Why have swings DISAPPEARED from playgrounds in Singapore? | MS Explains

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 132

  • @MothershipSG
    @MothershipSG  Рік тому +72

    Correction: In 2:12 and 2:22 of the video, the correct measurements for the minimum clearance between the swing seat and the floor should be 12 inches. We apologise for the error.

  • @mysticery
    @mysticery Рік тому +524

    No. I won't be excited about a cargo net or a water sprouting feature. I prefer the swing. Swing gives you the sensation of weightlessness. You just sit and swing. You don't even need to run around to have fun.

  • @leoesque2803
    @leoesque2803 Рік тому +155

    Slides, Swings, See saw, Merry go round and Monkey bars are like a must have for playgrounds.

  • @gtman913
    @gtman913 Рік тому +207

    See-saws are missing in our playgrounds too.

  • @elizabethteo
    @elizabethteo Рік тому +62

    I live in Tampines and there is a new playground recently opened… featuring all swings (I think easily 10 of them, though I didn’t count) and I think 3 trampolines.

    • @soyoy8503
      @soyoy8503 Рік тому +1

      where is it?

    • @CinnamintBerry
      @CinnamintBerry Рік тому

      Oo might consider visiting wherever that is

    • @feru1071
      @feru1071 Рік тому

      But the children!! :0

    • @slowsloth3809
      @slowsloth3809 Рік тому

      WELP I'M PACKIN MY BAGS

    • @elizabethteo
      @elizabethteo Рік тому +2

      @@soyoy8503 just across the train station. 5min walk. St 21.

  • @beautifuldurian
    @beautifuldurian Рік тому +65

    Reminiscing, behind old airport road, there was a super tall metal slide. It’s was scary for some kids, but it’s like Universal Park in the 90s. Still miss the fun old times.
    Too bad, now when kids are injured, whatever the reason, the town council gets calls and e-mails of complaints. Last time our parents would say, we need to be careful ourselves or very good, you deserve it.
    We use to climb wild guava trees and rambutan trees to eat the fruits, pull tapioca plants to get the tuber. Catch mollies, rainbow fishes in small streams in Bedok camp /Kew Drive area in the 70s n 80s. So much fun.

    • @mushlikestoeat8859
      @mushlikestoeat8859 Рік тому

      There is still one further away near mountbatten Station. Quite tall and scary for kids younger than 4.

    • @KMTepi
      @KMTepi Рік тому

      Yep, me and my cousins used to climb these skinny trees to get the pretty magenta flowers on it and i remember being so dissapointed because i stood on the highest most stable branch possible but my arms were to short to reach them

  • @lkgpuanimho0349
    @lkgpuanimho0349 Рік тому +38

    Because ppl keep complaining the swings randomly swing at night without anyone using it (haunted) 👻

  • @oterenceo
    @oterenceo Рік тому +59

    When we have people suing our government because of drain covers, you can expect to have policies to pre-empt similar situations. When it comes to children, it's safety before fun.

  • @limconnie9709
    @limconnie9709 Рік тому +29

    Good explanation! It’s incredibly hard to find swings in SG!

  • @thomastan7511
    @thomastan7511 Рік тому +47

    More swings are required.

    • @beautifuldurian
      @beautifuldurian Рік тому +1

      Agree, but some people would just hog it for many hours. Seen many selfish people. They just won’t budge even upon many requests. Maybe some timing device is required.

    • @gladiatorgamer9502
      @gladiatorgamer9502 Рік тому

      No

    • @fyysha
      @fyysha Рік тому +4

      @@beautifuldurian people can be annoying and selfish. And I agree.
      But like, once the timer ends, then what? The swing automatically throws the child onto the ground? 🤣

    • @wholegroinbread593
      @wholegroinbread593 Рік тому

      The police comes and you get thrown in jail

  • @BK8MoneyMaker
    @BK8MoneyMaker Рік тому +33

    Swings are my favorite no matter how old I am 🥺

  • @marknicholson6562
    @marknicholson6562 Рік тому +29

    I’m sure everyone who used a swing fell of it or had something happen But then got back on it. Then let their imagination run riot. The swing became a starship or a car or just height. The imagination should be allowed to bloom. Sometimes simplicity is better as an open book. Look at toys. How many children play more with the box than the toy inside. Makes you think about the modern world.

    • @KMTepi
      @KMTepi Рік тому

      I remember i found a gift box and ended up using it as a house/shop/everything for my legos, even cut some tape and stick it on the outside to look like it

    • @channelpolitica1364
      @channelpolitica1364 Рік тому

      I never fell off a swing. Never ever. You will only fall off a swing if you stop holding onto the ropes that suspend it.

  • @cassandrawong3175
    @cassandrawong3175 Рік тому +7

    The only concern is the EPDM rubber smelling nasty in the afternoons. I wonder if those emit toxic gases when our weather gets really hot? Hope the government can think about that.

  • @remyazharyyosef1811
    @remyazharyyosef1811 Рік тому +3

    We've played in those playgrounds in our childhood. Remember we used to scale those scary heights and tried to jump from one height to another. And there was actual sand in the playgrounds. So what does that tell you about the kids of today and yesteryears? Ponder on it. We didn't have mobile phones or the Internet or social media like today.
    True, times and generations will change. But even we're regarded as old among the young ones I'm glad that I had gone through those childhood phases in my life.
    But albeit, whether there are swings or not, accidents will bound to happen one way or another no matter how careful we are. And true, regulations are good but still the conditions of human minds will always go beyond the controlled zone. That's what makes us human.

  • @cloroxbleach9222
    @cloroxbleach9222 Рік тому +4

    There's nothing else on the playground like swinging along with a friend on the swings. Seesaws maybe... but swings take less energy

  • @Comingsafra
    @Comingsafra Рік тому +12

    love swings able to sit and swing for an hr

  • @weegie3343
    @weegie3343 Рік тому +2

    Swings still are my favourites, and thankfully most in my area (England) have at least 2

  • @tinachen9728
    @tinachen9728 Рік тому +1

    We have a play ground where I live and I use to play on it the firer man pole looks dangerous if you don’t put your feet around it properly so it’s a good thing they removed it to replace with one swing and slide to be less dangerous.

  • @ongkristian9006
    @ongkristian9006 Рік тому +4

    There are swings near Fort Canning MRT. You should check them out.

  • @chocolatesnowyz
    @chocolatesnowyz Рік тому +1

    I have seen Swing set in some places around Singapore, I still go on them when i see one but Nowadays I see more for small kids to play with them. not like for all ages like the old ones. so Its still hard to find a a fun swing that can be use for all ages. although I like the trampolines that been added to the newer playground, fun to get on one.

  • @RVNCT
    @RVNCT Рік тому +12

    Im from the states and when i was younger we used to throw the swings over like 2 or 3 times so its higher from the ground and so we can jump higher whenever we wanted to jump off a swing 😂😂.
    We used to even sit on the swing and twist the swings so we could spin around

  • @martinlee7102
    @martinlee7102 Рік тому +9

    Buying a HDB flat may arguably, in a sense, become even less affordable, for some Singaporeans, with the lower loan that they may be able to borrow, due to the new 3% for the purpose of determining the sum that one can borrow, as well as the lower 80% LTV limit.
    For example, a 4-room HDB flat costing $605,000 in future BTO launches such as Ang Mo Kio BTO Aug 2022, may require a minimum owner(s)’ income of $7,650 ($484,000 for 25 years 3% loan repayment = $2,295 ÷ 30% MSR = $7,650), as well as a minimum down-payment of $121,000.
    Given that the target market for BTO flats are young couples who have just gotten married to form a family cluster, how many of these couples would be earning more than $7,650, and also have $121,000 for the down-payment?

    • @jayl5009
      @jayl5009 Рік тому +2

      Even then, most of the BTO launches are heavily subscribed. Generational wealth transfer may be playing a role here with the elevated prices. Realistically, most young working adults would be hard pressed to afford the current HDB prices without some financial help, except for the smaller flats in less popular areas.

    • @johnnyhaze4605
      @johnnyhaze4605 Рік тому

      then maybe don't buy mature estate such as AMK, and also 3-room flats are a viable option for younger couples also. But sure, I do agree the housing prices are really getting out of hand. Then again, supply and demand :(

  • @bellaliao439
    @bellaliao439 Рік тому +1

    I'm a Singaporean and there is quite a number of swings around my estate

  • @tinachen9728
    @tinachen9728 Рік тому +1

    My school used tree bark not sand and our sand pit Is closed up with a cover to prevent animal from gong in their and we replaced the sand too.

  • @chinchang5117
    @chinchang5117 2 місяці тому

    I think there has to be a balance between fun and safety. My suggestion is that we can build 2 kind of playgrounds. Type S playgrounds are maybe 80% safe and 20% not fun. Type F playgrounds are 80% fun and 20% dangerous. Let the children decide where they want to play!

  • @mrjumaatsamian
    @mrjumaatsamian Рік тому

    I played the concrete playground before and the design is acutually weird it used to have a swing on the brige of the playground but pls leave that alone because that swing is broken no more swing they removed them

  • @StefanyHuangPBM
    @StefanyHuangPBM Рік тому +1

    Love this channel so so much, really improve my english

  • @DressedRunner
    @DressedRunner Рік тому +1

    That guy's parents must've been a huge fan of Wong Kar Wai

  • @clnhq___
    @clnhq___ Рік тому +1

    While safety is important isn't it normal to get some minor injuries when playing? I think having more options in playgrounds can increase children's interest in playing and help them exercise more instead of using phones. Imagine growing up without playing with swings.

    • @haileyrain9305
      @haileyrain9305 Рік тому +1

      Yes, kids should get mildly injured on playgrounds. It helps them in the real world with learning how to handle those situations

  • @KillaCatzGames
    @KillaCatzGames Рік тому

    I remember being on a swing when I was younger, idk if it's still there since I haven't visited it in a while.

  • @venusNcold
    @venusNcold Рік тому

    Those wooden balancing beams with actual spring in them... I miss those, now even if they have its not wood and it doesn't wobble.

  • @pllin240
    @pllin240 Рік тому +2

    the metallic slide all hidden is not safe at all, if child gets stuck or claustrophobic and panic, what happens to get child out of the slide tunnel?

  • @ivanlimzg
    @ivanlimzg Рік тому +1

    A grass patch at my place was concrete-ed over. Prolly cos of maintenence lor

  • @MelonLemon007
    @MelonLemon007 9 місяців тому

    I miss playing hide n seek n catch in the early 90s with my primary friends in pasir ris. Pasir ris primary school alumni here 🎉

  • @lucasakachubby8694
    @lucasakachubby8694 Рік тому

    Very weird thing, but my friend has marked most of the swings in the West to North, I do not know how, he just travels around until he's find a swing. Mans has homework but doesn't do but instead goes and finds swings

  • @nothingokk
    @nothingokk Рік тому

    There’s a sand pit and swings near siam square Mookata Punggol

  • @TheRealYashNotFake
    @TheRealYashNotFake Рік тому

    I mean, it’s Singapore so if something is mysteriously vanished, it’s probably because of safety reasons, unfortunate though.

  • @bdlsypk
    @bdlsypk Рік тому +1

    The problem is no one monitor and maintain these things nowadays.

  • @Wechz750
    @Wechz750 Рік тому +1

    If you want to play on a swing again go to a playground near 三 挑吧 I know the Tiao is wrong

  • @gipski500
    @gipski500 Рік тому

    There's like swings in new playgrounds. So far only saw in semb

  • @itzSoonz
    @itzSoonz Рік тому +1

    So... no more Playground designers doing swings anymore?

  • @thatspideyfan8273
    @thatspideyfan8273 Рік тому

    Well there are quite a lot of swings at 2 playgrounds close to my home

  • @wangjinwen7708
    @wangjinwen7708 Рік тому +3

    because of selfish reason and decision of some small group of people. and a town run by bo chap people, no hope. nowadays swings are only exclusive and found in parks near private estates

  • @768jefiline7
    @768jefiline7 Рік тому +1

    That's why I have a swing in my living, instead of a sofa.

  • @nothingokk
    @nothingokk Рік тому

    4:23 has my house playgrounds!

  • @xJ9pQw2sR5
    @xJ9pQw2sR5 Рік тому

    Yeah some bloody kid used that swing in Singapore around 1985 to hit me in the head. that was 5 stitches at changi hospital with no anaesthesia.

    • @gammavelorum9551
      @gammavelorum9551 Рік тому

      track that guy down and do the same thing to his kid

  • @shafiqapandi5271
    @shafiqapandi5271 Рік тому +2

    Meanwhile in Aljunied town council, Playgrounds have been disappearing and replaced with swings.

  • @talkky
    @talkky Рік тому

    damn, look at mothership even throwing in SS HAHAHAA good research

  • @syirahgaming
    @syirahgaming Рік тому +1

    The playground beside my house still have swings

  • @norman6499
    @norman6499 Рік тому

    Then my kids must be super lucky to have abundance of swings and sandpit near our house? Punggol waterway cascadia

  • @takemeseriouslynt
    @takemeseriouslynt Рік тому

    I feel like playground are becoming less and less common, gettin replaced with condo buildings, always them damn condo building, and not even affordable ones, they keep killing local business and playgrounds

  • @MsFlyWhale
    @MsFlyWhale Рік тому

    There are swings everywhere in Taiwan and no one cares about regulations 😂
    So cool to know how much effort Singapore government has put into providing children a safer playground
    Have you ever jumped out of swing and flied in the middle of air and tried to stand still afterwards?

  • @iridebuses
    @iridebuses Рік тому

    Tiong Bahru Park Still have

  • @removalval4163
    @removalval4163 Рік тому

    Time to ask them to remove the swing at my nearby playground. To follow the trend.😂

  • @aaaduccs6667
    @aaaduccs6667 Рік тому +1

    I miss swings :((

  • @seng628
    @seng628 Рік тому +4

    review playground small Boy ,gril

  • @prometheus7387
    @prometheus7387 Рік тому +2

    Well my playground has swings and it was added pretty recently

  • @conned
    @conned 4 місяці тому

    Sad......silly reason....not just swing but round-abouts, sands, grass, children need this to fine tune their sensory n vestibular senses....
    We took easy way out...u realize our playgrounds are always near roads?..

  • @medrict
    @medrict Рік тому +2

    Play value ≠ amount of fun. Put swings and let Darwin awards do its thing 🤣

  • @meowmeowcatfish
    @meowmeowcatfish Рік тому

    I still cant find a playground without swings

  • @Soshiaircon91
    @Soshiaircon91 Рік тому

    SS457 ruined everyone's playground.

  • @jakekatelin
    @jakekatelin Рік тому

    I’m father of 2. And I still playground.

  • @wrgqwegfq1667
    @wrgqwegfq1667 Рік тому

    wym? my estate literally just built 2 swings at 2 different playgrounds?

  • @thecrow1898
    @thecrow1898 Рік тому

    It’s okay I found out how to get swings back
    I bought rope with me and now I tire it to a tree and swing on it

  • @NokiaHumanForm
    @NokiaHumanForm Рік тому

    0:25 proton exora 💖💖
    Sorry let me being a Malaysian show my patriotism a bit hahaha

  • @martinlee7102
    @martinlee7102 Рік тому +4

    How the heck is HDB affordable when you include the land costs
    The definition of DSR is all costs related to housing, such as mortgage, maintenance, property taxes, insurance, utilities, etc, and not just the mortgage repayments, as a percentage of net income and not gross income.
    Also, the use of “averages” is meaningless for the lower-income. Moreover, the very concept of average affordability is flawed because those who cannot afford to buy or cannot afford to continue to pay, will not be included in the “average affordability” statistics.
    Has the very high utilisation of CPF for housing contributed to Singapore’s very poor scores in the Global Pension Index 2010 - country with the lowest score for ‘minimum retirement income as a percentage of average income’ and ‘net replacement rate’?

  • @nicholasfoo6749
    @nicholasfoo6749 Рік тому +4

    I think there are also lesser monkey bars

    • @yuxin6725
      @yuxin6725 Рік тому +2

      And fire man's pole :"

  • @violetmolloy68
    @violetmolloy68 Рік тому

    I have swings at my school so I’m not arguing

  • @merciful8747
    @merciful8747 Рік тому +1

    still got swings what..

  • @mikeang80
    @mikeang80 Рік тому

    Amk Park still have swing seats.

  • @bomber001
    @bomber001 Рік тому

    WAIT THE SEESAWS ARE GONE???

  • @wsant2872
    @wsant2872 Рік тому +3

    Now you know why we have raised a generation of strawberries

  • @pllin240
    @pllin240 Рік тому

    worse playground is in Sky Peak at Bt Batok ...

  • @KyawLinYaungTunBlgps
    @KyawLinYaungTunBlgps Місяць тому

    My hdb still got 2 swings

  • @gszxc
    @gszxc Рік тому

    Wth Singapore using inches now???

  • @StefanyHuangPBM
    @StefanyHuangPBM Рік тому

    Especially have a english word at the video

  • @jamesyue1348
    @jamesyue1348 Рік тому +3

    let me tell you why
    Simply because foreigners don't like it.

  • @Aryanne-wm6br
    @Aryanne-wm6br Рік тому

    There's too much space and trees People don't need that , even my block 936 those best place is Soo Bad because 🌳grass no flowers like old ones, I remember maze road 🛣️ and traffic playgrounds , people play badminton outside, is Soo waste because grass with no effort idea💡🤷🤷 Stop calling people safety is very Goblock 🦺 parents can teach them , even 6 yo kids is smarter than parents

  • @hanninguyen5064
    @hanninguyen5064 Рік тому

    My paark has swings lol,FRAUD😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @khanht5
    @khanht5 Рік тому +4

    Why on earth is the regulation in inches?

    • @griefer3454
      @griefer3454 Рік тому

      Not an issue really, the people who do it would probably convert it or just use measurement tools with inches xD

    • @johnbrowning3986
      @johnbrowning3986 Рік тому +3

      Americans

    • @dremasaydenmiafamily1161
      @dremasaydenmiafamily1161 Рік тому +2

      Cos they brought in Americans to evaluate the safety standards.

  • @ZERO_0594
    @ZERO_0594 Рік тому

    Cause kids and adults love to do helicopter 360° then kena injure themselves

  • @jytan740
    @jytan740 Рік тому

    still got swing

  • @tetrisnstuff8881
    @tetrisnstuff8881 Рік тому

    666th like

  • @Aryanne-wm6br
    @Aryanne-wm6br Рік тому

    I don't like the new playgrounds
    Looks "low budget" they keep put Space and Exercise 👴Who the heck want that ,Can't you just put skatepark or something
    Creative🛣️🚸 it looks ridiculous and lazy ( people want generation 90s because people are working kids hard to get out)

  • @martinlee7102
    @martinlee7102 Рік тому +4

    Focus on stupid things the media in sg