WHAT IF FORMULA 1 raced on GRAN TURISMO's CIRCUITS?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 136

  • @MarcoVilla1993
    @MarcoVilla1993  9 днів тому +35

    Since a lot of you are asking for a complete onboard video, i'll upload it this wednesday. 👍

  • @Reiderreiter
    @Reiderreiter 6 днів тому +73

    I hope the person/people at Polyphony who designed the Lago Maggiore course have or get a side gig in actually designing real tracks. Because it is such an incredible circuit.

    • @bellerei2360
      @bellerei2360 4 дні тому +3

      Especially the middle sector is cracked

    • @EversonBernardes
      @EversonBernardes 3 дні тому +2

      Better than most stuff Hermann Tilke has came up with in the past 30 years, at least.

  • @MrJr1976
    @MrJr1976 7 днів тому +37

    Dragon Trail and Maggiore are some of my favorite tracks in the GT franchise. Purely because of how well they flow. I've tried basically every modern era of F1 on both circuits and the racing is spectacular. Also helps that I'm the one who ripped GTS' game files so I have some bias. Glad you enjoyed!

  • @Oz_of_Astora158
    @Oz_of_Astora158 6 днів тому +42

    It’s a crime Lago Maggiore doesn’t exist IRL

  • @NgKQ96
    @NgKQ96 7 днів тому +38

    You're missing the following:
    Apricot Hill Raceway
    Red Rock Valley Speedway
    Tahiti Road
    Grindelwald
    Seattle Circuit
    Rome Circuit
    Complex String
    Special Stage Route 11
    El Capitan
    Cape Ring

    • @DobieMeltfire
      @DobieMeltfire 6 днів тому +7

      and Sainte Croix, also there is an updated version of Trial Mountain

    • @K0BRAH95
      @K0BRAH95 5 днів тому

      I hope u mean cape ring periphery? God that would be amazing

    • @NgKQ96
      @NgKQ96 5 днів тому +2

      @@K0BRAH95 No, the complete track, as in this ua-cam.com/video/daSSpARQu1M/v-deo.html

    • @K0BRAH95
      @K0BRAH95 5 днів тому

      @ ah my bad 😅 my memory’s fuzzy, god I wish it existed IRL, would be scary as hell but yeah

    • @IIGrayfoxII
      @IIGrayfoxII 4 дні тому +2

      SSR11 it has the original chicane of death.

  • @RACECAR
    @RACECAR 8 днів тому +70

    Based on what I've observed with F1 and GT, here's how feasible I think it would be for F1 To Race on them if they were real:
    *High Speed Ring* : Kinda Iffy. Its mostly flat out (with only one other F1 track kinda like this) but its also super wide and F1 are all about "The Show". Its a coin toss really
    *Grand Valley* : Would like to point out this is the original Grand Valley Speedway, not the current Highway-1 (Scenery being the biggest difference). In either case, F1 would not go to either purely due to the lack of runoffs and insufficient facilities of the latter (Grade 1 nonsense and stuff)
    *Special Stage Route 5* : Another iffy one. On one hand, no cut outs in the barriers for car recovery (or safety intervention vehicles). On the other hand, F1 sure do love them some street circuits...
    *Autumn Ring* : Far too small for today's F1 cars AND it lacks runoff. Would need to be butchered beyond recognition.
    *Trail Mountain* : Another track that F1 would avoid, regardless of which iteration it was. Not even that new chicane, something that F1 loves for some reasons, would be enough considering the facilities are kinda tight and that Chicane IS the only amount of runoff you're getting.
    *Eiger Nordward* : Would absolutely agree they wouldn't like this. The list of "Totally not suitable for F1" issues here are numerous.
    *Mid-Field Raceway* : First actual track that could host an F1 race and meet Grade 1 standards. Guarantee the Crytocurrency ads or the Aramco ads would be obnoxious though.
    *Deep Forest* : Original not so much. Current one is another for the iffy pile.
    *Lago Maggiore* : Absolutely. Screams F1 venue with the way it flows and the Curb and Runoff areas.
    *Dragon Trail* : I think not only would F1 race here, but it'd be a sellout every year PURELY because people want to see who bins in the Chicane of Death ( people are morbid)
    *Tokyo R246* : Certainly could if it still looked like that today, especially if Honda wanted it (If you know, you know). Weirdly, it gives me Las Vegas Vibes.

    • @indigomizumi
      @indigomizumi 6 днів тому +3

      As far as the "new guard" of GT fictional tracks go I'd say Maggiore is my favorite. And considering that the main layout is billed as the GP circuit I have to assume it was designed to FIA Grade 1 specifications to begin with.

    • @FMecha
      @FMecha 6 днів тому

      @@RACECAR HSR also needs SAFER barriers, something the GT7 version lacks.

    • @hiimemily
      @hiimemily 5 днів тому +7

      Legitimately, the first time I saw the Las Vegas circuit layout, I thought "is that Tokyo R246?"

    • @arashiwashere
      @arashiwashere 5 днів тому

      If I remember correctly, in Tokyo R246 there's a Honda HQ building right before the start/finish line. I suppose Honda would like to take an F1 street circuit in there, if FIA agreed of course...

    • @Aunini
      @Aunini 5 днів тому

      I feel like Trial Mountain has some bigger issues than that

  • @v3lz0
    @v3lz0 9 днів тому +15

    The tokyo one kinda looks like vegas, but it would be cool to see f1 race at some of these circuits, most of these are doable for sure, great video!

    • @nathanstroud2223
      @nathanstroud2223 8 днів тому +1

      They do have some similarities in layout. Pull up both track maps side by side and they're not exactly identical, but there *IS* an uncanny resemblance. They're cut from the same cloth, and those who didn't know any better might assume they were designed by the same person.

    • @FlashoftheBlades
      @FlashoftheBlades 8 днів тому +3

      Tokyo R246 does look doable for F1. If not, there’s always SUPER GT or GT World Challenge Asia.

  • @maxdegraaf1333
    @maxdegraaf1333 7 днів тому +8

    We need an F1 fantasy season on these tracks

  • @skaldlouiscyphre2453
    @skaldlouiscyphre2453 9 днів тому +23

    I know it can't happen, but I'd love to see NASCAR or Trans-Am at High Speed Ring.

    • @windyman56
      @windyman56 7 днів тому +2

      I feel NASCAR would hate it there, can't see how they couldn't have to run the superspeedway package esp with how turn 1 is
      Also the concerning lack of SAFER barriers

    • @skaldlouiscyphre2453
      @skaldlouiscyphre2453 7 днів тому +1

      @@windyman56 I feel like the track would probably have SAFER barriers already installed if it was real. Being in GT kinda eliminates the need for making those changes.
      I don't think it would be a plate race, simply because the cars wouldn't stay bunched up like on an oval.

    • @windyman56
      @windyman56 6 днів тому +1

      @skaldlouiscyphre2453 yet they still have steel Armco barriers everywhere. Im surprised that the track in GT didn't have SAFER barriers considering how detail oriented the fictional tracks are. Maybe it would play out like the Daytona road course race during COVID?

    • @FMecha
      @FMecha 6 днів тому +1

      @@skaldlouiscyphre2453 They installed SAFER barriers at Northern Isle (Bristol), Blue Moon Bay (Pocono), and BB Raceway.
      EDIT: Also, PS3 era GT's NASCAR championships have HSR on both GT5 and GT6.

    • @skaldlouiscyphre2453
      @skaldlouiscyphre2453 5 днів тому

      @@FMecha Interesting. I've never played GT, but HSR was converted to rFactor so I've raced it plenty in rFactor.

  • @dsgv_086
    @dsgv_086 5 днів тому +2

    Grand Valley, Laggo Maggiore and Dragon Trail its actually very good tracks for F1

  • @RobinThomson277
    @RobinThomson277 6 днів тому +7

    Love the camera work, I feel like I'm watching F1 actually from another dimension.

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  6 днів тому +2

      @@RobinThomson277 Thank you, i get different opinion on this topic and i appreciate every feedback. 😊

  • @Dindyracer
    @Dindyracer 4 дні тому

    This was pretty neat! Thank you for your efforts! Also, the external cam was a nice touch. Most people love a good flyby shot lol. 🤙🏾
    As Gran Turismo release newer and newer iterations (they just released their take on a 90's F1 car) se get closer and closer to their fabled 'Formula Gran Turismo' from Gran Turismo 4 (their take on a then current F1 car). We can only hope they continue the trend so we can no longer wonder lol. Also, they updated Deep Forest and Trial Mountain! Hopefully you can find and enjoy those updated versions here! Thanks again!

  • @Patrikozius
    @Patrikozius 8 днів тому +5

    We need a part 2 of this 🤩🤩

  • @sirprizemuthafakka4912
    @sirprizemuthafakka4912 8 днів тому +4

    Interresting video, thanks 👍

  • @_fudgepop01
    @_fudgepop01 4 дні тому

    I appreciate what you were going for with the dynamic camerq changes - probably inspired by gran turismo’s replays themselves. I think it’s cool- but aye I’d recommend keeping them on separate videos so the viewer can decide how to see it ^^

  • @FMecha
    @FMecha 7 днів тому +4

    Coincidentally Project A-Spec (a GT2 mod/ROM hack) now has F1 cars.

  • @kornijboer
    @kornijboer 3 дні тому

    I love how you drive on the old versions, but some newer ones are just more suitable for f1

  • @superxavxii421
    @superxavxii421 3 дні тому

    Trial Mountain and High Speed Ring would be my dream tracks

  • @Trigoness
    @Trigoness 8 днів тому +1

    Amazing Vid, Keep On Goin'! I would like to see F1 2025 Circuits but in Wrong Way

  • @hiimemily
    @hiimemily 5 днів тому +2

    High Speed Ring is just a low-budget Monza.

  • @mariejuku
    @mariejuku 4 дні тому +1

    i firmly believe that trial mountain is the greatest fictional race track to ever do it
    generally i find poly's fictional tracks to be the absolute best in the business

  • @fuzzy-daddy83
    @fuzzy-daddy83 8 днів тому +14

    Second one is grand valley speedway pre gt7, not highway

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  8 днів тому

      You’re right!

    • @FlashoftheBlades
      @FlashoftheBlades 8 днів тому +5

      And is far better.

    • @azurerider812
      @azurerider812 6 днів тому +1

      @@FlashoftheBlades damn straight. GT7 one reeks of corpo meddling.

    • @FlashoftheBlades
      @FlashoftheBlades 6 днів тому +1

      @@azurerider812 I heard one fan theory that the speedway closed down because of urban sprawl, which resulted in some enthusiasts taking the racing to the streets in the form of the current Grand Valley - Highway 1.

    • @azurerider812
      @azurerider812 6 днів тому

      @FlashoftheBlades sadly accurate. For all the shit it gave me in the big boy events in GT2, I respect what it stands for: the ultimate challenge from Poly.
      Recently, Poly has been less and less Kaz and more Sony corporate...which is not a good look for the future once Kaz steps down.

  • @yacinemefrouche4338
    @yacinemefrouche4338 8 днів тому +3

    Always loved Midfield, always kinda reminded me of Suzuka Circuit or Kyalami

    • @MihzvolWuriar
      @MihzvolWuriar 8 днів тому +3

      Kyalami, I can see, but not Suzuka, Apricot Hill on the other hand is an exact attempt to replicate it's feeling.

  • @iankaranja7765
    @iankaranja7765 5 днів тому +1

    Lago Maggiore 🔥🔥🔥

  • @gearmeister
    @gearmeister День тому

    We need the real "Grand Valley" not just the new California Highway one...I instantly realized this was Asseto Corsa...mod tracks are lovely

  • @cashmasters99
    @cashmasters99 5 днів тому +2

    I wish Gt7 had the rights to modern f1 cars so bad. Probably won’t happen tho

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  5 днів тому +1

      I saw that with the latest update they added a 90s Formula 1 car, which is better in my opinion! 😁

    • @rosaria8384
      @rosaria8384 4 дні тому

      They had back in GT Sport but not anymore. Would rather see them do a Formula Gran Turismo with 2025 specs

  • @MatthiaGryffine
    @MatthiaGryffine 7 днів тому +1

    Surprised that they don't have the revised versions of circuits like Trial Mountain from GT7

  • @imliterallyjustjake
    @imliterallyjustjake 5 днів тому +1

    If F1 can actually pull off R246, they need to do it. Make a second race in Japan, I don’t think anyone would be mad at it whatsoever

  • @IIGrayfoxII
    @IIGrayfoxII 4 дні тому +1

    Glad you used the proper grand valley style and not that monstrositat called grand valley in GT7

  • @Villoresi
    @Villoresi 9 днів тому +3

    I would appreciate getting the full onboard lap with telemetry.
    Now then, I think I would have liked to have seen more of the pre-GT Sport circuits included. No offense to Lago Maggiore or Dragon Trail, but my definite preference is for the earlier, more organic designs from the GT series.
    If I was going to include any of the newer circuits, it would probably be Alsace, then followed by Kyoto-Yamagiwa. And if I was going to pick a City Circuit, too, then most likely, Shuto Expressway-East Loop.
    But yeah, seeing how the lap goes at places like Apricot Hill, El Capitan, New York City, Rome (GT2/GT3 version), and perhaps Madrid would be more up my alley.
    Even among the (somewhat) older designs, I think Eiger and Autumn Ring are a bit much.
    Also, Monaco has featured in the series, and I think doing something as close as possible to the 1973-75 layout would at least be interesting with the modern cars.
    I lie some elements of Cape Ring, but I thinks it's just "too much" and/or "too busy".
    I like 2 of the 3 Matterhorn layouts, but I recognize those are rather over-the-top.

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  9 днів тому +1

      I couldn’t do so many circuits because of the mods being not available or not good enough unfortunately. I really wanted to include Rome from GT5 but at the moment the only mod available is pretty much a pre-alpha.
      I played a lot of GT5 and Cape Ring was my favourite circuit but unfortunately there aren’t mods available of that track. At least i wasn’t able to find them.

    • @WolfoGangYT
      @WolfoGangYT 8 днів тому

      @@MarcoVilla1993oh yes Cape Ring was legendary and awesome😅🤩. Imagine the loop in a F1 Car

  • @Ramonatho
    @Ramonatho 3 дні тому

    Wow, I'm realizing how much the Vegas F1 circuit and Tokyo R246 are very similar...

  • @mohammednadasen-karim2055
    @mohammednadasen-karim2055 8 днів тому +3

    Deep forest raceway is pre GT7

  • @geoprancer
    @geoprancer 3 дні тому

    the GT7 layout of trial mountain would suit F1 more than the old layout

  • @neozone_tfp
    @neozone_tfp 2 дні тому

    If autumn ring comes back to GT7 I’m definitely racing a spec series with the (actually returning) 1992 Honda Civic Extra, and just run it like a cup on Autumn Ring Mini & the finale being a double head semi final and final with one being Suzuka east, and then the full autumn ring to finish or if all 3 come back, all final 3 rounds back to back, Apricot hill, Autumn ring, Silverstone international, not GP or National

  • @derosiflo6524
    @derosiflo6524 3 дні тому

    Deep forest layout in the lower left corner looks like the old Österreichring

  • @andreantunes1543
    @andreantunes1543 2 дні тому

    The Grand Valley one looks more like a mix of Trial Mountain and St.Croix itself

  • @IBNZ1W
    @IBNZ1W 4 дні тому

    Grand Valley actually looks kinda nice.

  • @清山下-o3p
    @清山下-o3p 2 дні тому

    gasly and tsunoda visited japan and seem to be driving and playing in japanese trucks

  • @MMR_LM
    @MMR_LM 4 дні тому

    Special Stage Route 5 at day is a crime

  • @rafaelpradosbarbosa9991
    @rafaelpradosbarbosa9991 9 днів тому +169

    Jus stick to the onboard camera man. The constant changes in the camera are really annoying...

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  9 днів тому +40

      Noted, thanks for the feedback. 😊

    • @MaximoSirianidelCarril
      @MaximoSirianidelCarril 8 днів тому

      Or sitck the onboard 1st and then the TV Camera ​@@MarcoVilla1993

    • @Jasonnf1
      @Jasonnf1 8 днів тому +39

      They arent that bad. Maybe just get solid 60fps. Getting the exterior shot where the car is taking high speed turns showing off the amount of grip the car produces is a nice touch

    • @BurnBot_TV
      @BurnBot_TV 7 днів тому +6

      Skill issue.

    • @ALR-MikeSans
      @ALR-MikeSans 7 днів тому +16

      Have you ever seen a GP of any motorsport?

  • @JDMcam702
    @JDMcam702 3 дні тому

    Need a part 2
    Can forget Apricot Hill

  • @Theb5638
    @Theb5638 4 дні тому

    5:49 going into here I would always flip

  • @MoparMeyhem
    @MoparMeyhem 2 дні тому

    Midfield Raceway feels the closest to a proper f1 ish track ngl

  • @antoninosardina7455
    @antoninosardina7455 8 днів тому +2

    Il deep-forest raceway sembra la versione old layout del circuito d'Austria

    • @nathanstroud2223
      @nathanstroud2223 8 днів тому

      I never really made that connection until I saw the updated version of the track for GT7, which added a tight "divebomb central" near-hairpin that reminds me of a similar corner on the current day Red Bull Ring.

  • @rayyagamer2011
    @rayyagamer2011 8 днів тому

    Bro iam imagining what if one of the drivers try to do the yeet jump at the last turn in trial mountain,its a type of thing stroll would do

  • @Fede89
    @Fede89 2 дні тому

    High speed ring ❤❤❤❤

  • @derekbrunette222
    @derekbrunette222 3 дні тому

    Grand Valley would be perfect, Most of the track has enough space for FIA grade 1 runoff areas. HOWEVER, the FIA would not like the tunnels

  • @AlanFormula12022
    @AlanFormula12022 6 днів тому

    I hope Tokyo R246 could replace Jeddah or Las Vegas.

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  5 днів тому

      I hope anything really could replace Jeddah or Las Vegas, i hate those new tracks. 🤣

  • @Pul160
    @Pul160 8 днів тому

    OOF there might be enough content to do a part 2! El Capitan, Cathedral Rocks, Grindelwald, Red Rock Valley, and I'm sure I'm missing some

  • @matthewmckinney5387
    @matthewmckinney5387 8 днів тому +1

    On gt5 in the f2007 Ferrari its possible to get sub 60 second laps at Tokyo r246

  • @ivato46
    @ivato46 3 дні тому

    grand valley is pretty good , its cery similar to zandvoort

  • @YT_timekiller001
    @YT_timekiller001 3 дні тому

    Uff, this really makes me appreciate the lighting of the GT games. They look so awful in this AC lighting.

  • @the_rustydoornob1164
    @the_rustydoornob1164 4 дні тому

    5:34 where u get the trial mountain track?

  • @cellphonelightsaber
    @cellphonelightsaber 4 дні тому

    11:41 oh shit that was flat out

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  4 дні тому +1

      @@cellphonelightsaber almost, just a tiny confidence lift due to the high curbs. Surely doable though.

  • @alitrin04
    @alitrin04 9 днів тому +2

    What ac mods are you using?

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  9 днів тому +4

      The car is the VRC Formula Alpha 2024:
      www.virtual-racing-cars.com/p/ac-formula-alpha-2024/
      The HUD is this one:
      www.patreon.com/CMRT/shop/cmrt-complete-hud-563983?source=storefront
      The tracks are all available by searching them on google, they're honestly not too hard to find. :-)

    • @alitrin04
      @alitrin04 9 днів тому +1

      @@MarcoVilla1993 thanks, imma try this out myself!

  • @FlashoftheBlades
    @FlashoftheBlades 8 днів тому

    Are there mods for the current layouts of High Speed Ring, Deep Forest Raceway and Trial Mountain?

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  8 днів тому

      I don’t think so, at least i couldn’t find them.

  • @mossy1496
    @mossy1496 8 днів тому

    Just curios, what are those throttle spikes on the telemetry when you are downshifting.

    • @mattjmck86
      @mattjmck86 8 днів тому

      Probably auto-blip or electronic kicker on the downshifts.

  • @musicwithcycling
    @musicwithcycling 3 дні тому

    TSU IN TOKYO ❤

  • @skyliner094
    @skyliner094 7 днів тому

    Tokyo is the most feasible but still, the highway ramp section in the 3rd sector would be a big no no for the fia, og deep forest would be perfect for indycar

  • @cellphonelightsaber
    @cellphonelightsaber 4 дні тому

    8:50 🅰️🙌

  • @PeterJamesVillegas
    @PeterJamesVillegas 3 дні тому

    Some of the circuits might work, if they were real....

  • @ManManSFT
    @ManManSFT 7 днів тому

    Imagine going flat our at 11:42

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  7 днів тому

      @@ManManSFT i tried a couple of times, the curbs are too high but with a perfect line in the perfect lap it’s possible.

  • @landy4497
    @landy4497 7 днів тому +1

    lago maggiore would go hard

  • @rosaria8384
    @rosaria8384 4 дні тому

    Only Lago Maggiore and Dragon Trail would fit in F1 ngl. The new iterations of Trial, Grand Valley, and Deep Forest aren't great for F1

  • @alexm3504
    @alexm3504 3 дні тому

    what game is this?

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  3 дні тому

      @@alexm3504 Assetto Corsa on PC with various mods.

  • @PrestageP
    @PrestageP 5 днів тому

    Not sure you are aware but your wheel is not able to handle the FFB that the game is giving it you can see next to the throttle the red is flashing like crazy which means your wheel is clipping. Turn down the FFB in game or on your base

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  5 днів тому

      Yes i know, thank you. 😊 Normally i set it up better but for this video i had a lot of tracks to drive and not much time to record. Also not every circuit gives problems to the force feedback. But yeah, i just need to lower it a bit. I have a Thrustmaster T818.

  • @TikyTheclown-GoldenBoy
    @TikyTheclown-GoldenBoy 7 днів тому

    i used one of this circuits which i crashed and flied away from the map ;-; lol

  • @donelmediterraneo8626
    @donelmediterraneo8626 5 днів тому

    Polyphony Digital are better at designing racing tracks than Herman Tilke

  • @Dilophosaurus_king
    @Dilophosaurus_king 4 дні тому

    You shouldve done lago maggiore reversed its way better

  • @TerkoizRHG
    @TerkoizRHG 5 днів тому

    No Special Stage Route 11? is it because it's too technical or something?

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  5 днів тому +1

      @@TerkoizRHG leaving something for Part 2! 😉

    • @TerkoizRHG
      @TerkoizRHG 5 днів тому

      @@MarcoVilla1993 Ok man, can't wait for it :D

  • @RodrigoBoschi
    @RodrigoBoschi 8 днів тому +1

    sono il tuo milleunesimo iscritto !

  • @94nolo
    @94nolo 3 дні тому

    no Seattle? lol

  • @edwardsicily
    @edwardsicily 9 днів тому

    Che ricordi

  • @scottl.1568
    @scottl.1568 6 днів тому +1

    No Complex String?!
    Delete your account....

    • @MarcoVilla1993
      @MarcoVilla1993  6 днів тому

      @@scottl.1568 If i put it in a part 2 can i keep my account? 🤣

  • @Railssob_Kaetson1
    @Railssob_Kaetson1 3 дні тому

    Graphics look absolutely horrible. Like a Wii version of Gran Turismo.

  • @WilliamRobinson-o4h
    @WilliamRobinson-o4h 8 днів тому +1

    Why does no one ever bother to add decent lighting to race room imports?