Fashom vs Nadine West - Affordable Fashion Subscription Boxes | Do I Cancel? Feeling Frustrated
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- Hey Yall, I’m excited about this mash-up. Nadine West clothing box vs Fashom clothing box. Which will stay? Which will go? Or will they both go? Let’s try on these clothes and find out! These women's clothing subscription boxes are similar in style and price point.
I’m 5’5” (almost) and 110 lbs for reference.
Nadine West
- Frequency: Monthly Subscription
- Price Average & Style Fee: average $10 - $30 per item & $0 style fee
- Shipping: US only - $9.98 and this is applied as a credit to anything you purchase, return shipping is free. If you keep nothing, you lose the $9.98.
- Preview Clothing being sent?: No
- Nadine West Coupon Code: PINKENVELOPE25 - Take $25 off a full box from Nadine West + Free Shipping
- Sign Up Here: thepinkenvelop...
- About Nadine West:
- 4 - 6 items per bag
- Keep only what your want & send the rest back for free.
- Great personal style quiz.
- They do have a Refer-a-Friend program
- Sizes: Small - 3X
Personal Thoughts:
They just aren’t me. Although shipments and receiving clothes are so easy and so smooth, there is 0 customization in my opinion. I wouldn’t be surprised if we were all receiving almost the same things. I have tried revamping my profile a few times with no changes. I don’t like receiving jewelry in my boxes and it is required to come in every box, so I always send it back. Also, the fit is always just a little bit off and the style is just a little mature for me. So for these reasons & more, I am taking a break from Nadine West.
VS
Fashom
- Frequency: On Demand (no subscription)
- Price Average & Style Fee: average $ per item & $20 style fee that is credited towards your purchase
- Shipping: Free
- Preview Clothing being sent?: Yes
- Fashom Coupon Code: None
- Sign Up Here: thepinkenvelop...
- About Fashom:
- 5 items per box
- Discounts you can earn: Keep 3 or 4 items and get 15% off and Keep All to get 30% off.
- You can exchange sizes
- For every box sold Fashom donates $1 to Second Chance Rescue NYC
- They do have a Refer-a-Friend program
- You can have a 15-minute video call with a member of their styling team at any time!
- Sizes: XSmall - 3X
Personal Thoughts:
They seem like they want to be hands-on and they want to provide strong customer service, however, their systems are antiquated in contacting support, leaving feedback on your preview, and leaving feedback on your box. Communicating with the is VERY difficult and frustrating. Also, their clothing styles just don’t match me. I have tried their box several times and have had to send whole boxes back because the sizing was wrong, cuts were weird, the style was off, etc So for these reasons and more, I have decided to take a break from Fashom.
#fashom #nadinewest #thepinkenvelope
Join my NEW exclusive Facebook group here - / thepinkenvelope
Nails by @haus_of_polish on IG
*Follow me on Social Media*
Instagram: / thepinkenvelope
Pinterest: / thepinkenvelope
Facebook: / thepinkenvelope
Blog: thepinkenvelop...
Email: samantha@thepinkenvelope.com
Interested in having your box showcased, mail it to
The Pink Envelope
2313 Lockhill-Selma #603
San Antonio TX 78230
Music by / lakeyinspired
*Disclaimer: these are just my opinions and I apologize in advance for misspelling, typos & overall nonsense! This post may contain affiliate links. We earn a small commission each time someone makes a purchase using one of our links, which helps to support the blog and is no additional cost to you. All opinions are my own.
Absolutely let Nadine West go. The clothing just appears cheap on video so I can only imagine what it looks like in person! Keep Fashom for a while. There were a few cute things, but some questionable items as well. I really think Front Door Fashion is the best clothing box you review.
Nadine West doesn’t seem to care much about their own products if the jewelry comes all knotted up. Definitely the right choice not to continue with them. The Fashom wasn’t my favorite either, but the quality seems better for the price point.
I totally agree with booting Nadine and keeping Fashom! I also agree with the items you said you were keeping from Fashom as those are the ones I was going to vote for. I hope you & your family & critters are having a great day/week! ❤️
Sweeeet! Thank you 😊
So happy to see you loving so many of the pieces! 💜 ~ #teamfashom xo
Great video! Nadine West almost immediately started sending me bags full of 16 to 19 items each month and with it lots of errors. Anyone who absolutely raves about Nadine have to be receiving a kick back. The sad thing is that out of every 10 items you find a real comfy keeper. I finnaly cxled after nothing matched the shipping slip and they would not lower the amount of items sent. Jewelry except for some bracelets are a rip off as well.
yep pretty much all of the positive videos about NW are sponsored
I think you should get rid of both boxes and focus more on front door fashion as they seem to give you better clothes, that seem more age appropriate. And whatever else fashion boxes you like. But if you do want to keep one keep fashom.
I totally agree on letting Nadine West go... Fashom seems way better. I did like the white top. The skirt is nice and looks like it would be good for bopping around with the kids in the heat of Texas.
Nadine seems to be about right for the budget. Those suggested prices are crazy for anywhere you buy. It seems like rainbow or something like that. But I love it does cater to lower budgets because everyone deserves something. I think it’s more for basic clothes. I signed up but I might be regretting after receiving stitch fix.
I think the first outfit looked nice and green looks great with your hair
When I first started receiving Nadine West, I really enjoyed it. As time went on, they kept making billing errors which was costing me a lot of money! I had no choice but to cancel. I wish their staff had been more careful about doing their jobs!
Thanks for sharing! That will definitely take the fun out of things quickly.
I have to say you look adorable in your flowy orange dress! ❤️❤️ It’s so hard to “help you choose” outfits because everything looks amazing on you lol!
Thank you! The orange dress is from a local SATX boutique!
@@Thepinkenvelope it’s adorable! ❤️
Personally, I think all the clothing sub boxes are a waste. I would rather pick my own clothes. I know that's just me and others like the option of having a sub box.
Tried Nadine West in the past, felt their items were cheaply made and never kept anything. Would not mind not seeing them again.
Hi Samantha, and thank you so much for sharing your latest Fashom unboxing with us! 😘 Your entire box gave us all Summer feels, but everything looks amazing on you! 😍 So happy that you found a couple of pieces to love in this box! Can't wait to style you again soon. 💜 ~ #teamfashom xo
Unpopular opinion…I liked the Nadine West outfits. The green pants and the dress with the shirt tied looked really cute!
I didn’t like anything that Nadine West sent to you. I sent for a Nadine West box for myself and I didn’t like anything in it. I felt that the material was very cheap and the prices were high for the less than stellar quality of the items I received. I cancelled after my first box due to the lack of quality.
Just found you and am so glad I did. Just began my hunt for "the best" Fashion Subscription Box. Was a Stitch Fix person for a few years, but have heard they have gone through many changes....not all positive. Your unboxing videos are fun to watch and very helpful. Your hair is GORGEOUS BTW! Do you by chance have a video that ranks your preferences? It seems I learn of a new candidate every day that I have never heard of before. I am Petite, so starting to expore my options there. Heading to check out Front Door Fashion now.
The thing I dislike with Nadine West the most is it there is no checkout process. You just jam everything you don't want back into the bag and they charge you for what didn't come back to them. This leaves the burden of making sure I was correctly charged on me.
The biggest thing I don't like about Fashom is if I don't want five items, I have to take the time to email them with requests. It would be better, and they would have a higher probability of selling me more items, if they would allow me to leave the feedback right there on the selection page.
Yes, that is a good point. That is weird!
I tried Nadine West twice and the clothes they sent were awful. I felt it was very low quality and nothing I would ever wear. The blue dress and second top from Fashom were awesome! I think I may give this box a try.
The Blue dress from Fashom is cute! That top looks good tucked into the shorts. I think white pants that fit you would be adorable. I know you like the esly top, I don’t like it but that’s just my tastes. I wish it was a prettier color. That skirt is different. Hard to style and not very cute.
I completely understand the personal feelings about the body con dress but I do have to say that you look amazing! Even relaxed I think you’re gorgeous!
Beautiful blue dress. I agree, I’d like a full outfit instead of pieces.
I like everything in the fashom box and it’s a great price point. Those tops are so cute!! The other box I would cancel. The items looked on the cheaper side.
We appreciate your support! Glad to hear your loving some of our latest styles💜 ~ #teamfashom xo
Just started Nadine west will get my second box this week… not impressed yet, I am excited to try fashdom, totally wish there was a discount but for the ease of order when I want it may be worth it.. I love love love the two tops and blue dress from fashdom. The tiered skirt would be a hard pass for me.. save the money for front door fashion, they are where I spend any extra Pennys I have… amazing system, pricey but worth every penny for the curation and care I swear they know me better than I know myself and when they send items that match other things they sent omg, makes me tear up and it’s so worth every cent… I can not wait to see what you share next…. Thanks sooo much for what you do..
I agree...definitely do not like the pieces from Nadine West. Fashom is definitely better although not the best. The Blue dress from this is the cutest of the lot!
I like the blue sleeveless too much better!
Fashom also try’s to stock made in America. I got rid of Nadine West because of the poor quality. BTW, you look amazing in the bodycon dress!
Fashom seems like a better fit that blue dress was very pretty. I drool over your front door fashion such a fantastic service.
Love that orange dress on you! Really liked the babydoll dress and green shirt, didn’t love the white shirt (maybe because I’m pale and can’t do white 🤣)
To pick between the two, I would say I am liking Fashom best. I do agree, I like the stylist to send outfits. I have no idea how to mix and match and put outfits together.
Try Trensend by Evereve or J B Style box. Both send outfits together. I get Trendsend and am always so happy with what they send. Always a fun capsule wardrobe in every box
You're right- Nadine West isn't a good fit for you. Loved the Fashom blue dress and 2 blouses. Wonder if the ruffled skirt would look better with a darker top? Might bring out the pattern more. Thanks as always for sharing!
Thanks for admiring our pieces! Great styling feedback as well💜 ~ #teamfashom xo
Dang, you make everything look amazing! I really love the orange dress and the blue Esley Mock Neck shirt on you. They are my favorites!
Loved the blue 👗 dress and the two tops in the fashom box. Totally agree with you about keeping fashom and getting a box now and then. But dropping Nadine West. Love your channel.♥️
🙌 thank you! I think everyone agrees Nadine is out & that makes things easy
I had Nadine West for a while and it is not a subscription I would ever recommend to anyone. The material they use for their clothing is so cheap, I can think of three items off of the top of my head that got little baby holes in them after not a lot of wear, and two items I had to sew/fix. I switched to Stitch Fix and I have never looked back. It was supposed to be a temporary thing because they are more expensive, but gosh darn it if I don't love and feel great in everything they send! The extra money is worth it to me for the quality of the clothing and the personalization from my stylist.
I love the green "mom" shirt.
Lol. Wham, bam, thank you mam - I really like both of the Fashom tops on you. I also like that you get a discount at 3 items not just on all of the items.
Glad to hear you like our service! ~ #teamfashom xo
The striped shirt would be cute with the denim shorts from your Front Door box. It looked a little frumpy with the longer skirt. I like the green pant color on you a lot! I feel like the top they paired with it was too similar to your complexion tone.
The blue Fashom dress was so cute on you! The Viola shirt reads as juniors to me, but it was pretty. The greenish top was much better for you. The skirt was unique, but I wouldn't know what to wear with it at all.
Fashom keep the blue dress and two shirts. I'm disappointed they won't give you a code, but I think they've done a pretty good job curating some stuff for you.
I think Fashom is more your style. I like the three items you picked. The dress and both shirts look great.
I’ve gotten a few fashom boxes and have always had good luck finding a few things. Before a beach vacation I kept a few cute things.
Great decision to boot Nadine West... They just don't seem to "get" you. The blue Fashom box dress 👗 looked incredible on you. It shows off your fantastic legs without being too much. I really liked the 2nd top, the 1st one, I could take it or leave it. The shirt is pretty but I too would struggle with how to style it. I love video talk through therapy. p. s. Love the dress you opened tge video in. Looking lovely lady 🌺
Nadine west is a no for me. With the skirt, I would tuck in a silky cami in a nude or soft pink. Hard to tell what would look best without seeing it in person. The dress, blue top, and skirt were my favorites :)
Maybe someone else has mentioned this, but Nadine West has really been problematic for many people. Just check the BBB. My first bag was fine - 7 items. I kept 2 leggings and necklace. My 2nd bag had 17 items! This seems excessive. My bag of 17 items had stains and snags. I kept one pair of leggings, since I already paid for shipping. When I returned it, that's when the problems began. Suddenly they said that they sent me 18 not 17 items. They also said that I kept something that I didn't. I'm lucky, because it wasn't a lot of money. However, if you check the BBB comments some people have truly horrible stories. Customer service wasn't helpful, I couldn't cancel, and they insisted that sent an 18th items. Thankfully, I took screen shots of my account and my cc company and the BBB got my money back.
Hello!! I vote to keep Fashom. They seems to have more of your style of clothing. Love your videos!!
Have you ever unboxed a Transcend from EverEve ? I enjoy your honest take on videos, even though I’m 5 foot 10 and a size 12 I get good takeaways on the quality and the customer service on each box… But Rachel from Front Door Fashion is my favorite of all of them, thanks to you. And honestly if I never get a super ruffled tiered skirt or dress again I will get down on my knees and kiss the ground because they all make me feel like I’m going to in Amish wedding. I think they look really cute on 25-year-old girls and that’s about it….Can’t wait for this trend to end. I thought the two tops from Fashom were cute - do you feel like the sizes are true? I’ve had a couple people tell me that this box is cut more for juniors and that’s definitely not my body type so just curious to know
Yes I have a couple Trendsend videos on here. They aren’t my fav, but definitely aren’t bad. Go watch & see.
As for Fashom, I think sizes run true to slightly big. I don’t think they are juniors at all, in fact I have found their clothes to be slightly too mature & boring & lacking the latest trends. I have a couple other videos on them on here if you want to check them out.
But yes, FDF is the best!
The floral skirt from fashom looks great on you,and the top colour looks good, but if you wear that top you need a chunky or statement necklace to balance out the skirt. Not shiny but something with natural hues.
You have a great eye! Loving these styling tips💜 ~#teamfashom xo
I would let Nadine West go. I’ve never had much luck with them and the quality reminds me of clothing from Kohl’s. Your Fashom box was great. Looking forward to seeing new boxes!
We love knowing you liked this style box! 😊 ~ #teamfashom xo
Fashom is a keeper! I think that both tops are great and that blue dress. I loved that skirt and I would pair it with a plain black top and a long gold necklace.
Happy to hear that you liked our picks! Also, great styling tip😊 ~ #teamfashom xo
You could wear anything. Really like the striped shirt. Like Viola top but too “cute”. White pants look used and I can never understand buying distressed jeans - Why? Tammy mock neck is a lovely shirt on you.
I would stop with Nadine West and just do Fashom occasionally. It's nice to show boxes that are a lower price point for those that can't afford Front Door Fashion or Trunk Club. Now that being said, I loved that bodycon dress with the shirt tied over it. I think you looked fantastic in that. And the dress is called Samantha! it might be bad mojo to send it back, lol The blue dress and second top were great from Fashom.
Thank you so much for showing the pros and cons
What a fun video, Samantha! Sorry, but NW is a No. Fashom has some cute items, I like the dress, the Viola, Essly shirts and the skirt. 💞
i would cancel both..never have been impressed with fathom although did like aqua? blouse. did like the blouse you kept from nadine..if i worked in an office i would have kept the skirt too
I like everything in the fashom box on you except those pants.
Love the Fashom dress, white top and green tops are so cute on you! I feel that way about the Nadine west too.
Our summer dresses our some of our faves this season!😊 ~ #teamfashom xo
I signed up with Nadine West for just a few months and everything they send me is like $40, I like cheaper and there is no discount. And they keep sending me earrings, I don't wear earrings and I have to keep updating the profile because everything defaults back to no selections. I just can't afford to keep spending more than $40 every single month. I'm going to stick with my Amazon Personal Shopper and Wee Blessings. This service is nice but too many issues with them...oh and every necklace is like $40, one came literally broken and now this current bag I have has one cheap plastic gold necklace and the other two are all tangled and knotted up as well.
I super agree with this comment.
I signed up with Nadie West, and after watching a couple unboxiing videos, I'm not excited to see what I get.
I agree with the other commenters, let Nadine West go.
The Viola top is cute, looks comfortable and cool.
the skirt from fashom is fab!!!keep keep
We'd adore seeing you slay this piece!💜 ~ #teamfashom xo
I agree on letting Nadine go and I'd say keep that button up shirt from them to get your money's worth and you can make it cute with a lot of different things. The Fashom dress, white top, and green top are keepers. I'm not really sure about the skirt just because I'm like you I wouldn't know exactly what to pair with it. As far as keeping the Fashom subscription, I couldn't give my opinion because I have never had them nor seen enough from them to decide . Can't wait to hear what you keep ❤️
We love your feedback! Check out our website for more info about us, we'd love to style you in the near future!💜 ~ #teamfashom xo
@@Fashom I will definitely check y'all out. Thank you
I think a lot of the pieces were okay....can't say I was super impressed with either box. Neither of them were a steal of a deal but neither of them were bad boxes either.
Definitely time to get rid of Nadine West. I don't know if I would keep Fashom either...except for their give back program. I am still not onboard with the $20 style fee...I think it pressures you to purchase an item that you don't love. Edited to add, I do love that bright blue dress from Fashom.
Ditch Nadine -the fabrics looked cheap-but also thought that blouse looked good. Fashom-I like to see this one-Wish there was a discount code!
Love this video and I usually don’t watch the fashion ones :) I thought Nadine West had pretty low quality when I used to get it
I agree about letting Nadine West go!!
Second outfit: the shirt has tabs to roll up and button up the sleeves which I kind of like. Again, I don’t think they go together and the skirt isn’t that flattering!
I haven't gotten anything from NW that's $10. or even $20. It's about $25-40 on average.
I agree! I'm seeing the same thing
I think I may have a Fashom discount if you don’t mind me sharing it. I don’t know if it’s still active so I will dig around.
Fashom did ok. The blue dress is definitely a win.
I'd dump both, but if you really want to keep one then Fashom. I'd love to see you review Short Story clothing box (if you haven't already and I missed it). I haven't seen many reviews and would just like to have that curiosity itch scratched on if it is worth it or not.
I would let Nadine west go and keep Fashom
Nadine West clothes seem to be on the cheaply made side. I got Fashom once and’s was not happy with the quality but watching this I might try them again.
Hi Andrea, thank you for sharing about this style box.💜 We'd love to style you again in the near future so you could experience some of our latest pieces! ~ #teamfashom xo
I have done both Nadine west and Fashom and I got rid of them both. I just didn’t care for the clothes and I thought they were both over priced for what they were sending me.
The dress might be cute with a blazer or sweater.
Nadine West is really bad other then the red white and blue shirt. Fashom is better...but..Why do these boxes want to dress you like a child other than Front door fashion. There is a price point issue that comes to play with these boxes and the quality and style you receive. I do not understand today's fashion, perhaps I am an old fuddy duddy! LOL. You are so pretty. My daughter in law is a red head and looks amazing in the right red with red lips...stunning, but she would never wear bright yellow either. She looks amazing in greens, just about every blue and to her surprise blush. BTW, you looked great in the blush skirt with the ruffles from fashom and the top you took off your bed! so pretty on you...keep that!
I just found your Channel and I’m inlove, I have always wanted to do subscribed boxes but never actually did one
Nadine west outfit number one those two things didn’t go together. Maybe the pants with something else would look better
I agree with letting Nadine West go and keeping Fashom
Y’all are making this easy 🙌
I love all. The Nadine west on you
The cap sleeve top has a cute pattern, but the ruffle detail is childish. If you're going to keep either, Fashom is definitely the better, but considering it has actual stylists, it's not great. Sorry to be a bummer today.
The Nadine West box has to go, go, go….it all looks cheap, cheap, cheap. The only item that looked like halfway decent quality was the button front striped blouse. I apologize if I offended anyone who liked the box, but in this economy, it’s important to be picky where one spends their hard-earned money 💰 The value is definitely NOT here. Regarding the Fashom box, maybe keep that in your line-up. I know you like the the blue frilly dress, but I feel like it is either for a 16 year old or the Tinkerbell character. The cap sleeve top is okay, but a little too cutsy. The aqua top is very nice, I’d keep that one. The white jeans would be nice if sized correctly. The layered/tiered skirt would be okay IF it was in a more flattering pattern or color. It was hard to see all of this on you after your Front Door Fashion video from the other day. That box was fabulous … and very classy!
Keep fashom and the cute tops. Also, that blue dress! Gorgeous xx
We appreciate the love for our pieces! ~ #teamfashom xo
I don't like anything in the first box. Looks cheap and not even worth the low price points. Wouldnt keep the subscription box.
The second box is worth keeping. The two tops and the dress looked really cute on you. I would only keep those 3 items.
Treat yourself to Fashom once a quarter you deserve it! Other then they have a tendency to send me really youthful items the quality is great.
While Nadine West does have that coupon code for new subscribers I don't think they actually give it to you I've done videos for them with a combined over a thousand plus views and never got a single credit to my box I find that hard to believe that absolutely no one used my code out of the thousand people that watched my videos... I know longer do Nadine West but for another reason they kept overcharging me
Nadine West to date is the worst subscription box I have ever received to include clothing boxes and not clothing. CHEAP KMART CLOTHING AND WHAT I RECIEVED WAS SO AWFUL. I don't ever want to talk myself into keeping something. You either love it or you dont!
No to the layered skirt. It looks like Home on the Prairie.
I would get rid of both. I think they are all cutsey. I am not a ruffle person at all...so that might be part of it.. Your orange dress has tiers that look soft and pretty and flowing.
Oh my gosh I couldn’t agree more with your interpretation of what a cute tiered dress is… The multi layered ruffle the ones that look like a librarian who is 90 going to church are a trend that I pray will disappear this year well that orange dress was adorable
I used to receive Nadine West, I just didn't like it. Keep Fashom!
Not a fan of Nadine West. That colors of the first outfit were questionable. The pants were not a great color. The top may have looked cute with other pants though. Love the items from Fashom! I would keep the red white and blue button down from Nadine West and the couple tops from Fashom!
Just the fact that Nadine West doesn't carry any XS items, would be a deal-breaker for me. I'm surprised most of the items fit you as well as they did. Fashom is the clear winner though.
I don’t think the Nadine West first outfit colors go together. I also don’t think they are from your color pallet. You look gorgeous in your other clothes. The second outfit I like the shirt but the skirt is a no in my opinion. You can tell a computer is making the choices. I am not a fan of the dress either. All in all I think the Nadine West box is a no. I agree keep the shirt, but I would cancel the Nadine West box.
Everything there you could get at Ross .
I tried Nadine West and was disappointed with the quality and style of clothing I received!
Really liked the Fashion items! Loved the blue dress!
We'd love to see you rocking this piece!💜 ~ #teamfashom xo
I have Nadine West years ago and cancelled it because I could get better quality at Walmart for cheaper. So Nadine has to go.
Fashom is way better. The other box chuck it out. It looks unsophisticated. Stay with Fashom hands down.
My first 2 shipments from Nadine West were pretty good (reasonably priced and nice selection) but each shipment thereafter was TERRIBLE. They ignored my style profile, feedback comments and requests so the selection was bad AND overpriced. I even got duplicate items that I had specified previously that I didn't like! So disappointing that I had to cancel. Not a good way to run a business.
Liked most of the items from Fashom ❤️
We love to hear it! She looked great in these styles😊 ~ #teamfashom xo
I would get rid of NW