I am so glad I found this! I'm teaching arches and domes in the context of the Romans to sixth graders, and I think this will be a helpful visual. Thanks!
a shell is a series of arch. So smart and cute explanation. Thank you, paul! You should consider to teach structure for future architects taking license exams.
Thanks - I started putting together a book many years ago...that became an iPhone/iPad app for a while although it is where I developed the images I use in the videos...so all good things!
My guy, I don’t know what you do for a living, but your ability to teach what should be complex and boil it to down for even a moron like myself to understand is incredible!
thank for share this explanation..! I must confess that I was looking for some information about drums and cymbals. As cymbal physics is not a well detailed issue your video really helped me to understand how this beautiful instrument works.
Great video! Could you elaborate on geodesic domes specifically? And particularly to the effects of rearranging the struts in different angles (while preserving the strong triangles structure). I'm considering building a geodesic dome for a home, and I wonder (in principle - of course I'll hire an architect for precise plans) if it's possible and how to push some struts around to open a bit wider space that can accommodate better rectangular doors and windows.
@@PaulKassabian make sure you look at Monolithic Domes, they have built hundreds of them using several methods, from small to very large. Their latest tension material is basalt fiber, which has many advantages over steel.
since geodesic domes come out of synergetics, the experiential science of the spherical, omnitriangulated structures of spacetime, i would suggest not breaking the pattern integrity with rectangular doors and windows, but rather go along with the omnitriangulation. it will be well worth it, not just structurally but even aesthetically.
A question about the hoop forces - You mentioned that the bottom experience tension forces instead of compression ones. But I wonder isn't that because we're used to imagine and build domes as hemi-spheres, which do not follow the catenary curve most optimal for arches? Even if it's a concrete or stone dome (that hold very well to compression forces, but poorly to tension) the bottom of the dome wouldn't be stable, unless its walls are thick enough to ensure the catenary curve is within the walls.
Thanks for your note. The hoop force is providing restraint, especially at the base, in lieu of any external horizontal support...essentially providing an internal "tieing" of the dome. So, to your note, if domes were more based on catenary geometry that would significantly reduce the hoop forces in the main dome but you would still have hoop forces at the base to provide overall equilibrium.
Hi, Paul! Great work, I've learned a lot! Arches, columns, beams, frames, cables/chains, domes... What about the best tunnel section ? You know, these days here in the S-W of Europe everyone is digging AA shelters...😆 Is it catenary best suited for the tunnel section shape ? What do you make of it ?
Domes (cúpulas) are popular in Mexico. It is said they are natural air conditioners. Is this significantly true. These are not domed structures but structures with domes on top. Thanks.
Good question! In many ways yes in that they are a 3D assembly that carry loads in compression. The wonderful thing is how there are so many variations of material, geometry, and construction that can use the basics of dome behavior!
@Paul Kassabian and how they can build them? It works as an arch, row by row until all four side connects, and after that as they build row by row at all side, when they finish a row it holds itself in position? Like the ring in the dome? This is how holow piramyd works also? And how bruneleschi dome was built in firenze? How he could make the structure self suporting with the L shaped brick? You agree the best option to cover that was a dome? And what stop this extremely heavy structure at the base to push the wals outward?
I am so glad I found this! I'm teaching arches and domes in the context of the Romans to sixth graders, and I think this will be a helpful visual. Thanks!
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you sir!
Please never stop making videos...
You don't know how much impact this has on budding civil engineers!
Thanks - more to come!
I have seen the Pantheon many times and it has always left me in awe. Your explanation makes it even more impressive. Thank you.
You're very welcome!
@@PaulKassabian Thank you very much for your video. This is very helpful in the context of sustainable mud homes that I'm looking to build
a shell is a series of arch. So smart and cute explanation. Thank you, paul! You should consider to teach structure for future architects taking license exams.
Fantastic explanation. Domes do compressive and hoop forces together. So simple. Who knew?
Would love a book written by you. You simplify things so well
Thanks - I started putting together a book many years ago...that became an iPhone/iPad app for a while although it is where I developed the images I use in the videos...so all good things!
Awesome, thank you.
Really informational! Keep doing what you do, can't wait to see this channel grow! 🙂
Thanks - working on it!
My guy, I don’t know what you do for a living, but your ability to teach what should be complex and boil it to down for even a moron like myself to understand is incredible!
You're welcome. Maybe unsurprisingly I'm a structural engineer...I'm a Principal at SGH in Boston. I used to teach at MIT then at Harvard GSD.
@@PaulKassabian Oh wow, that’s quite an impressive résumé!
I literally said "Yes" with you. Amazing work.
Hah - thanks!
Spent long time looking for a UA-cam channel like this one! Thank you 🙏
Thrilled to hear...there just isn't this type of discussion/explanation of structure around much...
Fantastic explanation!
Thanks!
Thank you for your insights into arches and domes. I am looking forward, during my retirement, to playing with these structures.
Thank you for this informative video Paul!!
Glad it was helpful!
Fascinating! Another great video! Thank you. 😊❤
Glad you enjoyed it
thank for share this explanation..! I must confess that I was looking for some information about drums and cymbals. As cymbal physics is not a well detailed issue your video really helped me to understand how this beautiful instrument works.
Well I'm glad I unintentionally helped!
Very much impressed by your explanation 🙂
Thanks a lot 😊
explanation is so clear
Thank you! Hope this is of many more to come!
Absolutely!
Thank you for explaining it so clearly!
You're welcome!
I really love the way you presented, Thank you sir
thanks - that means a lot!
Love your channel. I hope one day I'll use information from you to build my own shed or house 😅
Great video!
Could you elaborate on geodesic domes specifically?
And particularly to the effects of rearranging the struts in different angles (while preserving the strong triangles structure).
I'm considering building a geodesic dome for a home, and I wonder (in principle - of course I'll hire an architect for precise plans)
if it's possible and how to push some struts around to open a bit wider space that can accommodate better rectangular doors and windows.
Geodesic Domes is on my list...Bucky, Biosphere, Spaceship Earth...
@@PaulKassabian make sure you look at Monolithic Domes, they have built hundreds of them using several methods, from small to very large. Their latest tension material is basalt fiber, which has many advantages over steel.
since geodesic domes come out of synergetics, the experiential science of the spherical, omnitriangulated structures of spacetime, i would suggest not breaking the pattern integrity with rectangular doors and windows, but rather go along with the omnitriangulation. it will be well worth it, not just structurally but even aesthetically.
Keep it up, Paul. Thanks for this content.
Thanks, will do!
Thanks, and God bless you for this, very informative.
Love your explanations
Glad you like them!
A question about the hoop forces - You mentioned that the bottom experience tension forces instead of compression ones.
But I wonder isn't that because we're used to imagine and build domes as hemi-spheres, which do not follow the catenary curve most optimal for arches?
Even if it's a concrete or stone dome (that hold very well to compression forces, but poorly to tension) the bottom of the dome wouldn't be stable, unless its walls are thick enough to ensure the catenary curve is within the walls.
Thanks for your note. The hoop force is providing restraint, especially at the base, in lieu of any external horizontal support...essentially providing an internal "tieing" of the dome. So, to your note, if domes were more based on catenary geometry that would significantly reduce the hoop forces in the main dome but you would still have hoop forces at the base to provide overall equilibrium.
Great video. Thank you Paul!
Hey Tim - thanks for that!
Hi, Paul! Great work, I've learned a lot! Arches, columns, beams, frames, cables/chains, domes... What about the best tunnel section ? You know, these days here in the S-W of Europe everyone is digging AA shelters...😆
Is it catenary best suited for the tunnel section shape ? What do you make of it ?
Paul, What's the best shape to resist vacuum?
Also the dome?
I guess it's the same you are explaining in this video
I WISH TO BE LIKE U. SOME DAY.
Great video!
Thanks!
Nice work!
Thanks Dan!
Thanks you I have a question how Long Should You Wait to Remove Concrete domes Formwork ?
sir kindly make video on vaults also.
why the circle at the top allows the dome to be more efficient?
Amazing sir
thanks for saying so! Much appreciated!
Nice Sir
compare the forces of round domes to catenary domes. plz.
But what is the reason behind the choice? The dome seems so much more complicated than a standard roof line.
Thank you too much
2:55 Wow, is this why balls are bouncy? Everyside of a ball is basically the top with a lot of tension on it, anyone know?
Sir tell, dome is long life than RCC OR RBC
Domes (cúpulas) are popular in Mexico. It is said they are natural air conditioners. Is this significantly true. These are not domed structures but structures with domes on top. Thanks.
رائع
Twister proof
Human houses in the future are all dome-shaped 👍
I haven't found yet how the onion domes work, where the load excedes the bearing point, 🤔Why they don't collapse???😳😳😳😳😳
I need to find people to help me build amphibious dome homes that can help us survive doomsday.
High. Is the catalonian boveda works in the same manner than domes?
ua-cam.com/video/e50ncAOiEjw/v-deo.html
I'm talking about this.
Good question! In many ways yes in that they are a 3D assembly that carry loads in compression. The wonderful thing is how there are so many variations of material, geometry, and construction that can use the basics of dome behavior!
@Paul Kassabian and how they can build them? It works as an arch, row by row until all four side connects, and after that as they build row by row at all side, when they finish a row it holds itself in position? Like the ring in the dome?
This is how holow piramyd works also?
And how bruneleschi dome was built in firenze? How he could make the structure self suporting with the L shaped brick? You agree the best option to cover that was a dome?
And what stop this extremely heavy structure at the base to push the wals outward?