For those who don't understand about the same last name thing. Just ask yourself this question, why do we have the same last name even though we r not related by blood. Too many decades ago, we all scattered to many places, we don't know the true story but please respect each other as if the same last names r all from the same dad.
Yet we have the same surname as the Chinese or Korean yet we don't identify as either. Moreover, a majority of Hmong choose not to identify as Chinese/Miaozu yet continue to have their surname.
I don't get it with Hmong culture...it's wrong to date someone of your same last name (who might not even be related to you), but it's okay to marry your blood related 1st cousin (which is illegal in the United States)?!!!
They don’t Allow us in Hmong culture because it’s just how the rules is they always say it’s either your brother/sister your talking if it your same last name
Agreed.. and genetically 1st cousins are a no no. But Hmong people have lack of education back then so they made up random rules that made no sense. First cousins is just gross 🤢🤮🤮🤮🤢
Hey taboo cause he ate a heart when he is a boy. And his curse was he fell in love with a Yang girl but can marry cause of there last name. If your confused.
Hish-n-k Production can you guys do a full cover of the guy's version singing 'kuv hlub koj' as shown in the video 19:24. Please reply. I've been waiting.
Sorry to say from a Yang family. But this video makes no sense. Why we don’t eat heart is not because of taboo. I’m a little offended by the mean of this video. Why because this tells me that this younger generation don’t know about their culture. Other than that great movie and acting bravo.
Great portrayal of a contemporary conflict in the Hmong community. I just want to correct the pronoun in the dialogue "peb" (you plus 2 or more) to "wb" (strictly you and another person). Also, nouns are usually before adjectives. So it'll be "plawv qaib." Overall, incredible job!!
This story video is all wrong about the last name eating heart for guys n the taboo. Get the history correct before putting it out there like this young kids will get the wrong info.
This story was wrong when the title said chicken heart...I thought it was a movie about the yangs, actually the boys can’t eat the heart....if they eat they will go blind not taboo. Before do this movie they should asked the true..this story should called dating the same last name not chicken heart. I am a yang my parents told me that yang boys can’t eat chicken heart or they will go blind, but the yang girls can eat the heart, nothing wrong to the girls, not eating the heart to date or taboo. They should made two separated movies chicken heart and taboo are not the same. It didn’t make any sense since the beginning to the end.
Does it make sense if Hmong, we don’t care about our last name, if we could marry our same last name then it’s just the same we don’t have last name and it’s the same you trying to take our Hmong last name away. Have you ever heart or known there is a group of people any where on earth doesn’t have last name, if you do then please let me know, otherwise we are a little bit crazy for love when we still young but reputation means nothing to our future. Leadership only good or famous for better blood line. This is an acting or a movie but it could confuse our people specially the new generation. Our last name only can tell who we are, if you love Hmong or love yourself as a Hmong then do not destroy our only best we known.
Yes and no. I would like to because at least when we get married I don't have to worry about changing my last name. I mean feeling disowned hurts but I have to choose my own path and my own happiness I can't let my family control my life and control my happiness. It's my life and my choice. To me if it meant to losing everything I had I am willing to because I am with the person I love. I would like to suffer the hardship and pain in life with them.
I’m glad to see this reality exist within the Hmong community. I’m aware of the same surname prohibition but I’m against this unwritten rule of couples dating someone of the same surname even when there’s no familial relation between the two families. This is one aspect within the hmong culture that needs to change. It’s better to have our hmongs marry and stick together than have them marry off to some other race of people especially those who are not hmong. That guy should’ve man up and marry her and taker her with him. I see this depicted in a film and it just angers me. We’re the same ethnic group of people but the custom oppose their own Hmong people yet it allows a different ethnic race to marry a hmong person. I can understand this guy’s sorrow having to dump her. I agree with that guy calling him a chicken as he should’ve man up and marry her regardless of the opposition.
Chicken heart is a supernatural taboo. Marrying your last name is a relationship taboo that brings embarrassment to your family. Like pointing to the moon and get your ear cut comparing to sleeping with your mom or dad. Two different thing.
I don’t understand if they know they are the same last name why they still dating too I don’t agree on same last name dating too if I have a friends I will not be on their side not agrees on their dating too that’s my opinion don’t hated even they don’t have the same parent it still the same last name
My understanding is that they taboo. He chose to wed her. Have a son & son is curse. Son ate chicken heart & something bad will happen to son. Correct?
this topic is stupid it's not just about taboo. the main reason you don't marry your own last name is to try to keep from inbreeding. why is there a question about it? do it if your life depends on it but know that your kids are put in the high category of defects. you might as well marry your brother or sister while you're at it.
Shits imberessin the taboo to the chicken heart is u eat it and u go blind should of put that as the script not yangs falling in love with yangs that’s insectin
Props for trying to make a film but PLEASE DO YOUR RESEARCH BEFORE MAKING A FILM. When you're hmong, you can not date and marry your own last name. It is taboo and considered incest to the eyes of Hmong. Its a simple rule and there are and is many people out there for you to date and marry. Honestly this film should of gone a different direction or should of have been more directly stated that dating and marrying same last name is a no no. Ive seen it in real life of same last name getting together and marrying the U.S. law way. It is very awkward for both family involved because they dont know what to call each other. Some and or most families disown and cut off ties of their own children because of this. This film is a little bit confusing, storyline wise and message wise.
Hmong Yang people have a taboo about eating the heart. They say it has a curse on the Yang family that can make them go blind. From my understanding it came from a story where a mentally handicapped kid accidentally ate the heart of his father or something, mistaking it for a pigs heart. That person then went blind through heaven's curse or something like that. Since then, the Yangs from this line created the taboo of not eating the heart. --- something like that.. it's been a long time since I heard this story... prob got parts of it wrong.. but that's the jist of it.
This is the worst in every direction. The director didn’t really think about the storyline before shooting it. It felt like the director got bored and just do it for fun. Waste of time.
When he was a kid, he ate the chicken heart. In the present he is in a taboo relationship, that ending kinda symbolizes his decision, atleast thats how i saw it. Amazing though!
The dad is such a great actor..!! He literally is the exact portrayal of Hmong olgies and their rules.
he look to young to be her daddy
Ua tau zoo kawg
The new generation has to understand that this is not right and every culture has their own taboo. Dont blame the hmong.
Wonder if D. Yang knows they made a short film after him?
Replied
Fifty Shades of Grey?! HAHAHAHAHAHA. That's too funny.
Why does the couple keep saying “peb” instead of “wb”? Are they in a three way relationship with a ghost too?
😬
I know right!!! She can’t speak proper Hmong!
I love chicken hearts!
For those who don't understand about the same last name thing. Just ask yourself this question, why do we have the same last name even though we r not related by blood. Too many decades ago, we all scattered to many places, we don't know the true story but please respect each other as if the same last names r all from the same dad.
Yet we have the same surname as the Chinese or Korean yet we don't identify as either. Moreover, a majority of Hmong choose not to identify as Chinese/Miaozu yet continue to have their surname.
This is so refreshing, I loved every moment
I don't get it with Hmong culture...it's wrong to date someone of your same last name (who might not even be related to you), but it's okay to marry your blood related 1st cousin (which is illegal in the United States)?!!!
Kinda bs, honestly
Our Hmong culture are built on family relationship, to wed a last name means you dont care about your clan and the relationship within the clan.
They don’t Allow us in Hmong culture because it’s just how the rules is they always say it’s either your brother/sister your talking if it your same last name
Because in Hmong culture it’s like your brother or sister they want you to marry different last name so you have other relatives help you out
Agreed.. and genetically 1st cousins are a no no. But Hmong people have lack of education back then so they made up random rules that made no sense. First cousins is just gross 🤢🤮🤮🤮🤢
Hey taboo cause he ate a heart when he is a boy. And his curse was he fell in love with a Yang girl but can marry cause of there last name. If your confused.
Hish-n-k Production can you guys do a full cover of the guy's version singing 'kuv hlub koj' as shown in the video 19:24. Please reply. I've been waiting.
Hahaha you aren't the only person who has asked, I know the artist is busy these days but I'll definitely ask.
@@HishnK thank you so muchhhhh.❤
Was it just me or the instrument to this shortfilm sound like Maa vue nyob ua ke song... ???
Cas yuav nkim zog yug ua luaj. My words did not go to these actors but the people of one that acted this way.
A better mic for each of the characters would've made this video awesome.
That White guy spoke better Hmong than Hmong peeps this generation 😬
Proves that the person who crosses boundaries will do it over and over again... also brings bad lucks.
When she became the white guy haha got me hella good
Who's the singer of the cover song? Can we get a full cover?
Righhht I agree.
Sorry to say from a Yang family. But this video makes no sense. Why we don’t eat heart is not because of taboo. I’m a little offended by the mean of this video. Why because this tells me that this younger generation don’t know about their culture. Other than that great movie and acting bravo.
Can I get the links to all the different versions of the music?
Great portrayal of a contemporary conflict in the Hmong community. I just want to correct the pronoun in the dialogue "peb" (you plus 2 or more) to "wb" (strictly you and another person). Also, nouns are usually before adjectives. So it'll be "plawv qaib." Overall, incredible job!!
Thank you Tou, appreciate the feedback and corrections.
😢
This story line is confusing. Eating chicken heart supposed to make him blind, not taboo.
He is blind, didn't you see him throw his glasses in the future.
😂
This story video is all wrong about the last name eating heart for guys n the taboo. Get the history correct before putting it out there like this young kids will get the wrong info.
This story was wrong when the title said chicken heart...I thought it was a movie about the yangs, actually the boys can’t eat the heart....if they eat they will go blind not taboo. Before do this movie they should asked the true..this story should called dating the same last name not chicken heart. I am a yang my parents told me that yang boys can’t eat chicken heart or they will go blind, but the yang girls can eat the heart, nothing wrong to the girls, not eating the heart to date or taboo. They should made two separated movies chicken heart and taboo are not the same. It didn’t make any sense since the beginning to the end.
Does it make sense if Hmong, we don’t care about our last name, if we could marry our same last name then it’s just the same we don’t have last name and it’s the same you trying to take our Hmong last name away. Have you ever heart or known there is a group of people any where on earth doesn’t have last name, if you do then please let me know, otherwise we are a little bit crazy for love when we still young but reputation means nothing to our future. Leadership only good or famous for better blood line. This is an acting or a movie but it could confuse our people specially the new generation. Our last name only can tell who we are, if you love Hmong or love yourself as a Hmong then do not destroy our only best we known.
idgf what yall think but i would never let my kids marry same last name.
Yes and no. I would like to because at least when we get married I don't have to worry about changing my last name. I mean feeling disowned hurts but I have to choose my own path and my own happiness I can't let my family control my life and control my happiness. It's my life and my choice. To me if it meant to losing everything I had I am willing to because I am with the person I love. I would like to suffer the hardship and pain in life with them.
What’s the guy singer called? And the song?
Moua Meng Yang - Kuv Hub koj cover
Is it on youtube? Unable to find it.
It’s more of the parents fault. We the parents need to tell our children that they can not date or marry their own last name!!!
There's always someones in every pass generations that try to break the laws of the land..
50 shades of grey
Idk why she’s still living with her parents and is afraid of getting kicked out. When she has her bachelors going on masters 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
Because I know a lot of people with Bachelor's and Master's with no job.
I’m glad to see this reality exist within the Hmong community. I’m aware of the same surname prohibition but I’m against this unwritten rule of couples dating someone of the same surname even when there’s no familial relation between the two families. This is one aspect within the hmong culture that needs to change. It’s better to have our hmongs marry and stick together than have them marry off to some other race of people especially those who are not hmong. That guy should’ve man up and marry her and taker her with him. I see this depicted in a film and it just angers me. We’re the same ethnic group of people but the custom oppose their own Hmong people yet it allows a different ethnic race to marry a hmong person. I can understand this guy’s sorrow having to dump her. I agree with that guy calling him a chicken as he should’ve man up and marry her regardless of the opposition.
Dating or inbreeding with another Yang is considered taboo for most Hmong men with the last name Yang.
Chicken heart is a supernatural taboo. Marrying your last name is a relationship taboo that brings embarrassment to your family. Like pointing to the moon and get your ear cut comparing to sleeping with your mom or dad. Two different thing.
I don’t understand if they know they are the same last name why they still dating too I don’t agree on same last name dating too if I have a friends I will not be on their side not agrees on their dating too that’s my opinion don’t hated even they don’t have the same parent it still the same last name
I understand that Hmong ppl with the same last name can’t marry each other but her dad is rude.
Volume is way tooooo low!
What Dab Tsi
Isn't it plawv qaib?
My understanding is that they taboo. He chose to wed her. Have a son & son is curse. Son ate chicken heart & something bad will happen to son. Correct?
Ya'll need a better camera man!
Nasty. This will never change. No matter how many generations. Sorry kids.. Sorry. Can't marry same last name. Inbreeding is not good for your kids.
this topic is stupid it's not just about taboo. the main reason you don't marry your own last name is to try to keep from inbreeding. why is there a question about it? do it if your life depends on it but know that your kids are put in the high category of defects. you might as well marry your brother or sister while you're at it.
i'm confuse lol
It annoys me when she said Peb as in US... its supposed to be Wb... js.....
Shits imberessin the taboo to the chicken heart is u eat it and u go blind should of put that as the script not yangs falling in love with yangs that’s insectin
Props for trying to make a film but PLEASE DO YOUR RESEARCH BEFORE MAKING A FILM. When you're hmong, you can not date and marry your own last name. It is taboo and considered incest to the eyes of Hmong. Its a simple rule and there are and is many people out there for you to date and marry. Honestly this film should of gone a different direction or should of have been more directly stated that dating and marrying same last name is a no no. Ive seen it in real life of same last name getting together and marrying the U.S. law way. It is very awkward for both family involved because they dont know what to call each other. Some and or most families disown and cut off ties of their own children because of this. This film is a little bit confusing, storyline wise and message wise.
19:24
the next movie will be father wed his daughter and a mother wed her son.
Hahaha
I dont understand how the chicken heart relates to the taboo...confused..and i understand the hmong culture
Someone said that he ate the chicken hearts as a kid, and it led to this taboo, I actually don't know myself, haha
My understanding is that he loved her enough to go back in time to eat the chicken heart so that they would have never seen each other.
Hmong Yang people have a taboo about eating the heart. They say it has a curse on the Yang family that can make them go blind. From my understanding it came from a story where a mentally handicapped kid accidentally ate the heart of his father or something, mistaking it for a pigs heart. That person then went blind through heaven's curse or something like that. Since then, the Yangs from this line created the taboo of not eating the heart. --- something like that.. it's been a long time since I heard this story... prob got parts of it wrong.. but that's the jist of it.
Yang n yang o no o no...dating yur own last name nasty...it like yur own sister
This is the worst in every direction. The director didn’t really think about the storyline before shooting it. It felt like the director got bored and just do it for fun. Waste of time.
It confuses and I don't understand the story line.
When he was a kid, he ate the chicken heart. In the present he is in a taboo relationship, that ending kinda symbolizes his decision, atleast thats how i saw it. Amazing though!
Kinda sad...
Your movie is not make sense
Should be plawv qhaib
David yang nasty
We don't. Call it qaib plawv no is hmoob ntse aw!!!
F. T😢ghgb. ..
This movie is too cringy. Hmoob can't speak hmoob. Tsis zoo saib
Sorry but don’t like this movie
What’s the song to the girl playing the guitar?
Kuv Hub koj - Zoua Madeline Her