Sequel to this video is live now. For those who say what services are we getting in return for taxes, watch this. ua-cam.com/video/lZ20ePUkGSk/v-deo.htmlsi=Rv7KjrXCaUGHRwYH
Where do you think all the money for all the schemes come from? I mean there's always a scope of improvement of utilisation of taxes in every country and in every govt (in our case a big big one) But completely discarding the idea of taxes, that too coming from a freaking CA that kya ab sabun par bhi tax de? I mean lmao 🤣
@@A1mb0t_Fr0z3n😂😂 Itna vhalai ho raha hay ki doller ka price highest for ever in history ho geya.. Pakistan, Bangladesh kRte karte Pakistan ho geya desh 😂😂😂 bebokop
@@A1mb0t_Fr0z3n of course some tax is necessary for the state to function. but there has to be some reasonable limit. imo anything beyond 5% of the income of a citizen is oppression and tax terrorism. the govt should crackdown on wasteful use of tax money in paying the salary and pension of multi-millionaire MPs and MLAs, giving exemptions to rich "farmers" and siphoning of public funds via corruption, instead of increasing taxes on honest tax payers. no wonder a vast majority of the country dont pay tax. why should they ? if they can save their money, kudos to them. better they keep their money, rather than that money goes to the politician's pocket via corruption.
the real problem is corruption. hamare gaon ke pradhan ko nale banane ke liye 1.5Cr rupe aaye the to us ne 50 metre nala banba ke gaon ke lago se sign kar baliye or 50 metre me se adha tut bhi gaye.
@keshavbedi ye dono chize ek hai wo tax ka pesa logo ka hai or logo ki sahuliyat ke istamaal hona chahiye. and you always say that tax paying is good and i support that but the thing is that bijli ka bill ham bharang ge gas ka bill ham bharag ge pani ka bill ham bharang ge safaai karamchari ko pesa ham denge koi sarkari kaam(koi form bharana kisi sarkari document thik karana etc.) unke pesa ham denge hamare gaon ke sarkari hospital me koi doctor hi nahi beth ta band pada hai pata na kaba se or condition bhi bure hai same with sarkari schools to us chiz ka bhi bill ham bharen or gaon ke roado, nalo or naliyo ke condition to puchh na bhi nahi abhi 1 mahine pehle mere phone khugaya tha to ham police report likhane Gaye the (mujhe umeed to nhi thi ki wo dun denge par formality kiye) to wo usme bhi risbat mang raha tha. har kaam me risbat. na safaa haba na safety bas har time 'India vishwaguru hai' and cherry on the top current government the hate they are spreading last thing har baat ka bill to ye logo par tood dete hai fir ham tax bhi de or itna khatrnak tax the real problem is corruption
Agree with you, Brother. People have stupid logic against taxes that the Tax money is being used in Corruption so we should not pay taxes. So speak against corruption Not against Tax. Its like Car Accidents happens, So Ban the Cars. "When you Oppose everything Just because you want to Oppose, you look stupid"😂
the same fragile argument was passed when IPL auction was going on- 'batao desh ke liye khelne wale Rishabh pant par X amount ka tax lagega" and they are THE same people who'll cry afterwards that TAX THE RICH, not the "MIDAL KILAS", jab rich ko tax kar rahe the toh desh prem yaad aagaya yahi koi welfare scheme aaye toh freebies and dehat lazyness promoter bolenge, out of 1000's blunder nirmala has done, he chose this 🤡 and literally his point was tax kyu leti hai Nirmala? jaise tax sirf India mein sirf is govt mein lagna start hua hai and how will the country sustain? wo nahi pata🤐
Bro, I don't have a problem with taxes. I have a problem with how they are spent. Mostly on wastage like hikes in salaries for MP, MLAs, statues, parks or in taking away the debt of rich billionaires and giving "production linked incentives". Yes, taxes exist for redistribution of income but that redistrubution has been nearly non-existent in the past 10 years where inequaity has increased. At the same time, burden of taxes lie upon individual tax payers via income tax and GST over capital gains and corporate taxes. "Taxes like Europe, Services like Somalia" is a hyperbolic statement, the intent behind the statement is what captures the frustration. Nobody would be giving a shit about 18% GST on soap if I also did not have to worry about my child's future and education. I have been hearing for 15 years that only 2% of the population pays income tax. Even the most dismal reports on Indian economy claim that if your income is 25k/month or 3 lpa, you are in the top 10%. However according to New tax regime, we are taxed at 3 lpa. So where are the other 8% of tax payers? So, yes people should target this government and its tax policies.
@@keshavbedi Bro, you are again strawmaning. No one wants to abolish the taxes. They are fed up with increasing taxes, the small base from whom income tax is taken and the corruption which renders a lot of the taxes useless. Not to mention the inflation is also a stealth tax on us. We can also strawman & say that if you like taxes so much then start paying 95% in taxes and then only you will be called a 95% patriot.
bhai middle class tax utna bhar hi nahi paa rahi, cuz they simply don't have money, 11cr ki wealth wala middle class nahi hota chaman chumbak pehle middle class pata kar le hota kya hai, even 40k per month bhi middle class mein nahi ata yahi koi welfare scheme koi bhi sarkar le aaye toh saare so-called "midal kilas" ke muu se jaan nikal jayegi and rich (top 10%) hi hamesha majority tax dega, cuz they literally hoard majority the wealth of the nation
@@A1mb0t_Fr0z3n when did I said 11cr are wealth are middle class bhen I said people are not paying tax many shops outlet earn more than 5+ lakhs but don't pay tax and many big farmers they will own big cars but don't pay tax bhen ji
and those people with more wealth have significantly more chances to do well in life and get all the facilities, hence they keep on growing while the others can't and yahi gap zyda bada na hojaye uske liye taxes and tarifs introduce hue hai, so that everyone gets atleast SOME KIND of level playing field jaha par ye disparities kam hai, and desh already developed hai waha tariff kam hai
50% on Nobel prize sounds pretty reasonable and I don't think its comparable to Chess prize money. 1) Scientific funding for projects that would win you a noble prize comes from highly funded governmental research institute, so I don't think its absurd to ask 50% tax. 2) Gukesh unlike the noble laureates wasn't funded by the government. His Team included 7 Top level grandmasters which no doubt were highly expensive, and I think its fair to ask the tax to be exempted since he did win the country a world championship .
This is just a bad argument. 1. Scientific funding is available to all research and is based on merit of research. Scientists have to prove that their research is worthy and then they are funded. That funding exclusively funds research. So it requires great work to get that money. It is not that it is freely available. 2. By taxing Nobel Prize winners, you are basically making successful people pay for cost of unsuccessful people. 3. Govt. won't recover funding amount by taxing noble prize as the prize money is insignificant compared to its budget. However, that money is significant amount for the prize winner. 4. Gukesh has alternative sources of revenue. After winning, he will make money through ads and deals, which will be several times that of prize money. A scientist does not have these revenue sources. 5. Irrespective of that, the people who are trying to argue that finance minister is incompetent because we are taxing chess prize winners and saying Nimmo tai is extorting money from us, are acting like illiterates. Why not these CAs and intellectuals, tell us which schemes we should scrap to reduce requirements of tax? They won't do that because then public will criticize them. So, these youtubers deserve to be mocked
@@johnlove2954 “bad argument” the Irony is unreal 1) Funding is not given to all research, it is given to those research which have the maximum chance of giving the best ROI, do you honestly think research on fish biology is given the same money has research on vaccines? 2 &3) What are you even trying to say? “Making successful people pay cost of unsuccessful people” Are you trying to say we should remove all taxes? Because you could say that about any tax. Secondly Government makes back the profit in multiple ways, taxation of the prize is just one of those ways, and you could say separately for all of the ways “they won’t recover funding amount, so let’s remove it” and then by the end you’ve basically got rid of all sources. Also laureates are given 10-11 mill per award, and 5 million back to gov is not insignificant. 4) Gukesh has alternative source of money, he will make money from deals and ads? So what you’re saying is just because he’s got other sources of income he should be taxed, if you are this is just idiotic, and shows how little you know of chess earnings too. Also 1.3 mill is not a small amount, he’s not making several times that easily, how do you know he doesn’t need this money to invest further? However the most idiotic thing you said in this point was that A Nobel laureate has less alternative sources of income then a chess player 😂 what world are you living in, here’s 5 from the top of my head selling Books, edu tech platforms, money from going on shows, bigger social media presence thus giving ads and deals, a higher chance of getting granted funding for future projects…. Etc
@@SmortSquirtle you make bad arguments again 1. Yes, so you yourself say that funding is given to research that generates RoI. So there is no need to tax nobel prize additionally. 2. This is just height of stupidity. Your claim is international prizes should not be taxed because they result in greater reputation of country. Nobel Prize does exactly that. However, you yourself created a bizarre exemption for them because govt. Provides funding for them. That is a bad argument because by taxing nobel prize, you will not get any significant return, so better not tax it as well and burden the prize winner. But you are ok taxing scientists but not sportspersons. This is hilariously bad take. 😂 3. However, your last take is most hilarious and shows your idiocy. All taxes are based on who can earn more. That is why we have progressive taxation. Because the biggest point in putting taxes is burden on tax payer. Also all sources you mentioned for scientists are available to sportspeople. They can write books, they can appear on platforms, etc. All people with more than 0 iq know famous sportspeople earn more than famous scientists. You are literally defending taxing scientists while crying about taxing famous sportspeople. I don't know, what to say. You should try comedy
I stay in Europe. & I pay very high income taxes, but also receive a lot of social security benefits from govt. Here Govt spends a lot of money to keep the roads, parks, & drainage systems clean and functioning. Also here in Europe public transport is cheaper & better interconnected than India. Indians are ready to pay higher income taxes if they receive similar benefits. But currently India is taxing like Sweden to give benefits like Somalia.
There should be high tax on sports, acting & modeling or in general entertainment related fields because these things run on the sentiments of people. By logic also there should be less tax on necessary products & services like food products. A person should earn according to value they provide to the society. Even there should be 95% tax on revenue from obscene content.
see and analyze how govt is spending that tax, is it for social welfare or for loan waivers of cronies? Report curroption, etc. Or vote out the govt if you dont agree with their tax policies.
@@keshavbedi but that is definately not going to happen so better don't pay tax at all, and I don't agree with this "correction of income distribution", na sarkar mujhe help karti education me, na help karti hai job dhundne me, na help karti mujhe kisi medical emergency me or protection. Fir paying tax feels like getting stolen. Middle class has been seen as atm machine, police wale jab marzi chalan katke 1000 rupeey khech lete hai, ghar ka landlord apni marzi se deposit rakh leta hai, bemar pade to insuarance wale claim nai dete ,corporate wale waise bhi underpay karke bohot munafa kamalete hai, fir lastly tax.
The entire point of being a nation is that someone who is poor can & should benefit from the tax paid by the rich. Maharashtra & South states also make the same fallacy when they say north states take away the tax money paid by them. That is literally the point of federalism. Even a well read free market libertarian won't agree to this idea. Aur socialist to agree karenge hi. Reels like this show the absolute horrible standard of narrative in our country. We can't even understand most basic things. Bina soche samjhe narrative phailao bus
But it's not like south is europe and north is africa Redistribution should be fair, supporting the North's development without punishing the South for its progress. Funds should be shared based on contribution, population needs, and regional growth goals to ensure balanced development across the country.
@@randalthor69 very detailed topic for yt comments 😅 i guess you have your reasons for the opinion & I hope you'll analyse the inherent assumptions & biases and find new ideas around this on internet
I dont think people have a grievance against tax, per se, but grievance towards seeing the same revenue not being spent towards sustainable public infrastructure. Bridges crumbling less than 2 years after their construction, potholes across major roads, etc, have pointed towards legitimate grievance. Also, the fact the corporate tax share has decreased against consumer taxes, which further points towards the disparity of taxation, and concessions and bailouts to major corporates despite horrible practices, also further dispels the myth that taxes are for equitable distribution of private wealth. This clearly has not been happening in a new "viksit" cronified India. Again this is what a large section of populace believe anyway, and I find some legitimacy to the same.
Brother most of the taxes are either same or just increased a little bit, ofc some exceptions are there to be discussed Ye dikkat pehle bhi thi, but pehle india ka 15lpa kamane wale midal kilas twitter par chillate the nahi the Still with the increased consumer taxes our tax collection per capita is still low
It's not about tax collection, it's all about how the money is used for the public services. Pretty sure there's no inflation, the inflation is created one's , those cronies are talking loans and wasting it for nothing.
@ Did you ever travel by any road and seen it’s condition?, have you ever visited a government hospital and seen it’s condition?, have you ever visited a government school and seen it’s ruin? Taxes are sine qua non, for the development of any nation, but it depends on the government whether it uses the taxes for benefitting the common man. It’s not that you pay taxes and they automatically are used fairly and judiciously. If paying taxes is patriotism, then being vigilant and fighting the misuse or underuse of those taxes is patriotism too.
@@navinraut5920 I am Patna one of the worst places in India and the roads here are pretty good. Even Govt hospitals are better than Private Hospitals. Proud of what Nitish Kumar and BJP here has done. Maybe the govt in your state regardless if it's BJP non BJP Or Congress aren't doing any development vote them out.
Prize,gifts ke liye sahi hai but for the people who are earing less amount of money after that they are paying taxes in which they have to take care of their faimly because they are the only wage earners of the family.I mean you get the point.
*Europe aur US jaisi service nahi mil rahi ye bolna thik hai agar ye bol diya ki India Backward hai to UAPA lag jayega. midday meal ke khane me namak nahi itna bolne se hi UP me UAPA lag gaya tha.*
I have a point, and want your input in this. according to you, taxation is a means to distribute money evenly, basically taking from the rich and giving to the poor. But at the same time, the constitution allows certain individuals (especially people running their own businesses) to save taxes form various sources? CAs are taught how to save tax? The best CA is the one who helps you to save the maximum amount of tax? how are you going to explain this? if tax paying is really so patriotic, why does government enable certain rich part of society to save taxes on numerous things? Taxes are meant to level up the field for poor people, but that don't seem to be the case in real life. you can clearly see the rich is getting richer and poor is getting poorer. clearly, there is some flaw in taxation itself, don't you think? All the reforms in tax system, cleverly avoids having any impact on people with large wealth, and only affect the middle class people. kya karein, ambani ji se panga thodi le sakte hai.... don't you think this defeats the entire purpose of tax to begin with? don't you think the redistribution of money is happening for sure, but the other way around? saara patriotism ka theka middle class ne hi le rakha hai kya? Adani se tax kyu nahi lete tameez se?
Tax paying is not scary!! The thing thats scary is that even after paying huge lump of money to the government we still are not getting a good infrastructural development and public facilities!! If govt. can provide us with general public facilities no one will ever cry to pay taxes to that old lady!!!
For whatever technical reasons the fact is 'taxes like the USA, services worse than Somalia', if I am self-centred, if I can shift to a foreign country, then why not? It makes sense why more and more millionaires are leaving this country, what do you think most skilled and rich guys leaving a country, is this not a problem for a country at all? pls reply man
This quoted line is such a shitty take. Check per capita income of Somalia and USA and then check what amount does the government of India and these two countries have to spend per person. Clearly, you didn't watch till the end
Thx bhai, I never knew even Nobel prize money was taxed 🙈, but yes like you said the central point around taxing is helping the unfortunate people around. Also I am reminded that current meme culture on taxes is diff tax slab rates on diff kinds of popcorns 😅
keshav can you make a video on terms used such as "TAX Terr0rism", and 'that's why the rich leaves india', plus telling what exactly is middle class? cuz these arguments are suddenly on a rise on X, cuz "middle class" on twitter are angry cuz they have to pay 30% gst on their 15LPA+ income
What are your thoughts on taxing rich farmers for example that earn more than 12 lakh yearly (lets consider this is after everything that needs to be paid)
I don't really considering farming is fundamentally an economically unprofitable exercise. Agar koi fir bhi paise itna banaleta hai after going against those odds, I don't think it warrants tax. Plus, very few such farmers exist
True; CA sahab's video would have made more sense from the POV of the poor, rather than the 'middle class' All taxes are supposed to be redtributive in nature Popular rhetoric focuses on direct taxes, which are linked to one's earnings, while conveniently forgetting that all Indians pay indirect taxes without any such distinction and these disproportionately sap the poor more than anybody else However, this concept of top 1%, 10% etc is pretty flawed: the avg wealth of the top 1% is 54 L; while this is pretty big in the Indian context, does it even compare to big industrialists, entrepreneurs or even small successful business owners? For the top 10%, it's about 10L Clubbing these groups together makes little sense
I disagree with your point however. Because under the neoliberal govt the taxes are just being wasted. They are not being used in education, nutrition (govt banned eggs in midday meals), or growth of the basic superstrcutures or local mechanisms of the states. If you were seeing sweeping changes like china did during post 1990s or even after that none of such gradual improvements are happening. And all these taxes are going to cronies. Or to pay the impossible to pay indian govts debt to imf and other such institutions. The govt is not working on the basic superstrcutures. Its just pumping its cronies. Like as you know the basic superstrcutures like land reforms, hsr/msr, public transport, water services, waste management, nutrition, education all these things can only be modernized or maximized on a per capita basis by state policies and planning which this dumb govt keeps talking about against on all the major things the govt should actually be working upon. Both pro bjp and anti bjp liberals throw around these words freebies. Bhai tera baap or teri generation me se jitne bhi aage aaye hai woh jitne bhi limited freebies schemes (govt funding basic things like education, nutrition, healthcare, public transport, military and so forth) uski wajah se hua hai
3:08 sir log europe jaise services nahi chahte zinda rehne layak hawa peene layak paani aur khaane layak sasti roti ki maang karrahe hai Jo ki hamara fundamental right hai Tax apne desk ke liye investment hai jo govt kuch return ke promise par leti hai ...deshbhakti ke naam par sarkaari baabu ki wallet bharne ka naam nai
@@keshavbedisir no one is demanding for removal of taxes People are demanding for reasonable rate of taxes So that if i contribute to the economy I should be getting some incentive .....if taxes are too high there is no incentive for me to contribute something big to the economy Secondly people are demanding rationalised and efficient spending of taxes and not like some free money Our govt is extremely inefficient in this regard Govt is taking debt like there's no tomorrow Govt is increasing taxes like crazy Govt is disinvesting in public companies like all of them are liabilities This all fund raising could have been justifiable if they delivered something to the country but we all know our economy is struggling right now ....... where the fu*ck is all of that money ! And where did they spent it? There are no positive effects on economy Food inflation is touching the roof Wages have stagnated Iam a med student ...healthcare costs are crazy 90% Indians cannot afford it Sir if people dont see the return of their tax investment ... Unfortunately many will leave india which is happening in our country These are some reasonable demands which govt can listen to
I think Dectatorship should started in country and people should taxed 80% ...Also all youtuber and all income should be taxed 80%.. People should get to spend on Only food and Clothing... British were at least better than this Government 😢
Lmao. Not sure about Britain but as long as more jobs get created I won't mind paying even 40% tax. You guys need to raise your voice but on reasonable things. Tax isn't the issue Jobs are
Before commenting what services do we get in return, atleast have the basic decency to watch full video. And then, go through this detailed one. THEN SPEAK. ua-cam.com/video/8ZyT0UEAlYo/v-deo.htmlsi=DLY49GMz1KgmgJyz
Valid point but the amount of corruption and misuse there is, also makes sense to grant exemption to extraordinary achievers. Also its a request please make a vide on public sector, if bank privatization is good or not for example both from economy and worker POV
@keshavbedi Thanks for your opinion. Also what do you think about this welfare model of public banks as below and do you think this model should be slowly replicated in other sectors in a post capitalist world? Nationalized banks had pension scheme for employees joining upto 2010, the pension benefit is similar to Central govt employees and is funded directly from banks revenue expenditure. So banks sitting on healthy profits, workers too getting a share of it and it helps boost consumption etc as well and a stellar retired life, giving larger social mobility to their children as well who can take bigger risks and have higher rewarding careers also in return contributing to nation in more taxes! During banks loss years it's a problem, as tax payers money is used to re capitalize but can be avoided easily with good management. Today when I see banks like HDFC, profiting over 50k crores but having absolutely shit wages for majority of workers, shit worklife, barely any job security and sustainability for majority of workforce, I see what's the point of sitting over so much profits if basic workers life improvement can't be achieved and will definitely impact the next generation as well? Makes me think nationalized banks model was really good, specially if it could manage consistent profitability, and if having a accountable responsible management at the top free of political interference.
Keshav bhai don't you think that the burden of taxes is more on the salaried class, and it should also be on the top 0.1%, i.e, extremely wealthy? And if there is a wealth tax, how can we ensure that these businesses don't run off to a tax haven, like what a lot of the american firms did by running off to Ireland? These 'tax havens' are basically rewarding the firms for not paying taxes in their original countries.
Brother. He is criticising the government for the exorbitant tax rates. Raghav chaddha had summarised it very well. He said, "Indians pay taxes like USA, To get services like somalia". If we are paying our taxes, we have right to criticise our ministers and governemnt on it.
There are no exorbitant tax rates, and Raghav Chadda’s comment was idiotic. Had covered it in Part 2 of my video on Dhruv Rathee’s nonsense in Mission Swaraj
Bhai, please make a video on the impact of demonetisation on the Indian economy and how it has reduced our productivity. There is a superficial claim that Pakistan went bankrupt due to India's demonetisation, not because of their economic mismanagement.
While I agree that most of the people blabbering about taxes are top 1% or maybe top 5%, I'd say taxes haven't existed because of welfare. Public is made to think it is for welfare, but it's mainly because someone is capable enough to tax people. Taxes are like maintenance and way of asserting dominance for the ruling entity. Bringing inequality or income disparity down isn't always the goal of the ruling class, see what happened in last few decades.
@@keshavbedi On paper, yes. In reality, No. Specially in the Indian context. Also a most of welfare and development schemes help powerful people or groups ( builders, military industrial complex or healthcare complex ) more than they help the public. Not to mention, how are you taxed depends a lot on your bargaining power with the govt. You can be spending 5000 crores on a marriage and still not be the highest individual taxpayer.
basically jo log jivan me kuch ukhad nhi paa rhe vo ye arpit aur german shepherd jaiso ko dekh ke validation lete hain apne faliure ke liye aur sochte hain ki bhot bade intellectual hain
Keshav bhai, people are getting it wrong. Problem taxation me nahi hai balki corruption me hai. Hame video recording karni hogi jab bhi ham koi government office jaaye taki proof rahe ki hamara kaam dhang se hua nahi. Government ko law laana chahiye right to record ka. Mai ek government college me migration certificate lene gaya to clerk besharmo ki tarah paise maang raha tha.
@@keshavbedi but Somalia is for comparison how worst services we are getting from government it is like everyone is paying taxes below income level and above income level for example I have to pay taxes for everything and still have to pay taxes in the name of income tax what I get open sewage dirty road street dogs and cows every where garbage on road holes on road no safety on road healthcare facilities but so poor that you can't find bed and if I have to buy insurance plan company make so many loop holes in terms and conditions you will lose hope because if I case on company it take month to sue the company how slow the court system government school is so bad unhygienic food they teach three class like. 4th,5th,6th students with one teacher don't teach cleanliness I know india is very. Dirty and swacha bharat mission is a campaign which make no changes accept making toilets it do better when we make rules that have strict penalty and 6months of jail and police taking action immediately so that everyone should follow rules finance minister putting so many taxes. And how do we know it's is use in beneficial for society or its lose in corruption i trust nitin gadkari how many good highways and expressways but bihar bridge collapse how much corruption here it like losing all money on fraud
Bhai ek budhi Amma jiska koi Sahara nahi hai wo bhi jab roti khareedegi aur Ambani jab roti khareedega dono par same tax kaise lag sakta hai? Ye justifiable nahi hai Maine dusri countries me gst dekha hai wo kaafi simple hai aur usme govt basic needs jaise food par gst nai lagati
Sir, I think ye frustration aur aise videos ka Karan ye hai ki there's prevalence in general consciousness that government and officials (businessmen ofc) are highly corrupted people. . .Jo thoda bohot tax aa bhi rha hai use nhi ho rha theek se.
Please answer this - as per many recent reports like oxfam etc india's top 1 % holds around 45 -50% wealth and top 10 % around 74% wealth while bottom 50% holds less than 2% So dont you think tax revenues should also come in these proportions. But no most of the tax revenue ( direct taxes) come from income tax and major proportion is covered by middle class. Dont you think tax slabs are unfair ???
Everyone is paying taxes fool Some pay more Some pay less But everyone pays texes according to their capabilities And everybody is not equal in any term Except everyone has one face , 2 hands , 2 legs and one brain Bada hoja kid thoda sa 🤡
You made a video on degrowth na , I found something interesting related to it . Read an article by Tom Murphy website do the math called can modernity last ? And check his book he mention in his article go to alternative energy part and see the calculations for respective source of energy
Useless video ,we are backwards so we should not expect sir, This guy knows everything about everything which makes it laughable. Bol raha h service mt lo bs tax do .😂😂
See the rich have CAs and financial experts like you so they dont pay taxes and they have their own kind of little world where they spend lavishly buy expedive things and if required go to another country to settle down and there is no bad about it because its make sense that if i have intaligence ill do that and i am not against it but i am earning 30k a month and almost 15k is goning into direct or indirect taxes so what i am left with and how will i go from a poor to atlease a lower middle class.
mujhe kya mil rha hai tax deke ? agar mujhe charity hi karni hai toh bc mein khud q nhi anath ashram mein dedu mere salary ka agr 30 percent govt kat leti hai toh uske against mujhe kya deti hai tute hue pool gadho wali road patriotism itna hi khun mein hai toh apne saare assets income tax department ko donate karde .agar mujhe kisi dusre country mein tax ke badle achi living mil rhi hai toh mein wha q nhi shift hunga .pura tax system corrupted hai
Aap kuch bhi bolo govt ko tax middle class se utna hi lena chahiye jitna ke baad wo thik se savings kar pae aur dusra unki purchasing power thik thak rahe Tabhi hamari economy grow karegi warna govt jitni spending karle wo temporary push hai
extraordinary to he na bhai ! usa europe ka example le rahe ho to facility bhi to dekho bhaiya ! or sabun pr 18% gst le rahe he, aapse lena he ? do un 80 caror logo ko jinke khane ka intezam bhi sarkar kar rahi he ... bat vo 1 percent me aata he ye nahi he , bat ye he ki vo 1 percent me aake kis financial group ki voice ban raha he , wrna uss 99 % logo ko apne jiwan se time nhi milta he , samaj ki problems ko kese time denge ! baki , i like your work !
Say two countries have incomes 100 and 10000. I can say they pay 30% taxes in latter, so have 30% here too. But obviously, 30% on 10,000 would mean government having 3000 as opposed to just 30 here in absolute numbers.
Bro please think properly for the original reason for taxation. It is not a right of the government but to run it and provide services to citizens. Are these services audited for quality and accountability? Set aside about duties as the tax is paid. What about government duties? You think it's really being properly managed? What support has India given to Chess players before they were famous ? We are the least sporting nation for God's sake. Also don't show some random reel and get emotional.
@keshavbedi Original reason for the modern tax was to finance the public services and other government debt. It's not a great tool for wealth redistribution as wealth comes from their personal income and not government benefits. You may have public services that are low quality like pre college education, transportation, health and so on. It's same in most Western countries. Progressive taxation also failed. Class mobility is an illusion for non upper class as inflation and stagnant wages reset what they achieved over the years.
Paying taxes are not a extraordinary thing to do, yes but extorting a certain income class is not right, as a country who doesn't give a shit about your hardwork should be addressed too, here taxing gukesh is not problem but see the taxing amount on hard earned vs corporates its not right either it's not their fault too but they can change that it's not even that much of a work when you can increase taxes on popcorn at one seating. It's not like I'm new to your channel, iam even a subscribertoo. even though it's not their fault to begin with but there is no problem in addressing it. Even I think what arpit is talking is baseless but someone should address this extortion from certain income class
this time I can't agree with you, your example seems so vague and all of the sudden you feel like you need to match the tone to meet a certain political leaning crowd. Things like these makes creators like you fishy
Sequel to this video is live now. For those who say what services are we getting in return for taxes, watch this.
ua-cam.com/video/lZ20ePUkGSk/v-deo.htmlsi=Rv7KjrXCaUGHRwYH
Indian people apna Mindset badal na chahiye
Tax & Corruption are separate things. However the corrupt has made it so that we don't trust the very things which were established for our benifits.
"tax ka paisa logo ki bhalai pe hi jayega"
hahahahahaahhahahahahahahaaha
Where do you think all the money for all the schemes come from?
I mean there's always a scope of improvement of utilisation of taxes in every country and in every govt (in our case a big big one)
But completely discarding the idea of taxes, that too coming from a freaking CA that kya ab sabun par bhi tax de?
I mean lmao 🤣
@@A1mb0t_Fr0z3n😂😂 Itna vhalai ho raha hay ki doller ka price highest for ever in history ho geya.. Pakistan, Bangladesh kRte karte Pakistan ho geya desh
😂😂😂 bebokop
you want Indian govt to go bankrupt?
@@A1mb0t_Fr0z3n of course some tax is necessary for the state to function. but there has to be some reasonable limit.
imo anything beyond 5% of the income of a citizen is oppression and tax terrorism.
the govt should crackdown on wasteful use of tax money in paying the salary and pension of multi-millionaire MPs and MLAs, giving exemptions to rich "farmers" and siphoning of public funds via corruption, instead of increasing taxes on honest tax payers.
no wonder a vast majority of the country dont pay tax. why should they ? if they can save their money, kudos to them. better they keep their money, rather than that money goes to the politician's pocket via corruption.
@@A1mb0t_Fr0z3n which schemes????
the real problem is corruption. hamare gaon ke pradhan ko nale banane ke liye 1.5Cr rupe aaye the to us ne 50 metre nala banba ke gaon ke lago se sign kar baliye or 50 metre me se adha tut bhi gaye.
Uske khilaf bolna is different from ranting against paying taxes principally
mere pyare dost jab tax use hi nahi ho raha jis chiz ke liye de rahe hai to koi tax khushi khushi dega kiu ?@@keshavbedi
ye baat bhi hai 🤔 @@adied_2001
@keshavbedi ye dono chize ek hai wo tax ka pesa logo ka hai or logo ki sahuliyat ke istamaal hona chahiye.
and you always say that tax paying is good and i support that
but the thing is that bijli ka bill ham bharang ge gas ka bill ham bharag ge pani ka bill ham bharang ge safaai karamchari ko pesa ham denge koi sarkari kaam(koi form bharana kisi sarkari document thik karana etc.) unke pesa ham denge
hamare gaon ke sarkari hospital me koi doctor hi nahi beth ta band pada hai pata na kaba se or condition bhi bure hai same with sarkari schools to us chiz ka bhi bill ham bharen or gaon ke roado, nalo or naliyo ke condition to puchh na bhi nahi
abhi 1 mahine pehle mere phone khugaya tha to ham police report likhane Gaye the (mujhe umeed to nhi thi ki wo dun denge par formality kiye) to wo usme bhi risbat mang raha tha. har kaam me risbat.
na safaa haba na safety bas har time 'India vishwaguru hai' and cherry on the top current government the hate they are spreading
last thing har baat ka bill to ye logo par tood dete hai fir ham tax bhi de or itna khatrnak tax
the real problem is corruption
@@adied_2001school ke teacher ache nahi hai toh school ukhad doge kya?
Agree with you, Brother.
People have stupid logic against taxes that the Tax money is being used in Corruption so we should not pay taxes. So speak against corruption Not against Tax.
Its like Car Accidents happens, So Ban the Cars.
"When you Oppose everything Just because you want to Oppose, you look stupid"😂
Exactly
Abe gamdu to corruption to govt hi krri haina, ramdi
@@keshavbedi Abe gamdu to corruption to govt hi krri haina, ramdi
@@blackwolf6719 Ghar pe bhi ese baat krta tha kya?
Vese Last Line tere jese Jahil ke liye hi thi.
@@blackwolf6719 Exactly bhai 😂😂😂 Those who spoke up against corruption now they are saying corruption is inevitable( ex- Anna Hazare)
the same fragile argument was passed when IPL auction was going on- 'batao desh ke liye khelne wale Rishabh pant par X amount ka tax lagega"
and they are THE same people who'll cry afterwards that TAX THE RICH, not the "MIDAL KILAS", jab rich ko tax kar rahe the toh desh prem yaad aagaya
yahi koi welfare scheme aaye toh freebies and dehat lazyness promoter bolenge, out of 1000's blunder nirmala has done, he chose this 🤡
and literally his point was tax kyu leti hai Nirmala? jaise tax sirf India mein sirf is govt mein lagna start hua hai and how will the country sustain? wo nahi pata🤐
Again, taxation = good.
Tax money used to bail out or lend, or concede absurd sums to cronies = bad.
Clearly a difference between the two
Bro, I don't have a problem with taxes. I have a problem with how they are spent. Mostly on wastage like hikes in salaries for MP, MLAs, statues, parks or in taking away the debt of rich billionaires and giving "production linked incentives". Yes, taxes exist for redistribution of income but that redistrubution has been nearly non-existent in the past 10 years where inequaity has increased. At the same time, burden of taxes lie upon individual tax payers via income tax and GST over capital gains and corporate taxes. "Taxes like Europe, Services like Somalia" is a hyperbolic statement, the intent behind the statement is what captures the frustration. Nobody would be giving a shit about 18% GST on soap if I also did not have to worry about my child's future and education. I have been hearing for 15 years that only 2% of the population pays income tax. Even the most dismal reports on Indian economy claim that if your income is 25k/month or 3 lpa, you are in the top 10%. However according to New tax regime, we are taxed at 3 lpa. So where are the other 8% of tax payers? So, yes people should target this government and its tax policies.
I am speaking on those who are against taxes principally and fundamentally. Of course we can talk and criticize the corruption
@@keshavbedi Bro, you are again strawmaning. No one wants to abolish the taxes. They are fed up with increasing taxes, the small base from whom income tax is taken and the corruption which renders a lot of the taxes useless. Not to mention the inflation is also a stealth tax on us. We can also strawman & say that if you like taxes so much then start paying 95% in taxes and then only you will be called a 95% patriot.
Problem is that less people pay tax and hence middle class people who pay tax have to pay more
You're focussing on redistribution of incomes, not PRE-DISTRIBUTION. Check video link I mentioned in description.
bhai middle class tax utna bhar hi nahi paa rahi, cuz they simply don't have money, 11cr ki wealth wala middle class nahi hota
chaman chumbak pehle middle class pata kar le hota kya hai, even 40k per month bhi middle class mein nahi ata
yahi koi welfare scheme koi bhi sarkar le aaye toh saare so-called "midal kilas" ke muu se jaan nikal jayegi
and rich (top 10%) hi hamesha majority tax dega, cuz they literally hoard majority the wealth of the nation
@@A1mb0t_Fr0z3n when did I said 11cr are wealth are middle class bhen I said people are not paying tax many shops outlet earn more than 5+ lakhs but don't pay tax and many big farmers they will own big cars but don't pay tax bhen ji
and those people with more wealth have significantly more chances to do well in life and get all the facilities, hence they keep on growing
while the others can't and yahi gap zyda bada na hojaye uske liye taxes and tarifs introduce hue hai, so that everyone gets atleast SOME KIND of level playing field
jaha par ye disparities kam hai, and desh already developed hai waha tariff kam hai
@@keshavbedi You cannot assert that there is no interdependence on the two.
Even if everyone’s doing it , doesn’t mean that it’s right
Its right thing to do. 11 cr is no small amount
but if no one does it , that also doesnt mean its right .
in reality , situation matters
50% on Nobel prize sounds pretty reasonable and I don't think its comparable to Chess prize money.
1) Scientific funding for projects that would win you a noble prize comes from highly funded governmental research institute, so I don't think its absurd to ask 50% tax.
2) Gukesh unlike the noble laureates wasn't funded by the government. His Team included 7 Top level grandmasters which no doubt were highly expensive, and I think its fair to ask the tax to be exempted since he did win the country a world championship .
He is also funded by several other groups btw. Fairness is not the metric here.
@nananou1687 fairness is absolutely the metric. He is funded by several groups…. Yes. Are any of them by any chance governmental?
This is just a bad argument.
1. Scientific funding is available to all research and is based on merit of research. Scientists have to prove that their research is worthy and then they are funded. That funding exclusively funds research. So it requires great work to get that money. It is not that it is freely available.
2. By taxing Nobel Prize winners, you are basically making successful people pay for cost of unsuccessful people.
3. Govt. won't recover funding amount by taxing noble prize as the prize money is insignificant compared to its budget. However, that money is significant amount for the prize winner.
4. Gukesh has alternative sources of revenue. After winning, he will make money through ads and deals, which will be several times that of prize money. A scientist does not have these revenue sources.
5. Irrespective of that, the people who are trying to argue that finance minister is incompetent because we are taxing chess prize winners and saying Nimmo tai is extorting money from us, are acting like illiterates. Why not these CAs and intellectuals, tell us which schemes we should scrap to reduce requirements of tax? They won't do that because then public will criticize them.
So, these youtubers deserve to be mocked
@@johnlove2954 “bad argument” the Irony is unreal
1) Funding is not given to all research, it is given to those research which have the maximum chance of giving the best ROI, do you honestly think research on fish biology is given the same money has research on vaccines?
2 &3) What are you even trying to say? “Making successful people pay cost of unsuccessful people” Are you trying to say we should remove all taxes? Because you could say that about any tax. Secondly Government makes back the profit in multiple ways, taxation of the prize is just one of those ways, and you could say separately for all of the ways “they won’t recover funding amount, so let’s remove it” and then by the end you’ve basically got rid of all sources. Also laureates are given 10-11 mill per award, and 5 million back to gov is not insignificant.
4) Gukesh has alternative source of money, he will make money from deals and ads? So what you’re saying is just because he’s got other sources of income he should be taxed, if you are this is just idiotic, and shows how little you know of chess earnings too. Also 1.3 mill is not a small amount, he’s not making several times that easily, how do you know he doesn’t need this money to invest further? However the most idiotic thing you said in this point was that A Nobel laureate has less alternative sources of income then a chess player 😂 what world are you living in, here’s 5 from the top of my head selling Books, edu tech platforms, money from going on shows, bigger social media presence thus giving ads and deals, a higher chance of getting granted funding for future projects…. Etc
@@SmortSquirtle you make bad arguments again
1. Yes, so you yourself say that funding is given to research that generates RoI. So there is no need to tax nobel prize additionally.
2. This is just height of stupidity. Your claim is international prizes should not be taxed because they result in greater reputation of country. Nobel Prize does exactly that. However, you yourself created a bizarre exemption for them because govt. Provides funding for them. That is a bad argument because by taxing nobel prize, you will not get any significant return, so better not tax it as well and burden the prize winner. But you are ok taxing scientists but not sportspersons. This is hilariously bad take. 😂
3. However, your last take is most hilarious and shows your idiocy. All taxes are based on who can earn more. That is why we have progressive taxation. Because the biggest point in putting taxes is burden on tax payer. Also all sources you mentioned for scientists are available to sportspeople. They can write books, they can appear on platforms, etc. All people with more than 0 iq know famous sportspeople earn more than famous scientists.
You are literally defending taxing scientists while crying about taxing famous sportspeople.
I don't know, what to say. You should try comedy
Bro you gave me real clarity of thought ❤❤❤ .Tax has to be paid ,corruption is a different topic.
Gamdu jaake dekh tax ka paisa kaise chewtiya chizo me lagra hai
I stay in Europe. & I pay very high income taxes, but also receive a lot of social security benefits from govt. Here Govt spends a lot of money to keep the roads, parks, & drainage systems clean and functioning. Also here in Europe public transport is cheaper & better interconnected than India. Indians are ready to pay higher income taxes if they receive similar benefits. But currently India is taxing like Sweden to give benefits like Somalia.
There should be high tax on sports, acting & modeling or in general entertainment related fields because these things run on the sentiments of people.
By logic also there should be less tax on necessary products & services like food products.
A person should earn according to value they provide to the society.
Even there should be 95% tax on revenue from obscene content.
True
Paar woh log toh khudko farmer delcare kardete hai 😂
Fully exempted ho jate mtlab tax toh kabhi lagta hi nahi unpar
*SO WE KEEP OUR MOUTH SHUT AND PAY TAXES AS MUCH AS WE CAN, THAT'S WHAT U WANT TO SAY*
No, speak where you think money is being squandered, not principally against tax
see and analyze how govt is spending that tax, is it for social welfare or for loan waivers of cronies? Report curroption, etc. Or vote out the govt if you dont agree with their tax policies.
@@keshavbedi but that is definately not going to happen so better don't pay tax at all, and I don't agree with this "correction of income distribution", na sarkar mujhe help karti education me, na help karti hai job dhundne me, na help karti mujhe kisi medical emergency me or protection. Fir paying tax feels like getting stolen. Middle class has been seen as atm machine, police wale jab marzi chalan katke 1000 rupeey khech lete hai, ghar ka landlord apni marzi se deposit rakh leta hai, bemar pade to insuarance wale claim nai dete ,corporate wale waise bhi underpay karke bohot munafa kamalete hai, fir lastly tax.
we cant even protest as long as EVM is there
The entire point of being a nation is that someone who is poor can & should benefit from the tax paid by the rich. Maharashtra & South states also make the same fallacy when they say north states take away the tax money paid by them. That is literally the point of federalism. Even a well read free market libertarian won't agree to this idea. Aur socialist to agree karenge hi.
Reels like this show the absolute horrible standard of narrative in our country. We can't even understand most basic things. Bina soche samjhe narrative phailao bus
True.
But it's not like south is europe and north is africa
Redistribution should be fair, supporting the North's development without punishing the South for its progress. Funds should be shared based on contribution, population needs, and regional growth goals to ensure balanced development across the country.
@@randalthor69 very detailed topic for yt comments 😅 i guess you have your reasons for the opinion & I hope you'll analyse the inherent assumptions & biases and find new ideas around this on internet
I dont think people have a grievance against tax, per se, but grievance towards seeing the same revenue not being spent towards sustainable public infrastructure. Bridges crumbling less than 2 years after their construction, potholes across major roads, etc, have pointed towards legitimate grievance. Also, the fact the corporate tax share has decreased against consumer taxes, which further points towards the disparity of taxation, and concessions and bailouts to major corporates despite horrible practices, also further dispels the myth that taxes are for equitable distribution of private wealth. This clearly has not been happening in a new "viksit" cronified India.
Again this is what a large section of populace believe anyway, and I find some legitimacy to the same.
Brother most of the taxes are either same or just increased a little bit, ofc some exceptions are there to be discussed
Ye dikkat pehle bhi thi, but pehle india ka 15lpa kamane wale midal kilas twitter par chillate the nahi the
Still with the increased consumer taxes our tax collection per capita is still low
True, but I think with all this vishwaguru bs, people have raised their expectations, which is the cause of all troubles. @@A1mb0t_Fr0z3n
" jhooti kasam khau toh aap sab abhi mar jao " bkl😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
It's not about tax collection, it's all about how the money is used for the public services.
Pretty sure there's no inflation, the inflation is created one's , those cronies are talking loans and wasting it for nothing.
Yes, exactly but that's a different topic. But tax should be paid anyways.
@creopsy no one is saying , we don't want to pay tax. We don't want the corporates to take our money and waste it.
@@RahulMehra0361 yeah agreed, but I am just saying both topics are different
Mahaul h, log pareshaan hain
jaha tax lagega waha hamein dukhega
Tax is not the problem, tax used as a tool to destroy the common man is the problem, tax not used to develop our country is the problem.
How do you know that? Ever read any single budget document?
@ Did you ever travel by any road and seen it’s condition?, have you ever visited a government hospital and seen it’s condition?, have you ever visited a government school and seen it’s ruin?
Taxes are sine qua non, for the development of any nation, but it depends on the government whether it uses the taxes for benefitting the common man. It’s not that you pay taxes and they automatically are used fairly and judiciously. If paying taxes is patriotism, then being vigilant and fighting the misuse or underuse of those taxes is patriotism too.
@@navinraut5920 I am Patna one of the worst places in India and the roads here are pretty good. Even Govt hospitals are better than Private Hospitals. Proud of what Nitish Kumar and BJP here has done. Maybe the govt in your state regardless if it's BJP non BJP Or Congress aren't doing any development vote them out.
❤day tax dene se problem nahi hai tax dene ke baad bhi kido makaudo ki tarah treatment milne se problem hai
Logo ki bhalai....😂😂😂
Nahi?
Prize,gifts ke liye sahi hai but for the people who are earing less amount of money after that they are paying taxes in which they have to take care of their faimly because they are the only wage earners of the family.I mean you get the point.
*Europe aur US jaisi service nahi mil rahi ye bolna thik hai agar ye bol diya ki India Backward hai to UAPA lag jayega. midday meal ke khane me namak nahi itna bolne se hi UP me UAPA lag gaya tha.*
See my full video
I totally agree with you , no words or comments on your video you literally showed truth with logic
REAL ISSUE IS TAX EVASION BY AND TAX HAVN LIKE ADANI USING MAURITIUS
Sure
I have a point, and want your input in this.
according to you, taxation is a means to distribute money evenly, basically taking from the rich and giving to the poor.
But at the same time, the constitution allows certain individuals (especially people running their own businesses) to save taxes form various sources? CAs are taught how to save tax? The best CA is the one who helps you to save the maximum amount of tax? how are you going to explain this?
if tax paying is really so patriotic, why does government enable certain rich part of society to save taxes on numerous things? Taxes are meant to level up the field for poor people, but that don't seem to be the case in real life. you can clearly see the rich is getting richer and poor is getting poorer. clearly, there is some flaw in taxation itself, don't you think?
All the reforms in tax system, cleverly avoids having any impact on people with large wealth, and only affect the middle class people. kya karein, ambani ji se panga thodi le sakte hai.... don't you think this defeats the entire purpose of tax to begin with? don't you think the redistribution of money is happening for sure, but the other way around? saara patriotism ka theka middle class ne hi le rakha hai kya? Adani se tax kyu nahi lete tameez se?
Tax paying is not scary!! The thing thats scary is that even after paying huge lump of money to the government we still are not getting a good infrastructural development and public facilities!!
If govt. can provide us with general public facilities no one will ever cry to pay taxes to that old lady!!!
So before 2014, Indians did not use to pay tax?
@ we didn’t got the facilities that time too though taxes were less as compared to today!!!
People still will. You are not familiar with the thought process behind this
Really very thank you 😅 warna mai to.....
You last line absolutely correct
Tax is exist to correct difference in private market😁
Video started as a good one but mid-way I realised he's literally saying the point of "Sher paala hai, kharcha to hoga hi."
Nahi
@1:30 "Jitne bhi log mujhe dekh Rai h mai unki Kasam khara hu, agar mai jhuti kasam khara ru to aap sabb marr jaoo"..😂😂😂
@@Uncle_SAM96 abhe hutiye, hr jagah comedy ye jo bakwas kr raha vo nhi suni,
Bol raha tax dete raho services expect mt kro
For whatever technical reasons the fact is 'taxes like the USA, services worse than Somalia', if I am self-centred, if I can shift to a foreign country, then why not? It makes sense why more and more millionaires are leaving this country, what do you think most skilled and rich guys leaving a country, is this not a problem for a country at all?
pls reply man
This quoted line is such a shitty take. Check per capita income of Somalia and USA and then check what amount does the government of India and these two countries have to spend per person. Clearly, you didn't watch till the end
@@keshavbediyou didnt even answer his question. Stop beating round the bush 😂
Thx bhai,
I never knew even Nobel prize money was taxed 🙈, but yes like you said the central point around taxing is helping the unfortunate people around.
Also I am reminded that current meme culture on taxes is diff tax slab rates on diff kinds of popcorns 😅
keshav can you make a video on terms used such as "TAX Terr0rism", and 'that's why the rich leaves india', plus telling what exactly is middle class?
cuz these arguments are suddenly on a rise on X, cuz "middle class" on twitter are angry cuz they have to pay 30% gst on their 15LPA+ income
I have already posted plenty of videos on these topics. Search.
Upper 0.5 percent has to pay even more tax.
What are your thoughts on taxing rich farmers for example that earn more than 12 lakh yearly (lets consider this is after everything that needs to be paid)
I don't really considering farming is fundamentally an economically unprofitable exercise. Agar koi fir bhi paise itna banaleta hai after going against those odds, I don't think it warrants tax. Plus, very few such farmers exist
True; CA sahab's video would have made more sense from the POV of the poor, rather than the 'middle class'
All taxes are supposed to be redtributive in nature
Popular rhetoric focuses on direct taxes, which are linked to one's earnings, while conveniently forgetting that all Indians pay indirect taxes without any such distinction and these disproportionately sap the poor more than anybody else
However, this concept of top 1%, 10% etc is pretty flawed: the avg wealth of the top 1% is 54 L; while this is pretty big in the Indian context, does it even compare to big industrialists, entrepreneurs or even small successful business owners?
For the top 10%, it's about 10L
Clubbing these groups together makes little sense
I disagree with your point however. Because under the neoliberal govt the taxes are just being wasted. They are not being used in education, nutrition (govt banned eggs in midday meals), or growth of the basic superstrcutures or local mechanisms of the states. If you were seeing sweeping changes like china did during post 1990s or even after that none of such gradual improvements are happening. And all these taxes are going to cronies. Or to pay the impossible to pay indian govts debt to imf and other such institutions. The govt is not working on the basic superstrcutures. Its just pumping its cronies. Like as you know the basic superstrcutures like land reforms, hsr/msr, public transport, water services, waste management, nutrition, education all these things can only be modernized or maximized on a per capita basis by state policies and planning which this dumb govt keeps talking about against on all the major things the govt should actually be working upon. Both pro bjp and anti bjp liberals throw around these words freebies. Bhai tera baap or teri generation me se jitne bhi aage aaye hai woh jitne bhi limited freebies schemes (govt funding basic things like education, nutrition, healthcare, public transport, military and so forth) uski wajah se hua hai
Tax on commodities are overwhelming poor also.
Lekin politicians gives free bees n takeup tax paid money through outsourcing contracts to dear ones
bhaii dil ke baat keh di.
kb se yeh woke youtubers tax tax chila rhe the,
befaltu mein dimag ka kchra krte hain.
3:08 sir log europe jaise services nahi chahte
zinda rehne layak hawa
peene layak paani
aur
khaane layak sasti roti
ki maang karrahe hai
Jo ki hamara fundamental right hai
Tax apne desk ke liye investment hai jo govt kuch return ke promise par leti hai ...deshbhakti ke naam par sarkaari baabu ki wallet bharne ka naam nai
I always talk about it, how our priority should be clean air, water, etc. Doesn't mean we should say taxes shouldn't be there
@@keshavbedisir no one is demanding for removal of taxes
People are demanding for reasonable rate of taxes
So that if i contribute to the economy I should be getting some incentive .....if taxes are too high there is no incentive for me to contribute something big to the economy
Secondly people are demanding rationalised and efficient spending of taxes and not like some free money
Our govt is extremely inefficient in this regard
Govt is taking debt like there's no tomorrow
Govt is increasing taxes like crazy
Govt is disinvesting in public companies like all of them are liabilities
This all fund raising could have been justifiable if they delivered something to the country
but we all know our economy is struggling right now .......
where the fu*ck is all of that money ! And where did they spent it?
There are no positive effects on economy
Food inflation is touching the roof
Wages have stagnated
Iam a med student ...healthcare costs are crazy 90% Indians cannot afford it
Sir if people dont see the return of their tax investment ...
Unfortunately many will leave india which is happening in our country
These are some reasonable demands which govt can listen to
EXACTLY....
I think Dectatorship should started in country and people should taxed 80% ...Also all youtuber and all income should be taxed 80%.. People should get to spend on Only food and Clothing... British were at least better than this Government 😢
Lmao. Not sure about Britain but as long as more jobs get created I won't mind paying even 40% tax. You guys need to raise your voice but on reasonable things. Tax isn't the issue Jobs are
Sir ,milli or billi toh India se bahar jaa raha ha , middle class ke upar kiya kiya effect padhega, please make a detail video .
Bhai main bhi brave browser use karta hun 💪 you are economics teacher , please upload basic economics video for beginners please bhiya
But you should also agree that people in india earn very less so things that are basic necessity should be tax free.
I think income tax on Gukesh's Prize has been waived
Unfortunate
Before commenting what services do we get in return, atleast have the basic decency to watch full video. And then, go through this detailed one. THEN SPEAK.
ua-cam.com/video/8ZyT0UEAlYo/v-deo.htmlsi=DLY49GMz1KgmgJyz
Bros logic sab dusra video dekhne jaenge to idhar koi backlash hoga hi nahi😅
Valid point but the amount of corruption and misuse there is, also makes sense to grant exemption to extraordinary achievers.
Also its a request please make a vide on public sector, if bank privatization is good or not for example both from economy and worker POV
Not good
@keshavbedi Thanks for your opinion.
Also what do you think about this welfare model of public banks as below and do you think this model should be slowly replicated in other sectors in a post capitalist world?
Nationalized banks had pension scheme for employees joining upto 2010, the pension benefit is similar to Central govt employees and is funded directly from banks revenue expenditure.
So banks sitting on healthy profits, workers too getting a share of it and it helps boost consumption etc as well and a stellar retired life, giving larger social mobility to their children as well who can take bigger risks and have higher rewarding careers also in return contributing to nation in more taxes!
During banks loss years it's a problem, as tax payers money is used to re capitalize but can be avoided easily with good management.
Today when I see banks like HDFC, profiting over 50k crores but having absolutely shit wages for majority of workers, shit worklife, barely any job security and sustainability for majority of workforce, I see what's the point of sitting over so much profits if basic workers life improvement can't be achieved and will definitely impact the next generation as well?
Makes me think nationalized banks model was really good, specially if it could manage consistent profitability, and if having a accountable responsible management at the top free of political interference.
Keshav bhai don't you think that the burden of taxes is more on the salaried class, and it should also be on the top 0.1%, i.e, extremely wealthy? And if there is a wealth tax, how can we ensure that these businesses don't run off to a tax haven, like what a lot of the american firms did by running off to Ireland?
These 'tax havens' are basically rewarding the firms for not paying taxes in their original countries.
Apka MindSet best hai 🔥🔥🔥
Koi tax mat do, revolt krdo, no taxation without development
Brother. He is criticising the government for the exorbitant tax rates. Raghav chaddha had summarised it very well. He said, "Indians pay taxes like USA, To get services like somalia". If we are paying our taxes, we have right to criticise our ministers and governemnt on it.
There are no exorbitant tax rates, and Raghav Chadda’s comment was idiotic. Had covered it in Part 2 of my video on Dhruv Rathee’s nonsense in Mission Swaraj
Bhai, please make a video on the impact of demonetisation on the Indian economy and how it has reduced our productivity. There is a superficial claim that Pakistan went bankrupt due to India's demonetisation, not because of their economic mismanagement.
While I agree that most of the people blabbering about taxes are top 1% or maybe top 5%, I'd say taxes haven't existed because of welfare. Public is made to think it is for welfare, but it's mainly because someone is capable enough to tax people. Taxes are like maintenance and way of asserting dominance for the ruling entity.
Bringing inequality or income disparity down isn't always the goal of the ruling class, see what happened in last few decades.
@@janmejay_singh Nope. Taxes have been expanded precisely because of welfare, especially post FDR
@@keshavbedi On paper, yes. In reality, No. Specially in the Indian context. Also a most of welfare and development schemes help powerful people or groups ( builders, military industrial complex or healthcare complex ) more than they help the public. Not to mention, how are you taxed depends a lot on your bargaining power with the govt. You can be spending 5000 crores on a marriage and still not be the highest individual taxpayer.
basically jo log jivan me kuch ukhad nhi paa rhe vo ye arpit aur german shepherd jaiso ko dekh ke validation lete hain apne faliure ke liye aur sochte hain ki bhot bade intellectual hain
Genuine question sir, Why is there an increase in HNI's(Who pay majority amount of direct tax)leaving India to other countries?
Hahaha another brilliant video😅
Great content brother. Keep up the good work 👍🏻
1:25 😂
accha bhaii
Keshav bhai, people are getting it wrong. Problem taxation me nahi hai balki corruption me hai. Hame video recording karni hogi jab bhi ham koi government office jaaye taki proof rahe ki hamara kaam dhang se hua nahi. Government ko law laana chahiye right to record ka.
Mai ek government college me migration certificate lene gaya to clerk besharmo ki tarah paise maang raha tha.
Problem corruption se hoti to corruption par bolte.
Cybercell spotted
kiska cybercell?
Problem is, taxes like USA, services worse than Somalia.
Idiotic take. Check per capita income of both, and then see how much money US, India and Somalia has to spend per person
@@keshavbedi Somalia is a horrible equivalence, but clearly, in the case of India, the money spent is not reflected for a section of people.
@@keshavbedi but Somalia is for comparison how worst services we are getting from government it is like everyone is paying taxes below income level and above income level for example I have to pay taxes for everything and still have to pay taxes in the name of income tax what I get open sewage dirty road street dogs and cows every where garbage on road holes on road no safety on road healthcare facilities but so poor that you can't find bed and if I have to buy insurance plan company make so many loop holes in terms and conditions you will lose hope because if I case on company it take month to sue the company how slow the court system government school is so bad unhygienic food they teach three class like. 4th,5th,6th students with one teacher don't teach cleanliness I know india is very. Dirty and swacha bharat mission is a campaign which make no changes accept making toilets it do better when we make rules that have strict penalty and 6months of jail and police taking action immediately so that everyone should follow rules finance minister putting so many taxes. And how do we know it's is use in beneficial for society or its lose in corruption i trust nitin gadkari how many good highways and expressways but bihar bridge collapse how much corruption here it like losing all money on fraud
@@nananou1687 i don't know why my comment got deleted
Keshav kya aap please ye upper class, middle class aur poor class ke beech ka sabse sateek difference batha denge india aur other coutries mein🙏🙏🙏
Do check earlier videos I did on the topic
Adani par Tax nahi lagta Uska kya?
Bhai ek budhi Amma jiska koi Sahara nahi hai wo bhi jab roti khareedegi aur Ambani jab roti khareedega dono par same tax kaise lag sakta hai? Ye justifiable nahi hai
Maine dusri countries me gst dekha hai wo kaafi simple hai aur usme govt basic needs jaise food par gst nai lagati
Sir, I think ye frustration aur aise videos ka Karan ye hai ki there's prevalence in general consciousness that government and officials (businessmen ofc) are highly corrupted people. . .Jo thoda bohot tax aa bhi rha hai use nhi ho rha theek se.
That is why I buy emami Zandu toothPaste than Colgate...Bihar develop😅😅😅😂😂😂
2:45
Finance ministry ne tax maaf kar diya hai waise player ka
So it's a good decision to Move to a country which provides good enough services for the tax paid
Developed countries or regions will always provide better services than underdeveloped ones
Great content!
arpit is not chatared account..his language is not even professional
He is a Chartered Accountant. You clearly on the other hand, do not demonstrate enough knowledge to comment on that, given your "language"
What about millionaires/ enterpreneurs leaving India in recent years because of high taxes doesn't that decrease the volume?
Ridiculous
Very informative 🙌@@keshavbedi
Please answer this - as per many recent reports like oxfam etc india's top 1 % holds around 45 -50% wealth and top 10 % around 74% wealth while bottom 50% holds less than 2%
So dont you think tax revenues should also come in these proportions. But no most of the tax revenue ( direct taxes) come from income tax and major proportion is covered by middle class.
Dont you think tax slabs are unfair ???
pehle padhle middle class hota kya hai
everybody is equal, everybody needs to pay tax, simple
Everyone is not equal in economic terms, and everyone does pay tax
Everyone is paying taxes fool
Some pay more
Some pay less
But everyone pays texes according to their capabilities
And everybody is not equal in any term
Except everyone has one face , 2 hands , 2 legs and one brain
Bada hoja kid thoda sa 🤡
@@keshavbedithis was in reference to the guy saying finance minister is taking money from gukesh
I didn't say everybody needs to pay equal taxes
Freebies pe kya opinion hai? Also Gukesh ka Price money pe tax maaf hogya
See this:
ua-cam.com/video/Yw5qhjxHQiU/v-deo.htmlsi=FhVNK3wT1fdYj_g5
You can search other videos of mine on this topic as well
Bro is eating the left wing alive 😂
Not really. What I said is position of left. Ye log confused log hai
You made a video on degrowth na , I found something interesting related to it . Read an article by Tom Murphy website do the math called can modernity last ? And check his book he mention in his article go to alternative energy part and see the calculations for respective source of energy
Useless video ,we are backwards so we should not expect sir,
This guy knows everything about everything which makes it laughable.
Bol raha h service mt lo bs tax do .😂😂
link your video about taxation (the quid pro quo stuff) in the desc. please!!
Daali hui hai link. Check. Unjust Distribution Of Income In Private Markets
@keshavbedi thanks!!
Isi tax ka use hoga govt. bureaucrats real estate kharidege! Tu desh seva karte reh. Asli seva hoga Babuon, IAS, IPS ka.
See the rich have CAs and financial experts like you so they dont pay taxes and they have their own kind of little world where they spend lavishly buy expedive things and if required go to another country to settle down and there is no bad about it because its make sense that if i have intaligence ill do that and i am not against it but i am earning 30k a month and almost 15k is goning into direct or indirect taxes so what i am left with and how will i go from a poor to atlease a lower middle class.
mujhe kya mil rha hai tax deke ? agar mujhe charity hi karni hai toh bc mein khud q nhi anath ashram mein dedu mere salary ka agr 30 percent govt kat leti hai toh uske against mujhe kya deti hai tute hue pool gadho wali road patriotism itna hi khun mein hai toh apne saare assets income tax department ko donate karde .agar mujhe kisi dusre country mein tax ke badle achi living mil rhi hai toh mein wha q nhi shift hunga .pura tax system corrupted hai
See this.
ua-cam.com/video/8ZyT0UEAlYo/v-deo.htmlsi=mOkTNKwNoWGkmNAT
3:10 bhi wo saaf hawa ki baat kar rhe he . tax deke marna hi he tho dena hi kyu. africa me hasme jada safai hoti he
Can you make video on deshbhakt new podcast with Manish Sisodia deputy cm of Delhi
No time
YOU ARE CONTRADICTING YOURSELF 😅😂
How exactly
Aap kuch bhi bolo govt ko tax middle class se utna hi lena chahiye jitna ke baad wo thik se savings kar pae aur dusra unki purchasing power thik thak rahe
Tabhi hamari economy grow karegi warna govt jitni spending karle wo temporary push hai
1:16
"Sarkaari paisa hai..Logon ko bhalai mein hi jaaega."
Sarcasm tha ya genuine statement thi ?
Genuine statement. Where else will it go?
Sarcasm mai bol rahe honge ...
extraordinary to he na bhai ! usa europe ka example le rahe ho to facility bhi to dekho bhaiya ! or sabun pr 18% gst le rahe he, aapse lena he ? do un 80 caror logo ko jinke khane ka intezam bhi sarkar kar rahi he ... bat vo 1 percent me aata he ye nahi he , bat ye he ki vo 1 percent me aake kis financial group ki voice ban raha he , wrna uss 99 % logo ko apne jiwan se time nhi milta he , samaj ki problems ko kese time denge ! baki , i like your work !
Arey yaar, poori video kyun nahi sunte tum log?
🎉❤
Do you identify as a socialist/communist? Genuinely curious.
2:45 bhai kya aap ya fir koi aur bhi yeh wala concept samjha sakte ho absolute and percentage wala.
Say two countries have incomes 100 and 10000. I can say they pay 30% taxes in latter, so have 30% here too.
But obviously, 30% on 10,000 would mean government having 3000 as opposed to just 30 here in absolute numbers.
Bro please think properly for the original reason for taxation. It is not a right of the government but to run it and provide services to citizens. Are these services audited for quality and accountability? Set aside about duties as the tax is paid. What about government duties? You think it's really being properly managed? What support has India given to Chess players before they were famous ? We are the least sporting nation for God's sake. Also don't show some random reel and get emotional.
Original reason of taxation is redistribution. Not providing quid pro quo services
@keshavbedi Original reason for the modern tax was to finance the public services and other government debt. It's not a great tool for wealth redistribution as wealth comes from their personal income and not government benefits. You may have public services that are low quality like pre college education, transportation, health and so on. It's same in most Western countries. Progressive taxation also failed. Class mobility is an illusion for non upper class as inflation and stagnant wages reset what they achieved over the years.
you better travel the nation and find out ground reality
Paying taxes are not a extraordinary thing to do, yes but extorting a certain income class is not right, as a country who doesn't give a shit about your hardwork should be addressed too, here taxing gukesh is not problem but see the taxing amount on hard earned vs corporates its not right either it's not their fault too but they can change that it's not even that much of a work when you can increase taxes on popcorn at one seating. It's not like I'm new to your channel, iam even a subscribertoo. even though it's not their fault to begin with but there is no problem in addressing it. Even I think what arpit is talking is baseless but someone should address this extortion from certain income class
See video link in description
😂😂😂 BJP ka kamal
this time I can't agree with you, your example seems so vague and all of the sudden you feel like you need to match the tone to meet a certain political leaning crowd. Things like these makes creators like you fishy
😂😂😂😂