I’m so glad you noticed the connection to The Police in this song. This was Rush tribute to the Police. The band were big fans of Reggae and the Police in particular I really like this track as well. The great thing with Rush is you find and add new favorites as your Journey continues Thanks for going through this classic album I’m hoping for more Rush reactions in the future
Dear lady, you haven’t scratched the surface of the Rush rabbit hole. Allow an old member of the Rush army to give you a playlist, BUT be prepared for epic musical compositions that are not 3-4 minute “radio friendly” songs. These are 7-10+ minute masterpieces. Xanadu, 1981 Live in Montreal , Exit Stage Left tour La Villa Strangiato (studio version) from their Hemispheres album is the best, IMHO. An EPIC 9+ minute instrumental BTW, Neil Peart wrote all of Rush’s’ lyrics 99+% of them. He was RARELY seen (while not playing) without a book in his hands. A very avid reader of EVERYTHING he could get his hands on, and also authored many books. Reading the lyrics along with listening to them is essential, if you don’t know them. The Pass, from their album “Presto” is a beautiful change of pace for a Rush song, but it’s unmistakable Rush. I would also suggest, (if you’re into their “storytelling”, NO lyricist is better, IMHO, than Peart. RIP Professor. Explore 2112, side A. Yes, the entire side is a story and you can read all about it within the album cover. Cygnus X-1 , Book I & II. Book I is from their “A Farewell to Kings” album, and Book II is the entire side A of “Hemispheres”. MY personal favorite(s), (recall I DID SAY THAT I WAS an OLD member of the Rush army), are The Necromancer and The Fountain of Lamneth, both from the Caress of Steel album. You will have to “travel back in time” a couple decades to find some of these gems, but it’s worth the effort, trust me. The Rush rabbit hole is a VERY DEEP one. New sub, BTW. Love your mind. Enjoy ✌️❤
Hasn't scratched the surface? I'll say, only seen 2 of her reactions yet she GETS Rush. Oh, she's scratched alright and Wonderfully. When have you last heard someone break down so much of them musically, lyrically, psychologically after hearing 1 album?
MB yes. Good going dropping Caress. That's Rush. When Geddy handed Paul Stanley a tape of Caress, Paul said cool. Later when he gave it back to Geddy he said, in his Love Gun mindset, " I don't get it" I can really see that in my mind. Just too deep for him.
I absolutely can't wait for her to hear Signals and Grace Under Pressure.. Subdivisions, The Weapon, Analog Kid, Losing It, Red Sector A, Big Money etc.. I also really like to hear her interpretation of The Trees
WOW I haven’t heard this song for a long time. You’re the only reactor to pull this song. You’re smart and can comprehend songs way more than I and I learn from you. Thank You!
There’s a couple other reactors who’ve hit this one, though they might not be on your radar or showing up in your feed. Occasionally, I’ll go to the UA-cam search bar and type a song title followed by the word reaction, so then I’ll be pulling up all the reactions done to the song regardless of their names.
@@CANDOKNOWHOW - Indeed! _Redheaded Neighbor_ (meanwhile a proper Rush fan) had reacted to this song a while ago and also _Justin Panariello_ , who'd even listened his way through Rush's *entire* discography, plus live versions and interviews (He can't stand 'Cinderella Man' and had been poking fun at it several times, too 😅)
Moving Pictures was only the first of the best 4 album run a band ever had. I told my wife to slip in a copy of Signals in my casket when the time comes so I can spend eternity with a smile on my face.
Thank you again Rosalie for bringing more attention to RUSH, For long time fans, we have known what you are discovering. In my opinion, RUSH is not a band for the average music listener because they just don't understand what RUSH is doing. It takes a sophisticated ear and above average intelligence. However, as you mentioned, they still have the ability to deliver a catchy tune without sacrificing the RUSH sound. I think RUSH could have easily followed the herd and cranked out 3 1/2 minute songs with that would have been more radio friendly and endeared them to the music/radio industry, but that isn't who Geddy, Neil, and Alex are. Thanks again. Great reaction!!!!
Almost, but not quite. It was actually Rush who were influenced by The Police. By the end of the 70's, Rush was tiring on the big, epic, Prog-Rock concept music that they were doing, during the 1970s. It was a heavy-lift for them and they were burned out on that style of song writing. Then, in 1979, they played the Pink Pop Festival in Holland and The Police were a part of the group of bands playing that day-long show. Rush were very impressed with The Police and they ate-up their style and attitude. Also, Rush were still young men back then and they really loved all the new Punk, Post-Punk, and New Wave music that was coming out at the beginning of the 80's and that music was all very influential on them. They loved that music and they wanted to bring some of those more contemporary styles/flavors into their music. So, that is where we get songs like "Spirit of Radio", "Entre Nous" and many of the songs on the Moving Pictures album and beyond. So, keep going with Rush in the 1980s! You will love the Signals album, which followed Moving Pictures. Excellent New Rock, if you will...Prog-Power-Rock or "Prog-New Wave Rock" is kind of where they were at that time. Great stuff!
They never had a bad era in their musical evolution, I love early Rush but the later albums show a musical maturity to put them in my all time great bands list, they deserve to be in the debate.
I can't believe I'm the only commenter in two days! and apparently the first to view this video too? Vital Signs is a popular song...one of my favorites off the album as well, but I have to choose Red Barchetta and The Camera Eye as my first two favorites. There isn't a single song on the album that I don't question if it is my favorite every time I listen though... Great job on the full album reaction though, I agree with almost all of what your sociological/psychological take and meaning of the songs, any deviance isn't worth mentioning. My Rush journey is only a few years old itself, though I knew and liked half a dozen Rush tunes back in the day when they were new, I never took a deep dive into the Rush discography until just a few short years ago, me being in my mid 50's now. I mentally kick myself in the *ss everyday for waiting until my 50's to listen to more Rush, now my favorite band of all time. But I am so grateful that I did eventually look into them deeper and didn't miss out on this legendary trio, and pray I have many more years to listen to them. My knowledge of Rush now, though not complete or without error, is worthy of at least a master's degree if not doctorate at this point. I've never been so enthralled with any band or singer/song writer ever. Probably because they are the first group that I ever felt were on my intellectual level and gave me the complexity and detail in rock music I always craved, but didn't know it. To me Rush's music is every bit as great as the classical composers.
Rosale --- thank you for your reaction to this song. Only my 3rd time watching your videos Witch Hunt, YYZ, and now Vital Signs. Your reactions are more cerebral and more of an analyses which I find refreshing when it is done with an amazement and joy rather than cold and clinical. I've always been an avid reader, I remember being frustrated when I was very little that I couldn't read yet, being the youngest of 4 kids. I was maybe 3 or 4 and reading and stayed that way reading everything and anything. In jr high and high school, even though I was that surfer, stoner, jock, skateboarder into music I always had a paperback in my back pocket. I would read a book a week sometimes more. If I didn't like a class or what we were doing in a class I would read my book and get in trouble by the teacher and sent to the Dean's or principle's office. Can you imagine a teacher punishing a student for reading? Well, the principle and I got along very well and he said we're gonna do something about this. He looked in a large binder notebook and looking through the pages and then said okay here we go. He said this is a book of approved classes that a principle can use if there is a qualified teacher to instruct and enough students who desire to take that class. That notebook had classes that would keep kids in school and out of trouble for sure. Every subject and hobby and different life changing subjects. He said i have a proposition for you. You stop reading in your Algebra 2 class and do the work and I'll give you 5 credits a semester to read whatever books you want , not comics etc... abook at least 100 pages and on Friday of every week you turn in a 2 page book report to me on whater book you read. I could write a two page book report off the top of my head of a book I read 5 years ago, no problem. So that was a good deal. But I also really enjoy reading lyrics to songs. And there are some very gifted lyricists that average person pays no attention to. This Moving pictures album is amazing. I like the tracks that were used as the singles and got radio play but those aren't the best songs in my opinion. It's the side 2 tracks that are the best. Anyways your next Rush experience has to be the album that followed Moving Pictures is titled Signals. It also is absolutely an amazing album. More cerebral and personal than Moving Pictures. You have to experience that album. Then you shoukd go back deeper into the Rush rabbit hole and play 2112, Caress of Steel is a must listen. Rush's music changed after Power Windows and their music was still great but not as impactful in those years leading up to Neil's illness.
This is one of my favorite Rush songs. I love your examination of the line "A tired mind become a shapeshifter" one of the best lines. So perfect and true! Also the line "An ounce of perception, a pound of obscure" is of course a reference to the old saying "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure" but flipped. I LOVE IT!
Rosalie, first off, I Love all the Rush reactions, I think as you continue (at some point) you will have many more faves, I have been a fan of Rush since the 70s, I think personally Rush fans appreciate your reactions, and Ill finish by saying not only beautiful, your also very intelligent. Keep up the fantastic work.
OK First , glad you are discovering Rush. The title "Moving Pictures" is not a double entendre. It's more. Especially if your see the vinyl LP. They are on a movie set. The pictures themselves are moving(in motion). What is in the pictures are emotionally moving. And of course the moving men.
Your reaction is a testament to your depth of character and sensibility. This is a song that could easily be dismissed as cold and sterile, but you found an emotional connection to it. Nicely done.
I found your channel today and have watched about 6 of your videos so for. I really enjoy your analysis of the songs, your very intelligent. Welcome to the Rush rabbit hole, your addicted now, one of the greatest Rock bands of all time, definitely the most unique, and the best 3 musicians to ever form a trio band. There musical arrangements still blow me away today.
You are so intelligent, and a REAL thinker, as well as a great communicator, and just listening to you analyze this song makes me feel smarter. I completely enjoy and agree with your brilliant analysis of this song (as well as other songs you have analyzed in your other videos). Thanks for yet another awesome song analysis!
So glad I grew up listening to Rush. One of the reasons I picked up the guitar. So many days and nights playing to their albums. Even my parents became fans.
Yes, Rush liked The Police very much, and were influenced by The Police even though they were contemporaries and vice-versa. Very influenced by Yes as well, both as heroes of youth and as contemporaries later on. As you learn more about Rush you will realize that they were a band that very much kept up with the times regarding popular music. Being an influential band themselves, to the likes of Tool, The Foo Fighters and Dream Theater, they also allowed themselves to be influenced by contemporary bands. The thing was though, that Rush was around for over four decades, and many, many of their contemporaries fell by the way-side, broke up, or ended as bands one after the other as Rush, and a few others, like Van Halen, The Rolling Stones and Aerosmith just stayed in the game for decades. Many of the bands influenced by Rush became their contemporaries and then history while Rush remained. But if you go back to the beginning, back to Rush's first couple albums, they were heavily influenced by Led Zeppelin, Yes, Black Sabbath, cream and others. They even did an early single, before their first album, that was a cover of Buddy Holley's Not Fade Away, which in turn was covered by The Rolling Stones and other bands as well. By the late 70's Rush had truly found themselves and were doing much of the influencing, but Rush, as they were changing, changed their influences, like The Police and Genesis, Super Tramp, Van Halen, etc. They have a very unique 80's sound, changing from the 70's and that is as true in the 90's and 2000's up to their last album in 2012. While at the same time, in many ways, coming full circle in the 90's and 2000's moving back into being a power-trio of guitar, bass and drums and less synth/keyboards like in the 70's (they did incorporate keyboards, IIRC, around their 4th or 5th album and always had them to some extent after) If you want to hear some Rush music, that at first was mistaken for Led Zeppelin, check out the songs 'Working Man' and 'Finding My Way' off their self-titled debut album. How about a bit of Jimi Hendrix influence? Check out 'In The Mood' of their debut album or 'By-Tor and The Snow Dog' off their second album Fly By Night. Want to check out some Black Sabbath influence from Rush, look no further than 'The Necromancer' off their 3rd album Caress of Steel. Another song off of their debut album, 'I Need Some Lovin', you would have a great early seventies Rolling Stones song if you only replace Geddy's vocals with Mick Jagger.
Rush reaction videos are a dime a dozen on YT. However, this is one of the most insightful breakdowns, musicly and lyrically I've seen yet of this great band. Bravo to you.
Another fantastic Rush Reaction. I don't even remember a time when I wasn't a Rush fan. I also love my fellow Rush fans. They are an intelligent bunch. I learn new things in their comments. My favorite albums are definitely 2112 and Hemispheres. I will be a Rush fan as long as my lungs draw breath.
Don't be ashamed of loving this song or being your favorite. I have a special place in my heart for this song. I did an essay in college on this song, it moved me so much.
Rosalie, I much enjoy your reactions and particularly toward Rush. Their unique compositions and phenomenal sounds from a three-piece band is out-of-this-world. Please continue releasing entertaining reactions to really all genres. Many thanks..!
as a teen in the early 80s, already playing bass briefly at that point... I had the EXACT reaction when I heard that little bass solo for the first time.
Also one of my favourites! That song is so underrated in my opinion. Such a great album that it’s often overlooked and yet the lyrics and unusual blend of Sci-fi and reggae make it such a unique song ❤❤❤
btw, you are one of the best "Rush reactors" on you tube! You do a great job! keep it up, we need you and an evil world. Thank you! Jeffrey, i play bass, drums, guitar, synths and sing like Geddy because of them and I aslo have my own digital recording studio.
This song was by "The Fabulous Men" one of the Rush alter ego's. It was very new wave compared to the rest of Moving Pictures. It just shows how versitile they are, as writers and musicians.
Thanks for digging into the whole album! I was still in high school when this came out and just like all their music and the integrity of it this album left it's mark on me. I agree completely that we need more music that actually says something. If there are any singers that want to do that let me know, because I'm here and make music but don't have the voice for vocals. Thanks again for digging into so much of the great music that's out there Rosalie. Good job.
I've listened to Rush for years and the lyrics, but you have a great way of explaining the lyrics that I understand and appreciate their songs even more!
You earned a new subscriber. Clearly, you have the aptitude to do Rush reviews, because a proper Rush review must include so many elements that are simply not necessary for most modern rock music - and you do many of them very well. May I suggest a "deviation from the norm," of suggestions for your next Rush review? Don't get me wrong, Signals is one of my favorite albums, but your jam is the psychological and interpretive analysis of songs, correct? If that is the case, let me suggest two specific songs which would be right up your alley: The Trees and Natural Science. You will spend hours contemplating the meaning of each songs. I would also suggest you grab live clips for each as they are both very complex and beautifully orchestrated - as impressive to listen to as to think about. Great job and, regardless of your next choice, make sure you choose more Rush!
I love your breakdown of this whole album of Rush. And hope that you will pick another of Rushes albums to breakdown. I live in Canada and have seen Rush many times and will miss seeing the best 3 man band of all time. Rush is Timeless. I also love that a different generation is experiencing music that is considered the best.Music from the 60,70,80's was where you had true musicianship that you can't find today. I'm 60 years old and your right all the bands were influenced by each other back then.Rush,The Police,Led Zeppelin.Keep Rockin.
Amazing. I cannot remember the last time I heard this song, 2 or 3 decades cannot explain that. But boy did I remember the lyrics like it was yesterdsy, somehow here I was singing along, whew!!!
An ounce of perception a pound of obscure. I used that line in my senior quote. I shared already that I discovered Rush in 8th grade but found the b side in 11th and 12th grade. This song captivated me as I can see it did you. Glad you enjoyed it Glad you took the ride. I agree with much of what you say today is I have believed since yesteryear. I really acknowledge you for taking the patience to check it out. Nice meeting you - through these moving picture videos.
It's so refreshing and encouraging to see a new generation of critical thinkers discovering the profound philosophical depth of Neil's writing, and the sheer virtuosic musicianship of all three members of Rush.
Hello Rosalie, this comment is not about this video. I wanted to put my comment on your most recent post, in the hope that you will actually see it. I want to thank you for introducing me to Ren. He is absolutely brilliant and speaks for a group that is tragically marginalized by our society. Your pure appreciation and recognition of art in it's many forms is rare and greatly appreciated. Thank you for your content.
Rush's entire catalog speaks to a wide range of people and they are easily my favorite band and I frequently listen to their entire catalog from the first album to their last; however, my two favorite albums are Power Windows and Hold Your Fire with Grand Designs, Emotion Detector, Prime Mover, and High Water being my all time favorite Rush songs because they are the story of my life.
This was the last song on Moving Pictures which I think was a good lead into there next album, Signals. Look forward to many more reactions from Rush👍🎶
My brother showed me what Rush was all about in 1982 and I was hooked immediately. I had the pleasure of seeing them live 17 times before their retirement. I love all of Rush's music and it is very challenging to pick a favorite piece of music. With that being said 1 of my favorites ties into the journey you just completed, but is a sort of prequel on the album Permanent Waves the Song Natural Science would be my recommendation for the next Rush song you experience.
The band's Rush and Police were formed relatively close to each other and its easy to hear they've influenced each other being that they were both so dynamic.
Yes. Great reaction. Vital Signs is one of my favorites and I think it’s notoriously underrated. So glad you are appreciating Rush. One of the greatest bands of all time. Geddy calls their style “hard rock”. Many people describe their music as progressive and other terms, but I’ll go with what Geddy says, “hard rock“. Works for me. They’re just so awesome. Enjoy ❤
Great insight and commentary--the next album by Rush, Signals, is the most logical and most excellent place to pursue the musical extravaganza of Rush, if you want to be further mesmerized by their lyrics and music.
Another great reaction! I've really enjoyed your commentary and insights, breaking down Rush's music. Just a geeky thing, I've always held onto is this. Vital Signs is the last song of Moving Pictures. A banger, with subtle reggae vibes, that deals with the inner struggles, individuals have when trying to balance personal perspectives against society's pressures. One key lyric is, " signals get crossed and the balance distorted ". And the next album is titled " Signals". And talks about personal inner struggles and society's demands.....just genius!! Musically they are incredible and possibly one of the greatest ever....but lyrically, Neil's writing and the band's interpretation, is second to none. Keep up with the Rush reactions. Hopefully, you'll continue with the Signals album and discover their musical evolution. Subdivision, Analog Kid, Digital Man, Chemistry, Losing It and New World Man are amazing songs. Please check these out and see what you think
First, great catch on the Police comparison! Neil was a big fan of Stewart Copeland's drumming and the Police's sound. I had a sneaking suspicion this one might grab you (in a good way). I agree 100%. This song is so good, both from a composition standpoint and also lyrically. I challenge you to discover some of the "deviations" in the lyrics from line to line and verse to verse as Geddy literally sings about deviating and elevating from the norm. This song embodies the genius of this power trio like few others in their 38 year discography. SO GLAD you loved this one. I think it will age well over the years and remain one of your all time favs. especially given your psychological and human behavioral background. Last, just want to call out the line "Signals get crossed" as a foreshadowing of their next album: Signals (1982) which I think you will also love.
This was a big change for Rush, reggae, electronica shocked us, well me, 1981 17 years old being brought up on 2112, permanent waves wow this is what I loved about the ever changing rush ❤
Moving Pictures is a masterpiece of an album. Great from start to finish and not a bad song to be found anywhere. Still my favorite release from the band to this day. Great video and you have a new subscriber.
Actually Neil was not afraid to take elements of different genres and he admittedly said he was influenced by reggae and the Police in particular...And he and Stewart Copeland did become friends years later.
Rosalie, thank you for your insights. From my first time seeing Rush live (Chicago, 1977), I have been entranced by the sheer volume of information contained not only in the lyrics, but in the music itself. I'm no musician, but this band grabbed me by the ears and pulled me in. It's hard to believe sometimes that all this sound comes from three guys. For a true science fiction experience, I would recommend the title track from 2112, a 22-minute masterpiece that explores highs and lows, ins and outs, and some basics of the human condition. Now, moving on to another 1970s power trio, how about checking out Emerson, Lake, and Palmer? For a simple tune with very, very deep meaning, try out Lucky Man from their self-titled debut album. And for a rollicking adventure, nothing beats Pirates from the Works Volume 1 album. Keep on rockin'!
I loved, loved, loved your analysis of Moving Pictures. I first encountered Rush as a teenager, shortly after they released this album. I think you would also enjoy Presto and Power Windows from later in their catalogue. Very different musically and stylistically, but the lyrics are just as profound and enduring. Their final album, Clockwork Angels, is a true concept album, and a masterpiece as well. Look forward to more from you in respect to Rush, but also other music.
Best review of lyrics I've seen. Neil would have loved to see someone understanding the lyrics at this level. Very interesting that it's your favorite on this album. Well done!
Congratulations for completing the greatest album ever recorded. When one considers when the album was recorded (1981) and the level of technology at that time, combined with the musicianship and musicality and then the lyrical input, this album is a true Masterpiece, in the real sense of the word. Thanks for listening to the entire album, how you have a sense of one of the greatest (in my opinon) greatest bands in history,
My first Rush concert was back in 1984. I've been to several Rush concerts since, but the best was taking my nine year old to Clockwork Angels back in 2012. He is still a Rush fan.
The album after this, "Signals", has 3 more "hey, Rush like The Police" songs. "Analog Kid", "Digital Man", "New World Man". The last one only exists because side B was too short for cassette tape so they jammed a new song and it's the most Police like.
By far one of the best albums ever made! And not just because I am a live-long Rush fan, but it is so rare to have an album with NO bad or less than great songs as filler. Each and every one, as you have clearly seen and heard, is as good or better than the last. Rush had many more great songs in their long catalog, but this was the pinnacle album, taking them to new levels and turning the page into new genres and styles. Fantastic set of reactions! Thank you so much!
You have many many albums of Rush to still be enthralled and taken in by…. From 2112 through Presto, Roll the Bones all the way to Clockwork Angels. You will also discover that the lyrics, written by Neil, are based on their experiences in life as well as how the facets of society and reality have remained the same and evolved. Once again, as I’ve said before, you are an exceptional speaker, identifying specific aspects of song, like time signatures to soul-moving anthemic pieces which most are what Rush has seamlessly produced. Much love and respect to You.
You say you feel smarter from hearing these Rush songs and as a lifelong Rush fan, I definitely know how you feel. But you know what? Your experience as a trained psychologist/mental health person (not sure exactly so forgive me if I didn't get the specifics of your background right) and how you explain things made me feel smarter, too! Thank you for your insightful, thoughtful reactions, Rosalie! Looking forward to hearing more from you! 👍
Not all reactors are as good, that is for sure. I love hearing educated people, something sadly lacking as I see more evidence of some younger folks having no clue. Others hit it out of the park like Rosalie. Rock On!
Ever since I first listened and headbanged with my air guitar over my friend's Moving Pictures album at 11 in 1983, it became part of my life's soundtrack, especially for my first 30 years. And you @Rosalie, react and describe them so beautifully, in such ways that resound with me in such profoundness, that I could tell you which of my old memories, feelings and thoughts that have been triggered by each one song, either from back then, or now where I have deeply reconnected with the band's sounds. As far as recommendations go, I'd go next with the albums from, lets call it that same 80's era: Permanent Waves (Freewill, Jacobs Ladder, Natural Science), Signals (The Weapon, New World Man, Countdown), Grace Under Pressure (Distant Early Warning, Afterimage), Power Windows (Emotion Detector, Mystic Rythms), Hold your Fire (Time Stand Still,, Second Nature, Mission,...). I mean, either older or newer, every album, every song is a masterpiece, in one way or another, each with its own right. Oh, but the last one: Clockwork Angels, especially "The Garden", there are no words for this one, especially knowing it ultimately became the band's goodbye... For now, Limelight is my iPhone's ringtone. 😜 So thank you. ❤❤
I love the way you think. Sometimes you take a bit of a tangent, but always find your way back to the matter at hand. Watching you appreciate the band I love and grew up with, really is something to see.
I'd be curious to hear your take on the next album after this one, Signals, and the progression of ideas, to me it's a natural extension, especially after Vital Signs.
One of my favourites from MP. Really great that you enjoyed it Rosalie. Knew you would. I’ve LOVED your take on MP. One of my favourite albums. Now your reactions one of my favourites on You Tube
i have been a rush fan for decades but i have been starting to buy LP vinyl. i am hearing rush music that hasnt seen much airtime on mainstream radio or XM and i really like it. some of the material is really awesome. this track is pretty good
I'm curious if your next album will be by RUSH, or someone else? If I can recommend another band though, it would be YES. RUSH idolized YES, and the reason Geddy Lee played a Rickenbacker Bass was 'Chris Squire', the bass player for YES, who's now deceased. Hope you check them out. 'Close to the Edge' is there best album, but their song 'Roundabout' from their album 'Fragile' was their first #1 hit. One more thing: RUSH introduced YES, when they were inducted into the HOF, and they had Geddy play his bass with them on stage, at that induction, because Chris had passed away. They performed Roundabout, so if you'd like to see that performance, it's on UA-cam.
So cool to see someone discover and appreciate my favorite band RUSH! I would recommend my very close second favorite band, KANSAS for a first time reaction in the future. I'd start with the album KANSAS LEFTOVERTURE. Thoughtful spiritual lyrics, amazing musical compositions, and mind blowing musicianship!
I’m so glad you noticed the connection to The Police in this song.
This was Rush tribute to the Police. The band were big fans of Reggae and the Police in particular
I really like this track as well.
The great thing with Rush is you find and add new favorites as your Journey continues
Thanks for going through this classic album
I’m hoping for more Rush reactions in the future
In my mind there exists a cover of Vital Signs by The Police.
The Drummer from The Police Stuart Copeland was very close friends with Neil Peart!
See my admittedly wordy comment above. Near the end of the comment is the short story of Rush & The Police's 'feud'. Haha!
Apparently, Stuart said everyone told him that he was their "second" favorite drummer, lol!.
Outstanding interpertation.....you have passed Rush 101, now on to the 2nd semester....this will be a long and enlightening journey!!!
Dear lady, you haven’t scratched the surface of the Rush rabbit hole. Allow an old member of the Rush army to give you a playlist, BUT be prepared for epic musical compositions that are not 3-4 minute “radio friendly” songs. These are 7-10+ minute masterpieces.
Xanadu, 1981 Live in Montreal , Exit Stage Left tour
La Villa Strangiato (studio version) from their Hemispheres album is the best, IMHO. An EPIC 9+ minute instrumental
BTW, Neil Peart wrote all of Rush’s’ lyrics 99+% of them. He was RARELY seen (while not playing) without a book in his hands. A very avid reader of EVERYTHING he could get his hands on, and also authored many books. Reading the lyrics along with listening to them is essential, if you don’t know them.
The Pass, from their album “Presto” is a beautiful change of pace for a Rush song, but it’s unmistakable Rush.
I would also suggest, (if you’re into their “storytelling”, NO lyricist is better, IMHO, than Peart. RIP Professor. Explore 2112, side A. Yes, the entire side is a story and you can read all about it within the album cover.
Cygnus X-1 , Book I & II. Book I is from their “A Farewell to Kings” album, and Book II is the entire side A of “Hemispheres”.
MY personal favorite(s), (recall I DID SAY THAT I WAS an OLD member of the Rush army), are The Necromancer and The Fountain of Lamneth, both from the Caress of Steel album. You will have to “travel back in time” a couple decades to find some of these gems, but it’s worth the effort, trust me. The Rush rabbit hole is a VERY DEEP one. New sub, BTW. Love your mind. Enjoy ✌️❤
For me there are two great lyricist in prog-rock, or even in rock, that are amazing: Peter Hammill and Neil Peart.
amen. When you get Rush, you know.
She needs to listen to Subdivisions
Rush Army Baby!
Hasn't scratched the surface? I'll say, only seen 2 of her reactions yet she GETS Rush. Oh, she's scratched alright and Wonderfully. When have you last heard someone break down so much of them musically, lyrically, psychologically after hearing 1 album?
The drums are so complex in this song!!! It blows my mind every time I listen to it😛
No doubt a nod to Stewart Copeland.
If Vital Signs was your favorite, your next stop should be Signals, their next album for amplification of some of those ideas. Rush on!
Grace Under Pressure works as well.
She needs to start at first album and work upward. Early Rush was comparable to early Zep some say.
MB yes. Good going dropping Caress. That's Rush. When Geddy handed Paul Stanley a tape of Caress, Paul said cool. Later when he gave it back to Geddy he said, in his Love Gun mindset, " I don't get it" I can really see that in my mind. Just too deep for him.
I absolutely can't wait for her to hear Signals and Grace Under Pressure..
Subdivisions, The Weapon, Analog Kid, Losing It, Red Sector A, Big Money etc..
I also really like to hear her interpretation of The Trees
WOW I haven’t heard this song for a long time. You’re the only reactor to pull this song. You’re smart and can comprehend songs way more than I and I learn from you. Thank You!
There’s a couple other reactors who’ve hit this one, though they might not be on your radar or showing up in your feed.
Occasionally, I’ll go to the UA-cam search bar and type a song title followed by the word reaction, so then I’ll be pulling up all the reactions done to the song regardless of their names.
@@CANDOKNOWHOW - Indeed! _Redheaded Neighbor_ (meanwhile a proper Rush fan) had reacted to this song a while ago and also _Justin Panariello_ , who'd even listened his way through Rush's *entire* discography, plus live versions and interviews (He can't stand 'Cinderella Man' and had been poking fun at it several times, too 😅)
Lots of reactors do the entire Moving Pictures Album.
I don’t want to overwhelm you, but as great as Moving Pictures is, you’ve only scratched the surface of the world of RUSH.👍👍
Moving Pictures was only the first of the best 4 album run a band ever had. I told my wife to slip in a copy of Signals in my casket when the time comes so I can spend eternity with a smile on my face.
True but no better place to start. You can’t go wrong with Moving Pictures
Long time Rush fans feel that Rush wrote the storybook to our lives. Glad you are enjoying and getting to experience some of that!
That they did…
Thank you again Rosalie for bringing more attention to RUSH, For long time fans, we have known what you are discovering. In my opinion, RUSH is not a band for the average music listener because they just don't understand what RUSH is doing. It takes a sophisticated ear and above average intelligence. However, as you mentioned, they still have the ability to deliver a catchy tune without sacrificing the RUSH sound. I think RUSH could have easily followed the herd and cranked out 3 1/2 minute songs with that would have been more radio friendly and endeared them to the music/radio industry, but that isn't who Geddy, Neil, and Alex are. Thanks again. Great reaction!!!!
Almost, but not quite. It was actually Rush who were influenced by The Police. By the end of the 70's, Rush was tiring on the big, epic, Prog-Rock concept music that they were doing, during the 1970s. It was a heavy-lift for them and they were burned out on that style of song writing. Then, in 1979, they played the Pink Pop Festival in Holland and The Police were a part of the group of bands playing that day-long show. Rush were very impressed with The Police and they ate-up their style and attitude. Also, Rush were still young men back then and they really loved all the new Punk, Post-Punk, and New Wave music that was coming out at the beginning of the 80's and that music was all very influential on them. They loved that music and they wanted to bring some of those more contemporary styles/flavors into their music. So, that is where we get songs like "Spirit of Radio", "Entre Nous" and many of the songs on the Moving Pictures album and beyond. So, keep going with Rush in the 1980s! You will love the Signals album, which followed Moving Pictures. Excellent New Rock, if you will...Prog-Power-Rock or "Prog-New Wave Rock" is kind of where they were at that time. Great stuff!
They never had a bad era in their musical evolution, I love early Rush but the later albums show a musical maturity to put them in my all time great bands list, they deserve to be in the debate.
@@vicprovost2561Huge Rush fan here. Geddy’s voice was in tatters for the last 15 years of their touring days. Musically still spot on though.
No no no
Rush never had a bad phase . You just didn’t get the reverse polarity my friend
Geddy almost always pulled it off. Never disappointed me and I saw every tour
They played 4+ hours, no opening band, 1 break. wTF more do you want?
I can't believe I'm the only commenter in two days! and apparently the first to view this video too? Vital Signs is a popular song...one of my favorites off the album as well, but I have to choose Red Barchetta and The Camera Eye as my first two favorites. There isn't a single song on the album that I don't question if it is my favorite every time I listen though...
Great job on the full album reaction though, I agree with almost all of what your sociological/psychological take and meaning of the songs, any deviance isn't worth mentioning.
My Rush journey is only a few years old itself, though I knew and liked half a dozen Rush tunes back in the day when they were new, I never took a deep dive into the Rush discography until just a few short years ago, me being in my mid 50's now. I mentally kick myself in the *ss everyday for waiting until my 50's to listen to more Rush, now my favorite band of all time. But I am so grateful that I did eventually look into them deeper and didn't miss out on this legendary trio, and pray I have many more years to listen to them. My knowledge of Rush now, though not complete or without error, is worthy of at least a master's degree if not doctorate at this point. I've never been so enthralled with any band or singer/song writer ever. Probably because they are the first group that I ever felt were on my intellectual level and gave me the complexity and detail in rock music I always craved, but didn't know it. To me Rush's music is every bit as great as the classical composers.
My favorite Rush song is the one I'm listening to at that moment.
Rosale --- thank you for your reaction to this song.
Only my 3rd time watching your videos Witch Hunt, YYZ, and now Vital Signs.
Your reactions are more cerebral and more of an analyses which I find refreshing when it is done with an amazement and joy rather than cold and clinical.
I've always been an avid reader, I remember being frustrated when I was very little that I couldn't read yet, being the youngest of 4 kids. I was maybe 3 or 4 and reading and stayed that way reading everything and anything. In jr high and high school, even though I was that surfer, stoner, jock, skateboarder into music I always had a paperback in my back pocket. I would read a book a week sometimes more. If I didn't like a class or what we were doing in a class I would read my book and get in trouble by the teacher and sent to the Dean's or principle's office. Can you imagine a teacher punishing a student for reading?
Well, the principle and I got along very well and he said we're gonna do something about this. He looked in a large binder notebook and looking through the pages and then said okay here we go. He said this is a book of approved classes that a principle can use if there is a qualified teacher to instruct and enough students who desire to take that class. That notebook had classes that would keep kids in school and out of trouble for sure. Every subject and hobby and different life changing subjects.
He said i have a proposition for you. You stop reading in your Algebra 2 class and do the work and I'll give you 5 credits a semester to read whatever books you want , not comics etc... abook at least 100 pages and on Friday of every week you turn in a 2 page book report to me on whater book you read. I could write a two page book report off the top of my head of a book I read 5 years ago, no problem. So that was a good deal.
But I also really enjoy reading lyrics to songs. And there are some very gifted lyricists that average person pays no attention to.
This Moving pictures album is amazing. I like the tracks that were used as the singles and got radio play but those aren't the best songs in my opinion. It's the side 2 tracks that are the best.
Anyways your next Rush experience has to be the album that followed Moving Pictures is titled Signals. It also is absolutely an amazing album. More cerebral and personal than Moving Pictures. You have to experience that album.
Then you shoukd go back deeper into the Rush rabbit hole and play 2112, Caress of Steel is a must listen.
Rush's music changed after Power Windows and their music was still great but not as impactful in those years leading up to Neil's illness.
Love the analysis you made of the whole moving pictures album, a masterpiece of music
You rock Rosalie! More Rush please! 🙏😎😊
You my girl for this. This tune is incredible and very overlooked.
This is one of my favorite Rush songs.
I love your examination of the line "A tired mind become a shapeshifter" one of the best lines. So perfect and true!
Also the line "An ounce of perception, a pound of obscure" is of course a reference to the old saying "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure" but flipped. I LOVE IT!
They were simply masters.
Rosalie, first off, I Love all the Rush reactions, I think as you continue (at some point) you will have many more faves, I have been a fan of Rush since the 70s, I think personally Rush fans appreciate your reactions, and Ill finish by saying not only beautiful, your also very intelligent. Keep up the fantastic work.
OK First , glad you are discovering Rush. The title "Moving Pictures" is not a double entendre. It's more. Especially if your see the vinyl LP. They are on a movie set. The pictures themselves are moving(in motion). What is in the pictures are emotionally moving. And of course the moving men.
Dig your reactions. A breath of fresh air to hear someone speak intelligently on what they’re hearing.
Your reaction is a testament to your depth of character and sensibility. This is a song that could easily be dismissed as cold and sterile, but you found an emotional connection to it. Nicely done.
I found your channel today and have watched about 6 of your videos so for. I really enjoy your analysis of the songs, your very intelligent. Welcome to the Rush rabbit hole, your addicted now, one of the greatest Rock bands of all time, definitely the most unique, and the best 3 musicians to ever form a trio band. There musical arrangements still blow me away today.
You are so intelligent, and a REAL thinker, as well as a great communicator, and just listening to you analyze this song makes me feel smarter. I completely enjoy and agree with your brilliant analysis of this song (as well as other songs you have analyzed in your other videos). Thanks for yet another awesome song analysis!
I think of this song as a precursor to their next album, Signals
So glad I grew up listening to Rush. One of the reasons I picked up the guitar. So many days and nights playing to their albums. Even my parents became fans.
Yes, Rush liked The Police very much, and were influenced by The Police even though they were contemporaries and vice-versa. Very influenced by Yes as well, both as heroes of youth and as contemporaries later on. As you learn more about Rush you will realize that they were a band that very much kept up with the times regarding popular music. Being an influential band themselves, to the likes of Tool, The Foo Fighters and Dream Theater, they also allowed themselves to be influenced by contemporary bands.
The thing was though, that Rush was around for over four decades, and many, many of their contemporaries fell by the way-side, broke up, or ended as bands one after the other as Rush, and a few others, like Van Halen, The Rolling Stones and Aerosmith just stayed in the game for decades. Many of the bands influenced by Rush became their contemporaries and then history while Rush remained.
But if you go back to the beginning, back to Rush's first couple albums, they were heavily influenced by Led Zeppelin, Yes, Black Sabbath, cream and others. They even did an early single, before their first album, that was a cover of Buddy Holley's Not Fade Away, which in turn was covered by The Rolling Stones and other bands as well. By the late 70's Rush had truly found themselves and were doing much of the influencing, but Rush, as they were changing, changed their influences, like The Police and Genesis, Super Tramp, Van Halen, etc.
They have a very unique 80's sound, changing from the 70's and that is as true in the 90's and 2000's up to their last album in 2012. While at the same time, in many ways, coming full circle in the 90's and 2000's moving back into being a power-trio of guitar, bass and drums and less synth/keyboards like in the 70's (they did incorporate keyboards, IIRC, around their 4th or 5th album and always had them to some extent after)
If you want to hear some Rush music, that at first was mistaken for Led Zeppelin, check out the songs 'Working Man' and 'Finding My Way' off their self-titled debut album. How about a bit of Jimi Hendrix influence? Check out 'In The Mood' of their debut album or 'By-Tor and The Snow Dog' off their second album Fly By Night.
Want to check out some Black Sabbath influence from Rush, look no further than 'The Necromancer' off their 3rd album Caress of Steel. Another song off of their debut album, 'I Need Some Lovin', you would have a great early seventies Rolling Stones song if you only replace Geddy's vocals with Mick Jagger.
Rush reaction videos are a dime a dozen on YT. However, this is one of the most insightful breakdowns, musicly and lyrically I've seen yet of this great band. Bravo to you.
Thank you very much!! 😊
Another fantastic Rush Reaction. I don't even remember a time when I wasn't a Rush fan. I also love my fellow Rush fans. They are an intelligent bunch. I learn new things in their comments.
My favorite albums are definitely 2112 and Hemispheres. I will be a Rush fan as long as my lungs draw breath.
Don't be ashamed of loving this song or being your favorite. I have a special place in my heart for this song. I did an essay in college on this song, it moved me so much.
Moving Pictures is peak, best Rush IMO. The album is banger after banger.
I like the three albums before and two afterward just as well if not more.
Personally, I don't understand how anyone can have ONE favorite Rush album. I'm struggling to keep it down to five.
My favorite Rush album is all of them.
@@jumpman8282It's like picking your favorite child.
Rosalie, I much enjoy your reactions and particularly toward Rush. Their unique compositions and phenomenal sounds from a three-piece band is out-of-this-world. Please continue releasing entertaining reactions to really all genres. Many thanks..!
Alex's guitar part was something Andy Somers would write any day....Both beautiful guitar players
as a teen in the early 80s, already playing bass briefly at that point... I had the EXACT reaction when I heard that little bass solo for the first time.
Also one of my favourites! That song is so underrated in my opinion. Such a great album that it’s often overlooked and yet the lyrics and unusual blend of Sci-fi and reggae make it such a unique song ❤❤❤
btw, you are one of the best "Rush reactors" on you tube! You do a great job! keep it up, we need you and an evil world. Thank you!
Jeffrey, i play bass, drums, guitar, synths and sing like Geddy because of them and I aslo have my own digital recording studio.
If you watch the Rush documentary Beyond the Lighted Stage, the guys talk about The Police being a big influence.
Yeah the "Signals" album surely proves that.
This song was by "The Fabulous Men" one of the Rush alter ego's. It was very new wave compared to the rest of Moving Pictures. It just shows how versitile they are, as writers and musicians.
Thanks for digging into the whole album!
I was still in high school when this came out and just like all their music and the integrity of it this album left it's mark on me.
I agree completely that we need more music that actually says something. If there are any singers that want to do that let me know, because I'm here and make music but don't have the voice for vocals.
Thanks again for digging into so much of the great music that's out there Rosalie. Good job.
I've listened to Rush for years and the lyrics, but you have a great way of explaining the lyrics that I understand and appreciate their songs even more!
You earned a new subscriber. Clearly, you have the aptitude to do Rush reviews, because a proper Rush review must include so many elements that are simply not necessary for most modern rock music - and you do many of them very well. May I suggest a "deviation from the norm," of suggestions for your next Rush review? Don't get me wrong, Signals is one of my favorite albums, but your jam is the psychological and interpretive analysis of songs, correct? If that is the case, let me suggest two specific songs which would be right up your alley: The Trees and Natural Science. You will spend hours contemplating the meaning of each songs. I would also suggest you grab live clips for each as they are both very complex and beautifully orchestrated - as impressive to listen to as to think about. Great job and, regardless of your next choice, make sure you choose more Rush!
I really enjoy how you analyze the songs. After 40+ years of listening to RUSH, i still hear new things in their songs. Thank You!
Rosalie is climbing the charts, she catches some great nuances, and is very interesting. I always thought this was a reggae groove sped up.
I love your breakdown of this whole album of Rush.
And hope that you will pick another of Rushes albums to breakdown. I live in Canada and have seen Rush many times and will miss seeing the best 3 man band of all time.
Rush is Timeless.
I also love that a different generation is experiencing music that is considered the best.Music from the 60,70,80's was where you had true musicianship that you can't find today. I'm 60 years old and your right all the bands were influenced by each other back then.Rush,The Police,Led Zeppelin.Keep Rockin.
Best reaction/analysis of this album that I have seen. Great job.
That's how we all feel. Rush gives us something to think about in almost every song.
I actually shed a tear watching you react to this spectacular song.....😢
Wow!! You are right on it. You get the insights really good.
Amazing. I cannot remember the last time I heard this song, 2 or 3 decades cannot explain that. But boy did I remember the lyrics like it was yesterdsy, somehow here I was singing along, whew!!!
Samzies. Always liked it, but kinda the ‘forgotten’ track on an album with nothing but bangers
An ounce of perception a pound of obscure. I used that line in my senior quote. I shared already that I discovered Rush in 8th grade but found the b side in 11th and 12th grade. This song captivated me as I can see it did you. Glad you enjoyed it Glad you took the ride. I agree with much of what you say today is I have believed since yesteryear. I really acknowledge you for taking the patience to check it out. Nice meeting you - through these moving picture videos.
Permanent Waves is an even better album
My favorite album. Pure quality and master lyrics
This bassline while singing blows me away every time
Loved your comments and interpretation
Also mentioning that this was the closing song
Interestingly. The next Album is called Signals
Very well done. From the music, lyrics and feel, you've done a Really good job analyzing Rush. So Glad you found them. Enjoy!
Bravo.👏
An honest review of my favorite album. Nicely done.
I thoroughly enjoy your reactions Rush, particularly the analysis of Neil Peart’s lyrical compositions.
It's so refreshing and encouraging to see a new generation of critical thinkers discovering the profound philosophical depth of Neil's writing, and the sheer virtuosic musicianship of all three members of Rush.
Hello Rosalie, this comment is not about this video. I wanted to put my comment on your most recent post, in the hope that you will actually see it. I want to thank you for introducing me to Ren. He is absolutely brilliant and speaks for a group that is tragically marginalized by our society. Your pure appreciation and recognition of art in it's many forms is rare and greatly appreciated. Thank you for your content.
Rush's entire catalog speaks to a wide range of people and they are easily my favorite band and I frequently listen to their entire catalog from the first album to their last; however, my two favorite albums are Power Windows and Hold Your Fire with Grand Designs, Emotion Detector, Prime Mover, and High Water being my all time favorite Rush songs because they are the story of my life.
Out of every song on this album, this is my favorite. Moving Pictures is in my top 5 Lp's of all time.
I’ve said this many times in comments , it’s sure a classic album , that still derserves more recognition from music critics
An actual eargasm at 4:03.
It makes me so happy.
Great reactions to this album Rosalie.
This album is so good!
This was the last song on Moving Pictures which I think was a good lead into there next album, Signals. Look forward to many more reactions from Rush👍🎶
Police and Rush! You nailed my two favorite Bands!! (plus Dire Straits)
Simply the best band...ever.
My brother showed me what Rush was all about in 1982 and I was hooked immediately. I had the pleasure of seeing them live 17 times before their retirement. I love all of Rush's music and it is very challenging to pick a favorite piece of music. With that being said 1 of my favorites ties into the journey you just completed, but is a sort of prequel on the album Permanent Waves the Song Natural Science would be my recommendation for the next Rush song you experience.
The band's Rush and Police were formed relatively close to each other and its easy to hear they've influenced each other being that they were both so dynamic.
Yes. Great reaction. Vital Signs is one of my favorites and I think it’s notoriously underrated.
So glad you are appreciating Rush. One of the greatest bands of all time.
Geddy calls their style “hard rock”. Many people describe their music as progressive and other terms, but I’ll go with what Geddy says, “hard rock“. Works for me.
They’re just so awesome. Enjoy ❤
Great insight and commentary--the next album by Rush, Signals, is the most logical and most excellent place to pursue the musical extravaganza of Rush, if you want to be further mesmerized by their lyrics and music.
Another great reaction! I've really enjoyed your commentary and insights, breaking down Rush's music. Just a geeky thing, I've always held onto is this. Vital Signs is the last song of Moving Pictures. A banger, with subtle reggae vibes, that deals with the inner struggles, individuals have when trying to balance personal perspectives against society's pressures. One key lyric is, " signals get crossed and the balance distorted ". And the next album is titled " Signals". And talks about personal inner struggles and society's demands.....just genius!! Musically they are incredible and possibly one of the greatest ever....but lyrically, Neil's writing and the band's interpretation, is second to none. Keep up with the Rush reactions. Hopefully, you'll continue with the Signals album and discover their musical evolution. Subdivision, Analog Kid, Digital Man, Chemistry, Losing It and New World Man are amazing songs. Please check these out and see what you think
First, great catch on the Police comparison! Neil was a big fan of Stewart Copeland's drumming and the Police's sound. I had a sneaking suspicion this one might grab you (in a good way). I agree 100%. This song is so good, both from a composition standpoint and also lyrically. I challenge you to discover some of the "deviations" in the lyrics from line to line and verse to verse as Geddy literally sings about deviating and elevating from the norm. This song embodies the genius of this power trio like few others in their 38 year discography. SO GLAD you loved this one. I think it will age well over the years and remain one of your all time favs. especially given your psychological and human behavioral background. Last, just want to call out the line "Signals get crossed" as a foreshadowing of their next album: Signals (1982) which I think you will also love.
This is definitely an underrated Gem!!! Great reaction!
This was a big change for Rush, reggae, electronica shocked us, well me, 1981 17 years old being brought up on 2112, permanent waves wow this is what I loved about the ever changing rush ❤
Moving Pictures is a masterpiece of an album. Great from start to finish and not a bad song to be found anywhere. Still my favorite release from the band to this day. Great video and you have a new subscriber.
Don't apologize for your favourite song. I feel like us Rush fans all have different favourites.
Quite a few fans refer to RUSH music as "the soundtrack of their lives". Thanks for listening to them!
Actually Neil was not afraid to take elements of different genres and he admittedly said he was influenced by reggae and the Police in particular...And he and Stewart Copeland did become friends years later.
Rosalie, thank you for your insights. From my first time seeing Rush live (Chicago, 1977), I have been entranced by the sheer volume of information contained not only in the lyrics, but in the music itself. I'm no musician, but this band grabbed me by the ears and pulled me in. It's hard to believe sometimes that all this sound comes from three guys. For a true science fiction experience, I would recommend the title track from 2112, a 22-minute masterpiece that explores highs and lows, ins and outs, and some basics of the human condition.
Now, moving on to another 1970s power trio, how about checking out Emerson, Lake, and Palmer? For a simple tune with very, very deep meaning, try out Lucky Man from their self-titled debut album. And for a rollicking adventure, nothing beats Pirates from the Works Volume 1 album.
Keep on rockin'!
I loved, loved, loved your analysis of Moving Pictures. I first encountered Rush as a teenager, shortly after they released this album. I think you would also enjoy Presto and Power Windows from later in their catalogue. Very different musically and stylistically, but the lyrics are just as profound and enduring. Their final album, Clockwork Angels, is a true concept album, and a masterpiece as well. Look forward to more from you in respect to Rush, but also other music.
One of the greatest rock/metal albums of all time. A staple for my listening since the 80s.
Best review of lyrics I've seen. Neil would have loved to see someone understanding the lyrics at this level. Very interesting that it's your favorite on this album. Well done!
Lady, I dig your reactions, and you. This song is a great lead into Signals.
One of my fav song from them, very underrated.
Congratulations for completing the greatest album ever recorded. When one considers when the album was recorded (1981) and the level of technology at that time, combined with the musicianship and musicality and then the lyrical input, this album is a true Masterpiece, in the real sense of the word. Thanks for listening to the entire album, how you have a sense of one of the greatest (in my opinon) greatest bands in history,
My first Rush concert was back in 1984. I've been to several Rush concerts since, but the best was taking my nine year old to Clockwork Angels back in 2012. He is still a Rush fan.
The album after this, "Signals", has 3 more "hey, Rush like The Police" songs. "Analog Kid", "Digital Man", "New World Man". The last one only exists because side B was too short for cassette tape so they jammed a new song and it's the most Police like.
By far one of the best albums ever made! And not just because I am a live-long Rush fan, but it is so rare to have an album with NO bad or less than great songs as filler. Each and every one, as you have clearly seen and heard, is as good or better than the last. Rush had many more great songs in their long catalog, but this was the pinnacle album, taking them to new levels and turning the page into new genres and styles. Fantastic set of reactions! Thank you so much!
It was my favorite on the album when I was young.
You have many many albums of Rush to still be enthralled and taken in by…. From 2112 through Presto, Roll the Bones all the way to Clockwork Angels. You will also discover that the lyrics, written by Neil, are based on their experiences in life as well as how the facets of society and reality have remained the same and evolved.
Once again, as I’ve said before, you are an exceptional speaker, identifying specific aspects of song, like time signatures to soul-moving anthemic pieces which most are what Rush has seamlessly produced. Much love and respect to You.
You say you feel smarter from hearing these Rush songs and as a lifelong Rush fan, I definitely know how you feel. But you know what? Your experience as a trained psychologist/mental health person (not sure exactly so forgive me if I didn't get the specifics of your background right) and how you explain things made me feel smarter, too! Thank you for your insightful, thoughtful reactions, Rosalie! Looking forward to hearing more from you! 👍
Not all reactors are as good, that is for sure. I love hearing educated people, something sadly lacking as I see more evidence of some younger folks having no clue. Others hit it out of the park like Rosalie. Rock On!
Ever since I first listened and headbanged with my air guitar over my friend's Moving Pictures album at 11 in 1983, it became part of my life's soundtrack, especially for my first 30 years. And you @Rosalie, react and describe them so beautifully, in such ways that resound with me in such profoundness, that I could tell you which of my old memories, feelings and thoughts that have been triggered by each one song, either from back then, or now where I have deeply reconnected with the band's sounds.
As far as recommendations go, I'd go next with the albums from, lets call it that same 80's era: Permanent Waves (Freewill, Jacobs Ladder, Natural Science), Signals (The Weapon, New World Man, Countdown), Grace Under Pressure (Distant Early Warning, Afterimage), Power Windows (Emotion Detector, Mystic Rythms), Hold your Fire (Time Stand Still,, Second Nature, Mission,...).
I mean, either older or newer, every album, every song is a masterpiece, in one way or another, each with its own right.
Oh, but the last one: Clockwork Angels, especially "The Garden", there are no words for this one, especially knowing it ultimately became the band's goodbye... For now, Limelight is my iPhone's ringtone. 😜 So thank you. ❤❤
I love this album. Vital signs was the first rush song I ever heard.
This is a favorite song of the fans of the show Cheers. Deviate from the Norm.
I love the way you think. Sometimes you take a bit of a tangent, but always find your way back to the matter at hand. Watching you appreciate the band I love and grew up with, really is something to see.
Thank you for bearing w me when I go off on those tangents and for sticking around for the whole ride :)
@@rosalieelliottofficial The pleasure is mine! Thank you!
@@rosalieelliottofficialI still appreciate the tangents because they are still related to the subject matter at hand! Continue on please. 😊
I'd be curious to hear your take on the next album after this one, Signals, and the progression of ideas, to me it's a natural extension, especially after Vital Signs.
One of my favourites from MP. Really great that you enjoyed it Rosalie. Knew you would. I’ve LOVED your take on MP. One of my favourite albums. Now your reactions one of my favourites on You Tube
Ps. I saw Rush live in concert on this MP tour in Northern England. Still stands as one of my favourite concerts ever. x
i have been a rush fan for decades but i have been starting to buy LP vinyl. i am hearing rush music that hasnt seen much airtime on mainstream radio or XM and i really like it. some of the material is really awesome. this track is pretty good
I'm curious if your next album will be by RUSH, or someone else? If I can recommend another band though, it would be YES. RUSH idolized YES, and the reason Geddy Lee played a Rickenbacker Bass was 'Chris Squire', the bass player for YES, who's now deceased. Hope you check them out. 'Close to the Edge' is there best album, but their song 'Roundabout' from their album 'Fragile' was their first #1 hit. One more thing: RUSH introduced YES, when they were inducted into the HOF, and they had Geddy play his bass with them on stage, at that induction, because Chris had passed away. They performed Roundabout, so if you'd like to see that performance, it's on UA-cam.
I literally teared up watching your reaction
So cool to see someone discover and appreciate my favorite band RUSH! I would recommend my very close second favorite band, KANSAS for a first time reaction in the future. I'd start with the album KANSAS LEFTOVERTURE. Thoughtful spiritual lyrics, amazing musical compositions, and mind blowing musicianship!