Al salam alekom shaykh. I had to take a moment to say you are so well spoken and so knowledgable. Thank you for this eye opening and interesting talk I enjoyed it profoundly. Greetings from Egypt.
Singing spirituals helped to save my people during slavery. The hidden messages in the music that they sang informed them when the time was ripe to escape and whether or not slave catchers were in the area. I have been a Muslim for sixty years. I’m 71. I chose Islam for myself and was the second in my family to do so. I cannot imagine not being able to listen or sing or share with my friends songs of praise to Allah; and, truth be told, I love other forms of music as well and cannot imagine a world without it. Emma Goldman once famously said, regarding the Russian Revolution, “If I can’t dance, it’s not my revolution.” I believe that if 18:31 I couldn’t sing or listen to the music that helped to save my people, I know that I’d never have considered Islam.
Please don't change islam. Thats extremely disrespectful to us and our ancestors. If you think islam is not your thing, you can always leave, but it's extremely inconsiderate to change our religion or tell us to change our religion because you and your ancestors like it. Music was always haram in islam and always will be.
@@Fatex199 Please don't watch and comment about intelligent, well-thought-out discussions about detailed and nuanced issues in the Deen. This is disrespectful to our intelligent ancestors. If you think intelligence is not your thing, you can always continue in your simple life and have complete fulfillment through ignorance. But it is extremely inconsiderate to interrupt intelligent conversations with such statements just because you or your ancestors couldn't understand the video. Thoughtfulness has always been wajib in intelligence and always will be. Thank you.
@@MuslimInAbby Because I believe music is haram, you believe I am: disrespecting your ancestors, not intelligent, lives a simple life( this one is true), ignorant, inconsiderate,my ancestors are stupid and I don't even think. Try your best but we will not sit and let you guys make music halal. Not happening. We will resist.
I converted to Islam and didn't know about the music issue until a few months after taking my Shahada. Needless to say I had a hard time wrapping my head around music being Haraam, and the more scholars I talk to the more I understand it's more of a mainstream belief. I still listen to music but much more selective about what comes to my ears Mash'Allah
@@danyalm. Just Use Logic & have Self-Control. Easy Example, Pen or Tie can be use in a Good & Bad way. Fictional Book or Biography Book or Crime Recordings & Videos (on SocMeds or TV) or even Any Video Documentaries & many more. If we don't Control ourselves, We Will Deeply put those Words & Stories that No Matter What, bring more Negativity like Fear, Visual Trauma, Any Forms of Hallucinations, Sadness, Loneliness, Irrational Hate, Less Confidence, Trust Issues, etc. LIFE is a Test, that Self-Control is Always Everywhere in Everything. Fanatic in Anything is never a Good thing even if it's just Writing or Cooking.
@@danyalm. Be Careful of Sects. They're Heavily PoIiticaIy Involved. Whether it's Foods, Medicines, Entertainment, Sports, Education, etc., in Modern Era Heavily Control by GIobaIsts. If you pay attention to PLSTN Topic, I suggest you to also Search about Z[0N]SM. Always Check Every Aspects to Understand World & ReIigi0ns & Society Better. So you will understand why this and that happened or why it's become like this & that.
@@danyalm. I'm AIhamduIiIIah a MvsIim as well and live in the BGGST MvsIim PopvIation. There are 5 reIigi0ns here & so many Sects & CuIts in all 5. We're all here need to be careful, or else, we could fill ourselves with Irrational Hate, Unreasonable Dislike. *From Anyone especially Public Figures Anywhere, *Always Take a Good Fruits & Left The Bad Fruits. Any Education & Information, Always Logic & Try Find Sense. Never Praise or Rely on Anyone Deeply. That will easily Mislead you.*
@@danyalm. I hope you get to read 3 Replies I wrote for you. My comments usually got auto-deleted even when there's no cvrsing or thrts. My Govt also have Many Words that Cens0rd that only local can see, or only international can see, or no one except Me that can see.
To say HRM Not Logic especially Nothing in AI-Qvr'an have Clear Messages about it. Our Breath alone is Sound Frequency & Melody, Our Movements & Body alone is Instruments, Our Words and what we heard alone are also Words that have the same Character with Lyrics. Just Enjoy WITH SELF-CONTROL, also WITHOUT Using it to Negatively Impacting Your Character & Thinking.
Do you know what frequences are used now. Name 1 person who can enjoy quran and at the same time be a listener of music or ang scholar who did that in the past.
I am a practicing muslim. Music can not at all be haram or considered haram or sinful to listen to in Islam. GOD LOVES beauty. HE IS THE CREATOR OF BEAUTY in nature all around us..nature is not mute but full of sounds..of sea waves, sound of wind, sound of tree leaves moved by wind, birds chirrping or doves cooing.. the universe is not silent and had GOD wanted human beings not to listen to or enjoy music HE WOULD NOT HAVE CREATED our ears ! It is a crime or rather a sin if we deprive our ears of what is also nourishment for our souls. GOD IS PEACE AND LIGHT . HE LOVES BEAUTY and it is an insult to Islam to assume or believe what anyone wants us to deny using as a gift : our ears and ability to hear , to hear what is beautiful !
مَا أَحَلَّ اللهُ فِيْ كِتَابِهِ فَهُوَ حَلاَلٌ، وَمَا حَرَّمَ فَهُوَ حَرَامٌ، وَمَا سَكَتَ عَنْهُ فَهُوَ عَافِيَةٌ، فَاقْبَلُوْا مِنَ اللهِ الْعَافِيَةَ، فَإِنَّ اللهَ لَمْ يَكُنْ نَسِيًّا، ثُمَّ تَلاَ هَذِهِ الآية: وَمَا كَانَ رَبُّكَ نَسِيّٗا _Whatever Allah has permitted in His Book is lawful, whatever He has forbidden is forbidden, and whatever He has remained silent about is permissible. So accept Allah’s forgiveness, for Allah is not forgetful. Then he recited this verse: Maryam 19:64 ... and never is your Lord forgetful_ Hadith narrated by Al-Hakim, 2/375, considered as hasan (good) by Al-Albani in Ghaayatul Maraam, p. 14. if you find a verse stating music is haram in quran then it is haram. if you can't find one, don't play god with music
Objectively speaking, "Music" is just a vibration of air which has certain patterns that we find it enjoyable. This is how audio is being inscribed into a vinyl discs, that very vibrations across the specified time. It's a very wide category, on the other side you have birds who can play "Music" by their chirpings which can soothe our morning, meanwhile on the other opposite side it can be intoxicating to our mind like what they do in Rock concerts where people can literally lose their minds in a mosh pit. The purring of a cat can also be considered as a music to our ears, and this particular vibrations emitted by a cat's purr can lower blood pressure, lessen stress, and even promote healing. Music is just a vibration of air within specified frequency ranges of 20 Hz to 20 kHz that has certain patterns that we find it pleasing to our ears. If you go beyond that frequency we can't hear it, and if it doesn't have any pattern then it's just a noise. Certain frequency music has been known contributes reducing tension and anxiety, according to National Institute of Health. It is the content that matters. I think it is unwise to blanket wrap them all as a prohibition. But in the end this is just my opinion, Allah swt knows best.
What kind of secular-atheist-derived ruling point of view is this? ‘Music is just a vibration of air’? So by that logic, humans are just atoms moving around-so killing and bringing destruction would simply be atoms moving too? Akhi, you need to reconsider what you’re allowing into your intellect (Aql) right now. Go back to the Book of Allah and the explanations of the scholars. This is a sincere piece of advice.
Natural sound like a cat purring, and then artificially created tunes are not within the same group of sounds. The prophet (peace be upon him) has prohibited music for general uses as far as I am aware. This is supported by Sahih Bukhari 5590 If you have any evidences from the Quran or Sunnah to support your beliefs, then state them; otherwise it should be assumed that your beliefs are non-Islamic, and likely derived from desire; which is even more so likely to be true if you reject clear evidences in favour of your thoughts and feelings.
This materialistic perspective offers nothing whatsoever to a conversation on morality. Although the fancy words may satisfy your pride, they are a non-contribution to the discussion. Allah knows best
Something worrying I noticed is that I did not see *any* dalil from our religious sources (Quran, Hadith, statements from scholars), but rather it was *all* your opinion. I do think that your reasoning fails but I'm not going to go into that - what I am more concerned about is the fact that these days, random laymen feel as if they can generate fatawa based on nothing but their feelings. I advise you to repent to Allah for speaking about His din without any knowledge. You have no right to do that.
More like we just enjoy it With Control on Ourselves, Without Letting Our Selves be Someone Else. Like Depressed, Hateful, Anger, Sad, Pessimistic. Let it just be Sounds just like we hear the voice of TV or people speaking in public.
It's not a video on Fiqh. Their is no "ruling" on music in Islam, there is simply a dialect of tension in the scholarly tradition. That's the point of this lecture... use your own discretion. Allah gave you ears and an intellect. Protect your ears from what may enter your heart. If you personally find a piece of music as beneficial and enjoyable, then continue to benefit from it. If not, then discard it. Simple.
Yes, true. AIIah SWT is The Creator that Not Hypocrite. And to say that it's HRM means Not Logical. The Fact, that it's Propaganda Fights between GIobaIists Versus People with ReIigi0n especially actually CHRSTNs. Because GIobaIists Pushed Psychological Pressure like Negative Affirmative & Satanism Artsy through Mvsic (Clips, Stages, Lyrics). They Want People to be used to Those STNC vibes & Depression, while Away with identity as CHRSTN. Here Some Sects of MSLMs, take a piece of cake with many different Reasons, but Wrong Way to Educate. Whether it's Melody, Lyrics, Instruments, Sound Frequency, None Of These are Logic & Sense to say that Mvsic is HRM. Because We All Surrounded by Melody & Sound Frequency Everyday Everywhere, Anything Around Us even our Fingers can be Instruments as it has Sounds. And There are So Many Scary or even Negative Words in News, Magazine, Any Books, Poetry, Ads, Anywhere. Even out AI-Qvr'an have some Talks about HeII and many scary things to teach us and guide us.
Our trueself we are only the spirit. Souls are still mind Mind is knowledge Spirit is BEAUTY, BLISS, LOVE, INTUITION, THE TRUE NAMES (SOUNDS), it always hears and listens, never talks like the mind. We listen first then we see,, we never see first, then listens.. Sounds created light, not light created sounds
Our attention not suppose to go to the music, but trying putting the attention to a single note sound, example putting attention to the drum in the music, or putting attention to the guitar in the music..
amazing lecture. but i need to point out a very important matter regarding modern music. If anyone can research how we TUNE our instruments in modern days, A=440hz, is not at all like how all humanity used to tune their instruments. there is a conspiracy about how they changed the frequencies so it affects us in a negative way. 440 promotes individuality, it is the opposite of integrity and if compared to 432hz for instance, is exactly the opposite. what i want to point out here, is that we need to check what music we listen to , not only based on the intention of this piece of music (belly dancing or promoting sins), but also how this music is affecting us on higher level. there is a lot about this subject, so thats why i encourage you brothers and sisters, to research why we were forced to switch to 440hz, and also if they embed malevolent "binaural beats" in popular songs....
Elhamdulillah brother winters, this is so needed as very talented brothers on u tube do dava but are tunnel visioned and for the life of me l can't imagine such talented muslims have no idea that music is a complex discussion as one cannot bag music into a black bag and cast it as it were to a corner, the universe hums, in music, our blood pulses music,our hearts spiral upwards with music our humanness is musical, Allahu Teala gave us gifts that are immeasurable, how then would Allahu Teala deprive creation of intrinsically wonderous beauty that sounds form in and around us,righteous people are supposed to understand evil and good,music is energy which can be channelled to create evil effects, this is the same with technology, sounds simple yet talented muslims are tunnel visioned and this is alarming as it causes divisions in the umma,thank you brother muad for discussing this subject
Brother murad l can easily imagine music having shape and colour and tones are are not unlike colour tones, just as paintings have an effect on our senses when we take in the consideration of colours applied to a particular art work, so every thing in universe is intertwined with supreme perfection Allahu Teala has imbued in to creation, everything is given it's perfect balance and value measure Allahu Teala is our lord how could we think of deficiency when we see immeasurable perfection that stares at us at every moment
I love 💗 Islam ☪️ but I’m a music major piano 🎹 n my two dogs are my boys 🐕 I’m American so I gotta understand cultures are gonna vary n I still might go to church ⛪️
MIND was preventing humanity to go within to understand the real revealations of sounds. Mind kept humanity trapped life after life in it s 3 realms, and became slaves to Deaths.. mind told humanity to pay more attention to goodness n badness related topics, but did not told humanity that there is something called becoming a slave to DEATHS ALWAYS life after life
To understand becoming a slave to deaths always, first of all revelations suppose to come directly from God with no in between help of Angels, only tru the 100th names
Hadith from Sahih al-Bukhari (No. 5590 - Mu’allaq Hadith) The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said: “There will be among my Ummah people who will regard as permissible (halal) fornication (zina), the wearing of silk (for men), wine (khamr), and musical instruments (ma‘āzif).” (Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-Ashriba, Hadith No. 5590 - Mu‘allaq form)
We shouldn't be so harshly critical of those that we perceive as "Haram Police", even if at times they are wrong. They also help to keep us in check, and review our actions. We should be more cautious of those that rubber stamp everything as "Halal".
@@scarfaceyam145 Quran and Sunnah. Quran says little to nothing about Music directly. Sunnah has examples of it being allowable. So it's not so easy as all Haram or all Halal. Which I'm sure the speaker covered in their long talk.
@@scarfaceyam145 Whenever those who say Music is Haram, they say all the imams considered it as Haram which is a big lie. When it comes to Islam, its ALLAH declares Haram and Halal. Ask them did ALLAH say it’s haram? You will see that they get hesitated . I can clearly say there are no verses which prohibits Music or instruments in the Quran. There are hadiths which allowed Music in even with instruments. 👇🏻 . Hadiths narrated by Aisha(ra) where prophet SA allowed instrumental music in his own house. - Sahih Bukhari 987, 3931, 949, 952. Sahih Muslim 892b, etc. * Prophet(SA) compares the rhythmic recitation of Quran of his companion to the rhythmic music of Flutes - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, 1087. * Prophet SA invited wedding singers to a wedding function - Sunan Ibn Majah 1900 * Prophet SA accepted the invitation by a slave girl for listening to her music - Tirmidhi 3690 Just because some scholars said it’s haram doesn’t make anything haram in Islam. Truth will always be clear! Nobody can hide the truth, it will reveal itself.
I choose blindly follow Prophet ﷺ and all his companions and all the companions children children's until the 4 imam madhab from the 4 schools of thoughts. Music remains Haram permissible. Who are you to tell me music is Halal? We also know that sufism doesn't have a quality and qualified scholar and ulama can be follow as a madhab or school of thought. When, your thoughts is not worthy to compare with 1 of Imam madhab. What if the four say haram? If above their knowledge, they are also companions. If they hear you say this, you will definitely be scourged😅
My guy. You're being disrespectful to someone who is a better Muslim than you. I'm saying he is better based in the judgement of your comment. Carry yourself better. What you said may be right but how you said it was just rude.
@@AbuSabak77 There was never a blank prohibition or permisbiltiy on music before and there are hadiths of the prophet allowing music especially those with duff and singing. I recommend you read the Fatwa of the Grand Mufti of Al-Azhar about music published in 1980.
@@daee121 Hadith from Sahih al-Bukhari (No. 5590 - Mu’allaq Hadith) The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said: “There will be among my Ummah people who will regard as permissible (halal) fornication (zina), the wearing of silk (for men), wine (khamr), and musical instruments (ma‘āzif).” (Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-Ashriba, Hadith No. 5590 - Mu‘allaq form)
I implore muslims to listen to people like Abdal Hakim Murad and not the angry and arrogant 'dawah' people like Mohammed Hijab, who has now embraced Andrew Tate!
@@danalmariti509 Abdal Hakim Murad has himself said that such people should be avoided. Through Jordan Peterson M. Hijab has become well known and he must have put so many right thinking people off Islam forever, including Mr Peterson. The ummah needs to do more to criticise such arrogant interlopers
@@danalmariti509so facts are now bad? A fact is a fact. It could either be good or bad. And your claim has no basis because Hijab openly, and might I say enthusiastically, displays his deeds to the public. Many of todays “dawah” men are pompous and arrogant. Showcasing attitudes and behaviors that have no place in Islam. Let alone a public stage.
@madjackmcjock of Abdulhakim Murad talking about one of his controversial takes? Spare me a lifespan. You guys think hes knowledgeable cos he Oxford and speaks with some decent tajweed lol.
Majority of religions this days their revealations are not coming directly from God, they are using in-between help of angels, when you use angels you fall into traps of MIND AND TIME
The 99 are for the mind, not the spirit. Spirit our trueself needs the 100th names, full revealations as it s food. This 100th names, are 5 selected sounds.. Speech of God are uncreated exist as sounds. Duty of founder of religion are suppose to revealed this 100th names..
Yes we understand sounds from the outside first, but finally everything is within in dhikr. Understanding what are DUALITY sounds first, when two things hits together, from here it takes you to the final sound, the soundless sound, where DUALITY CEASES.. islam are afraid to talk bout this things, because they already placed it at Akhirat, to be known at that time. Actually this are now now, to be known within now. Humanity rites to know the real Names now, now and now..
This lecture should not be misunderstood to say music is halal. Most of the lecture was about non-instrumental music, and when the Shaykh spoke of instrumental music he was very clear on what he did say.
The full revealations of the 100th Names will take you ultimately in unity with God. But this considered Syirik in islam to unite with God. For this reasons the truth was thrown in akhirat s dustbin.. at the moment islam more interested in KNOWING GOD ONLY, BUT NOT UNITY.. but islam does not know by knowing, separation n deaths is always there, not freed yet
@@santinolowe7225 Am I saying anything, saying that those who say music is haraam blindly without any evidence, they have strong opinions and many people say that music is bad. Some of the following are the words of the Salaf scholars regarding singing (music) Ibn Mas'ud said: "Singing grows hypocrisy in the heart as water grows vegetables." Al Qasim ibn Muhammad was asked about singing, and he replied: "I forbid singing to you and I hate it when you hear it." Then the questioner said, "Is singing haram?" Al Qasim said, "O son of my brother, if Allah has separated the right from the wrong, then where does Allah put 'singing'?" 'Umar ibn 'Abdul Aziz once wrote a letter to a teacher who taught his children, saying, "Let the first thing my children learn from your character be your hatred of singing. For it comes from the devil and its end is the wrath of Allah. I know from reliable scholars that listening to singing and musical instruments and being enamoured of them will only grow hypocrisy in the heart as water grows grass. By Allah, abstaining from singing is actually easier for a person of intelligence than having hypocrisy entrenched in the heart." Fudhail ibn Iyadh said, "Singing is the incantation of adultery." Adh Dhohak said, "Singing corrupts the heart and incurs the wrath of Allah." Yazid ibn Al Walid said, "O my son, beware of listening to singing for it only inflames lust, lowers self-esteem, and even takes the place of liquor which makes you drunk. ... Know that singing is an incentive to commit adultery." If you disagree, then speak well and show your evidence, saying that people who say music is haram are spiritually dead is very arrogant and outrageous.
@@santinolowe7225 Am I saying anything, saying that those who say music is haraam blindly without any evidence, they have strong opinions and many people say that music is bad. Some of the following are the words of the Salaf scholars regarding singing (music) Ibn Mas'ud said: "Singing grows hypocrisy in the heart as water grows vegetables." Al Qasim ibn Muhammad was asked about singing, and he replied: "I forbid singing to you and I hate it when you hear it." Then the questioner said, "Is singing haram?" Al Qasim said, "O son of my brother, if Allah has separated the right from the wrong, then where does Allah put 'singing'?" 'Umar ibn 'Abdul Aziz once wrote a letter to a teacher who taught his children, saying, "Let the first thing my children learn from your character be your hatred of singing. For it comes from the devil and its end is the wrath of Allah. I know from reliable scholars that listening to singing and musical instruments and being enamoured of them will only grow hypocrisy in the heart as water grows grass. By Allah, abstaining from singing is actually easier for a person of intelligence than having hypocrisy entrenched in the heart." Fudhail ibn Iyadh said, "Singing is the incantation of adultery." Adh Dhohak said, "Singing corrupts the heart and incurs the wrath of Allah." Yazid ibn Al Walid said, "O my son, beware of listening to singing for it only inflames lust, lowers self-esteem, and even takes the place of liquor which makes you drunk. ... Know that singing is an incentive to commit adultery." If you disagree, then speak well and show your evidence, saying that people who say music is haram are spiritually dead is very arrogant and outrageous.
@@santinolowe7225 Am I saying anything, saying that those who say music is haraam blindly without any evidence, they have strong opinions and many people say that music is bad. If you disagree, then speak well and show your evidence, saying that people who say music is haram are spiritually dead is very arrogant and outrageous.
he said rarely people are tone deaf.... i hear some of yall trying yalls hardest to match some sort of pitch on the "amin" at the end of Fatihah during salat.... 🤣
27 min into the lecture, still no fiqhi discussion about music. I gave up. And yes, sound does have a profound effect on human beings. Listening to Dr. Murad puts me to sleep (in a good way).
You want to learn about fiqh, listen to real Muslim, Arabic speaking scholars. Reverts tend to bring a heavy package with them from their previous lives.
@@OmarBenjumea"any instrumental" you forget the people of Madinah used music to welcome the Prophet Muhammad SAW when he arrived in the city. The people sang and played instruments to express their joy.
ua-cam.com/users/livesBDnlxGmuaw?si=YzJV2tyR_RlN1V7o 1 hour, 11 minutes of this video, ibnu tamiyyah did mention the uncreated speech of God, are the sounds.. It is the responsibility of founders of religions to revealed this selected sounds, upgrade them as NAMES, THE 100TH NAMES. but sadly not revealed in islam. Only sound of bells are mentioned, balance are thrown into end of time, akhirat s dustbin
As a Prophet Muhammad wasn't protected hence in Quran Allah admonishes Muhammad as referring to him as Nabi ( not Messenger) why do you make Haraam what Allah has made Halaal,,,, Muhammad was protected as a Messenger i.e the message he brought (Qur'an )was intact without error,, but as a prophet he was left to his own devices like us all , we make mistakes and learn from them ,,, Music or any other device becomes disliked when its used in the negative way like nuclear energy is clean but making a bomb from it is negative ,,, a knife helps cut food but can also be used to unalive people does that mean it should be banned,,, of course not the benefits out way the harms ,, so music that promotes a certain behavior or dumbs people shouldn't be encouraged but to ban music because someone mistranslated what Muhammad said shouldn't be a law as clearly the verses on gambling and intoxication couldn't music of been slipt into that verse ,,,
Actually music is unwelcome because it resonate all the time at one's mind, who listen or do it, even at the time of prayer. It's an instrument of Satan to divert peoples from rememberence of Allah.
what an evil way to think. you are responsible for your own sins and what occupies your own mind. leave iblees out of it. if youre listening to evil music perhaps listen to something positive
It’s Haram ..and Allah made it so as a test , just like eating pork is pleasing to some people , listening to music pleases the ear, and so this is a test are you gonna listen to your desires or are you gonna obey Allah..
@ what you watch on UA-cam can be haram yes , not UA-cam itself Propagating Islamic knowledge or learning about it on UA-cam would actually earn you hasanaat
@@myguybru I already explained it above …and as a Muslim for you to mock and make light of Allah’s tests says a lot … 29:2) Do people think that they will be let go merely by saying: “We believe,” and that they will not be tested,1 (29:3) for We indeed tested those who went before them? Allah will most certainly ascertain3 those who spoke the truth and those who lied. 1.
Whenever those who say Music is Haram, they say all the imams considered it as Haram which is a big lie. When it comes to Islam, its ALLAH declares Haram and Halal. Ask them did ALLAH say it’s haram? You will see that they get hesitated . I can clearly say there are no verses which prohibits Music or instruments in the Quran. There are hadiths which allowed Music in even with instruments. 👇🏻 . Hadiths narrated by Aisha(ra) where prophet SA allowed instrumental music in his own house. - Sahih Bukhari 987, 3931, 949, 952. Sahih Muslim 892b, etc. * Prophet(SA) compares the rhythmic recitation of Quran of his companion to the rhythmic music of Flutes - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, 1087. * Prophet SA invited wedding singers to a wedding function - Sunan Ibn Majah 1900 * Prophet SA accepted the invitation by a slave girl for listening to her music - Tirmidhi 3690 Just because some scholars said it’s haram doesn’t make anything haram in Islam. Truth will always be clear! Nobody can hide the truth, it will reveal itself.
@@majhee55this guy is an established scholar of Ahl Assunah Wa Jamaa, a maliki of fiqh more precisely. As if been spiritually focused and committed is a back thing now? Demonizing tassawuf that is established on the sunnah will only make your heart hardened, and you can take this as a kind reminder to watch your soul instead of looking down on well established seekers of Allah SWT.
Music is haraam. If one has to make a 40 min video ro explain, it is not fully haraam, he is a misguided soul & should repent & use just 2 sec of his life & say, music is haraam, thatz it.
UA-cam is Haram. Leave now. For the sake of Allah. UA-cam is doing RIBBA and ur giving them money by watching ads you are a part of the RIBBA. Pathetic.
You are not a scholar and have no knowledge of Islam, this scholar spend his whole life studying Islam and this lecture was very informative and he’s right music is not just flat out haram there are layers of this religion you take the religion at point blank when you are not even a learned person
@@omairnazir7487 haha layers. There is no layers. There r devaints and there r ones who r on straight path. Sufis r deviants & only them have made music halal.
Sounds like Modern Era of Sect MSLMs that Spread HRM & HLL with NO LOGIC. If you are a PROPLSTN, I'm sure you didn't actually learn. At least for me as a PROPLSTN, I learn that SOMETHING DOESN'T MAKE SENSE, IT'S A LIE, MEANS NOT THE TRUTH NO MATTER WHAT PORTIONS. Just look at the reasons. Make Sense?? Melody, how About Our Feet as we walk and our "Lalala" "Nanana" those Acapella??? Lyrics, how about News, Book, TV, Hearsays Talking, School??? They always have Negative Sentences, can impacted Negatively. Sound Frequency, our Breath??? Our Vocal tone??? Wind? Rain? Cooking?? Instruments, what's Instruments actually? When those who say HRM explaining Instruments, then it's exactly The Same with Our Fingers work with Spoon, Fork, Pillow, Hair, Clothes, our Movements and Body creating Sounds. How Dvmb more you can be...
Hadith from Sahih al-Bukhari (No. 5590 - Mu’allaq Hadith) The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said: “There will be among my Ummah people who will regard as permissible (halal) fornication (zina), the wearing of silk (for men), wine (khamr), and musical instruments (ma‘āzif).” (Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-Ashriba, Hadith No. 5590 - Mu‘allaq form)
Al salam alekom shaykh. I had to take a moment to say you are so well spoken and so knowledgable. Thank you for this eye opening and interesting talk I enjoyed it profoundly. Greetings from Egypt.
Imam Hakim Murad, this lecture was exceptionally INFORMATIVE AND WONDERFUL!! Thank you!! Thank you.
Singing spirituals helped to save my people during slavery. The hidden messages in the music that they sang informed them when the time was ripe to escape and whether or not slave catchers were in the area. I have been a Muslim for sixty years. I’m 71. I chose Islam for myself and was the second in my family to do so. I cannot imagine not being able to listen or sing or share with my friends songs of praise to Allah; and, truth be told, I love other forms of music as well and cannot imagine a world without it. Emma Goldman once famously said, regarding the Russian Revolution, “If I can’t dance, it’s not my revolution.” I believe that if 18:31 I couldn’t sing or listen to the music that helped to save my people, I know that I’d never have considered Islam.
60 years Mashallah! Alhamdullilah how beautiful. May Allah give you many more years in health and faith.
Please don't change islam. Thats extremely disrespectful to us and our ancestors. If you think islam is not your thing, you can always leave, but it's extremely inconsiderate to change our religion or tell us to change our religion because you and your ancestors like it. Music was always haram in islam and always will be.
This is beautiful alhamdulillah thank you for sharing. I share the same sentiment even though I’m from a different background (Hispanic/Latino)
@@Fatex199 Please don't watch and comment about intelligent, well-thought-out discussions about detailed and nuanced issues in the Deen. This is disrespectful to our intelligent ancestors. If you think intelligence is not your thing, you can always continue in your simple life and have complete fulfillment through ignorance. But it is extremely inconsiderate to interrupt intelligent conversations with such statements just because you or your ancestors couldn't understand the video. Thoughtfulness has always been wajib in intelligence and always will be. Thank you.
@@MuslimInAbby
Because I believe music is haram, you believe I am:
disrespecting your ancestors, not intelligent, lives a simple life( this one is true), ignorant, inconsiderate,my ancestors are stupid and I don't even think.
Try your best but we will not sit and let you guys make music halal. Not happening. We will resist.
I converted to Islam and didn't know about the music issue until a few months after taking my Shahada. Needless to say I had a hard time wrapping my head around music being Haraam, and the more scholars I talk to the more I understand it's more of a mainstream belief. I still listen to music but much more selective about what comes to my ears Mash'Allah
@@danyalm. Just Use Logic & have Self-Control. Easy Example, Pen or Tie can be use in a Good & Bad way. Fictional Book or Biography Book or Crime Recordings & Videos (on SocMeds or TV) or even Any Video Documentaries & many more. If we don't Control ourselves, We Will Deeply put those Words & Stories that No Matter What, bring more Negativity like Fear, Visual Trauma, Any Forms of Hallucinations, Sadness, Loneliness, Irrational Hate, Less Confidence, Trust Issues, etc. LIFE is a Test, that Self-Control is Always Everywhere in Everything. Fanatic in Anything is never a Good thing even if it's just Writing or Cooking.
@@danyalm. Be Careful of Sects. They're Heavily PoIiticaIy Involved. Whether it's Foods, Medicines, Entertainment, Sports, Education, etc., in Modern Era Heavily Control by GIobaIsts. If you pay attention to PLSTN Topic, I suggest you to also Search about Z[0N]SM. Always Check Every Aspects to Understand World & ReIigi0ns & Society Better. So you will understand why this and that happened or why it's become like this & that.
@@danyalm. I'm AIhamduIiIIah a MvsIim as well and live in the BGGST MvsIim PopvIation. There are 5 reIigi0ns here & so many Sects & CuIts in all 5. We're all here need to be careful, or else, we could fill ourselves with Irrational Hate, Unreasonable Dislike. *From Anyone especially Public Figures Anywhere, *Always Take a Good Fruits & Left The Bad Fruits. Any Education & Information, Always Logic & Try Find Sense. Never Praise or Rely on Anyone Deeply. That will easily Mislead you.*
@@danyalm. I hope you get to read 3 Replies I wrote for you. My comments usually got auto-deleted even when there's no cvrsing or thrts. My Govt also have Many Words that Cens0rd that only local can see, or only international can see, or no one except Me that can see.
@@danyalm. I only see 2 of 4 replies from me to you...
...may Allah increase this umma in faith and wisdom. May Allah protect this umma from all fitna the known and the unknown. ...
Music is nourishment for soul.
A deep discussion on intentions and actions are also a must. Intentions are mind related. Actions are body related
To say HRM Not Logic especially Nothing in AI-Qvr'an have Clear Messages about it. Our Breath alone is Sound Frequency & Melody, Our Movements & Body alone is Instruments, Our Words and what we heard alone are also Words that have the same Character with Lyrics. Just Enjoy WITH SELF-CONTROL, also WITHOUT Using it to Negatively Impacting Your Character & Thinking.
Having come from a Christian background,I've always wondered if string instruments are haraam,how come nabii Daud alayhi salaam played the harp!
Do you know what frequences are used now. Name 1 person who can enjoy quran and at the same time be a listener of music or ang scholar who did that in the past.
I am a practicing muslim. Music can not at all be haram or considered haram or sinful to listen to in Islam. GOD LOVES beauty. HE IS THE CREATOR OF BEAUTY in nature all around us..nature is not mute but full of sounds..of sea waves, sound of wind, sound of tree leaves moved by wind, birds chirrping or doves cooing.. the universe is not silent and had GOD wanted human beings not to listen to or enjoy music HE WOULD NOT HAVE CREATED our ears !
It is a crime or rather a sin if we deprive our ears of what is also nourishment for our souls.
GOD IS PEACE AND LIGHT .
HE LOVES BEAUTY and it is an insult to Islam to assume or believe what anyone wants us to deny using as a gift : our ears and ability to hear , to hear what is beautiful !
مَا أَحَلَّ اللهُ فِيْ كِتَابِهِ فَهُوَ حَلاَلٌ، وَمَا حَرَّمَ فَهُوَ حَرَامٌ، وَمَا سَكَتَ عَنْهُ فَهُوَ عَافِيَةٌ، فَاقْبَلُوْا مِنَ اللهِ الْعَافِيَةَ، فَإِنَّ اللهَ لَمْ يَكُنْ نَسِيًّا، ثُمَّ تَلاَ هَذِهِ الآية: وَمَا كَانَ رَبُّكَ نَسِيّٗا
_Whatever Allah has permitted in His Book is lawful, whatever He has forbidden is forbidden, and whatever He has remained silent about is permissible. So accept Allah’s forgiveness, for Allah is not forgetful. Then he recited this verse: Maryam 19:64 ... and never is your Lord forgetful_
Hadith narrated by Al-Hakim, 2/375, considered as hasan (good) by Al-Albani in Ghaayatul Maraam, p. 14.
if you find a verse stating music is haram in quran then it is haram. if you can't find one, don't play god with music
Objectively speaking, "Music" is just a vibration of air which has certain patterns that we find it enjoyable. This is how audio is being inscribed into a vinyl discs, that very vibrations across the specified time. It's a very wide category, on the other side you have birds who can play "Music" by their chirpings which can soothe our morning, meanwhile on the other opposite side it can be intoxicating to our mind like what they do in Rock concerts where people can literally lose their minds in a mosh pit. The purring of a cat can also be considered as a music to our ears, and this particular vibrations emitted by a cat's purr can lower blood pressure, lessen stress, and even promote healing.
Music is just a vibration of air within specified frequency ranges of 20 Hz to 20 kHz that has certain patterns that we find it pleasing to our ears. If you go beyond that frequency we can't hear it, and if it doesn't have any pattern then it's just a noise. Certain frequency music has been known contributes reducing tension and anxiety, according to National Institute of Health.
It is the content that matters.
I think it is unwise to blanket wrap them all as a prohibition. But in the end this is just my opinion, Allah swt knows best.
What kind of secular-atheist-derived ruling point of view is this?
‘Music is just a vibration of air’?
So by that logic, humans are just atoms moving around-so killing and bringing destruction would simply be atoms moving too?
Akhi, you need to reconsider what you’re allowing into your intellect (Aql) right now. Go back to the Book of Allah and the explanations of the scholars.
This is a sincere piece of advice.
Natural sound like a cat purring, and then artificially created tunes are not within the same group of sounds.
The prophet (peace be upon him) has prohibited music for general uses as far as I am aware.
This is supported by Sahih Bukhari 5590
If you have any evidences from the Quran or Sunnah to support your beliefs, then state them; otherwise it should be assumed that your beliefs are non-Islamic, and likely derived from desire; which is even more so likely to be true if you reject clear evidences in favour of your thoughts and feelings.
This materialistic perspective offers nothing whatsoever to a conversation on morality. Although the fancy words may satisfy your pride, they are a non-contribution to the discussion. Allah knows best
Something worrying I noticed is that I did not see *any* dalil from our religious sources (Quran, Hadith, statements from scholars), but rather it was *all* your opinion. I do think that your reasoning fails but I'm not going to go into that - what I am more concerned about is the fact that these days, random laymen feel as if they can generate fatawa based on nothing but their feelings.
I advise you to repent to Allah for speaking about His din without any knowledge. You have no right to do that.
More like we just enjoy it With Control on Ourselves, Without Letting Our Selves be Someone Else. Like Depressed, Hateful, Anger, Sad, Pessimistic. Let it just be Sounds just like we hear the voice of TV or people speaking in public.
How many of yall even watch this fully before commenting ☺️
Exactly ❤️
This is informative but at 26 minutes it's still a discourse on what musical cultures are rather than Islamic rulings.
It's not a video on Fiqh. Their is no "ruling" on music in Islam, there is simply a dialect of tension in the scholarly tradition. That's the point of this lecture... use your own discretion. Allah gave you ears and an intellect. Protect your ears from what may enter your heart. If you personally find a piece of music as beneficial and enjoyable, then continue to benefit from it. If not, then discard it. Simple.
@@AbdullahMikalRodriguez watch Shaykh Uthmans video on Music being haram where he showcases evidences from all four madhabs with full details.
I like one of the concluding remarks," it is safe to err on the side of caution".
It's legalism which IS prohibited!
Lecture is highly intellectual
Comment section is full of intellectual dwarf....
Listen to complete lecture first
Music is a Gift from Allah. Woe those who abuse it.
Yes, true. AIIah SWT is The Creator that Not Hypocrite. And to say that it's HRM means Not Logical.
The Fact, that it's Propaganda Fights between GIobaIists Versus People with ReIigi0n especially actually CHRSTNs. Because GIobaIists Pushed Psychological Pressure like Negative Affirmative & Satanism Artsy through Mvsic (Clips, Stages, Lyrics). They Want People to be used to Those STNC vibes & Depression, while Away with identity as CHRSTN. Here Some Sects of MSLMs, take a piece of cake with many different Reasons, but Wrong Way to Educate.
Whether it's Melody, Lyrics, Instruments, Sound Frequency, None Of These are Logic & Sense to say that Mvsic is HRM. Because We All Surrounded by Melody & Sound Frequency Everyday Everywhere, Anything Around Us even our Fingers can be Instruments as it has Sounds. And There are So Many Scary or even Negative Words in News, Magazine, Any Books, Poetry, Ads, Anywhere. Even out AI-Qvr'an have some Talks about HeII and many scary things to teach us and guide us.
Is it? 🤔
How do you know?
@@Maraqaba1 Since it can heal, just like poison if used correctly can heal, it must be a sacred gift from Allah (swt)
You are so far from being accurate and true that the sound of your instrument is not finely tuned.
@@Yahyamourad_ That's just your opinion though.
Our trueself we are only the spirit.
Souls are still mind
Mind is knowledge
Spirit is BEAUTY, BLISS, LOVE, INTUITION, THE TRUE NAMES (SOUNDS), it always hears and listens, never talks like the mind.
We listen first then we see,, we never see first, then listens..
Sounds created light, not light created sounds
Our attention not suppose to go to the music, but trying putting the attention to a single note sound, example putting attention to the drum in the music, or putting attention to the guitar in the music..
amazing lecture. but i need to point out a very important matter regarding modern music. If anyone can research how we TUNE our instruments in modern days, A=440hz, is not at all like how all humanity used to tune their instruments. there is a conspiracy about how they changed the frequencies so it affects us in a negative way. 440 promotes individuality, it is the opposite of integrity and if compared to 432hz for instance, is exactly the opposite.
what i want to point out here, is that we need to check what music we listen to , not only based on the intention of this piece of music (belly dancing or promoting sins), but also how this music is affecting us on higher level. there is a lot about this subject, so thats why i encourage you brothers and sisters, to research why we were forced to switch to 440hz, and also if they embed malevolent "binaural beats" in popular songs....
spirit always hears or listens..
Mind only talks..
We LISTEN FIRST then we SEE.. LISTEN COMES FIRST
Elhamdulillah brother winters, this is so needed as very talented brothers on u tube do dava but are tunnel visioned and for the life of me l can't imagine such talented muslims have no idea that music is a complex discussion as one cannot bag music into a black bag and cast it as it were to a corner, the universe hums, in music, our blood pulses music,our hearts spiral upwards with music our humanness is musical, Allahu Teala gave us gifts that are immeasurable, how then would Allahu Teala deprive creation of intrinsically wonderous beauty that sounds form in and around us,righteous people are supposed to understand evil and good,music is energy which can be channelled to create evil effects, this is the same with technology, sounds simple yet talented muslims are tunnel visioned and this is alarming as it causes divisions in the umma,thank you brother muad for discussing this subject
Brother murad l can easily imagine music having shape and colour and tones are are not unlike colour tones, just as paintings have an effect on our senses when we take in the consideration of colours applied to a particular art work, so every thing in universe is intertwined with supreme perfection Allahu Teala has imbued in to creation, everything is given it's perfect balance and value measure Allahu Teala is our lord how could we think of deficiency when we see immeasurable perfection that stares at us at every moment
Very informative
MIND is suppose to be treated as a servant, not a master
"If you want to find the secrets of the universe, think in terms of energy, frequency and vibration"- Nikola Tesla
Did the MIND sinned OR the spirit sinned????
Soul is still mind always attached to subtle part of mind
I love 💗 Islam ☪️ but I’m a music major piano 🎹 n my two dogs are my boys 🐕 I’m American so I gotta understand cultures are gonna vary n I still might go to church ⛪️
MIND was preventing humanity to go within to understand the real revealations of sounds. Mind kept humanity trapped life after life in it s 3 realms, and became slaves to Deaths.. mind told humanity to pay more attention to goodness n badness related topics, but did not told humanity that there is something called becoming a slave to DEATHS ALWAYS life after life
The MIND, had pushed the whole truth into end of time, akhirat s Dustbin
A small but important point: Shetland is NOT in England. It's in Scotland and in the UK.
If this observation hadn't been raised Hakim Murads effort would have gone in vain.
To understand becoming a slave to deaths always, first of all revelations suppose to come directly from God with no in between help of Angels, only tru the 100th names
Hadith from Sahih al-Bukhari (No. 5590 - Mu’allaq Hadith)
The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said:
“There will be among my Ummah people who will regard as permissible (halal) fornication (zina), the wearing of silk (for men), wine (khamr), and musical instruments (ma‘āzif).”
(Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-Ashriba, Hadith No. 5590 - Mu‘allaq form)
"Mualaq"
We shouldn't be so harshly critical of those that we perceive as "Haram Police", even if at times they are wrong.
They also help to keep us in check, and review our actions.
We should be more cautious of those that rubber stamp everything as "Halal".
Thank you brother Murad
Assalamu aleykum warahmatu 'llahi wabarakatuhu. Thank you. Music is ok untill it is not disturbing the tawhid.
And who are you and where do you get your evidences from for this statement of yours?
@@scarfaceyam145 Quran and Sunnah. Quran says little to nothing about Music directly. Sunnah has examples of it being allowable. So it's not so easy as all Haram or all Halal. Which I'm sure the speaker covered in their long talk.
@@scarfaceyam145 Who are you? The thought police?
@@bayreuth79they are someone who thinks critically and does not allow desires in dunya to cloud their judgement based on Islamic principles
@@scarfaceyam145 Whenever those who say Music is Haram, they say all the imams considered it as Haram which is a big lie.
When it comes to Islam, its ALLAH declares Haram and Halal. Ask them did ALLAH say it’s haram? You will see that they get hesitated
.
I can clearly say there are no verses which prohibits Music or instruments in the Quran.
There are hadiths which allowed Music in even with instruments. 👇🏻
.
Hadiths narrated by Aisha(ra) where prophet SA allowed instrumental music in his own house.
- Sahih Bukhari 987, 3931, 949, 952.
Sahih Muslim 892b, etc.
* Prophet(SA) compares the rhythmic recitation of Quran of his companion to the rhythmic music of Flutes
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, 1087.
* Prophet SA invited wedding singers to a wedding function
- Sunan Ibn Majah 1900
* Prophet SA accepted the invitation by a slave girl for listening to her music
- Tirmidhi 3690
Just because some scholars said it’s haram doesn’t make anything haram in Islam. Truth will always be clear! Nobody can hide the truth, it will reveal itself.
I choose blindly follow Prophet ﷺ and all his companions and all the companions children children's until the 4 imam madhab from the 4 schools of thoughts. Music remains Haram permissible. Who are you to tell me music is Halal? We also know that sufism doesn't have a quality and qualified scholar and ulama can be follow as a madhab or school of thought. When, your thoughts is not worthy to compare with 1 of Imam madhab. What if the four say haram? If above their knowledge, they are also companions. If they hear you say this, you will definitely be scourged😅
really, well go find the word arabic word for 'music' in the hadith..
Did the prophet and sahaba read Qur'an? Did they go on UA-cam? Learn to use your mind.
My guy. You're being disrespectful to someone who is a better Muslim than you. I'm saying he is better based in the judgement of your comment. Carry yourself better. What you said may be right but how you said it was just rude.
@@AbuSabak77 There was never a blank prohibition or permisbiltiy on music before and there are hadiths of the prophet allowing music especially those with duff and singing.
I recommend you read the Fatwa of the Grand Mufti of Al-Azhar about music published in 1980.
@@daee121 Hadith from Sahih al-Bukhari (No. 5590 - Mu’allaq Hadith)
The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said:
“There will be among my Ummah people who will regard as permissible (halal) fornication (zina), the wearing of silk (for men), wine (khamr), and musical instruments (ma‘āzif).”
(Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-Ashriba, Hadith No. 5590 - Mu‘allaq form)
I implore muslims to listen to people like Abdal Hakim Murad and not the angry and arrogant 'dawah' people like Mohammed Hijab, who has now embraced Andrew Tate!
You can make your point without saying bad things about other people.
@@danalmariti509 Abdal Hakim Murad has himself said that such people should be avoided. Through Jordan Peterson M. Hijab has become well known and he must have put so many right thinking people off Islam forever, including Mr Peterson. The ummah needs to do more to criticise such arrogant interlopers
@@danalmariti509so facts are now bad?
A fact is a fact.
It could either be good or bad.
And your claim has no basis because Hijab openly, and might I say enthusiastically, displays his deeds to the public.
Many of todays “dawah” men are pompous and arrogant.
Showcasing attitudes and behaviors that have no place in Islam. Let alone a public stage.
I agree but unfortunately people dont enjoy long nuanced lectures, only tiktok style short clickbait stuff. Humanities brains are fried
what ................?
1) He hasn't embraced ANdrew Tate
2) he not hot headed angry internet mullah you talk about
Then who thrown the real NAMES into akhirat s Dustbin, this was not the work of true God, it was the MIND
Throw the same line back at these people: Before you blindly say music is halal.
The blind ones are you.
You didn't watch the video at all, did you?
@madjackmcjock of Abdulhakim Murad talking about one of his controversial takes? Spare me a lifespan. You guys think hes knowledgeable cos he Oxford and speaks with some decent tajweed lol.
@@AbuYusha01Are you unintelligent? Watch the video before you comment next time.
Agree
Majority of religions this days their revealations are not coming directly from God, they are using in-between help of angels, when you use angels you fall into traps of MIND AND TIME
The 99 are for the mind, not the spirit. Spirit our trueself needs the 100th names, full revealations as it s food. This 100th names, are 5 selected sounds..
Speech of God are uncreated exist as sounds. Duty of founder of religion are suppose to revealed this 100th names..
Yes we understand sounds from the outside first, but finally everything is within in dhikr.
Understanding what are DUALITY sounds first, when two things hits together, from here it takes you to the final sound, the soundless sound, where DUALITY CEASES..
islam are afraid to talk bout this things, because they already placed it at Akhirat, to be known at that time. Actually this are now now, to be known within now.
Humanity rites to know the real Names now, now and now..
This lecture should not be misunderstood to say music is halal.
Most of the lecture was about non-instrumental music, and when the Shaykh spoke of instrumental music he was very clear on what he did say.
The full revealations of the 100th Names will take you ultimately in unity with God. But this considered Syirik in islam to unite with God. For this reasons the truth was thrown in akhirat s dustbin.. at the moment islam more interested in KNOWING GOD ONLY, BUT NOT UNITY.. but islam does not know by knowing, separation n deaths is always there, not freed yet
you need help
People who think music is haram are spiritually dead
Be careful of what you said.
@@Abdurrahman-z1v2y be careful what you impose on others.
@@santinolowe7225 Am I saying anything, saying that those who say music is haraam blindly without any evidence, they have strong opinions and many people say that music is bad.
Some of the following are the words of the Salaf scholars regarding singing (music)
Ibn Mas'ud said: "Singing grows hypocrisy in the heart as water grows vegetables."
Al Qasim ibn Muhammad was asked about singing, and he replied: "I forbid singing to you and I hate it when you hear it." Then the questioner said, "Is singing haram?" Al Qasim said, "O son of my brother, if Allah has separated the right from the wrong, then where does Allah put 'singing'?"
'Umar ibn 'Abdul Aziz once wrote a letter to a teacher who taught his children, saying, "Let the first thing my children learn from your character be your hatred of singing. For it comes from the devil and its end is the wrath of Allah. I know from reliable scholars that listening to singing and musical instruments and being enamoured of them will only grow hypocrisy in the heart as water grows grass. By Allah, abstaining from singing is actually easier for a person of intelligence than having hypocrisy entrenched in the heart."
Fudhail ibn Iyadh said, "Singing is the incantation of adultery."
Adh Dhohak said, "Singing corrupts the heart and incurs the wrath of Allah."
Yazid ibn Al Walid said, "O my son, beware of listening to singing for it only inflames lust, lowers self-esteem, and even takes the place of liquor which makes you drunk. ... Know that singing is an incentive to commit adultery."
If you disagree, then speak well and show your evidence, saying that people who say music is haram are spiritually dead is very arrogant and outrageous.
@@santinolowe7225 Am I saying anything, saying that those who say music is haraam blindly without any evidence, they have strong opinions and many people say that music is bad.
Some of the following are the words of the Salaf scholars regarding singing (music)
Ibn Mas'ud said: "Singing grows hypocrisy in the heart as water grows vegetables."
Al Qasim ibn Muhammad was asked about singing, and he replied: "I forbid singing to you and I hate it when you hear it." Then the questioner said, "Is singing haram?" Al Qasim said, "O son of my brother, if Allah has separated the right from the wrong, then where does Allah put 'singing'?"
'Umar ibn 'Abdul Aziz once wrote a letter to a teacher who taught his children, saying, "Let the first thing my children learn from your character be your hatred of singing. For it comes from the devil and its end is the wrath of Allah. I know from reliable scholars that listening to singing and musical instruments and being enamoured of them will only grow hypocrisy in the heart as water grows grass. By Allah, abstaining from singing is actually easier for a person of intelligence than having hypocrisy entrenched in the heart."
Fudhail ibn Iyadh said, "Singing is the incantation of adultery."
Adh Dhohak said, "Singing corrupts the heart and incurs the wrath of Allah."
Yazid ibn Al Walid said, "O my son, beware of listening to singing for it only inflames lust, lowers self-esteem, and even takes the place of liquor which makes you drunk. ... Know that singing is an incentive to commit adultery."
If you disagree, then speak well and show your evidence, saying that people who say music is haram are spiritually dead is very arrogant and outrageous.
@@santinolowe7225 Am I saying anything, saying that those who say music is haraam blindly without any evidence, they have strong opinions and many people say that music is bad. If you disagree, then speak well and show your evidence, saying that people who say music is haram are spiritually dead is very arrogant and outrageous.
he said rarely people are tone deaf.... i hear some of yall trying yalls hardest to match some sort of pitch on the "amin" at the end of Fatihah during salat.... 🤣
27 min into the lecture, still no fiqhi discussion about music. I gave up. And yes, sound does have a profound effect on human beings. Listening to Dr. Murad puts me to sleep (in a good way).
You want to learn about fiqh, listen to real Muslim, Arabic speaking scholars. Reverts tend to bring a heavy package with them from their previous lives.
@@OmarBenjumeaDumbest comment I read, bravo.
What the Quran forbade was not music but idle speech. 🤔
Yes, but: ua-cam.com/video/MePw9E1s6Rs/v-deo.html
Music is Haram.
What is Music?
@@nanashi7779
Any instrumental or vocal sounds meant for entertainment, or stirring the soul with emotions and lust are prohibited in Islam.
@@OmarBenjumea"any instrumental" you forget the people of Madinah used music to welcome the Prophet Muhammad SAW when he arrived in the city. The people sang and played instruments to express their joy.
@@OmarBenjumea Is recited poetry music? It qualifies as vocal sounds meant for entertainment, which stirs the soul with emotions
@@Aripuni1
The whole story was fake. Also, the Madinah people were not Muslim at the time, they converted after he settled down.
Good one, though!
theres nohing contreversial about this you delusioanl sufi
ua-cam.com/users/livesBDnlxGmuaw?si=YzJV2tyR_RlN1V7o
1 hour, 11 minutes of this video, ibnu tamiyyah did mention the uncreated speech of God, are the sounds..
It is the responsibility of founders of religions to revealed this selected sounds, upgrade them as NAMES, THE 100TH NAMES. but sadly not revealed in islam. Only sound of bells are mentioned, balance are thrown into end of time, akhirat s dustbin
Why do we need music? Is the quran not enough? Did the prophet pbuh play music? Haram or not, I don't think we should engage in music
Why do you need social media or TV or westernized school and capitalistic 9 to 5 jobs?
@@apap745 did the prophet go on UA-cam?
As a Prophet Muhammad wasn't protected hence in Quran Allah admonishes Muhammad as referring to him as Nabi ( not Messenger) why do you make Haraam what Allah has made Halaal,,,, Muhammad was protected as a Messenger i.e the message he brought (Qur'an )was intact without error,, but as a prophet he was left to his own devices like us all , we make mistakes and learn from them ,,,
Music or any other device becomes disliked when its used in the negative way like nuclear energy is clean but making a bomb from it is negative ,,, a knife helps cut food but can also be used to unalive people does that mean it should be banned,,, of course not the benefits out way the harms ,, so music that promotes a certain behavior or dumbs people shouldn't be encouraged but to ban music because someone mistranslated what Muhammad said shouldn't be a law as clearly the verses on gambling and intoxication couldn't music of been slipt into that verse ,,,
There are hadiths about music which make it haram
@@kamoliddinrasulov5283 There are none.
I’m not sure about this presentation.
Is he trying to justify music in Islam?
X
Actually music is unwelcome because it resonate all the time at one's mind, who listen or do it, even at the time of prayer. It's an instrument of Satan to divert peoples from rememberence of Allah.
what an evil way to think. you are responsible for your own sins and what occupies your own mind. leave iblees out of it. if youre listening to evil music perhaps listen to something positive
It’s Haram ..and Allah made it so as a test , just like eating pork is pleasing to some people , listening to music pleases the ear, and so this is a test are you gonna listen to your desires or are you gonna obey Allah..
@ what you watch on UA-cam can be haram yes , not UA-cam itself
Propagating Islamic knowledge or learning about it on UA-cam would actually earn you hasanaat
@ good for them
@@myguybru I already explained it above …and as a Muslim for you to mock and make light of Allah’s tests says a lot …
29:2) Do people think that they will be let go merely by saying: “We believe,” and that they will not be tested,1 (29:3) for We indeed tested those who went before them? Allah will most certainly ascertain3 those who spoke the truth and those who lied. 1.
@@Sheriff1977 your right. I have made a mistake on my replies. I didn't think of it like that.
@ well done my brother…it’s rare to see honesty in people ..may Allah guide you and keep you steadfast
Totally ridiculous legalism.
10 mins in and no Quran ayah or hadith presented as evidence. What is this?
Whenever those who say Music is Haram, they say all the imams considered it as Haram which is a big lie.
When it comes to Islam, its ALLAH declares Haram and Halal. Ask them did ALLAH say it’s haram? You will see that they get hesitated
.
I can clearly say there are no verses which prohibits Music or instruments in the Quran.
There are hadiths which allowed Music in even with instruments. 👇🏻
.
Hadiths narrated by Aisha(ra) where prophet SA allowed instrumental music in his own house.
- Sahih Bukhari 987, 3931, 949, 952.
Sahih Muslim 892b, etc.
* Prophet(SA) compares the rhythmic recitation of Quran of his companion to the rhythmic music of Flutes
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, 1087.
* Prophet SA invited wedding singers to a wedding function
- Sunan Ibn Majah 1900
* Prophet SA accepted the invitation by a slave girl for listening to her music
- Tirmidhi 3690
Just because some scholars said it’s haram doesn’t make anything haram in Islam. Truth will always be clear! Nobody can hide the truth, it will reveal itself.
This guy is of the western “Sufi” variety
Where in the Quran does it state that music is haram?
@@f_s_h1990 Islam was 90% Sufi for nrly a thousand years giving jurisprudence and ijtihad but I don't think that you know what "sufi" actually means
@@majhee55this guy is an established scholar of Ahl Assunah Wa Jamaa, a maliki of fiqh more precisely. As if been spiritually focused and committed is a back thing now? Demonizing tassawuf that is established on the sunnah will only make your heart hardened, and you can take this as a kind reminder to watch your soul instead of looking down on well established seekers of Allah SWT.
Music is haraam. If one has to make a 40 min video ro explain, it is not fully haraam, he is a misguided soul & should repent & use just 2 sec of his life & say, music is haraam, thatz it.
UA-cam is Haram. Leave now. For the sake of Allah. UA-cam is doing RIBBA and ur giving them money by watching ads you are a part of the RIBBA. Pathetic.
Go waste your time on nasheeds bro.
You are not a scholar and have no knowledge of Islam, this scholar spend his whole life studying Islam and this lecture was very informative and he’s right music is not just flat out haram there are layers of this religion you take the religion at point blank when you are not even a learned person
@@omairnazir7487 haha layers. There is no layers. There r devaints and there r ones who r on straight path. Sufis r deviants & only them have made music halal.
Go ahead and follow your deviancy but stop pretending to care about the truth and misleading others
Sounds like Modern Era of Sect MSLMs that Spread HRM & HLL with NO LOGIC. If you are a PROPLSTN, I'm sure you didn't actually learn. At least for me as a PROPLSTN, I learn that SOMETHING DOESN'T MAKE SENSE, IT'S A LIE, MEANS NOT THE TRUTH NO MATTER WHAT PORTIONS. Just look at the reasons. Make Sense??
Melody, how About Our Feet as we walk and our "Lalala" "Nanana" those Acapella???
Lyrics, how about News, Book, TV, Hearsays Talking, School??? They always have Negative Sentences, can impacted Negatively.
Sound Frequency, our Breath??? Our Vocal tone??? Wind? Rain? Cooking??
Instruments, what's Instruments actually? When those who say HRM explaining Instruments, then it's exactly The Same with Our Fingers work with Spoon, Fork, Pillow, Hair, Clothes, our Movements and Body creating Sounds.
How Dvmb more you can be...
What is the deviation? 🤔
Is there a law against music in the Quran?
Support ex muslim movement
The Dark/Fairly Fair Skin Najd Wahabi Arabs will be crossed at this.
Hadith from Sahih al-Bukhari (No. 5590 - Mu’allaq Hadith)
The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said:
“There will be among my Ummah people who will regard as permissible (halal) fornication (zina), the wearing of silk (for men), wine (khamr), and musical instruments (ma‘āzif).”
(Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-Ashriba, Hadith No. 5590 - Mu‘allaq form)