esta ópera es fantástica en todos los aspectos! La música, las melodías que utiliza, la orquestación, la instrumentación que usa (que no todo en la ópera son los cantantes, recuerdo que también hay una orquesta sin la cual sería imposible cualquier ópera), las arias y los números corales...
Me llama la atención sobre todo el uso en esta ópera del saxofón y del xilófono en la orquesta.
Increíble elenco por cierto.
Maravilhosa Ópera, Cena, Interpretação, Figurino, Cenário, Orquestra, Vozes...
Maravillosa Aria
Best Version EVER!
I started crying from the first chords...
Is so good❤️😭
brilliant!!!!
Bravísimo
puccini no pudo soportar haber matado a su pequeña Liu
Tu che di gel sei cinta
Da tanta fiamma vinta
L'amerai anche tu
L'amerai anche tu!
Prima di quest'aurora
Io chiudo stanca gli occhi
Perché egli vinca ancora
Ei vinca ancora
Per non
Per non vederlo più!
Prima di quest'aurora
Di quest'aurora
Io chiudo stanca gli occhi
Per non vederlo più!
This interpretation and Millo's ruled for me in this era.
he's one of the palace's 3 head chiefs...the other two are named pong and pang :)
Incredible performance. She sings with such tenderness, conviction and humility that one cannot resist being moved to tears. Also acting and staging is completely natural with no contrived "pause" when Liu grabs the knife and stabs herself.
Bellissime interpretazioni! Ma nascera mai piu' un ' altro gigante come puccini! Noi italiani come musicisti siamo ineguagliabili
manifique bravo !
Insuperabile interpretazione! Bravissimi !
Chills everywhere.
Turandot per me è l'opera più bella di Puccini e mi pare che questa è un'ottima edizione
È veramente l'opera più bella. Sono perfettamente d'accordo. Brava Luisa ( come sempre)
Ascoltare questo canto è come salire verso l'infinito e la con le stelle. Puma
OH PERINI ROMANO ERA QUESTA LA ROMANZA CHE AVEVO SCELTO E CHE HO CANTATO QUEL GIORNO, RAMMENTI O DEVO MOSTRARTI QUEL REGISTRATORE, SI C' E' ANCHE IL NASTRO
Mitchell is the only one that surpasses the great Moffo in this role.
Viva l'Opera Italiana! 🇮🇹
She does really the best she can!
Magnificent although more of a spinto imo. She sang Turandot later in her career.
Dragan Vidic
Yes but Liù needs a voice that is lyric and has a dramatic thrust as well. Puccini’s Orchestration gets full at times and needs a voice that can soar over it. She’s the perfect voice for this role!!! She does better than “ the best she can” in this role and excels more than most here!!
FACTS!!!
@31122051, entonces lo correcto segun el gran bodiloto seria: 'canta meravigliosa ma alla americana'. Y digo yo, que significa 'alla americana'? Por que no escribe bodiloto un diccionario del bel canto y la lirica italiana? Seria un 'bombazo' editorial.
Per non ve der lo piu e respiri derl no anche no....😢
Inguaribile Romantico , she sounds spinto because that is what she is -a spinto soprano .I agree that this is not a typical sweet Liù , but just as great.Which of these Puccini roles is the hardest one to sing :Mimi , Musetta , Tosca , Butterfly or Liù?
Mimi is the easiest...Tosca and Liù are the hardest...
Yes ,it is a very hard role.The only soprano I know that played both of them on stage is Caballé.But ,I do think that this role requires a dramatic ,not spinto soprano.Tosca is mostly played by spinto or dramatic soprano ,rarely lyric soprano.Mimi -lyric or spinto soprano
Minnie -spinto or dramatic soprano
Butterfly-lyric or spinto soprano
Liù -lyric or spinto soprano
Musetta-soubrette or lyric soprano
Teodora Pipin Liu is a very lyric role!
As Mimi. But Puccini demand a spinto for climaxes in Butterfly and Manon Lescaut and Tosca. It's hard to find youthful voices with power for Mimi and Butterfly therefore often sung by spintos.
Maria La Divina always said that Puccini was hard on The Voice. And she was right was she ever wrong. Puccini wrote the most heartbreaking tearful operas. He had no equal never will. Toscanini knew him well. The last great composer. Eva Marton sang Turandot very well it was not perfect but in her prime she did a very good job. Dimitrova a true dramatic soprano also performed it's very well. I have both DVDs and you cannot compare greatness. Leona Mitchell had an incredible voice she sounded like leontyne price and Mirella freni. Who could ask for anything more. I agree she was not a lyric soprano but a lyrics spinto. Thank you for posting very much appreciated
I think Tosca is the hardest. And Turandot. Very hard.
Devo VONSULTARE I CLEMENTONI,???SI STO PARLANDO DEI DUE FRATELLI MIRANDA ED ENNIO
@31122051 Hai veramente ragione carissimo amico!!! Conosco molto bene questa Turandot,ce l'ho in dvd e l'unico cantante che non mi piace in essa è il povero Simone Boccanegra per i suoi ACUTI FOLGORANTI. Troppo sprecato per una tessitura così centrale che al massimo arriva a Do sovracuto,lui poi è abituato a cantare anche fa e sol sovracuti, pensa un po'!!!Infatti ascoltati,da questa produzione,In questa reggia della Marton e vedi lui alla fine come la sovrasta facendo TARZAN!!!!!!!! Ciao ciao
Una de las mejores arias de la ópera turandot.. para mi Puccini en verdad supo representar el amor incondicional y verdadero. tanto asi incluso,dar la vida por el..( lastima que nunca sabremos que pasaría por la mente de el después de este acto.)
MAGARI DEVO RAMMENTARVI LA CONTESSA SCUDERI IN LUNGOTEVERE DEI MELLINI N.22
Ahora las mujeres se mueren tomando selfies. True Story
Verdad !!!
DANIEL 10:18 o cuando las dejan en visto... 😒
Sunshine Sunashi
¡O como aquella pendeja del Facebook.!
Pobre Liu
perché non chiami ti prego Antonello rondi UA-cam
CONSULTARE
lol wut
Too angry and "spinto"...I dont' get the sweetness and the vulnerability that a character like Liù requires, this is not Santuzza or Tosca, this is a humble slave dying for his loved, sharing her fragility!
Just awful. Sounds like a mother, not a girl.
You've got to be kidding me! Leona Mitchell and awful DO NOT go in the same sentence! She owns this role..and there is NO one else who sings it like "THIS"!
Struggende
The best Liú