Deeply Understanding Chamkila | Video Essay

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 364

  • @gurjeetsing4160
    @gurjeetsing4160 7 місяців тому +117

    "Chamar Hun Bhookha nhi marunga"💪😇
    Very inspirational story of Amar Singh Chamkila saab❤❤❤🙏💐

  • @akanshaverma6236
    @akanshaverma6236 7 місяців тому +49

    "agar society art ko control karegi toh art kabhi bhi ban hee nahi payegi"...👏 💯

  • @Shayankhan48
    @Shayankhan48 7 місяців тому +523

    I think you forget to talk about Diljit the chameleon. I didn't see Diljit anywhere in this movie, it was always chamkila. Kuddos to Diljit for such a wonderful act.

    • @zaviyarahmad7266
      @zaviyarahmad7266 7 місяців тому +23

      Also Parineeti rocked as Amarjot

    • @shivanipardeshi3114
      @shivanipardeshi3114 7 місяців тому +13

      Yes award winning acting thi..

    • @saratdas1988
      @saratdas1988 7 місяців тому +4

      indeed... Iron Man ki yaad aa gayi. before 2008 I didn't even know about the comic book character... then I saw the movie witb RDJ and realised, iske alaawa koi nahi kar sakta tha ye role. Same for Diljit playing the eponymous role fo Chamkila.
      the end of the movie , during credits... where they blend it finally as "gaana wo gaa reha hain" par screen pe diljit aur parineeti... and it doesn't even look like a playback

    • @neelthegreat5764
      @neelthegreat5764 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@saratdas1988dost puri chamkila movie dekhne ke bad bhi tum ye keh rahe ho iske alawa koi ni kar sakta? Agar kisi ko chance milta he to vo bhi perform karega.. Dalit or unpadh hone ke bawjud chamkila ne jo perform kia vo koi bhi kar sakta he.. Vese hi diljit kya tum bhi uska role kar sakte ho.. Tarif karo kisi ki puja nahi..

    • @saratdas1988
      @saratdas1988 7 місяців тому +2

      @@neelthegreat5764 dekho sajeev lagne me to ek baat hoti hai na. Haan shaayd koi aur kar paaye, wohi as you said.. chance milega tab naa.. humko jo dikh raha hai busi pe bolenge na. Us hisaab se to Animal aur Gabbar ke baare mein bhi bola jaa sakta hai ke koi aur karta to shaayad alag hota aur achchha hota.. jo dikha hai usike baare me bol rahe hai kewal. good as a performance which seems embodying.. hence

  • @rahulnagarwal862
    @rahulnagarwal862 7 місяців тому +167

    After watching this movie i got the answer why imtiaz Ali made biopic?
    He doesn't force you to think that , "yahi bikta h to m bechunga" (like all other artists did). He doesn't impose that ," mere sath bura hua ya society gandi h to m bhi vaisa hi hu.."
    Because 1) chamkila gave the highest selling spiritual songs.
    2) He never made any vulgar songs after that.. he sang but not made.
    3) He resist to sing those songs as much as he could but he knows that this is public who can forgive you very easily.
    Now my opinion why he made this film :
    1) He wanna show that we as a society are very hypocate, we always have a problem who got fame. (All other artists sangs those vulgur songs but Target was always chamkila.
    2) If you are big enough then everyone try to get fame by pushing you down , like : without ever know reporters wrote about you.
    Dharam tries to impose their value and restrict you of doing many things which are unnecessary.
    3) Compititors try to defame you.

    • @swarajdash9975
      @swarajdash9975 7 місяців тому +1

      kya bak rya h bhai ?

    • @manisha551991
      @manisha551991 7 місяців тому +1

      Imtiaz Ali is a class director.i have never seen a director at least his generation who visualised songs as if they are themselves telling the story

  • @kushanchakraborty6770
    @kushanchakraborty6770 7 місяців тому +107

    The film works because:
    1. Great cinematography, direction, characterisation.
    2. Doesn't infantalise the audience and force them to think a particular way (ref: your point on glorification). Rather, it humanises everyone including the women who apparently the powers that be tried to protect, but who didn't need protection.
    3. Really takes us in the middle of the story - Punjab in the 80s. The production design, the language, the characters. All feel very realistic. The audience is bang in the middle of the action, and not viewing it as outsiders in 2024.
    It seems like Imtiaz Ali has really come of age with this film. For once, I liked Parineeti Chopra also.

    • @paras3271
      @paras3271 7 місяців тому

      Ha

    • @Jotu007
      @Jotu007 7 місяців тому +1

      Diljit se kya dikkat hai bhai uski bhi thodi tarif kardo

  • @tingneihatkuki8337
    @tingneihatkuki8337 7 місяців тому +42

    The honesty, admiration and dedication with which Diljit Dosanjh played the character was the most beautiful part of it.
    Aone if the most memorable scenes for me were: the delima he face leaving while handing over the cash to his 1st wife and their child, the moment wheb he see tve bug poster of his hero in Canada, the interview with the journalist explaining he doesn't have the power to decide the rights and wrongs about his singing (he is just catering to his audience and he just wants to sing), the place where he is almost tored and gave up thinking too much about the threats he qas facing.....

  • @devkrishnabhambri433
    @devkrishnabhambri433 7 місяців тому +14

    In this movie it is clearly depicted that how an artist is stuck between society and few portion of society which loves the same. Basically if artist try to change people don't accept that change and demand what he is not allowed by certain part of society. In this movie Chamikla made a statement "ki mein kiski suno logon ki jo mere show mein aate hai ya unki jo nahi aate hai". "Mein nahi bhi gaana chahon toh bhi log mujhse wohi chahte hai ki mein waise gaane gao". So as an artist should he stop singing or continue singing which will cost to his life. A great artist who kept on fighting till his last breath and was killed before watching himself on big screen in punjabi movie, which was his dream.

  • @Siiiddharth
    @Siiiddharth 7 місяців тому +63

    That cinematic frame where inspector is watching through window into past of Chamkila ❤️🫡🔥

  • @asf5275
    @asf5275 7 місяців тому +12

    The narrative of society vs art(artist) or their dependency on each other is shown very spontaneously by Imtiaz Ali Sir....
    There in a scene, a group of lady is criticizing the lyrics and suddenly the end up dancing on the chamkila type songs..... even the DSP, at the end takes out some records of chamkila, he kept secretly inside jeep....
    So.... how in spite of enjoying his song, people( few) were unable to accept due to society....
    Quality of art can't be measured , it's up to the observer.... what I like may not be liked by someone else....
    A true masterpiece from a master....❤❤

  • @kunalsingh8267
    @kunalsingh8267 7 місяців тому +14

    It's Masterpiece move from Imtiaz Ali sir. I really felt the emotions of Chamkila when he was confused and don't know what to do everything getting wrong for him but he always wanted to make audience happy.

  • @prasadjoshi4997
    @prasadjoshi4997 7 місяців тому +32

    I think the film is made perfectly. There is no loophole. The film is biopic of Amar Singh and the film shows the life journey of him. There is no over drama. Great performance of Diljit Dosanjh. So everything works for me. This is the best biopic i have seen after 12th fail

  • @Naturelife577
    @Naturelife577 7 місяців тому +22

    I don't know why everyone ignoring Diljit, The man praised by the legend SRK himself

  • @Tamtam-gz5bj
    @Tamtam-gz5bj 7 місяців тому +208

    Really liked the movie. It just makes you feel how hypocritical our society is

    • @CinemaDweller-qg3oq
      @CinemaDweller-qg3oq 7 місяців тому +7

      Like you... calling him khalistani without any proof 😂😂

    • @CinemaDweller-qg3oq
      @CinemaDweller-qg3oq 7 місяців тому

      @technoblade9924 lol......I hope you are not hindu who wants hindu rashtra.... Convert every person living in Indian to become hindu..... otherwise you are same as those who wants khalistan.....who wants to break this nation...... Or only people asking khalistan are bad? Not hindu rashtra people?

    • @ajk9233
      @ajk9233 7 місяців тому +14

      ​@technoblade9924 those who are in power want india to be hindu rashtra. Why don't you question that?

    • @harjasx
      @harjasx 7 місяців тому

      ​​​@technoblade9924 yall don't even have an idea about what this whole thing g is about and now jus target Sikhs because yall have been manipulated to do so. For God's sake or should I say for indias sake go and do some research about this thing from a somewhat neutral media. It was a political agenda implanted by your beloved gov only to use it as an escape to spread hate crime against Sikhs. On ground level you won't even cross paths with a single person IN INDIA who would say sum dumb shit like this. Yall jus use some 2-3 people outside of India Makin a fuss about it and draw a conclusion about the whole thing. Yall hypocrite af why don't yall call out the pro Hindu Rashtras such as bjp aren't they doing the same with India by fuckin up with it's secularism.
      Focus on the real issues to make it a better country rather than the issues created by the governments to win election around and you'll be adding sum to for the growth of this country instead of hatred
      What do you think you're doing by calling artists like him khalisani, Makin them more patriotic or hateful to the country ?

    • @empathy.11
      @empathy.11 7 місяців тому +2

      @technoblade9924 y'all say that hindus and sikhs are the same, so khalistan is also like hindu rashtra don't worry 😂😂😂😂

  • @khamoshi1819
    @khamoshi1819 7 місяців тому +71

    One of my favourite dialogue is -Duniya samajhdaari se nahi chalti bas chalti hi jaati he

  • @gurpriitchd
    @gurpriitchd 7 місяців тому +5

    This is a different style of filmmaking. Non judgemental portrayal of its protagonist. It doesn’t make the audience love or hate someone of the film. I watched the movie and it is a non dramatised account of the events from Chamkila’s life. It is a very honest film of an honest artist Chamkila. Daljit Dosanjh deserves an award for his acting.

  • @jiveshbrar6033
    @jiveshbrar6033 7 місяців тому +2

    The film was so grounded and raw, same locations, same people, same emotions, same thought process. Being a chamkila fan since childhood, I felt I wasnt even close to what chamkila actually was as an artist+ as a human. "doing his job honestly, took him away from us". thank you for the depth you told @5ocial team.

  • @sayan7314
    @sayan7314 7 місяців тому +7

    I REALLY liked the movie, especially the last 30 minutes of the movie, the last 30 mins shows how he fears the people threatening him, how he performs on the stage here his idol performed, HOW HE CHANGED, the scene where he light up a bidi just after taking the 4 promises- it showed that he became A KALAKAR, he is just totally engulfed in his art, now he doesn't fear anyone, dosent care about anyone, no society no threats, now its just him and his art. Just after that scene his friend says "us din mujhe samjha ke chamkila pagal ho chuka hai" aur sub ko pata hai har kalakar ko log peh leh pagal he keh teh hai😂. "YEAH BANDOOK WALEH HAI, INKA TOH KAAM HAI GOLI CHALANA TOH YEAH CHALA ENGAY, HUM GANE BANA NEH WALEH HAI HAMARA KAAM HAI GEET GA NA TOH HUM GAENGAY, NA WOH HAMAREH LIYE RUK NENGAY, NA HUM UN K LEA" he dosent care about right and wrong, now its just an artist performing his art. And the song MAINU VIDA KARO ❤ its lyrics .. it just sums it all ( am sure @inotherwords will make an analysis video on its lyrics, those who know will know) . Others might have different perspective, different option on it... but this is how i saw this movie .. sn

  • @akshitsingh2961
    @akshitsingh2961 7 місяців тому +27

    Just watched Amar Singh Chamkila and Elvis (Elvis is also a biopic based on the life of Elvis Presley) By watching both I got to know that just because of some people living in this society how great talents lead to death or change their real self for their lives. 90s India and 70s America level of thinking was the same...

  • @BELLION_Ashborne
    @BELLION_Ashborne 7 місяців тому +11

    Man the lyrics "TUM SABHI SAAF SAHI HUN MAATHMELA MAIN" what a performance by Diljit paaji❤❤ and pareeniti maam what a music/song by ar rehman sir and all the singers and the direction of the movie by imtiaz ali sir🔥🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐

  • @Souraav.guptaa
    @Souraav.guptaa 7 місяців тому +1

    I was blown away by the cinematography in "Amar Singh Chamkila"! They really nailed that gritty, realistic feel of 80s Punjab, especially during the concert scenes where it feels like you're in the crowd. But then they also have these flashback moments that are super nostalgic and soft, showing a different side of Chamkila.
    It's not just pretty pictures - the way they use split screens and mix in old footage tells the story of a singer caught in the middle of intense social change. Sometimes it's a bit jarring, but I think that's on purpose to keep you on your toes and show how complex his story really is. The cinematography adds this whole other layer to the film, making it a must-watch for the visuals alone.

  • @dhirenpariyar9294
    @dhirenpariyar9294 7 місяців тому +1

    Just finished watching the movie: "Amar Singh Chamkila" on Netflix.
    The best biopic movie i have ever seen so far!❤️Feels very realistic on every points of aspects without glorifying the character. Diljit Dosanjh and Parineeti Chopra has played their role very commendably👏
    and the screenplay, cinematography everything stands out perfectly.👌
    Imtiaz Ali and his team has created an true artist film with lots of grace and gratitude.
    It feels like Diljit Dosanjh wasn't playing the character but he was living as a character which made me feel very sad for the tragic death of Singer Amar Singh Chamkila and his wife Mrs. Amarjot Kaur.🥺
    Huge Respect to the Amar Singh Chamkila team from Nepal🇳🇵🙏

  • @dheerajpal9307
    @dheerajpal9307 7 місяців тому +23

    Movie me Chamkila or Babbi ki past journey dikhate hai, or khas moments show krte time director bich bich me unki dead bodies dikhate hai, to wo ek emotional hike dete hai unn moments ko, usse or jyada feel aata hai characters ke liye, and surely the starting scenes is one of the biggest in the film, literally shocked...

  • @moviecric700
    @moviecric700 7 місяців тому +36

    Very rare film
    EVERTHING WORKED FOR ME
    I NEITHER SKIPPED A SINGLE SECOND IN THIS FILM

  • @madhavanthegreat3813
    @madhavanthegreat3813 7 місяців тому +7

    I really think this is the best way of V presenting a video for the viewers instead of the face came where the camera quality is too low and the expression that he gives are not at all needed as we came to see a movie review

  • @ManpreeSingh799
    @ManpreeSingh799 7 місяців тому +4

    The ending song nd lyrics summed up whole Chamkla's life... really really appreciable ❤

  • @meettank5828
    @meettank5828 7 місяців тому +2

    chamkila is diljit's once in a lifetime performance . he literally lived that character . also parineeti showed potential for her character as amarjot . happy to see imtiaz ali's success after years :)

  • @Eatwithkaranvlogs
    @Eatwithkaranvlogs 7 місяців тому +5

    Brilliance in each and every department makes Amar Singh Chamkila a masterful depiction of a singer who was a superhit among masses

  • @SwarnkarVikash06
    @SwarnkarVikash06 7 місяців тому +2

    The Presentation of imtiaj Sir Just Fabulous. Look at the way he tells the story and in his every film songs are story driven type not like burden in story . He is just fantastic

  • @parthdabholkar_008
    @parthdabholkar_008 7 місяців тому +5

    i really enjoyed the film. this film really does not follow the pattern of an Imtiaz Ali film, and that is where Imtiaz Ali wins as a director. Thank you Vishal for such a correct commentry.

  • @subhrajbarman4849
    @subhrajbarman4849 7 місяців тому +2

    first of all we must appreciate Imtiaz Ali for such dramatic movie, this movie purely shows what was Punjab and how the people began to listen Chamkila . At that time people of Punjab was were surrounded by horrors of killings and societal norms. So Chamkila rose up there to soothen the moods and pressure of the people.

  • @lareveur6094
    @lareveur6094 7 місяців тому +8

    Apart for cinematic aspect what i liked in chamkila portrail is how satisfied he was with world and how much he achieved... Its like meditation

  • @GokulRao-i1b
    @GokulRao-i1b 7 місяців тому +11

    Diljit will finally get his breakthrough iam not a Punjabi but know Hindi and watch Hindi films and loved this guy in udta Punjab such a talented artist

    • @GokulRao-i1b
      @GokulRao-i1b 7 місяців тому +1

      Bro you are responding to a comment really 😱

  • @aliarmanapurbo-ih8xl
    @aliarmanapurbo-ih8xl 7 місяців тому +8

    I loved the movie.I am a big fan of Imtiaz Ali.I think the movie also talk about what is vulgure in our society.For example what Chamkila's father in law and mother in law did in the climax.

  • @sanchitpahwa
    @sanchitpahwa 7 місяців тому

    The beauty of the film is you can simply draw a parallel between Chamkila and Moosewala. Obviously no one wants to be evil/vulgar/unusual, but if the society loves them for that, the artist has to portray that role his entire life. Moosewala sang "Shaam Te Savere Bhaalde Vivaad Ne, Aiven Tere Naal Karde Fasaad Ne, Chauvi Ghante Naale Nind-de Paraune Nu, Naale Ohde Kalle Kalle Geet Yaad Ne" where he's talking about the media and the society in general, stating that they try to involve him in controversies day and night, but still remember his songs word by word. Most of the people I know don't even know the lyrics of Moosewala songs but still vibe to them, I think that is the power of creativity and music which breaks barriers, and even if people understand the lyrics, they love him more, that's why his videos have millions of views and that only is the reason that Chamkila's records were also sold in millions. During the first part of the film, you can see that the DSP (first of all, the guy who played the DSP was fantastic as he had the perfect blend of the devilish and sympathetic mindset of that of a senior policeman) was kinda negligent towards Chamkila's fame because he had a pre generated image of him as a vulgar and fluke-ish, aira gaira types, but as he got to know about him from his close ones, he got the real image and you can see by the end of the film, during the music video of "Vida Karo" when the Commissioner is saying that Chamkila was this Chamkila was that, portraying him negatively, the DSP stood silent because he knew the truth but he had to stay shut because that's what society is, you can't argue with your seniors or else you will invite trouble.

  • @abyheek7037
    @abyheek7037 7 місяців тому +34

    The song "Vida Karo" exemplified how is life was , "Tum sabhi pak sahi, paap ka dariya main" and people loved those songs even though he once tried to change to decent songs but people demanded the vulgar ones.

  • @bruceWayne.darKnight
    @bruceWayne.darKnight 7 місяців тому +64

    Chamkila🤝Sandeep Reddy Vanga, this statement deepens as much as you think of it.

    • @meghzaikovlogs7300
      @meghzaikovlogs7300 7 місяців тому +2

      One of the bestest❤

    • @sachinsingh2983
      @sachinsingh2983 7 місяців тому +5

      Brother sandee is half minded this is true

    • @dakshchopra1299
      @dakshchopra1299 7 місяців тому +2

      This point was rolling in my head this afternoon a lot!

  • @sajeevsarathie
    @sajeevsarathie 7 місяців тому +8

    I wrote this on my page
    अमर सिंह चमकीला जितने लोकप्रिय थे,अपने गीतों के "अश्लील" बोलों के लिए उतने ही बदनाम भी रहे। चमकीला जन साधारण के कवि थे, जो वही लिखते रहे, और उसी भाषा में लिखते रहे जिसमें वो पले बढ़े थे। जहां एक बड़ा जन समूह उनके इन गीतों से अनायास ही जुड़ जाता था वहीं कुछ लोगों को लगता था कि उनके गीत औरतों को गलत अंदाज में प्रस्तुत करते हैं और युवाओं के जेहन को भष्ठ कर रहे हैं।
    इम्तियाज चमकीला को किसी हीरो की तरह पेश नहीं करते, बल्कि उन्हें उनकी सारी कमियों के साथ परदे पर उतारते हैं और हर कुछ सीन्स के बाद इनपर कटाक्ष करती कुछ लाइंस भी आ जाती है, फिर वो विरोध धर्म के ठेकेदारों से हो या फिर चमकीला के खुद के घर से। इस देश के लोक गीतों में पुरुष और स्त्री की सोच, काम वासना आदि को लेकर हमेशा ही छेड़ छाड़ भरे अंदाज के चुटीले गीतों की परंपरा रही है जिन्हें औरतें भी चाव से गाती सुनती आई है। मैं बोतल शराब की हूं मुझे गट गट पी ले पर आपत्ति जताने वाले ड्राइंग रूम में बैठकर किसी अधनंगी मॉडल को सॉफ्ट ड्रिंक के विज्ञापन में बोतल की शेप में ढलते देख वाह वाह करते नहीं थकते। इम्तियाज समाज के इस दोगलेपन पर भी फिकरा कसते हैं।
    उनकी फिल्मों की खासियत होती है कि फिल्म के नायक नायिका ही नहीं बल्कि हर छोटे से छोटा किरादार भी आपको याद रह जाता है, बेहतरीन स्टोरी प्रेजेंटेशन और संगीत तो होता ही है शानदार। इस फिल्म में ये सब है, दरअसल ये विंटेज इम्तियाज की वापसी है। इरशाद और रहमान की जोड़ी का यादगार संगीत, मैनू विदा करो, नरम कलेजा, तू क्या जाने जैसे बेमिसाल गीत, और उनका फिल्मांकन, दिलजीत और परिणीति की माइंड ब्लोइंग परफार्मेंस और इन सबको बखूबी समेटता इम्तियाज का निर्देशन, अमर सिंह चमकीला को एक कभी न भूलने वाला अनुभव बना देता है।
    फिल्म के हर पक्ष पर बहुत कुछ बोलने का मन है पर फिलहाल संक्षेप में बस इतना ही कि बिना एक भी पल गंवाए देख डालिए इस फिल्म को नेटफ्लिक्स पर।
    #punjabimusic #highpitchedvocals #tumbi #amarsinghchamkila #dugri #ludhiana #elvisofpunjab #ImtiazAli #diljitdosanjh #ParineetiChopra #arrahman #AnjumBatra #mohitchauhan #arijitsingh #IrshadKamil #Netflix #chamkilamovie

  • @ndroidvalley8510
    @ndroidvalley8510 7 місяців тому +8

    The film delivered us a harsh example of our society

  • @MrJapjotSingh
    @MrJapjotSingh 7 місяців тому +5

    #myopinion Imtiaz Ali's film "Chamkila" sparks my interest, especially when compared to last year's "Jodi" directed by Amberdeep Singh. Interestingly, "Jodi" was also inspired by Chamkila's life, depicting the story of an artist named Sitara. As you rightly mentioned, a biopic should avoid glorifying a hero's life excessively. However, "Jodi" seemed to fall into this trap at times. For instance, there were scenes where Sitara's controversial songs were glorified, and he himself felt ashamed of their vulgarity. Similarly, the comparison between his songs and mainstream Hindi songs seemed to justify his explicit content. In both "Chamkila" and "Jodi," there were depictions of the artist's involvement in films, portraying the legacy he left behind. Despite these shortcomings, both films succeeded in capturing hearts and delivering memorable music. Diljit's performance in "Jodi" was particularly noteworthy, adding fire to the screen.

  • @yashkajal4646
    @yashkajal4646 7 місяців тому +3

    A film that makes an impact on my thinking process that an artistic soul always harrassed by typical practices of society and in the end either art dies or the artist. A strong narrative and screenplay works for me so loud and hats off to it's makers so brave . I want our cinema to exactly like this beutiful and real for audience that's all from my thinking 😊

  • @SPturns
    @SPturns 7 місяців тому +5

    For me,Ishq Mitaye song was a fresh breath as I expected a long dramatic scene after Chamkila's death at the beginning of the movie

  • @souravdhara8498
    @souravdhara8498 7 місяців тому +3

    Kuch anokha dekhne mila . Chamkila dekhne k bad uske bare m or janne ka man kia. Imtiyaz Ali kya derection kia h . Maja ageya behtirin krigiri

  • @skaar7
    @skaar7 7 місяців тому +3

    everything worked in this movie bro. i found myself rewinding so many scenes

  • @dikshachaudhary7253
    @dikshachaudhary7253 7 місяців тому +1

    sach kahu to aisa laga ki jaise bade dino baad pet bhar ke khana khaya.... wo sukoon mila.... totally worth it...

  • @m_bochare
    @m_bochare 7 місяців тому

    I didn't know anything about chamkila I just randomly started watching it and was shocked by the beginning of the film, the way imtiaz Ali has captured the scene it worked perfectly, reminded me of the way Villeneuve's polytechnic has started, amazing film, amazing video ❤

  • @chetanj19
    @chetanj19 7 місяців тому +17

    Imtiaz Ali film ❤

  • @eudemus
    @eudemus 7 місяців тому +2

    Aapka perspective Imtiaz Ali ke perception ke kaafi kareeb hai.❤

  • @shahidmehmood9702
    @shahidmehmood9702 7 місяців тому +1

    Actually this was the film , where I can't describe the energy i felt after watching. Its was something new, different. I felt chamkilla already new he will be killed , but he continued. Yes you are right, Imtiaz sir didn't white washed his bad aspects , he just showed how a normal man would do with opportunities presented to him . As chamkila said " pehlay kam krletay hai phir bad mei beith kr sochy gay sahi tha k galt'

  • @ushamehar7927
    @ushamehar7927 7 місяців тому

    I like the movie a lot, can't imagine that it's a imtiaz ali's movie...
    He make a documentary movie with almost a perfect cinematography of 70's and 80's era,.....animation , real photos and lyrics explain leaves a big impact on us. 0ne of the best documentary movie I ever seen...
    Shows all the stages of feeling what chamkila thinks and how he manage to deal with it...
    But demand the government of find the culprit of assassination of chamkila and his wife...

  • @krunalkule306
    @krunalkule306 7 місяців тому +1

    Chamkila showed the mirror to the society and few society members denied it.

  • @JaggieTv
    @JaggieTv 7 місяців тому +1

    & what about diljit ?

  • @siqlainhaider2917
    @siqlainhaider2917 7 місяців тому

    This is Imtiaz Ali's masterpiece
    Masterpiece of film making....

  • @divyaprakashmishra5667
    @divyaprakashmishra5667 7 місяців тому +2

    Imtiyaz Ali is the wonderful director.And Rockstar or Amar Singh Chamkila both are the too nice films . But the fact is that these two actor -director dues of Ranbir Kapoor & Imtiyaz Ali and Diljit Dosanjh & Imtiyaz Ali both are outstanding and wonderful.

  • @paulneo21
    @paulneo21 7 місяців тому +2

    The song VIDA KARO speaks the heart of Chamkila and it's sad the society now is still the same as during Chamkila's time.

  • @lalithab9039
    @lalithab9039 7 місяців тому

    Due to Imtiaz Ali Sir we are able to know about Chemkila. As you said it sometimes depicted as a documentary and as a movie. Its a master piece.

  • @chinmayoak4398
    @chinmayoak4398 7 місяців тому +2

    For Oscars? Not because i agree or i don't. Because it's a very genuine blend of multiple cinema related thoughts

  • @saratdas1988
    @saratdas1988 7 місяців тому +1

    2 distinct soundtracks in one movie.. the original's recreations- and the 2nd by a.r.rahman and irshad kamil.
    the song naram kaalja though... highlights the duality of society very well

  • @priyanshjain7506
    @priyanshjain7506 7 місяців тому

    I think its a great movie.. It amazingly portrays the dual nature of the society like in the scene at Amarjot's house her family were talking about can a man think of such vulgar lyrics and a minute later they all accepted their notorious side and started dancing on similar songs.
    Adding on to the 5ocial's analysis, Chamkila always had a choice to stop singing vulgar songs but the moral dilemma becomes his weakness and he fails to keep the promise everytime. This shows a lot about his personality that he secretly liked singing all those songs.

  • @santoshsadanshiv6259
    @santoshsadanshiv6259 7 місяців тому +1

    That Last song was at next level

  • @rijuwanahaque8054
    @rijuwanahaque8054 7 місяців тому

    I loved-
    1. Diljit
    2. Parineeti
    3. Co actors
    4. Everything ❤

  • @vishalgupta5164
    @vishalgupta5164 7 місяців тому +1

    Ye aisi movie h jise dekhne ke baad sayad hi koi ek scene Dil or dimag se utra ho❤

  • @AshishKumar-cj6fv
    @AshishKumar-cj6fv 7 місяців тому +2

    As a punjabi I like the movie ,chamkila songs and Diljit paji..

  • @TarsbirSinghnatt
    @TarsbirSinghnatt 7 місяців тому +4

    Yes definitely right but when a person when the person on the top the Rivals and his relatives also jealous because he is the man who own the industry

  • @mishrashiva9543
    @mishrashiva9543 7 місяців тому +8

    Need a movie on Shiv Kumar batalavi ❤

    • @sukhanpreetsingh2395
      @sukhanpreetsingh2395 7 місяців тому +1

      Panjab has great history

    • @NailsByAsh813
      @NailsByAsh813 7 місяців тому

      ​@@sukhanpreetsingh2395So does every other state in this country. 😂😂

  • @rajdeepdhillon92
    @rajdeepdhillon92 7 місяців тому

    It’s was a great movie from every aspect right from the beginning to end. The way of story telling was really catchy. Thrilling performance by Diljit Dosanjh & Tikki (Chamkila’s Friend). Vibe of music as they created so real as it was during the era of 80’s that was an authentic touch of Movie. Effortless Acting by Diljit Dosanjh & perfect Direction by Imtaz Ali. 🙌🙌

  • @ashishthefoodmaniac9239
    @ashishthefoodmaniac9239 7 місяців тому

    I am so lost in the world amar singh chamkila
    The last time i was lost in a biopic was 12 years ago with Pan Singh Tomar.
    Diljit Dosanjh! You're the pride of indian cinema a true artist

  • @aniruddhamane4007
    @aniruddhamane4007 7 місяців тому

    "Your explanation was really beautiful. It made me connect with the movie for the past two days. It's been on my mind."

  • @Proudpunjabi1512
    @Proudpunjabi1512 7 місяців тому

    Diljit ki pehli movie dekhi ha jis man diljit ko real acting man dekha ha.ye imtiaz sir ka kamal ha...

  • @PoorMovieGoer
    @PoorMovieGoer 7 місяців тому +1

    Yeh ab tak ka Imtiaz ki sabse acha kaam hai

  • @Sumit_pandey77
    @Sumit_pandey77 7 місяців тому +1

    CHAMKILA IS MASTERPIECE FOR ME..

  • @rajpreetk610
    @rajpreetk610 7 місяців тому

    Diljit showed his best in this movie. Just loved to see the movie again and again

  • @rashandhillon795
    @rashandhillon795 7 місяців тому +1

    Diljit naam hi kafi he♥️

  • @sancharipathak9051
    @sancharipathak9051 7 місяців тому

    The best dialogue is " Hum jaiso ko to bas jaise taise karke jina hota hain" Agar main ap jaisa hota to aap ati kya.
    The next thing is real life photography which are perfect place.

  • @amoniBohemian
    @amoniBohemian 7 місяців тому

    Ek baaat aur Bhaiya ❤Stage p Jo bhi seeen ar song h wo real m Chamkila ka original h❤

  • @sanchay8701
    @sanchay8701 7 місяців тому

    As shown in the movie chamkila was grown up listening to local folk songs of punjab which were also vulgar so he sang like that this is most of the old punjab music decades se aisa hee chalta aarha tha punjab ne chamkila ne kuch naya nahi kiya tha bas chamkila kee young age me kam time me itni jyada fame gain krne se dusre singers jal gaye jaisa movie me dikhaya aur bas unhone usko girwana chaha aur jab chamkila ka sathi police waalo se kehta hai ki janta ko kya sunna hai kaun chunta hai? Ekdum sahi baat boli usne janta ko jo sunna janta hi chunti hai chamkila ne unpe force nahi kiya ki yehi suno

  • @Laxmi.Pandor
    @Laxmi.Pandor 7 місяців тому +2

    Please! Vi give review of these amazing movies:-
    1. Aadujeevitham (The GOAT Life)
    2. DUNE
    3. Bramayugam
    4. Manjummel boys
    5. Gaami

  • @suryavardhansharma9353
    @suryavardhansharma9353 7 місяців тому

    direction to storytelling everything gives you a new way of presenting a story , a story of how hypocrite society is and how a artist who just wanted to be with his art and society doesn't let him to do the same . My pov is the same as yours, society doesn't allow us to follow "right to express" because they just can't bear the truth or things which are close to truth which i believe was shown in this movie as well and and projects like Tandav which gave us an on point view regarding via its political commentary , which ultimately results in cancelling or get edited like Kashyap's maximum city. As it restricts the flimmaker to go away from reality , and the same reason i loved this flim because it give you how, what and why everything happen in there true sense.

  • @VikasSenMusicLover
    @VikasSenMusicLover 7 місяців тому +1

    👍🏻 chamkila is totally new experience for us

  • @rohitverma3120
    @rohitverma3120 7 місяців тому

    I just loved this film...ending jaante hue bhi I was just enjoying this movie....itni achhi screenplay performance by actors, costume.... originality ko barkarar rakhna....
    Mujhe film mein sabse achhi baat woh lagi Jo kumud Mishra ke jariye samjhane ki koshish ki gayi....aur woh bilkul sahi hai

  • @25thfilmsbyparth
    @25thfilmsbyparth 7 місяців тому

    Masterpiece “Amar Singh Chamkila”❤

  • @voyagerway6401
    @voyagerway6401 7 місяців тому

    Ek taraf hamare yaha BMCM jaisi movies banti hai,,,jinki itni hype kar di jaati hai,,,or ek ye chamikla ,,,This is the real content ,,,,

  • @gmauryamails
    @gmauryamails 7 місяців тому +1

    I think this is Daljeet's best performance.

  • @pal4566
    @pal4566 7 місяців тому +5

    So much to say about this movie:
    1) At least respect people in their death.
    2) Imtiaz Ali touches the right strings of 'slice of life' and 'hauntingness of stardom' with this one.
    3) Trying to pacify everyone in the world, like many of Imtiaz's characters do is like moths running straight into the flame.
    4) This feels so close to reality, to the point I've not quite seen in films before. The dialogues, gestures, acting, and interactions all feel like how would people talk in real life. It brings a genuine feeling.
    5) Diljit's charm is through the roof, even when he's succumbing to the dark side.
    6) every character feels human. There is not glorification of any of the grey acts committed.
    7) just a thought: when the deed is done and all is said and gone, and you sit in the middle of the night wondering what went wrong. And even if you knew about it... Would you change it?

  • @rudraprakashdash1985
    @rudraprakashdash1985 7 місяців тому +1

    Chamkila for me is a very different kind of biopic bcoz as said in th video it doesn't glorify the artist... In the opening scene we did Chamkila getting kind hence throughout the film we want to know the reason for why he got killed....evenually the filmakers wanted tht as in the process of generating pityness for Chamkila we see the rise of him as a mass hero.

  • @kamranashraf2433
    @kamranashraf2433 7 місяців тому +1

    This is imtiaz ali best work

  • @jaspreetclar4788
    @jaspreetclar4788 7 місяців тому +2

    One of the best film!

  • @lakshyathakkar2011
    @lakshyathakkar2011 7 місяців тому

    Best deeply understand on chamkila.
    Firstly I loved
    about its cinematography, songs and diljit doshanjh 's performance.
    I really liked imtiaz ali's direction. ❤😊😊

  • @pashtosongs848
    @pashtosongs848 7 місяців тому

    No one has the right to ask people to select this or that. I am in love with chamkila and his devotion. Remember I first came to know about chamkila 3 days before the movie

  • @marwanmahmud1357
    @marwanmahmud1357 7 місяців тому

    This is a finest film making by Imtiaz Ali.
    Deserves a National award
    For AR Rahman, Imtiaz Ali, Diljit Dosanj.

  • @ashminsingh3193
    @ashminsingh3193 7 місяців тому +1

    diljit paaaji was outstanding.......

  • @Shayankhan48
    @Shayankhan48 7 місяців тому +1

    This movie made me think that nothing is wrong and nothing is right in this world

  • @aamhuman
    @aamhuman 7 місяців тому

    whole another league, another masterpiece for lifetime

  • @rahulssachdeva090
    @rahulssachdeva090 7 місяців тому

    I like the movie because bhut deep thi , koi khule aam kuch kre toh glt h pr sb chupke vo hi kr rhe h or vo shi h ...

  • @RishabhSingh-ou1qq
    @RishabhSingh-ou1qq 7 місяців тому

    The detection singing and screen play and acting all together ❤❤❤

  • @jasssomal9977
    @jasssomal9977 7 місяців тому +6

    I am from Punjab and also from sikh family.
    Chamkila is very very very popular and have cult audience even today in Punjab, haryana and Rajasthan's some parts.
    He died at the age of 27 but i shocked how fast and growing his life he married two times and see so much popularity. It's too too much for a simple person from village. I think if he cross his 30s maybe he starts good songs because his children grown up and then he also realized.

  • @ketankhanna1608
    @ketankhanna1608 7 місяців тому

    I was waiting for your take on Chamkila movie ❤❤❤❤ really Imtiaz Ali is my role model the way he shows movies are truly masterpiece in storytelling ❤❤❤❤ After Jab we met Chamkila is 2nd best film of Imtiaz Ali and bestest performance by Diljit and parineeti ❤❤❤❤ever I want to experience this kind of films in theatre but 😭 Imtiaz Ali took right decision to release in ott to reach the every target audience fastly ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @ss.shikharshukla
    @ss.shikharshukla 7 місяців тому

    2:21 mujhe toh samjh aagaya tha ki killing scene hai starting,setup hi aisa kar rahe the ki kuch unexpected hone wala hai.
    Baar baar yeh lines use karna "aa raha hai chamkila" and uski tarif,log bahut jyada excited hai,wait kar kar rahe hai and then chamkila ke aate hi uski death

  • @ayeshasyed1682
    @ayeshasyed1682 7 місяців тому +3

    Can anyone explain why exactly did Chamkila feel bad after his show sold more tickets than Amitabh's? 5:52

    • @iamPrinceK
      @iamPrinceK Місяць тому +1

      Same question popped in my mind

  • @cbcreation3569
    @cbcreation3569 7 місяців тому

    We need this type of movies making.

  • @pritisharma9490
    @pritisharma9490 7 місяців тому

    Beautiful movie!! Bollywood me logo ko sikhna chahiye ki ek biopic ese banai jati hai. Literally movie ye sochne par majboor kr deti h ki kya chamkila galat tha? Mere opinion me to nhi.