Violinists; they simultaneously look like they would have a polite formal conversation with you, but also impale you with the bow out of mild annoyance.
I actually like the third one the best, i think the articulation of his notes was very sharp. #1 had a screech of the E string at the end #2 was on the wrong tempo, too quick. #3 was perfect imo
but it was supposed to be like fierce wind at least on the notes, instead of melody in the third time. 1st time has to be like so much wind, 2nd brute and 3rd clean
I love reading these comments, its fun to see the difference between the ears of people that actually plays violin and the opinions of the people that does not play it.
yeah, i've played violin since i was three, that squeak didn't even mean anything. she still had the best tempo and dynamics but the third guy had the best articulations
in my opinion, the first one was the most in-tune and most on-beat without sounding too rushed, the second one was honestly the most impressive in how fast and crisply the latter half was played compared to the other two, and the third one had the most flair and the best sounding finish to it. overall, i think the first one was the cleanest performance (yes, yes, despite the “screech” - it happens) and was my favorite.
This short is amazing. Apart from getting to see and hear these talented musicians, I get to see some observations, and get some insights about this expertise. Also I agree with your comment, the first one sounded best for me, the second was amazing for the speed, and the third was just outstanding all throughout although I prefer the overall sound of the first. Anyhow they're all amazing!
Tbh, i don't have any experience in violin or music in general, but before i entered the comment section I simply thought each one had a different personality. Like i get that experts look for perfection and being in tune with source material, but the differences of these three is what made them shine to me. I know to people, some parts of what they did were counted as mistakes, but to me every bit of sound they poured out was simply just right.
I loved the 2nd one because her end rhythm was really nice and dramatic and whole solo was like really squeaked and perfect amount of everything so hers!!! ⭐️✨✨✨💖💖💖🎵🎼🎶
After 2 years playing the trumpet and participating in band, it has come to my attention that very good musicians tend to have swing in their performances.
Someone at my school in year 11 played this with him doing the solo parts and omg I've never seen everyone cheer so loud, as Someone who loves music it just made me smile
It’s so funny to me I play the violin, I see this and think I can play it. The moment I actually think about trying to play it I instantly realize how tough it would be. Been playing for 4.5 years, I’ll get there eventually
I just had a violin audition, and I failed miserably, so now I'm watching people that made it and crying. You're awesome guys! Edit: Turns out, I did not fail miserably. I got in as third chair
I choose between either one of them. But if they can’t play and get along with one another, then I’ll have to go to Europe and get those two guys who can play beautifully and harmonize it brings a tear to your eyes. And they can stand on their feet and play and play in various travel venues. They collaborate, and not adversarial in their performances.
1st one was the most enjoyable despite the squeak, 2nd one tried way to hard to get volume and just crunched, 3rd one was clean but maybe a little passive
The 1st one is the only on-beat execution of this music I’ve ever heard. Of course, I haven’t heard 100% of violinists in the world 😊but still. Bravo!!!
![Try to Beat me at Violin [🎻100 Violin Giveaway]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ctIbXWIHVXo/mqdefault.jpg)
![Try to Beat me at Violin [🎻100 Violin Giveaway]](/img/tr.png)
The guy done it perfect,with elegant sound.
True
Según la partitura están representando un 'horrible viento', así que probablemente no buscara un sonido limpio y perfecto
No he didn’t
@@glappyclappylet’s see you play it
Stop fighting guys
Although 1st girl squeaked, she had the best tempo and dynamics... found her solo the most pleasing to listen to
Agreed, the timing of each note and dynamics through the notes were basically perfect.
exactly.
Yeah
Agreed, only thing off was the screech which is so hard not to do oml
AGREED
Vivaldi's music is great and so are performers.
absolutely 💜
Summer by Vivaldi is my fav piece
@@calm351same
@@calm351My favorites are "Dvorak symphony No. 9" and the last movement of "Mahler (Titan) symphony No. 1" they are really epic pieces.
😊😊😅x@@angelicart.6
Love how you all looked slightly annoyed with each other but super polite at the same time lol🎉
that's violinists for ya
@@pollosasadosalcarbonbasically lol
Yeah the second girl's smile at the guy was a "fuck you you're good"
Fr thi😂
Violinists; they simultaneously look like they would have a polite formal conversation with you, but also impale you with the bow out of mild annoyance.
the first one has the best phrasing and expressiveness
Agreed. Third one was clear and well articulated but his expressiveness suffered
Hell nah. The third is the beat
@@Flluuxxare you a violinist in any way
@@zooble_. I’ve been playing for nine years, and I am very good.
@@Flluuxx the commenter never said that the first one was the best, he only said that it has the best expressiveness
i think the third one did the best, his tone was very nice
He had the melodious part, the other 2 had the part that's supposed to represent fierce wind
@@larviniwhat you talking about, they had equal parts
@@thodgounaris4223no they are all different
No
@@larvini not just that bro, its also bc of his skill
I actually like the third one the best, i think the articulation of his notes was very sharp. #1 had a screech of the E string at the end #2 was on the wrong tempo, too quick. #3 was perfect imo
#2’s intonation was not good either
but it was supposed to be like fierce wind at least on the notes, instead of melody in the third time. 1st time has to be like so much wind, 2nd brute and 3rd clean
I agree, 3 did it the best
i concur
Agree
I loved the first one, the little squeak was funny ngl, but she had the best tone and intonation. The other two were still amazing!! ❤
nah in terms of tone 3rd won
vivaldis winter focuses mainly on the expression tho and they all respresented their respective emotions equally great.
@@gatunix_the third one doesn’t align with the tone of the song though
Yea I liked the first one too😆
Idk what they all like abt third, let it be
@@gab6031 The song is supposed to be like that..
I love reading these comments, its fun to see the difference between the ears of people that actually plays violin and the opinions of the people that does not play it.
People are calling out her squeak and I’m just sitting here like: damn y’all really don’t play huh
literally like the squeak did not matter😭
Fr
Even though I've been playing viola for almost a month, the squeak wasn't a big deal Llke some people even said the squeak was funny
yeah, i've played violin since i was three, that squeak didn't even mean anything. she still had the best tempo and dynamics but the third guy had the best articulations
number 1 has the perfect timing number 2 has the quickest arm and a unique sound and number 3 has the textbook technique all of you are amazing
in my opinion, the first one was the most in-tune and most on-beat without sounding too rushed, the second one was honestly the most impressive in how fast and crisply the latter half was played compared to the other two, and the third one had the most flair and the best sounding finish to it. overall, i think the first one was the cleanest performance (yes, yes, despite the “screech” - it happens) and was my favorite.
This short is amazing. Apart from getting to see and hear these talented musicians, I get to see some observations, and get some insights about this expertise.
Also I agree with your comment, the first one sounded best for me, the second was amazing for the speed, and the third was just outstanding all throughout although I prefer the overall sound of the first. Anyhow they're all amazing!
Tbh, i don't have any experience in violin or music in general, but before i entered the comment section I simply thought each one had a different personality.
Like i get that experts look for perfection and being in tune with source material, but the differences of these three is what made them shine to me. I know to people, some parts of what they did were counted as mistakes, but to me every bit of sound they poured out was simply just right.
#1 is the best. as a former violin player, she did not rush her part and was able to use majority of the bow.
I CANT RUN AWAY FROM THIS SONG HELP
1st was my fav, messy and dramatic, i love it
The girl on the right is smiling so much and it’s so wholesome lol
Oh cramity
@@frododododo "Amity! Oh, cramity!"
I loved the 2nd one because her end rhythm was really nice and dramatic and whole solo was like really squeaked and perfect amount of everything so hers!!! ⭐️✨✨✨💖💖💖🎵🎼🎶
The guys play through was so CLEAN
It's not supposed to be since the song is called "fierce wind"
@@iroast_randomepeople I’m talking about the clarity of the sound he produces . The other two girls sound scratchy and not as clean
@@kannonpatterson ahh ok :)
Intonation is InTerEsTinG
I loved the 1st one, but all were great!
WE'RE GETTING OUT OF THE VARDOHUS FORTRESS WITH THIS ONE 🔥🔥🔥🔥‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️
that was incredible! this deserves more attention!
I really liked the tempo and rythem #2 had, it was very dramatic and striking.
Yaaa
I just want to appreciate the tempo y'all chose. I find most people take the allegro wayyyyy too fast and it such a disservice to this piece
You guys just gave me another sign to watch YOUR LIES IN APRIL again 😭
Fr fr ughhh im craving for it now 😭
IM REWATCHING IT RIGHT NEOW LOL😹BUT ITS SAUR SAD😿
Not April!!! 😭😭😭😭
Not your lies in April 😭 r u ok
your lie*
We making out of vardohus fortress with this banger 🗣️🔥💯💯
🗣️
WE ARE MEELING THE BOMBER ON THIS ONE🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
WE TURNIN ON WITH THIS ONE, FELLAS!🗣️🔥🔥🔥
NO SAPPER!!!!!!!! 😢😢😢
"Loading canister!"
"Winter" is my favorite movement of the Four Seasons. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I can only dream of becoming this well, its so beautiful
So clean
The girl with the carpet dress had a nice tone!
I think the second one, is more like classic❤❤ Love all three
Like the first the most, probably would chose #3 if this was another piece but for Winter #1 suits best.
The last was as if both the first and second have been perfectly combined in near perfection.
Oof string from first one 💀
But yall still amazing, love it 🩷
yea I heard that too lol
After 2 years playing the trumpet and participating in band, it has come to my attention that very good musicians tend to have swing in their performances.
I know nothing about music or violins, but my fav was the first one :)
"Help!"
"They're coming! Help us!"
"Help us!"
I LOVE the attitude
The young lady on the left has the best and cleanest sound, imo! ❤
The girl on the left had the best tempo and expressiveness she is the most pleasing to listen to
Felt like a villain awakening back story from three people
THE GUY MAKE IT PERFECT
I love the third one the best, sounded clear and didn't screech, loved the trills
As a brass player, I know nothing about violins, but I love the tone of the first person who played.
The First messed up the ending, the second messed up the start, the guy did it perfect
this is the song that got me to start playing violin at 6 years old istg it's been my one goal during my 7 years practicing :)
I liked the sound of the first violinist in the colorful skirt. The other two were screechy.
I love how they were all respectful of each other's moment in the sun instead of trying to play over each other
the first one had really nice tone 😍
We gonna pass through vardohus fortress with this one🥶🥶🥶🔥
All violinists are god's gift to humanity
i like the first one the most. simple and clean 😊
The girl wearing dress did the best because when she played i didn't hear other notes only one
The guy was great
Sarah tried holding back after the squeak but you ain't slick! Kidding very well done
The guy played the best 🎉
ALL 3 WERE SO GREAT and i love Vivaldi four seasons
Played violin for 7 years but could never play up to this level lol switched to guitar
The young lady on the left is delightful 😊
Who is doing the other violins that we hear in the back ?
a speaker
Someone at my school in year 11 played this with him doing the solo parts and omg I've never seen everyone cheer so loud, as Someone who loves music it just made me smile
My toxic trait is thinking I can do this 😂
(I have played viola for only two years 😅 )
finally someone else who played the viola!! i've been playing it for three years and i obviously can't
It’s so funny to me I play the violin, I see this and think I can play it. The moment I actually think about trying to play it I instantly realize how tough it would be. Been playing for 4.5 years, I’ll get there eventually
@@brysonparker3723 honestly so true lol
Love how intense the first one sounded vs how elegant the last sounded💛
The guy had the best intonation, sound and expression imo😬
we turnin on the lighthouse with this one 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯💯
Hell yeah 🔥🔥
3rd one definitely sounds the best to me.
My favorite music... Vivaldi's winter.
Thank you❤
Ever wonder who made coca cola?
Well the answer is not as surprising as you think.
Huh? This is a violin video-
I love how each one sounded unique
idk, I loved that ❤
ima act like i can tell the difference ☠️
I liked the first one best. But, I enjoyed their collaboration at the end even better.
The guy was best
So much skill in one video , wonderful
I just had a violin audition, and I failed miserably, so now I'm watching people that made it and crying. You're awesome guys!
Edit: Turns out, I did not fail miserably. I got in as third chair
The first one touched my heart ❤
The guy was the best 👍
the guy did it best, the way he did it so elegantly proves he knows the steps of the violin.
I think the guy did it perfectly spot on to the original sound
Yeah. The third one was the absolute best. Guy slayed that. They’re all great, but his sounded just perfect!
I want to know how many takes this took 😅
One i bet, you can notice some of the mistakes they made. Nevertheless, all 3 of them are really good 😅
From a technical standpoint the guy is the obvious winner. No squeaking or skipping on the notes and no dual tones
The seastrings? You should be violists then?
BTW, liked the first the most. Wasn't the "best", but the most interesting to listen to.
As a pianist, I hear no difference and think they they all nailed it 🔥🔥🔥
The guy ❤
The guys intonation is just smooth like butter
#1 was by far cleanest. #2 was sloppiest.
Gave me literal CHILLS
like im not even joking ✨✨
I like the second one the best
Y'all are so goodd!!
Number 1 was number 1 but also she played lowest position so 🤷🏼🤷🏾.
Wdym she was playing position 1
@@malslifeisover5087that was the point
@@lele-pi1ys Oh wait yeah im stupid.
I choose between either one of them. But if they can’t play and get along with one another, then I’ll have to go to Europe and get those two guys who can play beautifully and harmonize it brings a tear to your eyes. And they can stand on their feet and play and play in various travel venues. They collaborate, and not adversarial in their performances.
Oooooogloria
1st one was the most enjoyable despite the squeak, 2nd one tried way to hard to get volume and just crunched, 3rd one was clean but maybe a little passive
they all look depressed and spiteful 💀
It’s a very intense piece, maybe they were just focusing?
@@Ruan_V very true but still you cannot deny they do look a bit sad and bitter, no?
@@yenlaj true i guess
are u dumb what r u yapping about the two girls were smiling
r u blind or deaf
The boy was so good and so smooth
Definitely was the best
Well then… they just have to take turns
You can tell the difference in each violin, it’s really beautiful
The last one gave me chills, but all were so amazing
The 1st one is the only on-beat execution of this music I’ve ever heard. Of course, I haven’t heard 100% of violinists in the world 😊but still. Bravo!!!
Last one gave me goosebumps ❤❤
The first one cadence is always delightful