"He's A Better All-Round Centre-Forward!" Ally McCoist INSISTS Isak is A BETTER Striker Than Haaland

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 161

  • @user-ls1lu7gu4u
    @user-ls1lu7gu4u День тому +41

    Harland is a better goal scorer he’s not a better footballer than Isak. Harland can’t do what Isak does.

    • @Charlieb82
      @Charlieb82 День тому +1

      100% my thoughts too. Haaland can't create a goal from nothing for himself or take it round 4/5 players, but he's the better finisher

    • @Maccycityblue
      @Maccycityblue День тому +2

      Isak can't do what haaland does

    • @fifty-five6929
      @fifty-five6929 День тому

      ​@@Charlieb82yes he can put keep pushing that lie if you want

    • @smanvir94
      @smanvir94 День тому

      @@fifty-five6929isak plays with gykores aswell

    • @skilla20
      @skilla20 День тому +4

      @@Maccycityblue He literally is doing what Haaland does he's scoring a goal a game right now.

  • @Photosoflife
    @Photosoflife День тому +24

    Haaland is completely off the charts and generational.
    City: 125 matches, 111 goals, 15 assists
    Dortmund: 89 matches, 86 goals, 23 assists
    Salzburg: 27 matches, 29 goals, 7 assists
    Norway: 39 matches, 38 goals, 4 assists
    Premier League: 86 matches, 79 goals, 13 assists
    Champions League: 45 matches, 46 goals, 5 assists
    Total: 282 matches, 264 goals, 49 assists

    • @jamiecummings9666
      @jamiecummings9666 День тому +1

      In a city squad. So what do u think if players swapped teams for last 3 seasons 😮

    • @ishanthapa7781
      @ishanthapa7781 День тому

      ​@@jamiecummings9666He literally gave stats of Dortmund, Salzburg as well. He isn't good just cause of city squad.

    • @Bradleyeg6
      @Bradleyeg6 День тому +2

      What people are forgetting too is Haaland plays different for City in comparison to how he played for Dortmund where he was constantly running in behind

    • @othinusz3576
      @othinusz3576 День тому

      @@jamiecummings9666 Remind me of Isak's incredible time at Dortmund

    • @hackapump
      @hackapump День тому +4

      A player like Isak can never put up Haaland's numbers, regardless of quality, simply because he doesn't have that single-minded focus on getting served in the box. He participates in the buildup, often leading it. As a consequence players next to Isak, like Gordon, scores a lot too. Haaland is focused on timing his runs while his team mates are creating chances. So they're two completely different players playing in the same position. Which makes a comparison tricky and kind meaningless, IMO.

  • @davebyrne1980
    @davebyrne1980 День тому +10

    Haaland is an out & out goal scorer... the epitome of the 'give it to the big man up top' style of play.
    Isak, is a much better rounded centre-forward... he's as comfortable setting up other players as putting them away himself, able to cross & dribble the ball as typified by his assist for Jacob Murphy against Everton a couple of seasons back.

  • @Kelly-r9n
    @Kelly-r9n День тому +7

    It's a bit like the old Henry or Shearer debate in that Henry was the better footballer but you're picking Shearer regardless. Haaland is just out of form currently but he'll be back. You're not replacing 111 goals in 125 games for "he can dribble past players easier". If the old 4-4-2 was still in fashion they'd be great together up front

  • @smanvir94
    @smanvir94 День тому +3

    Us geordies always knew this time was gonna come u can see how Isak creates and doesnt just wait in the box

  • @s12856
    @s12856 День тому +21

    The fact that Haaland is the one everyone compares anyone else to, is all you need to know

    • @benmatthews1779
      @benmatthews1779 День тому +2

      haaland beats any sticker on goals but what Isak brings to the table thou is way more important

  • @robward7513
    @robward7513 День тому +11

    Right now Isak is the best in Europe !!!!!

    • @Les-i7e
      @Les-i7e День тому

      Good but best in Europe .I don't think so

  • @ghsense2626
    @ghsense2626 День тому +11

    Hes a better Centre Forward but certainly not a better striker.

  • @RaseYourProbs
    @RaseYourProbs День тому +2

    Im a Newcastle fan, but comparing the 2 of them isn't fair on either. Halaand is a goal machine, he doesn't do much else, you give him the ball and he will score. All strikers will habe ups and downs, hes not different. Isak is a different type, he get involed he offers intelligent passes and is involved in build up. The better striker depends on what your team actually needs. For arsenal i reckon a Haaland type would actually be better they have players that are brilliant at building up, they just need the finisher.

  • @garywallace5602
    @garywallace5602 День тому +16

    Stay humble, Haaland fanboys...Isak is king! 👑

  • @stevecooke2893
    @stevecooke2893 День тому +4

    I think ppl are confused about the question. When it comes to having the ball at your feet in the box, Haaland is unstoppable.
    But that's not the question. It says an all round striker. Isak doesn't just score goals, he creates them too, plus he's got the left winger position in his locker. When's the last time Haaland got an assist? When does Haaland play on the wings?
    Haaland's a natural scorer, but Isak gets the prize for versatility

    • @liberalslayer7220
      @liberalslayer7220 День тому

      Haarland 86 appearances 79 goals 14 assists Isak 70 appearances 44 goals and 7 assists. Haarland has won more penalties got a better shot success percentage created more big chances and has been dispossessed less times than isak. Plus he’s been caught offside half the amount of times that Isak is. Facts don’t lie

    • @stevecooke2893
      @stevecooke2893 День тому +1

      @liberalslayer7220 you didn't listen to a word I said. I admitted Haaland is the best striker. Every fact you put up is correct as far as i know. So what exactly do you think I'm arguing with?
      As I said, Haaland scores better than anyone, but that's all he does. He can't take on other roles. Isak doesn't have that, but he does have versatility that Haaland lacks

    • @liberalslayer7220
      @liberalslayer7220 День тому

      @stevecooke2893 so supplying more assists and bigger chances created has won more penalties and is dispossessed less. The fact that Manchester City typically doesn't play to Haarlands strengths. By playing the early pass in behind the defence like he used to play in Germany.

    • @Jaxel1926
      @Jaxel1926 День тому +1

      @@liberalslayer7220those stats if anything shine for isak he plays for Newcastle not a treble winning side who have spend hundreds of millions

    • @liberalslayer7220
      @liberalslayer7220 День тому

      @ I’m a little bit confused on the point about how much money has been invested into the two clubs. The fact that Newcastle has spent half a billion in transfers since Howe has been manager. Which is about the same amount as what Manchester City have spent but city’s also sold players to run at a profit so in terms of net spend Newcastle have spent more money. Howe has literally replaced the whole team in transfer deals

  • @josephajibowo-wp2rw
    @josephajibowo-wp2rw День тому +3

    Halaand as a player is built for scoring goals. I defend Halaand a lot in other context.
    However, you're always underwhelmed when you watch him against the big clubs. He's mostly anonymous. If City and Newcastle play only against the Big 6 in the PL and you collect their goalscoring stats, I'd be close and I dare say Isak outscores him.
    More importantly though, Isak would come out man of the match in more games than Halaand would against bigger oppositions. That's simply because Isak has more in his locker when the goals don't come in a game.
    As a Chelsea fan, that's why I would always rate Hazard as the best player in the PL for the duration he played in the competition. In games against the big 6, Hazard's stats was even better than against sides lower. He'd be MOTM in those games year on year that it was ridiculous. He doesn't have to score or assist in games for everyone to rave about the performances. Isak has that over Halaand every week.

  • @andymcnab2.0
    @andymcnab2.0 День тому +2

    It would be a unbelievable strike partnership
    We talking 60+ goals a season easy.

  • @Triple_X_X
    @Triple_X_X День тому +12

    I'm a huge fan of Isak but these british media are so del ūded and reactionary 😂 after 3 months Isak is the best striker?? These guys ball knowledge is hilarious ASF..
    Haaland might not be a flashy and technically great striker but he's a generational traditional striker, fox in the box predator..
    Isak is the best technically great all-round striker in the world and I'd choose Isak becuz he fits Barça philosophy but Haaland is THE guy..He can score 3, 4, 5 goals in 1 game without having more than 5 touches, at the end of the day, he got the goals

    • @SC.KINGDOM
      @SC.KINGDOM День тому +2

      Norway lost to Scotland Halaand ghosted 😂

    • @josephajibowo-wp2rw
      @josephajibowo-wp2rw День тому

      @@Triple_X_X
      Do you just want to argue because you're a strawman?
      Glazed Halaand all day only to turn around and say you'd prefer Isak because of his all round play and fitting Barca's philosophy.
      Do you love to hear only yourself have an opinion?
      Isak only been good for 3 months??
      But I'm sure you are one of those fanboys who thick Yamal is better than Saka, Foden, and Palmer despite him breastfeeding only a couple of months ago.

    • @Charlieb82
      @Charlieb82 День тому +2

      Haaland is a better finisher, but can't create his own goal. Isak is a more all round striker, but isn't as good a finisher (he can miss more chances). You're talking about comparing the cream of the crop though, so being second to Haaland is fine.

    • @toonarmy8524
      @toonarmy8524 День тому +3

      he scored 21 league goals in a team nowhere near as good as city, Haarland should be scoring with all the service he gets. as i said earlier he was piss poor when city lost 11 games what was haarland doing then sweet fa.

    • @Unpopular_Truth
      @Unpopular_Truth День тому +3

      You constantly rant about how much you hate British media, but you spend all your time watching and commenting on it. What a weirdo.

  • @fifty-five6929
    @fifty-five6929 День тому +2

    Funny how come he has 0 major honours to his name and Haaland still has more goals than him in what is a terrible season for him

  • @paulmcgreevy3011
    @paulmcgreevy3011 День тому +1

    There has never been a striker like Haaland anywhere anytime. Undoubtedly the best there’s ever been.

    • @skilla20
      @skilla20 День тому

      There's never been prolific strikers are you serious?

    • @brettsinclair3550
      @brettsinclair3550 День тому

      @@skilla20 Your mind is playing games with You.

  • @joshuam7992
    @joshuam7992 День тому +1

    As a united fan nooooooo, Isak is no we're near near Haaland and never will be.

  • @Maccycityblue
    @Maccycityblue День тому +2

    Whos the strikers who scores more goals? haaland!! End of chat

  • @ArchieSimpson-s8e
    @ArchieSimpson-s8e День тому +2

    Let’s be honest it’s like the Salah vs Ronaldo debate. No one comes close to Ronaldo as a RW in premier league or Haaland at striker currently in prem. but people like to just compare. Isak will never get the amount of goals Haaland does

    • @josephajibowo-wp2rw
      @josephajibowo-wp2rw День тому

      @ArchieSimpson-s8e and Halaand will never be the best player on the pitch without scoring a goal. That's how you know a one trick pony.

    • @Adam-f8c
      @Adam-f8c День тому

      Put Isak in that Man City team and Al bet he does get the same if not more numbers than Haaland.

    • @Fbdhdbrbdjxn
      @Fbdhdbrbdjxn День тому

      @@josephajibowo-wp2rwand Isak will
      Never be able to lace garlands boots… that’s how you know Isak is 10% the player Haaland is

    • @Fbdhdbrbdjxn
      @Fbdhdbrbdjxn День тому

      @ 🤣🤣 and that’s why your a bum on benefits and not a manager in the premier league mate. Aguero who is top 3 greatest ST in premier league history got no where near Haaland numbers in “this Man City team”

  • @Triple_X_X
    @Triple_X_X День тому +3

    Someone pin this message..Come May, Ally McCoist will say Haaland is the best striker in the world and act like this video right here never happened 😂

  • @davidrobinson2776
    @davidrobinson2776 14 годин тому

    Comparisons are pointless and daft. Haaland's game is completely different. He's like Lineker or Greaves in as much as he might only touch the ball 3 times in 90mins but score 2 goals. Isak is like Salah or Henry as he can play wide and contribute to the build up.
    Nobody can argue with Haaland's record even though Isak is a better footballer.

  • @omarahmad7890
    @omarahmad7890 18 годин тому

    It's Henry vs. shearer history repeating its self

  • @Gav3sixty
    @Gav3sixty 20 годин тому

    Its like henry said, pep is to controlling, we dont know exactly what haaland is capable of because pep retricts his movement, any other club would have him run the front line snd not just stand in the centre

  • @robertlough1685
    @robertlough1685 День тому

    Isak is a better technician but Haaland is more of a beast

  • @T90337
    @T90337 День тому

    Haaland is a better target man and relies heavily on his team mates, while Isak is more of versatile, can create his own chances and is better all round.

  • @shamrockballs1066
    @shamrockballs1066 День тому +2

    That first caller is not a Newcastle fan 😂😂 complete set up.

    • @michaelmcdougall943
      @michaelmcdougall943 День тому +6

      Definitely had a Mackem twang about him like

    • @shamrockballs1066
      @shamrockballs1066 День тому +5

      ​@@michaelmcdougall943 'Nick the Newcastle fan', no Geordie accent, praises Talk sport then proceeds to talk about Isak reminding him of Henry, that he's better than Haaland, talks about Arsenal being happy to finish in CL places and says Arsenal 'missed a trick' not signing him. Aye right. 'Nick the Newcastle Fan' didn't talk once about Newcastle or the match last night. All slanted towards Arsenal and Isak leading the conversation to be Arsenal should sign the best striker in the league Isak so they can win the PL. I don't buy him as genuine.

  • @StanleyMubby-q5d
    @StanleyMubby-q5d День тому +1

    Isak is an all round striker indeed and Halaand is not but still the truth is that Halaad is above Isak

  • @josephajibowo-wp2rw
    @josephajibowo-wp2rw День тому +7

    Isak is the best central forward in the world. He offers more than Halaand and is better than Mbappe at everything Mbappe is decent at except scoring.

    • @Triple_X_X
      @Triple_X_X День тому +5

      😂😂😂 I'm a huge fan of Isak but he's NOWHERE near Mbappe..stop this Prem bias and LaLiga jealousy.. I'm a Barça fan but Mbappe is way clear WTF are you cracking?

    • @robbiekop7
      @robbiekop7 День тому

      So Isak is better than Isak ? 😲

    • @josephajibowo-wp2rw
      @josephajibowo-wp2rw День тому +1

      @Triple_X_X
      WTF are you on about?
      I'm looking at both players (Mbappe and Isak) now not what they have done before.
      Also, I'm comparing central forward performances from both men. Mbappe has played much better before than what he's currently showing. And Isak is playing better than he's ever produced. When you stripe away the goals and emotional glazing you feel for Mbappe, it is clear Isak has better:
      First touch,
      Striker IQ,
      Finesse,
      Technique,
      Elegance,
      Control,
      Passing,
      Dribbling, and
      Creativity.
      I have watched Mbappe for Real Madrid and he looks lethargic, heavy, and can't beat a man for his life unless his pace can get away from defenders. Maybe Mbappe has more goals this season than Isak, but I don't look at Mbappe playing right now and say I'm watching the better player overall than Isak.
      Your emotional ranting about Laliga Vs PL was hilarious to read. I don't know why you feel slighted. Me saying I'd have Isak instead of Mbappe as my central forward doesn't equate to Isak is better than anyone in Laliga. Heck, I don't even think Mbappe is the best player in his own team.
      Even the Laliga president, Javier Tebas KNOWS the PL is the best domestic competition in the world and competed by the best collection of football clubs in the world.

    • @josephajibowo-wp2rw
      @josephajibowo-wp2rw День тому

      @@robbiekop7 Thanks, ...more than Halaand I meant to say 😏

    • @daryljackson6088
      @daryljackson6088 День тому

      I do worry Madrid will go for him.

  • @davidgalbraith694
    @davidgalbraith694 День тому +2

    With haaland if hes not scoring he offers little when you see him with norway with "lesser" players and not the same service he gets at club level hes pretty average

    • @Photosoflife
      @Photosoflife День тому +7

      @davidgalbraith694
      By "pretty average" you mean 38 goals and 4 assists in 39 appearances for Norway?

    • @davidgalbraith694
      @davidgalbraith694 День тому +2

      @Photosoflife almost half of those have been against teams like kosovo Kazakhstan Gibraltar Cyprus Luxembourg and armenia he has 1 goal against Holland and 1 against Denmark he's not faced any real quality

    • @Detroiy2k
      @Detroiy2k День тому

      He would struggle at Newcastle, haaland needs constant service..isak can do both..callum Wilson would do what haaland did at city

    • @Photosoflife
      @Photosoflife День тому

      @davidgalbraith694
      So if it’s that easy then where are all the other international strikers putting up a goal per match average? Hmm?

    • @Photosoflife
      @Photosoflife День тому

      @Detroiy2k
      It’s actually the very opposite. People who say things like Haaland needs constant service and is only a penalty box poacher never saw him at Dortmund or Salzburg. Let alone in just the past few matches for City. Haaland is an absolute monster in space and on the counterattack. He would naturally fit in with sides like Newcastle, Liverpool, and Tottenham much more than City.

  • @flyer1658
    @flyer1658 День тому

    I don't think there's a team in the world at the moment that Isak doesn't walk into

  • @rugbyanalyst1
    @rugbyanalyst1 День тому

    Different type of strikers. Isak has been in incredible form but he needs to do it for longer and at the highest level to be labeled "better" than Haaland. Haaland has been a machine wherever he has gone.

  • @brettsinclair3550
    @brettsinclair3550 День тому

    Isak makes Newcastle great. That is the difference.

  • @kurtmiller7040
    @kurtmiller7040 День тому +11

    Haaland bang average footballer. Isak is the best in the world atm

    • @eL--RaL
      @eL--RaL День тому +3

      Best in the world?? 😂 Have you heard of Lewandowski and Kane?

    • @Rocky-w5r
      @Rocky-w5r День тому +2

      He is not even the best Swedish striker 😂

    • @Kat-jk7zq
      @Kat-jk7zq День тому

      @@Photosoflife he was obviously reffering to Isak.

    • @Rocky-w5r
      @Rocky-w5r День тому

      @@Photosoflife Gyökeres and isak mate. Take time to understand a comment.

    • @tyronleemorriss
      @tyronleemorriss День тому

      @@eL--RaL Kane 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @dawnking5318
    @dawnking5318 16 годин тому

    Ally mcoist the best commentator needs to do moretoon games

  • @Baldnesz
    @Baldnesz День тому

    Baby Faced Assasin II is a different style of Striker.

  • @Skunkman-w5x
    @Skunkman-w5x 18 годин тому

    That’s a funny story. Isak is having the season of his life , haaland having a really poor season, yet haaland has 16 league goals and your man isak , on fire, world beater, compared to Henry, is on 13 goals. But isak is much better 😂😂😂

  • @BredaToon
    @BredaToon 23 години тому

    Haaland is a better striker for me. Isak is a much better footballer and team player though.

  • @tomcrown9546
    @tomcrown9546 День тому

    Ally, Have a look at the goal scoring records ! Haaland is double that of Isaks per game!

  • @Detroiy2k
    @Detroiy2k День тому +1

    They are both strikers ,end of..if u ask haaland to do what isak does,he can't,otherwise he'd be doing it..isak is a proper player..haaland would struggle at Newcastle

    • @philipmorrison5284
      @philipmorrison5284 День тому +1

      Rubbish so how he's not struggling at Norway and every where he plays since he was a kid 🙄

  • @jmz1892
    @jmz1892 День тому +4

    Haaland is finished. There's a new kid on the block 👍

  • @paulwalton3391
    @paulwalton3391 15 годин тому

    Down ta ONE MAN wor Eddie!!!!!

  • @ciaranwilliams1252
    @ciaranwilliams1252 День тому

    Isak the better all around striker. Thats clear
    Haaland a better finisher. Thats also clear
    I'm a nufc fan i watch nufc every week isak misses a lot also.

  • @ulfanfinneriksen4643
    @ulfanfinneriksen4643 День тому

    If it's not Arsenal I cheer for Newcastle.

  • @ulfanfinneriksen4643
    @ulfanfinneriksen4643 День тому

    No , no, no give your head a wobble. Haaland no 1 striker on the planet.

  • @jeanlundi2141
    @jeanlundi2141 День тому

    Gyokeres better than both.

  • @TrueLife-o2j
    @TrueLife-o2j День тому

    Nope. Get into the semantics of what makes a great striker all you like, at the end of it all they are measured by the number of goals scored. Haaland is far better.

  • @Charlieb82
    @Charlieb82 День тому

    Everyone saying Haaland is a better player just remember.... stay humble 😜

  • @Asapurbae
    @Asapurbae День тому +1

    Isak all day

  • @1akeem
    @1akeem День тому

    warra treble for isak

  • @HughDallas99
    @HughDallas99 День тому

    2 players bought. From a farmer's league weird

  • @KG-vn8ou
    @KG-vn8ou День тому

    Mcoist talks some b*llox at times. A strikers main job is to put the ball in the onion bag. Haarland does that better than anybody at the moment on the planet. Stop this talk of all round shite. For a team that’s at the top of its game he’s the guy that will finish off your good play.

  • @GermanChickenwing
    @GermanChickenwing День тому +18

    Put Haaland and Isak on the market today, Bayern, Barca, Real dont get near Isak.. Haaland didn't score for how many games ? Still Isak couldn't get near him..Lets stop the stupidity now

    • @youtubedislikes3756
      @youtubedislikes3756 День тому +5

      Guys won the treble, 2 prems, over a hundred goals in under 3 seasons at city. But doesnt score for a few games so now Haaland would be 2nd choice at Newcastle 😂

    • @Detroiy2k
      @Detroiy2k День тому +7

      But u have to play to haaland 1 strength, scoring, he ain't creating his own goals or for others
      Haaland would struggle at Newcastle

    • @GermanChickenwing
      @GermanChickenwing День тому

      @Detroiy2k Are you talking about the same Isak? He is similar to Haaland when creating for himself..I cant remember 1 goal this season where he scored by himself..Correct me if I am wrong. Haaland would struggle at Newcastle? You are damm right, City is the only club he has played for, smh

    • @SC.KINGDOM
      @SC.KINGDOM День тому +2

      😂 Haaland is average

    • @jamjam2833
      @jamjam2833 День тому +2

      Watch another game kid, you struggle with this one.

  • @mulissanacher
    @mulissanacher День тому

    lol

  • @frankbevan413
    @frankbevan413 День тому

    TBF McCoist is half cut most the time

  • @johndewhurst1582
    @johndewhurst1582 День тому

    To be compared to Haaland is praise indeed for Isak both great strikers but Haaland wins the battle for me.

  • @VideoAssistantRafi
    @VideoAssistantRafi День тому

    Are we getting that silly now? The current holder of the PL golden boot the last couple seasons & on course to collect possible third consecutive one yet we putting him down under Isak? That just end it rightly there boys I understand you trying to run a channel but coming from you couple muppets is a bit too much to even laugh it off👎bad podcasting

  • @jab-gn3sw
    @jab-gn3sw День тому

    What a Pile of BS from Talksport , Isaak isn't worth half of Haaland, the goals prove it FFS

    • @brettsinclair3550
      @brettsinclair3550 День тому

      So as a Norwegian I love to see Isak play. Haaland is great but as a team player I have to go with Isak.