I am deeply convinced that the most important thing in the CW is reception. The main training time should be aimed at this, because the better you recognize the melodies of the CW signs, the faster and better your QSOs will be. On which key to work - everyone chooses for himself. Both on the straight and on the iambic key, in any case, you will pass through the melodies of the signs. I use both types, according to my mood) 73 best wishes de R4PGC
Great advice. Learn to send with a straight key first and get the spacing right. After a while you will just "know" what sounds right regardless of the speed. CW is my favorite mode since I was first licensed in 1959. 73 to all de K7RMJ Frank
As a professional musician, I can vouch for teaching and learning the code using a straight key. The straight key at least forces one to learn the rhythm of the key. Good straight key technique allowed me to form coherent code with a bug, when I was pursuing my Extra. Paddles and bugs are a lousy way to acquire a decent fist for the inexperienced. - AL7W
I'm learning CW presently, and I have both a Begali Simplex and the large Putikeeg straight key, which is about ten times more well made than it has any business being at the price. I was making a video for facebook this evening, and I was trying to explain the difference in a manner that non-hams would understand. I came up with an analogy that I think works quite nicely. I'm probably not the first to come up with it. But I explained it like this: The straight key is a piano. Paddles are a synthesizer. Everything a piano does is controlled in real-time by the operator. A synthesizer, on the other hand, is programmed in advance, and hitting a key essentially just plays what is pre-programmed. I had the Begali first, during my first three or so attempts to learn CW, and I acquired the straight key this week because I saw someone on youtube say "learn to send on a straight key first." Luckily, I'm not very far along, so switching between the two isn't a big deal. My routine is as follows: Add a letter, and practice copying using software. Then, once I hit 90 percent, I send the random string of letters generated by the software with both the straight key, and then the paddles until I can get my CW decoder to 90%. This way, I'm practicing receiving and sending concurrently as I add letters to my repertoire. This is working quite nicely so far. I'm training at 25WPM character, 15WPM effective. With the Begali, I can send at 25WPM no problem, but definitely cannot copy and that effective speed, yet.
I too am going to learn code and have a J38. I would like to know how to properly set one up. Tension and gap is what I am trying to set. Appreciate you and your videos. Am also a licensed pilot and wish you well in your aviation endeavors. KG5KRQ
can't you just change the wpm of the keyer in the rig? the dot dash ratio is also adjustable so a super slow keyer can use paddles fine if their rig allows for these adjustments.
I have heard that answer many times, but it is absolutely wrong for me. I have had repetitive motion issues, so I purchased a good paddle (Kent) even though I have had a J38 since I was a teenager. The proper way to learn code is to use the Farnsworth method. Make character speed around 18 wpm but leave space between characters to achieve a slower speed. Some say start with 25 wpm character speed. The ARRL code practice over the air is done that way, 18 wpm character speed for all slower code speeds starting with 5 wpm. I look for slower code on air to practice copying, but much of the straight key slow code is so bad it is hard to copy. Learning on a paddle will make your sending better and make the transition to faster speeds quicker. 73 Kent K9AEE
Can slow key people understand fast key? Can fast key people understand slow key? Doesn't matter how fast you are if nobody understands your call for help.
This advice has never been clear to me. If you start with a paddle you are getting lots of practice hearing the proper length and spacing. Learning to use a paddle takes a few minutes. I know, because this is how I started. I have yet to get into straight keys, but I'm confident that when I do I will have those aural patterns cemented in my head to guide me.
2022 is my year for CW. I plan to take the ARRL CW class (already bought the CD set). I plan to buy the finger keyer for POTA use, but may get a paddle set later. Any recommendations? Advice? Thoughts? de W4CEC
I am deeply convinced that the most important thing in the CW is reception. The main training time should be aimed at this, because the better you recognize the melodies of the CW signs, the faster and better your QSOs will be. On which key to work - everyone chooses for himself. Both on the straight and on the iambic key, in any case, you will pass through the melodies of the signs. I use both types, according to my mood)
73 best wishes de R4PGC
Great advice. Learn to send with a straight key first and get the spacing right. After a while you will just "know" what sounds right regardless of the speed. CW is my favorite mode since I was first licensed in 1959. 73 to all de K7RMJ Frank
As a professional musician, I can vouch for teaching and learning the code using a straight key. The straight key at least forces one to learn the rhythm of the key. Good straight key technique allowed me to form coherent code with a bug, when I was pursuing my Extra. Paddles and bugs are a lousy way to acquire a decent fist for the inexperienced. - AL7W
I'm learning CW presently, and I have both a Begali Simplex and the large Putikeeg straight key, which is about ten times more well made than it has any business being at the price. I was making a video for facebook this evening, and I was trying to explain the difference in a manner that non-hams would understand. I came up with an analogy that I think works quite nicely. I'm probably not the first to come up with it. But I explained it like this: The straight key is a piano. Paddles are a synthesizer. Everything a piano does is controlled in real-time by the operator. A synthesizer, on the other hand, is programmed in advance, and hitting a key essentially just plays what is pre-programmed.
I had the Begali first, during my first three or so attempts to learn CW, and I acquired the straight key this week because I saw someone on youtube say "learn to send on a straight key first." Luckily, I'm not very far along, so switching between the two isn't a big deal. My routine is as follows: Add a letter, and practice copying using software. Then, once I hit 90 percent, I send the random string of letters generated by the software with both the straight key, and then the paddles until I can get my CW decoder to 90%. This way, I'm practicing receiving and sending concurrently as I add letters to my repertoire. This is working quite nicely so far. I'm training at 25WPM character, 15WPM effective. With the Begali, I can send at 25WPM no problem, but definitely cannot copy and that effective speed, yet.
You are a great Elmer 👍
Thank you!
I too am going to learn code and have a J38. I would like to know how to properly set one up. Tension and gap is what I am trying to set. Appreciate you and your videos. Am also a licensed pilot and wish you well in your aviation endeavors. KG5KRQ
Thank you, Dave. I learned CW on a straight key when 12. N0QFT
can't you just change the wpm of the keyer in the rig? the dot dash ratio is also adjustable so a super slow keyer can use paddles fine if their rig allows for these adjustments.
I have heard that answer many times, but it is absolutely wrong for me. I have had repetitive motion issues, so I purchased a good paddle (Kent) even though I have had a J38 since I was a teenager. The proper way to learn code is to use the Farnsworth method. Make character speed around 18 wpm but leave space between characters to achieve a slower speed. Some say start with 25 wpm character speed. The ARRL code practice over the air is done that way, 18 wpm character speed for all slower code speeds starting with 5 wpm. I look for slower code on air to practice copying, but much of the straight key slow code is so bad it is hard to copy. Learning on a paddle will make your sending better and make the transition to faster speeds quicker. 73 Kent K9AEE
Dave, please check the spelling of the word “straight” in the beginning of the video, upper left corner of screen.
Argh!
THANKS FOR THE INFO. 73, KE7LGD SOUTHWEST , UTAH
Thanks for the video, Dave. That's good advice! My problem is that I *send* morse *WAY* faster than I can receive!! LOL!
73 de Karl, VE3GUN FN04
Rip tilty lamp :(
Can slow key people understand fast key?
Can fast key people understand slow key?
Doesn't matter how fast you are if nobody understands your call for help.
This advice has never been clear to me. If you start with a paddle you are getting lots of practice hearing the proper length and spacing. Learning to use a paddle takes a few minutes. I know, because this is how I started. I have yet to get into straight keys, but I'm confident that when I do I will have those aural patterns cemented in my head to guide me.
2022 is my year for CW. I plan to take the ARRL CW class (already bought the CD set). I plan to buy the finger keyer for POTA use, but may get a paddle set later. Any recommendations? Advice? Thoughts? de W4CEC
2 dits, 4 dits, 6 dits, a "dah"-lar... All for straight keys stand up and holler.
.... .. .... ..