I think that Jensen Ackles or Henry Cavill would kill it as Arthur and Robert Pattinson as John, I love the idea of Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Dutch, but I also see Christian Bale as him
Norman as John and Bob as Hosea are the most on point. They would act these characters perfectly i think. But damn, John Boyega as Charles? I think it would be far better if Charles was played by an actual native american. Also the director should be Taylor Sheridan, he did an amazing job with Yellowstone and it's spin-offs, he knows exactly what WESTERN means.
@@lukas-kevynmuller6697I agree with you but I do have to admit finding a half native/black actor will be tough to find. There was a time where America had a few. I would hope there's some now. But I'd settle for a Native actor for Charles Smith. Especially not John Boyega.
Jeff Bridges: Cornwall Michael Rooker: Colm O’Driscoll Neal McDonnogh: Agent Milton Aaron Eckhart: Archer Fordham Bryan Cranston: Edgar Ross Ethan Hawke: Swanson Ross Marquad: Captain Monroe Jonathan Joss: Rains Fall Michael Culditz: Colonel Favors Chazz Palminteri: Bronte Lauren Cohen: Bonnie Jeff Goldblum: Trelawny
Of course I’d really like to see a few of these actors portraying the games characters, but I’d rather have the actors from the game playing their respective parts in a movie.
Brad Pitt should be Arthur, Clint Eastwood should be Hosea, Joe Anderson should be Micah, Johnny drop should be Javier, and James monoa should be Charles.
👌🏼Top pick! Nothing to object to, apart from the payroll costs skyrocketing when you hired them. But AI may only be interested in the arts and not be too savvy with finances. 🤡
![Casting the Live-Action Red Dead Redemption Movie [2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/THBudufNqII/mqdefault.jpg)
![Casting the Live-Action Red Dead Redemption Movie [2024]](/img/tr.png)
i think Peter Blomquist should still play Micah
Absolutely
Bob Odenkirk as Hosea is ON POINT hes absolutely perfect for the old silver tounged con-man role
*Hi I'm saul goodman*
*Did you know you have rights?*
*Constitution says you do*
I think Odenkirk would made better Trelawney
I was also thinking Harrison Ford but Bob is not a bad choice either
Damn Hosea is secretly a lawyer 💀
Paused it on Emily blunt, let’s see if it’s who I think it is
Edit: it was lol
I think Sebastian Stan should play John Marston. He nails the look so well
Nick offerman as Pearson is the best thing in the world 😂
might be the best casting for a movie I have seen in forever
I had a dream where Norman Reedus was John, never thought I’d actually see it.
Bob Odenkirk as Hosea Matthews
Michael Mando as Javier Escuella
David Harbour as Bill Williamson
Tomer Capone as Kieran Duffy
Alice Eve as Abigail Roberts Marston
Jason Momoa as Charles Smith
Kevin Hart as Lenny Summers
I think that Jensen Ackles or Henry Cavill would kill it as Arthur and Robert Pattinson as John, I love the idea of Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Dutch, but I also see Christian Bale as him
They wouldn't be able to follow the original plot when they got charged with crimes the "Better Holler Hosea" theme song would begin to play
"Mister Sheriff, my ga- I mean my friends here were just passing by and saw all those dead bodies"
Woody Harrelson as Micah Bell
Aaron Paul as Sean MacGuire
Karl Urban as John Marston
Charlize Theron as Sadie Adler
Antony Starr as Arthur Morgan
The only one I really agree with is Norman Reedus as John Marston
That's the only one I don't agree with 😂
@@TheStraightestWhitesthow????
Fuck no, he should just stick to play Daryl and Daryl ONLY.
@@TheStraightestWhitest Couldn’t agree more, like seriously???? 💀🤣
Norman Reedus doesn’t even have the right beard to play John 🤦♂️😂
Norman as John and Bob as Hosea are the most on point. They would act these characters perfectly i think. But damn, John Boyega as Charles? I think it would be far better if Charles was played by an actual native american. Also the director should be Taylor Sheridan, he did an amazing job with Yellowstone and it's spin-offs, he knows exactly what WESTERN means.
I think an American Native should play Charles...
Hes half black and native
@@LeoConklinJohn boyega looks like lenny
@@antonio-2099 His hips are too fucking wide to be Lenny hahaha, I would cast Lenny as Daniel Kaluuya
@@LeoConklinyupp, but the native American part is arguably more important to his character.
@@lukas-kevynmuller6697I agree with you but I do have to admit finding a half native/black actor will be tough to find. There was a time where America had a few. I would hope there's some now. But I'd settle for a Native actor for Charles Smith. Especially not John Boyega.
Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Dutch Van Der Linde
The only actor that would do justice as arthur is arthurs voice actor
This would be a kolossal but arguably the best movie thats ever been
This is exactly what I’ve been waiting for.
Jeff Bridges: Cornwall
Michael Rooker: Colm O’Driscoll
Neal McDonnogh: Agent Milton
Aaron Eckhart: Archer Fordham
Bryan Cranston: Edgar Ross
Ethan Hawke: Swanson
Ross Marquad: Captain Monroe
Jonathan Joss: Rains Fall
Michael Culditz: Colonel Favors
Chazz Palminteri: Bronte
Lauren Cohen: Bonnie
Jeff Goldblum: Trelawny
Ethan Hawke as Swanson would be perfect!
I'd get Ron Perlman as pig farmer.
Arthur gonna have an infinity gauntlet in this one
T bag from prison break as Sonny in the swamps
Red Dead Redemption The Series 2025 Showtime and Paramount Plus
Tbag prison break as Sonny in the swamps
Of course I’d really like to see a few of these actors portraying the games characters, but I’d rather have the actors from the game playing their respective parts in a movie.
LENNNAYYYYYYY
But seriously man, of you make a part 2 (please make a part 2 with cornwall, colm, bronte an the like) ya gotta have LENNAH MY BOAH
Better call Hosea
This is good, good
Can AI make movies now ? Cuz this would actually be pretty dope !
Well they're trying and it's the reason actors are on strike right now. They want to take their likeness without permission to make movies.
I thought the writers were on strike...
in a few years for sure, not yet though
thanos as arthur morgan 🔥🔥
Norman reeds as John Marston 1000%
AI did John C Riely dirty... Also no to Fin playing Charles, just no.
Robert Downey Jr as Swanson
Norman redid as John?
That's brilliant idea but how he gonna replicate that raspy voice....
He can just do his striker voice
Brilliant idea my ass, that would be the worst "John Marston" casting ever 💀
@@dex337 I mean a majority put him or Keanu as there ideal fan casts so it isn’t the worst in complete honesty
@@user-qz7nd8iz9d Keanu > Norman
@@dex337how about u calm the fuck down it's just an idea
I think that Caitlyn Jenner should play as Arthur Morgan tbh.
Nah Tom Holland
I want what you're smoking
@@albertdio420 smoking that oleander sage pack
Better call hosea matthews
Woody Harrelson as Micha bell
kino
@@MrWepx-hy6sn who’s that?
Okenkirk!!!!
I wish billy bob thornton was still younger he would make a great dutch
I don’t know why, but I would really like to see V. Mortinson in some capacity in Rdr 2.Greate video, thanks
He could have been John in his younger days.
Charlotte Theron bugger off noooo wayyy
I feel like Hugh Jackman would be a amazing Arthur
He was the second choice
make more of this its amazing and can you try Half-Life 2?
working on it now... who do you think should play Freeman?
@@InterdimensionalTV1 bryan cranston
edit: with hair
@@Alastorthealtruist isn't he too old? 67
@@InterdimensionalTV1 oh sorry, please choose you're choice and sorry for the late reply's im kinda busy, very sorry.
Jack black as Uncle!
I always sees john's as norman. 😂
Brad Pitt should be Arthur, Clint Eastwood should be Hosea, Joe Anderson should be Micah, Johnny drop should be Javier, and James monoa should be Charles.
Ed Sheeran as Sean
Joel Edgerton or Hugh jackman would also be cool for arthur
Michael Shannon (Zod from Superman) for me is a good fit for Arthur.
i think hugh jackman will do a good arthur and keanu as good jhon
no, no, no not Bob odenkirk. have you guys not seen how much Clint Eastwood now look like hosea?!
0:45 Lenny
W Hosea
Imo Josh Brolin is too old for Arthur, he's pushing 60
Chris Pine
@@chunkemonke398he has the eyes of Arthur
Nothing a little makeup and hair dye can’t fix
these are ai created images😮
Walton looks nothing like Micah, Peter clearly can do it better in terms of look and voice acting as Micah’s voice is his normal voice.
John Boyega would be a better Lonnie than Charles. You need someone older for Hosea. The others were spot on. Goggins would be so good as Micah lbvs
Margot Robbie for Sadie adler
Brad pitt is arthur morgan!!
I think John Boyega would be better as Lenny.
Charles smith is more indian than black
👌🏼Top pick! Nothing to object to, apart from the payroll costs skyrocketing when you hired them. But AI may only be interested in the arts and not be too savvy with finances. 🤡
would prolly be a good cast for western but not rdr2
I think Jared Padalecki would be a good John Marston. Norman is too skinny to play Marston
You're acting like John is buffed as hell which he isn't. At all. 😂😂😂
Don't agree with the female casting, but otherwise, pretty darn solid choies.
i think josh brolin is too short playing arthur
No one is more suited to play John Marston as Keanu Reeves is.
For those who don't know, Josh Brolin was Bran in The Goonies.
lmao no to so many of these
Non of them fit
pretty bad ngl
@InterdimensionalTV1🤔🤔
Red Harlow --> Scott Eastwood
Horrible cast😂