Bob Dylan - The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll (RARE LIVE FOOTAGE) [England 1965]
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 гру 2018
- This was recorded at De Montfort Hall in Leicester, England on May 2, 1965. I already uploaded the audio (which is, along with most of the other tracks from the Leicester show, on the playlist titled "Leicester, UK 1965"), but I thought this unforgettable performance deserved a music video.
Bobby's 1965 England Tour has some of the best live versions of his songs ever, and most were recorded right off the soundboard for the documentary "Don't Look Back." I managed to get my hands on all of the known recordings, and will be posting many more to come.
Enjoy this gem while you can!
![Bob Dylan Interview & "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll" [FOLLOW LINK BELOW FOR FULL VERSION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PK05VilsYaw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Bob Dylan Interview & "The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll" [FOLLOW LINK BELOW FOR FULL VERSION]](/img/tr.png)
![Bob Dylan - Mr. Tambourine Man (RARE LIVE FOOTAGE) [Liverpool, England 1965]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-7NCGhmlROA/mqdefault.jpg)
Hard to believe I was at this concert - as a sixteen year old schoolboy from nearby Oakham. One of the most exciting moments of my life.
oh wow! what was it like?
Wishing if you can kindly tell the story of your experience. 🌞
Yes, we would like to know!
@@gratefulgee3123 I agree
I saw him about the same time, maybe a couple months earlier. I saw him in Troy, NY just outside Albany. He was playing stuff from Bringing It All Back Home. It was a small venue, small audience. He was amazing. A tiny figure in black, working his way through these songs that were unlike anything I'd heard before.
this song is so pertinent today. I've listened to this song a thousand times over the past 40 years, and still feel pain. Maybe hearing this song when I was a boy of 10 made me a little better of a man at 60. There is only one race, the human race.
sure! and there is only one race amongst Dogs as well...The Dog race. Pitbulls and Chihuahuas....all the same.
@@benhenningburk9781 Yes, they are the same. One would treat a chihuahua with kindness the same as a doberman. The visual differences are irrelevant.
Maybe even 50 years!. I got a late start, "discovering" Dylan at age 16 in 1966! (55 years ago)
There is only race the human race
So well put simple but effective
@@patrickpower3750 So true, Patrick. But so many came last in the race. Why? What is wrong with us?
I don't believe that I could ever tell that a particular song is the greatest song ever written, but I gotta say - whenever someone asks me that question, this one immediately comes to my mind.
God has blessed our world with Bob Dylan
I don't believe in God, but I agree.
The phrasing on the last "Bury the rag most deep in your face" is beautiful.
The man can sing! He's really an amazing vocalist who can do so much with one word or short phrase, really make you feel what he's expressing.
Some of the greatest lyrics ever written.
Bob was such a beautiful looking young man. Add that to his other magnificent gifts and he is in a league of his own. We can only love him. ❤️
Magical performance, Only the face of Bob, with his mesmerizing eyes and powerful voice. Nothing
disturbing , just me/you absorbed into his world..🎼🎶🌺🌸💕🌸🌺
This is just stunning.
He's so brilliant and perceptive it is amazing!! As a child I sang this in a coffee house while playing my old Kay.
It never ceases to amaze me. The difference between this Dylan and the Dylan a year later on his return to the UK. Two different people.
Everyone was changing.
Someone said he met 3 different Dylans over 3 days when he played on one of Bobs albums. Wish I could remember the player, but thats Bob. Why he intrigues so much. and Inspires so much. "He" is constantly shape shifting. So to speak.
But what happened a year later?
Check out the 1966 UK tour
@@tb27tb27 Judas!
I love his tales, voice, music and face so much...💌
Have seen this version before, it’s beautiful. Must be on Don’t Look Back. Yup of course. See now. The words are obviously heart rending. Love 💕 how young Bob uses his eyes to emphasise his words. Putting his whole body and being into getting these words out right. Intense concentration. And he has the face of an Angel.
This footage is from the documentary film DONT LOOK BACK, directed by DH Pennebaker, who pioneered this genre of filmmaking.
Holy jesus what an upload. What a performance
It was 58 years ago, although I remember the occasion like it was yesterday, when I was sat in the front row of the De Montfort orchestra stalls only a few feet away from this incredible individual, totally spellbound by the man and his songs.
This is the best channel on UA-cam period. Thank you so much for these footages.
Thank you Pig for finding this live version. The real deal here.
I kinda didn't realize he was still playing this song in 1965!
Doesn't get much better than this
Hattie Carroll was a black woman who died as the result of an injury she got at a white only party in Maryland when one of the guests beat her with his cane because she poured his bourbon too slowly.
an early version of an ally using their celebrity to shed light on the injustices imposed upon black people in America. When I was young, my mom told me about this song one day while she was playing a Bob Dylan album. I've been a fan ever since. Without Bob writing this song, the case would've never received national and international attention.
Most of his music was about the people who hold up this pyramid scheme of capitalism.
Dylan’s talent for songwriting knows no bounds.
Has to be the best version this
I love what Dylan does with the word "all" in the line "criticize all fears". Now who says the man can't sing?
His has masterful control over his voice. He can sing a note so delicately, but still stay in tune. That has been true all through his career, even in something more recently like "Once Upon A Time".
Wonder why he didnt do that in the album version
This is a much better version than that slower studio version.
Here you can almost feel the emotions flowing through his voice.
Rest in Peace, DA Pennebaker.
Incredible........
so young and so perfect ...... beautiful .... thanks a lot ♥♥♥
One of my all-time favorites ❤️! Great job on the video. Clear as a bell! Thank you😎
Hypnotical performance!.I really love this song!
THE GENIUS!!!!
Where do you get all of these rare footages? Unbelievable, may long live this channel 🤩
Much of the footage is from the film “Don’t Look Back,” which chronicled Dylan’s tour of England in 1965 (?)
This song is great on whole nother level.....
Thank you so much Swingin'
I love the rage in his voice! Everybody must understand this lyrics!
My goodness, I'm delighted to read such wonderful comments about b dylan. An amazing song..perfect. But ya know, there are quite a few wonderful videos... Did you ever see the CBC production called QUEST? It'll knock you out. It's about 1965, little b and w film . It takes place in a tiny hunting type lodge or bar. Dylan is the wandering troubadour going from table to table with about 4 at a table. The men are playing cards. Gradually they begin to Listen. Hattie Carroll is the 1st 🎵 ..as I recall. As they listen, their poker cards are substituted for little journals. Some men are now writing as you see them in quiet contemplation.
This hunting bar has been transformed.
B dylan is confident and serious throughout his singing.
I learned that night that he loves his words, his music and performing.
He is "The Song and Dance Man " till this day.
Btw, I have never heard ... even once.. a flat note.
His pitch is spot on...till this day.
It’s true. Bob is an exceptionally good singer. As you say, always in perfect pitch.
People who say he can’t sing don’t know what singing is.
Thank's a lot from France !
The best...
Almost 10k, amazing
Thank You
è sempre una boccata d'ossigeno ascoltarti
I like the version best that's on the Rolling Thunder Revue album.
I love it!
A M A Z I N G !
The greatest
Heard this as a 14 yr aged boy trying to process the delivery, sound and lyrics in the 60;s I got it even then as Dylan never mentions Black or white. Although i thought it was set in the 20's not in 1963. And heres to Emmitt Till and George Floyd too.
George Floyd
You mean the carpet stain who was 8 times in jail, porn actor, junkie that died of a fentanyl overdose.
How dare you put his name with Emmitt Till & Hattie Carroll.
Your ignorance is staggering.
not much i can say about this fellow he brought me a feeling of freedom
Proud to say I come from Leicester & have been to the Demontfort Hall many times
👍👍
❤
🙏🏽💔🙏🏻
This is A NOBEL PRIZE SONG
and
The " Mc Fly's " don't have to work it out!
🥇🏅🤓
He did win a Nobel Prize, not just for this song, but (I think) his whole body of work.
S Pig, is this by any chance from the bbc concert? I had a bbc tv sound studio recording of the whole show, but not having a reel to reel machine myself, left that tape somewhere unknown . Someone must have one somewhere 😢
This was not recorded at BBC studios. This is from Leicester. None of the footage of the BBC concert is known to survive, unfortunately :/ however, all the tracks still exist. Here’s half of the concert (half was cut out for copyright reasons, unfortunately): ua-cam.com/video/Ricp-ksprmg/v-deo.html
Thanks for the info, and your posts. I was a young bbc tech and actually on the crew that recorded his bbc show. Hence got a studio copy on reel to reel. Also a studio script with all the songs, sadly also lost. Still, a fantastic memory. Great work SP.
@@peterstreet3289 No way!! Did you see him perform?
Absolutely! I was with the crew that recorded the show. As you can imagine I remember it well. He had been totally uninterested in rehearsals which had disappointed me but from the first bars of the show was awesome. That same year I got to the tv recordings of Joan Baez, Tom Paxton, Julie Felix and even appeared in the audience in the P,P and Mary show! Always a sad mystery that the Dylan recording got lost or over taped. Great work with your postings.
Thank you, Peter! You’re so lucky that you saw him. I’d give anything to go back in time to that concert. It’s a legendary concert and to be able to say you helped tape it... wow. Happy Easter!
Jeez, looks like t'was made yesterday! Sad.
Bob and poor Hattie Carroll
😊
Could you upload a full footage video of Bob singing Tom Thumb’s Blues (or Sweet Marie or Achilles if they even exist?!) from 65/66? I love you!
I'll see what I can do! Love you too :)
Temporary like Achilles is one of my favorite songs. It sets such a vivid mood of the 1960s. And the imagery is so cool! “I watch upon your scorpion, who crawls across your circus floor” unbelievable.
👍
Essa história é real
And you who philosophise disgrace and criticise all fears
Hattie Carroll.......55 years later....Breonna Taylor, Ahmad Aubery, George Floyd...will it stop?
too true, too sad...
Yeah what I was thinking. as Zappa would say Don't forget to register to vote.
@Victor Alexander All so true. I wish the snowflakes would do some research.
@Winston Leg-Thigh I don't think it was that different. He's just talking about a particular situation. Too many hear this and attach their feelings to every bit of fake news.
As a black man don't put George Floyd on this list, he overdosed.
The one dislike must be the incarnate of William Zanzinger?
i first heard this song in the movie when i was fifty-one years old and it really punched me in the heart. the first time i heard it, it thought he was saying, "who had ten children, who never sat once at the head of the table." i thought he was saying her children never sat once at the head of the table, which actually made it more devastatingly poignant. I seriously wondered how a kid that age could write something that profound and wise beyond his years. the mistake in that movie were there were so few complete songs--it's okay to see what bob said backstage but the thing would be to have as many of his complete songs as possible. in retrospect, this was the best thing he ever did on video and the knucklehead cameraman only recorded half of a song here or there. the other thing he did worth looking at was Concert for Bangladesh with George Harrison, which did have whole songs.
Hes in a hurry....good ole Bob
🤦🏻♂️🤫
William Zantzinger died in 2009
We all meet our fate. He had to come to regret his actions against Hattie Carroll. If not....may he be reborn as a Rat.
Who is the woman behind Dylan at 0:30?
It looks like Suze Rotolo.
And🎶🎶 What A? True 💎 💝🙏😂🔥✌️ It? Is😎👍 S-P-😭
,,, ... a six-month sentence ...
harp@ 3:32
Amazing, isn’t it?
"William Zantzinger killed poor Hattie Carroll"
*Crowd Applauds*
Sick bastards, thats terrible.
no, they were applauding the song, not that he killed her.
Just Bob with his harmonica & guitar on stage of course the music was good today the likes of Beyonce need to appear with scantily clad girls to make up for her lack of artistic talent.
この唄は悲し過ぎる・・けど事実であり、ザンジガー氏は自身の非を認める事無くディランを批難していたらしい・・(-""-;)
this song is not about whites and blacks. This song is about rich and poors.
hattie was hit once? with a toy cane by a drunk...he is dead.
You misunderstand the context. Zantzinger was a violent drunk, both in speech and action, and his cane was no toy to use on an elderly and vulnerable woman.
La chanson la plus anti racistes que je connaisse !
OK Boomer.
This Bob Dylan story is misleading:
William Zanzinger did not beat Hattie Carroll to death. He was drunk. He beat the people around him with a stick, including his wife. Hattie did not suffer serious injury. She just reacted very badly to the assault. Because she had had previous heart problems and high blood pressure, she over-reacted, resulting in her death.
Athena Minerva Dylan’s sequence of events might’ve not been completely accurate, but William Zantzinger (real name) certainly deserved this song and certainly deserved more jail time for her death. He most definitely caused it, as her brain hemorrhage likely would not have occurred if it wasn’t for him. It’s a complicated moral debate on whether he should’ve been convicted for manslaughter (which he was) or murder though.
I’d also say “overacted” is a poor choice of words. She is not to blame for her death.
@@SwinginPig
Nonsense! Over-reacted does not mean she was to blame. You obviously do not understand that murder is based on the intent to kill. There was no intent to kill. Don't talk rubbish!
He beat people around him with a stick? Sounds like a great guy. Just another day at the office huh?
Athena Minerva ummm actually you’re wrong. If a defendant fatally wounds a victim, even if the defendant only intended to hurt the victim, the defendant is still liable for murder. Look it up on law.cornell.
Thank's a lot from France !